1
<%
UNIVERSITY
OF CALIFORNIA
LOS ANGELES
SCHOOL OF LAW
LIBRARY
_.^^
Digitized by the Internet Archive
in 2007 with funding from
IVIicrosoft Corporation
http://www.archive.org/details/bankruptcylawannOOeastiala
THE
BANKEUPTCT LAW ANNOTATED
BEING THE
NATIONAL BANKRUPTCY ACT OF 1898
AS AMENDED
FEBRUARY 5th, 1903.
THE
ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY, THE OFFICIAL FORMS
AND THE UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
WITH
ALL THE DECISIONS SINCE 1898, DIGESTED AND ARRANGED
UNDER APPROPRIATE SECTIONS WITH
FULL CROSS-REFERENCES,
AND
ALL FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
Together with
A LIST OF JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES, WITH THEIR
JURISDICTIONS.
ERRATA.
Page 48. Below Section 4-b insert "as amended by act of 1903, Section
, of amended act, post."
Page 114. Section 18-a, twelfth line from top, "in equity" should be
nthin parenthesis.
Page 127. Strike out "c" before the star in the last line of Section 2.3-b.
Page 284. Strike out last line "as amended, etc."
Page 361. Words in brackets "See General Order XXVII" should read
See General Order XXXVII."
Page 508. Under "Sixth Circuit"— "Terms"— in place of "Chicaeo"
sad "Cincinnati." *
THE
BANKRUPTCY lAW ANNOTATED
BEING THE
NATIONAL BANKEUPTCY ACT OF 1898
AS AMENDED
FEBRUARY 5th, 1903.
THE
ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY, THE OFFICIAL FORMS
AND THE UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
WITH
ALL THE DECISIONS SINCE 1898, DIGESTED AND ARRANGED
UNDER APPROPRIATE SECTIONS WITH
FULL CROSS-REFERENCES,
AND
ALL FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
Together with
A LIST OF JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES, WITH THEIR
JURISDICTIONS.
BY
SIDNEY CORNING EASTMAN.
Referbb in Bankruptcy in Chicago.
CHICAGO :
Ti H. FLOOD & CO.
1903.
Copyrighted 1903
BY
Sidney Corning Eastman.
1903
s
,-->
\
*'The primary object of a bankruptcy law is to secure a
just distribution of the bankrupt's property among his
creditors; the secondary object is the release of the bank-
rupt from the obligation to pay his debts." Justice Miller,
in Wilson v. City Bank (1873), Sup. Ct. of U. S., 17 Wall.
(U. S.), 473.
H-^>05r>»sr r^ry
PREFACE.
The United States is the only civiHzed nation which has
not had a permanent bankruptcy code. The laws of 1800,
1841 and 1867 were respectively repealed after a few years
trial. The defects in each created a sentiment of opposi-
tion which finally grew sufficiently strong to cause its
destruction. Many have come to regard such legislation
as necessarily short-lived and to believe its object should be
like imto the old Jewish law, a periodical discharge for
the financially crippled. The real object and value of
bankruptcy law is, however, well shown in that early case,
an extract from which is presented on a preceding page.
The administrative feature of the law does not so forcibly
arrest the attention of the casual observer as does the
discharge part, yet in the former is the real effectiveness
and utility of the law found.
The Referees in Bankruptcy under the law of 1898, early
in their experience, came together in convention and talked
over the new law, compared notes, exchanged ideas and
finally appointed committees to take up in a careful and
elaborate manner all suggestions that were offered for im-
y proving the law. Their labors resulted in the elaboration
of an amendatory act which they presented to the com-
mittees of the Senate and House of Representatives. Judge
Hoar of the Senate and Congressman Ray of the House
(now United States District Judge for the Northern Dis-
trict of New York), cordially received these suggestions
and invited further labors. The result is shown in the
adoption of the amendment of February 5, 1903, which
is incorporated in this volume.
VI PREFACE.
It is apparent that the interest which has been thus dis-
played and the education which the country has had on
the subject of bankruptcy legislation has made a change
in public sentiment, and it is confidently asserted by those
competent to speak that a national bankruptcy law has
become a part of our jurisprudence, to be amended and
improved from time to time, but never to be repealed.
Every effort has been made to secure accuracy in the
book and to avoid errors. For those errors that have
crept in, the stress of preparation in the midst of exacting
official duties will in a measure be an explanation.
The author invites criticisms and suggestions from the
users of this book.
The author desires to make recognition of the valued
assistance of Mr. Carl V. Wisner of the Chicago bar, in
the preparation of this work.
Sidney Corning Eastman.
Chicago, March, 1903.
i
SCOPE NOTE.
This volume is the outgrowth of a system of note taking
made necessary in practice. It contains a brief notation
of every decision which has found its way into print since
the law of 1898 came into being, down to March 15, 1903.
It does not claim to be a text book, but contains the features
of an annotated statute and an index digest.
It has been the effort to collect all the cases on the sub-
ject of bankruptcy decided since 1898. To that end a
careful search of all the reports, State and Federal, has been
made. This has been done by going to the reports them-
selves. The collections of bankruptcy cases in the National
Bankruptcy News (cited N. B. N.) and in the American
Bankruptcy Reports (cited A. B. R.) have been carefully
examined, and all cases foimd therein digested and arranged
imder appropriate sections. One himdred and fifty cases
or more have been fotmd and digested, not now found
in any series of reports devoted to bankruptcy decisions.
The purpose has been to give the lawyer the use of all
his Hbrary, and with that end in view reference has been
made to the various reports in which each case is reported.
Owing to the large niimber of cases and the fact that they
cover every portion of the United States, the court, the
district and the date of the case has been given so that the
lawyer can see at a glance whether a case has been decided
and is controlling in his district and circuit. A list of the
judicial officers of the coiuts of bankruptcy has been added,
as this information has not been found in any other publica-
tion, and the numerous inquiries therefor seemed to
justify its publication. It has been obtained by personal
VU SCOPE NOTE.
correspondence with the clerks and referees in the various
districts.
In carrying out the original plan of placing imder each
section or paragraph all the decisions relating to it, with a
short note of the substance of the case, it became apparent
towards the close that by reason of the increasing number
of cases some sections were overloaded. It was too late
to attempt a cirrtailment, and it was deemed better to
carry out the plan irrespective of the growing bulk. A
difficulty arose which is apparent in that, owing to the
somewhat incoherent shape which the act assumed from
the manner of its production, many sections cross and inter-
fere with each other, which resulted in an embarrassment
in correctly placing the notes.
The purpose has been to give the lawyer who has occa-
sion to consider questions of bankruptcy law a complete
working tool containing all the statute and case law.
TABLE OF CONTENTS.
Sec. Paob.
8 U. S. Constitution 1
CHAPTER I.
definitions.
Sec.
1 Meaning of Words and Phrases 3
CHAPTER II.
CREATION OP COURTS OP BANKRUPTCY AND THEIR JURISDICTION.
2 Jurisdiction of Coxirts of Bankruptcy 11
CHAPTER III.
BANKRUPTS.
3 Acts of Bankruptcy 32
4 Who May Become Bankrupts 47
5 Partners 51
6 Exemptions of Bankrupts 58
7 Duties of Bankrupts 69
8 Death or Insanity of Bankrupts 75
9 Protection and Detention of Bankrupts 76
10 Extradition of Bankrupts 78
11 Suits by and against Bankrupts 78
12 Compositions when Confirmed 85
13 Compositions, when Set Aside 89
14 Discharges, when Granted 89
15 Discharges, when Revoked 103
16 Co-debtors of Bankrupts 104
17 Debts not AflEected by a Discharge 105
CHAPTER IV.
COURTS AND PROCEDURE THEREIN.
18 Process, Pleadings, and Adjudications 113
19 Jury Trials , 119
20 Oaths, Affirmations 121
21 Evidence 122
22 Reference of Cases after Adjudication 125
23 Jurisdiction of United States and State Courts 126
24 Jtirisdiction of Appellate Courts 132
25 Appeals and Writs of Error 135
X TABLE OF CONTENTS.
Page.
26 Arbitration of Controversies 139
27 Compromises 139
28 Designation of Newspapers 139
29 Offenses 140
30 Rxiles, Forms, and Orders 142
31 Computation of Time 142
32 Transfer of Cases 143
CHAPTER V.
OFFICERS, THEIR DUTIES AND COMPENSATION.
33 Creation of two OfiBces 145
34 Appointment, Removal, and Districts of Referees 145
35 Qualifications of Referees 146
36 Oaths of Office of Referees 147
37 Number of Referees 147
38 Jurisdiction of Referees 147
39 Duties of Referees 149
40 Compensation of Referees 152
41 Contempts before Referees 154
42 Records of Referees 156
43 Referee's Absence or Disability 156
44 Appointment of Trustees 156
45 Qualifications of Trustees 158
46 Death or Removal of Trustees 158
47 Duties of Trustees 158
48 Compensation of Trustees 162
49 Accotmts and Papers of Trustees 164
50 Bonds of Referees and Trustees 164
51 Duties of Clerks 167
52 Compensation of Clerks and Marshals 168
53 Duties of Attorney-General 169
54 Statistics of Bankruptcy Proceedings 169
CHAPTER VI.
CREDITORS.
55 Meetings of Creditors 170
56 Voters at Meetings of Creditors 172
67 Proof and Allowance of Claims 173
58 Notice to Creditors 185
59 Who may File and Dismiss Petitions 187
60 Preferred Creditors 192
TABLE OF CONTENTS. XI
CHAPTER VII.
ESTATES.
Page.
61 Depositories for Money 204
62 Expenses of Administering Estates 204
63 Debts which may be Proved 205
64 Debts which have Priority 7 210
65 Declaration and Payment of Dividends 217
66 Unclaimed Dividends 219
67 Liens 220
68 Set-offs and Counter Claims 238
69 Possession of Property 239
70 Title to Property 241
71 Clerks to index Petitions and issue Certificates of Search 255
72 Referees and Trustees to receivie no greater compensation than
Act provides 255
Time Act goes into effect 251
Time Amendment goes into effect 256
General Orders in Bankruptcy 257
Official Forms in Bankruptcy T 285
United States Equity Rules 361
Amendment of Feb. 5, 1903 397
Report of House Committee 7 406
Former Bankruptcy Statutes 423
Judicial Officers of Courts of Bankruptcy^ 506
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
A.
Ablowich. In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 102.
Ablowich V. Stursburg (1901), C. C.
A., 2nd Cir. 98.
Abrahamson & Bretstein, In re
(1898), N. Dist. N. Y., Moss,
R., 148, 186.
Abraham Steers Lumber Co., In re
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Thomas,
J., 180.
Abram, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 159.
Abraham, In re (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 18, 129,
135.
Adams, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Moss, R., 236, 251.
Adler v Jones (1901), C. C. A. 6th
Cir., Day, J., 87, 88.
Adams Sartorial Co., In re (1900),
Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 16.
Adler. In re (1900), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J, 88.
Aiken, Lambert & Co. v. Hoskins
(1901), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Hough-
ton, J., 99.
Alfred, In re (1899,) W. Dist. Mo.,
Mott, R., 59.
Altman, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 52.
Altman, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe J., 51.
Albert Goodman Shoe Co., In re
(1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPher-
son, J., 238.
Alderson, In re (1900), Dist. W. Va.,
Jackson, J., 205, 216.
Allen, In re (1899), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 30, 207.
Allen V. French (1901), Sup. Ct.
Mass. Barker, J., 195.
Alexander, In re (1900), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 181.
American Brewing Co., In re (1902),
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Bunn, J., 7,
44, 118.
Anonymous, In re (1899) .Dist.Wash-
ington, Hanford, J., 167.
Anson, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
•DeHaven, J., 215.
Ankenny, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
James, R., 174.
Ankenny, In re (1900), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 70, 177.
Anderson, In re (1900), Dist. S. C,
Brawley, J., 25.
Anderson, In re (1900), W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 195.
Anderson, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 67.
Andrea, In re (1902), E. Dist. Wis.
Seaman, J., 221.
Andrews v. Mathes (1902), Sup. Ct.
Ala., Harlson, J., 253.
Arkell, In re (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Ingraham, J., 106.
Amett, In re (1901) ,|W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 28, 157, 241, 247.
Arington v. Arington (1902), Sup.
Ct. N. C, Fuchs, J., 111.
Arrington Co., H. J., In re (1902),
E. Dist. Va., Waddill, J., 89.
Armour Packing Co. v. Brown (1899)
Sup. Ct. Minn., 2.
Arnold, In re (1899), Dist. .Ky.,
Evans, J., 188, 233.
Arnold v. Trevianns (1903), Sup.
Ct. N. J., Jenks, J., 222.
Asbury Park Bldg., &c., v. Shepard
(1901), Sup. Ct. N.J. ,33.
Atkins V. Wilcox (1900) , C. C. A., 8th
Cir., McCormick; J., 175.
Audubon v. Shufeldt (1901), Sup. Ct.
U. S., Gray, J., 47, 175.
Averill, In re (1899), K. Dist. Ohio,
Remington, K., 204,213,
B.
Baker, In re (1899), E. Dist. Tex.,
Hurley, R., 107, 210.
Baker, /« re (1899), Dist. Kan.,
Hook, J., 77.
Barker, In re (1899), Dist. Minn.,
Lochren, J., 153, 218.
Barrows, In re , W. Dist. Va., Paul,
J., 244.
Basch, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., WS.
Baudouine, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 244.
Baudouine, In re (1900), C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 20, 85
Baumann, In re (1899). W. Dist.
Tenn., Hammond, J., 8.
XIV
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages.
Baker-Ricketson Co., In re (1899),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 10, 32,
37, 39, 42.
Barden, In re (1900), Dist. N. C,
Purnell. J., 54, 92, 168.
Bardes v. Hawarden Natl. Bank
(1900), Sup. Ct. U. S., Gray, J.,
18, 20, 127, 138.
Bates, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 254.
Bartlett v. United States (1901),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J.,
141.
Baumann v. Feist (1901), C. C. A.,
8th Cir., 99.
Baer v. Grell (1901), Municipal Ct.
of New York, Joseph, J., 105.
Bank v. Craig Bros. (1901), W. Dist.
Ky., Evans, J. 50.
Bank of Commerce v. Elliott (1901),
Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall, J., 84,
131, 134.
Barrett, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Wise, R., 180, 200.
Bashline, In re (1901), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 180.
Baber,/n re (1902), W. Dist. Tenn.,
10, Hammond, J., 159.
Barker, In re (1901), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 153.
Barnes Mfg. Co. v. Norden (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Dixon, J., 109.
Baird, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 20.
Barber V. Franklin (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 230,
253.
Bashinski v. Talbot (1902). C. C. A.,
5th Cir., Shelby, J., 69.
Bank v. Iron Co. (1899), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 128, 226.
Babitt V. Kelly (1902), Ct. App. Mo.,
Good. J.. 194.
Balk V. Harris (1902). Sup. Ct. N.
C. Furches. J., 111.
Barclay v. Barclay (1900), Sup. Ct.
111., Phillips, J.. 111.
Baemcroflf, In re (1902) , E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 115.
Bailey v. Glover (1874), Sup. Ct.
U. S., 1.
Bates Machine Co., In re (1899),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 48.
Baginsky & Co., In re (1899), E.
Dist. La., Gurley, R., 164.
Beck, In re (1899), S. Dist. la..
Woolson, J., 213.
Beddingfield, In re (1899), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 189.
Becker, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.;
Dunn, R., 162.
Bear & Co. v. Chase (1900), C. C. A.,'
4th Cir., Waddill, J.. 84, 234.
Becker, In re E. Dist., Pa., McPher-
son, J., 16, 17.
Beers v. Hanlin (1900), Dist. Ore.;
Bellinger, J., 34, 210.
Bemer, H. D. In re (1899), N. Dist.
O., Remington, R. 14.
Bean, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 60, 71,72.
Beauchamp, In re (1900), Dist. Md.,
Morris. J., 64, 67.
Berkowitz, /n re (1900), S. Dist.
N. Y., Wise, R., 102.
Bemer, In re (1900), S. Dist. O.,'
Remington, R., 96.
Becker, In re (1901) , N. Dist. N. Y.;
Coxe, J., 71, 99.
Bemis, In re' (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,"
Coxe, J., 98.
Bender, In re (1901), W.^Dist. Ark.,"
Rogers, J., 18, 22.
Beaver Coal Co.. In re (1901), Dist.
Ore., Bellinger, J., 237.
Beck, In re. (1901), Dist. Mass.;
Lowell. J., 54, 73.
Benedict v. Duhel (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., McLaughlin, J., 193.
Beaver Coal Co., In re (1902), C. C.
A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J., 237.
Beerman, In re (1901). N. Dist. Ga.;
Newman, J., 72, 84.
Beach v. Macon Grocery Co. (1902),
C. C. A.,5thCir.. 17,21.
Beak, In re (1902), Dist. Ind., Baker,
J., 68.
Beals, In re (1902) . Dist. Ind., Baker,
J., 231.
Beebe, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.;
McPherson, J., 94.
Bellah. In re (1902). Dist. Del.,
Bradford, J. .9, 33. 117, 190.
Benedict. In re (1902). Sup. Ct. N.
Y., Houghton, J., 245.
Berry v. Jackson (1902), Sup. Ct.
Ga., Lumpkin, J., 107.
Belding, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.;
Lowell, J., 194.
Bernhardt v. Curtis (1902), Sup. Ct.
La., Provosky, J., 104.
Bingham, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.;
Wheeler. J.. 210.
Bindseil v. Smith (1900), Ct. App.
N. J., Dixon, J., 80.
Bindseil v. Coshion (1900), Sup. Ct.
N. J., 132.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED,
XV
The numbers refer to the pages.
Big Meadows Gas Co., 7« re (1902),
W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J.,
189.
Binders?;. McDonald, E.Dist. Wis., 1.
Blumberg, In re (1899), E. Dist.
Tenn., Clarke, J., 109.
Blakely v. Booneville Natl. Bank
(1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
229.
Blakely v. Booneville Natl. Bank
(1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
199.
Blocy. in re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Shipman, J., 199.
Blair, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 13, 52, 196.
Blankfein, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 72.
Blankfein, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 157.
Blair, In re (reOl), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 236.
Block, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Shipman, J., 8, 35, 100.
Blumberg v. Bryan (1901), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., McCormick, J., 176.
Bloomingdale v. Empire Rubber Mfg.
Co., (1902). E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 20. 241.
Blake et al. v. Francis Valentine Co.
(1898), N. Dist. Cal., Hawley,
J., 4. 79. 253, 254.
Boasberg. In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y.. Hotchkiss, R., 100.
Booth, In re (1899), N. Dist. Ga..
Upson, R., 81.
Bozeman, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ga.,
Myrick, R., 245.
Booth, In re (1899), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 246.
Boston, In re (1899), Dist. Neb.,
Munger, J., 63.
Botts V. Hammond (1900), C. C. A.,
4th Cir.. Simonton, J.. 220.
Boardman, In re Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J.. 248.
Booneville Natl. Bank v. Blakely
(1901). C. C. A.. 7th Cir., Jen-
kins. J.. 17, 18. 136.
Bolinger, In re (1901). W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 62.
Boorstin, In re (1902), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J.. 61.
Boyd V. Glucklich (1902) , C. C.A. .8th
Cir.. 26.
Boyd V. Lemon Gale Co. (1902),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J.,
10, 34, 35.
Bondenote v. Hannamann (1902),'
Sup. Ct, la., Waterman, J.,
195.
Bray et al. v. Cobb (1898), E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell, J., 45, 119, 120.
Bray v. Cobb (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
PumeU, J., 108, 152, 146, 156,
174.
Brooks, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.;
Wheeler, J., 22.
Bragasa, In re (1900), N. Dist. Tex.;
Meek, J., 102.
Bracken v. Milner (1900), W. Dist.
Mo., PhiUips, J., 110.
Bragasa v. St. Loviis Cycle Co. (1901),
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Pardee, J.,
99.
Brewster, In re (1902), N. Dist.
N. Y., Smith. R.. 175.
Brice. In re (1899), S. Dist. la.;
Woolson, J., 13.
Brice, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.;
Woolson, J., 44, 47.
Brice, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.;
Shiras, J., 102.
Brinckmann, In re (1900), Dist. Ind.;
Baker, J., 188.
Brown. In re (1899). W. Dist. Pa.;
Buffington, J., 62.
Brown, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.;
Ransom, R., 62.
Brogdbine, In re, Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J., 242.
Brooke, In re (1900), Dist. Ore.;
Bellinger, J., 79.
Brooks, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.;
McPherson, J., 157.
Browne, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.;
McPherson, J., 20.
Brown v. Case (1901), Sup. Ct. Mass.;
Lathrop, J., 221, 235.
Brown, In re (1901), C. C. A.; 6th
Cir., 117.
Brown, In re (1901), E. Dist. Mo.;
Rogers. J., 188.
Brown v. Barker (1902). Sup. Ct. N.
Y., Hiscock, J., 244.
Bruss-Ritter Co., In re (1898), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 2, 17,
252
Brumelkamp, In re (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Stone R., 71, 116, 264,
286.
Brumelkamp, In re (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 72, 121, 147,
286.
Bnmdage. In re (1900), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 74.
XVI
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages.
Brundin, In re (1901), Dist. Minn.,
Lochren, J.,213.
Bryan v. Bemheimer (1901), U. S.
Sup. Ct., Gray. J., 20, 22, 40.
Bryant, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Tenn., Clarke, J., 96.
Bryant v. Kinyon (1901), Sup. Ct.
Mich., Hooker, J., 110.
Brice v. Guaranty Co. (1901), C. C.
A., 6th Cir., Severens, J., 176.
Bryan v. Madden (1902), Sup. Ct. N.
Y., Russell, J., 199.
Buntrock Clothing Co., In re (1899),
N. Dist. Ia.,Shiras, J.,21.
Burnett v. Morris Mercantile Co.
(1899), Dist. Ore., Bellinger,
' J., 129.
Buntrock Clothing Co., In re (1899),
N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 79, 82.
Bushnell (1899), Dist. N. J., Parker,
R.,97.
Buelow, In re (1899), Dist. Wash.,
Handford, J., 63.
Burrus, In re (1899), W. Dist. Va.,
Jackson, J., 214, 223.
Burka, In re (1900), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 245.
Burka, In re (1901), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond. J., 76, 115, 117, 209.
Bumham v. Pidcock (1900). N. Y.
Sup. Ct.. McAdam, J., 106, 109.
Burk V. RoUinson (1901), Sup. Ct.
R. I., 58.
Burke, In re, (1901) N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 213.
Burlington Malting Co. (1901), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 188.
Bussey, In re (1901), W. Dist. Mo.,
Crittenden, R., 254.
BuUis, In re (1902). Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Springer, J., 109.
Bullock, In re (1902). E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 179.
Burrell & Com, In re (1903), S. Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 45.
Byrne & Co., In re (1899), S. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 225.
C.
Camp. In re (1899), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J.. 59.
Carpenter Bros. v. O'Connor (1899),
O. Cir. Ct.. 2nd Dist.. Wilson,
J., 15, 79, 80.
Carter, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ga.,
Myrick, R., 130.
Carter 7^. Peoples Natl. Bank (1900),
Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 81.
Carter v. Goody ktmtz (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 198.
Cain, F. F., In re (1899), N. Dist.
111., Eastman, R., 49, 190.
Cameron, &c.. In re (1899), W. Dist.
Mo., Phillips, J., 49.
Carmichael, In re (1899). N. Dist.
la., Shiras. J.. 51.
Carmichael, In re (1901), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 65.
Carter v. Hobbs (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 128, 129.
Caroline Cooperage Co., In re (1899),
E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 30,
163, 212, 215.
Campbell, In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 215.
Cashman, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,'
Brown, J., 97.
Carley, In re (1902), C. C. A., 3rd
Cir., Gray, J., 92.
Carley, In re (1901), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 123. 124.
Carley. In re (1902), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 123.
Cabus, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Pendleton. R.. 99.
Carpenter, In re (1901). C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 67.
Case, In re (1901), N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 245.
Caswell, In re (1901), Dist. R. I.,'
Borrows, R., 64.
Carver & Co., In re (1902), E. Dist.
N.C., Pumell, J., 44, 275.
Carleton, In re (1902). Dist. Mass.
Lowell, J., 53.
Carling v. Seymour Lumber Co.,
(1902,) C.C. A., 5th Cir.. Shelby,
J., 1. 17.255.
Campbell v. Thompson (1902), Sup.
Ct.. Colo.. Thompson. J.. 244.
Carr. In re (1902). E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell. J.. 160.
Chemical Natl. Bank v. Mayer
(1899). E. Dist. N. Y.. Thomas
J., 51.
Challoner. In re (1899). N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat. J.. 105.
Chambers, Calder & Co., In re (1900)
Dist. R. I., Brown. J., 81, 82.
Chattanooga Natl. Bank v. Rome
Iron Co. (1900), Cir. Ct., N.
Dist. Ga.. Newman. J., 221.
Chatfield v. O'Dwyer (1900), C. C.
A., 8th Cir., 136.
Chicago-Joplin Lead Co., In re
(1900), W. Dist. Mo., Philips,
J.. 61.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XVU
The numbers refer to the pages;
Christensen; In re (1900), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 120, 238.
Christensen, In re (1900), N. Dist.
la., James, R., 183,193, 201.
Chrystal Spring Bottling Co., In re
(1900), Dist. Va., Wheeler, J.,
19, 237, 244.
Chapman, In re (1900), N. Dist.
Ill.,Kohlsaat,J.,38, 247.
Chicago Title & Trust Co. v. Roblins
Sons (1901), Cir. Ct., N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat, J., 37.
Chism V. Citizens Bank of Clarks-
dale (1900), Sup. Ct. Miss.,
Terrell, J., 199, 200.
Chase, Ex parte (1900), Sup. Ct.
S. C, Pope, J., 232.
Chambers, Calder & Co., In re (1901) ,
Dist. R. I., Littlefield, R., 184,
273.
Chappeli, John, In re (1901), E. Dist.
Va., Waddill, J., 7.
Champion, In re (1902) , S. Dist. Ala.,
En-in, R., 197.
Chequasset Lumber Co., In re (1901) ,
S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 190.
Chesapeake Oyster & Fish Co., In
re Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 50.
Chaplin, In re (1902), Dist Mass.,
Lowell, J., 182.
Chauncey v. Dyke Bros. (1902),
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 21.
City Natl. Bank v. Doolittle (1901),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Toulmin, J.,
87. 88.
City Natl. Bank of Greenville v.
Bruce (1901), C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Waddill, J., 176.
Citizens Bank v. W. C. DePauw Co.
(1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Grosscup, J., 33, 36.
Claflin Co. v Eason, Trustee (1899),
E. Dist. Tex., White, R., 107,
216.
Cliffe, In re (1899). E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 28, 39, 115.
Clute, In re (1899), Superior Ct.
San Francisco, Coffey, J., 240.
Clark V. American Mfg., &c., Co.
(1900), C. C. A., 4th Cir.,
Waddill, J., 40.
Clisdell, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Moss, R., 15.
Clisdell, In re (1900), N. Dist. N.
Y..Coxe,J., 14,92.
Clisdell, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Moss, R., 15.
Claiborne. In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 77, 84.
Claff, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.;
Lowell, J.. 106.
Clark, In re (1901), Dist. Wash.,
Hanford, J., 52.
Clemmons v. Brinn (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y.,McAdam, J., 106.
Cleland v. Anderson (1902), Sup.
Ct. Neb., Pound, J., 249.
Coe Powers et al.. In re (1899), N.
Dist. O., Remington, R., 10,
173.
Coflfman, In re (1899), N. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 28, 60.
Cohn, In re (1899), W. Dist. Mo.,
Rathbum, R., 99.
Collier, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 167.
Collisi, In re (1899), W. Dist. Mich.,
Blair, R., 159.
Continental Natl. Bank v. Katz
(1899), Superior Ct. Cook Co.,
lU., Ball, J. ,79.
Columbus Electric Co. v. Worden
(1899), 181.
Coffin, In re (1899), E. Dist. Texas,
Dillard, R.,152, 163, 181.
Collins, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Sawyer, R., 235.
Cobb, In re (1901), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 277.
Cobb, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. C,"
Pumell, J., 228.
Cohn, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 131.
Cornell, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 140.
Cox V. Wall (1899), W. Dist. N. C,
Ewart, J., 128.
Cooks V. Peoples Natl. Bank (1901),
N. Y. Sup. Ct., Houghton, J.,
195.
Collingnon, In re (1900), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 206.
Columbia Real Estate Co., In re
(1900), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
42, 115.
Conhaim, In re (1900), Dist. Wash-
ington, Hanford, J., 159, 179.
Covirrier Journal, &c., Co. v. Schaafer
Meyer Ptg. Co. (1900), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Lurton, J., 134, 136,
183
Covington, In re (1901), W. Dist.
N. C, Pumell, J., 150.
Cogley. In re (1901), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 159.
Cohn, In re (1900), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 123.
XVlll
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pagas.
Cole. In re (1901). W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 84.
Cooke, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91.
Corbett, In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 241.
Corn, In re (1901). N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 101.
Cobb V. Overman (1901), C. C. A.,
4thCir., Waddill, J.,206.
Coe, Powers & Co., In re (1901), C.
C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 216.
Collins V. McWalters (1901), Sup.
Ct., N. Y., Gildersleeve, J.,
94, 105, 109.
Colwell V. Tinker (1901), N. Y. Sup.
Ct., Gildersleeve, T, 108.
Cohn, In re (1901), Dist. Ore., Bel-
linger, J., 99.
Cobb, /«r^.,E. Dist. Mass., Farmer,
R., 123.
CoUer, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 65.
Columbia Bank v. Birkett (1901),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Clark, J., 110.
Columbia Real Estate Co., In re
(1902), C. C. A., Tth Cir., Sea-
man, J., 115, 133.
Colwell V. Tinker (1902), N. Y. Sup.
Ct., Ct. App., Bartlett, J., 105.
Colton Export & Import Co., In
re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 180.
Countryman, In re (1903), W, Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 107.
Coddington, In re (1902), W. Dist.
Pa., Archbald, J., 46.
Conrader, In re (1902). W. Dist.
Pa., BuflFington, J., 57.
Costello V. Harbaugh (1898), Ct.
App. 111., 2.
Crenshaw, In re, S. Dist. Ala.,
Toulmin,J.,93.
Cronin, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 188.
Crooks V. Peoples Natl. Bank (1899),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Herrick, J.,
193 195
Crow, In r^'(1902), W. Dist. Ky.,
Dean, R., 217.
Craft V. Morrow (1902), Penn. Co.
Ct., Taylor, J., 222.
Cronson, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Pa., 216.
Criterion Watch Case Mfg. Co., In
re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise,
R., 89.
Crocker, In re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Wise, R., 176.
Crist, In re (1902), S. Dist. Ala.;
Toulmin, J., 93. 95.
Curtis. In re (1899), S. Dist. 111.,
Allen, J. ,2, 41,253.
Curtis. In re (1899), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Jenkins. J., 189.
Cunningham v. Bank (1900). C. C.
A., 6th Cir., Lurton, J., 150,
276.
Curtis, In re (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Jenkins, J., 136, 214.
Currier, In re (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 83.
Gushing, In re (1901), W. Dist.
N. Y., Moss, R., 209.
CuUinane v. State Bank of Waverly
(1902), Sup. Ct. la., Bishop,
J., 228.
D.
Damon, In re, W. Dist. N. Y.;
Hazel, J., 169.
Davidson, In re (1901), S. Dist. la.,'
McPherson, J., 195.
Daniels, In re (1901), Dist. R. I.,*
Brown, J. ,56, 211, 217.
Davis, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 246.
Davis V. Stevens (1900), Dist. S.
Dak., Carlin. J., 32.
Davis. In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 246.
Davis, In re (1903), W. Dist. Tex.,"
Maxey. J., 244.
Davis V. Bohle (1899), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Thayer, J., 2, 17. 40, 229,
240.
Dawley, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.,"
Wheeler, J., 65.
Daubner, In re (1899), Dist. Ore.;
Bellinger, J., 65.
Darwin. In re (1902), C. C. A.. 6th
Cir., Day, J., 231.
Day V. Beck, &c., Co. (1902). C. C.
A., 5th Cir., Shelby, J., 40,
118, 120.
Dayville Woolen Co. (1902). Dist.
Conn.. Townsend. J., 158.
DeLong. In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Moss. R.. 80.
DeLue, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 235.
DeLeeuw, In re (1899), Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 97.
Deuel, In re (1900), W. Dist. Mo.,
Philips. J.. 27.
Demarest, In re (1901), Dist. N. J.,
Kirkpatrick, J., 59.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XIX
The numbers refer to the pages.
DeLand v. Niptur & Chany Bank
(1903), Sup. Ct. la., Demarest,
J.. 194.
Dean v. Justices, &c. (1899), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 91.
Dews, In re (1899), Dist. R. I.,
Brown, J., 100.
Dews, In re (1900), Dist. R. I.,
Brown, J., 96, 98.
Denning, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 56.
Dean v. Plane et al. (1902), Sup.
Ct. 111., Cartwright, J., 193.
Dillon, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 183.
Dillon, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 61.
Diller, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 64.
Dinglehoef Bros, In re (1901), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 14.
Distler v. McCauley (1901), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Woodward, J. 105.
Dixon, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 90.
Diack, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 249.
Diack, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 27.
Dietz, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 103.
Dickinson, In re (1902), W. Dist.
N. Y., Moss, R., 197.
Dickson v. Wyman (1901), {In re
Jourdan), C. C. A., 1st Cir.,
Putnam, J., 201.
Dixon, /n re (1902), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 153.
Doyle V. Hall (1899), Appellate Ct.
111., 1st Dist., Horton, J., 232.
Doty, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Dexter, R., 184.
Dow, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.,
McPherson, J.,99.
Dobson, In re (1899), N. Dist. 111.,
Kohlsaat, J.,
Dougherty & Co., In re (1901), N.
Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 237.
Dole, In re (1901) , Dist. Vt., Wheeler,
J., 247.
Dreebin, In re (1900), N. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 214.
Dressel v. No. State Ltunber Co.
(1902^, E. Dist. N. C, Pumell,
J., 14, 179.
Drake, In re (1902), Dist. S. C,
Brawley, J., 50.
Duell, In re (1899). W. Dist. Mo.,
Philips, J., 155.
Durham, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Ark., Trieber, J., 20.
Duncan v. Landis (1901), C. C. A.,'
3rd Cir., Gray, J., 7, 39, 120,
134.
Dtinlap V. Thomas (1902), Sup. Ct.
Washington, White, J., 233.
Duncan, In re (1899), N. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 213.
Dunnigan Bros., In re (1899), Dist.
Mass., Lowell, J., 53, 58.
Duguid, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 47.
Dunbar v. Dunbar (1901), Sup. Ct.
Mass., Barber, J., 208.
Duffy, In re (1902), Middle Dist.
Pa., Archbald. J., 69.
Dundas, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 200.
Duplan Silk Co. v. Spencer (1902),
C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J.,
221 245.
Dupree,'/» re (1899), E. Dist. N.
C, Pumell, J., 44. 188.
Durham, In re (1902), Dist. Md.,
Morris, J., 130, 132.
Duble, In re (1902) , Middle Dist. Pa.,
Archbald, J., 208.
Dvorak, In re (1901), N. Dist. la,,
Shiras, J., 185.
Dwyer, In re (1902), Dist. N. Dak.
Amidon, J., 47, 119.
Eaton, In re (1901), N, Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 96.
Easley, In re, (1898,) W.Dist. Va.,
Paul, J., 234.
Easley, In re (1899), W. Dist. Va.,"
Paul, J., 21.
Eagles & Crisp, In re (1899), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 171.
Eagles & Crisp, In re (1900), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell. J., 54.
Ebert, In re (1899), W. Dist. Wis.,
Lewis, R., 192, 197.
Edson, In re (1902), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 193, 205, 208.
Eggert, In re (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir.,Jenkins,J.. 197.198.
Ehle. In re (1901), Dist Vt., Wheeler,
J., 245.
Eisenberg, In re (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 186.
Eidemiller, In re (1900), N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat, J., 44.
EUis V. L. Hayes, &c.: Co. (1902),
Sup. Ct. Kas., Smith, J., 189,
251.
XX
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pagM:
Elliott V. Toeppener (1902), Sup.
Ct. U. S., Fuller, J., 120.
Elstree v. Burt (1902). Sup. Ct.
R. I., Douglas, J., 104.
Elgin State Bank v. Rice (1902),
C. C. A., Sth Cir., Lochren,
J., 230.
Ells, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 205.
Elk Park, &c., Co., In re (1899),
Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 49.
Ellithorpe, In re (1901), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 60.
Elmira Steel Co., In re (1901), N.
Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 8, 14,
118, 190.
Elmira Steel Co., In re (1901), N.
Dist. N. Y., Moss, R., 14, 39,
118.
Empire Metallic Bedstead Co.,
In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 5.
Empire, &c., Co., In re (1899), N.
Dist. N. Y.,Coxe, J.,37.
Empire Metallic Bedstead Co.,
In re (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
Shipman, J., 37.
Emsley & Son, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 223, 234.
Emsley & Co., In re (1900), C. C.
A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 234.
Emerick, In re (1900), W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 242.
Emsile, In re (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Wallace, J., 82.
Engle, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 237.
Epstein, In re (1901), E. Dist. Ark.,
Trieber, J., 247.
Epstein, In re (1901), W. Dist.
Ark., Trieber, J., 163.
Ervin, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 55.
Ervin, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 175.
Eshwege & Cohn, In re (1902), S.
Dist. N. Y., WilUs, R., 214.
Etheridge Fumitvu-e Co., John A.,
In re (1899), Dist. Ky., Barr,
J., 2, 17,252.
Evans, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 68.
Evans v. Rounsaville (1902), Sup.
Ct. Ga., Little, J., 106, 226.
Evans v. Stalle (1903), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Stark, J., 111.
Ewing, In re (1902), C. C. A.. 2nd
Cir., 38, 190.
P.
Fahy, In re (1902), N. Dist. Iowa,
Shiras, J., 90.
Farley & Co., In re (1902), W. Dist.
Va., McDowell, J., 53, 187.
Farmer, In re (1902), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 205, 208.
Fall City Shirt Mfg. Co., In re (1899),
Dist. Ky., Evans, J. ,216.
Falconer, In re (1901), C. C. A.,
Sth Cir., Thayer, J., 61, 72.
Feigenbaum, In re (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y.,Adams,J.,91.
Feldstein, In re (1902), C. C. A.,
Lacombe, J., 101.
Feuerlicht, In re (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y., Smith,;., 193.
Fellereth, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Ricks, J., 198.
Ferguson, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 38.
Feldstein, In re (1900) , S. Dist. N. Y.,"
Brown, J., 73, 101.
Fellows V. Freudenthal (1900), C. C.
A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 30,
97 153.
Fields \. karter (1902), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., 94.
First Natl. Bank v. Hym (1902), Sup.
Ct. la., McLain, J., 81.
First Natl. Bank of Denver v.
Klugg (1902), Sup. Ct. U. S.,
Fuller, J., 133, 135.
Fisher, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Olmstead, R.,242.
Fixen, In re (1899), S. Dist. Cal.,'
Wellborn, J., 17, 123.
Fielding, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Mo., Philips, J., 153, 163, 217.
Finklestein, In re (1900), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 95.
Finley, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 171.
Fisher, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 242.
Finley, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 271.
Fisher v. Cushman (1900), C. C. A.,
1st Cir., Putnam. J., 20. 27.
Fitchard, Inre (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe. J., 98.
Fixen & Co., In re (1900), C. C. A.,
9th Cir., Morrow, J., 10, 181.
Filer. In re (1900). S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 13. 32.
Filer, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Dexter, R., 176.
TABLE OP CASES DIGESTED.
XXI
The numbers refer to the pages.
Fider, In re (1899), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Wanty, J., 111.
Fite V. Fite (1901), Ct. App. Ky.,
Guffy, J., 205.
Fife, In re (1901), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J.,6, 209.
Finnigan v. Hall (1901), N. Y. Sup.
Ct., Russell, J., 105.
First Natl. Bank of Guilford v.
Weare (1901), Sup. Ct. Me.,
Emory, J.. 252.
Fleishman (1902), Dist. Ct. N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat, J., 95.
Flannagan, In re (1902), W. Dist.
Tex., Maxey, J., 68.
Flick, In re (1900), S. Dist. O.,
Thompson, J., 176, 211.
Fly, In re (1901), S. Dist. Cal.,
Wellborn, J., 66.
Forbes, In re (1901), N. Dist. O.,
Doyle, R., 248.
Foley, Dean Lumber Co. v. Sawyer
(1899), Sup. Ct. Minn., Mitchell,
J. 2.
Foerst, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 123.
Folb, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 173.
Fowler, In re (1899), W. Dist. Wis.,
Bunn, J., 122.
Fowler, In re (1899), Dist. Conn.,
Banks, R., 130.
Fort Wayne Electric Co., In re
(1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
153 225
Forsyth' v. Vehmeyer (1900), U. S.
Sup. Ct., Peckham, J., 109.
Force, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer, R., 211.
Foreman v. Burley (1901), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., Putnam, J., 137, 175.
Fox, In re (1900), N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 88.
Fox, Simon, In re (1901), N. Dist.
I O., Remington, R., 185.
French v. R. Pets Co. (1900), 132.
Franklin, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 130.
Freche, In re (1901), Dist. N. J.,
Kirkpatrick, J., 109.
Frazee v. Nelson (1901), Sup. Ct.
Mass., Morton, J., 233.
Fruda v. Osgood (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. H.,Blodgett,J., 132.
Frey v. Torrey (1902), Sup. Ct. N.
Y.,Laughlin, J., 109.
Freschberg. In re (1902), S. Dist. N.
Y., Wise, R., 115.
Frazier, In re (1902), W. Dist. Mo.;
Philips, J., 221.
Freimd, In re (1899), N. Dist. Penn.,
James, R., 51.
Frick, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Fay, R., 212, 215.
Franks, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ala.,
Toulmin, J., 22.
Price, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 94, 279, 356.
Friedman, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Holt, R., 246.
Friedman, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Holt, R., 178, 225.
Frazier v. Southern Loan & Trust
Co. (1900), C. C. A., 4th Cir.,
Paul, J., 22.
Freund, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 97, 98.
Friederich, In re (1900), C. C. A.,
7th Cir., Jenkins, J„ 59.
Franklin Syndicate, In re (1900),
E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J.,
73, 186.
Frye v. Penna. Trust Co., (1900)
Sup. Ct. Pa., Green, J., 200.
Frank, In re (1901), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 92.
Francis- Valentine Co., In re (1899),
N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., (235).
Francis- Valentine Co., In re (1899),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J.,
240.
Fxilton Club, In re (1902), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 50.
Funk, In re (1900), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 33, 47.
G.
Gany, In re (1900), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 245, 246.
Gardner, In re (1901), E. Dist. Va.,
Waddill,J.,153.
Gardiner, In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 247.
Gasser, In re (1900), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Sanborn, J., 279.
Garden, In re (1899), N. Dist. Ala.,
Bruce, J., 61.
Gay, In re (1899), Dist. N. H.,
Aldrich, J., 52, 167.
Gallagher, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer, R.. 196.
Gamer, In re (1901), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 229.
Gaylord, In re (1901), N. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 99.
XXll
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages.
Gaylord, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Wallace, J., 95.
Gaylord, In re (1901), E. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 242.
Gaylord, In re (1902), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 182.
Gabriel v. Tonner (1902), Sup. Ct.
Cal., Gray, J., 199.
Gans V. Ellison (1902), C. C. A., 3rd
Cir., Acheson, J., 201, 202.
Gashington, In re (1902), N. Dist.
Tex., Meek, J., 208.
Gamer, In re (1902), W. Dist. Va.,
McDowell, J., 62.
Gage V. Bates Machine Co. (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. H., Mather, J.,
81, 131.
Gerdes, In re (1900), S. Dist. O.,
Thompson, J., 129.
Gerson, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
Mason, R., 176.
Gerson, In re E. Dist. Pa., Mason, R.,
163.
Gerson, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
Mason, R., 163, 214, 216.
Gerson, In re (1901), C. C. A., 3rd
Cir., Acheson, J., 207.
Gee V. Gee (1901), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Lovely, J., 110.
Gemer v. Yates (1900), Sup. Ct.
Neb., Sullivan, J., 112.
GhigUone, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 46.
Gibbs, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 66.
Gillette & Prentice, In re (1900),
W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 56,
57, 190.
Gibbs, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 225.
Gister, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 82.
Githens v. Shiffler (1902), Middle
Dist. Pa., Archbald, J., 32.
Gilbert, In re (1902), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 8, 35, 37, 38.
Gibson, In re (1902), Sup. Ct. L T.,
Clayton, J., 71.
Glover Grocery Co. v. Done (1902),
Sup. Ct. Ga., Lvunpkin, J.,
87.
Globe Cycle Works, In re (1899),
N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.,
79.
Glasner, Snyder & Co., In r<?(1902),
Dist. Md., Brinton, R., 74.
Glass, In re (1902), N. Dist. N. Y.,
King, R., 265, 279.
Gladding Co., In re (1902), Dist.
R. L, Barrows, R., 207.
Good, In re (1900), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Thayer, J., 133, 135.
Goodman Shoe Co., Albert, In re
(1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPher-
son, J., 238.
Goldman, In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 247.
Goldsmith, In re N. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 174.
Goldberg, In re (1898), Dist. Utah.
Baldwin, R., 130, 131.
Goldman, Beckman & Co. v. Smith
(1899), Dist. Ky., Barr, J.,
33, 34, 116, 266.
Goldman, Beckman & Co. v. Smith
(1899), Dist. Ky., Durrett, R.,
220.
Goldstein, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Pa., Van Wormer, R., 216.
Goodier v. Barnes (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y.,Coxe, J., 127, 132.
Goodale et al, In re (1901), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 95.
Goodman v. Brunner (1901), C. C.
A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 136.
Goetzinger, In re (1901), W. Dist.
Pa., Bunffington, J., 56.
Goodyear Rubber Co. v. Schreiber
(1902), Sup. Ct. Washington, Ful-
ler, J., 253.
Gordon, In re (1902), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 66.
Goyer Co. v. Jones (1901), Sup. Ct.
Miss., 105.
Goldberg, In re (1902), N. Dist.
N. Y.,Ray,J.,81,231.
Gottardi, In re (1902), S. Dist.
Cal., Wellborn, J., 26, 27.
Gray, In re (1900), Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Barrett, J., 228.
Greenewald, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 215.
Greater American Exposition, In re
(1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir.,
Thayer, J., 130.
Grayson, In re (1901), Sup. Ct. L
T., 69.
Grant, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 35, 41.
Green, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 22.
Griffith, In re (1899), E. Dist. Tenn.,*
Grayson, R., 130.
Grabs, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ohio,
Geiger, R., 248.
TABLE OP CASES DIGESTED.
xxm
The numbers refer to the pages.
Grist, In re (1898), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 77.
Grimes, In re (1899), W. Dist. N. C,
Alexander, R., 61.
Grimes, In re (1899), W. Dist. N. C,
Ewart, J., 13, 59, 60, 161, 213.
Grubs-Wiley Co., In re (1899). W.
Dist. Mo., Rathbun, R., 214.
Green River Deposit Bank v. Craig
Bros. (1901), W. Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 40, 41, 116.
Grossman, In re (1901), E. Dist.
Mich., Swan, J., 75.
Groves, In re (1901), N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 64, 74.
Greth, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 182.
Gracewich, In re (1902), C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., Wallace, j., 246.
Graff, In re (1902), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 179.
Greenberg, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.,
Townsend, J., 101.
Gutman & Wenk, In re (1902), S.
Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 81.
82, 241.
Gutwillig, In re (1898), So. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 40.
Gutwillig, In re (1899). C. C. A.,
2nd Cir.. Wallace. J., 28. 82,
234.
H.
Hartmann. In re (1899), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 93, 108.
Hamilton, In re (1900), W. Dist.
Ark., Rogers, J., 16.
Hansen v. Stephens (1902), Sup.
Ct. Ga., Little, J., 23.
Harris, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 58.
Harris, In re (1902), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 87.
Harris, In re (1899), N. Dist. O..
Ricks, J., 56.
Harris, In re (1899), N. Dist. 111.,
Wean. R.. 71, 249, 265.
Hatch, In re (1900). S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 65.
Hawk V. Hawk (1900), W. Dist.
Ark., Rogers, J., 206.
Haensel, In re (1899), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 85, 242.
Hayden, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Locke, J. .73, 74.
Harrison Merc. Co., In re (1899).
W. Dist. Mo., Philips, J., 213.
Hatch, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mich.,
Davock, R,, 59.
Hammond, In re (1899). Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 224.
Harper & Bro., In re (1900), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 33, 37.
Harrington, In re (1900). N. Dist.
Tex.. Meek. J.. 63.
Harrington, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Tex., Dillard, R., 65.
Hathhom, In re (1900), E. Dist.
La., Gurley, R.. 73.
Hanna & Kirk, In re (1901), E.
Dist. Pa.. McPherson, J., 36.
Harper, In re (1900). N. Dist. 111.,
Kohlsaat. J., 37, 39.
Hale et al.. In re (1901), E. Dist.
N. C.,Pumell,J.,52, 92.
Hargardine-McKittrich Dry Goods
Co. V. Hudson et al. (1901).
Cir. Ct. U. S.. E. Dist. Mo..
Rogers, J., 106.
Haskin, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 67.
Hassenbusch, In re (1901), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Clark. J.. 78.
Har^'ey v. Smith. In re (1901), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Knowlton, J., 226.
Harmon v. Feldhein et al. (1902).
Sup. Ct. Mich., 195.
Hanover Natl. Bank v. Moyses
(1902). Sup. Ct. U. S.. Fuller.
C. J., 1,64.
Hardt v. Schuylkill Plush & Silk
Co. (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Ingraham, J., 231.
Harpke, In re (1902), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Grosscup, J., 194.
Hawk, In re (1902), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Sanborn, J., 104.
Hamilton v. McCrosky (1900), Sup.
Ct. Ga.. Lewes, J., 208.
Hamilton Furniture & Carpet Co.,
In re (1902), Dist. Ind.. Baker.
J., 222.
Hathaway v. Masterson (1902),
Ct. App. 111., 1st Cir., Water-
man, J., 104.
Harrison v. Walker (1902), Sup.
Ct. Mich.. Montgomery, J..
195.
Hayes. Foster & Ward, In re (1902),
W. Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 208.
Haskell v. Merrill et al. (1900), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 244.
Headley, In re (1899), W. Dist. Mo..
Philips, J., 74, 179, 274.
Heinsfurter, In re (1899). S. Dist.
la., Woolson, J., 16, 228.
Herrman, In re (1900) , S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 97.
XXIV
TABLE OP CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages.
Henrich, In re (1899), Dist. Md.,
Hisky, R., 248.
Hesselton v. Prince (1899), Dist.
Mass., Lowell, J., 242.
Heyman, In re (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Thomas, J., 183.
Heyman, In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 87.
Hebbart, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 192.
Hemby, Hutchinson Publ. Co., In
re (1900), N. Dist. 111., Kolh-
saat, J., 130.
Henschel, In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Wise, R., 28.
Henschel, In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 5, 157, 173.
Head & Smith, In re (1902), W.
Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 229.
Henschel, In re (1902), C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 173,
273.
Hemstreet, In re (1902), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 122.
Henschel, In re (1902), S. Dist. N.
Y., Adams, J., 13, 137.
Herron Co. v. Sup. Ct./n re (1902),
Sup. Ct. Cal., Harrison, J., 2.
Herzikopf, In re (1902), S. Dist.
Cal., Wellborn, J., 117.
Hill V. Levy, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Va., WaddiU, J., 181.
Hirsch, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 92, 96.
Hicks V. Knost, In re (1899), S. Dist.
O., Thompson, J., 129.
Hicks V. Knost, In re (1900), U. S.
Sup. Ct., Gray, J., 128.
Hilbom, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 87.
Hilton, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 84.
Hixon, In re (1899), S. Dist. la..
Woolson, J., 279.
Hill, In re (1899), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 22, 60.
Hirsch, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 53, 91.
Hindman, In re (1900), C. C. A.,
9th Cir., Hawley, J., 66.
Hicks, In re (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheel-
er, J., 41, 75.
Hilberg, In re (1901), W. Dist. Pa.,
Myers, R., 209.
Hickey, In re (1901), N. Dist. Ja.,
Shiras, J., 182.
Hinsdale, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 248.
Hines, In re (1902)., S. Dist. Va.
Keller, J., 68.
Higgins, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.;
Evans, J., 234.
Hoadley & Monroe, In re (1900), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 244.
Hoag, In re (1899), W. Dist. Wis.,
Bunn, J., 63.
Horgan & Slattery, In re (1910), C.
C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace J., 74,
123.
Howland, In re (1901), N. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 222.
HoUoway, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.;
Evans, J., 80, 82.
Holman, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J. ,91, 102, 279.
Hopkins, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 64.
Hopkins, In re (1899), N. Dist.
Ala., Turner, R., 62, 236.
HoUenfeltz, In re (1899), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 224.
Houston, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 84, 205.
Howard, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 122, 177.
House, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 99.
Hoover, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 104.
Hoyer v. Comstock (1901), Sup. Ct.
la., Gibbons, J., 202.
Holden, In re (1902), C. C. A., 9th
Cir., McKenna, J., 69, 249.
Hoover, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 62.
Howden, In re (1901), N. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 94.
Holstein, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.,
Piatt, J., 98, 101.
Harbaugh v. Costello (1900), Sup.
Ct. 111., Magruder, J., 2.
Hoffman Addn., In re (1900), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97.
Holland v. Cunliflf (1902), Ct. App.
Mo., Barclay, J., 111.
Hood V. Blair State Bank (1902),
Sup. Ct. Neb., Barnes, J., 252.
Hubbard, In re (1899), N. Dist.
Ill.,Kohlsaat,J.,108.
Hughill, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Ricks, J., 234.
Huber, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Judson, R., 97, 206.
Huddleston, In re (1899), N. Dist.
Ala., Turner, R., 149, 240.
Huffman, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.,
Myers, R., 236.
Humbert & Co. (1900), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 118, 188, 266.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXV
The numbers refer to the pages.
Huston,"7M re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Holt, R., 243.
Huenergardt v. Brittain Dry Goods
Co. (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir.,
Thayer ,J., 67.
Hull, In re (1902) , Dist, Vt., Wheeler,
J., 243, 246.
Hutchinson v. Otis (1902), C. C. A.,
1st Cir., Putnam, J., 231.
Hutcinson v. Leroy (1902), C. C.
A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 129,
136.
Hunt, In re (1902), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J.,117.
Hyde & Glo Mfg. (5©. (1900), E
Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 116.
Hyman, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 102.
Ideal Clothing Co. v. Hazel (1901),
Sup. Ct. Mich., 129.
Idzell, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolsen, J., 93.
Independent Thread Co., In re (1902)
Dist. N. Y., Kirkpatrick, J.,
50.
Ives, In re (1902), C. C. A., 6th Cir
Wanty, J., 28, 54, 118, 136.
J.
Jacobs, In re (1899), W. Dist. la.,
Jones, R., 198, 225.
Jackson, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 177.
Janecki Mfg. Co. v. McElwaine (1900)
Dist Ind., Baker, J., 58.
Jacobs,' In re (1900), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Thayer, J., 134.
Jamieson, In re (1901), Dist R. I.,
Littlefield, R., 243.
Jackson, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 68, 221.
Jaquith v. Alden In re (1902) , C. C.
A., 1st Cir., Lowell, J., 202.
Jefferson, In re (1899), Dist. Wash.,
Handford, J., 123.
Jefferson, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 205.
Jehu, In re (1899) , N. Dist. la., Shiras
J., 75, 177, 187.
Jemison Mercantile Co., In re (1902),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick,
J., 135, 190, 192.
Jennings, In re (1902), W. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 231.
Johnson, In re- (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 236.
Johnson v. Wold (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir.,Shely,J.,33, 34, 35.
Jones, In re (1899), S. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 63.
Johnson v. Cohn (1902), Sup. Ct. N.
Y., Gildersleeve, J., 194.
Jones & Cook, In re (1900), E. Dist.
Mo., Adams, J., 56, 57.
Jones V. Stevens, In re (1901), Sup.
Ct., Me. Wiswell, J., 143.
Johnson, In re (1901), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 68.
Johnson, Admr., v. Parmenter (1901)
Sup.Ct.Vt.,Rowell,J.,lll.
Jourdan, In re (Dickson v. Wyman
(1901), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J.,
202.
Jones, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 179.
Jones V. Schermerhom (1900), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Adams, J., 132, 233.
Jones, In re (1902), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell,J.,56.
Joseph V. Makley (1902), Sup. Ct.,
N. Y., App., Div., O'Brien, J..
84.
Jones V. Rock & Malloy (1898), Dist.
Ct. Pa., Clayton, J., 194.
K.
Kahn, In re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Wise, R., 85.
Kahn v. Export & Commission Co.
(1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 201.
Kaizer, In re (1902), Dist. Mont.,
Knowles, J.,163.
Kaldenberg, In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 175.
Kalter, Max In re (1899), E. Dist.
Pa., Mason, R., 165.
Kaiser, In re (1900), Dist. Minn.,
Lochren, J., 92, 279.
Kautter & Cohen, In re S. Dist. N.
Y., Adams, J., 74.
Kaufman, In re (1900), E. Dist. N.
Y., Thomas, J., 209.
Kenney, In re (1900), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Laconde, J., 237.
Ketchum, In re (1901), C. C. A., 6th
Cir.,Clark, J., 27, 28.
Keller, In re (1901), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J.. 181, 196, 201, 215.
Kersten & Kersten, In re (1901), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 22, 37,
42.
Kellogg, In re (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.,
McMaster, R.. 237.
Kellogg, In re (1902), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 20, 132, 227, 246.
XXVI
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages;
Ketcham v. McNamara (1900), Sup.
Ct. Conn., Baldwin, J., 243.
Keystone Coal Co., In re (1901), W.
Dist. Pa., Van Womer, R., 50.
Keystone Coal Co., In re (1901), W.
Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 50.
Kenyon, In re (1902), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 100, 101.
Keller v. Fort Wayne Electric Co.
(1899), Cir. Ct.Ia., Craig, J., 232.
Kelley, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 239.
Kenney, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 52.
Kerby- Dennis Co., In re (1900), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 235.
Kerski, In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Forward, R., 27.
Keegan v. King (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 23.
Kelley Dry Goods Co., In re (1900),
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 24,
41, 42, 213, 266, 276.
Kemp, In re (1900), Dist. Col., Hal-
lett, J., 233.
Kingman, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer, R., 256, 254.
Kimball v. Rosenham Co., In re
(1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., San-
bom, J., 108, 202.
Henry C. King Co., In re (1902),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 179.
Kirby-Dennis Co., In re (1899), C. C.
A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 220.
Kimball, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 81, 82.
Kindt, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 116.
Kindt, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 20, 191, 201, 260.
Kimball, /n re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 175, 260.
Kinmouth v. Brautigam (1900),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Collins, J., 233.
Klein & Co.. In re (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 159.
Klopholtz & Brien, In re (1902), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 226.
Kleinhans, In re (1902), W. Dist.
N. Y., Hazel, J., 17.
Kletchka, Inre (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 80, 81, 82.
Klingman, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 196.
Klein, In re (1900), N. Dist., 111.,
Kohlsaat, J., 83.
Klingaman, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Gale, R., 245.
Knott, In re (1900), Dist. Vt., Whee-
ler, J., 176.
Knott V. Putnam (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 94, 106.
Knost & Wilhelmy, In re (1899), S.
Dist. O., Waite, R., 181, 193.
Knox, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 181.
Kross, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 75, 212.
Kuffler, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 157.
Krinsky Bros., In re (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 26, 28.
Kuntz, In re (1899), Dist. Minn.,
Dovan, R., 244.
^,.
Lane v. Holcombe (1902), Sup. Ct.
Mass., Knowlton, J., 111.
Laundry v. First Natl. Bank (1903) ,
Sup. Ct. Kans., 193.
Landis v. McDonald, (1901), Ct. App.
Mo., Ellison, J., 194.
Lampkin v. Peoples Natl. Bank
(1902), Sup. Ct. Mo., Ellison, J.,
199.
Lafleche, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 109.
Lamoillie, &c.. Bank v. Stevens Est.
(1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J.,
55.
Lawlor, In re (1901), Dist. Washing-
ton, Handford, J., 215, 217.
Lanshaw, In re (1902), Dist. Mo.,
Philips, J., 174.
Lange, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 34, 249.
Langslow et al.. In re (1899), N.
Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 167.
Laskaris, Inre (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Morse, R., 15.
Lasser Bros., In re (1900), C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 175.
Lazarovic, In re (1898), Dist. Kans.,
Corey, R., 16, 148.
Lange, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 41.
Lange, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 196.
Laughlin, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 52, 58, 72.
Levi, In re (1903), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 194.
Levy, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 54.
Leslie, In re (1903), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Ray, J., 95.
Leicester v. Hoadley (1903), Sup.
Ct. Kas., Cunningham, J., 112.
Lesser, In re, C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
Shipman, J., 237.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXVU
The numbers refer to the pages.
Lengert Wagon Co., In re (1901),
S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 22.
Lemon, &c., Co., In re (1901),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Day, J., 29,
130.
Levi, In re (1902), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Van Vorhis, R., 180.
Levor v. Seiter et al.. In re (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Patterson, J.,
194, 231, 233.
Lehigh Lumber Co., In re (1900), W.
Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 56,
196.
Levy, In re (1901), W. Dist, Pa.,
Buffington, J., 86, 88.
Levy, -^'t ■"« (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 168.
Lewis, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 207, 214.
Leopold, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Wise, R., 101.
Lesser, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J.. 175.
Lesser Bros., In re (1901), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 100.
Levor v. Seiter (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Leventripp, J., 229.
Lea Bros. v. Geo. M. West Co.
(1899), E. Dist. Va.,Waddill,J.,
28, 252, 253.
Lewis & Bros., In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 6, 229.
Lewis, In re (1899), 8. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 44.
Leeman, In re (1899), Dist. Me.,
Sprague,, R., 180.
Leidigh Carriage Co. v. Stengil (1899)
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 28,
40, 41, 47, 83, 115, 251.
Leigh Bros., In re (1899), Dist. Col.,
Patterson, R., 220.
Levy & Richman, In re (1899), N.
Dist. N. Y., Moss, R., 51.
Lehman v. Crosby, In re (1900), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 128.
Lesser, In re (1900), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Lacombe, J., 79.
Lewensohn, In re (1900), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 75, 76, 157,
225.
Liebowitz, In re (1901), N. Dist.
Tex., Meek, J., 185.
Little, In re (1901), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 60, 131, 183, 226.
Linton, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
Hoflfman, R., 120, 273.
Lisun V. Kraus (1901) , Sup. Ct. N. Y..
Hazel, J., 112.
Lipke, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 27, 78.
Little River Ltmiber Co., In re (1899)
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 34,
193.
Little River Lumber Co., In re (1900)
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 212.
Libby, In re (1900), Dist. Vt., Whee-
ler, J., 65.
Lipman, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.
Brown, J., 174.
Lieber, In re (1899), Dist. Pa.,'
Mason, R., 102.
Lond, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mich.;
Davock, R., 220.
Logorri V. Haven (1902), Sup. Ct. N.
Y.,Gildersleeve,J., 232.
Lott V. Yoimg (1901), C. C. A., 9th
Cir.,Hawley,J.,52.
Louisville Trust Co. v. Comingor
(1902), Sup. Ct. U. S., Fuller. J.,
128.
Louisville Trust Co. v. Marx (1899),
Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 129.
Logan, In re (1900), Dist. Ky.;
Evans, J., 93.
Logan V. Nebraska Moline Plow Co.
(1902), Sup. Ct, Neb., Day, J.,
221.
Lowensohn, In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 225. 234.
Locks. In re (1900), W\ Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 96.
Lorillard, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2d
Cir., Lacombe, J., 108.
Lowenstein, In re (1899), S. Dist.N.
Y., Brown, J., 174.
Ludovice Roofing Tile Co. v. Penn.
Inst, for the Blind, C. C. A.,
Dist. Pa., Archbald, J., 231.
Luckhardt, In re (1900), Dist, Kan.,'
Hook, J., 49.
Lyon. In re (1901), S. Dist N. Y.,'
Wise, R., 273.
Lyon V. Clark (1900) , Sup. Ct. Mich.,'
Moore, J., 131, 132.
Lynch, In re (1900), S, Dist. Ga.;
Speer, J., 66, 161.
Lynch, In re (1889), W. Dist. Mo.;
Crittenden, R., 65.
M.
MaUno, In re (1902), E. Dist. N. Y.J
Adams, J., 158.
Marsh, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.;
Piatt, J., 208.
Marx et al., In re (1900), Dist. Ky.J
Evans, J., 73, 102.
Mallner, In re (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y.;
Patterson, J., 111.
XXVIU
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refer to the pages.
Macon Sash, &c., Co., In re (1901),
S. Dist. Ga., Spear, J., 1, 17, 23,
130.
Manning, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 66, 269.
Martin v. Bigelow (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Scott, J., 7, 201.
Margden v. Sugden (1902), Sup.Ct.
N. H.,Renwick,J.,199.
Mackey, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2d
Cir., 249.
Magid-Hope Silk Mfg. Co., In re
(1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
14, 115.
Maisner v. Maisner (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Patterson, J., 99, 105.
Mammoth Pine Lumber Co., In re
(1901), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers,
J, 192.
Marks & Garson, In re (1901) ,W.Dist.
N. Y., Van Vooris, R., 206.
Marsh, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 96.
Marvin v. Anderson (1901), Sup. Ct.
Wis., Marshall, J., 7.
Matthews, In re (1901), W. Dist.
Ark., Rogers, J., 236.
Mauran v. Crown Carpet Lining Co.
(1901), Sup. Ct. R. I., Rogers,
J., 2-235.
Mayer, In re (1901), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Woods, J., 25, 66.
Mackeller, In re (1902), Middle Dist.
Pa., Archibald. J., 173.
Mauran v. Crown Carpet Lining Co.
(1901), Sup. Ct. R. I., Rogers,
J., 2-235.
MaCauley, In re (1900), E. Dist. N.
Y., Thomas. J., 105.
Mahler, In re (1900), E. Dist. Mich.,
Swan, J., 206.
Maples, In re (1901), Dist. Mont.,
Knowles, J., 91. 118.
Marcus, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 207.
Marcus, In re (1901), C. C. A., 1st
Cir., Putnam, J., 207.
Marten, In re (1901), W, Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 80.
May, In re (1900), Dist. Minn., Mer-
riman, R.. 242.
Mason, In re (1900), W. Dist. N. C,
Ewart, J., 14, 117.
Matthews, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras,J.,167.
Mayer. In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman,J..26. 27, 212, 213.
Mayer, In re (1899), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 123.
Mayer, In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.;
Seaman, J., 215.
Mackel v. Rochester (1900), C. C. A.,
9th Cir., Morrow, J., 74.
Marden v. Phillips (1900), Dist.
Mass., Brown, J., 178.
Marquette, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 66.
Marshall Paper Co., In re (1900), C.
C. A., 1st Cir., Colt, J., 91, 94.
Mackey & Co., In re (1898), N. Dist.
N. Y., Collier. R., 150.
Marine Machine & Conveyor Co., In
re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown
J., 13, 15, 42.
Mather v.Coe.&c.Co. (1899), N. Dist.
O., Ricks, J., 34, 36, 38, 116, 261,
302.
Marshall Paper Co., In re (1899),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 93, 104.
Mason & Son, In re (1899) , Dist. R. L
Littlefield, R., 51.
Mahoney et al. v. Ward (1900), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 24, 52, 71
115, 302.
McCormick v. Page (1901), Ct. App.
111., Dibbell, J., 199.
McCuUough & Linn v. Goodheart
(1899), Cumberland Co. Com.
Pleas Ct., Biddle, J., 254.
McCall V. Hening (1902), Sup. Ct.
Ga., Little, J., 111.
McArvdy v. Tantz (1902), Cir. Ct.
Pa., Weard. J., 2.
Mclntyre v. Malone et al. (1902) , Sup.
Ct. Neb.,81.
McCallum In re (1902), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson. J., 19.
McCarty, In re (1901), N. Dist 111.,
Humphrey, J., 95.
McGahan v. Anderson (1902), C. C.
A., 4th Cir., Jackson, J., 25,
161, 64.
McHarry (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Grosscup, J., 248.
McLean v. Mayo (1901), E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell. J., 80.
McNair v. Mclntyre (1902), C. C.
A., 4th Cir., Simonton, J., 53,
58, 182.
McBachran, In re (1902), E. Dist.
Wis., Seaman, J., 101.
McCartney, In re (1901), E. Dist.
Wis., Seaman, J., 21.
McFarland Carriage Co. et al. v.
Salanas et al. (1901). C. C. A.,
5th Cir., 21.
McFarland Carriage Co. v. Salanas
(1901), E. Dist. La., Boarman,
J.. 247.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXIX
The numbers refers to the pages.
McGee, In re (1901), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 34, 35, 36.
McGill. In r- (1901), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Day, J., 171, 173.
McKey v. Lee (1901), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Grosscup, J., 181, 201.
McNamara et al. v. Helena Coal Co.
(1900), N. Dist. Ala., Bruce,
J., 49.
McCutchen, In re (1900), E. Dist.
S. C, Brawley, J., 64.
McDonnell, In re (1900), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 242.
McDuff, In re (1900), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Pardee, J., 148,266.
McGum, In re (1900), Dist. Nev.,
Hawley, J., 279.
McDanielw. Strand (1901), CCA
4th Cir., Simonton, J., 134.
McAdam, In re (1899), S. Dist.N.
Y., Brown, J., 140.
McBride, In re (1899), E. Dist. N.
C, Pumell, J. 209.
McCullogh & Linn v. Goodhard
(1899), Cir. Ct. Pa., Cumber-
land Co., Pa., Biddle, J., 2.
McCormick, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 25, 27.
McFaun, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J. ,56, 72, 93, 108.
McLam, In re (1899). Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 139, 223.
McKay, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Wheeler, R., 245.
McKee, In re (1899), Jefferson Co.
Ct., Ky., Gregory, J., 252, 254.
McNamara, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Wise, R., 98.
Mencke v. Rosenberg (1902), Sup.
Ct. Pa., Mestrezot, J., 231.
Mercur, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
Archbald, J., 53,58, 187.
Metzger Toy & Novelty Co., In re
(1902), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers,
J., 197.
Metcalf Bros. v. Barker (1902) , Sup.
Ct. U. S., Fuller, C J., 257.
Metcalf V. Barker (1902), Sup. Ct.
U. S., Fuller J., 222, 231, 237,
251.
Meggett, In re (1900), Sup. Ct. Wis..
Dodge, J., 112.
Mersman, In re (1901). W. Dist. N.
Y.. Hotchkiss, R., 131, 196.
Messengill, In re (1902), E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell, T-, 86, 88.
Meriwether, In re (1901), W. Dist.
Ark., Trieber, J., 59.
Mellen, In re (1899) , S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J, 73, 124.
Meyer, In re (1902), N. Dist, Tex.7
Meek, J., 179.
Meyer, In re (1899), C C. A., 2nd
Cir, Wallace, J., 40, 52, 53.
Meyers, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91, 263.
Meyers, In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 95, 103, 104, 134.
Meyers & Chami, In re (1900), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 175.
Meyer & Dickinson, In re (1901), E.
Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 180.
238
Meyers, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 36.
Meyers & Co., In re (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 246, 254.
Mercur, In re "E. Dist. Pa., McPher-
son, J., 191.
Miller v. Shiver (1900), Sup. Ct.
Pa., Fell, J., 230.
Michie, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 21, 131.
Mitchell, In re (1902), Dist. Del.,
Bradford, J., 6, 207.
Miner, In re (1902), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 92, 176.
MiUer v. Black (1901), Dist. Ct.
Pa., 69.
Miller Electric Maintenance Co.,
In re (1901), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 19,28.
Miller, In re (1900), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 8, 36, 39.
Miller, In re (1900), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 27, 154.
Miller, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 251.
Miller, In re (1899), W. Dist. Mo.,
Crittendon, R., 64.
Mills V. Kieman (1900), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Birchoff, J., 127.
Mingo Valley Creamery Assn., In
re (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPher-
son, J., 34.
Mitchell V. McClure, In re (1900).
U. S. Sup. Ct.. 128.
Minn. &c.. Construction Co., In re
(1900),Sup. Ct. Ariz.,51.
Michel. In re (1899), E. Dist. Wis.;
Jones, R., 212.
Mitchell V. McClure, In re (1899),
W. Dist. Pa., Buffington. J., 127.
Mitchell, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Pa., Van Werner, R., 163.
Monroe, In re (1902), Dist. Wash.,'
Handford, J., 72, 91.
Moore, In re (1901), Middle Dist.
Ala., Jones, J., 62.
XXX
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refers to the pages:
Moran v. King (1901), C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Boyd, J., 60, 72.
Morton, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 179.
Morey Mer. Co. v. Schiflfer (1902), C.
C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J.,
182 202
Morris, 'in re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 45.
Morse & Rogers v. Kaufman (1902) ,
Sup. Ct. App., Va., Whittle,
J., 109, 110.
Mosier, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 56.
Morgan v. Wordell (1901), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 239.
Morrison, In re (1901), E. Dist.
Ark., Trieber, J., 67.
Moore, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 159.
Moore, In re (1900), Dist. W. Va.,
Jackson, J., 240.
Morales, In re (1901), S. Dist. Fla.,
Locke, J., 44.
Moran, In re (1900), W. Dist. Pa.,
Paul, J., 63, 72.
Morris V. Dodd, In re (1900), Sup.
Ct. Ga., Fish, J., 243.
Morgan, In re (1900), W. Dist.
Ark., Rogers, J., 102.
Morrow, In re (1899), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J.,96.
Moyer, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 38, 188.
Muhlhausen Co., In re (1902), N.
Dist. O., Remington, R., 163.
Murray v. Beal (1901), Sup. Ct.
Utah, 44.
Mueller v. Bruss (1901), Sup. Ct.
Wis., Bamum, J., 253.
Mueller v. Nugent (1902), Sup. Ct.
U. S., Fuller, J., 26, 27, 128,
148, 240.
Mutual Mercantile Agency, In re
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams,
J., 42, 50.
Mullen, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 229.
Munroe v. Dewey, In re (1900), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 244.
Murray, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 54, 118, 263.
Murray v. Beale (1899), Dist. Utah,
Marshall, J., 19, 128, 129, 232.
Murray et al.. In re (1899), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 263.
Mussey, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 109.
Mutual, &c., Assn. v. Beatty (1899),
C. C. A.. 9th Cir., Morrow, J.,
108.
Myers, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,"
Mason, R., 65.
Myers, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 242.
Myers v. Hart (1901), C. C. Ohio,
Cook J., 131.
N.
Nachman, In re (1902), Dist. S. C,
Brawley, J., 74, 123.
Natl. Bank of the Republic v. Hobbs
(1901), Cir. Ct. S. Dist. Ga.,
Speer, J., 262.
Natl. Bank v. Moyss (1902), Sup.
Ct. U. S., Fuller, C. J., 148.
Nathan, In re (1899), Dist. Nev.,
Hawley, J., 81.
Natl. Distilling Co. v. Seidel (1899),
Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall, J.,
84.
Natl. Bank & Loan Co. v. Spencer
(1900), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Spring,
J., 232.
Neeley, In re (1902), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Lacombe, J., 84.
New Lamp, &c., Co. v. Ansonia
Brass. &c., Co. (1876), Sup.
Ct. U. S., 1.
New Orleans Acid & Fertilizer Co
V. Grisson & Suggs (1901), Sup.
Ct. Miss., Calhoun, J., 228.
Nelson, In re (1899), W. Dist. Wis.,
Bunn, J., 36, 39, 43, 59, 117.
Neustadter v. Chicago Dry Goods
Co. (1899), Dist. Washington,
Handford, J., 119, 186, 236.
Newberry, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Mich., Sevems, J., 138.
New York & Westchester Water
Co., In re (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 49.
New York Economical Ptg. Co.,
In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
Putnam, J., 134, 221, 251.
Neiman, In re (1901), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 210.
Newton, In re (1901), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Adams, J., 23, 24.
Nixon, In re (1901), Dist. Mont.,
Knowles, J., 46.
North V. Taylor (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Parker, J., 243.
Norcross, In re (1899), W. Dist. Mo.,
Hall, R., 49.
Northrup, In re (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 148.
TABLE OF CASKS DIGESTED.
XXXI
The niimbers refers to the pages.
Norcross v. Nathan (1900), N. Dist.
Cal.. Hawley, J., 4.
Norcross v. Nathan (1900), Dist.
Nev., Hawley, J., 128.
Nowell, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J.,
Norcross v. Nave & McCord Mer-
cantile Co. (1900), C. C. A.,
8th Cir., 136.
Novak, In re (1900), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 43, 246, 247.
Nunn, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ga.,
Proudfoot, R., 60.
Nugent, In re (1900), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Severens, J., 83.
Nye V. Hart (1901), 132.
O.
O'Connell, In re (1899). S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 211.
O'Gara, In re (1899), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 97.
Oconee Milling Co., In re (1901), C.
C. A., 5th Cir., 225.
Oderkirk, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 64.
Ogden V. Saunders (1827), Sup. Ct.
U. S., 1.
Ogles, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 80, 116, 261,
302.
Ogles, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Walker, R.. 214, 239.
Ogilvie, In re (1901), S. Dist. Ga.,
MacDonell, R., 67.
Ohio Co-operative Shear Co., In
re (1899), N. Dist. O., Fay, R.,
245.
Old Town Bank v. McCormick
(1903), Sup. Ct. Md., Fowler,
J.. 2.
Oliver, In re (1899), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven,J.,28, 148.
Oliver V. Hilgers (1902), Sup. Ct.
Minn., Lewis, J., 199.
Oliver. In re (1901), W. Dist. Mo.,
Philips, J., 201.
Oleson, In re (19011, N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J. ,65, lOT.
Oriental Society, In re (1900), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 49.
Orman. In re (1901), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., 134.
Osbom, In re (1900), W. Dist. N.
Y., Hazel, J., 62.
Osbom V. Perkins (1901), C. C. A.,
1st Cir., Aldrich,J.,94.
Osbom, In re (1902), C. C. A., 1st
Cir., Putnam, J., 93.
Otto, In re (1902), Dist. N. J., Kirk-
patrick, J.. 98, 101.
Otto, In re (1902), Dist. N. J.,
Lewis, R., 94.
Ott, In re (1899), S. Dist. la., Wool-
son, J., 211.
Overstreet, In re (1899), E. Dist.
Ark., Dooley, R., 59.
Owens V. Bmce (1901), C. C. A.;
4th Cir., Waddill, J., 163.
P.
Patten v. Corley (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Bartlett, J., 221.
Paxton V. Scott (1902), Sup. Ct.
Neb., 111.
Page, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 242.
Park. In re (1900), W. Dist. Ark.;
Rogers, J., 60.
Patty -Joiner Co. v. Cummins (1900),
Sup. Ct. Texas, Gaines, J.,
2, 41.
Page, In re (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir.,"
Bradford, J., 242.
Page V. Edmunds (1902), U. S. Sup.
Ct., McKenna, J., 242.
Packer v. Whittier (1899), C. C. A.,'
1st Cir., Webb. J., 180.
Parker, In re (1899), Dist. Kans.,"
White, R., 63, 75, 92.
Parmenter Mfg. Co. v. Hamilton
(1898), Sup. Ct. Mass., Knowl-
ton, J., 2, 38, 37.
Parmenter Mfg. Co. v. Hamilton
(1899), Sup. Ct. Mass., Know-
ton, J., 252.
Pauley, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.;
Hotchkiss, R., 254.
Page. In re (1900), N. Dist. O.;
Ricks, J., 115, 133.
Reiser, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 13, 29.
Peoples Bank of Buffalo v. Brown
(1902), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Dal-
las, J., 122, 123,
Peterson v. Nash Bros. (1901), C. C.
A., 8th Cir., Adams, J., 200. 201.
Pennewell, In re (1902), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Severens, J., 208.
Peck V. Connell (1902), Sup. Ct.
Pa.. Porter. J., 194.
Penzansky. In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer. R., 47.
People V. Schwartz & Greenberg
(1902). Criminal Ct. Cook Co.,
111., Kavanagh, J., 74.
Pearsall v. Nasau Natl. Bank (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Jenks, J., 201,
232.
xxxu
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refers to the pages.
Peacock, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 92, 279.
Pease, In re (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R.,230.
Peter Paul Book Co., In re (1900),
W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 42,
202, 213.
Pearsall v. Nashua Natl. Bank
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Jenks,
J., 232.
Peck Lumber Mfg. Co. v. Mitchell
(1899), Lackawanna Co. Ct.
Pa., Com. Pleas, Edwards, J.,
4, 256.
Peters, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Olmstead, R., 73.
Peterson, In re (1899), E. Dist,
Wis., Jones, R., 161.
Pearson, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 235.
Pearson, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
Coffin, R., 240.
Peterson, In re (1899), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 60.
Pepperdine v. Natl. Exchange Bank
(1900), Ct. App. Mo., Bland, J.,
194.
Perkins v. McCauley (1899), S. Dist.
Cal.. Wellborn, J., 129.
Phillips V. Dreher Shoe Co. (1902) ,
Middle Dist. Pa., Archbald,
J., 44.
Phillips V. Turner (1902), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., 131.
Philadelphia & Lewes Transporta-
tion Co., In re (1902), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 50.
Phelps, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R.. 200.
Phillips, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 101.
Phihmon v. Marshall (1902), Sup.
Ct. Ga., Cobb, J., 111.
Pinkhard v. Willis & Bros. (1900),
Sup. Ct. Texas, Gill, J., 232.
Picken v. Dent (1901), C. C. A.,
4th Cir., Goff, J., 83.
Pickens v. Dent (1902), Sup. Ct. U.
S., Fuller, J., 81, 83.
Pirie V. Chicago Title & Trust Co.
(1901), Sup. Ct. U. S., McKen-
na, J., 10, 178. 179.
Pierce, In re (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 95, 350.
Pierce & Son, In re (1900). Dist.
Washington. Handford, J.', 52'
Pierce, In re (1901), Dist. Col.,
Hallett, J., 153.
Pinkell, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 209.
Pittelkow, In re (1889), E. Dist.
Wis., Seaman, J.. 82, 225.
Planing Mill Co., In re (1901), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 44.
Plummer, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 163.
Plimpton, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 168.
Plotke, In re (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Seaman, J., 13, 15.
Platts, In re (1901), Dist. S. D.,
Carland, J.,229.
Porter Bros., In re (1901), Dist.
Ky., Evans, J., 80.
Powers Dry Goods Co. v. Nelson
(1901), Sup. Ct. N. D., Young,
J., 66, 237.
Pope, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J.,65.
Polakoff, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 140.
Powers, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.,
Mott, R., 236.
Porter v. Cummings (1900), Sup.
Ct. Ga., Fish, J., 83.
Post, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,
Fisher, R., 71.
Prentis v. BLichardson's Estate (1898)
Sup. Ct. Mich., Moore, J., 232.
Prager, In re (1902), Dist. Col.,
Harrison, R., 68.
Pridmore v. Torrey (1902), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 110.
Price & Co., In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 23, 85, 131.
Price, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 73, 186.
Purvine, In re (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., Newman, J., 27, 134, 155.
Pursell, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.,
Piatt, J., 122.
Purcell, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.,
Townsend, J., 28.
Q.
Quackenbush, In re (1900), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 97.
R.
Ratliff, In re (1901), E. Dist. N. C,"
Pumell, J., 10, 195.
Ray, In re (1899), Dist. Washington,
Worden, R., 15.
Read & Knight, In re (1901), S. Dist.
N. Y., Dexter, R., 181, 182.
Real Estate Trust Co. v. Thompson
(1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson,
J., 131.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXXUl
,The numbers refers to the pages.
Reed v. Eqmtable Trust Co. (1902),
Sup. Ct. Ga., Lumpkin, J., 226.
Rees V. Boggs (1902), C. Ct. Pa.,
Bell, J., 2.
Reed v. Cross (1899), Stiperior Ct.
Cook Co., 111., Ball, ]., 79.
Reliance Co., In re (1900), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 273.
Reichman, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 36, 38.
Rennie, In re (1899), Dist. I. T.,
Robinett, R., 168.
Resler, In re (1899), Dist. Minn.,
Merriman, R., 71.
Resler, In re (1899), Dist. Minn.,
Lochren, J., 71.
Rhodes, In re (1901), N. Dist. Ohio,
Wing, J., 63.
Rhodes, In re (1900), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 175, 234.
Rhutasell, (1899) N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 94, 107.
Richard, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 2, 224.
Riker, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., 128.
Richter v. Nimmo (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Jenks, J., 198.
Richards, In re (1900), N. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe. J., 157.
Ripon Knitting Works v. Schreiber
(1900), Dist. Wash., Handford,
J., 26.
Richardson v. Woodward (1900),
C. C. A., 4th Cir., Pumell, J.,
64, 67.
Richards, In re (1899), W. Dist.
Wis., Bunn, J., 228, 236.
Richman & Levy, In re (1899), N.
Dis. N. Y., Morse, R.
Richards, In re (1899), C. C. A.,
7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 134, 138,
222 223.
Rider, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J. ,85, 86, 273.
Rosenberg, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 184.
Rosenthal v. Nave et al. (1900), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Barker, T-.81.
Robinson, In re (1902), W. Dist.
Mo., Philips, J., 221.
Rose V. Vinton (1900). Pa. Ct. Com.
Pleas, Wallace, J., 244.
Rosenthal, In re (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 84.
Ross V. Saunders (1901), C. C. A.,
4th Cir., Putnam, J., 137.
Roalswick, In re (1901), Dist. Mont.
Knowles, J., 226,
Rothschild, In re (1901), S. Dist.
Ga.,Cravatt, R., 61,240.
Ronk, In re (1901), Dist. Ind.^
Baker, J., 229.
Rosenfeld v. Siegfried (1901), Ct.
App. Mo., Bland, J., 112.
Rosenberg, In re (1901), S. Dist.
N. Y., Pendelton, R., 201.
Royal, In re (1901), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 72, 95.
Royal, In re (1902), E. Dist. N. C;
Pumell, J., 90, 93.
Royston v. Weis (1902), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., 53.
Rogers, In re (1902), S. Dist. Ga.;
Speer, J., 1, 21.
Roche, In re (1900), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., 137, 213.
Rogers Milling Co., In re (1900),
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 181.
Rollins Gold, &c., Co., In re (1900),
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 42.
Rosser, In re (1900), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Sanborn, J., 134.
Rockwood, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,'
Shiras, J., 240.
Rogers, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.;
Howard, R., 79, 108.
Romanow, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 49, 188, 189.
Rose, In re (1899), N. Dist. O.,'
Hunter, R., 214.
Rouse, In re (1898), N. Dist. O.,
Remington, R., 207.
Rouse, Hazard & Co., In re (1899),
C. C. A., 7th Cir., 133, 134, 135,
213.
Rosser, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mo.;
Rogers, J., 74, 75, 154, 155.
Rosser, In re (1900), E. Dist. Mo.,
Rogers, J., 26.
Robinson !>. White (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J. ,85, 132.
Rome Planing Mills (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 34, 35, 39.
Rome Planing Mills, In re (1900), N'
Dist, N. Y.,Coxe,J.,8, 43.
Roy, In re (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler,
J., 96.
Rusch, In re (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 159.
Russell, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 24, 82, 275.
Russell & Birkett, In re (1901), N.
Dist. N. Y., Hawley, R., 106.
Ruse, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ala.,
Jones, J., 67.
Rumsey, &c., Co. v. Novelty Mfg.
Co. (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams,
J., 28, 32, 34, 41.
XXXIV
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refers to the pages.
Ruppel, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 225.
Russell & Birkett, In re (1900), C.
C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 21.
Russia, In re (1899), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 244.
Rude, In re (1900), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 120, 171,
Rudnick, In re (1900), Dist. Wash-
ington, Handford, J., 59, 196.
Rudnick, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.
Lowell, J., 89.
RufE V. Milner (1901), Ct. App. of
Mo., Bland, J., 110.
Ryan, In re (1901), N. Dist. 111.,
Kohlsaat, J., 201.
S.
Bargeiit v. Sargent (1901), Ohio Cir.
Ct., Phillips, J., 111.
Ban Gabriel San. Co., In re (1900),
S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J., 49.
San Gabriel San. Co., In re (1900),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., 83.
Ban Gabriel San. Co., In re (1901),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., 130.
Banderlin, In re (1901), E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell, J., 52, 53, 236.
Sabin v. Camp (1900), Dist. Ore.,
Bellinger, J., 34, 198.
Sanborn, In re (1899), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 148.
St. Albans Fdry. Co., In re (1900),
Dist. Vt., Mott, R., 83.
St. John, In re (1901), N. Dist. N.
Y., Coxe, J., 247.
Sabine, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 149, 153, 218,
240.
Sapiro, In re (1899), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 28, 73, 241.
Scott V. Devlin (1898), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 254.
Scruby v. Norman (1901), Ct. App.
Mo., Smith, J., 249.
Schmitt, In re, Dist. O., Wayne,
J., 224.
Scheivley, In re (1902), Cir. Ct.
Pa. 2.
Schreck't;. Hanlon (1902), Sup. Ct.
Neb., Duffie, J., 131.
Schryerv. Citizens Natl. Bank (1902)
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Lawlin, J., 195.
Schenck, In re (1902), Dist. Wash-
ington, Handford, J., 92, 94.
Schenkein & Coney, In re (1902), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.,
38, 53, 78.
Schenkin, In re (1902) , 45.
Scheuer v. Smith & Co. (1901), C.
C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 39,
76.
Scott, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Olmstead, R., 30, 149.
Schultz, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 101.
Schafer, In re (1900), N. Dist. N.
Y., 180.
Schaeffer, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 206, 250.
Scheld, In re (1900), C. C. A., 9th
Cir., Ross, J., 69, 249.
Schmilovitz v. Bernstein (1901),
Sup. Ct. R. I., Douglas, J., 247.
Scanlon & Co., In re (1899), Dist.
Ky., Evans, J., 214.
Schlesinger, In re (1900), C. C. A.,
8th Cir., Shipman, J., 26.
Schlesinger, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 26, 28.
Schloerb, In re (1899), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 16.
Schrom, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 16.
Scott, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 16, 142, 276.
Schertzer, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 102.
Schreck, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 90.
Scott, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.,
Buffington, J., 73.
Scott, In re (1899), N. Dist. Tex.,'
Meek, J. ,174, 218, 273.
Schiller, In re (1899), W. Dist. Va.,
Paul, J., 72, 276.
Severin v. Robinson (1901), Appel-
late Ct. Ind., Wiley, J., 233.
Seebold, In re (1901), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 5, 237.
Seebold, In re (1902), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 2.
Seabolt, In re (1902), W. Dist. N.
C, Boyd, J., 59, 76.
Seymour v. Richardson, &c., Co.
(1902), Ct. App. 111., Freeman,
J., 111.
Seabrig v. Wellington (1901), N. Y.,
Sup. Ct., App. Div,, Adams, J.,
199.
Sears, In re (1902), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir 187 189
Sears, in re (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 143.
Seay, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 180.
Sewell, In re (1902), E. Dist. Ky.,
Cochran, J., 229.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXXV
The numbers refers to the pages.
Seydfel, In re (1902), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 68.
Seivers, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 2, 17, 127, 256.
Sellers v. Bell (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 60, 98,
100, 167, 168.
Shirely, In re (1901), C. C. A.. 6th
Cir., Day, J., 225.
Shilliday, In re (1899), W. Dist. Pa.,
Blair, R., 206.
Sherman v. Luckhardt (1902), Sup.
Ct. Kans., Doster, J., 193.
Sherman v. Luckhard (1902), Mo.
Ct. App., Smith, J., 195.
Shenkin & Coney, In re (1902), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 53.
Shaw, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 175, 215.
Shera, In re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 28.
Shirley, In re (1901), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Day, J.,
Shepard, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 84.
Shepherd, In re (1900), N. Dist.
111., Eastman, R., 226.
Shattuck & Bugh, In re (1901), W.
Dist. N. Y., McMaster, R., 57.
Shuller, In re (1901), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 66.
Sheldon v. Parker (1902), Sup. Ct.
Neb.,Duffie, J., 131.
Shaeflfer, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 250.
Shapiro, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 33, 57.
Sheinbaum, In re (1901), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 129.
Sheridan, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 228.
Shorer, In re (1899), Dist. Conn.,
Townsend, J., 100.
Silverman Bros., In re (1899), W.
Dist. Mo., Crittenden, R., 209,
215.
Simpson v. Van Etten, C. C. E., Dist.
Pa., Dallas, J., 236.
Sims, In re (1902), W. Dist. Ga.,
Speer, J., 207.
Sirrine v. Stoner Marshall Co. (1902),
Sup. Ct. S. C, 193.
Silverhom, In re (1900). N.Dist.IU.,
Kohlsaat, J., 21.
Silberstein v. Stahl et aL (1900), N.
Y. Sup. Ct., Russell, J., 128.
Silverman v. Schoor (1899). S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 212.
Simonson v. Sinscheiner (1901), C.
C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 116, 206.
Sinscheiner v. Simonson (1900), C.
C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 116, 206.
Sievers, In re (1899), E. Dist. Mo.,
Adams, J., 2, 17, 127, 256.
Simonson, In re (1899), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 115, 116, 187.
Skillin V. Maibrunn (1902), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J., 131.
Skinner, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 96.
Skillun V. Edelman (1902), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 253.
Slomka, In re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 208.
Slack, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 76.
Slingluflf, In re (1900), Dist. Md.,
Morris, J., 72, 249.
Smalley v. Langenower (1902), Sup.
Ct. Washington, FuUerton, J.,
161.
Small V. Mueller (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Bartlett, J., 253.
Sloane, In re (1900), S. Dist. la.;
Shiras, J., 196.
Smith & Dodson, In re (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 256.
Smith, In re (1902), Dist. Conn.,
Piatt, J., 44.
Smith, In re (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 2, 40.
Smith, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 28, 84.
Smith V. Zachry (1902), Sup. Ct.
Ga., Little, J., 106, 226.
Smith V. Keegan (1901), C. C. A,:
1st Cir., Putnam, J., 93.
Smith V. Meisenheimer (1898), Sup
Ct. Ky., Lewis, J., 81.
Smith, In re (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 75, 140.
Smith V. Stansfield (1901), Sup.
Ct. Minn., Lewis^., 108.
Smith, In re (1901), W. Dist. N. C,
Pumell,J.,213.
Smith V. Bellford (1901), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Severens, J., 22.
Smith, In re (1901), W. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 213.
Smith V. Wheeler (1900), N. Y. Sup.
Ct., Mervin, J., 104.
Smith, In re (1899), S. Dist. Ga.,
Speer, J., 240.
Smith, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 157, 172, 205,
210.
Smith, In re (1899), W. Dist. Tex.,
Maxey, J., 24, 25, 63, 64, 267,
269, 276.
XXXVl
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refers to the pages.
Smoke, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 181.
Soper & Slade, In re (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 258, 267.
Soldosky, In re (1901), Dist, Mont.,
Lochren, J., 200.
South End Improvement Co. v.
Hardin (1902), Sup. Ct. N. J.,
Reed, J., 222.
Soudans Mfg. Co., In re (1902), C.
C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J.,
226.
Southern Loan & Trust Co. v. Ben-
bow (1899), W. Dist. N. C,
Ewart, J., 4, 19, 23, 80, 229.
Sprawlin v. Colson Bros. (1902), Sup.
Ct. Miss., Tennel, J., 125.
Spear et al.. In re (1901), Dist.Vt.,
Wheeler J., 100.
Spencer v. Duplan Silk Co. (1902),
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 189.
Stickney & Babcock Coal Co. v.
Goodwin (1901), Sup. Ct. Me.,
Wiswell, J., 233.
State ex rel Crane et al. v. Chamber
of Commerce of Minneapolis,
(1899.) Sup. Ct.Minn., Canty,
J., 243.
State V. Superior Ct. King Co. (1899) ,
Sup. Ct. Washington, Bevis,
J., 253.
Staunton, In re (1902), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 68.
Sturges V. Crowinshield (1819), Sup,
Ct. U. S., 1.
Standard Latmdry Co., In re (1901),
N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J.,
246.
Standard Laundry Co., In re (1902),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., Hawley, J.,
221
Stark, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Holt, R., 100.
Stark, In re (1899), S, Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 101,
Steele & Co., /«r^ (1899), S. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 63, 248, 250.
Stevenson & King, In re (1899), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 59.
Stevenson, In re (1899), Dist. Del.,
Bradford, J., 6, 43, 44, 143,
190, 302.
Stevens, In re (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 55.
Stem, In re (1899), Dist. Ind., Bak-
er, J., 24, 185, 219.
Steger, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ala.,
Jones, J.. 50, 119.
Stem V. Louisville Trust Co. (1901),
C, C. A.. 6th Cir., Severens,
J., 34, 197.
Stege, In re (1902), C, C, A., 2nd
Cir., 10.
Stem, In re (1902), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Townsend, J., 190, 208.
Stevens v. Meyers (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Ingraham, J., 107.
Stone, In re (1902), E. Dist. Ark.,
Treiber, J., 67, 68.
Storck Lumber Co., In re (1902),
Dist. Md., Morris, J., 1, 255.
Stedman v. Bank of Monroe (1902),
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Lochren, J.,
231.
Stratton v. Lawson (1902), Sup.
Ct. Wash., Mount, J., 195.
Steed & Ctirtis (1901), E. Dist. N.
C, Pumell, J. ,92.
Steininger Merc. Co. (1901), C. C.
A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 220.
Stokes, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 56, 243.
Stokes, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Wise, R., 65.
Stokes, In re (1899), Dist. Wash.,
Munter, R., 14.
Stotts, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 212.
Stone V. Jenkins (1900), Sup. Ct.
Mass., Morton, J., 88.
Storm, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 36, 39.
Stout, In re (1900), W. Dist. Mo.,
Philips, J., 67, 150.
Strobel v. Knost (1900), S. Dist.
Ohio, Thompson, J., 181.
Stumpf, In re (1900), Sup. Ct. Okla.,
Burwell, J., 136.
Styer, In re (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 148. 234.
Sugenheimer, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 121, 271.
Sullivan, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 209.
Steele v. Buel (1900), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Caldwell, J., 66, 69.
Stein, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., 115.
Steindler & Hahn, In re (1900), S.
Dist. N. Y., Pendleton, R., 95.
Steuer, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 115.
Stevens, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 56, 178.
Stoever. In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J.. 273.
Stoner, In re (1901), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 250.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXXVll
The numbers refers to the pages.
Strause v. Hooper (1901), E. Dist.
N. C. Pumell, J.. 57, 93.
Stroud V. McDaniel, In re (1901), C.
C. A., 4th Cir., Pumell, J., 226.
Stendts, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.
Hotchkiss, R., 196, 206, 209,
215.
Swift, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 175, 226.
Swift, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Olmstead, R., 216.
Swords, In re (1901), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 69.
Swartz V. St. Louis Fourth Natl.
Bank (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir.,
Sanborn, J., 34, 35, 180, 194.
Swartz V. Siegel (1902), E. Dist.
Mo., Adams, J., 199.
Swartz V. Siegel (1902), C. C. A.
8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 4, 5.
Sykes, In re (1901), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 94. 119.
T.
Talbot, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 175.
Talbot, In re (1902), W. Dist. Ga.,
Speer,J.,68.
Taylor, In re (1901), Dist. Col.,
Hallett, J., 26.
Taylor, In re (1901), N. Dist. Cal.
Holland, R., 254.
Taylor v. Taylor (1900), N. J.,
Chancery, Reed, J., 222.
Taylor, In re (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.
King, R., 187, 196.
Taylor, In re (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Bunn, J., 49, 116, 117,
302.
Taft V. Fourth Natl. Bank (1900)
C. C. Ohio, 195.
Tanner, In re (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.,
McMaster, R., 200.
Tatem, Mann & Co., In re E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell, J., 220, 255.
Tenney, In re, S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 223.
Teague, In re (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 233.
Tebo, In re (1900), Dist. W. Va.,
Jackson, J., 9, 213, 215, 226,
275.
Terrill, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.
Wheeler, J., 200, 211.
Tecopa Mining & Smelting Co., In
re (1901), S. Dist. Cal., Well-
bom, J., 50.
Thompson Sons, In re (1901), E.
Dist. Pa., Hvmter, R., 200.
Thompson, Sons, In re (1902), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 201.
Thompson, In re (1902), S. Dist. Ga.,
Speer, J., 61.
Thomas, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 91, 107.
Thomas, In re (1899), Dist. Wash-
ington, Hanford, J., 63.
Thomas, In re (1900), W. Dist. Pa.,
Biiffington, J., 36, 38.
Tilden, In re (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 63, 67, 210.
Tirre, In re (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J. ,49, 188.
Tinker, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91, 108.
Todd, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 20, 71, 149, 153.
Tonawanda St. Planing Mill Co., In
re (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.
Hotchkiss, R., 142.
Tontine Surety Co. of N. J., In re
(1902), Dist. N. T., Kirkpatrick,
J., 50.
TopUflE, In re (1902), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 197, 202.
Torrence v. Winifred Natl. Bank
(1903), Sup. Ct. Kans., Green,
t. 233.
Tobias, In re (1900), W. Dist. Va.,
Paul, J., 65.
Tollett, In re (1900), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Lurton, J., 61.
Tollett, In re (1900), E. Dist. Tenn.
Grayson, R., 61.
Tompkins v. Hazen (1900), N. J.
Ct. App., Bartlett, J., 109.
Turner v. Turner (1901), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 80, 105.
Tune, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ala.,
Jones, J., 19, 66, 149, 235.
Tudor, In re (1899), Dist. Col.,
Hallett, J., 18, 27, 28, 249.
Turrentine v. Blackwood, 1900, Sup.
Ct. Ala., Harralson, J., 129.
Tumbull, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Olmsted, R., 64.
Tumbull, In re (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 63.
Twaddell, In re (1901), Dist. Del.,
Bradford, J., 247.
Tyrrell v. Hammerstein (1900), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., McAdams, J., 61,
108.
u.
U. S. V. McAleese (1899), C. C. A.,
3rd Cir., McPherson, J., 18.
xxxvm
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
The numbers refers to the pages.
United States v. Union Surety &
Guaranty Co. (1902), S. Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 166.
Ulf elder Clothing Co., In re (1899),
N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J.,
188
Union, &c., Mfg. Co., In re (1902),
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J.,
34, 197.
Utt, In re (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Woods, J., 116, 163, 245.
V.
Valentine Co., In re (1899), N. Dist.
Cal., DeHaven, J., 235.
Valentine & Co., In re (1899), C. C.
A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J., 240.
Van Orden, In re (1899), Dist. N. J.,
Kirkpatrick, J., 206.
Vaughan, Inre (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.
Brown, J., 222.
Vaccaro v. Security Bank (1900), C.
C. A., 6th Cir., Lurton, J., 32,
35 42 54.
Van Alstyiie, In re (1900), N Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 85.
Veitch, In re (1900), Dist. Conn.,
Townsend, J., 210.
Vietor v. Lewis, In re (1899), Smp.
Ct.N.Y., O'Brien, J., 83.
W.
Wakeman v. Throckmorton (1902),
Sup. Ct. Conn., Baldwin, J., 232.
Wallal V. Camp (1901), Sup. Ct. Pa.,
Beaver, J., 232.
Watertown Carriage Co. v. Hall
(1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Smith,
J., 106.
Watertown Carriage Co. v. Hall
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Smith,
J., 208.
Watschke v. Thompson (1901), Sup.
Ct. Minn., Lewis, J., 237.
Waterbury Furniture Co., In re
(1902), Dist. Conn., Townsend,
J., 180, 195.
Waukesha Water Co., In re (1902),
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 13, 20.
Wagner v. U. S. (1900), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Day, J., 82.
Walsh, In re (1900), S. Dist. O.,
Thompson, J., 75.
Waxelbaum, In re (1900), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 61, 266.
Wall V. Cox (1901), Sup. Ct. U. S.,
Gray, J., 127.
Ward, In re (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 15.
Walther, Inre (1899), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, j., 107.
Walker, In re (1899), Dist. N. Dak.,
Amidon, J., 5, 73, 75.
Washburn Bros., In re (1900), Dist.
Conn., Townsend, J., 6.
Waxelbaum, In re (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y.,Brown, J., 14,266.
Weeks v. Fowler (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. H., Case, J., 249.
West Co. V. Bevory et al. (1898) , Sup.
Ct. N. H., Young, J.,2.
Wetmore v. Wetmore (1899), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J., 48, 111.
Wenham v. Martin (1902), Ct. App.
111., Waterman, J., 110.
Welty V. Welty (1900), Ct. App. 111.,
1st Dist., Windes, J., 111.
Wetmore, In re (1901), W. Dist. N.
Y., Knight, R., 141.
Weil, In re (1901), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 130.
West Norfolk Lumber Co., In re
(1902), E. Dist. Va., Waddill,
J., 217.
Weissner, In re (1902), E. Dist. N.
Y., Thomas, J., 159, 182.
Wells, In re (1902), W. Dist. Mo.,
McPherson, J., 241.
West, In re (1902), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 68.
Western Cold Storage Co. v. Hurd
(1902), W. Dist. Mo., PhiHps,
J., 107.
Westphall Bros. & Co., In re (1902),
W. Dist. Cal., Wise, R., 74.
Westcott Co. V. Berry et al. (1899),
Sup. Ct. N. H., Young, J., 254.
Wetmore, In re (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 96, 244, 247.
Wetmore, In re (1900), S. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 247.
West. In re (1901). C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Shipman, J., 32, 33.
Wertheimer, In re (1900), S Dist.
N. Y.,Adams,J.,91,176.
Wells, In re (1900), W. Dist. Ark.,
Rogers, J., 67, 245.
Wetmore, In re (1901), C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Bradford, J., 247.
West Bros. v. Lea & Co. (1899), Sup.
Ct. U. S., White, J., 40.
Webb, In re (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 95, 97.
Welch, In re (1901), S. Dist. O.,
Thompson, J., 96, 98.
TABLE OF CASES DIGESTED.
XXXIX
The numbers refers to the pages.
Westlund, In re (1899), Dist. Minn.,
Lochren, J., 215,
White V. Thompson et al. (1903),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., 231.
White, In re (1900), W. Dist. Mo.,
Philips, J., 61.
White V. Bradley Lumber Co. (1902),
S. Dist. Ala., Toulmin, J., 190.
White V. Schloerb (1900), Sup. Ct.
U. S., Gray, J., 23.
Whitely Grocery Co. v. Roach (1902),
Sup. Ct. Ga., Fish, J., 199.
Whitener, In re (1900), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., Pardee, J., 20, 133, 247.
White, In re (1900), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 25, 269.
Wilson V. City Bank (1873). Sup. Ct.
U. S., 1.
Wilcox, In re (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Shipman, J., 93.
Wilson, In re (1901), W. Dist. Va.,
Paul, J., 67.
Wittenberg, &c., Co., In re (1901),
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 197.
Wilbur V. Watson (1901), Dist. R.
I., Brown, J., 255.
Wilkes, In re (1902), E. Dist. Ark.,
Treiber, T-. 220.
Wilson Bros. v. Nelson (1901), Sup.
Ct. U. S., Gray, J., 38, 39.
Wiessner, In re (1902), E. Dist. N.
Y., Thomas, J., 159, 182.
Williamson, In re (1901), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 60.
Wilson, In re (1902), W. Dist. Ark.,
Rogers, J., 26, 27.
Wilson V. Parr (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga.,
Little. J., 23.
Wilson V. Pa. Trust Co. (1902), C. C.
A., 3rd Cir., Achison, J., 176.
Wilson, In re (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 64.
Wilcox & Wright, In re (1899), Dist.
Tenn., Grayson, R., 175.
Wilcox, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 55, 56.
Williams, In re (1900), Dist. Wash-
ington, Hanford, J., 14.
Wolfstein, In re (1899) , N. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 279.
Wood V. Vandewer (1900), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Rumsey, J., 87.
Worden v. Columbus Electric Co.
(1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
10, 179, 236.
Wolff, In re (1900), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 90, 92.
Worcester Co., In re (1900), C. C.
A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 134,
216.
Wolfensohn, In re (1900), S. Dist.
N. Y., Dexter, R., 93.
Woodruff V. Chesere (1901), C. C.
A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J.,
67.
Woodside Coal Co., 7n re (1900), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 49.
Woodruff et al.. In re (1899), S.
Dist. Ga., Speer, J., 62.
Wolpert, In re (1899), N. Dist. N.
Y., Hotchkiss, R., 92, 279.
Worland, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 225.
Wolf, In re (1899), Dist. N. J.,
Kirkpatrick, J., 259.
Wood, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 185, 210, 224.
Woodward, In re (1899), E. Dist. N.
C, Pumell, J., 59, 60.
Woodward, In re (1899), E. Dist.
Tex., DiUard, R., 43.
Wolf, In re (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras. J., 224, 228.
Wood, In re (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 99.
Woodbury, In re (1900), Dist. N. D.,
Amidon, J., 20.
Wright Lumber Co., In re (1902),
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 11,
34.
Wright, In re (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 135, 216.
Wright, In re (1899), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 220.
Wyly, In re (1902), N. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 179.
Y.
Yates, In re (1902), N. Dist. Cal.,
DeHaven, J., 6, 47, 209.
Yost, In re (1902), Middle Dist. Pa.,
Archbald, J., 68.
Yotmg, In re (1899), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 223.
Young, In re (1901), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Thayer, J., 38.
Young V. Young (1901), N. Y. Sup.
Ct., Gildersleeve, J., 105.
Young V. Upson (1902), S. Dist. N.
Y., Hazel, J., 194.
Yukon Woolen Co. (1899), Dist.
Conn., Townsend, J., 245.
z.
Zartman v. Hines, In re (1901), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hawley, R., 176.
Zeitner Brewing Co., In re (1902),
S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 45.
Zimmerman v. Ketcham (1903) , Sup.
Ct. Kans., Pollock J.. 111.
FEDERAL CONSTITUTION,
ARTICLE 1, SECTION 8.
"The congress shall have power * * to establish
* * uniform laws on the subject of bankruptcies through-
out the United States, * * and to make all laws which
shall be necessary and proper for carrying such power into
execution."
Under this power bankruptcy laws have been enacted by Congress
as follows: Apr. 4th, 1800, amended Apr. 29th, 1802, repealed Dec.
19th, 1803; August 19th, 1841, repealed March 3rd, 1843; March 2nd,
1867, amended July 27th, 1868, Jtme 14th, 1870, June 30th, 1870, June
8th, 1872, Feb. 13th. 1873, March 3rd, 1873, June 22nd, 1874, April
14th, 1876, July 26th, 1876, repealed in entirety June 7th, 1878; July
1st, 1898, amended Feb. 5th, 1903. See post former Bankruptcy Acts.
Purpose of Bankruptcy Laws.
Jurisdiction of National Law exclusive. New Lamp, etc., Co. v. An-
sonia Brass, etc., Co. (1876), 91 U. S. 656.
Primary object of bankruptcy act is to secure a just disposition of
property among creditors ; secondary object is release of bankrupt from
his debts. Wilson v. City Bank (1873), 17 Wall. (U. S.), 473.
Speedy distribution of assets of bankrupt is purpose of bankruptcy
act, second in importance only to equality of distribution. Bailey v.
Ghver (1874), 21 Wall. (U. S.), 342.
Bankruptcy Act of 1898, Constitutional.
The act discussed and its constitutionality upheld. Hanover Nat.
Bank V. Moyses (1902), 186 U. S., 181; 8 A. B., R. 1.
State Insolvency Lav/s. Suspended by National Bankruptcy Act.
Former Statutes Construed. Sturges v. Crowninshield (1819),
4Wheaton (U. S.), 122; Ogden v. Saunders (1827), 12 Wheaton (U. S.),
213.
Act of 1898. General State Law suspended or superseded. In re
Macon Sash, etc., Co., S. Dist. Ga., Speer, J. (1901), 112 Fed., 323;
7 A. B. R., 66; In re Storch Lumber Co. (1902), Dist. Md., Morris, ]. 114
Fed., 360; 8 A. B. R. 86; In re Rogers (1902), S. Dist. Ga., Speer, J.,
116 Fed., 435; 8 A. B. R. 723; Carling v. Seymour Lumber Co. (1902),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby, J., 113 Fed., 483; 8. A. B. R. 29.
2 FEDERAL CONSTITUTION. [ART. 1, § 8.
California law held still in force as to persons not coming under the
Act. Herron Co. v. Superior Court (1902), Sup. Court Cal., Harrison,
J., 68 Pac, 814.
Illinois Act construed. In re Curtis (1899), S. Dist. 111.; Allen, J., 91
Fed., 137; affirmed (C. C. A., 7th Cir.), Jenkins, J., 94 Fed., 312; 2 A.
B. R. 226.
Illinois Act held suspended and County Court deprived of jurisdic-
tion. Horbaughv. Costello (1900), Sup. Court, 111., Magruder, J., 184
111. 110; affirming Costello v. Harbaugh (1898) 83 111., App. 29.
Indiana Act construed. In re Smith (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
92 Fed., 135; 2 A. B. R. 9.
Kentucky Act construed. In re John A. Etheridge Fiimiture Co.
(1899), Dist. Ky., Barr, J., 92 Fed., 329; 1 A. B. R. 112.
Missottri Act construed. In re Seivers (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams,
J., 91 Fed., 366; 1 A. B. R. 117; affirmed sub nom. Davis v. Bohle
(1899) (C. C. A.), 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 92 Fed., 325; 1 A. B. R. 412.
Massachusetts Act construed. Parmenter Mfg. Co. v. Hamilton et
al. (1898), Sup. Court Mass., Knowlton, J., 172 Mass., 178; 1 A. B. R. 39.,
Maryland law held not suspended. Old Town Bank v. McCortnick
(1903), Sup. Court Md., Fowler, J., 53 Atl. 934.
Minnesota Act construed. Armour Packing Co. v. Brown (1899), Sup.
Court Minn. 76 Minn., 465. Foley Bean Lumber Co. w. Sawyer (1899),
Sup. Court Minn., Mitchell, J., 76. Minn., 118.
New Hampshire Act suspended. Wescott Co. v. Berry ct al. (1898)
Sup. Court, N. H., Young, J., 69 N. H, 505.
North Carolina Act construed. In re Richard (1899), E. Dist. N. C„
Pumell, J., 94 Fed., 633; 2 A. B. R. 506.
Peimsylvania Act of 1901 construed and held suspended. Rees v.
Boggs (1902), C. Court Pa., Bell, J., 26 Pa., C. C, 284. In re Scheivley
(1902), 26 Pa. C C, 34; also McArvdy v. Tantz (1902), Weard.
J., 26 Pa. C. C, 417; McMullen's Petition (1902), 26 Pa. C. C, 157,
Bankruptcy law does not conflict with Pennsylvania law relating to
attachments. McCullough v. Linn & Goodhard (1899), Circuit Court
Pa., Biddle, J., 22 Pa. C. C, 369.
Rhode Island Act construed. Matnan v. Crown Carpet Lining Co.
(1901), Sup. Court R. I., 50 Atl., 381.
Texas Act construed. Patty-Joiner Co. v. Cummins (1900), Texas
Sup. Court, Gaines, J., 93 Texas, 598; 4 A. B. R. 269; 57 S. W., 566.
Wisconsin Act construed. Binder v. McDonald (1900), 106 Wis.,
332; In re Bruss-Ritter Co. (1898), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 90 Fed.,
651; 1 A. B. R., 58.
ANNOTATED BANKRUPTCY STATUTE.
CHAPTER 1.
DEFINITIONS.
Section. 1 Meaning of Words and Phrases.
(1) A person"^ against whom a
petition has been filed.
(2) adjudication.
(3) appellate courts.
(4) bankrupt.
(5) clerk.
(6) corporations.
(7) court.
(8) courts of bankruptcy.
(9) creditors.
(10) date of bankruptcy.
(11) debt.
(12) discharge.
(13) document.
(14) holiday.
(15) when deemed insolvent.
(16) Judge.
(17) oath.
(18) officer.
(19) persons.
(20) petition.
(21) referee.
(22) conceal.
(23) secured creditor.
(24) States.
(25) transfer.
(26) trustee.
(27) wage earner..
(28) Words in Masculine gender.
(29) Words importing the plural
number.
(30) Words
ntxmber.
importing singular
An Act To establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the
United States.
Approved July 1st, 1898. Chapter 541, Acts of Fifty-fifth Congress.
30 Statutes at L., 544. 2 Sup. R., S. U. S. 843. Amended February
5th, 1903. As to time when Act goes into effect, see Sec. 71, post.
As to time amendment goes into effect see amendment of Feb. 5, 1903,
post.
Section 1. Meaning of Words and Phrases.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives
of the United States of America in Congress assembled.
a The words and phrases used in this Act and in pro-
3
4 MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. [§ 1.
ceedings pursuant hereto shall, trnless the same be incon-
sistent with the context, be construed as follows :
The Act is remedial and should have reasonable construction accord-
ing to the fair import of its terms with view to effect its objects. Blake v.
Francis Valantine Co. (1898), N. Dist. Cal., Hawley, J., 89 Fed., 691;
Norcrossv. Nathan (1900) ,N.Dist.oiCal.,Uawley, J., 99 Fed., 414; 3 A.B.
R., 613; Soutftern Loan & Trust Co. v. Benbow (1899), W. Dist. N. C
Ewart, J., 96 Fed., 514. 3 A. B. R. 9.
Where the language is clear and unambiguous it must be held to
mean what it plainly expresses, and no room is left for construction.
Swarts V. Siegel et al. (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 117 Fed., 13;
8 A. B. R., 689.
(1) <« A person against whom a petition has been filed"
shall include a person who has filed a voluntary petition ;
Applies to voluntary and involtmtary cases. Peck Lumber Mfg. Co.
v. Mitchell (1899), Lackawanna County Court (Perm.) Common Pleas,
Edwards, J., 1 A. B. R., 701; 1 N. B. N., 262.
(2) "Adjudication" shall mean the date of the entry of
a decree that the defendant, in a bankruptcy proceeding, is
a bankrupt, or if such decree is appealed from, then the date
when such decree is finally confirmed ;
As to adjudications, see Sec. 18. post.
(3) "Appellate Courts" shall include the circuit courts of
appeals of the United States, the supreme courts of the
Territories, and the Supreme Court of the United States ;
As to manner of taking appeals see Sec. 25 post.; also, Gen. Ord.
XXXVI.
(4) "Bankrupt" shall include a person against whom an
involtmtary petition or an application to set a composition
aside or to revoke a discharge has been filed, or who has filed
a voluntary petition, or who has been adjudged a bank
rupt.
As to application of definition, see Sec. 4b. post.
Person against whom petition has been filed is within meaning of
word as used in the act prior to adjudication. In re Hicks (1901), Dist.
Vt., Wheeler, J., 107 Fed., 910 6 A. B. R., 182; 3 N. B. N.. 959..
§ 1.] MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. 6
(5) "Gerk" shall mean the clerk of a court of bank-
ruptcy ;
See as to what are courts of bankruptcy, Sec. 1 (8) . post.
(6) «* Corporations" shall mean all bodies having any
of the powers and privileges of private corporations not
possessed by individuals or partnerships, and shall include
limited or other partnership associations organized under
laws making the capital subscribed alone responsible for
the debts of the association;
For discussion of meaning of this section see : In re The Empire Metallic
Bedstead Co. (1899), N. Dist., N. Y., Hotchkiss R., 1 A. B. R. 136.
(7) "Court" shall mean the court of bankruptcy in which
the proceedings are pending, and may include the referee ;
(8) "Courts of bankruptcy" shall include the district
courts of the United States and of the Territories, the su-
preme court of the District of Colimibia, and the United
States court of the Indian Territory, and of Alaska ;
See as to Jurisdiction and specific designation of courts. Sec. 2, post.
Does interest of District Judge give ground for removal of cause tmder
Sec. 601, Rev. Stat., U. S. ? In re Seebold (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir. Mc-
Cormick, J., 105 Fed., 910: 5 A. B. R. 358.
(9) "Creditor" shall include anyone who owns a demand
or claim provable in bankruptcy, and may include his duly
authorized agent, attorney, or proxy;
An accommodation maker, an indorser or surety on the obligations of
a bankrupt within this definition. Swarts v. Siegel (1962), C. C. A.
8th Cir. Sanborn, J., 117 Fed. 13; 8 A. B. R. 689.
General terms of definition of "creditor" must apply in absence of re-
strictive language. In re Walker (1899), Dist. N. Dakota; Amidon, J.,
96 Fed., 550; 1 N. B. N. 510;
"Attorney" in this section includes attorney at law though he has
no power to vote except on additional security. In re Henschel (1901),
S. Dist., N. Y. Brown, J., 109 Fed., 861; 6 A. B. R. 305: 3 N. B. N.
933.
6 MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. [§ 1
(10) "Date of bankruptcy," or "time of bankruptcy,"
or "commencement of proceedings," or "bankruptcy," with
reference to time, shall mean the date when the petition was
filed;
As to computation of time see Sec. 31 post.
The filing of the petition in good faith gives jurisdiction to the court,
and the moment of filing is the precise point of time from which the various
limitations in the Act are to be read. In re Chas. Lewis & Bro. (1899),
S. Dist., N. Y., Brown, J., 91 Fed., 632; 1 A. B. R. 458; 1 N. B. N.,
556.
Insufficient petition withdrawn and amended - date of filing the amend-
ment is the date when proceedings commenced. In re Washburn Bros.
(1900), Dist. Conn. Townsend J. 99 Fed., 84; 3 A. B. R. 585.
In the computation of time, exclude the day the act of bankruptcy
was committed and include the day the petition was filed, In re Stevenson
(1899), Dist. Del., Bradford J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R. 66; 1 N. B. N.
313.
(11) "Debt" shall include any debt, demand, or claim
provable in bankruptcy ;
"Debt." in bankruptcy law is not restricted to its strict legal meaning
"a sum due by certain and express agreement." In re Fife (1901), W.
Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 109 Fed., 880; 6 A. B. R., 258; 3 N. B. N., 835.
This Subdivision is limited by Sec. 60a. In re Yates (1902), N.
Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 114 Fed., 365; 8 A. B. R., 69. See also to the
same effect: In re Mitchell (1902), Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 116 Fed., 87;
8 A. B. R., 324.
(12) *'Dischai^e" shall mean the release of a bankrupt
from all of his debts which are provable in bankruptcy, ex-
cept such as are excepted by this Act ;
As to granting of discharges see Sec. 14 and notes.
As to debts not affected by discharge, see Sec. 17 and notes. For
definition of debts which are provable in bankruptcy, see Sec. 63 and notes.
(13) "Document" shall include any book, deed, or in-
strument in writing ;
See Sec. 70a as to title to documents relating to bankrupt's property
vesting in trustee.
I 1.] MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. 7
(14) "Holiday" shall include Christmas, the Fourth of
July, the Twenty-second of February, and any day appointed
by the President of the United States or the Congress of
the United States as a holiday or as a day of public fasting or
thanksgiving ;
As to computation of time, see Sec. 31 and notes.
(15) [When person insolvent.] A person shall be
deemed insolvent within the provisions of this Act whenever
the aggregate of his property, exclusive of any property
which he may have conveyed, transferred, concealed, or
removed, or permitted to be concealed or removed, with
intent to defraud, hinder or delay his creditors, shall not
at a fair valuation, be sufficient in amount to pay his debts;
Act of 1867 made person insolvent who could not pay his debts in
ordinary course of business. Sec. 39, Act of 1867, post.
As to "conveyed, transferred, concealed or removed, etc.," see Sec.
3a (1), and notes. As to debts which may be proved, see Sec. 63 and
notes.
Insolvency in administration of bankruptcy and insolvency laws is
inability to pay debts as they mature in the regular covirse of business;
non-payment of contracts challenged for fraud on ground of insuffi-
ciency of assets has application to inability to pay. Marvin v. Anderson
(1901), Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall, J., 6 A. B. R., 520; 87 N. W., 226.
An adjudication on an involuntary petition raises no presumption
of insolvency as to any antecedent date. In re John Chappell (1901),
E. Dist. of Va., Waddell, J., 113 Fed., 545; 7 A. B. R., 608.
Inability to pay debts in full as they mature is not the same as "prop-
erty at a fair valuation not sufficient to pay debts." Martin v. Bigelow
(1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Sp. Term.; 36 Misc., 298.
Adjudication on involuntary petition containing allegation of act of
bankruptcy involving insolvency on previous date is res adjudicata on
all creditors. In re Am. Brewing Co. (1902), 112 Fed., 752; 8 A. B. R.,
463.
Definition in this section must be strictly adhered to. Duncan v.
Landis (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 106 Fed., 839; 5 A. B. R., 649;
3 N. B. N., 673.
Confession of inability to pay debts prima facie evidence of insolvency.
8 MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. [§ 1.
In re Lange (1899), N. Dist. Iowa, Shiras, J., 97 Fed., 197; 1 A. B. R.,
189; 1 N. B. N., 60.
Judgment and levy not proof of insolvency. Levor v. Setter (1901),
N. Y. Sup. Ct., Sp. Term; 34 Misc., 382.
Debtor presumed to know his insolvency. In re Gilbert (1902), Dist.
Ore., Bellinger, J.. 112 Fed., 951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
Corporations suspension of business and inability to pay debts —
presumption of insolvency. In re Elmira Steel Co. (1901), N. Dist., N.
Y., Hazel, J., 109 Fed., 456; 5 A. B. R., 484.
Dissolution of a firm and inability to meet debts is strongest evidence
of insolvency. In re Miller (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed.,
764; 5 A. B. R., 140.
Property exempt from execution included on trial of contested petition.
In re Bauman (1899), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 96 Fed., 946.
Prospective profits on goods purchased not assets. In re Bloch (1901) ,
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 109 Fed., 790; 6 A. B. R., 300; 3 N. B. N., 894.
Evidence improperly rejected. In re Bloch (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
109 Fed., 790; 6 A. B. R., 300; 3 N. B. N., 894.
Insolvency established. In re Rome Planing Mill Co. (1900), N.
Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 99 Fed., 937; 3 A. B. R., 766.
Insolvency denied. In re Gilbert (1902), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 112
Fed.. 951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
(16) "Juifee" shall mean a judge of a court of bank-
ruptcy, not including the referee ;
As to What are Courts of Bankruptcy, see ante Sec. 1 (8), and notes.
As to when powers of Judge are vested in referee, see Sec. 38a.
(17) "Oath" shall include affirmation ;
As to punishment for false oath, see Sec. 29b (2) , and notes. As to
who may administer oaths, see Sec. 20a. Refusal to take oath, con-
tempt. Sec. 41a (4).
(18) "Officer" shall include clerk, marshal, receiver,
referee, and trustee, and the imposing of a duty upon or the
forbidding of an act by any officer shall include his successor
and any person authorized by law to perform the duties of
such officer;
As to officers, their duties and compensation, see Chapter V. post.
"Person" defined, Sec. 1 (19) post.
§ 1.] MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. 9
(19) "Persons" shall include corporations, except where
otherwise specified, and officers, partnerships, and women,
and when used with reference to the commission of acts
which are herein forbidden shall include persons who are
participants in the forbidden acts, and the agents, officers,
and members of the board of directors or trustees, or other
similar controlling bodies of corporations ;
As to offenses under this act forbidden see Sec. 29a post and notes.
As to violations of the Bankruptcy law and punishment therefor see
Sec. 2 (4) and notes,
(20) "Petition" shall mean a paper filed in a court of
bankruptcy or with a clerk or deputy clerk by a debtor
praying for the benefits of this Act, or by creditors alleging
the commission of an act of bankruptcy by a debtor therein
named ;
As to petitions see Sec. 59 and notes. As to acts of bankruptcy by
a debtor, see Sec. 3 post and notes. As to what are Courts of bank-
ruptcy, see Sec. 2 post. For definition of Clerk, see Sec. 1 (5) ante. As
to filing of papers see Gen. Order II and notes. As to Creditors filing
involuntary petitions, see Sec. 59b and notes.
(21) "Referee" shall mean the referee who has juris-
diction of the case or to whom the case has been referred, or
any one acting in his stead ;
As to duties, powers, qualifications of referee, see Chapter V post.
Sec. 33 to Sec. 34, inclusive. Courts of bankruptcy determine territorial
Jurisdiction of referees, Sec. 34a (2). As to Reference of cases, see Sec.
22 (a).
A referee is in fact a judge of the Bankruptcy Court. In re Tebo (1900) ,
Dist. W. Va., Jackson, J., 101 Fed., 419; 4 A. B. R., 235.
(22) "Conceal" shall include secrete, falsify, and mu-
tilate ;
This clause construed. In re Bellah (1902), Dist. Del., Bradford, J.,
116 Fed., 69; 8 A. B. R., 310.
(23) "Secured creditor" shall include a creditor who
10 MEANING OP WORDS AND PHRASES. [§ 1.
has security for his debt upon the property of the bankrupt
of a nature to be assignable under this Act, or who owns
such a debt for which some indorser, surety, or other persons
secondarily liable for the bankrupt has such security upon
the bankrupt's assets;
As to how value of securities ascertained, see Sec. 57 and notes.
This section limits the meaning of "secured creditor" to its strict
definition. It does not amplify the usual meaning of the term. In
re Coe, Powers & Co. (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 1 A. B. R.
275; 1 N. B. N., 294.
(24) '^States" shall include the Territories, the Indian
Territory, Alaska, and the District of Columbia ;
As to State insolvency laws, see Sec. 71 (a) and notes.
(25) **Transfer" shall include the sale and every other
and different mode of disposing of or parting with
property, or the possession of property, absolutely or con-
ditionally, as a payment, pledge, mortgage, gift, or security;
As to the further construction and application of "transfer," see Sec.
60c and notes. When transfer is act of bankruptcy, Sec. 3a (1) and notes.
"Transfer" is used in its most comprehensive sense and is intended
to include every means and manner by which property can pass from the
ownership and possession of another. Pirie v. Chicago T. & Tr. Co.
(1901), U. S. Sup. Court, McKenna, J., 182 U. S., 444; 5 A. B. R., 814;
3 N. B. N., 566.
Payment of money on account is a transfer. In re Fixen (1900), C.
C. A., 9th Cir., Morrow, J., 102 Fed., 295; 4 A. B. R., 10.
Word "property," as here used, includes money. Boyd v. Lemon Gale
Co. (1902), C. C, A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 114 Fed., 647; 8 A. B. R., 81.
Payment of money in due course of business a "transfer." Worden
v. Columbia Electric Co. (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 96 Fed., 803;
contra In re Rathff (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell. J., 107 Fed., 80; 5
A. B. R., 713.
Receivership is not a transfer. In re Baker- Ricketson (1899), Dist.
Mass., Lowell. J., 97 Fed., 489; 4 A. B. R., 605; 2 N. B. N., 133.
Deposit in bank is a "transfer." In re Stege (1902), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., 116 Fed., 342; S A. B. R., 515.
§ 1.] MEANING OF WORDS AND PHRASES. 11
As to application of "transfer" see: In re Ed W. Wrigkt Lumber
Co. (1902), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 114 Fed., 1,011; 8 A. B. R., 345.
(26) "Trustee" shall include all of the trustees of an
estate ;
For appointment, duties, qualifications of trustees, see Sec. 44 to 51,
inclusive, and Gen. Ord., XIII, XIV, XV and XVII. As to when more
than one trustee in an estate, see Sec. 47b and notes.
(27) "Wage earner" shall mean an individual who
works for wages, salary, or hire, at a rate of compensation
not exceeding one thousand five himdred dollars per year ;
As to prior claim of wage earner with construction of term. See Sec.
64 b (4) post and notes thereunder. Wage-earner exempted from invol-
tuitary bankruptcy, Sec. 4b post and notes.
(28) [Words importing masculine gender.] Words im-
porting masculine gender may be applied to and include cor-
porations, partnerships, and women ;
See definition of persons. Sec. 1 (19) ante and notes. See as to words
imparting singular number. Sec. 1 (29) and Sec. 1 (30) post.
(29) [Words importing Plural Number.] Words im-
porting the plural number may be applied to and mean only
a single person or thing;
For definition of persons, see Sec. 1 (19) ante and notes, see also Sec.
1 (28) ante, and Sec. 1 (30) post.
(30) [Words importing singular number.] Words im-
porting the singular niunber may be applied to and mean
several persons or things.
See Sec. 1 (29) ante.
CHAPTER II.
CREATION OF COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY AND THEIR
JURISDICTION.
Sec. 2. Courts op Bankruptcy named. — Jurisdiction.
(1) to adjudge persons bankrupt.
(2) to allow and disallow claims.
(3) to appoint receivers.
(4) to try and punish bankrupts.
(5) to permit temporary transac-
tion of business.
(6) to substitute persons in pro-
ceedings.
(7) to collect and distribute as-
sets.
(8) to close estates.
(9) to confirm and reject com.
positions.
(10) to modify, etc., referee's
findinsr.
(11) to determine exemptions.
(12) to discharge bankrupts, etc.
(13) to enforce orders.
(14) to extradite bankrupts,
to make all necessary orders
for enforcement of provis-
ions of act.
to punish for contempts be-
fore referees.
(17) to appoint trustees.
to tax costs.
transfer cases to other courts
of bankruptcy.
(20) specified powers.
(15)
(16)
(18)
(19)
Sec. 2. Courts of Bankruptcy named. — Jurisdiction.
[Jurisdiction of courts of banlcniptcy.] That the courts
of bankruptcy as hereinbefore defined, viz., the district
courts of the United States in the several states, the
supreme court of the District of Columbia, the district
courts of the several Territories, and the United States
courts in the Indian Territory and the District of Alaska,
are hereby made courts of bankruptcy, and are hereby in-
vested within their respective territorial limits as now es-
tablished, or as they may be hereafter changed, with such
jurisdiction at law and in equity as will enable them to
exercise original jurisdiction in bankruptcy proceedings, in
12
§ 2. (1)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 13
vacation in chambers and during their respective terms,
as they are now or may be hereafter held, to
Courts of bankruptcy defined Sec. 1 (8) ante. For jurisdiction of U.
S. and State Courts, see Sec. 23 post, and notes thereimder.
Federal court sitting as court of bankruptcy is always open and does
not lose jurisdiction to alter interlocutory orders by termination of
term at which they were entered. In re Henschel (1902), S. Dist., N.
Y., Adams, J., 114 Fed., 968; 8 A. B. R., 201.
(1) [To adjudicate persons bankrupt.] Adjudge persons
bankrupt who have had their principal place of business,
resided, or had their domicile within their respective terri-
torial jurisdiction for the preceding six months, or the
greater portion thereof, or who do not have their principal
place of business, reside, or have their domicile within the
United States, but have property within their jurisdictions,
or who have been adjudged bankrupts by courts of com-
petent jurisdiction without the United States and have
property within their jurisdictions ;
Compare with Sec. 1 of Act of 1867 post.
See Forms 1 and 3 for allegations of residence in petitions, also Gen.
Ord. VI, as to petitions in different districts, and Gen. Ord. VII, as to
priority of petitions when two or more are filed against a common debtor.
Ancillary jurisdiction exercised by court of bankruptcy. In re Peiser
(1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 115 Fed., 199; 7 A. B. R., 690.
Business, residence and domicile, facts on which court must base its
jurisdiction to adjudge persons bankrupt. In re Marine Machine &
Conveyor Company (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 91 Fed., 630;
1 A. B. R., 421; 1 N. B. N., 135; In re Brice (1899), Dist. Iowa,
Woolson, J., 93 Fed., 942; 2 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N., 310; In r^ Blair
(19 00), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed., 76; 3 A. B. R., 588; 2 N. B.
N., 890; In re Filer (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 108 Fed., 209;
5 A. B. R., 332; 3 N. B. N., 366; In re Plotke (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Seaman, J., 104 Fed., 964; 5 A. B. R., 171; 3 N. B. N., 122; In re Grimes
(1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 94 Fed., 800; 2 A. B. R., 160; 1 N. B.
N., 339.
Court of bankruptcy no power to enter order to show cause to be served
on person outside the District. In re Waukesha Water Co. (1902), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 116 Fed., 1,009; 8 A. B. R., 715.
14 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2.(1)
Residence must have commenced at least six months prior. In re
Stokes (1899), Dist. Washington, Munter, R.; 1 A. B. R., 35; 1 N. B. N.,
106; (see note to this case, 1 A. B. R., 37).
Domicile not lost by temporary absence however prolonged where
intention to return remained. In re Williams (1900) , District Washing-
ton, Hanford, J., 99 Fed., 544; 3 A. B. R., 677; 2 N. B. N., 206.
"Domicile" and "Residence" defined. Three months of either inside
the six months period essential to the jurisdiction. In re Berner (1899)
N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 3 A. B. R., 325; 2 N. B. N., 268, 330.
Residence of bankrupt is jurisdictional fact; burden on bankrupt to
show it. 7w r^ Waxelbaum (1899) , S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed.,
562; 3 A. B. R., 267; 2 N. B. N., 103. Same on rehearing. 7« r^ Waxel-
baum (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 589; 3 A. B. R., 392;
2 N. B. N., 228.
Objection to jurisdiction of court of bankruptcy on account of resi-
dence must be promptly raised, otherwise waived by creditors. In re
Mason (1900), W. Dist. N.C., Ewart,J. 99 Fed., 256; 3 A. B. R., 599; 2
N. B. N., 425.
Principal place of doing business of a corporation is where its business
is in fact done, not where it merely markets its products. Full discussion
of jurisdiction of court on "principal place of business." In re Elmira
Steel Company (1901), N. Dist. New York, Moss, R.; 5 A. B. R., 484.
Residence not shown by the mere temporary lodging in a boarding
house in the State although intention to return is claimed. In re Dingle-
hoef Brothers (1901), E. Dist. North Carolina, Purnell, J., 109 Fed., 866;
6 A. B. R., 242; 3 N. B. N., 946.
A corporation created by law of one State may be adjudged bankrupt,
in another. In re Magid-Hope Silk Mfg. Co. (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J., 110 Fed., 352; 6 A. B. R., 610; Dressel v. North State Lumber Co. (1901),
E. Dist. N. C, Purnell, J., 107 Fed., 255.
Objection to jurisdiction over person must be promptly taken. In re
Mason (1900), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 99 Fed., 256; 3 A. B. R., 599,
2 N. B. N., 425.
As between two United States District Courts, the one whose aid is first
invoked is entitled to charge of the proceedings. In re Elmira Steel
Company (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J.; 5 A. B. R., 484.
Want of jurisdiction to adjudicate one a bankrupt cannot be raised by
creditors in opposition to discharge. Grounds enumerated in the statute
only can be raised. In re Clisdell (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 101
Fed., 246; 4 A. B. R., 95; 2 N. B. N., 638.
§2.(2)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 15
A corporation having its general office within a district more than six
months prior to filing of petition is within jurisdiction of the court. In
re Marine Machine & Conveyor Co. (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J ,
91 Fed., 630; 1 A. B. R., 421; 1 N. B. N., 136,
A petition stating disjunctively "that the petitioner has had his princi-
pal place of business, or has resided, or has had his domicile for greater
portion of six months, etc.," is insufficient on its face to confer jvu4sdic-
tion. Inre Laskaris (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Moss, R.; 1 A. B. R., 480;
1 N. B. N., 209.
"Place of business," "residence" and "domicile" compared and dis-
cussed. In re Cisdell (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Moss, R.; 2 A. B. R., 424.
Words "greater portion" are synonymous with "longest period" in
the Act of 1867. The petition may be filed in the District in which
bankrupt has resided for the longest period dtiring the preceding six
months. In re Ray et al. (1899), Dist. of Washington, Worden, R.; 2
A. B. R., 158; 1 N. B. N., 336.
Jurisdiction dependent on principal place of business must show
that there was business carried on. Making an assignment void by law
does not carry on the business by virtue thereof. In re Plotke (1900),
C. C. A., 7thCir., Seaman, J., 104 Fed., 964; 5 A. B. R., 171;3N. B.
N., 122.
Jtuisdiction conferred where parties proceed to hearing on petition
before referee without objecting to jtuisdiction. In re Steuer (1900),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 104 Fed., 976; 5 A. B. R., 209; 3 N. B. N , 226.
No jurisdiction by svunmary process where there is none by plenary
suit. In re Ward (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 104 Fed., 985; 5 A. B.
R., 215; 3 N. B. N., 216.
Jurisdiction of the federal courts is acqviired the moment petition is
filed. Carpenter Bros. v. O'Connor (1899), Ohio Cir.Ct., 2nd Cir., Wil-
son, J.; 1 A. B. R.,381.
(2) [Allow and disallow claims.] Allow claims, dis-
allow claims, reconsider allowed or disallowed claims, and
allow or disallow them against bankrupt estates ;
As to Creditors and Claims, see Sec. 55 to 60, inclusive.
As to time of hearing claims, see Sec. 55b. As to procedure. Sees. 57,
and 65. As to Forms for proof of claim, see Forms 32, and 33. For
Proof of Claims, Gen. Ord. XXL
As to Estates, see Sec. 70 and notes.
16 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2.(3)
For proof and allowance of claims, see Sec. 57 and notes thereunder.
What are provable debts see Sec. 63 and notes.
Claim of creditor filed and disallowed is res adjiidicata in the bank-
ruptcy proceeding. In re Heinsfurther (1899),. S. Dist. Iowa, Woolson,
J., 97 Fed., 198; 3 A. B. R., 109; 1 N. B. N., 504.
Referee no jurisdiction to find in considering claims that bankrupt
was gfuilty of fraud in contracting the debt. In re Lazarovic (1898), Dist.
Kan., Corey, R.; 1 A. B. R., 476.
(3) [Appoint receivers.] Appoint receivers or the mar-
shals, upon application of parties in interest, in case the
courts shall find it absolutely necessary, for the preservation
of estates, to take charge of the property of bankrupts after
the filing of the petition and imtil it is dismissed or the
trustee is qualified ;
See (5) post tmder this Section and notes. Also (7) and notes and
amendment as to compensation. As to possession of property and
proceedings to seize the same, see Sec. 69a and Sec. 3e.
For definition of trustee see Sec. 1 (26) ante; as to suits by trustees
Sec. 236; relative to appointment of trustees Sec. 44 and 45 and notes.
Bankrupt court having obtained possession will not suffer State officer
to interfere therewith. In re Schloerb (1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman,
J., 97 Fed., 326; 3 A. B. R., 224; 2 N. B. N., 234.
Receiver's fee must be fair and reasonable. In re Scott (1900), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 97 Fed., 588; 3 A. B. R., 625; 2 N. B. N., 440.
Fire instirance policy held to belong to receiver in bankrucpty who
could collect the premium, and not to a bank which claimed it as col-
lateral, and which if maintained would have invalidated the policy. In
re Hamilton (1900), ei al, W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 4 A. B. R., 543; 2 N.B.
N.. 957.
Receiver has power to sell liquor license as an asset if transferable
under law of State. In re Becker (1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J.
98 Fed., 407; 3 A. B. R., 412; 2 N. B. N., 225.
Marshal entitled to fees same as receiver. In re Adams Sartorial Co.
(1900), Dist. Colo., HoUett, J., 101 Fed., 215; 4 A. B. R., 107; 2 N. B. N.,
635.
Before adjudication receiver no extra territorial jurisdiction. Inde-
pendent procedure necessary to take possession of assets in foreign state.
In re Schrom (1899), N. Dist. of Iowa, Shiras, J., 97 Fed., 760; 3 A. B.
R., 352.
§2. (3)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 17
Receiver under bankruptcy law derives his powers from that statute
alone and object of his appointment is to preserve the property of the
bankrupt so as to prevent its destruction. Is not a common law receiver.
Cannot institute suit to recover property etc. Boonville Nat. Bank v.
Blakey (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, 'J., 107 Fed., 891; 6 A. B. R.,
13; 3 N. B. N., 644.
Summary proceedings by landlord to remove bankrupt tenant from
premises enjoined at suit of receiver, hire Kleinhans (1902) , W. Dist.
N. Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 107; 7 A. B. R., 604.
Bankruptcy Court will take jurisdiction of a motion to appoint a re-
ceiver even when proceedings are pending in State Cotu-t. In re Bruss-
Ritter Co. (1898), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 90 Fed., 651; 1 A. B. R., 58;
1 N. B. N., 39; In re John A. Ethridge Fumittu-e Co. (1899), Dist. Ky.,
Barr, J., 92 Fed., 329; 1 A. B. R., 112; 1 N. B. N., 139.
Bankruptcy Cotirt will appoint marshall to take charge of bankrupt's
property even if proceedings in State Court pending. Davis v. Bohle
(1899), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 92 Fed., 325; 1 A. B. R., 412; 1 N.
B. N., 216; affirming in re Sievers (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 91
Fed., 366; 1 A. B. R., 117; 1 N. B. N., 60.
Bankruptcy Court will not appoint receiver of property claimed ad-
versly. Carling v. Seymour Lumber Co. (1902), C. C. A., 6th Cir., 113
Fed., 483; 8 A. B. R., 29; reversing in re Macon Sash, etc., Co. (1901),
S. Dist. Ga. , Speer, J . , 1 12 Fed. , 323 ; Beach v. Macon Grocery Co. (1902) ;
C. C. A. 5th Cir., 116 Fed., 143; 8 A. B. R., 751.
Assignee under general assignment appointed receiver. In re John
A. Etheridge Furniture Co. (1899), Dist. Ky., Barr, J., 92 Fed., 329;
1 A. B. R., 112; 1 N. B. N., 139.
Receiver must preserve assets intact. He is only a custodian and
caretaker. In re Kleinhans (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed.,
107; 7 A. B. R., 604; Boonville Nat. Bank r. Blakey (1901); C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Jenkins, J., 107 Fed., 891; 6 A. B. R., 13; 3 N. B. N., 644.
Covu-t of Bankruptcy may, under its general equity powers, appoint
receivers. In re Fixen (1899), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J.. 96 Fed., 748;
2 A. B. R., 822.
Receiver not to exercise general powers conferred on trustee. In re
Kleinhans (1902), W. Dist. N. Y.„ Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 107; 7 A. B. R.,
604.
Court may order receiver to sell property. In re Becker (1899), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 98 Fed., 407; 2 N. B. N., 245.
Coxirt may issue injunction in aid of receiver. In re Kleinhans (1902),
W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 107; 7 A. B. R., 604.
18 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2.(5)
Receiver can not forcibly seize property in possession of an adverse
claimant. Bardes vs. Hawarden First Nat. Bank (1900), U. S. Sup. Ct.,
Gray, J. ,178 U.S., 538; 4 A. B. R., 163; 2 N. B. N., 725; in re Bender (1901),
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 106 Fed., 873; 5 A. B. R., 632.
Receiver in bankruptcy has statutory powers only — has not the power
to sue exercised by trustee. Boonville Nat. Bank v. Blakely (1901), C.
C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 107 Fed., 891; 6 A. B R., 13.
Marshal having seized the property of purchaser, damages, attorneys,
fees and costs were allowed purchaser for the improper seizure. In
re Arbaham (1899), C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 93 Fed., 767; 2 A.
B. R., 266; 1 N. B. N.. 281.
(4) [Try and punish bankrapts.] Arraign, try, and pun-
ish bankrupts, officers, and other persons, and the agents,
officers, members of the board of directors or trustees, or
other similar controlling bodies of corporations for violations
of this Act, in accordance with the laws of procedure of the
United States now in force, or such as may be hereafter
enacted, regulating trials for the alleged violation of laws
of the United States ;
"Bankrupf'defined Sec. 1 (4) and notes. "Officers" defined Sec. 1
(18) and notes. "Persons" defined Sec. 1 (19) and notes. As to jury
trials see Sec. 19 post and notes. For offenses under this Act see Sec. 29
post and notes.
Arrest by bankrupt tmder State process for fraudulent insolvency
will not be challenged by bankruptcy court. U. S. v. McAleese (1899),
C. C. A., 3rd Cir., McPherson, J., 93 Fed., 656; 1 A. B. R., 650; 1 N. B.
N., 265.
In defense to a proceeding for failure to account for assets, confession
of squandering the same not sufficient. In re Tudor (1899), Dist. Colo.,
Hallett, J., 96 Fed.. 942; 4 A. B. R., 78; 2 N. B. N., 168.
(5) [Authorize temporary transaction ol business.] Au-
thorize the business of bankrupts to be conducted for
limited periods by receivers, the marshals, or trustees, if
necessary, in the best interests of the estates,* and allow
such officers additional compensation for such services, but
not at a greater rate than in this Act allowed trustees for
similar services.*
As amended by law of 1903, Section 1 of amendment, page — post. Amendment
adds matter between stars.
§2.(7)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — ^JURISDICTION. 19
See ante (3) and notes. As to compensation of trustees see post. Sec.
48 as amended.
(6) [Bring in additional parties.] Bring in and sub-
stitute additional persons or parties in proceedings in bank-
ruptcy when necessary for the complete determination of a
matter in controversy.
Trustee may be ordered by the court to enter his appearance and
defend any pending suit, Sec. lib post. He may prosecute suits brought
by bankrupt, Sec. lie post. As to when third persons other than the
bankrupt, trustee and creditors may be brought in, see Sec. 23 post and
notes.
Bankruptcy proceeding is in rem, and all those interested in the res
are regarded as parties to it. Southern Loan & Trust Co. v. Benhow
(1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96 Fed., 514; 3 A. B. R., 9; 1 N. B.
N., 499.
(7) [Collect and distribute assets.] Cause the estates of
bankrupts to be collected, reduced to money and distributed,
and determine controversies in relation thereto, except as
herein otherwise provided;
For administration of estates, Chapter VII post. As to suits in rela-
tion to bankrupt's property, see Sec. 11 post, and notes. See ante (3)
and (5) and notes. Jurisdiction of courts in suits by trustee. Sec. 23b
post and notes. As to possession of property, see Sec. 69 post and notes.
Title to property, Sec. 70 post.
Bankruptcy court has exclusive jurisdiction over property of bank-
rupt and has sufficient equity powers to have all claims brought in and
enforced by it. Murray v. Beale (1899), Dist. of Utah, Marshall, J., 97
Fed., 567; 3 A. B. R., 284; 2 N. B. N., 164.
Claim of creditors for the return of goods is cognizable by the bank-
ruptcy court. In re McCallum (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 113
Fed., 393; 7 A. B. R., 596.
Bankruptcy court has inherent power to punish inter-meddlers by
summary process. 7h re Tune (1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 115 Fed.,
906; 8 A. B. R., 285.
Bankruptcy court may assess stockholders of bankrupt corporation.
In re Miller Electric Maintenance Co, (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J.,
Ill Fed., 515; 6 A. B. R., 701; 3 N. B. N., 1,002; In re Crystal Spring
Bottling Co. (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 96 Fed., 945; 3 A. B. R., 194;
3 N. B. N., 180.
20 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2.(7)
The jurisdiction to determine controversies under this sub-head
depends, (1) whether the controversy is one having reference to prop-
erty actually in the possession of the bankruptcy court or belonging to
the bankrupt's estate; or (2) whether it arises in the bankruptcy pro-
ceeding; or (3) whether from nature of the controversy power is conferred
on the court to determine conflicting liens and apportion assets. In re
Kellogg (1902), Vf. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 120; 7 A. B. R., 623.
The words "except as herein otherwise provided," refer to the provis-
ions of Sec. 23a and b, limiting the jurisdiction of bankruptcy courts.
Bryan v. Bernheimer (1901), U. S. Sup. Court, Gray, J., 181 U. S., 194;
5 A. B. R., 623; 3 N. B. N., 482; Bardes v. Hawarden First National Bank
(1900), U. S, Sup. Court, Gray, J., 178 U. S., 535; In re Kellogg (1902),
W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 120; 7 A. B. R., 623; In re Woodbury
(1900), Dist. N. Da.,Amidon, J., 98 Fed., 833; 3 A. B. R., 457; 2jN.^B.
N., 284.
This clause construed. In re Baudouine (1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
Wallace, J., lOlFed., 574; 3 A. B. R., 651; 1 N. B. N., 506. In re Browne
(1900), E. Dist, Pa., McPherson, J., 104 Fed., 762; 5 A. B. R., 220: In re
Rosenberg (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 116 Fed., 402; 8 A. B.
R., 624.
Owner of property may interv'ene. In re Whitener (1900), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., Pardee, J., 105 Fed., 180; 5 A. B. R., 198; 3 N. B. N., 316; Fisher
V. Cushman (1900), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 103 Fed., 860; 4 A. B.
R., 646; In re Kindt (1900), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 107; 3
A. B. R., 546; 2 N. B. N., 373; see likewise In re Todd (1901), S. Dist.
N Y., Brown, J., 109 Fed., 265; 6 A. B. R., 88; 3 N. B, N., 833; In re
Durham (1900), E. Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 104 Fed., 231; 4 A. B. R., 760
2 N. B. N., 1,101.
Property secured by fraud of bankrupt ordered returned to owners.
Bloomingdale v. Empire Rubber Mfg. Co. (1902), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas,
J., 114 Fed., 1,016; 8 A. B. R., 74.
District court shovdd examine ground for summary application for
order directing surrender of property and if there appears to be a real con-
troversy, matter must be referred to the state court. In re Baird (1902),
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 115 Fed., 1023; 8 A. B. R., 649.
District Court must determine whether a real controversy exists —
cannot act in personam upon adverse claimants who reside in another
district. In re Waukesha Water Co. (1912), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J.,
116 Fed., 1009; 8 A. B. R., 715.
State court cannot refuse to surrender assets until its officers are paid
I 2. (7)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 21
fees. In re Rogers (1902), S. Dist. Ga., Speer, J., 116 Fed., 435; 8 A. B.
R., 723.
Bankruptcy court cannot dispose of adverse claim to property of bank-
rupt in possession of third person without consent of the parties. In re
Michie (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 116 Fed., 749; 8 A. B. R., 734.
Sale of property in hands of receiver by order of bankruptcy court,
though creditors had been on same. Beach v. Mason, Grocery Co. (1902),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., 116 Fed., 143; 8 A. B. R., 751, where District Court has
acquired possession of property it has power to adjudicate liens claimed
thereon. Chauncey et al. v. Dyke Bros. (1902), C. C. A-, 8th Cir., Thayer,
J., 119 Fed., 1.
Bankruptcy cotirt has no jurisdiction over funds of execution sale,
where the judgment on which sale was based was obtained more than four
months prior to filing the petition, even though the sale was within the
four months preceding. In re Easley (1899), W Dist. Va., Paxil, J., 93
Fed., 419; 1 A. B. R., 715; 1 N. B. 230.
Jurisdiction of property in possession of District Court is not to be in-
terfered with by proceedings in state courts subsequently brought. In
re Russell & Birkett (1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 101 Fed.;
248; 3 A. B. R., 658.
Mortgagees obtaining possession of property prior to filing of petition,
cannot be compelled by summary process to deliver same to the trustee.
In re Buntrock Clothing Co. (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 92 Fed.,
886; 1 A. B. R., 454; 1 N. B. N., 291
Bankruptcy court no jurisdiction over fund, title to which has been
adjudicated by another court of competent jurisdict ion . Quaere. Has
District Covut jurisdiction of suit agaist trustee by claim of property held
by him. J. B. McFarlane Carriage Co. et al. v. Salanas et al. (1901),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., 106 Fed., 145; 5 A. B. R., 442.
Jurisdiction in garnishment proceedings against the bankrupt inheres
in District Cotirt. In re McCartney (1901), E. Dist. Wis. Seaman, J.,
109 Fed., 621; 6 A. B. R., 367.
Jurisdiction wanting in District Court to compel assignee to turn over
assets on stimmary proceedings — no contempt where party ordered to
do the impossible and turn over money squandered. Sinsheiner et al.
v. Simonson et al. (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Severens, J., 107 Fed., 898;
5 A. B. R., 537.
Jiirisdiction wanting in District Court in suit by trustee to compel
third party to bankruptcy proceedings to sell certificate of Board of Trade
held by bankrupt as collateral. In re Silberhom (1900), N. Dist. 111.,
Kohlsaat, J., 105 Fed., 899; 5 A. B. R., 568.
22 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY, — JURISDICTION. [§2.(7)
Money turned over by bankrupt to wife can not be reached by sum-
mary order. /nr^Green (1901),E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 108 Fed.;
616; 6 A. B. R., 270.
State court having taken possession of estate by receiver more than
four months prior to bankruptcy, will not be divested of control. Frazier
V. So. Loan & Trust Co. (1900), C. C A., 4th Cir.,Paul, J., 99 Fed., 707,
3 A. B. R., 710.
r
Possession of assets by trustee should be obtained by application to
State Court, In re Kersten & Kersten (1901), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman,
J., 110 Fed., 929; 6 A, B. R., 516.
Where proceedings in State Court are in nature of insolvency proceed-
ings state administration is suspended by bankruptcy. In re Kersten
& Kersten (1901), E. Dist, Wis., Seaman, J., 110 Fed., 929; 6 A. B. R., 516-
Jurisdiction of bankruptcy court prevails over State court which had
appointed a receiver on grounds of insolvency. Comity requires that
bankruptcy receiver apply for an order for possession. In re Lengert
Wagon Co. (1901). S. Dist. N.Y., Adams, J., 110 Fed., 927; 6 A. B. R., 535.
It is error on a summary petition to compel an assignee of bankrupt
without notice to turn over property to the trustee. Smith v.Belford
(1901), C. C. A. 6th Cir.,Sevems, J., 106 Fed., 658; 5 A, B. R., 291.
Jurisdiction in district Court to order purchaser of assets under general,
assignment to turn over property of estate to the purchaser in bank-
ruptcy proceedings. Bryan v. Bernheimer 1901), U. S. Supreme Ct.,
Judge Gray, 181 U. S., 181; 5 A. B. R., 623.
Jurisdiction of District Court to take possession of property of bank-
rupt which was in possession, although mortgagee claims title and pos-
session. In re Bendeer (1901), W. Dist. Ark.,, Rogers, J., 106 Fed., 873;
5 A. B. R., 632.
Court of bankruptcy has no power by summary process to order
sheriff to turn over to trustee money obtained from sale under execution
made null by bankruptcy adjudication. In re Franks (1899), S. Dist.
Ala., Toulmin, J., 95 Fed., 635; 2 A. B. R., 634.
The jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court over exempt property is
limited to setting the exempt property aside. Disputes concerning title
to property left to other courts. In re Hill, N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J.,
96 Fed., 185; 2 A. B. R., 798; 2 N. B, N,, 180.
Bankruptcy court has power to compel purchasers at a chattel mort-
gage sale of bankrupt's goods, after adjudication to turn property pur-
chased over to trustee. In re Brooks (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J.;
1 A. B. R., 531; 1 N. B. N., 240.
A stockholder without personal interest may be ordered to surrender
§2.(8)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 23
to Marshal and held for contempt if he refuses. In re Macon Lumber
Co. (1901), S. Dist. Ga., 112 Fed., 323; 7 A. B. R., 66.
Goods in possession of bankrupt at time of adjudication are in posses-
sion of the bankrupt court. No process of the state court can take them
out. Summary relief proper. White & Ors v. Schloerb et al. (1900), U.
S. Sup. Ct., Gray, J., 178 U. S., 542; 4 A. B. R., 178; 2 N. B. N., 721.
Jurisdiction of State court which has appointed receiver of a firm is
not to be assailed in bankruptcy court in subsequent proceeding — no order
will be made on the receiver to turn over the assets. Trustee must apply
to state court for such an order. In re Price & Co. (1899), So. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 92 Fed., 987; 1 A. B. R., 606; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Adjudication in bankruptcy will be respected by state court and funds
in receiver's hands be ordered turned over to the trustee. State court
will allow for costs and expenses of the receivership. Wilson v. Parr
(1902), Little, J., Sup. Ct. Ga., 8 A. B. R., 230.
Bankruptcy Court having possession of property of bankrupt will not
allow a subsequent proceeding in State Court to interfere with the same.
Keegan v. King (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 96 Fed., 758; 3 A. B. R., 79.
Property being administered by a state court should not be disturbed
by a court of bankruptcy unless it is evident that an injustice will be done
to the general creditors by administration in the State Court. Southern
Loan & Trust Co. v. Benbow (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96 Fed.,
514; 3 A. B. R., 9; 1 N. B. N,, 499.
Reopening of estate should be based on proper petition setting up the
facts. In re Newton (1901), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Adams, J., 107 Fed., 429;
6 A. B. R., 52.
State court cannot demand as a condition of turning over property in
hands of receiver that costs of administration be first paid. Hanson v.
Stephens (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 42 S. E., 1028.
(8) [Close estates.] Close estates, whenever it appears
that they have been fully administered, by approving the
final accounts and discharging the trustees, and reopen them
whenever it appears they were closed before being fully ad-
ministered :
Duty of trustee to close estates expeditiously. Sec. 47a (2).
Trustee to file final account fifteen days before the final meeting of
creditors. Sec. 47 post.
Creditors to have ten days' notice. Sec. 58a post.
24 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2.(11)
As to death or removal of trustee, Sec. 46. See generally ante (3) (5)
(7) and notes thereto. As to administration of estates, see Chapter VII.
Speedy closing of estates duty of courts of bankruptcy. In re Stein
(1899), Dist. Ind.,Baker, J.,94Fed., 124;1 A. B. R., 662; 1 N. B. N., 339.
Court reluctant to reopen estate. In re Newton (1901), C. C. A.,
8th Cir., Adams, J., 107 Fed.. Rep., 429; 6 A. B. R., 52; 3 N. B. N., 978;
In re Shaffer (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 104 Fed., 982; 4 A. B. R.
728; 3 N. B. N., 54.
(9) [Confirm or reject compositions.] Confirm or reject
compositions between debtors and their creditors, and set
aside compositions and reinstate the cases;
For confirmation or rejection of compositions, see Sec. 12 and Sec.
13, post. Gen. Ord. XXXII. For effect of setting aside composition
on title to property, see Sec. 64 c and Sec. 70d, post. For forms for
composition see Forms 60 and 61, post.
(10) [Pass on referee's findings.] Consider and confirm
modify or overrule, or return, with instructions for further
proceedings, records and findings certified to them by
referees ;
As to Practice on review of referee's finding, see Gen. Ord. XXVII.
As to findings of the referee, see Sec. 38 and 39, post, and notes.
Ruling of referee to which exception is desired to be made to the' Judge
shovdd be accompanied by an order, and petition for review should be
filed. In re Smith (1899), W. Dist. Texas, Maxey, J., 93 Fed., 791; 2
A. B. R., 190; 1 N. B. N., 532.
Orders and decrees may be made and corrected at any time, the court
being always open. Mahoney et al., v. Ward (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 100 Fed., 278; 3 A. B. R., 770; 2 N. B. N., 538.
Petition for review essential before judge will review referee's order.
In re Russell (1900), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 105 Fed., 501; 5 A. B.
R., 566; 3 N. B. N., 365. In re Smith (1899), W. Dist. Texas, Maxey,
J., 93 Fed., 791; 2 A. B. R., 190; 1 N. B. N., 532.
Petition for review is in nature of assignment of errors and only mat-
ters included therein will be passed on. In re T. L. Kelley Dry Goods
Co. (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 747; 4 A. B. R., 528.
(11) [Pass on claims to exemption.] Determine all
claims of bankrupts to their exemptions ;
§2.(13)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — ^JURISDICTION. 25
As to exemptions to which bankrupt is entitled, see Sec. 6 post and
notes, also Sec. 47 (11), post, annd notes as to duty of Trustee in regard
to exemptions. Bankrupt to schedule exemptions, Sec. 7 (8) post. Form
No. 1, Sch. B (5).
Court will not review a finding or order of the referee that property
is not exempt, unless a trustee has been appointed and has set apart the
bankrupt's exemption. In re Smith (1899), West Dist. Texas, Maxey,"
J., 93 Fed., 791; 2 A. B. R., 190; 1 N. B. N., 532.
Bankruptcy Court exclusive jvuisdiction to determine right to ex-
emptions as between bankrupt and trustee. McGahan v. Anderson (1902) ,
C. C. A., 4th Cir., Jackson, J., 113 Fed., 115; 7 A. B.R., 641; affirming in
re Anderson (1900), Dist. S- C, Brawley, J., 103 Fed., 854; 4 A. B. R.
640
Petition for exemptions reasonable so long as the estate remains in
such a condition that exemptions can be allowed. In re White (1900),
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed., 774; 4 A. B. R., 613; 3 N. B. N., 270.
An order setting apart homestead exemptions may be vacated during
the term at which entered. In re Mayer (1901) , C. C. A., 7th Cir., Woods,
J., 108 Fed., 599; 6 A. B. R., 117; 3 N. B. N., 592.
(12) [Discharge bankrupts..] Discharge or refuse to dis-
charge bankrupts and set aside discharges and reinstate the
cases ;
As to discharges, see Sections 14, 15 and 16, post, and notes. See also
Gen. Order XII, XXXI and Forms 57, 58 and 59. As to debts not affected
by discharge, see Sec. 17 post and notes.
(13) [Enforce orders.] Enforce obedience by bank-
rupts, officers, and other persons to all lawful orders, by fine
or imprisonment or fine and imprisonment ;
As to imprisonment for contempts before referees, see Sec. 41 post
and notes. Officers defined, Sec. 1 (18) and notes. Persons defined.
Sec. 1 (19) and notes.
Bankrupt committed for failure to pay tnistee fifteen himdred dollars
which the court found he had concealed. In re McCormick (1899), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 566; 3 A. B. R., 340; 2 N. B. N., 204.
Before commitment for contempt for disobedience to the orders of the
court wilfvil disobedience should be proved beyond a reasonable doubt.
In re McCormick (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 566; 3 A.
B. R., 340; 2 N. B. N., 204.
26 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2. (13)
In proceedings for contempt for failure to pay over money to the trus-
tee there should be an order to show cause and an application for hearing.
Bankrupt may be attached for failure to obey order to pay over. It
must appear that he has the money at the time he is ordered to turn it
over. In re Rosser (1900). C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 101 Fed., 562;
4 A. B. R., 153.
Imprisonment for contempt for failure to turn over money to a trust-
ee approved in re Schlesinger (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Shipman, J., 102
Fed., 117; 4 A. B. R., 361; 2 N. B. N., 169.
Ripon KnittingWorks v.Schreiber (1900), Dist. of Washington, Hand-
ford, J., 101 Fed., 810; 4 A. B. R., 299; 2 N B. N., 545.
No absolute order committing for contempt should issue before the
order to show cause. In re Rosser (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sandbom,
J., 101 Fed., 562; 4 A. B. R., 153.
In re Schlesinger (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Bro\\'n, J., 97 Fed., 930; 3 A.
B. R., 342; 2 N. B. N., 169.
Contempt proceedings enforcible against bankrupt for failure to turn
over goods found to be under his control by the referee. Proof, however,
should be convincing to justify the summary process. In re Mayer (1900) ,
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 97 Fed., 328; 3 A. B. R., 533; 2 N. B. N., 257.
Injunction — contempt for violating where only verbal notice of its
issuance is given. In re Krinsky Bros. (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., A Jams,
J., 112 Fed., 972; 7 A. B. R., 535.
Bankrupt committed to jail for failure to- surrender assets. In re
Wilson (1902), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 116 Fed., 419; 8 A. B. R., 612.
Bankrupt's ability to perform order must clearly appear. Boyd v.
GluckUch (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., 116 Fed., 131; 8 A. B. R., 393.
Power of committment should be cautiously exercised. In re Gottardi
et al. (1902), S. D. Cal., Wellborn, J., 114 Fed., 328.
Referee has power in first instance to make summary order for sur-
render of property — district court power under the bankruptcy act
and under general equity powers to commit the guilty party to jail.
Mueller v. Nugent (1902), U. S. Sup. Court, Fuller, J., 184 U. S., 18;
7 A. B. R., 224
Debtor must be discharged when it appears that he cannot siurender
concealed property. In re Taylor (1901), Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 114
Fed., 607; 7 A. B. R., 410.
Assignee of bankrupt fined for contempt. In re Krinsky (1902),
S. Dist. N. Y., 112 Fed., 972; 7 A. B. R., 535.
§2.(15)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY.— JURISDICTION. 27
(14) [Extradite bankrupts.] Extradite bankrupts from
their respective districts to other districts;
As to extradition of bankrupts, see Sec. 10 ante. As to removal of
accused from one district to another, see Sec. 1,014 R. S. U. S.
This is the same power defined more specifically in Sec. 10. In re
Ketchum (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Clark, J., 5 A. B. R., 532; 3 N. B. N.,
769.
(15) [Make orders.] Make such orders, issue such pro-
cess, and enter such judgments in addition to those specific-
ally provided for as may be necessary for the enforcement
of the provisions of this Act ;
For rules, forms and orders, see Sec. 30 and notes.
For discussion of jurisdiction see Sec. 23 and notes.
As to enforcement of orders, see Sec. 2 (13) and notes and Sec. 41.
As to jurisdiction of referees, see Sec. 38a (4) .
This section is sufficient to authorize holding bankrupt by writ of
ne exeat where section 9 (b) is insufficient. In re Lipke (1900) , S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 970; 3 A. B. R., 569; 2 N. B. N., 347.
A court of bankruptcy has power to adjudicate the validity of a
transfer of accounts and compel the surrender by the fraudulent assignee
thereof. In re Kerski (1899), E. Dist. Wis., Forward, R.; 2 A. B. R.,
79; 1 N. B. N., 328.
Bankruptcy Court has general equity powers to enforce orders. Muel-
ler V. Nugent (1902), U. S. Sup. Court, Fuller, J., 184 U. S., 18; 7 A. B. R.,
224. In re Wilson (1902), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 116 Fed., 419; 8
A. B. R., 612; In Gottardi et a/. (1902), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J.,
114 Fed., 328; In re Miller (1900), Nor. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 105 Fed., 57;
5 A. B. R., 184; 3 N. B. N., 329. Fisher v. Cushman (1900), C. C. A., 1st
Cir., Putnam, J., 103 Fed., 860; 4 A. B. R., 646. In re Diack (1900),
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 100 Fed., 770.
Power may be exercised by the referee in the first instance subject to
review by the judge. Mueller v. Nugent (1902), U. S. Sup. Ct., Fuller,
J., 184 U. S. 18; 7 A. B. R., 224; In re Miller (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 105 Fed., 57; 5 A. B. R., 184; 3 N. B. N., 329. In re Deuell (1900), W.
Dist. Mo., Philips, J., 100 Fed., 633; 4 A. B. R., 60. In re Mayer (1900),
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 98 Fed., 839; 3 A. B. R., 533. In r^McCormick
(1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 566. In re Purvine (1899),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Newman, J., 96 Fed., 192; 1 N. B. N., 326. In re Tudor
(1899), Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 96 Fed., 912; 1 N. B. N., 476; same case
28 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§2. (15)
(1900), 100 Fed., 796; 2 A. B. R., 808; In re Oliver (1899), N. Dist.Cal.,
De Haven, J., 96 Fed., 85; 2 A. B. R., 783; 1 N. B. N., 329. In re Coffman
(1899), N. Dist. Tex., Meek, J., 93 Fed., 422; 1 N. B. N., 326. In re Sapiro
(1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 92 Fed., 340; 1 A. B. R., 296; 1 N. B.
N., 136.
Filing of petition is in effect an attachment and injunction. In re
Krimsky (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 112 Fed., 972; 7 A. B. R.,
535; In r^Amett (1901), W. Dist Tenn, Hammond, J., 112 Fed., 770;7
A. B. R., 522.
' Order issued before trustee appointed, restraining removal of fixtures
from bankrupts' premises. In re Smith (1902), Nor. Dist. Ga., Newman,
J., 113 Fed., 993; 8 A. B. R., 55.
Bankruptcy Court may enjoin assignee under State law from parting
with assigned property. Rumsey, etc., v. Novelty, etc., Mfg. Co. (1899),
E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 99 Fed., 699; 3 A. B. R., 704; 2 N. B. N., 128;
In re GutwiUig (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 92 Fed., 337; 1
A. B. R., 388; 1 N. B. N., 554. In re Lea v. George M. West Co. (1899),
E. Dist. Va., Waddill, J., 91 Fed., 237; 1 A. B. R., 261; 1 N. B. N., 79.
Leidigh Carriage Co. v. Stengil (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 95 Fed.,
637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 296.
Bankruptcy Court has power to order assessment of stockholders for
impaid subscription to capital stock. In re Miller Electric Maintenance
Co. (1901), W. Dist., Pa., Buffington, 111 Fed., 515; 6 A. B. R., 701.
Section 2a gives full jurisdiction for examination, even though District
Court under Section 25e might not entertain the suit. In re Clifle (1899) ,
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 97 Fed., 540; 3 A. B. R., 257; 1 N. B. N., 509.
Examination may be had of a trustee under state court proceedings
appointed more than four months prior to bankruptcy touching his
doings. In re Purcell (1902), Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 114 Fed., 371;
8 A. B. R., 96.
Bankrupt ordered to pay over money held by him to the trustee. In
re Schlesinger (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 930; 3 A. B. R.,
342; 2 N. B. N., 169.
Bankrupt ordered to pay over money in his possession to trustee —
no deductions made for money spent in a debauch. In re Tudor (1899),
Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 100 Fed., 796; 2 A. B. R., 808; 1 N. B. N., 476.
In re Henschel (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R.; 7 A. B. R., 207. In
re Shera (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 114 Fed., 207; 7 A. B. R
552.
Orders may be vacated at any time without regard to terms, unless
rights have vested thereunder. In re Ives (1902), C.C. A., 6th Cir.,
Wanty, J., 113 Fed., 911; 7 A. B. R., 692.
§2.(18)] COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. 29
Order should be based on motion or petition for precise purpose. In
re Lemon, , etc., Co. (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Day, J., 112 Fed., 296;
7 A. B. R., 291.
Bankruptcy Court of New York ordered trust company of Philadel-
phia to pay money held for the bankrupt, but attached by a creditor to
the receiver in bankruptcy and fined the company for contempt for non-
compliance. The Pennsylvania District Coiu-t entered ancillary order
enforcing the payment. In re Peiser (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson,
J., 115 Fed., 199; 7 A. B. R., 690.
(16) [Punish contempts before referees.] Punish persons
for contempts committed before referees ;
As to procedure in contempt proceedings, see Sec. 41, post, and notes.
Bankrupt's exemption from arrest does not extend to arrest for contempt.
Sec. 9a. ,
(17) [Appoint and remove trustees.] Pursuant to the
recommendation of creditors, or when they neglect to rec-
ommend the appointment of trustees, appoint trustees, and
upon complaints of creditors, remove trustees for cause upon
hearings and after notices to them ;
As to appointment of trustee, see Sec. 44, post. As to qualification
and duties of trustee, see Sec. 45 and notes. As to Removal of Trustee,
see Sec. 46. Judge must approve appointment of trustee and he only
can remove. Gen. Order XIII. No official or general trustee to be
appointed. Gen. Ord. XIV. As to when coiirt may order appointment
of trustee, see Gen. Ord. XV. As to Notice of appointment, see Gen.
Ord. XVI. Forms No. 22-24, notice of appointment. Trustees not
appointed in certain cases. Gen. Ord. XV. Order that no trustee be ap-
pointed. _ Form No. 27.
(18) [Tax costs.] Tax costs, whenever they are allowed
by law, and render judgments therefor against the unsuc-
cessful party, or the successful party for cause, or in part
against each of the parties, and against estates, in pro-
ceedings in bankruptcy ; and.
As to costs of preserving' estate and administration, see Sec. 64b. As
to costs against creditor when involuntary petition is dismissed, Sec. 3e.
Attorney's fee taxable as part of costs of administration, Sec. 64b (3).
Costs may be proved as a claim against estate. Sec. 63a (3). As to cost,
in contested cases, see Gen. Order XXXIV.
30 COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY. — JURISDICTION. [§ 2. (19)
Referee's jurisdiction as to, taxation of costs discussed and upheld
In re Scott (1902), Dist. Mass., Olmstead, R., 7 A. B. R., 710.
Costs of storing personal property sustained by a creditor while hold-
ing the property subject to a lien which is dissolved by an adjudication
in bankruptcy not taxable against the estate, but provable as a claim.
In re Allen (1899), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 96 Fed., 512.
When intervening creditor unsuccessful and property levied on is sur-
rendered and sold the costs of caring for it in the interim will not be taxed
against the creditor, though all the witness fees may be so taxed. In re
Caroline Cooperage Co. (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 96 Fed.. 604;
1 N. B. N., 534.
Reference to a referee on questions arising from opposition to dis-
charge is in effect to a special master and costs for the services as such
may be taxed in favor of referee as special master. Fellows v. Freuden-
thal (1900) ; C. C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 731; 4 A. B. R., 490;
3 N. B. N., 97.
(19) [Transfer cases.] Transfer cases to other .courts
of bankruptcy.
Judge may for cause at any time transfer cases from one referee to an-
other, Sec. 22 (b). As to petitions in different districts, see Gen. Ord.
VI. Where cases transferred compensation of referees is apportioned,
Sec. 40b. and notes.
[Unspecified powers.] Nothing in this section contained
shall be construed to deprive a court of bankruptcy of any
power it would possess were certain specific powers not
herein enumerated.
See ante Sec. 2 (15).
Bankruptcy Court may order reference to special master as in ordinary
equity practice. Fellows v. Freudenihal (1900) , C. C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman,
J., 102 Fed., 731; 4 A. B. R., 490; 3 N. B. N., 97.
CHAPTER III.
BANKRUPTS.
Sec. 3. Acts op bankruptcy.
a.
(1) Conveyances to defraud.
(2) Preferences through transfers.
(3) Preferences through legal pro-
ceedings.
(4) Made general assignment.
(5) Admitted inability to pay.
b. Petition must be filed within
four months.
c. Defense of solvency — burden
of proof.
d. Person denying insolvency.
e. Petitioner to give bond. Al-
lowance of costs and damages.
Sec. 4. Who May Become Bank-
rupts.
a. Voluntary bankrupt.
b. Involtmtary bankrupts.
Sec. 5. Partners.
a. Partnership may be adjudged
bankrupt.
6. Administration of partnership
estate.
c. Jurisdiction over one partner
sufficient.
d. Trustee keep separate accounts
of partnership and individual
property
€. Apportionment of expenses.
jF. Payment of debts — disposi-
tion of surplus.
g. Partnership claims against in-
dividual estate.
h. Where all partners are not
bankrupt.
Sec. 6. Exemptions of Bank-
rupts.
a. Exemptions allowed.
Sec. 7. Duties of Bankrupt.
(1) Attend meetings of creditors.
(2) Comply with orders.
(3) Examine proofs of claims.
(4) Execute papers.
(5) Transfer property to trustee.
(6) Give trustee information.
(7) Inform trustee of false claim.
(8) File schedules.
(9) Attend meetings of creditors
and submit to examination.
Sec. 8. Death or Insanity of
Bankrupt.
a. Proceedings not to abate.
31
Sec. 9. Protection and Deten-
tion OF Bankrupts.
a. Bankrupt exempt from arrest.
(1) Not exempt for con-
tempt.
(2) Where discharge not re-
lease.
c. Detention of bankrupt for
examination.
Sec. 10. Extradition of Bank-
rupts.
Sec. 11. Suits by and against
Bankrupts.
a. Stay until adjudication.
b. Appearance of trustee.
c. Trustee may prosecute.
d. Suits against estate within
two years.
Sec. 12. Compositions When
Confirmed.
a When composition may be
offered.
6. Application for confirmation.
c. Date for hearing.
d. Conditions of confirmance.
(1) Best interests of credi-
tors.
(2) Bankrupt entitled to dis-
charge.
(3) Must not be collusion.
e. Distribution of assets.
Sec. 13. Compositions when set
ASIDE.
a. May be set aside,''when.
Sec. 14. Discharges, when
GRANTED.
a. Application for discharge.
6. Hearing of application.
(1) Committing an offense
bars discharge.
(2) Destroying books bars
discharge.
c. Confirmation of composition
discharges from debts.
Sec. 15. Discharges, when Re-
voked.
Co-debtors of Bank-
rupts.
Debts not affected by
discharge.
Taxes.
Judgment for frauds, etc.
Claims not scheduled.
Created by fraud.
Sec. 16.
Sec. 17.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
32 acts of bankruptcy. [§ 3 a
Section 3. Bankrupts.
(3) [Acts of bankruptcy.] a Acts of bankruptcy by a
person shall consist of his having
As to acts of bankruptcy under Act of 1867, see Sec. 39 of that act
post, Sec. 1 of Act of 1841, post, also Sec. 1 of Act of 1800.
Insolvency is not a feature of the acts of bankruptcy. In re West
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 108 Fed., 940; 5 A. B. R., 734.
(1) [Conveyances to defraud.] Conveyed, transferred, con-
cealed, or removed, or permitted to be concealed or removed,
any part of his property with intent to hinder, delay, or
defraud his creditors, or any of them ; or
See post (2) (3) and (4) with notes. For definition of "transierred"
see ante Sec. 1 (25) ; of "concealed" see Sec. 1 (22) ante.
Flight of bankrupt with property is both a concealment and a removal
of property w^ith intent to defraud creditors and is an act of bankruptcy.
In re Filer (1900), S Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 108 Fed., 209; 5 A. B.
R., 332.
This is the same as fraudulent transfer at common law. Githens v.
Shiffler (1902), Middle Dist. Penn., Archbald, J., 112 Fed., 505; 7 A. B.
R., 453.
Intention to prefer not same as intention to defraud. Githens v.
Shiffler (1902), Middle Dist. Penn., Archbald, J., 112 Fed., 505; 7A
B. R., 453.
Debtor who absconds with property guilty of intent to defraud. In
re Filer (1900), S Dist. N.Y ., 108 Fed., 209; 5 A. B. R., 332.
Voluntary transfer to a trustee without preference an act of bank-
ruptcy vmder this clause. Runisey, etc., Co. v. Novelty Mfg. Co. (1899),
E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 99 Fed., 699; 3 A. B. R., 704.
Failure of partner to oppose application for receiver does not render
them chargeable tmder this section. Vaccaro v. Security Bank (1900),
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Lurton, J., 103 Fed., 436; 4 A. B. R., 474; 2 N. B. N.
1,037.
Consent to receivership without preference is an act of bankruptcy.
Davis v. Stevens (1900), Dist. S. Da., Garland, J., 104 Fed., 235; 4 A.B
R., 763; 3 N. B. N., 131.
Allowing receiver to be appointed in State court not act of bankruptcy.
In re Baker- Ricketson (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 97 Fed., 489; 4
A. B. R., 605; 2 N. B. N., 133.
§ 3 a. (2)] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 33
Chattel mortgage more than a year old does not bring one giving it
under this section. Asbury Park Bldg., etc., v. Shepherd (1901), Sup. Ct.
N. J., 50 Atl., 65.
Transfer by an insane person not an act of bankruptcy. In re Funk
(1900), N. Dist. Iowa, Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 244.
Petitioning creditors need not prove insolvency under this clause.
In re West (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 108 Fed., 940; 5 A.
B. R., 734.
Petition need not allege details of concealment. In re Bellah, Dist.
Del., Bradford, J. (1902), 116 Fed., 69; 8 A. B. R., 310.
Corporation applying for receiver more than four months before
bankruptcy not under this clause. In re Harper & Bro (1900), S D.
N. Y., Brown, J., 100 Fed., 266; 2 N. B. N., 605.
Withdrawal of money by partner from insolvent firm not an act of
bankruptcy. In re Shapiro (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 106 Fed.,
495; 5 A. B. R., 839.
(2) [Preference by transfer.] Transferred, while insol-
vent, any portion of his property to one or more of his cred-
itors with intent to prefer such creditors over his other
creditors; or
Transfer more than four months old by a corporation not act of bank-
ruptcy tmder this section. Citizen's Bank v. W . C. T>e Pauw Co. (1901)
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Grosscup, J., 105 Fed., 926; 5 A. B. R., 345.
T\Tien transfer of property a preference. Sec. 60a post. Trustee may
recover property transferred when transfer a preference. Sec. 60 d. post.
As to when a person is insolvent, see ante Sec. 1, sub. (15), and notes.
See also ani^ Sec. 1, Sub. (22).
"Transfer" defined. Sec. 1 (25) ante, and notes. Trustee takes title to
property transferred, Sec. 70a (5) .
Transfer by insolvent to secure a creditor either directly or indirectly
constitutes an act of bankruptcy. Goldman, Beckman & Co. v. Smith
(1899) , Dist. of Ky., Barr, J., 93 Fed., 182; 1 A. B. R., 266; 1 N. B. N., 160.
Burden of proving insolvency not on the creditors under this section,
but btirden on bankrupt to prove solvency. In re West (1901) ; C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 108 Fed., 940; 5 A. B. R., 734.
Conveyance of personal property by an insolvent to a creditor to pay
a debt is an act of bankruptcy. Johnson v. Wold (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., Shelb/, Judge, 93 Fed., 640; 2 A. B. R., 84; 1 N. B. N., 325.
34 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3a. (2)
The insolvency must be found to be as of the date of the act of bank
ruptcy. In re Rome Planing Mill (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J„
96 Fed., 812; 3 A. B. R., 123; 2 N. B. N., 531.
Transfer may consist of sale of assets and payment of certain creditors
therewith. Boyd v. Lemon Gale Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee,
J., 114 Fed., 647; 8 A. B. R., 81.
Transferring property to a creditor on which the creditor pays a sum
as balance in favor of transferror, is a fraudulent preference and an act
of bankruptcy. Intent to make a preference will be presumed. John-
son V. Wold (1899), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby ,J., 93 Fed., 640; 2 A. B. R.,
84; 1 N. B. N., 325.
Conveying property and paying off part of the creditors comes under
this clause. In re Mingo Valley Creamery Assn. (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
McPherson, J., 100 Fed., 282; 4 A. B. R., 67; 2 N. B. N., 679.
A person is insolvent when the aggregate of his property exclusive
of that conveyed in fraud of creditors, is insufficient at a fair valuation
to pay his debts. In re Rome Planing Mill Co. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 99 Fed., 937; 3 A. B. R., 123.
Transfer is within the meaning of the law no matter how devious the
transaction if creditor acquires from the debtor what ought to be dis-
tributed under Bankruptcy Act among all the creditors. Stern v. Louis-
ville Trust Co. (1901); C. C. A., 6th Cir., Severens, J., 112 Fed., 501; 7 A. B.
R., 305. In re McCee (1901), N. Dist. of N. Y., Coxe, J., 105 Fed.,
895; 5 A. B. R., 262. In re Lange (1899), N. Dist. of la., Shiras, J., 97
Fed., 197; 1 A. B. R., 189; 1 N. B. N., 60. Goldman, Beckman & Co. v
Smith (1899), Dist. of Ky., Barr, J., 93 Fed., 182; 1 A. B. R., 266; 1 N. B.
N., 160. Mather v. Goe (1899), N. Dist Ohio, Ricks, J., 92 Fed., 333 1.
A. B. R., 504; 1 N. B. N., 554. Smarts v. St. Louis Fourth National Bank
(1902); C. C. A., 8th Cir., 117 Fed., 1; 8 A. B. R., 673.
Transfers not held acts of bankruptcy. Union etc. Mfg. Co. (1902).
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 112 Fed., 774; 7 A. B. R., 472. Rumsey etc;
Co. v. Novelty etc. Mfg. Co. (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 99 Fed., 699,
3 A. B. R., 704. ' Sabin v. Camp (1900), Dist. Ore., Billinger, J., 98 Fed.,
974; 3 A. B. R., 578; 2 N. B. N., 375. In re Little River Lumber Co. (1899)
W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 92 Fed., 585; 1 A. B. R., 483; 1 N. B. N, 306.
An insolvent giving a mortgage to secure a preexisting indebtedness
commits act of bankruptcy. In re Ed. Wright Lumber Co. (1902), W.
Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 114 Fed., 1,011.
Where there is no other creditor with provable claim transfer is not
an act of bankntptcy. Beers v. Hanlin (1900), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J.,
99 Fed. 695; 3 A. B. R., 745; 3 N. B. N., 749.
§3 a. (2)] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 35
Conveyance to father-in-law held a transfer. In re Grant (1901) , S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 106 Fed., 496; 5 A. B. R., 837.
Transfer of partnership property not act of bankruptcy where indi-
vidual estate stifficient to satisfy debts. Vaccaro v. Security Bank (1900) ;
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Lurton. J., 103 Fed., 436; 4 A. B. R., 474; 2 N. B. N..
1,037.
Petitioning creditors must prove insolvency, transfer and intent. In
re Rome Planing Mill Co. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J.. 96 Fed., 812;
3 A. B. R., 123; 2 N. B. N., 531.
Intent to prefer must appear. In re Gilbert (1902) , Dist. Ore., Bellin-
ger, J., 112 Fed., 951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
Test of preference is one member of a class of creditors receiving more
than another. Swarts v. St. Louis Fourth Nat. Bank (1902), C. C. A., 8th
Cir., Sanborn, J., 117 Fed., 1; 8 A. B. R., 673.
Transfer of large part of property conclusive evidence of intent. In re
McGee (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 105 Fed., 895; 3 N. B. N., 224.
Full payment by insolvent firm to several creditors, leaving others
tmpaid, sufiicient proof. Boyd v. Lemon etc. Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., Pardee, J., 114 Fed., 647; 8 A. B. R., 81.
Amount of transfer affects presimiption. In re Gilbert (1902), Dist
Ore., BeUinger, J., 112 Fed., 951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
The intent is entirely that of the debtor. In re Rome Planing Mill
Co. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 96 Fed., 812; 3 A. B. R., 123; 2 N.
B. N., 531.
Payment by an insolvent debtor operating as a preference is prima
facie evidence that a preference was intended- In re Bloch (1901), C.
C. A.. 2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 109 Fed., 790; 6 A. B. R., 300; 3 N. B.
N., 894.
Transfer while insolvent presumes preference. In re Schmechel Cloak
etc. Co. (1900), W. Dist. Mo., Philips, J., 104 Fed., 64; 4 A. B. R., 719;
3 N. B. N., 110. yohnsonv. Wald (1899), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 93 Fed., 640;
2 A. B. R., 84; 1 N. B. N., 325.
Debtor is presumed to know his financial condition. In re Gilbert;
(1902), Dist. Ore., BeUinger, J., 112 Fed., 951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
(3) [Preference through legal proceedings.] Suffered or
permitted, while insolvent, any creditor to obtain a prefer-
ence through legal proceedings, and not having at least
five days before a sale or final disposition of any property
36 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3a. (3)
affected by such preference vacated or discharged such
preference ; or
As to meaning of "insolvent" see ante Sec. 1, Sub. (15) and notes.
Preference defined Sec. 60 post, and notes.
Confession of judgment on note made prior to the passage of the
Bankruptcy Act not an act of bankruptcy. In re Nelson (1899), W.
Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 98 Fed., 76; 1 A. B. R., 63; 1 N. B. N., 301.
The intent of the bankrupt is not an element — fact of judgment and
execution sufficient to warrant proceedings. In re Reichman (1899),
E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 91 Fed., 624; 1 A. B. R., 17; 1 N. B. N., 556.
In re Meyers (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 1 A. B. R., 1; 1 N. B.
N., 293.
Partnership commencing proceedings for appointment of receiver and
distribution of assets under a State insolvency law guilty of an act of
bankruptcy. Mather v. Coe (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks, J., 92 Fed.,
333; 1 A. B. R., 504; 1 N. B. N., 554.
Failure to pay matured judgment' notes, on which jud£;ments were
taken and levy made, is an act of bankruptcy. In re Thomas (1900),
W. Dist. Pa., Buflington, J., 103 Fed., 272; 4 A. B. R., 571; 2 N. [B.
N., 1,021.
A corporation suffering execution commits an act of bankruptcy which
cannot be avoided by taking volvmtary action for a dissolution. In re
Storm (1900), , E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 103 Fed., 618; 4 A. B
R., 601.
Assignment of part of claim of money due by municipality more than
fovu* months before action is not an act of bankruptcy. In re Hanna &
Kirk (1901), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 105 Fed., 587;',5 A. B. R., 127;
3 N. B. N., 237.
A payment to officer by execution defendant is such a levy as con-
stitutes an act of bankruptcy. In re Miller (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel,
J., 105 Fed., 57; 5 A. B. R., 140.
A preferred creditor may qualify to file petition by surrendering pref-
erence. In re Miller (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 105 Fed., 57; 5
A. B. R., 140.
A transfer with a preferential intent may be made through a third
person and still be an act of bankruptcy. In re McGee (1901), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 105 Fed., 895; 5 A. B. R., 262; 3 N. B. N., 224.
Where concealment is alleged as an act of bankruptcy, actual conceal-
ment must be shown, not merely concealment of the consideration.
Citizens Bank v. W. C. De Paiiw Co. (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Grosscup.
J., 105 Fed., 926; 5 A. B. R., 345; 3 N. B. N., 244.
§3a. (3)] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 37
Insolvency at time of preferential levy must be shown to sustain ac-
tion to recover from creditor-r-insolvency after the levy and caused by
it not adequate. Chicago Title & Trust Co. v. Roehlings Sons (1901),
Cir. Ct. N. Dist. of Illinois, Kohlsaat, J., 107 Fed., 71; 5 A. B. R., 368;
3 N. B. N., 354.
Act of bankruptcy committed by suffering a judgment and garnish-
ment thereon. In re Harper (1900), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 105 Fed.,
900; 5 A. B. R., 567.
Appearing as parties to a suit in State court and consenting to the ap-
pointment of a receiver, which proceeding works a preference is an act of
bankruptcy. Such proceedings no bar to proceedings in bankruptcy.
In re Kersten & Kersten (1901), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 110 Fed., 929;
6A.B. R., 516;3N. B. N., 913.
Suffering a receiver to be appointed is not an act of bankruptcy.
In re Baker, Ricketson Co. (1899), Dist. of Mass., Lowell, J., 97 Fed.
489; 4 A. B. R., 605; 2 N. B. N., 133.
Voluntary application for a receiver by a corporation is equivalent
to a general assignment and an act of bankruptcy. In re Empire, etc.,
Co. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.. Hotchkiss, R., 98 Fed., 981; 1 A. B. R., 136;
1 N. B. N., 301.
Preferences obtained by application for receivership by members
of insolvent firm "suffered or permitted" within this section. In re Ker-
sten (1901), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 110 Fed., 926; 6 A. B. R., 516;
3 N. B. N., 913.
The voluntary application by a corporation under the New York stat-
ute for a receiver, is equivalent to making a general assignment (full dis-
cussion of the purposes of the act) . In re Empire Metallic Bedstead Co.
(1899), No. Dist. N. Y.., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 136; 1 N. B. N., 13.
(Reversed see post.)
Stipulation for the appointment of a receiver in the State Court, in ad-
verse proceedings, followed by a transfer of assets is not act of bank-
ruptcy if in fact the bankrupt does not know he is insolvent. Expe-
diency of considering a transfer of a small part of the estate as an act
of bankruptcy doubted. In re Gilbert (1901), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J.,
112 Fed., 951; 8. A. B. R., 101.
Act of bankruptcy not committed by voluntary application by cor-
poration for receiver in state court — this is not equivalent to a general
assignment. In re Empire Met. Bedstead Co. (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
Shipman, J., 98 Fed., 981; 3 A. B. R., 575; 2 N. B. N., 304.
Appointment of receiver of corporation on volvmtary application not
an act of bankruptcy. In re Harper & Bros. (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 100 Fed., 266; 3 A. B. R., 804; 2 N. B. N., 605.
38 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3a. (3)
Stipulation for the appointment of a receiver of a firm not an act of
bankruptcy. In re Gilbert (1902), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 112 Fed..
951; 8 A. B. R., 101.
The petition must allege that preferential payments were made with
intent to prefer. In re Ewing (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 115 Fed., 707;
8A. B. R.,269.
This section does not apply to enforcing a lien of a mortgage given
more than five months prior to the filing of the petition. In re Chapman
(1900), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 99 Fed., 395; 3 A. B. R., 607.
Where a receiver is appointed in the State court of the property of a
copartnership, and the operation of the State statute is to give preferences
not given by the bankruptcy act, an act of bankruptcy has been com-
mitted. Mather v. Coe, Powers & Co. (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks, J.
92 Fed., 333; 1 A. B. R., 504; 1 N. B. N., 544.
The intent of the bankrupt is involved. Act of bankruptcy complete
if proceedings are had, or a preference given while solvent, but insolvent
when the judgment is secured. In re Moyer, E. Dist. Pa., McPherson,
J., 93 Fed., 188; 1 A. B. R., 577; 1 N. B. N., 260.
This section does not apply to such levies and liens as have accrued
long prior to the passage of the bankruptcy act. In re Ferguson (1899),
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 95 Fed., 429; 2 A. B. R., 586.
Time of act of bankruptcy dates from five days anterior to date of sale
of property on execution under an attachment commenced long anterior
to four months. Parmenier Mfg. Go. v. Stoever (1899), C. C. A., 1st Cir.,
Putnam, J., 97 Fed., 330; 3 A. B. R., 220; 2 N. B. N., 174.
Proceedings to recover property seized by marshal should be by mo-
tion or by plenary suit in the discretion of the court. In re Yoimg (1901) ,
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Ill Fed., 158; 7 A. B. R., 14.
Intent of the bankrupt no feature of the act of bankruptcy. The
entry of judgment by confession on an old power of attorney is "suffering"
and "permitting" within the meaning of the act. Wilson Bros. v. Nelson
(1901), U. S. Sup. Court, Gray, J., 183 U. S., 191; 7 A. B. R., 142.
Burden of proof of solvency is on the .bankrupt when the allegation
shows concealment of money greater than the indebtedness of the bank-
rupt. In re Schenkein & Coney (1902), W Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss,
R.,7A. B. R., 162.
Actual results of legal proceedings only considered. In re Fergeson
(1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 95 Fed., 429; 2 A. B. R., ,586. In re
Moyer (1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 93 Fed., 188; 1 A. B. R., 577.
In re Reichman (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 91 Fed.. 624; 1 A. B. R.,
17; 1 N. B .N., 556. In re Chapman (1900), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J.,
§3 a. (3) ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 3d
99 Fed., 395; 2 A. B. R., 607; in re Baker-Ricketson (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 97 Fed., 489; 2 N. B. N.. 133; in re Harper (1900), N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat, J., 105 Fed., 900; 5 A. B. R., 567.
"Legal proceedings" means any proceedings in a cotirt of justice by
which the property of the debtor is seized and diverted from his general
creditors. In re Rome Planing Mill (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J.,
96 Fed., 812; 3 A. B. R., 123; 2 N. B. N., 531.
Corporation held to have committed act of bankruptcy within this
section. Scheuer v. Smith, etc., Co. (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J.,
112 Fed., 407; 7 A. B. R., 384.
Preferences must have been "suffered or permitted," failure of a debtor
to vacate a preference does not constitute an act of bankruptcy imder
this section. Dtmcan v. Landis (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 106
Fed., 839; 5 A. B. R., 649; 3 N. B. N., 673.
Actual levy on property not necessary. In re Miller (1900), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 764; 5 A. B. R., 140.
Failure to defend actions and allowing executions is an act of bank-
ruptcy. In re CHffe (1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 94 Fed., 354;
2 A. B. R., 317; 1 N. B. N., 509.
Creditor need not wait for sale. In re Rome Planing Mill (1899) , N.
Dist. N.Y., Coxe, J., 96 Fed., 812; 3 A. B.R., 123; 2 N. B. N., 531. In re
Elmira Steel Co. (1901), W. Dist. N. Y, Hazel, J., 109 Fed., 456; 5 A.
B. R., 484.
Act of bankruptcy in not vacating execution within time, Parmenter
Mfg. Co. V. Stoever (1899), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 97 Fed., 330;
3 A. B. R., 220; 2 N. B. N., 174.
Corporation appljHng for dissolution and permitting judgments guilty
of act of bankruptcy. In re Storm (1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J.,
103 Fed., 618; 4 A. B. R., 601.
Execution and levy act of bankruptcy. In re Thomas (1900) , W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 103 Fed., 272; 4 A. B. R., 571; 2 N. B. N., 1,021.
Judgment on warrant of attorney an act of bankruptcy. In re Nelson
(1899), W. Dist. Wis., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 76; 1 A. B. R., 63; 1 N. B. N.,
567.
Judgment on irrevocable power of attorney several years old unvacated
an act of bankruptcy. Wilson v. Nelson (1901), U. S. Sup. Ct., Gray,
J., 183 U. S., 191; 7 A. B. R., 142.
There must be voluntary acquiescence on the part of the debtor. Dun-
can v. Landis (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 106 Fed., 839; 5 A. B. R.,
649; 3 N. B. N., 673.
40 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3a. (4)
(4) [General Assignment.] Made a general assignment
for the benefit of his creditors, * or being insolvent
applied for a receiver for his property or because of insolvency
a receiver or trustee has been put in charge of his property
under the laws of a State, of a Temtor>% or of the United
States*
As amended by act of 1903, Sec. 2 of amendment, see pagre — post. Amendment
adds matter between stars.
General assignment is an act of bankruptcy and insolvency of the bank-
rupt not a feature essential to the adjudication - construction of the
remaining parts of Sec. 3 (b) (c) and (d) does not require insolvency to
accompany the act of bankruptcy; motive of assignment not to be consid-
ered. West Co. V. Lea & Co. (1899), U. S. Sup. Ct., White, J., 174 U. S.,
590. 2 A. B. R., 463;1 N. B. N., 409. In re Meyer (1899), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Wallace, J., 98 Fed., 976; 3 A. B. R., 559. Leidigh Carriage Co. v.
Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 95 Fed., 637; 2 A. B. R., 383;
1 N. B. N., 296. Davis v.Bohle (1899), C. C. A., 8th Cir., 92 Fed., 325;
1 A. B. R., 412; 1 N. B. N., 216. In re Smith (1899). Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
92 Fed., 135; 2 A. B. R., 9. Clark v. American Mfg. Co. (1900) , C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Waddell, J ., 101 Fed., 962; 4 A. B. R., 351. Day v. Bick etc. Hardware
Co. (1902) , C. C. A., 5th Cir., 114 Fed., 834; 8 A. B. R., 175; Bryan v. Bern-
heimer (1901), 181 U. S., 188; 5 A. B. R., 623; 3 N. B. N., 482. Green River
Deposit Bank v. Craig (1901), W. Dist. Ky., '" .ns, J., 110 Fed., 137;
6 A. B. R., 381; 3 N. B. N., 897.
General assignment of majority of directors and stockholders of cor-
poration is an act of bankruptcy. Question of fact in involuntary bank-
ruptcy referable to a referee. Clark v. Mfg. & Enameling Co. (1900);
C. C. A., 4th Cir., Waddell, J., 101 Fed., 962; 4 A. B. R., 351.
General assignment an act of bankruptcy. State general assignment
law not void but voidable by the act. The New York law not a general
insolvency law like that of Mass. A general assignment an act of bank-
ruptcy as a fraud under the bankruptcy act. The assignee is an accom-
plice and the title of the property passes to the trustee on his appoint-
ment. In re GutwiUig (1898), Brown, J., S. Dist. N. Y., 90 Fed., 475;
1 A. B. R., 78; 1 N. B. N., 40.
A general assignment is an act of bankruptcy, although not accom-
panied by insolvency. Leidigh, etc., Co. v. Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., opinion by Taft, J., 95 Fed., 637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 387.
Creditors who appear in general assignment proceedings to attack
preferences are not estopped from filing petition for involuntary bank-
ruptcy. Estoppel must be based on some acquiescence and approval.
§3 a. (5)] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 41
Leidigh, etc., Co. v. Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 95 Fed.,
637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 296.
Assignment vinder State law held not an act of bankruptcy. See
authorities discussing distinction between State insolvency laws and
statutes permitting general assignments collected and discussed. Patty-
Joiner Co. V. Cummins (1900), Tex. Sup. Ct., Gaines, J., 4 A. B. R., 269;
57 S. W., 566.
Executing a deed of trust, which in general effect operates as a general
assignment, is an act of bankruptcy. Rumsey Co. v. Novelty Mfg Co.
(1899), E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 99 Fed., 699; 3 A. B. R., 704; 2 N. B.
N., 128.
A general insolvency law is suspended by the bankruptcy act and
proceedings under it are void, not merely voidable. Law of Illinois
governing insolvency proceedings held to be a general insolvency law.
In re Curtis (1899), S. Dist. 111., Allen, J., 91 Fed., 737; 1 A. B. R., 440;
1 N. B. N., 163.
A general assignment is voidable, not void, and can be avoided only
by a subseqvient adjudication in bankruptcy. In re Romanow (1899),
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 92 Fed., 510; 1 A. B. R., 461.
Creditors assenting to the general assignment estopped to file petition
for involuntary bankruptcy, based on such assignment as an act of bank-
ruptcy. In re Romanow (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 92 Fed., 510; 1
A. B. R., 461.
Where partnership and individual members make an assignment,
act of bankruptcy is committed by all of them. Green River Deposit
Bank V. Craig (1901), W. Dist. of Ky., Evans, J., 110 Fed., 137; 6 A. B.
R., 381; 3 N. B. N., 897.
Assignment by all but one member of partnership where other member
assents, act of bankruptcy. In re Grant (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 106 Fed., 496; 5 A. B. R., 837; 3 N. B. N., 425.
or (5) [Admitted inability to pay.] Admitted in writing
his inability to pay his debts and his willingness to be ad-
judged a bankrupt on that ground.
See Sec. 4 post, and notes. See notes to (4) ante.
Sufficient admission of insolvency shown by letter of bankrupt offer,
ing compromise of claims. In re Lange (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown
J., 91 Fed., 361; 3 A. B. R., 231; 1 N. B. N., 60.
Consent by a corporation is an act of bankruptcy. In re Kelly Dry
Goods Co. (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 747; 4 A. B. R.,
42 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. t§^t>.
628. In re Columbia Real Estate Co. (1900), Dist. of Ind., Baker J.,
101 Fed., 965; 4 A. B. R., 411.
A corporation whose board of directors adopts a resolution authoriz-
ing its president to address letters to its creditors admitting its inability to
pay debts, and its willingness to be adjudged a bankrupt, and whose
president writes letters to its creditors to that eflfect, is guilty of an act of
bankruptcy. In re Machine & Conveyor Co. (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91 Fed., 630; 1 A. B. R., 421; 1 N. B. N., 135.
Act of bankruptcy not shown by appointment of receiver of a firm,
although with the firm's consent — it is not a general assignment — in-
solvency not shown where one partner's estate sufficient to pay firm
debts — semhle such receivership might be merged in bankruptcy proceed-
ings if other acts of bankruptcy were committed by the insolvent. Vac-
caro v. Security Bank et al. (1900), C. C. A., 6th Cir., 103 Fed., 436; 4 A.
B. R., 474; 2 N. B. N., 1,037.
Admission by a corporation not shown by a resolution authorizing an
officer to make such admission when the officer makes it in writing after
the petition in bankruptcy has been filed. In re Baker- Rickertson Co.
(1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 97 Fed., 489; 4 A. B. R., 605; 2 N. B. N.,
133.
Query: Can a wife make the admission ? In re Peter Paul Book Co.
(1900), W, Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 786; 5 A. B. R., 105.
Consent by corporation is an act of bankruptcy. In re Kelly Dry
Gk)ods Co. (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J , 102 Fed., 747; 4 A. B R.,
528.
Admission by one partner of a firm of insolvency of firm is an act of
bankruptcy. In re Kersten & Kersten (1901), E. Dist. Wis., 110 Fed.,
929; 6 A. B. R., 516; 3 N. B. N., 913.
Admission signed by the president of a corporation by order of board
of directors, an act of bankruptcy. In re Mutual Mercantile Agency
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., Ill Fed., 152; 6 A. B. R., 607
Board of directors of a corporation may make the admission. In re
Rollins Gold, etc., Min. Co. (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J , 102 Fed.
982; 4 A. B. R., 327.
The consent of a corporation to be adjudged bankrupt valid. In re
Columbia Real Estate Co. (1900), Dist. of Ind., Baker, J., 101 Fed., 965;
4 A. B. R., 411.
h [Petition to be filed within four montlis.] A petition
may be filed against a person who is insolvent and who has
committed an act of bankruptcy within four months after
§3b.] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 43
the commission of such act. Such time shall not expire
until four months after (1) the date of the recording or
registering of the transfer or assignment when the act con-
sists in having made a transfer of any of his property with
intent to hinder, delay, or defraud his creditors or for the
ptirpose of giving a preference as hereinbefore provided, or a
general assignment for the benefit of his creditors, if by
law such recording' or registering is required or permitted,
or, if it is not, from the date when the beneficiary takes
notorious, exclusive, or continuous possession of the property
unless the petitioning creditors have received actual notice
of such transfer or assignment.
As to computation of time see Sec. 31a post and notes.
"Transfer" defined Sec. 1 (25) ante. As to what are acts of bank-
ruptcy, see ante (a). As to procedure in involuntary cases, see Sec. 59
post. For definition of insolvency Sec. 1 (15) ante and notes. Petition
defined. Sec. 1 (20) ante. Person defined. Sec. 1 (19) ante.
Petition shoiild be verified by creditor, not by attorney unless the at-
torney is better informed than the client. Specific facts must be alleged,
not general allegations. In re Nelson (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J.,
98 Fed., 76; 1 A. B. R., 63; 1 N. B. N., 567.
In the computation of time, exclude the day when the act of bank-
ruptcy was committed and include the day when the petition was filed.
In re Stevenson (1899), Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B.
R., 66; 1 N. B. N., 313.
The notoriety of the possession depends on the character of the prop-
erty. The statute only requires that there shall be no effort at conceal-
ment. In re Woodward (1899), E. Dist. Tex., Dillard, R., 2 A. B. R.,
233; 1 N. B. N., 252.
Referee's finding as to the insolvency not disturbed, except on strong
showing. In re Rome Planing Mills (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J.,
96 Fed., 812; 3 A. B. R., 766; 2 N. B. N., 531.
Wife as creditor not debarred from proceeding against her husband
in bankruptcy. In re Novak (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed..
800; 4 A. B. R., 311.
What constitutes insolvency determined. In re Rome Planing Mill
Co. (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 99 Fed., 937; 3 A. B. R., 766; 2
N. B. N., 531.
44 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3c.
Creditor of unliquidated claim for damages not entitled to file a peti-
tion in involuntary bankruptcy. In re Morales (1901), S. Dist. Fla.,
Locke, J., 105 Fed., 761; 5 A. B. R., 425; 3 N. B. N., 432.
In Illinois an infant may not be adjudged a bankrupt in involuntar>'
proceedings. In re Eidemiller (1900), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 195
Fed., 595; 5 A. B. R., 570; contra in re Brice (1899), S Dist. la.,
Woolson, J , 2 A. B. R., 197.
Four full months after the act of bankruptcy allowed for filing the
petition. In re Planing Mill Co. (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.;
6A. B.R., 38;3N. B. N.,637.
Bankrupt offering to testify to facts waives question of jurisdiction of
court. In re Smith (1902), Dist. Conn., Piatt, J., 117 Fed., 961; 9 A.
B. R., 98.
A surety who has not yet paid the debt is not a creditor and cannot
file petition in involuntary bankruptcy. Phillips v. Dreher Shoe Co
(1902), Middle Dist., Pa., Archbald, J., 112 Fed., 404; 7 A. B. R., 326.
Adjudication of insolvency on ground of act of bankruptcy com-
mitted while insolvent, is res ad judicata as to the insolvency as to credi-
tors. In re American Brewing Co. (1902), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Btmn, J.,
112 Fed.. 752; 7 A B. R., 463.
An assignment more than four months old will not be assailable. In
re Carver & Co. (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 113 Fed., 138; 7 A.
B. R., 539.
In computing the four months exclude the day on which the act of
bankruptcy was committed. In re Dupree (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
nell, J , 97 Fed., 28; 1 N. B. N., 513. In r^ Stevenson (1899), Dist. Del.
Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R., 66.
Preference not within four months. Murray v Beal (1901), Sup. Ct
Utah, 65 Pac, 726. In re Lewis (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 91
Fed., 632; 1 A. B. R., 458; 1 N. B. N., 556.
Chattel mortgage an act of bankruptcy (1901), Mo. Ct. App., 88 Mo.
App.. 335.
Four months period applies to duplicate petitions. In re Dupree
(1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 97 Fed., 28; 1 N. B. N., 513.
c [Defense of solvency.] It shall be a complete de-
fense to any proceedings in bankruptcy instituted under the
first subdivision of this section to allege and prove that the
party proceeded against was not insolvent as defined in this
Act at the time of the filing the petition against him, and if
§3cd.] ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. 45
solvency at such state is proved by the alleged bankrupt the
proceedings shall be dismissed, and under said subdivision
one the burden of proving solvency shall be on the alleged
bankrupt.
For definition of insolvency, see ante Sec, 1 Sub. (15). For proceed-
ing in involuntary .cases, see Sec. 59 post.
Alleged bankrupt entitled to costs on dismissal of petition, but no
allowance for coimsel fees or* damages. In re Morris (1902), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 115 Fed., 591; 7 A. B. R., 709.
■ Burden of proof of solvency is on the alleged bankrupt where removal
and concealment are charged. In re Schenkin (1902), 113 Fed., 421;
7A. B. R., 162.
Corporation solvent in fact does not becoine insolvent by appoint-
ment of receiver — complete defense that corporation is solvent even
though receiver has been appointed. In re Henry Zeitner Brewing
Co. (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 117 Fed., 799; 9 A. B. R., 63.
Solvency of partnership complete defense though partnership in the
hands of a receiver. In re Burrell & Co. (1903), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams,
J.,9A. B. R.,178.
d [Person denying insolvency.] Whenever a person
against whom a petition has been filed as hereinbefore pro-
vided imder the second and third subdivisions of this section
takes issue with and denies the allegation of his insolvency,
it shall be his duty to appear in court on the hearing, with
his books, papers, and accoimts, and submit to an examination,
and give testimony as to all matters tending to establish sol-
vency or insolvency, and in case of his failure to so attend
and submit to examination the burden of proving his sol-
vency shall rest upon him.
For proceedings in involimtary cases, see Sec. 59, post. For definition
of "person against whom petition has been filed", see, ante, Sec. 1, sub. (1).
A partner may oppose a petition the same as an involimtary bankrupt.
Gen. Order VIII.
Burden of proving solvency, when alleged, being on bankrupt on his
failure to produce his books, adjudication may be made pro confesso.
Bray v. Cohb (1898), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 91 Fed., 102; 1 A. B. R.,
153; 1 N. B. N., 209.
46 ACTS OF BANKRUPTCY. [§3e.
Bankrupt must submit to cross-examination; and credits must be
estimated at actual value. In re Coddington (1902), W. Dist. Pa.,
Archbald, J., 118 Fed., 281.
e [Petitioner to give bond.] Whenever a petition is filed
by any person for the purpose of having another adjudged
a bankrupt, and an appHcation is made to take charge of
and hold the property of the alleged bankrupt, or any part
of the same, prior to the adjudication and pending a hearing
on the petition, the petitioner or applicant shall file in the
same court a bond with at least two good and sufficient
sureties who shall reside within the jurisdiction of said court,
to be approved by the court or a judge thereof, in such sum
as the court shall direct, conditioned for the payment, in
case such petition is dismissed, to the respondent, his or her
personal representatives, all costs, expenses, and damages
occasioned by such seizure, taking, and detention of the
property of the alleged bankrupt.
As to seizure of bankrupts' property and bond to be given on such
seizure, see post. Sec. 69a and notes. For form of bond of petitioning
creditor, see Form No. 9, post.
[Allowance of costs and damages.] If such petition be dis-
missed by the court or withdrawn by the petitioner, the
respondent or respondents shall be allowed all costs, cotmsel
fees, expenses, and damages occasioned by such seizure,
taking or detention of such property. Counsel fees, costs,
expenses, and damages shall be fixed and allowed by the
court, and paid by the obligors in such bond.
As to costs and contested adjudications, see Gen. Ord. XXXIV. For
proceedings in involuntary cases, see Sec. 59, post.
Where bond not given no taxation of counsel fees against the petition-
ing creditor; ordinary costs provided by Gen. Ord. XXXIV. In re
Ghiglione (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 93 Fed., 186; 1 A. B. R.,
580; 1 N. B. N., 351.
District Court will tax costs, disbursements and attorney's fees against
petitioning creditors in favor of one sought to be made a bankrupt where
proceedings are unsuccessful. In re Nixon, (1901) Dist. Mont., Knowles,
J., 110 Fed., 633; 6 A. B. R., 693.
§4 a.] who may become bankrupts. 47
Sec. 4. Who May become Bankrupts.
a [Voluntary bankrupts.] Any person who owes debts,
except a corporation, shall be entitled to the benefits of this
Act as a voluntary bankrupt.
Analogous provisions, act 1841, Sec. 7; act 1867, Sec. 11, post.
For definitions of corporations, see Sec. 1, sub. (6), ante. Person in-
cludes corporations, officers, partnerships and women. Sec. 1, sub. (19)
ante, and notes. See as to persons by whom proceedings may be con-
ducted general order IV and notes. "Debts" defined, Sec. 1 (11), ante,
and notes.
Where by state law an infant is liable for debts, such infant may be
adjudged bankrupt. In re Brice (1899), S. Dist. of la., Woolson, J.,
93 Fed., 942; 2 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N., 310.
The fact that distinction is made between natural and artificial persons
and that there is a distinction made between classes of artificial persons,
does not render the bankruptcy act unconstitutional. Lehigh Co. v.
Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 95 Fed., 637; 2 A. B. R., 383;
1 N. B. N., 387.
Where a voluntary petition is filed subsequent to an involuntary pe-
tition and the adjudication on the volimtary petition would injure the
estate by securing preferences to creditors, the adjudication should be
on the involvmtary petition. In re Dwyer (1902), Dist. N. Dak., Ami-
don, J., 112 Fed., 777; 7 A. B. R., 532.
Infant may not be adjudged bankrupt. A firm of which he is a mem-
ber may. In re Duguid (1899), E. Dist. N. C," Pumell, J., 100 Fed., 274;
3 A. B. R., 794; 2 N. B. N., 607. See notes under Sec. 3, clause 6, ante.
An infant may be adjudged bankrupt when he owes debts which he may
not disaffirm on his majority, /n r& Penzansky (1902) , Dist. Mass., Far-
mer, R., 8 A. B. R., 99.
Insane person can not be adjudged a bankrupt. In re Funk (1900),
N. Dist. la., Shiras. J., 101 Fed., 244; 4 A. B. R., 96.
An officer of regular army may be adjudged bankrupt. Audubon v.
Shufcldt (1901), 181 U. S., 575; 5 A. B. R., 829.
"Debts" as defined in Sec. 1 (11) must be strictly followed. In re
Yates (1902), N. Dist. Col., De Haven, J., 114 Fed., 365; 8A. B.R.,69.
There must be an existing provable debt to entitle one to take advan-
tage of bankruptcy act. Judgment suspended on appeal not such debt.
In re Yates (1902), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 114 Fed., 365; 8 A. B. R.,
48 ' WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. [§4b.
The bankruptcy act is not tmconstitutional by reason of provisions
for volimtary bankruptcy. Nat. Bank v. Moyses (1902), U. S. Sup. Ct.,
Chief Justice Fuller, 186 U. S., 181; 8 A. B. R., 1.
One not insolvent may be a voluntary bankrupt. Wetmore v. Wet-
more (1899), N. Y. Sup. Ct. O'Brien, J., 44 N. Y. App. Div., 220.
b [Involuntary bankrupts.] Any natural person, ex-
cept a wage earner or a person engaged chiefly in farming
or the tillage of the soil, any unincorporated company, and
any corporation engaged principally in manufacturing, trad-
ing, printing, publishing, *mining*, or mercantile pursuits,
owing debts to the amoimt of one thousand dollars or over,
may be adjudged an involuntary bankrupt upon default or
an impartial trial, and shall be subject to the provisions
and entitled to the benefits of this Act. Private bankers,
but not national banks or banks incorporated imder State
or Territorial laws, may be adjudged involuntary bank-
rupts. *The bankruptcy of a corporation shall not release
its officers, directors, or stockliolders, as such, from any lia-
bility under the laws of a State or Territory or of the United
States.*
"Person" defined Sec. 1 (19) and notes. "Wage-earner" defined-
Sec. 1 (27) and notes. "Corporations" defined Sec. 1 (6) and notes.
"Debts" defined Sec. 1 (11) and notes and 63a and notes. Person against
whom an involvmtary petition has been filed is entitled to jury trial on
the question of his solvency Sec. 19 (a) and notes. "Adjudication" de-
fined Sec. 1 (2) and notes. For form of involimtary petition, see Form
No. 3. As to involuntary petitio ns, see Sec. 59 and notes.
An admission by the officers of a corporation of Mass. not sufficient cause
for involvmtary bankruptcy. Stockholders vote necessary — semble
a corporation cannot make any such admission as an evasion of the act.
In re Bates Machine Co. (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 91 Fed., 625;
1 A. B. R., 129; I. N. B. N., 135.
A fire insurance company may not be adjudged a bankrupt. In re
Camerort, etc., Co. (1899), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 96 Fed., 756; 2
A. B. R., 372; 1 N. B. N., 383.
The amoimt of one thousand dollars indebtedness necessary to give
jurisdiction in involuntary bankruptcy may be estimated, when neces-
sary, by including among the creditors, one who has received a preference
§4b.] WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. 49
voidable by Sections 60 (a) and (b). In re Cain (1899), N. Dist., 111.,
Eastman, R.; 2 A. B. R., 378; 1 N. B. N., 389.
To the same effect, in re Tirre (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 95
Fed., 425; 2 A. B. R., 493; 1 N. B. N., 402.
An incorporated private hospital, conducted for profit, is a mercan-
tile company and liable to bankruptcy. In re San Gabriel San. Co.
(1900). S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J., 95 Fed., 271; 2 A. B. R., 408; 1 N.
B. N., 390.
Debts preferentially paid are to be cotmted as existing in estimating
the amount of liabilities to confer jurisdiction. In re Norcross (1899),
W. Dist. Mo., Hall. R., 1 A. B. R., 644; 1 N. B. N., 528.
Company engaged in furnishing water does not come tmder this
classification, and is not subject to be adjudicated bankrupt. In re New
York & Westchester Water Co. (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98
Fed., 711; 3 A. B. R., 508; 2 N. B. N., 414.
A mining company not subject to bankruptcy [amendment of Feb.
5th, 1903, changes this]. In re Elk Park Mining & Milling Co. (1899),
Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 101 Fed., 422 ; 4 A. B. R., 131.
Company engaged in theatrical performance not subject to bank-
ruptcy. In re Oriental Society (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 104
Fed., 975; 5 A. B. R.,219
Debtor changing his business to farming within four months cannot
escape prosecution of involtmtary bankruptcy. In re Luckhardt (1900),
Dist. Kan., Hook, J., 101 Fed., 807; 4 A. B. R., 307.
A farmer may not be adjudged a bankrupt on involuntary petition,
even on default. In re Taylor (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Bunn, J., 102
Fed. , 728; 4 A. B. R., 515; 2 N. B. N., 92.
Coal mining company, though operating a store, is not principally
engaged in mercantile pursuits, and is not liable to bankruptcy proceed-
ings. [Amendment Feb. 5th, 1903, changes this.] McNamara et al. v,
Helena Coal Co. (1900), N. Dist. Ala., Brice, J.; 5 A. B. R., 48.
Mining company not subject to proceedings in bankruptcy. In re
Woodside Coal Co. (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 105 Fed., 56;
5A. B. R., 186; 3 N. B. N., 336.
A coal company which buys coal in the ground, mines and markets
it, is subject to bankruptcy, its principal business being trading. In re
Keystone Coal Co. (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Van Wormer, R.; 5 A. B. R.
389; 3 N. B. N., 344.
Reversed— 7n re Keystone Coal Co. (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington,
J., 109 Fed., 872; 6 A. B. R., 377; 3 N. B. N., 938.
Corporation engaged in smelting ore is a manufacturing corporation.
50 WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. [§4b.
In re Tecopa Mining & Smelting Co. (1901), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J.,
110 Fed., 120; 6 A. B. R., 250.
Facts which tend to show whether an alleged bankrupt is engaged
chiefly in farming, in re Mackey (1901), Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 110
Fed., 355; 6 A. B. R., 577.
What constitutes being engaged chiefly in farming discussed. In re
Drake (1902), Dist. S. C, Brawley, J., 114 Fed., 229; 8 A. B. R., 137.
Pleading to merits waives the objection that an involuntary petition
does not allege that defendant is not a farmer or wage-earner. Verifica-
tion of petition which is defective, may be corrected on motion, juris-
diction being acquired by the filing of the petition. Bank v. Craig
Brothers (1901), W. Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 110 Fed., 137; 6 A. B. R., 381.
A mercantile agency may be adjudged bankrupt. In re Mutual Mer-
cantile Agency (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., Ill Fed., 152; 6 A. B.
R., 607.
A restaurant or hotel not a mercantile or trading business and not
subject to involuntary bankruptcy. In re Chesapeake Oyster & Fish Co.,
Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., 112 Fed., 960; 7 A. B. R., 173.
After an involuntary petition filed and no adjudication, bankrupt may
file his voluntary petition and hearing will be held on it. The involvm-
tary petition may be stayed to protect costs or other rights. In re
Stegar (1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 113 Fed., 978; 7 A. B. R., 665.
An incorporated social club cannot be adjudged bankrupt. In re
FuRon Club (1902), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 113 Fed., 997; 7 A. B.
R., 670.
A corporation cannot for the sake of procuring adjudication in bank-
ruptcy, collude with a creditor so that a claim is split up to make the
necessary numbers. In re Independent Thread Co. (1902), Dist. N. J.,
Kirkpatrick, J., 113 Fed., 998; 7 A. B. R., 704.
A corporation which never did in fact any trading or mercantile busi-
ness cannot be adjudged a bankrupt. It does not matter what it is
empowered to do. In re Tontine Surety Co. of New Jersey (1902),
Dist. of N. J., Kirkpatrick, J., 116 Led., 401 ; 8 A. B. R., 421.
A corporation engaged in the business of carriage by water of passen-
gers and goods for hire may not be adjudged a bankrupt. In re Phila-
delphia & Lewes Transportation Co. (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J.,
114 Fed., 403; 7 A. B. R., 707.
Petitioners must allege and prove that the alleged bankrupt was en-
gaged in one of the enumerated businesses. In re Chicago-Joplin Lead Co.
(1900), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 104 Fed., 67; 4 A. B. R., 712.
Must be engaged in enumerated pursviits at the time of filing the pe-
tition. In re Minn., etc., Constr. Co. (1900), Sup. Ct. Ariz., 60 Pac, 881-
§ 5 a.] who may become bankrupts. 51
Sec. 5.
a [Partnership may be adjudged bankrupt.] A partner-
ship, during the continuation of the partnership business,
or after its dissolution and before the final settlement thereof,
may be adjudged a bankrupt
Analogous provisions act 1841, Sec. 14 post; act of 1867, Sec. post.
As to proceedings in partnership cases, see Gen. Order VIII and notes.
"Person" used in this act includes corporation. Sec. 1 (19) ante. For form
of petition see Form No. 2. See h. c. d. e. f. g. and h., post, and notes.
Individual partners can not be discharged without bringing in co-
partners. In re Freund (1899), N. Dist. Pa., James, R., 1 A. B. R., 25;
1 N. B. N., 105.
So long as any partnership assets or liabilities remain, the same may
be adjudicated. In re Levy & Richman (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Moss,
R.; 2 A. B. R.. 21; 1 N. B. 287.
Where the property of a partner is used to pay the debt of a co-partner,
his trustee is subrogated to the rights of the creditor whose debt is so
paid. In re Mason & Son (1899). Dist. R. I., Littlefield, R.; 2 A. B. R.,
60; 1 N. B. N., 331.
In a petition to adjudicate a partnership a bankrupt notice to non-
joining partners is essential. In re Altman, N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., (1899) ,
96 Fed., 263; 2 A. B. R., 407; 1 N. B. N., 358.
Individual petitions are no notice to firm creditors and will not bar
firm debts. In re Carmichael (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed.,
594; 2 A. B. R., 815.
An act of bankruptcy by a partner for the firm binds the firm; such
as an assignment by one partner of the firm's assets. Chemical Nat.
Bank V. Aleyer, et al., (1899) E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 92 Fed., 896; 1
A. B. R., 565; 1 N. B. N., 304.
An adjudication on the petition of two of four partners that the co-
partnership be adjudged a bankrupt as a co-partnership and as individuals
is erroneous and should be set aside. Neither the co-partnership nor the
individual members are relieved from debts. In re Altman, (1899) N.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 689; 1 N. B. N., 358.
Existence of unpaid debts where there are no partnership assets, and
the partnership has ceased to exist, not a sufiicient ground to adjudge
partnership a bankrupt, idem
Partnership and individxial petitions may be joined and one fee only
52 WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. [§5a.
charged on filing. In re Gay (1899), Dist. N. H., Aldrich, J., 98 Fed.,
870; 3 A. B. R., 529.
Partnership may be adjudged a bankrupt irrespective of individuals
who may be drawn in, if they have committed an act of bankruptcy. In
re Meyer (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 98 Fed., 976; 3 A. B. R.,
659.
Petition in involuntary bankruptcy against a co-partnership should
show whether all members are insolvent or not. In re Blair, S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed., 76; 3 A. B. R., 588; 2 N. B. N., 890.
Members of the partnership may not be adjudged bankrupts on in-
volvmtary petitions. Mahoney et al. v. Ward (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
nell, J., 100 Fed., 278; 3 A. B. R., 770; 2 N. B. N., 538.
Individual partner shovild file schedvile both for himself and partner-
ship. Notices to creditors shoiild contain the statement showing desire
to be released from partnership debts; otherwise such debts not barred.
Inre Laughlin (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 589; 3 A. B. R., 1.
What constitutes a partnership. In re Kenney (1899), S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 554; 3 A. B. R., 353; 1 N. B. N., 401.
Where one partner is dead, bankruptcy court will take jurisdiction of
the estate, but not to dispossess the administrator without his consent.
In re Pierce & Son (1900), Dist. Wash., Handford, J., 102 Fed., 977; 4 A.
B. R., 489; 2 N. B. N., 977.
Where it appears that all proceedings are partnership in character,
individual discharge not given. In re Hale et al., (1901), E. Dist. N. C,
PumeU, J., 107 Fed., 432; 6 A. B. R., 35.
In bankruptcy, partners and the individual members are distinct en-
tities— bankruptcy of one does not necessarily involve them both.lj^/n
re Sanderlin (1901), E. Dist. N. C, PumeU, J., 109 Fed., 857; 6 A. B. R.,
384.
What facts constitute a partnership for purposes of adjudication in
bankruptcy. Lott v. Young (1901), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Hawley, J., 109
Fed., 798; 6 A. B- R., 436.
Facts insufficient to show partnership. In re Clark (1901) , Dist. 1 Wash.
Handford, J., Ill Fed., 893; 7 A. B. R., 96.
Partner may not file petition as a creditor against his copartner. In
re Shenkein & Coney (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 7 A. B. R.,
162.
Failure more than eight years before too stale to order all partners
to show cause why they should riot be adjudicated in the bankruptcy pro-
ceedings of one of them. Royston v. Weis (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 112
Fed., 962; 7 A. B. R., 584.
§5 a.] WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. 55
Bankruptcy of one member of a partnership dissolved does not aflfect
mortgage given by firm, where firm is not adjudicated. McNair v. Mc-
Intyre (1902). C. C. A., 4th Cir., Simonton, J., 113 Fed., 113; 7 A. B.
R., 638.
Intention of Congress that partnership should be an entity, like a
corporation for purposes of the bankruptcy act. In re Meyer (1899),
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 98 Fed., 976; 3 A. B. R., 559.
Firm committing act of bankruptcy may be adjudged bankrupt,
though the individual members not guilty of such acts. In re Sanderlin
(1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 109 Fed., 857; 6 A. B. R., 384.
Partnership petition is a separate proceeding — each partner seeking
discharge must file separate petition and pay fees accordingly. In re
Farley & Co. (1902), W. Dist. Va., McDowell, J., 115 Fed., 359; 8 A. B
R., 266.
In case of a volimtary petition by a partner a firm creditor may not
object to the adjudication on the grovmd of solvency — even if the co-
partner does come to object, it is an individual right as to him. Com-
parison between acts of 1841, 1867 and 1898. history of Legislation.
In r^Carleton (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 115 Fed., 246; 8 A. B. R., 270.
Fact that one copartner is a minor will not prevent the adjudication
of the firm if act of bankruptcy has been committed. In re Dunnigan
Bros. (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 95 Fed., 428; 2 A. B. R., 628.
Procedure where partner seeks discharge from individual and firm
debts. In re Hartman (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 593;
3 A. B. R.,65.
Individuals having been adjudged bankrupts and discharged years
afterwards, an amendment will not be entertained to declare a firm debt,
where the effect will be to disturb transactions long since closed. In re
Mercur (1902), E. Dist. Pa., Archbold, J., 116 Fed., 655; 8 A. B. R., 275.
Creditors may petition against members as well as against the firm.
idem.
Partners may petition for adjudication though there are no assets of
the firm. In re Hirsch (1899), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 97 Fed.,
571; 2 A. B. R., 715.
Partnership continues if debts exist though the debts may be out-
lawed. In re Levy (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 95 Fed., 812; 2
A. B. R., 21.
Members of a firm unwilling to join in a petition by part of firm may
be adjudged involtmtary bankrupts. In re Murray (1899), S. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 600; 3 A. B. R., 601.
Acts of bankruptcy on part of firm discussed. Vaccaro v. Security
Bank (1900), C.C. A., 6th Cir.,Lurton, J., 103 Fed., 436; 4 A. B. R., 474.
54 WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. [§5bcd.
Separate filing fees for the partner and each member thereof neces-
sary. In re Barden (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 101 Fed., 553;
4 A. B. R., 31. As to partnership exemptions, see notes to Sec. 6a.
b [Administration of partnership estate.] The creditors
of the partnership shall appoint the trustee; in other re-
pects so far as possible the estate shall be administered as
herein provided for other estates.
As to administration of estates see Chap. VII, post.
Creditors of the partnership appoint the trustee in the case of a joint
petition; in case of a separate petition the separate creditors have
the right to vote. In re Beck (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell,' J., 110
Fed., 140; 6 A. B. R., 554.
One not owner of claim against partnership cannot vote at election
of partnership trustee. In re Eagles & Crisp (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 99 Fed., 695; 3 A. B. R., 733.
c [Jurisdiction over one partner sufficient.] The court
of bankruptcy which has jurisdiction of one of the partners
may have jurisdiction of all the partners and of the adminis-
tration of the partnership and individual property.
As to jurisdiction to adjudicate bankrupt, see Sec. 2 (1) and notes
ante. See for proceedings in partnership cases Gen. Ord. VIII, post.
The court acquires jurisdiction of the proceeding on the filing of the
petition. If it is filed by all partners the adjudication is made at once;
if by less than all, the partner who refuses to join in the petition, may
oppose the adjudication as he might if the proceeding was involuntary,
and he may make every defense open to a debtor upon such petition.
In re Ives (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Wantly, J., 113 Fed., 911; 7 A. B.
R., 692.
d [Trustee to keep separate accounts.] The trustee shall
keep separate accounts of the partnership property and of
the property belonging to the individual partners.
'As to duties of trustees to prepare accounts, see Sec. 47a and notes;
post; also Gen. Ord. XVII.
§5ef.] WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. 55
e [Expenses apportioned.] The expenses shall be paid
from the partnership property and the individual property
in such proportions as the court shall determine.
As to expenses of administration, see Sec. 62a and notes, post.
f [Payment of debts— surplus.] The net proceeds of the
partnership property shall be appropriated to the payment
of the partnership debts, and the net proceeds of the in-
dividual estate of each partner to the payment of his in-
dividual debts. Should any surplus remain of the property
of any partner after paying his individual debts, such sur-
plus shall be added to the partnership assets and be applied
to the payment of the partnership debts. Should any sur-
plus of the partnership property remain after paying the
partnership debts, such surplus shall be added to the assets
of the individual partners in the proportion of their re-
spective interests in the partnership.
Proceedings in partnership cases outlined. Gen. Ord.Vlll. post See
c. b. c. d. e. g. and h under this section and notes therevmder.
Individual creditors shall be paid first out of individual assets and
partnership creditors paid next out of individual assets — the converse
follows in partnership assets. In re Wilcox (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J., 94 Fed., 84; 2 A. B. R., 117; 1 N. B. N., 494.
A solvent partner is a creditor of the insolvent members. In re Ste-
vens (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 104 Fed., 325; 5 A. B. R., 9.
Partnership note endorsed by individual member remains a partnership
liability and not a claim against the individual. Lamoille, etc. Bank v.
Stevens Est., (1901), Wheeler, J., 107 Fed., 245; 6 A. B. R., 164.
While a corporation was a de facto partner in a bankrupt firm and es-
topped to claim money advanced under the partnership agreement, it is
not so estopped as to money previously advanced. In re Ervin (1902),
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J.. 114 Fed., 596; 7 A. B. R, 480.
In bankruptcy proceedings of a partner of a firm, costs of suit incurred
by firm are not preferred claims, though State insolvency law makes it a
preferred claim. In re Daniels (1901), Dist. R. I., Brown, J., 110 Fed.,
745; 6. A. B. R., 699.
A retiring partner, who sold his interest and took notes of contintung
partner may not prove up so as to prejudice creditors of old firm. In re
Denning (1902), Dist. Mass.. Lowell. J.. 114 Fed., 219; 8 A. B. R., 133.
56 WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. [§5fg.
Real estate standing in the name of one partner, but really the firm
property, to be sold and applied to the payment of firm debts. In re
Goetzinger (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 110 Fed., 366; 6 A. B. R.,
399.
Cotirt will ascertain the facts as to whether land is purchased with
partnership ftmds, though in the individual names, and determine
whether it is individual or firm assets. In re Mosier (1901), Dist. of Vt.,
Wheeler, J., 112 Fed., 138; 7 A. B. R., 268.
Purpose of bankruptcy act to apply partnership assets to payment
of partnership debts, no scheme permitted to charge partnership assets
with individual debts. In re Jones (1900), E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 100
Fed., 781; 4 A. B. R., 141.
Chattel mortgage executed by individual members of firm can not be
proved as a claim against the partnership estate. In re Jones (1902),
E. Dist., N. C, Pumell, J., 116 Fed., 431; 8 A. B. R., 626.
What constitutes individual and partnership debts. In re Stevens,
(1900). Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 104 Fed., 323; 5 A. B. R., 9.
Discussion of partnership assets. In re Lehigh Lumber Co. (1900),
W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 101 Fed., 216; 4 A. B. R., 221.
Surplus partnership assets applied to individual debts. In re Gillette
& Prentice (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 769; 5 A. B. R., 119.
Individual and firm assets are to be marshalled where member and
firm are both adjudicated bankrupt. In re Wilcox (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 94 Fed., 84; 2 A. B. R., 117.
Where partnership adjudged a bankrupt individual estates are drawn
into bankruptcy court. In re Stokes (1901), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson,
J.. 106 Fed., 312; 6 A. B. R., 262.
Distribution of estate should be on basis that the bankrupt was sole
owner of the business even though there is secret partner. In re Harris
(1899), N. Dist. O., Ricks, J., 108 Fed., 5l7.
Firm debts not affected by the adjudication of a member of the firm
on his voluntary petition. In re McFaun (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 96 Fed., 592; 3 A. B. R., 66.
Where only individual assets remain both partners being insolvent
constitute an exception to the rule of distribution and partnership
creditors may share equally with individual creditors. In re Conrader
(1902), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 9 A. B. R., 85.
g [Claims to be marshalled.] The court may permit the
proof of the claim of the partnership estate against the
individual estates, and vice versa, and may marshal the
§5gll.] WHO MAY BECOME BANKRUPTS. 57
assets of the partnership estate and individual estates so as
to prevent preferences and secure the equitable distribution
of the property of the several estates.
See o, b, c, d, e and /, ante and notes. As to proof of claims, see Sec.
67a and notes, and Gen. Ord. XXI post. Form of proof of debt by part-
nership, see Form No. 34 and notes.
Attempting to charge partnership assets with an individual claim
is a fraud. In re Jones & Cook (1900) , E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 100 Fed.
781; 4 A. B. R., 141; 2 N. B. N., 193.
Liability of firm not shown where notes are signed by the individuals
not using firm names. Stratise v. Hooper (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell,
J., 105 Fed., 590; 5 A. B. R., 225.
Claims on notes signed by two members of a bankrupt firm allowed
against the firm where the money was used by the firm. In re Shat-
tuck & Bugh (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., McMaster, R., 6 A. B. R., 56.
Both individual and partnership estates may be marshalled to se-
cure an equitable distribution of the property. In r^_Gillette & Prentice
(1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 769; 5 A. B. R., 119.
Firm and individual assets must be marshalled. In re Shapiro &
Novick (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 106 Fed., 495; 5 A. B. R., 839.
h Administration where aljl partners are not bankrupt.]
In the event of one or more but not all of the members of a
partnership being adjudged bankrupt, the partnership
property shall not be administered in bankruptcy, unless by
consent of the partner or partners not adjudged bankrupt,
but such partner or partners not adjudged bankrupt shall
settle the partnership business as expeditiously as its nature
will permit, and accoimt for the interest of the partner or
partners adjudged bankrupt.
See o, h, c, d, e, f and g, tmder this section, and notes. See also pro-
ceedings in partnership cases. Gen. Ord. VIII post.
This section does not apply where the adjudication is refused because of
the infancy of a partner. In re Dunnigan Bros. (1899), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 95 Fed., 428; 2 A. B. R., 628; 1 N. B. N., 528.
Individual adjudication and administration of estate will continue
after a secret partnership is discovered — such secret partner is assumed
to have assented. In re Harris (1899), N. Dist. O., Remington, R.;
4 A. B. R., 132; 2 N. B. N., 868.
58 EXEMPTIONS- OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
Partners not adjudged bankrupt required to account for interest of
the bankrupt partner in the firm business. In re Laughlin (1899), N.
Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 589; 3 A. B. R., 1.
Fact that two members of firm are adjudged bankrupt does not make
the firm bankrupt, and a partnership not necessarily adjudged bank-
rupt. In re Mercur (1902), E. Dist. Pa., Archbald, J., 116 Fed., 655; 8
A. B. R., 275.
Discharge from partnership debts authorized on proper proof. Jan-
ecki Mfg. Co. V. McElwaine (1901), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 107 Fed., 249.
Provisions of this section do not apply where one partner is infant.
In re Dimnigan Bros. (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 95 Fed., 428; 2 A.
B. R., 628.
Trustee of insolvent member no right to firm assets. Burke v. Rol-
linson (1901), Sup. Ct., R. I., 49 Atl., 694.
Mortgage by a firm not invalidated by bankruptcy proceedings
against member of firm only. McNair v. Mclntyre (1902), C. C. A., 6th
Cir., Simonton, J., 113, Fed., 113; 7 A. B. R., 638.
Sec. 6. Exemptions of Bankrupts.
a [Exemption under State laws.] This act shall not
effect the allowance to bankrupts of the exemptions which
are prescribed by the State laws in force at the time of the
filing of the petition in the State wherein they have had
their domicile for the six months or the greater portion
thereof immediately preceding the filing of the petition.
Courts of bankruptcy to determine all claims of exemptions. Sec.
2, Sub. (11), a«<^, and trustee to set apart bankrupt's exemptions. Sec.
47, Sub. (11) post, and notes. See the exemption laws of each state
in which district cotirt is located.
As to statement of claim to exempt property, see Form 1, Schedule
B (5), Analogous provisions, Act of 1800, Sec. 18, 34, 35, 53; Act of 1841,
Sec. 3; Act of 1867, Sec. 14 amended Act June 8th, 1872, Ch. 30; Act
March 28, 1873, Ch. 235.
Intention to use an unbroken colt for team work where the Vt. law
allows team of horses is sufficient to exempt under the bankruptcy act.
/nr« Alfred (1899), Dist. Vt., Mott, R.; 1 A. B. R., 243.
Where each partner consents to the exemptions of the other, as re-
quired by No. Carolina law, the exemptions may be allowed out of the
partnership estate. In re Grimes (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewert, J., 94
§6 a.] EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. 59
Fed., 800; 2 A. B. R., 160; 1 N. B. N., 339. In re Stevenson & King
(1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 93 Fed., 789; 2 A. B. R., 230; 1 N.
B. N., 266.
Under the Wis. Law exemptions may be claimed out of a partnership
propert}^ In re Nelson (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 98 Fed., 76; 2
A. B. R., 556; 1 N. B. N., 567.
Arkansas exemption law allows no exemption from partnership prop-
erty. In re Meriwether (1901), W. Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 107 Fed., 102;
5 A. B. R., 435.
Exemptions allowed partner out of partnership assets, when joint
interest is severed. In re Friedrich (1900), C. C. A., 7th Ci.,Renkins,
J., 100 Fed., 284; 3 A. B. R., 801.
Exemptions in New Jersey not allowed out of partnership assets.
In re Demarest (1901), Dist. N. J., Kirkpatrick, J., 110 Fed., 638; 6 A.
B. R., 232.
In North Carolina exemptions allowed out of partnership assets by
consent of other partners. In re Seabolt (1902), W. Dist. N. C, Boyd,
J., 113 Fed., 766; 8 A. B. R., 57.
Exemptions of one partner may attach to property of the partnership
of which the bankrupt is a member, provided previously thereto the firm
has transferred same to one member. In re Rudnick (1900), Dist. Wash.,
Hanaford, J., 102 Fed., 750; 4 A. B. R., 531; 2 N. B. N., 975.
The rule of the state of which the bankrupt is a resident followed as to
exemptions — where allowed out of partnership assets the United States
Court will follow. In re Camp (1899), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 91 Fed,,
745; 1 A. B. R., 165; 1 N. B. N., 142.
Exemptions of forty acres as homestead on which bankrupt claims an
intention to build and occupy, is not allowed under Michigan statute,
as intention does not create homestead. In re Hatch (1899), E. Dist.,
Mich., Davock, R., 2 A. B. R., 36; 1 N. B. N., 293.
Homestead exemptions pass to the bankrupt. The reversionary inter-
est should be sold by the trustee. In re Woodward, E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
nell, J., 95 Fed., 260; 2 A. B. R., 339; 1 N. B. N., 352.
Exemptions are to be passed on by the District Court. Arkansas
Homestead Law construed. In re Overstreet (1899), E. Dist. Ark., Dool-
ey, R.; 2 A. B. R., 486; 1 N. B. N., 408.
Under the Alabama exemption law a gold watch worth fifty dollars
comes under necessary and proper wearing apparel. Sellers v. Bell (1899) ,
C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 94 Fed., 801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
Exemptions of tools and implements under the California law con-
60 EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
sidered. In re Peterson (1899), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 95 Fed. ,417;
2 A. B. R., 630; 1 N. B. N., 430.
Exemption lost by failure to claim the same in the schedule can not
be claimed by amendment. In re Nunn (1899), S. Dist. Ga., Proudfit,
R.; 2 A. B. R., 664; 1 N. B. N., 427.
Exemption not allowed by way of amendment to schedule out of prop-
erty which had already passed to trustee. Distinction between property
which law makes exempt and that which the bankrupt claims to be ex-
empt. Moran v. King (1901), C. C. A.. 4th Cir., Ill Fed., 730; 7 A. B. R.,
176.
Exemptions where state law does not allow cash exemptions con-
strued. In re Woodward (1899), E. Dist. N.C., Pumell, J., 95 Fed., 955;
2 A. B. R., 692; 1 N. B. N., 430.
Exemptions must be set aside by the trustee and no one can act in
his place. In re Grimes (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96 Fed., 529;
2 A. B. R., 730; 1 N. B. N., 516.
Jurisdiction of bankrupt court limited to setting the exempt property
aside. Disputes concerning title to be left to other courts. In re Hill
(1899), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 96 Fed., 185; 2 A. B. R., 798; 2 N. B.
N., 180. In re Little (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed., 621; 6
A. B. R. 681.
Title to crops growing on exempt land of a voluntary bankrupt vest in
trustee. In re Coffman, N. Dist. Tex., Meek, J., 93 Fed., 422; 1 A. B. R.,
630; 1 N. B. N., 402.
Construction of the New York law, as regards money of pensioner
of the United States invested in real estate. In re Ellithorpe (1901), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., Ill Fed., 163; 5 A. B. R., 681.
Pension money exempt but subject to costs of filing petition. In re
Bean (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 100 Fed., 262; 4 A. B. R., 53.
Under Georgia law exemption only allowed where the claimant comes
with clean hands. In re Williamson (1901), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J.,
114 Fed., 190; 8 A. B. R., 42.
The right to exemption is not lost by bankrupt withholding assets
orhaving made fraudulent transfer. In re Park (1900) , Dist. Ark., Rogers,
J., 102 Fed., 602; 4 A. B. R., 432; 2 N. B. N., 981.
Fraudulent concealment of property by the bankrupt does not deprive
him of right to exemption. In re Rothschild (1901), S. Dist. Ga.,
Cravatt, R.; 6 A. B. R., 43.
Exemptions vmder Georgia law forfeited for fraud in concealing as-
sets. In re Waxelbaum (1900). N. Dist. Ga., 101 Fed., 228; 4 A. B. R.,
120; 2 N. B. N., 228.
§6a.] EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. 61
Exemption law of Georgia~requires debtor to make fvtll and fair dis-
closure of all his personal property. Omission to do so in bankruptcy
will forfeit his claim to exemptions. In re Boorstin (1902), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 114 Fed., 696; 8 A. B. R., 89.
Property which had been preferentially transferred and afterwards
surrendered to the trustee, becomes subject to the bankrupt's claim for
exemption. In re Falconer (1901) , C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 110 Fed.,
111;6A. B. R.,557. /nr^Talbott (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 116 Fed.,
417; 8 A. B. R., 427.
The statute of Georgia forfeits exemption in property conveyed in
fraud of creditors. Where the property was reconveyed to the grantor,
who afterwards became bankrupt, the old fraudulent transfer is no
longer involved and exemption may be claimed. In re Thompson (1902) ,
S. Dist. Ga., Spear, J., 115 Fed., 924; 8 A. B. R., 283.
Exemptions in Missovui cannot be allowed out of property recovered
by a trustee from preferred creditors. In re White (1900), W. Dist. Mo.,
Phillips, J., 103 Fed., 774; 6 A. B. R., 45.
Conveyance of homestead vmder Tenn. law which is fraudulent in
law but not in fact, will not bar homestead. In re ToUett (1900), C. C.
A., 6th Circt., Lurton, J., 105 Fed., 425; 5 A. B. R., 404.
In Tennessee a fraudulent conveyance bars the debtor's claim for home-
stead. In re ToUett (1900), E. Dist. Tenn., Grayson, R.; 5 A. B. R.
305.
Exemptions of bankrupt should be allowed if practicable by partition
If not, then property should be sold and exemptions allowed out of pro-
ceeds. In re Dillon (1900), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 100 Fed., 627;
4 A. B. R., 45.
When exemptions must be taken from property incapable of division
without injury, the court should order the sale of the property and pay
him his exemptions out of the proceeds. In re Grimes (1899), W. Dist.
N. C., Alexander, R., 2 A. B. R., 610; 1 N. B. N., 426.
State law of exemptions prevails. Where it allows a waiver, waiver
sustained in bankruptcy. In re Garden (1899), N. Dist. Ala., Bruce, J.,
93 Fed., 423; 1 A. B. R., 582; 1 N. B. N., 169.
Exemptions where creditors have waiver of the same - it is duty of
bankruptcy court to protect the creditor in collecting his claim out of ex-
empt property. In re Woodruff, et al. (1899), S. Dist. Ga., Spear, J., 96
Fed. 317; 2 A. B. R., 678; 1 N. B. N., 423.
Although under Pennsylvania statute an exemption may be waived
in favor of the payee of a note, yet a judgment on such note avoided as
preferential under the act, destroys the benefit of the waiver of the ex-
emption. The creditor having proved claim as a general creditor is
62 EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
lestopped to claim waiver of exemptions. In re Bolinger (1901), W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 108 Fed., 374; 6 A. B. R., 171.
Holder of judgment note containing waiver of exemptions cannot take
advantage of waiver in bankruptcy unless note reduced to judgment
and execution issued. In re Brown (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Ransom, R.;
1 A. B. RsL, 256; 1 N. B. N.,230.
Exemption may be waived by bankrupt, but is not forfeitable. In
re Brown (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 100 Fed., 441; 4 A. B. R.,
46; 2 N. B. N., 590.
Under Alabama law waiver of exemptions in note will not bar the
claim for the same. In re Moore (1901), Mid. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 112
Fed., 289; 7 A. B. R., 285.
Where bankrupt has waived his exemptions in lease and landlord has
destrained, no exemptions can be claimed against landlord out of the de-
strained property. In re Hover (1902), Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 113
Fed., 134; 7 A. B. R., 330.
Under Virginia statutes exemption will not be allowed where it will go
not to the bankrupt's family, but to those creditors who hold waivers of
the exemption. In re Gamer (1902), W. Dist. Va., McDowell, J., 115
Fed., 200; 8 A. B. R., 263.
Bankrupt does not lose right to exemptions by failing to claim on
an execution the property afterwards being returned to the estate in
bankruptcy he may waive exemptions as to one creditor but does not
thereby as to all. In re Osbom (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104
Fed., 782; 5 A. B. R., 111.
Waiver of exemptions discussed in re Becker (1899), E. Dist. Pa.,
Dunn, R.; 2 A. B. N., 202.
Where bankrupt has waived his exemptions in lease and landlord has
destrained no exemption can be claimed against landlord out of the de-
strained property, hire Hoover (1902), E. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J.,
113 Fed., 136; 7 A, B. R., 330.
Waiver of exemptions does not create a lien on exempt property. In
re Hopkins (1899), N. Dist. Ala., Turner, R.; 1 A. B. R., 209; 1 N. B.
N.. 171.
Amendment .allowed of claim for exemption when made to help the
bankrupt's family, but not when it would merely enure to benefit of se-
cured creditor. In re Moran (1900), W. Dist. Pa., Paul, J., 105 Fed., 901;
5 A. B. R., 472.
Under Mass. law watch not an article of necessary wearing apparel.
In re Tumbull (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 106 Fed., 667; 5 A. B,
R., 549.
§6 a.] EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. 63
Adjudication by state court before bankruptcy allowing homestead ex-
emption is res adjudicata. In re Rhodes (1901), N. Dist. O., Wing, J.,
109 Fed., 117; 5 A. B. R., 197.
Under the Kansas exemption law a plat of grotind containing less than
an acre and having on it several buildings not used for dwellings ex-
clusvely, allowed the bankrupt's family as exemptions on his decease.
In re Parker (1899), Dist. Kan., White, R.; 1 A. B. R., 70S; 1 N. B.
N., 261.
Sec. 6 is controlled by Section 70. In re Steele &Co. (1899), S. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 98 Fed., 78; 3 A. B. R., 549; 2 N. B. N., 281.
Exemptions under Texas law — what constitutes abandonment of
business homestead. In re Harrington (1900), N. Dist. Tex., Meek,
J., 99 Fed., 390; 3 A. B. R., 639; 1 N. B. N., 613.
Taxes on exempt property to be paid out of general fund in hands of
trustee. In re Tilden (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 91 Fed., 500; 1
A. B. R., 300; IN. B. N., 134.
Exemption laws to be liberally construed. Idem.
Court to aid bankrupt to obtain his homestead may order a sale of
part of his several pieces of property, which are all mortgaged, free of
iens. In re Thomas, Dist, Wash., Handford, J. (1899), 96 Fed., 828;
3 A. B. R., 99; 1 N. B. N., 551.
A diamond stud worth $250 held to be wearing apparel. In re Smith, ,
(1899), W. Dist. Tex., Maxey, J., 93 Fed., 791; 3 A. B. R., 140; 1 N. B.
N., 532.
Exemptions in Wisconsin allow bankrupt gold watch as wearing ap-
parel. In re Jones (1899), S. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 97 Fed., 773;
3 A. B. R., 259; 2 N. B. N., 296.
Construction of Wisconsin statute covering exemptions. In re Hoag
(1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 97 Fed., 543; 3 A. B. R., 290.
Application by bankrupt of money in payment of claims on exempt
property shortly before bankruptcy — trustee will be subrogated to claim.
In re Boston (1899), Dist. Neb., Munger, J., 98 Fed., 587; 3 A. B. R., 38S;
2N. B. N.,19
Exemptions under law of State of Washington allowed and discussed.
In re Buelow (1899), Dist. Wash., Handford, J., 98 Fed., 86; 3 A. B. R.
389; 2 N. B. N., 26.
Exemption imder S. Carolina law discussed. In re McCutchen (1900) ,
E. Dist. So.Car.,Brawley, J., 100 Fed., 779; 4 A. B. R., 81; 2 N. B. N., 636.
A watch not a necessary article of wearing apparel. In re Tumbull
(1901), Dist. Mass., Olmstead, R.; 5 A. B. R., 231; 3 N. B. N., 294.
64 EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
Gold watch and chain necessary wearing apparel in Rhode Island.
/« re Caswell (1901), Dist. R. I., Barrows, R.; 6 A. B. R., 718.
Bankruptcy act provides time and manner of claiming exempt prop-
erty and must be followed. Exempt property must be described in
schedules and descriptions must be specific and definite. In re Groves
(1901), N. Dist. O., Remington. R.; 6 A. B. R., 728.
Exemptions allowed under state process followed shortly by bank-
ruptcy. Under Virginia law bankrupt's wife may claim homestead as
head of a family, although living with her husband. Richardson v. Wood-
ward (1900), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Pumell, J., 104 Fed., 689; 5 A. B. R., 94.
Exemptions allowed under state process, followed shortly by bank-
ruptcy, cannot be claimed a second time. In re Miller (1899), W. Dis.
Mo., Crittenden, R.; 1 A. B. R., 647; 1 N. B. N., 263.
Exemptions of bankrupt should be allowed if practicable by parti-
tion, if not, then property should be sold and exemptions allowed out
of proceeds. In re Diller (1900). N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 100 Fed., 931;
4 A. B. R., 45.
Exemption being indivisible property should be sold and exemption
attach to proceeds. In re Oderkirk (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103
Fed., 779; 4 A. B. R., 617.
Expenses of the sale of indivisible homestead are not chargeable to
the bankrupt. In re Hopkins (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed.,
781; 4 A. B. R., 619.
Before question of exemption can come before the court, trustee must
be appointed and set aside the exempt property. In re Smith (1899),
W. Dist. Tex., Maxey, J., 93 Fed., 791; 2 A. B. R., 190.
Homestead acquired while insolvent from proceeds of property un-
paid for not allowable. Burden of proving solvency on banlcrupt. Mc-
Gahan v. Anderson (1902), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Johnson, J., 113 Fed., 115;
7 A. B. R., 641.
The bankruptcy act is not unconstitutional by reason of the exemp-
tions in this section. Hanover National Bank v. Moyses (1902), U. S.
Sup. Ct., Chief Justice Fuller, 186 U. S., 181, 8 A. B. R., 1.
Exemption laws of Maryland considered and discussed. In re Beau-
champ (1900), Dist. Md., Morris, J., 101 Fed., 106; 4 A. B. R., 151.
Exemptions under North Carolina considered and construed. In re
Wilson (1900), Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 101 Fed., 571; 4 A. B. R., 260.
District Court has no jurisdiction over exemptions after allowance.
In re Hatch (1900), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 102 Fed., 280; 4 A. B. R., 349;
1 N. B. N., 293.
§6 a.] EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. 65
Status of property at time of adjudication will determine whether it
is a business homestead or not. In re Harrington (1900), E. Dist. Tex.,
Dillard, R., 3 A. B. R., 639; 1 N. B. N., 513.
Under Pennsylvania statute bankrupt can not claim his exemptions
out of the proceeds of a liquor license. In re Myers (1900), E. Dist. Pa.,
Mason, R., 4 A. B. R., 536; 2 N. B. N. 860.
Exemptions under the Virginia law not allowed unless a showing is
made by claimant that he has a clean title. In re Tobias (1900) , W. Dist.
Va.. Paul, J., 103 Fed., 68; 4 A. B. R., 555.
Under the New York statute a single woman allowed her necessary
wearing apparel as exempt, and what constitutes same. In re Stokes
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise R., 4 A. B. R., 560; 3 N. B. N., 443.
Homestead law of the United States (U. S. Rev. St., Sec. 2296), giv-
ing one hundred and sixty acres of land free of prior debts, not dis-
turbed by bankruptcy — growing crops thereon not exempt. In re
Daubner (1899), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 96 Fed., 805; 3 A. B. R., 368;
1 N. B. N., 520.
Under the Vermont law a race horse not exempt. In re Libby (1900),
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed., 776; 4 A. B. R., 615.
The rentals of exempt land of the bankrupt contracted for and accru-
ing after adjudication, do not constitute assets of his estate in bankruptcy.
In re Oleson (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed., 796; 7 A. B. R., 22.
A watch is a "tool" or "implement of trade" if value suitable for pur-
poses and is exempt under Mass. law. In r^ CoUer (1901), Dist. Mass.,
LoweU, J., Ill Fed., 503; 7 A. B. R., 131.
Temporary absence from homestead exempt under Missouri law is
no abandonment. In re Lynch (1899), W. Dist. Mo., Crittenden, R.,
1 A. B. R., 245; 1 N. B. N., 182.
Facts under Kentucky law not showing abandoning of homestead.
In re Carmichael (1901), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 108 Fed., 789; 5 A. B.
R., 551.
Temporary leaving of homestead not an abandonment. In re Pope,
S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., (1900), 98 Fed., 722; 3 A. B. R., 525; 2 N. B. N.,
427.
Under the Vermont law one who reserved a room in a tenement house
owned by himself, but boarded and roomed elsewhere, can not claim a
homestead. In re Dawley (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 94 Fed., 795;
2 A. B. R., 496; 1 N. B. N., 528.
Homestead exemption abandoned by bankrupt absconding. In re
Mayer (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Woods, J., 108 Fed., 599; 6 A. B. R., 117.
G6 EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
Under the California statute a farmer, who temporarily changes his
occupation with no intention of a pennanent abandonment of it, can claim
his exemptions after his adjudication. In re Fly (1901), S. Dist. Cal.,
Wellborn, J., 110 Fed., 141; 6 A. B. R., 550.
A lien on exempt property is subject to the jurisdiction of the state
court solely. Powers Dry Goods Co. v. Nelson (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Dak.,
7 A. B. R., 506
Exemption law of Pennsylvania construed. In re Manning [(1902),
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 112 Fed., 948; 7 A. B. R., 571.
Where the value of the homestead does not appear to be more than the
exemption then the whole should be set over to the bankrupt. In re
Gibbs (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 109 Fed., 627; 4 A. B. R., 619.
Exemption allowed in Vermont out of an estate of tenancy by courtesy.
In re Marquette (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed., 777; 4 A. B. R.,
623.
Where dispute between bankrupt and trustee as to the value of prop-
erty claimed as exempt under the Georgia law, property should be offered
at public sale. In re Lynch (1900), S. Dist. Ga., Speer, J., 101 Fed.,
579; 4 A. B. R., 262.
In California, horse and wagon used by painter in carrying his material
is exempt — such painter to be considered a laborer. In re Hindman
(1900), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Hawley, J., 104 Fed., 331; 5 A. B. R., 20.
Exemption of policy of insurance by state law prevails in bankruptcy
Steele v. Buell et al. (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., CaldweU, J., 104 Fed.,
968; 5 A. B. R., 165.
In Vermont a homestead exemption which is subject to claims prior
to the exemptions will be sold by the bankruptcy court in such
parts as will pay the claims free of the homestead. In re Gordon
(1902), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 115 Fed., 445; 8 A. B. R., 255.
Duty of court of bankruptcy to protect exempt property from attach-
ment of liens, which would nullify the policy of the law. In re Tune
(1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 115 Fed., 906; 8 A. B. R., 285.
A preferential mortgage covering property which might have been
claimed as exempt, cannot be sustained as to such property, as the right
of exemption is personal to the bankrupt and cannot pass to another.
In re SchuUer (1901), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 108 Fed., 591; 6 A. B.
R., 278.
Under the Virginia law the bankrupt must designate the particular
claims claimed as exempt. In re Wilson (1901), W. Dist. Va., Paul, J.,
lOSFed., 197;6A. B. R., 287.
Under Florida statute a bankrupt who has carried on business imder
§6a] EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. 67
a corporate name may claim exemptions out of the assets. In re Car-
penter (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 109 Fed., 558; 6 A. B.
R., 465.
Under Pennsylvania statute no exemption allowed in cash. In re
Haskin (1901), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 109 Fed., 789; 6 A. B. R., 485.
What constitutes "head of family" under Arkansas statute, discussed.
In re Morrison (1901), E. Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 110 Fed., 734; 6 A. B.
R., 488.
Under Missouri lawclaims existing prior to acquisition of homestead
are superior to exemption. In re Stout (1900), W. Dist. M. Phillips, J.,
109 Fed., 794; 6 A. B. R., 505.
Exemptions under Mass. insolvency law favorable to bankrupt not
allowed under bankruptcy law, as insolvency law suspended in its opera-
tion. In re Anderson (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 110 Fed., 141; 6
A. B. R., 555.
No jurisdiction in plenary suits to adjust liens on exempt property by
creditors — trustee has no title to exempt property. Woodruff v. Chesere
(1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir McCormick, J., 105 Fed., 601; 5 A. B. R., 296.
Title to exempt property does not pass to trustee — bankruptcy court
cannot pass on exempt property. In re Wells (1900), W. Dist. Ark.,
Rogers, J., 105 Fed., 762; 5 A. B. R., 308.
Exemptions must be carried out as provided by state law — the bank-
ruptcy court will not settle claims adverse to the exemption, but will
relegate the party to the state court. In re Ogilvie, S. Dist. Ga., Mac-
donell, R. (1900) ; 5 A. B. R., 374.
Exemption laws must be liberally construed. In re Tilden (1899),
S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 91 Fed., 500; 1 A. B. R., 300; 1 N. B. N., 134.
Construction of exemption laws of State Court will be followed. In
re Stone (1902) E. Dist. Ark. Trieber J. 116 Fed. 35; 8 A. B. R. 416:
Established rules of construction prevail where State Courts have not
passed on exemption laws. Richardson vs. Woodward (1900) ; C. C. A.
4th Pumell J. 104 Fed. 878; 5 A. B. R. 94; In re Beauchamp (1900)
Dist. Md. Morris J. 101 Fred. 106; 4 A.B. R. 151.
Bankrupt acting in good faith may change his homestead within foiu-
months under Kansas law. Huenergardt v. Brittain Dry Goods Co. (1902),
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 116 Fed., 31; 8 A. B. R., 341.
In allowing exemptions out of a stock of merchandise the prevailing
cost to trade should be adopted by appraisers. In re Prager (1902),
Dist. Colo., Harrison, R., 8 A. B. R., 356.
Creditor who has had notice cannot contest claim for exemption af-
68 EXEMPTIONS OF BANKRUPTS. [§6a.
ter discharge. In re Ruse (1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 115 Fed.,
993; 8 A. B. R., 411.
Arkansas law construed — construction of State law by highest court
of state binding on bankuptcy court. In re Stone (1902), E. Dist. Ark.,
Trieber, J., 116 Fed., 35; 8 A. B. R., 416.
Exemptions claimed from property recovered by trustee from assign-
ee under general assignment. In re Talbot (1902), W. Dist. Ga., Speer,
J., 116 Fed., 417; 8 A. B. R., 427.
"Perfect good faith" defined as relating to homestead exemptions
under Georgia law. In re West (1902), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 116
Fed.,767;8A. B. R.,564.
Bankruptcy court no further jurisdiction over exempt property than
necessary to set aside and dispose of questions incident thereto. In re
Jackson (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 116 Fed., 46; 8 A. B. R., 594.
Duty of bankrupt vmder Indiana law to disclose exemptions in gar-
nishment proceedings. In re Beak (1902), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 116 Fed.,
530; 8 A. B. R., 639.
Bankrupt denied his exemptions out of recovered preference. In re
Evans (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 116 Fed., 909; 8 A. B. R., 730.
Costs of the proceedings should be deducted from exemptions. In re
Hines (1902), S. Dist. W. Va., Keller, J., 117 Fed., 790; 7 A. B. R., 27.
Bankrupt may not be allowed his exemption, or any part out of a
fund produced by a sale of personal property by his assignee. In re
Staunton (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 117 Fed., 507; 9 A. B.
R.,79.
Business Aomestead which has been abandoned may not be claimed
as exempt tmder Texas law. In re Flannagan (1902), W. Dist. Texas,
Maxey, J., 117 Fed., 695; 9 A. B. R., 140.
A fraudulent assignment under the law of Pennsylvania bars exemp-
tions. In re Yost (1902), Middle Dist. Pa., Archbald, J., 117 Fed., 792;
9 A. B. R., 153.
Exempt property not subjected to lien of purchase price vmder Iowa
law. In re Seydel (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 118 Fed., 207.
Under Iowa law one homestead allowed to be exchanged for another —
exemption will attach to the proceeds of sale of the old before the new
was acquired. In re Johnson (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 118 Fed.,
312.
Under Pennsylvania law exemptions must be claimed out of specific
property — not generally as to amoxmt. In re Duffy (1902), Middle Dist.
Pa., Archbald, J., 118 Fed., 926.
§7 a.] DUTIES OF BANKRUPTS. 69
Exemptions not lost by the bankrupt's assignment for the benefit
of creditors which was surrendered to the trustee, the assignment not
being fraudulent. Bashinski v. Talbot (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby,
J., 119 Fed., 337.
Improvement on Indian lands allowed bankrupt Indian. In re Gray-
son (1901), Sup. Ct., Ind. Ter., 61 S. W., 984.
This section controlled by Sec. 70a (5). In re Scheld (1900), C. C. A.,
9th, Ross, J., 104 Fed., 870; 5 A. B. R., 102. In re Holden (1902) , C. C. A.,
9th Cir., McKenna, J., 113 Fed., 141; 7 A. B. R., 615; contra Steele v. Buel
(1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Caldwell, J., 104 Fed., 968; 5 A. B. R., 165.
Exemption laws of Georgia construed. In re Swords (1901), N
Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 112 Fed., 661; 7 A. B. R., 436.
Pennsylvania statute construed as to exemption note. Miller v.
Black (1901), 10 Pa. Dist., 255.
As to amendments of schedules claiming exemptions, see notes to
Sec. 7 (8), post.
Sec. 7. Duties of Bankrupts.
a [Attend meetings and hearing.] The bankrupt shall
(1) attend the first meeting of his creditors, if directed by the
court or a judge thereof to do so, and the hearing upon his
application for a discharge, if filed ;
For definition of bankrupt see Sec. 1 (4) and notes, ante.
As to meetings of creditors, see Sec. 55, post, and notes.
As to discharge, see Sec. 14, post. As to hearings on application for
discharges see Sec. 14b, and notes, post.
(2) [Comply with orders.] Comply with all lawful
orders of the court ;
Court may include the referee. Sec. 1, sub. (7), ante, and notes.
As to duties of persons in proceedings before referees, see Sec. 41, post,
and notes. As to how contempts before referees are pvmished, see Sec.
41b and notes. Contempt in refusing to obey orders to surrender assets
Sec. 2 (13) and notes, ante.
(3) [Examine proofs of claims.] Examine the correct-
ness of all proofs of claims filed against his estate ;
As to proof of claims see Sec. 57 and notes. Also Gen. Ord. XXI,
post.
70 DUTIES OP BANKRUPTS. [§7a.
(4) Execute and deliver papers.] Execute and deliver
such papers as shall be ordered by the court;
"Cotirt" may include the referee Sec. 1 (7) and notes, ante.
(5) Execute transfers.] Execute to his trustee transfers
of all his property in foreign countries ;
As to title to property vesting in the trustee see Sec. 70a and notes.
post.
(6) [Inform trustee of evasions of law.] Immediately
inform his trustee of any attempt, by his creditors or other
persons, to evade the provisions of this Act, coming to his
knowledge ;
As to offences tinder this act, see Sec. 29 and notes, post.
(7) [Disclose false claim.] In case of any person having
to his knowledge proved a false claim against his estate,
disclose that fact immediately to his trustee;
Duty of bankrupts to assist in contesting spimous claims — suflBciency
of objection — practice. In re Ankeny (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.,
100 Fed., 614; 4 A. B. R., 72; 2 N. B. N., 349.
As to punishment for presenting false claim see Sec. 29b (3) , and notes.
(8) [Prepare and file schedules.] Prepare, make oath
to, and file in court within ten days, unless further time
is granted, after the adjudication, if an involuntary bank-
rupt, and with the^petition) if a voluntary bankrupt, a
^schedule of his prof^erty, showing the amount and kind of
property, the location thereof, its money value in detail)
and aflist of his cr^itors, showing their residences, if known,
if tmknown, the fact to be stated, the amounts due each of
them, the consideration thereof ,Hhe security held by them
if any, and a claim for such exen^tions as he may be en-
titled to, all in triplicate, one copy of each for the clerk, one
for the referee, and one for the trustee ; and
Amendment of schedules. Gen. Ord. XI. As to Schedules in involun-
tary bankruptcy, see Gen. Ord. IX and notes. As to frame of Schedules
§7 a.] DUTIES OF BANKRUPTS. 71
see Gen. Ord. V. As to form of Schedules, see Form No. 1 and Schedules.
As to exemptions see Sec. 6 and notes ante.
Bankrupt in involuntary cases may be attached for failure to furnish
schedules. Gen. Order VIII, post.
Scheduling debts barred by the statute of limitations does not revive
them and make them provable against the estate. In re Resler (1899),
Dist. Minn., Marriman, R., 95 Fed., 804; 2 A. B. R., 166; 1 N. B. N., 280.
Property acquired by the bankrupt since the fiUng of the original pe-
tition and prior to adjudication is not such property as is required to be
scheduled. In re Harris (1899), N. Dist. 111., Wean, R., 2 A. B. R., 359;
l.N. B. N., 384.
Quaere: Can corporation in which bankrupt is a stockholder be com-
pelled to furnish lists of stockholders with date of becoming stockholders.
In re Post (1899), N. Dist. O., Fisher, R.; 1 N. B. N., 294.
A vested remainder by will should be scheduled. In r^Shenberger
(1900), N. Dist. O., Ricks, J., 102 Fed., 978; 4 A. B. R., 487; 2 N.B. N.
783.
Schedules should state the street and ntmiber, addresses of creditors,
else they will be defective. In re Brumelkamp (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Stone, R., 2 A. B. R., 318; 1 N. B. N., 360.
Printed forms must be used. Mahoney v. Ward (1900), E. Dist. N.
C, Pumell, J., 100 Fed., 278; 3 A. B. R., 770.
Bankrupt must schedule all his property. In re Becker (1901), N.
Dist. N. Y., Coxe. J., 106 Fed., 54; 5 A. B. R., 438.
Exempt property should be scheduled and claimed as exempt. In re
Bean (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 100 Fed., 262; 4 A.B. R.. 53. In re
Todd (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 112 Fed., 315; 6 A. B. R., 88. ;
Scheduling a claim barred by the statute of limitations does not revive
it. In re Resler (1899), Dist. Minn., Lochren, J., 95 Fed., 804; 2 A. B. R.,
602; 1 N. B. N., 280.
Where schedule named certain parties as creditors the defense of
statute of limitations against such creditors was thereby waived so far
as the bankrupt personally was concerned. In re Gibson (1902), Indian
Ter., Clayton, J., 69 S. W., 974.
Debts not scheduled not discharged. In re Monroe (1902) , Dist. Wash. ,
Handford, J., 114 Fed., 398; 7 A. B. R., 706.
Schedules must show the amounts due creditors. In re Schiller (1899) ,
W. Dist. Va., Paul, J., 96 Fed., 400; 2 A. B. R., 704.
Verification must be by the bankrupt and clearly show that fact. In re
Blankfein (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 191; 3 A. B. R.,
72 DUTIES OF BANKRUPTS. [§7a.
165. In re Brumelkamp (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 95 Fed., 814;
2 A. B. R., 318.
Amendment of schedules allowed. In re Royal (1901), E. Dist. N. C,
Purnell, J., 112 Fed., 135; 7 A. B. R., 106. In re Slingluff (1900), Dist
Md., Morris, J., 105 Fed., 502; 5 A. B. R., 76. In re Beerman (1901), N."
Dist. Ga., Ne-«vTnan, J., 112 Fed., 662; 7 A. B. R., 431. In re Falconer
(1901), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 110 Fed., Ill; 6 A. B. R., 557. In
re Bean (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 110 Fed., 262; 4 A. B. R., 53. In
re LaughHn (1899), N. D!st. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 589; 3 A. B. R., 1
7»reMcFaun (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 592; 3 A. B. R., 66.
Further exemptions not allowed by amendment. In re Moran (1900),
W. Dist. Va., Paul, J., 105 Fed., 901; 5 A. B. R., 472; affirmed in Moran
V. King (1901), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Boyd, J., Ill Fed., 730; 7 A. B. R., 176.
(9) [Submit to examinations.] When present at the
first meeting of his creditors, and at such other times as the
court shall order, submit to an examination concerning the
conducting of his business, the cause of his bankruptcy, his
dealings with his creditors and other persons, the amount,
kind, and whereabouts of his property, and, in addition, all
matters which may affect the administration and settlement
of his estate ; but no testimony given by him shall be offered
in evidence against him in any criminal proceeding.
Provided, however. That he shall not be required to attend
a meeting of his creditors, or at or for an examination at a
place more than one hundred and fifty miles distant from
his home or principal place of business, or to examine claims
except when presented to him, unless ordered by the court,
or a judge thereof, for cause shown, and the bankrupt shall
be paid his actual expenses from the estate when examined
or required to attend at any place other than the city,
town, or village of his residence.
Refusal to submit to examination contempt, Sec. 41a (4), post. As
to examination on question of solvency. Sec. 3d. ante. As to meetings
of creditors, see Sec. 55b. Form of order for examination of bankrupt.
Form No. 28. See also Sec. 21 and notes ante. Referee may examine
bankrupt, or cause him to be examined at instance of any creditor, Sec.
65, post, and notes.
§7 a.] DUTIES OF BANKRUPTS. 73
Witness may not be compelled to testify concerning gambling. In
re Feldstein (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 103 Fed., 269; 4 A. B. R.,
321; 2 N. B. N., 982.
Bankrupt may not be compelled to answer incriminating questions —
however it seems he may not claim the benefit of a discharge thereafter.
In re Hathhom (1900), E. Dist. La., Gurley, R., 2 A. B. R., 298; 1 N. B.
N., 361.
Bankrupt may not be required to give testimony which may incrimi-
nate him. In re Scott (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 95 Fed., 815;
1 A. B. R., 49; 1 N. B. N., 161.
Examination of bankrupt may be held after discharge, if within the
year. In re Peters (1899), Dist. Mass., Olmstead, R., 1 A. B. R., 248;
1 N. B. N., 165.
Where bankrupt is no longer in jeopardy by reason of a conviction,
no further protection is needed and he may be compelled to answer ques-
tons which otherwise might be incriminating. In re Franklin S5mdicate
(1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 101 Fed., 402; 4 A. B. R., 511; 2 N.
B. N., 522.
The evidence taken under the examination tmder this section can not
be used on objections to discharge. In re Marx, et al., (1900), Dist. Ky.
Evans, J., 102 Fed., 676; 4 A. B. R., 521.
Creditors who were not present at first meeting of creditors are entitled
to examine the bankrupt, on giving statutory notice without filing speci-
fications of objections to discharge. Costs of notices and examination
taxed against examining creditors. In re Price (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91 Fed., 635; 1 A. B. R., 419; 1 N. B. N., 131.
Bankrupt may not be examined as to circumstances of an assignment
for benefit of creditors, unless foundation laid for the belief that property
was concealed at the time of assignment and still is concealed by him.
In re Hayden (1899), S.- Dist. N. Y., Locke, J., 96 Fed., 199; 1 A. B. R.,
670; 1 N. B. N., 265.
Bankrupt can not refuse to produce books of account on ground that
they contain incriminating evidence. In re Sapiro (1899), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 92 Fed., 340; 1 A. B. R., 296; 1 N. B. N.. 136.
A creditor who is listed as such by a bankrupt, may examine the bank-
rupt before filing proof of claim. In re Walker, Dist. N. Dak., Amidoni
J., 96 Fed., 550; 3 A. B. R., 35; 1 N. B. N., 510.
Bankrupt required to attend for examination wherever reasonably
necessary. In re Mellen (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 326;
3 A. B. R., 226; 2 N. B. N., 69.
Examination of bankrupt and witnesses takes wide latitude. Books
74 bUTlES OP BANKRUPTS. t§7a.
of corporation in which bankrupt is interested may be produced. In re
Horgan & Slattery (1900), C. C. A.,2nd Cir., Opinion by Wallace, J., 98
Fed., 414; 3 A. B. R., 253; 2 N. B. N., 233.
Transactions prior to the passage of the act will be investigated if tend-
ing to show fraud occurring subsequent. In re Headley (1899) , W. Dist.
Mo., Phillips, J., 97 Fed., 765; 3 A. B. R., 272; 2 N. B. N., 250.
This section construed and bankrupt held bound to testify. Mackel
V. Rochester (1900), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Marrow, J., 102 Fed., 314; 4 A.,
B. R. 1; 2 N. B. N., 880.
Bankrupt must submit to examination at the instance of his trustee
as to the affairs and transactions connected with the bankrupt estate.
In re WestfaU & Bros. & Co. (1902), W. Dist. Cal., Wise, R.; 8 A. B. R.,
431.
Books and papers of a bankrupt corporation may not be used on in-
dictment against officers of a corporation to criminate them, where the
books and papers were taken from them by receiver. People v. Swartz
and Greenherg (1902), Kavanaugh, J.; 8 A. B. R., 487.
Bankrupt not compelled to testify or to turn over his books and papers,
where it is claimed by so doing he would be furnishing evidence which
would avail in a criminal charge pending — constitutional privilege can
not be invoked where the evidence could not possibly injure him. In
re Kauter & Cohen, S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 117 Fed., 356; 9 A. B. R.,
104.
Examination of bankrupt not limited to four months preceding bank-
ruptcy. In re Brtmdage (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 100 Fed., 613;
4 A. B. R., 47; compare In re Hayden (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Locke,
J., 96 Fed., 199; 1 A. B. R., 670.
Bankrupt having voluntarily moved out of jurisdiction of court while
proceedings pending therein, must pay his own expense on returning for
examination. In re Groves (1901), N. Dist. O., Remington, R.; 6 A.
B. R., 732.
Effect of the protection of the statute extends only to prosecutions
in the federal courts. In re Nachman (1902), Dist. S. C, Brawley, J.,
114 Fed., 995; 8 A. B. R., 180.
The constitutional privilege to refuse to answer questions tending to
incriminate may be raised by plea to petition of trustee to compel bank-
rupt to disclose and turn over assets. In re Glassner, Snyder & Co.
(1902), Dist. Md., Brinton, R., 8 A. B. R., 184.
Bankrupt not compelled to' answer questions which may tend to crimi-
nate him. In re Rosser (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Rogers, J., 96 Fed., 305;
2 A. B. R., 755; 1 N. B. N., 469.
§8 a.] DEATH OR INSANITY OF BANKRUPTS. 75
The bankrupt may not be compelled to answer incriminating questions.
In re Rosser (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Rogers, J., 96 Fed., 305; 2 A. B. R.,
755; IN. B. N., 469.
Duty of bankrupt to make a full and fair disclosure of all his business.
In re Grossman (1901), E. Dist. Mich., Swan, J., Ill Fed., 507; 6 A.
B. R., 510.
Creditor need not file his claim before examining bankrupt. In re
Walker (1899), Dist. N. Da., Amidon, J., 96 Fed., 550; 3 A. B. R., 35;
In re Jehu (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 94 Fed., 638; 2 A. B. R., 498
Bankrupt must attend and submit to examination on all reasonable
occasions. In re Lewensohn (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed.,
73; 3 A. B. R., 299.
Bankrupt not protected on cross-examination of matter he has
voltmteered. In re Walsh (1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Thompson, J., 104
Fed., 518; 4 A. B. R., 693.
Bankrupt's counsel should not participate in examination. In re
Kross (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 96 Fed., 816; 3 A. B. R., 187; 1
N. B. N., 566.
Bankruptcy act gives no immunity, except on matter of bankrupts'
testimony. In re Smith (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 112 Fed.,
509; 7 A. B. R., 213.
Sec. 8. Death or Insanity of Bankrupts.
a [Not to abate proceedings.] The death or insanity of
a bankrupt shall not abate the proceedings, but the same
shall be conducted and concluded in the same manner, so
far as possible, as though he had not died or become insane :
Provided, That in case of death the widow and children
shall be entitled to all rights of dower and allowance fixed
by the laws of the State of the bankrupt's residence.
See General Equity Rule 87 as to the appointment of guardian and
prochein ami.
Death of bankrupt will not stop proceedings on objections to discharge.
In re Parker (1899), Dist. Kan., White, R.; 1 A. B. R., 615; 1 N. B.
N., 1. 40.
Death of bankrupt before adjudication could not abate suit in invol-
untary case. In re Hicks (1901), Wheeler, J., Dist. Vt., 107 Fed., 910;
6 A. B. R., 182.
This section applies to a corporation voluntarily seeking a dissolution.
76 PROTECTION AND DETENTION OF BANKRUPTS. [§9a.
Scheuer v. Smith, etc., Co.(1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 112 Fed.,
407; 7 A. B. R., 384.
Exemptions of deceased bankrupt pass to his administrator. In re
Seabolt (1902), W. Dist. N. C, Boyd, J., 113 Fed., 766; 8 A. B. R., 57.
Dower in bankrupt's real estate preserved to widow. In re Shaeffer
(1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 105 Fed., 352; 4 A. B. R.,728.
Guardian of limatic bankrupt appointed. In re Burka (1901), W.
Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 107 Fed., 674; 5 A. B. R., 843.
Death of bankrupt after his personal estate is disposed of leaves no
allowance for widow — her dower in the real estate is not affected by his
death before it has been disposed of. In re Slack (1901), Dist. Vt.,
Wheeler, J., Ill Fed., 523; 7 A. B. R., 121; see also In re Seabolt (1902),
W. Dist. N. C, Boyd, J., 113 Fed., 766; 8 A. B. R., 57.
Sec. 9. Protection and Detention of Bankrupts.
a [Exemption from arrest.] A bankrupt shall be ex-
empt from arrest upon civil process except in the following
cases :
This section construed by general order XII — suspends exercise of
right of arrest pending application for discharge. In re Lewenson (1900)
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed., 73; 3 A. B. R., 594; 2 N. B. N., 315.
The exemption from arrest should be accompanied by the condition of
bankrupt filing bond not to abscond. In re Lewenson (1900), S. Dist
N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed., 73; 3 A. B. R., 594; 2 N. B. N., 315.
This section affords no protection against costs taxed at the time of
filing the petition. In re Marcus (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 104 Fed.,
331; 5 A. B. R., 19.
(1) [Process for contempt.] When issued from a court
of bankruptcy for contempt or disobedience of its lawful
orders ;
As to contempts see Sec. 41 and notes, post. See as to orders issued
by court of bankruptcy, Sec. 2 (15) and notes, ante.
(2) [Process from State court.] When issued from a
State coiut having jurisdiction, and served within such
State, upon a debt or claim from which his discharge in
bankruptcy would not be a release, and in such case he shall
be exempt from such arrest when in attendance upon a court
§9b.] PROTECTION AND DETENTION OF BANKRUPTS. 77
of bankruptcy or engaged in the performance of a duty-
imposed by this act.
As to debts not barred by discharge, see Sec. 17 and notes, post. For
definition of debt, see Sec. 1 (11) and notes, ante.
Provision of this section appUes to cases arising only after fihng peti-
tion. In re Claiborne (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 109 Fed., 74;
5 A. B. R., 812.
Bankrupt court will not release bankrupt from arrest by State court on
judgment for support of bastard child, such claim not being dischargeable.
In re Baker (1899), Dist. Kan., Hook, J., 96 Fed., 954; 3 A. B. R., 101;
1 N. B. N., 547.
Remedy of creditor on judgment for wages to arrest debtor under New
York statute is lost under bankruptcy procedure, and injunction will
issue. In re Grist (1899), N. Dist. N. Y. Hotchkiss, R.; 1 A. B. R., 89.
h [Detention for examination.] The judge may, at any
time after the fiHng of a petition by or against a person, and
before the expiration of one month after the qualification of
the trustee, upon satisfactory proof by the affidavits of at
least two persons that such bankrupt is about to leave the
district in which he resides or has his principal place of busi-
ness to avoid examination, and that his departure will
defeat the proceedings in bankruptcy, issue a warrant
to the marshal, directing him to bring such bankrupt
forthwith before the court for examination. If upon
hearing the evidence of the parties it shall appear to the
court or a judge thereof that the allegations are true and
that it is necessary, he shall order such marshal to keep such
bankrupt in custody not exceeding ten days, but not im-
prison him, until he shall be examined and released or give
bail conditioned for his appearance for examination, from
time to time, not exceeding in all ten days, as required by
the court, and for his obedience to all lawful orders made in
reference thereto.
For definition of judge, see Sec. 1 (16) and notes, ante. Refusal to
submit to examination by bankrupt is contempt. Sec. 41a (4), post.
This remedy shotUd be strictly construed and carefully applied. In
78 EXTRADITION OF BANKRUPTS. [ § 10 a. § 1 1 a
re Schenkein & Coney (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 113 Fed., 421;
7 A. B. R.. 162.
Warrant need not state that bankrupt is brought before the court for
examination. In re Lipke (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed.,
970; 3 A. B. R., 569.
This section applies merely- to restraining bankrupts from departing
from the district. In re Ketchum (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Clark, J.,
5 A. B. R.. 532.
Power of bankruptcy court does not extend to arrest of one not within
the district. In re Hassenbusch (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Clark, J.,
108 Fed., 35.
Sec. 10. Extradition of Bankrupts.
a [Proceedings under indictment govern.] Whenever a
warrant for the apprehension of a bankrupt shall have been
issued, and he shall have been found within the jurisdiction
of a court other than the one issuing the warrant, he may-
be extradited in the same manner in which persons under
indictment are now extradited from one district within
which a district court has jurisdiction to another.
See section 2, Sub. (14) ante, and notes thereunder. Section 10 de-
fines the same power as is defined in Sec. 2, Sub. (14). In re Hassenbusch
(1901) , C. C. A., 108 Fed., 35.
Only one warrant necessary to extradite from one district to another,
one to be delivered to sheriff from whose custody the prisoner is taken,
another to the sheriff to whom the custody is taken and the original
writ with the marshal's return thereon shall be returned to the clerk of
the District Cotu^ to which he is removed. U. S. Revised Statute, Sec.
1,029.
Sec. 11. Suits by and against Bankrupts.
a [Stay of suits.] A suit which is founded upon a claim
from which a discharge would be a release, and which is
pending against a person at the time of the filing of a pe-
tition against him, shall be stayed until after an adjud-
ication or the dismissal of the petition ; if such person is
adjudged a bankrupt, such action may be further stayed
until twelve months after the date of such adjudication, or,
§ 11 a.] SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. 79
if within that time such person applies for a discharge, then
until the question of such discharge is determined.
As to jurisdiction of State and United States Courts, see Sec. 25, post.
As to claims which discharge releases, see Sec. 17 and notes post. As to
discharges, see Sec. 14 and notes post. As to filing of petition, Gen.
Ord. II. Question of staying suit may be referred to referee. Gen.
Order XII (3) post. See c under this section and notes thereunder.
As to meaning of "adjudication" see Sec. 1 (2).
Creditor's bill by which lien was acquired more than four months before
filing bankruptcy petition, should not be stayed. Continental Nat. Bank
V. Katz (1899), Sup. Ct. Cook County, Ills., Ball, J.; 1 A. B. R., 19; 1 N. B.
N., 165.
Although the lien was acquired less than four months before the pe-
tition, stay order denied. Reed v. Cross (1899), Sup. Ct. Cook County,
Ills., Ball, J., 1 A. B. R., 34; 1 N. B. N., 267.
Creditor's bill on judgment attaching is fraudulent. Conveyance en-
joined where granted filed same inside four months grantee having re-
conveyed to bankrupt. In re Brown (1899), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J.
91 Fed., 358; 1 A. B. R., 107; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Bankruptcy court may restrain attachment sale of property pending
filing of involimtary petition. Blake, et al., v. Francis Valentine Co.
(1899), N. Dist. Cal., Hawley, J., 89 Fed., 691; 1 A. B. R., 372; 1 N. B,
N., 47.
The granting of an injunction is a matter of discretion. The Dis-
trict Court has plenary pow^ers where suit in a State Court is on a debt to
which a discharge would be a release. In re Globe Cycle Works (1899),
N. Dist. N.Y., Hotchkiss, R., 2 A. B. R., 447; 1 N. B. N., 421.
State court no jurisdiction to appoint a receiver after filing of bankrupt-
cy petition. Carpenter v. O'Conner (1898), Ohio Cir. Ct., 2nd Dist., Opin-
ion by Wilson, J., 1 A. B. R., 381; 9 Ohio Cir. Dis., 201.
Power to stay suits discretionary with the District Court. In re Lesser
(1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., LaCombe, J., 99 Fed., 913; 3 A. B. R., 758; 2
N. B. N.. 599.
Suit in a State Court to settle bankruptcy account as administrator
will be stayed pending hearing on application for discharge. In re Rogers
(1899), Dist. Ky., Howard, R., 1 A. B. R., 541; 1 N. B. N., 211.
Proceedings to foreclose chattel mortgage will not be stayed by a court
of bankruptcy — trustee should appear in the State Court. In re Bunt-
rock Clothing Co. (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 92 Fed., 886; 2 A. B. R.
98; 1 N. B. N., 291.
Courts of bankruptcy will stay proceedings supplementary to execu-
80 SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. [§11 a.
tion in a State Court. In re Kletchka (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 92 Fed., 901; 1 A. B. R., 479; 1 N. B. N., 160.
Trustee having brought suit to set aside transfer in state court the
previous jtuisdiction of the United States coUrt in having enjoined the
defendant does not bar the State Court. Bindseil v. Smith (1900), Ct.
of App., N. J., Dixon, J., 5 A. B. R., 40.
After adjudication it is entirely discretionary with the bankruptcy
court to stay proceedings of the State Court and require a sale of mortgaged
property to be made by the trustee in bankruptcy. Bankruptcy court shall
not interfere with the proceedings where it is apparent that not enough
will be realized to satisfy the mortgage debt. In re HoUoway (1899),
Dist. Ky., Evan^, J., 93 Fed., 638; 1 A. B. R., 659; 1 N. B. N., 254.
To justify granting an injunction restraining attachment proceed-
ings prior to filing involuntary petition, it must appear that suit by trus-
tee would be an inadequate remedy. In re Ogles (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 93 Fed., 426; 1 A. B. R., 671; 1 N. B. N., 400.
Judgment in State Court may be enjoined when it was obtained by
fraud. So. Loan Co & Trust v. Benbow (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart,
J., 96 Fed., 514; 3 A. B. R., 9; 1 N. B. N., 499.
Where it seems that the mortgage exceeds the value of the property
the District Court will not enjoin the foreclosure. In re Porter & Bros.
(1901), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 109 Fed., Ill; 6 A. B. R., 259.
State Court has no right to proceed with an action there pending. Car-
penter Bros. v. O'Connor (1898), Ohio Cir. Ct., 2nd Cir.; 1 A. B. R., 381;
9 Ohio Cir. Dis., 201.
District Court has jurisdiction to restrain replevin proceedings in
State Court. In re Agins (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.; 1 N. B. N., 184.
Staying of stiit for bankrupt in state court, will not affect right of plaint-
iff as surety on a bond given in the proceedings. In re Marten (1901),
W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 105 Fed., 753; 5 A. B. R., 423.
An injunction issued by a referee restraining an action in the State
court against a bankrupt does not release persons jointly liable with the
bankrupt. In r^ Delong (1899), Nor. Dist. N. Y., Moss, R., 1 A. B. R.,
66; 1 N. B. N., 26.
Execution to enforce alimony against bankrupt will not be enjoined.
Turner v. Turner (1901), Dist. Ind. Baker, J., 108 Fed., 785; 6 A. B. R.,
287.
District Court no jurisdiction to enjoin suit for trespass against United
States Marshal, McLean v. Mc^yo (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Purncll, J., 113
Fed., 106; 7 A. B. R., 115.
Proceedings in State Court supplementary to execution may be en-
§ 11a.] SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. 81
joined. In re Kletchka (1899), Sou. Dist. N. Y., Bro^vTi, J., 92 Fed.
901; 1 A. B. R., 479; 1 N. B. N., 160.
Chattel mortgagee in possession may be enjoined from selling. In re
Nathan (1899), Dist. Nev., Hawley, J., 92 Fed., 590; 1 N. B. N., 563.
Suit against trustee may be enjoined. In re Gutman & Wenk (1902)
S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 114 Fed., 1,009; 8 A. B. R., 252.
Injunction granted to restrain ejectment suit in State court. In re
Chambers, Calder & Co. (1900), Dist. R. I., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 865; 3
A. B. R., 537; 2 N. N. N.. 388.
Bankruptcy Court may enjoin pending execution and levy. In re
Kimball (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 97 Fed., 29; 1 N. B. N., 515.
Mortgage foreclosure may be enjoined and property sold in bankruptcy
court where it seems to be for the interest of the estate. In re Booth
(1899), N. Dist. Ga., Upson, R., 2 A. B. R., 771; 1 N. B. N., 476.
Jurisdiction of District Court does not authorize the enjoining of a
suit in a state court begun years before — doctrine of Bardes v. Hawarden
Bank again announced; Pickens v. Dent (1902), Sup. Ct., U. S., Fuller,
J.; 9 A. B. R., 47.
Where a petition for an injunction in a pending bankruptcy proceed-
ing describes as "In the District Court of the United States for the
Northern District of New York, in bankruptcy No. 1141" is specific
enough to give them court jurisdiction. In re Goldberg (1902) , N. Dist.
N. Y., Roy, 117 Fed., 692; 9 A. B. R., 156.
This section does not prevent entry of a special judgment on a verdict
where defendant had been adjudicated bankrupt after verdict, where
the security on bond is still liable. Rosenthal v. Nove et al. (1900), Sup.
Ct., Mass., Barker, J., 175 Mass., 559.
Action in State Court should be stayed pending disposition of bank-
ruptcy proceedings against defendant. First Nat. Bank v. Hym (1902),
Sup. Ct. la., McLain, J.; 91 N. W., 784.
Application for stay of proceedings should be made in State Court.
Mclntyre v. Malone et al. (1902), Sup. Ct. Neb., 91 N. W., 246.
Application by mortgagee for stay of foreclostire proceedings in State
Court by reason of bankruptcy proceedings denied. Carter v. People's
Nat. Bank (1900), Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 109 Ga., 573.
Stay of proceedings not granted where the lien wtis obtained more
than four months before. Smith v. Meisinheimer (1898), Sup. Ct. Ky.,
Lev/is, J., 20 Ky. Law Rep., 954.
Vacation of judgment against bankrupt not granted trustee as he had
adequate remedy by action to recover property. Gage v. Bates Mach.
Co. (1902), Sup. Ct. N. H., Wather, J., 52 Atl., 457.
82 SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. [§ Ha.
Jurisdiction in bankruptcy court to enjoin creditor proceeding in
State court sustained. In re Kimball (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington,
J., 97 Fed., 29; 3 A. B. R., 161; 1 N. B. N., 515.
Section 11 applies to both voluntary and involuntary cases. In re
Gister (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.. 97 Fed., 322; 3 A. B. R., 228; 2
N. B. N., 297.
Better practice is to apply for stay in State court. Idetn.
Proceedings to foreclose chattel mortgage will not be stayed by a
court of bankmptcy — the trustee should appear in the State court. In
re Buntrock Clothing Co., N. Dist., la., Shiras, J. (1899), 92 Fed., 886;
2A. B. R., 98;1N. B. N., 91.
After adjudication it is entirely discretionary with the bankruptcy
court to stay proceedings of State court and require a sale of mortgaged
property to be made by trustee in bankruptcy. Bankruptcy court
should not interfere with proceedings where it is apparent that not enough
will be realized to satisfy the mortgage debt — Sec. 11 and Sec. 45 con-
strued. In re HoUoway (1899), Dist. of Ky., Evans, J., 93 Fed., 638;
1 A. B. R., 659; 1 N. B. N., 264.
Landlord restrained from making ejectment where its enforcement
would prejudice the estate. In re Chambers, Coldeer & Co. (1900), Dist.
R. I., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 865; 3 A. B. R., 537; 2 N. B. N., 388.
Courts of bankruptcy may grant an injtmction restraining the assignee
xmder general assignment from disposing of or interfering with the prop-
erty which comes into his hands until a petition in bankruptcy is disposed
of. In re Gutwillig (1899), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., opinion, Wallace, J., 92
Fed., 337; 1 A. B. R., 388; 1 N. B. N., 340.
Bankruptcy court has power to issue injunction restraining mortgagee
from foreclosing liens and to order property of bankrupt sold free from
liens. In re Pittelkow (1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 92 Fed., 901;
1 A. B. R., 472; 1 N. B. N., 234.
Replevin sviit in state court restrained where property in hands of
trustee. In re Russel (1900), N, Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 101 Fed., 248;
5 A. B. R., 566; 3 N. B. N., 365. In re Guttman & Wenk (1902), S.Dist.
N. Y., Adams, J., 114 Fed., 1,009; 8 A. B. R., 252.
Courts of bankruptcy will stay proceedings supplementary to execu-
tion in a state court. In re Kletchke (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.,
92 Fed., 901; 1 A. B. R., 479; 1 N. B. N., 160.
Proceedings in state court to enforce mechanic's liens should be en-
joined. In re Emsile (1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 98 Fed., 716;
4 A. B. R., 126; 2 N. B. N., 171.
§ 11 a.] SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. 83
Mortgage foreclosure stayed in state cotirt where commenced after
bankruptcy, to determine validity of mortgage. In re San. Gabrie
San. Co. (1900), C. C. A., 9th Cir., 102 Fed., 310; 4 A. B. R., 197; 1 N.
B. N., 390.
State court appointing receiver of realty claimed by trustee — discus-
sion of question involved. Porter v. Cummings (1900), Sup. Ct. Ga.,
Fish, J., 1 N. B. N., 520.
Injunction to restrain paying out of money realized by execution sale
will not be granted where the purpose is to stay the proceedings imtil
bankruptcy proceedings can be instituted. Victor v. Lewis (1899), N.
Y. Sup. Ct., 1 A. B. R., 667; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Suit in state court restrained sufficiently to enable trustee to inter-
vene. In re Klein (1900), N. Dist. lU., Kohlsaat, J., 97 Fed., 31; 3
A. B. R., 174; 1 N. B. N., 486.
Proceedings in garnishment in state court against bankrupt may be
stayed or not in the discretion of the bankruptcy court. In re St. Albans
Foundry Co. (1900), Dist. Vt., Mott, R.; 4 A. B. R., 594; 2 N. B. N., 1,093.
Jurisdiction of district court is sustained to stay proceedings in state
court. Habeas Corpus from district court will release bankrupt who is
held by state court under order for omitting to pay alimony, which by
district court decree was held a provable and dischargeable debt. State
court may not review the conclusions of the decree of the District Court.
Wagner v. United States et al. (1900), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 104 Fed.,
133. 4 A. B. R., 596.
Jurisdiction in district Court to enjoin disposition of property claimed
as belonging to the estate, though it is in the possession of third parties,
vmtil such time as a trustee might bring appropriate suit. In re Currier
(1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 5 A. B. R., 639.
Jurisdiction in District court to enjoin proceedings against the bank-
rupt property pending in State court at time of bankruptcy. Picken v.
Dent et al. (1901), C.C. A., 4th Cir., Goff, J., 106 Fed., 653; 5 A. B. R., 644.
The jurisdiction of state courts and courts of bankruptcy over adminis-
tration of insolvent estates is not concurrent — the latter have paramount
jurisdiction. Leidigh Co. v. Stengl (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Taft, J.,
95 Fed.. 637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 387.
Jurisdiction of District court is not shown in case of agent of bankrupt
withholding assets to compel surrender of the same. Resort must be
had to plenary suit in State court. In re Nugent {Wayne Knitting
Mills V. Nugent) (1900), C. C. A.. 6th Cir., Severens, J., 104 Fed., 530; 4
A. B. R., 747.
Bankruptcy court may restrain third person from changing status of
84 SUITS BY AND AGAINST BANKRUPTS. [§llb.
property whicfe is claimed as part of assets of the estate. In re Smith
(1902). N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 113 Fed., 993; 8 A. B. R., 55.
This section applies only to suits that are pending and proceedings
therein. In re Claiborne (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 109 Fed.,
74; 5 A. B. R., 812.
Suit on tmliquidated claim after adjudication stayed. In re Hilton
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 104 Fed., 981; 4 A. B. R., 774.
Action for false representation not stayed as not dischargeable. In
re Cole (1901), W. Dist. N. Y.. Hazel, J., 106 Fed., 837; 5 A. B. R., 780.
Stay of proceedings to enable bankrupt to plead his discharge. In
re Rosenthal (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 108 Fed., 368; 5 A.B.
R., 799.
Stay order not granted against suit for over due alimony. In re Shep-
ard (1899), 8. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 187; 5 A. B. R., 857.
In re Houston (1899) , Dist. of Ky., Evans, J., 94 Fed., 119; 2 A. B. R., 107.
Garnishment and attachment will be restrained pending discharge.
In re Beerman (1901), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 112 Fed., 662; 7A;
B. R., 431; Bear v. Chase (1900), C. C. 4th Cir., WaddiU, J., 99 Fed., 920.
3 A. B. R., 746.
b [Appearance of trustee ordered.] The cotirt may order
the trustee to enter his appearance and defend any pend-
ing suit against the bankrupt.
As to jurisdiction of U. S. and State Courts, see Sec. 23 and notes.
Trustee must apply to state court and be governed by its rules and
practice. Bank of Commerce v. Elliott (1901), Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall,
J., 109 Wis., 648; 6 A. B. R., 409.
It is within the discretion of the state court to allow trustee to inter-
vene. National Distilling Co. v. Seidel (1899), Sup. Ct. Wis., 1; 103 Wis.,
484.
Trustee becomes liable for costs and damages, having substituted
himself for defendant bankrupt in a replevin suit. In re Neely (1902).
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Lacombe, J., 113 Fed., 210; 7 A. B. R., 312.
Under New York statute trustee must give bonds for cause of action
accruing prior to his appointment. Joseph v. Makley (1902), Sup. Ct
N. Y., App. Div., O'Brien, J., 8 A. B. R., 18.
It is discretionary with the State court to permit trustee to be made a
party — trustee must appear and defend according to the rules of the State
court. National Distilling Co. v. Seidel (1899), Sup. Wis., Marshall, J.,
103 Wis., 489.
§12a.] COMPOSITIONS, WHEN CONFIRMED. §5
c [i'TOSCCution of suit by trustee.] A trustee may, with
the approval of the court, be permitted to prosecute as
trustee any suit commenced by the bankrupt prior to the
adjudication, with like force and effect as though it had been
commenced by him.
As to suits by trustee, see Sec. 23b and notes. See also Sec. 60b and
notes.
Trustee having submitted to jurisdiction of state court in collecting a
lien due the estate is bound by the decision of that court. In re Van
Alstyne, N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 100 Fed., 929; 4 A. B. R., 42; 2 N. B, N.,
642.
This section construed in favor of jurisdiction of bankruptcy court
in suits by trustee against third persons. In re Boudouine (1900) , C. C. A.,
2nd. Cir., Wallace, J., 96 Fed., 536; 3 A. B. R., 651; 1 N. B. N., 506.
Where state court has taken jurisdiction by suit by trustee in bank-
ruptcy the United States court has no revisory power. Robinson v. White
(1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 97 Fed., 33; 3 A. B- R., 88; 1 N. B. N., 613.
This section relates only to those actions that are part of the bank-
rupt's estate — action for malicious prosecution no part of bankrupt's
estate. In re Haensel (1899), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 91 Fed., 355;
1 A. B. R., 286; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Trustee must go in the state court and ask to have receiver of property
belonging to the bankrupt turn same over to trustee. In re B. L. Price
& Co (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown. J., 92 Fed., 987; 1 A. B. R., 606;
1 N. B. N., 240.
d [Two years limitation.] Suits shall not be brought by
or against a trustee of a bankrupt estate subsequent to
two years after the estate has been closed.
As to closing estates, see Sec. 2 (8) and notes. As to duties of trustees
in closing estates, see Sec. 47 a and notes. See for suits by trustee Sec.
23b and notes, also a 6 c of this section.
Sec 12. Compositions, when Confirmed.
a [Wlien may be offered.] A bankrupt may offer terms
of composition to his creditors after, but not before, he has
been examined in open court or at a meeting of his creditors
and filed in court the schedule of his property and list of his
creditors, required to be filed by bankrupts.
86 COMPOSITIONS, WHEN CONFIRMED, ' [§12b.
As to examination of bankrupt, see Sec. 7 (9) and notes ante. As to
examination at first meeting of creditors, see Sec. 55b and notes, post.
As to schedule of property and list of creditors see Sec. 7 (8) and notes.
See also bed and e under this section and notes.
The sections of act which compel dissenting creditors to be bound
and to accept the composition must be strictly construed. In re Rider
(1899). N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 96 Fed., 808; 3 A. B. R., 178.
Composition must be offered to all and all must have a chance to accept-
In re Rider (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 96 Fed., 808; 3 A. B. R.,
178.
Composition does not affect the rights of secured creditors — they are
not parties to it and have no provable claims and their objections are
not to be regarded. In re Kahn (1902), S. Dist. N .Y., Wise, R., 9 A.
B. R., 107.
b [Application for confirming.] An application for the
confirmation of a composition may be filed in the court of
bankruptcy after, but not before, it has been accepted in
writing by a majority in number of all creditors whose claims
have been allowed, which number must represent a majority
in amount of such claims, and the consideration to be paid
by the bankrupt to his creditors, and the money necessary
to pay all debts which have priority and the cost of the pro-
ceedings, have been deposited in such place as shall be
designated by and subject to the order of the judge.
Application may be referred to a referee. Gen. Ord. XII (3). Peti-
tion for meetng to consider composition Form No. 60 and notes. No-
tices to creditors of hearings on application for confirmation of com-
position, see Sec. 58a (2) and notes. See a, c and d of this section.
Assignee of large number of creditors counted as one creditor only.
In re Messengill (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 113 Fed., 366; 7 A.
B. R., 669.
Composition will be rejected where majority do not concur and all
have not had notice. In re Rider (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 96
Fed., 808; 3 A. B. R., 178.
Creditors having once accepted composition offered them will not
b« allowed to withdraw their . consent in the absence of fraud. In re
Levy (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 110 Fed., 744; 6 A. B. R., 299.
Amount deposited for costs must be sufficient in order to confirm. In
re Rider (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 96 Fed., 808; 3 A. B. R., 178.
§12cd.] COMPOSITIONS, WHEN CONFIRMED. 87
c [Hearing application.] A date and place, with refer-
ence to the convenience of the parties in interest, shall be
fixed for the hearing upon each application for the con-
firmation of a composition, and such objections as may be
made to its confirmation.
Creditors must have at least ten days notice of hearing. Sec. 58a
(2) and notes. As to opposition to composition, see Gen. Ord. XXXII.
Creditors who oppose composition should enter their appearance and
file specifications in writing of the grounds of their opposition. City
Nat. Bank v. Doolittle (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Touhnin, J., 107 Fed.,
236; 5 A. B. R., 736; Adler v. Jones (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir.; Day, J.,
109 Fed., 967; 6 A. B. R., 245.
Notice of hearing given by referee. In re Hilbom (1900) , S. Dist. N.
Y., Brown, J., 104 Fed., 866.
Burden is on the objecting creditors to show that action of the major-
ity is not for the best interests of all the creditors. In re Heyman (1901) ,
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 108 Fed., 207.
Confirmation of a composition proposed by the bankrupt followed
by dismissal of the case discharges bankrupt from all ordinary claims —
not necessary that holders participated in ' composition proceedings.
Glover Grocery Co. v. Dome (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Liunpkin, J., 42 S.
E., 347; 8 A. B. R., 702.
Confirmation of composition does not bar right of action against
the stockholders on their subscription. Wood v.Vanderveer (1900), Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Ramsey, J., 55 N. Y. App. Div., 549.
Unless confirmation provides for costs it will not be confirmed. In
re Harris (1902), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 117 Fed., 575; 9 A. B
R., 20.
d [When composition confirmed.] The judge shall con-
' firm a composition if satisfied that
(1) [Best interest of creditors.] It is for the best in-
terests of the creditors;
Matter of composition may be referred to a referee on questions of
fact. Adler v. Jones (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 109 Fed., 967;
6 A. B. R., 245.
As to appeal where confirmation is referred, see Sec. 24o and notes.
88 COMPOSITIONS, WHEN CONFIRMED. [§12d.
(2) [Bankrupt entitled to discharge.] The bankrupt has
not been guilty of any of the acts or failed to perform any
of the duties which would be a bar to his discharge ; and
As to discharge when granted, see Sec. 14b and notes. As to duties
of bankrupts, see Sec. 7a.
(3) [Offer must be in good faith.] The offer and its
acceptance are in good faith and have not been made or
procured except as herein provided, or by any means,
promises, or acts herein forbidden.
When composition confirmed title revests in bankrupt. Sec. 70f.
As to discharge after composition, see Sec. 14c post. Objectors to
confirmation of composition must file specifications. Gen. Ord. XXXII.
For forms relating to compositions, see forms No. 60 to 63, inclusive.
Creditors must have at least ten days' notice of hearing for confirma-
tion of compositions. Sec. 58a (2) post. On revocation of composition,
property is to be applied to the payment of claims. Sec. 64 post.
No appeal from decision of creditors on offer of composition. In re
Adler (1900), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 103 Fed., 444; 4 A. B. R.,
583; 3 N. B. N., 15.
After a composition an action commenced by trustee will enure to the
benefit of the bankrupt. Stone v. Jenkins (1900) , Sup. Ct. Mass., Morton,
J., 4 A. B. R., 568; 57 N. E., 1,002.
Objections to composition that it is not for the best interests of the
estate — burden on the objector to prove it. City Nat. Bank v. Doolittle
(1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Toulmin, J., 107 Fed., 236; 5 A. B. R., 736.
Refusal of District court to approve composition will not be reviewed
imless it appears that the discretion of the court was abused. Adler
v. Jones (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 109 Fed., 967; 6 A. B. R., 245.
When composition agreement once signed by creditors, they may not
withdraw consent in absence of fraud. In re Levy (1901), W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 110 Fed., 744; 6 A. B. R., 299.
Referee no jurisdiction unless specifically conferred, to hear claims
on composition. In re Fox (1900), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 6
A. B. R., 525; 3 N. B. N., 1,012.
An assignee of a number of claims counts as only one vote. In re
Messingill (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 113 Fed., 366; 7 A. B. R.,
669.
Composition should be confirmed if no misconduct is shown and the
proposition offered substantially all the estate will produce. /« r^ H. J.
§l4a] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 89
Arrington Co. (1902), E. Dist, Va., Waddill, J., 113 Fed., 498; 8 A. B.
R. 64.
Composition should be confirmed unless it clearly appears it would be
for the interest of the creditors to reject it. In re Criterion Watch Case
Mfg. Co. (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 8 A. B. R., 206.
e [Distribution of assets.] Upon the confirmation of a
composition, the consideration shall be distributed as the
judge shall direct, and the case dismissed. Whenever a
composition is not confirmed, the estate shall be admin-
istered in bankruptcy as herein provided.
Sec. 13. Compositions, When Set Aside.
a [When fraud practiced.] The judge may, upon the
application of parties in interest filed at any time within
six months after a composition has been confirmed, set
the same aside and reinstate the case if it shall be made to
appear upon a trial that fraud was practiced in the procuring
of such composition, and that the knowledge thereof has
come to the petitioners since the confirmation of such com-
position.
See ante Sec. 12 and notes. As to disposition of property when com-
position set aside, see post, 64c.
Compositions may be set aside only for fraud. This section limits
and qualifies Sec. 2 (9). An error in address of creditors in schedules,
whereby he receives no notice, will not set composition aside. In re
Rudnick (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 93 Fed., 787; 2 A. B. R., 114;
1 N. B. N., 531.
Sec. 14. Discharges, When Granted.
a [Application for Discliarge.] Any person may, after
the expiration of one month and within the next twelve
months subsequent to being adjudged a bankrupt, file an
application for a discharge in the court of bankruptcy in
which the proceedings are pending; if it shall be made to
appear to the judge that the bankrupt was unavoidably
00 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§l4b.
prevented from filing it within such time, it may be filed
within but not after the expiration of the next six
months.
For definition of discharge, see Sec. 1 (12) ante, and notes. Creditors shall
have at least ten days' notice of application for discharge. Sec. 58(2) and
notes post. As to revocation of discharge, see Sec. 15 post, and notes.
Application for discharge may be referred to referee. Gen. Ord. XII.
As to petitions for discharges and what petition should state, see Gen.
Orders XXXI and XXXII. As to proceedings in opposition to discharge
see Gen. Ord. XXXII. Petition for discharge must be verified. Sec.
18 and notes />05<. For form of petition f»r discharge, see form 57. For
form of order for discharge, see form 59.
Court without power to discharge xmless application made within
eighteen months. In re Fahy (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 116 Fed.,
239; 8 A. B. R., 354.
No second petition allowable after first petition is denied. The practice
on reference to referee of hearing on objections to discharge is that before
a special master, exceptions to findings of fact must be taken. Othei--
wise such findings are conclusive. Grand jury having found no bill on
case presented on which discharge was refused, is no ground for vacating
order denying discharge. In re Royal (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J.,
113 Fed., 140; 7 A. B. R., 636.
Application must be within the time limit of the statute. In re Wolff
(1900), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 100 Fed., 430.
Petition for additional six months must be within the time limit.
/« r^ Fahy (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 116 Fed., 239; 8 A. B. R., 354.
h [Hearing application.] The judge shall hear the appli-
cation for a discharge, and such proofs and pleas as may be
made in opposition thereto by parties in interest, at such
time as will give parties in interest a reasonable oppor-
tunity to be fully heard, and investigate the merits of the
application and discharge the applicant unless he has
Specifications of objections must be filed by the creditors opposing
discharge. Gen. Ord. XXXII and Form No. 58. As to conduct of pro-
ceedings, see Gen. Ord. IV and notes.
Advice of counsel, although not always sufficient excuse, may be
allowed as an explanation. /« r^ Schreck (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotch-
kiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 366; 1 N. B. N., 334.
Objections to discharge must be specific, not general. In re Dixon
§l4b.] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 91
(1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 93 Fed., 440; 1 A, B. R., 610; 1 N. B.
N., 326.
General discharge does not affect the question as to what debts are
barred by it. In re Tinker (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed.,
79; 3 A. B. R., 580; 2 N. B. N., 391.
Specification of objections to discharge must be as specific as an in-
dictment. In re Hirsch (1899), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 96 Fed.,
468; 2 A. B. R., 715; 2 N. B. N., 137.
Specifications of objections to discharge must be based on one or both
of the two grounds enumerated in the act. In re Thomas (1899), S.
Dist. la., Woolson, J., 92 Fed., 912; 1 A. B. R., 515; 1 N. B. N., 329.
Insufficient specifications of objections to discharge should be stricken
out. In re Holman (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 92 Fed., 512;
1 A. B. R., 600; 1 N. B. N., 552.
Denial of discharge for partnership no bar to application of individual
member for discharge. In re Feigenbaiun (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams,
J., 7 A. B. R., 339.
Bankrupt organizing bogus corporation for purpose of concealing
assets not entitled to discharge. In re Wertheimer (1900), S. Dist. N.
Y., Adams, J., 6 A. B. R., 756.
A creditor whose claims are not barred by discharge cannot move to
vacate discharge. In re Monroe (1902), Dist. Wash., Hanford, J., 114
Fed., 398; 7 A. B. R., 706.
Discharge of a debt by bankruptcy proceedings is not prevented by
reason of the discharge being refused in previous state insolvency pro-
ceedings. Dean v. Justices, etc.. Sup. Ct., Mass., Holmes, J. (1899); 2
A. B. R., 163; 1 N. B. N., 336.
Discharge of partners on individual petitions without showing non-
existence of firm assets, not granted. In re Meyers (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 757; 2 A. B. R., 707; 1 N. B. N., 515.
A bankrupt creditor corporation is dischargeable — such discharge does
not affect the secondary liability of officers. In re Marshall Paper Co.
(1900), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Colt, J., 102 Fed., 872; 4 A. B. R. 468; 2 N. B.
N., 1,053.
Discharge refused where sole creditor's claim was not dischargeable on
ground of being wilful and malicious injury to person. In re Maples,
Dist. Mont., Knowles, J., 105 Fed., 919; 5 A. B. R., 426.
Examination of bankrupt may be used as evidence on objection to dis-
charge. In re Cooke (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 5 A. B. R., 434.
Partnership petition not basis for discharge of individual where all
92 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§ 14b.
proceedings arcj partnership in character. In re Hale, ct al. (1901) , E. Dist.
N. C, PximeU, J., 107 Fed., 432; 6 A. B. R.. 35.
Fraudtilent conduct of bankrupt prior to bankruptcy no ground for
refusing discharge. In re Steed & Curtis (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
nell, J., 107 Fed., 682; 6 A. B. R., 73; 3 N. B. N., 941.
Fact that bankrupt owes but one debt does not bar right to discharge.
In re Frank (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 6 A. B. R., 156; 3 N. B
N., 35.
On objections to discharge and reference to a referee, referee can pass
on admissibiUty of evidence — he has no authority to allow amendments.
In re Kaiser (1900), Dist. Minn., Lochren, J., 99 Fed., 689; 3 A. B. R., 767;
2 N. B. N., 123.
Partnership may be discharged; so long as debts exist partnership con-
tinues. In re Hirsch (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 571;
3 A. B. R., 344; 2 N. B. N., 137.
Question of jurisdiction on ground of want of domicile can not b« raised
on objection to discharge. In re Clisdell (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe,
J.. 101 Fed., 246; 4 A. B. R., 95; 2 N. B. N., 638.
Application for discharge more than eighteen months after adjudica-
tion nwnc pro tunc not allowed. In re Wolff (1900) , N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven,
J., 100 Fed., 430; 4 A. B. R., 74; 2 N. B. N., 908.
Specifications of objections to discharge must be definite and certain
and allege statutory ground. In re Peacock (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
neU, J., 101 Fed., 560; 4 A. B. R., 136; 2 N. B. N., 758.
Death of bankrupt will not prevent or stop proceedings on objections
to discharge. In re Parker (1899), Dist. Kans., White, R., 1 A. B. R..
615; 1 N. B. N., 261.
Courts of bankruptcy may award costs against creditors who file ob-
jections to discharge. In re Wolpert (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss
R.; 1 A. B. R., 436; 1 N. B. N., 238.
Hearing will be deferred until fees are paid. In re Barden (1900),
E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 101 Fed., 553; 4 A. B. R., 31; In re Fees pay-
able by voluntary bankrupts (1899), Dist. Wash., Hanford, J., 95 Fed.,
120.
Statements false in matters of slight consequence no bar. In re
Miner (1902), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 114 Fed., 998; 8 A. B. R., 248.
Where intentional fraudulent transfer made discharge will be re-
fused. In re Schenck (1902), Dist. Washington, Hanford, J., 116 Fed..
654; 8 A. B. R., 727.
Amendments of specifications liberally allowed. In re Carley (1902)
C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 117 Fed., 130; 8 A. B. R., 720.
§l4b.] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 93
Defects in specifications waived where' not raised on hearing. In re
Osborne (1902), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 115 Fed., 1; 8 A. B R., 165
Bankrupt need not demur to specifications to avail himself of their
insiifficiency. In re Crist (1902), S. Dist. Ala., Toxilmin, J., 116 Fed.,
1,007; 9 A. B. R., 1.
If no objection is made the court will presume that no reason exists
for not granting a discharge. In re Royal (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell,
J., 113 Fed., 140; 7 A. B. R., 636.
Discharge of individual members of a firm refused where the adjudica-
tion is only of the firm. Strause v. Hooper (1901) , E. Dist. N. C, Pumell,
J., 105 Fed., 590; 5 A. B. R., 225; 3 N. B. N., 276.
Testimony of other witness than the bankrupt on first meeting not com-
petent on objections to discharge. In re Wilcox (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Shipman, J., 109 Fed., 628; 6 A. B. R., 362; 3 N. B. N., 876.
Burden of proof on objecting creditors. Idem.
Practice — no answer or other pleading by bankrupt to a specification
necessary — a false oath made by bankrupt in his examination no ground
for objection to his discharge — .
Objection to discharge cannot be taken pro confesso. In re Logan
(1900), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 102 Fed., 876; 4 A. B. R., 525; 2 N. B-
N., 1,056.
Discharge not obtainable on individual petition against firm debts un-
less all the petition and notices so declare — instructions as to procedure.
In r^Hartman (1899), N.Dist.Ia.,Shiras, J. ,96 Fed., 593; 3 A.B. R., 65.
To same effect in re McFaun (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed.,
592; 3 A. B. R., 66.
Objections to discharge must show that the intent was unlawful.
Smith v. Keegan (1901), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., Ill Fed., 157; 7
A. B. R., 4.
The burden of proof is on the person who objects to discharge of bank-
rupt. In re Idzall (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 96 Fed., 314; 2
A. B. R., 741.
Objection to discharge must aver distinctly the facts. Referee no
power to allow amendments to specifications. In re Wolfensohn (1900),
S. Dist. N. Y., Dexter, R., 5 A. B. R., 60.
Fraudulent transfer is not necessarily a bar to discharge. In re
Crenshaw, S. Dist. Ala., Toulmin, J,, 95 Fed., 632; 2 A. B. R., 623.
Oversight in making a schedule is not a bar to discharge. Idem.
Quere: May bankrupt corporation be entitled to discharge. In re
Marshall Paper Co. (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 95 Fed., 419; 2 A. B.
94 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§l4b.(l)
R., 653; 1 N. B. N., 407. It is entitled to discharge In re Marshall
Paper Co. (1900), C. C. A., 102 Fed., 872.
Specification of objections to discharge may, in the discretion of the
court, be filed nunc pro tunc — creditor held not to have proved his claim.
In re Price (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 96 Fed., 611; 2 A. B. R.,
674; 1 N. B. N., 432.
Grounds of objection to discharge must be proved by clear and con-
vicning testimony. In re Howden (1901), N. Dist. N". Y., Coxe, J., Ill
Fed., 723; 7 A. B.R., 191 contra, Knott v. Putnam (1901), Dist. Va.,
Wheeler, J., 107 Fed., 907; 6 A. B. R., 80.
Discharge not refused because of a claim based on fraud. In re
Rhutassell, (1899), N.Dist. la., Shiras,J., 96 Fed., 597; 2 A. B. R., 697;
1 N. B. N., 572.1
Decision of lower court on question of discharge will be sustained, un-
less the decision is clearly against the weight of evidence. Duplicity of
pleading should be raised below, not in the Appellate Court for the first
time. Osborne v. Perkins (1901), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Aldrich, J., 112 Fed.,
127; 7 A. B. R., 250.
Objections to discharge must in all cases proceed in regular order.
In re Sykes (1901), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 106 Fed., 669; 6 A.
B. R., 264.
No court bound to take judicial notice of discharge. Collins v. Mc-
Walters (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., 35 Misc. (N. Y.). 648; 6 A. B. R., 593.
(1) [Committed an offense.] Committed an offense pun-
ishable by imprisonment as herein provided ; or
For offenses under the act, see Sec. 29a and notes.
Discharge granted where grounds of opposition were transfers more
than a year old. Fields v. Kartner (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 115 Fed.,
950; 8 A. B. R., 351.
Where specifications of objections to discharge fail to aver that bank-
rupt "knowingly and fraudulently" made a false oath, they are fatally
defective. In re Beebe (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 116 Fed.,
48; 8 A. B. R., 597.
Discharge denied though fraudulent transfers were made more than
four months before. In re Schenck (1902), Dist. Wash., Hanford, J.,
116 Fed., 554; 8 A. B. R., 727.
Discharge refused where assets shown to be concealed. In re Otto
(1902), Dist. N. Y., Lewis, R., 8 A. B. R., 753.
After filing specifications for discharge no pleading necessary by
bankrupt — bankrupt may demur or move to strike out for insufficiency
§14b. (1)] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 95
or go to trial on the merits. In re Crist (1902), S. Dist. Ala., Toulmin,
J., 116 Fed., 1,007; 9 A. B. R., 3.
Where money received by bankrupt after filing petition, burden of
proof is on him to prove that it was turned over to trustee on his applica-
tion for discharge. In re Leslie (1903), N. Dist N. Y., Ray, J., 119 Fed.,
406.
Offenses and frauds of agents not imputable to the bankrupt principal.
In re Meyers (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 105 Fed., 353; 5 A. B. R.,
4; 2 N. B. N., 111.
Objections to discharge must be confined to the statutory ground —
non-residence in the state of the bankrupt no ground for objections to
discharge — on ground of perjury sufficient facts must be produced to
sustain objections. In re Goodale, et al. (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe,
J., 109 Fed., 783; 6 A. B. R., 493.
Fraudulent preference not amounting to a concealment no bar to
discharge. In re Pierce (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 102 Fed., 977;
4 A. B. R., 554; 2 N. B. N., 984.
Fraudulent preferences before passage of the act no bar to discharge.
In re Webb (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 98 Fed., 404; 3 A. B. R., 204;
2 N. B. N., 289.
Discharge refused where bankrupt has large unexplained shortage
of assets. In re Finklestein (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 101 Fed.,
418; a A. B. R., 800; 2 N. B. N., 839.
Proof of false oath will bar discharge irrespective of question as to
whether he can be convicted of perjury. In re Gaylord (1901) , C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Wallace, J., 106 Fed., 833; 7 A. B. R., 1.
The effect of discharge on a debt does not govern right to discharge.
General discharge will be granted even if the only debt scheduled is one
that would not be affected by discharge. In re McCarty (1901) , N. Dist.
111., Humphrey. J., Ill Fed., 151; 7 A. B. R., 40.
Omitting cash in bank from his schedule and making no effort to amend
his schedule constitutes fraudulent concealment. In re Royal (1901),
E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 112 Fed., 135; 7 A. B. R., 106.
Discharge denied on the groimd that bankrupt has not surrendered
all his property and rights of property where he had life estate capable
of voluntary alienation, but not attached by creditors, where bankrupt
files voluntary petition. In re Fleishman (1902), Dist. Ct., N. Dist.
111., Kohlsaat, J., 25 Nat. Corp. R., 520.
Buying claim of opposing creditors by bankrupt, directly or indirectly,
is ground for refusing discharge. Also where bankrupt has property in
wife's name for purpose of concealment, discharge refused. In re Steind-
96 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§14b. (1)
ler & Hahn (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Pendleton, R., 5 A. B. R., 63; 3 N.
B. N., 81.
Objections to discharge not sustained where concealment of assets is
alleged, but is not shown to be wilfully, intentionally, knowingly and
fraudulently done. An appropriation by husband of wife's interest, in a
business, does not vest equitable title in him. In re Bryant (1900), E.
Dist. Tenn., Clark, J., 104 Fed., 789; 5 A. B. R., 114; 2 N. B. N., 1,058.
Discharge — bankrupt carrying on business in wife's name — circum-
stances not showing fraud, discharge granted. In re Locks (1900), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 783; 5 A. B. R., 136.
Omitting property from schedules wiU not bar discharge if not done
with fraudulent intent. In re Eaton (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J.,
110 Fed., 731; 6 A. B. R., 531.
No fraud in omitting to schedule property of which though legally his
he might have reasonable doubt as to ownership. In re Marsh (1901),
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 109 Fed., 602; 6 A. B. R., 537.
Failure to schediile contingent interest under father's will not vested
at time of bankruptcy no bar to discharge. In re Wetmore (1900), E.
Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 99 Fed., 703; 3 A. B. R., 700.
Discharge refused where bankrupt on examination made false state-
ments as to his disbursements. In re Dew^s (1900) , Dist. R. I., Brown, J .,
101 Fed., 549; 3 A. B. R., 691; 2 N. B. N., 437.
Fraudulent concealment is not always shown by fraudulent convey-
ance— secret trusts must be scheduled or discharge v/ill not be allowed .
In re Bemer (1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 4 A. B. R., 383; 2 N.
B. N., 268.
False oath is made when bankrupt omits $37.50 from his schedules.
In re Roy (1900), Dist. Vt.. Wheeler, J., 96 Fed., 400; 3 A. B. R., 37; 1
N. B. N.. 526.
Discharge refused where bankrupt had omitted property previously
fraudulently transferred to his wife, /w r^ Welch (1901), S. Dist. Ohio,
Thompson, J., 100 Fed.. 65; 3 A. B. R., 93; 1 N. B. N., 533.
Fraudulent conveyance of bankrupt will bar the discharge. In re
Skinner (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 97 Fed., 190; 3 A. B. R., 163.
Omission to schedule assets from mistake of law or fact will not bar
discharge. In re Morrow (1899), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 97 Fed.,
674; 3 A. B. R., 263.
Discharge granted. No concealment of assets shown — failure to
schedule valueless land no objection. In re Hirsch, S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 97 Fed., 571; 3 A. B. R., 344; 2 N. B. N., 137.
§14b. (1)] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 97
Discharge refused on failure to account for assets. In re O'Gara, Dist.
Ore., Bellinger, J., 97 Fed., 932; 3 A. B. R., 349.
Discharge not denied for acts committed before the passage of the
bankruptcy act. In re Webb (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 98 Fed.,
404; 3 A. B. R., 386; 2 N. B. N., 11.
The concealment of assets and false oath to bar discharge must be clear-
ly shown. In re DeLeeuw (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed.,
408; 3 A. B. R., 418; 2 N. B. N., 267.,
Omission from schedule without fraudulent intent not a bar to dis-
charge. In re Freund (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., 98 Fed., 81; 3 A. B. R.,
418; 1 N. B. N., 305.
Discharge will not be granted when bankrupt fails to accoimt for assets.
In re Mendelsohn (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 102 Fed., 119; 4
A. B. R., 103; 1 N. B. N., 391.
Undetermined proceedings for discharge under law of 1867 not a bar
to this procedure. In re Herrman (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.,
102 Fed., 753; 4 A. B. R., 139; 2 N. B. N., 905.
Where bankrupt by mistake included in his schedules property which
did not belong to him, and there is absence of proof that false oath was
wilful and fraudulent, there is no ground for refusing discharge. In re
Bushnell (1899), Dist. N. J., Parker, R., 1 N. B. N., 528.
No ground for objection to discharge that bankrupt did not deliver
correct statement of accotmts where every effort has been made to procure
the statement. Idem.
Innocent failure to schedule creditors will not be a groimd for refusing
discharge. In re Huber (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Judson, R. ; 1 N. B. N., 432.
Discharge refused for concealment of assets which are fraudulently
transferred prior to the act, but over which the bankrupt continues to ex-
ercise ownership. In re Quackenbush, N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 102 Fed.,
282; 4 A. B. R., 274; 2 N. B. N., 964.
Discharge denied for refusal to turn over assets. In re Cashman (1900) ,
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 103 Fed., 67; 4 A. B. R., 326; 2 N. B. N., 980.
Discharge refused for concealment of assets. In re Hoffman Addn.
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 102 Fed., 979; 4 A. B. R., 331; 2 N. B.
N., 554.
Omitting to schedule shares of stock in name of wife not shown to be
in trust for bankrupt, even if open to attack by trustee no ground for
withholding discharge. Fellows et at v. Freudenthal (1900), C. C. A.,
7th Cir., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 731; 4 A. B. R., 490.
Failure to schedule assets with knowledge of their existence constitutes
a false oath within the meaning of the act and will be ground for
98 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§ 14 b. (1)
barring discharge. In re Welch (1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Thompson, J.,
3 A. B. R., 93; 1 N. B. N., 533.
The intentional omission from the schedule of small items of goods
worth in the aggregate only fifty dollars, is sufficient ground for refusing
a discharge. In re Lowenstein (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Holt, R., affirmed
by Brown, J., 2 A. B. R., 193; 1 N. B. N., 326.
A transfer to his wife by bankrupt and thereafter bankrupt's working
ostensibly for the wife in the conduct of the business is not fraudulent con-
cealment to bar discharge in the absence of a trust in the husband's favor.
In re Fitchard, N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 103 Fed., 742; 4 A. B. R., 609;
2 N. B. N., 1,075.
Mere fact of failing to schedule property which had been conveyed to
the wife without intent to defraud creditors, no bar to discharge. In re
Freund (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 81; 3 A. B. R., 418.
Effect of discharge is to be determined when it is pleaded. In re White
(1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Mack, R., 2 N. B. N., 536.
Facts showing concealment — fraudulent transfer to wife — ^no explana-
tion— failure to keep books — obstructing investigation by trustee. In re
Bemis (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 104 Fed., 672; 5 A. B. R., 36; 3 N.
B. N., 49.
Discharge denied for concealing assets of estate. Ablowtch v. Sturs-
burg (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 105 Fed., 751; 5 A. B. R., 403.
Concealment of assets shown in bankrupt selling out at wholesale and
not satisfactorily proving that he had actually paid out proceeds — the bur-
den being on him so to do. In re Holstein (1902), Dist. Conn., Piatt, J.,
114 Fed., 794; 8 A. B. R., 147.
False oath should be such as to show purpose to defraud or misrepre-
sent. Mistakes in figures as to liabilities and assets without such piupose
no ground for withholding discharge. In re Otto (1902) , Dist. N. J., Kirk-
patrick, J., 115 Fed., 860; 8 A. B. R., 305.
Fraudulent concealment of property is not shown from the mere
equitable interest of a bankrupt which may be shown on a bill. In re
Dews. Dist. of R. I., Brown, J., 96 Fed., 181; 2 A. B. R., 691; 1 N. B.
N., 411.
Omission to schedule $500 advanced seven years before by the bank-
rupt to his wife is not a bar to discharge. Sellers v. Bell, C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 94 Fed., 801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
Fraudulent transfer of property will bar the discharge though made
before the act was passed, as it was the duty of the bankrupt to schedule
the same. In re McNamara (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 2 A. B.
1^., 566; 2 N. B. N.. .^41.
§14b. (1)] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 99
Discharge denied when bankrupt omitted to schedule a vested remain-
der vmder his father's will. In re Wood (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., 95 Fed.,
946; 3 A. B. R., 572; 1 N. B. N., 530.
Voluntary gift to a wife several years before proceedings not a ground
for opposing discharge, although open to attack by trustee. In re House
(1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 103 Fed., 616; 4 A. B. R., 603; 2 N.
B. N., 1,099.
Objecting creditors must show that bankrupt knowingly and fraudu-
lently concealed property belonging to his estate in order to resist dis-
charge on ground of concealment of property. In re Cohn (1899), W.
Dist. Mo., Rathbum, R., 1 A. B. R., 655; 2 N. B. N., 299.
Discharge refused for failure of bankrupt to account for moneys in
his possession shortly before bankruptcy. In re Cabus (1901) , S . Dist.
N. Y., Pendleton, R., 6 A. B. R., 156.
Facts showing stock of a company held for bankrupt's benefit provided
he reduced same to possession, do not show such intent as justified
charge of concealment. In re Conn. (1901), Dist. Ore.,^ Bellinger, 108
Fed., 525; 6 A. B. R., 217; 3 N. B. N., 955.
Costs incurred prior to filing of petition are barred by discharge.
Those incurred after are not so barred. Aiken, Lambert & Co. v. Haskins
(1901), N. Y. Sp. Ct., Houghton, J., 70 N. Y., Sup. 293; 34 Misc., 505;
6 A. B. R.,46.
False oath before the referee ground for objection, though not testify-
ing, although such testimony cannot be used against him criminally.
In re Dow (1900), S. Dist. la., McPherson, J., 105 Fed., 889; 5 A. B. R.
400.
Mingling funds of the bankrupt with those of his wife in bank so that
they cannot be distinguished is ground for withholding discharge — costs
of referee's fee for reference allowed. Bragassa v. St. Louis Cycle Co.
(1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 107 Fed., 77; 5 A. B. R., 700.
Objection to discharge on ground of false oath not established by show-
ing he had made statement previously which conflicted with the present
oath. Bauman v. Feist (1901), C. C. A., 8th Cir., 107 Fed., 83; 5 A. B.
R., 703.
Where objection to ground of discharge is false oath the evidence must
be clear and convincing. In re Gaylord (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe,
J., 106 Fed., 833; 5 A. B. R., 410.
Omission from schedule of tontine life policy will bar discharge. In
re Becker (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 106 Fed., 54; 5 A. B. R., 438.
Alimony in arrears not provable or dischargeable debt. Maisner v.
Maisner (1901), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Patterson, J.; 6 A. B. R., 295; 3 N. B.
N., 999.
100 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§l4b. (2)
Fraudulent intent to prefer — burden of proof of insolvency and intent
on issue is on creditor — intent is so shown when the insolvency is proved
and the fact of transfer burden of intent then rests on the bankrupt — val-
ue of property determined by the receivers is evidence on question of in-
solvency. In re Block (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Shipman, J., 109 Fed.,
790; 6 A. B. R., 300; 3 N. B. N., 894.
Concealment from trustee not to be technically construed — conceal-
ment from receiver of state court pending appointment, will apply to the
trustee. In re Lesser Bros. (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., 108 Fed., 205; 5 A. B
R., 330.
(2) [Destroyed books.] With (fraudulent) intent to
conceal his (true) financial condition (and in contemplation
of bankruptcy), destroyed, concealed, or failed to keep books
of account or records from which (his true) * such * con-
dition might be ascertained ; or
As amended by Act of 1903. See 4 of Amendment, page , post.
lAmendment omits matter between brackets and adds matter between stars.]
Destruction of books by bankrupt before the act not in contemplation
of bankruptcy is no fovmdation for refusing discharge. In re Stark
(1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Holt, R., 1 A. B. R., 180; 1 N. B. N., 232.
Concealment of books in order to be an objection to discharge must
have been in contemplation of bankruptcy. In re Boasberg (1899) , N.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 353; 1 N. B. N., 133.
Objections to discharge not sustained by proof of fraudulent conceal-
ment of books by a bankrupt prior to the passage of the act. In re
Shorer (1899), Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 96 Fed., 90; 2 A. B. R., 165; 1
N. B. N., 331.
Failure to keep books must relate to a period since the passage of the
bankruptcy act. In re Dews (1899), Dist. R. I., Brown, J., 96 Fed., 181;
2 A. B. R., 483; 1 N. B. N., 411.
The failure to keep books where the business does not require book-
keeping is not an objection to discharge. Sellers v. Bell (1899), C. C. A.,
5th Cir. McCormick, J., 94 Fed., 801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
Failure to keep books must be with fraudulent intent. In re Spear
et al. (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed., 779; 4 A. B. R., 617.
Failure to keep books — facts showing fraudulent intent. In re Kenyon
(1902). N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.. 112 Fed., 658; 7 A. B. R., 527.
Objections to discharge not found to be proved beyond a reasonable
doubt. Circxunstances showing concealment and failvire to keep books.
§l4b. (2)] DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. 101
In re Greenberg (1902), Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 114 Fed., 773; 8 A.
B. R., 94.
Failure to keep books of account shown by omission to make any
entry of debts to bankrupt's relatives in his books, except on private
memorandum books, which were lost. In re Feldstein (1902), C. C. A.,
Lacombe, J., 2nd Cir., 115 Fed., 259; 8 A. B. R., 160.
Discharge not refused, although there was looting of assets by credi-
tors and disappearance of books a long time before failure. In re Phillips
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 844; 3 A. B. R., 542; 2 N. B.
N., 424.
Discharged denied where books were shown to be falsified. In re
McBachron, E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, 116 Fed., 783; 8 A. B. R., 732.
Discharge — effect of failing to keep books shown on examination as
affecting right to discharge. In re Leopold (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise,
R., 5 A. B. R., 278.
Where able business man failed to keep books of account when he
knew himself to be hopelessly insolvent, he is not entitled to discharge.
In re Kenyon (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 112 Fed., 658; 7 A. B. R,
527.
Fraudulent keeping of books by one partner in effort to cheat both
creditor and partner, not chargeable against the innocent partner and no
bar to discharge. In re Schultz, Jr. (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.
109 Fed., 264; 6 A. B. R., 91; 3 N. B. N., 844.
Objection to discharge not sustained for failtire to keep books where
the business was such that books would not ordinarily be kept. In re
Com (1901), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 106 Fed., 143; 5 A. B. R., 478.
Concealment of assets and failure to keep proper books of account
bars discharge. In re Holstein (1902), Dist. Conn., Piatt, J., 114 Fed.,
794; 8 A. B. R., 147.
Discharge refused where bank account concealed. In re Otto (1902),
Dist. N. J., Kirkpatrick, J., 115 Fed., 860; 8 A. B. R., 305.
Concealment more than a year before adjudication no bar to dis-
charge. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 115 Fed., 950; 8 A. B. R., 351.
Where no objection to discharge the fraudulent keeping of books is
shown, it is not necessary to prove that it was in contemplation of bank-
ruptcy. This may be inferred from the facts. In re Feldstein (1901),
S. Dist. N. Y., 108 Fed., 794; 6 A. B. R., 458; 3 N. B. N., 810.
Loss of books in 1891 does not show fraudulent intent and is no ground
for opposing discharge. In re Stark (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.,
96 Fed., 88; 2 A. B. R., 785; 1 N. B. N., 232.
102 DISCHARGES, WHEN GRANTED. [§l4b. (3)
Failure .to keep books before the Act no objection to discharge. In re
Holman (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J. ,92 Fed., 512; 1 A. B. R., 600;
1 N. B. N., 552.
In re Schertzer (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 99 Fed., 706; 3 A.
B. R., 699; 2 N. B. N., 520.
Discharge denied — bankrupts held to have concealed their books by
failing to account for them, /n re Ablowich (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 99 Fed., 81; 3 A. B. R., 586; 2 N. B. N., 386.
Failiire of bankrupt's husband, who was her agent, to keep books, not
to be imputed to the bankrupt, /n r^ Hyman (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 97 Fed., 195; 3 A. B. R., 169.
Destruction of books before passage of the act no bar to discharge;
nor is debt created by a fraud before passage of the act a bar to discharge.
In re Lieber (1899), Dist Pa., Mason, R., 3 A. B. R., 217; 2 N. B. N., 21.
Failure to keep books must be shown to be with fraudulent intent.
In re Brice S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., (1900) 102 Fed., 114; 4 A. B. R., 355.
Trader presumed to keep books. Instifficient explanation to account
for their non-production will prevent discharge. In re Berkowitz (1900),
S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 4 A. B. R., 37.
Discharge refused for failure to keep books — bankrupt purposely
commingled his funds with his wife's and kept no books of his own. In
re Bragasa (1900), N. Dist. Tex., Meek, J., 102 Fed., 936; 4 A. B. R., 519;
2 N. B. N., 837.
The' failure to' keep books must be in contemplation of bankruptcy ;
not merely of insolvency. In re Marx (1900), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 102
Fed., 676; 4 A. B. R., 521; 2 N. B. N., 837.
Facts showing concealment of books. In re Morgan (1900), W. Dist.
Ark., Rogers, J., 101 Fed., 982; 4 A. B. R., 402; 2 N. B. N., 846.
*(3) [Obtained property on false representation.] Ob-
tained property on credit from any person upon a materially
false statement in writing made to such person for the pur-
pose of obtaining such property on credit ; or*
*(4) [Transferred property to defraud.] At any time
subsequent to the first day of the four months immediate-
ly preceding the filing of the petition transferred, removed,
destroyed, or concealed, or permitted to be removed, de-
stroyed, or. concealed any of his property with intent to
hinder, delay, or defraud his creditors ; or*
§15 a.] DISCHARGES, WHEN REVOKED. 103
*(5) [Discharged within six years.] In voluntary
proceedings been granted a discharge in bankruptcy with-
in six years ; or*
*(6) [Refused to obey orders.] In the coiirse of the
proceedings in bankruptcy refused to obey any lawful order
of or to answer any material question approved by the
court.*
As amended by act of Feb. 5, 1903. Amendment adds matter between stars. See
Sec. 4 cf Amendment, post.
c [Cofirmation of composition.] The confirmation of a
composition shall discharge the bankrupt from his debts,
other than those agreed to be paid by the terms of the com-
position and those not affected by a discharge.
For proceedings in compositions, see Sec. 12 and 13. On confirmation
of composition, title to bankrupt's property revests in him. Sec. 70f
and notes.
Sec. 15. Discharges, when Revoked.
a [Facts to be shown.] The judge may, upon the appli-
cation of parties in interest who have not been guilty of
undue laches, filed at any time within one year after a dis-
charge shall have been granted, revoke it upon a trial if it
shall be made to appear that it was obtained through the
fraud of the bankrupt, ,and that the knowledge of the
fraud has come to the petitioners since the granting of the
discharge, and that the actual facts did not warrant the
discharge.
On revocation of discharge trustee appointed, Sec. 44 .As to disposi-
tion of property, see Sec. 64c and notes. See as to discharges, ante. Sec.
14 and notes.
Discharge revocable for fraud if attacked in one year. In re Meyers
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 757: 3 A. B. R., 722; 2 N.
B. N., 669.
Discharge vacated when opposition thereto was bought off by privity
of the bankrupt. In re Dietz (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed.,
563; 3 A. B. R., 316; 2 N. B. N., 125.
104 CO-DEBTORS OF BANKRUPTS. [§l6a.
Question as to whether a discharge should be revoked may upon pe-
tition of creditors not guilty of laches, be referred to the referee. In re
Meyers (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 757; 3 A. B. R., 722;
2 N. B. N., 669.
To revoke discharge fraud in procuring it must be shown. In re Hoover
(1900), E. Dist. Pa.. McPherson, J. 5, A. B. R., 247; 3 N. B. N., 327.
Creditors must show diligence in seeking revocation of discharge. Gen-
eral allegation not enough. In re Oleson (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.,
110 Fed., 796; 7 A. B. R., 22.
Discharge can not be vacated and case reinstated to damage of creditor
without notice, where action is more than a year after adjudication. In
re Hawk (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn. J., 114 Fed., 916; 8 A. B. R.,
71.
The remedy given by this section is exclusive and the order can not
be questioned or attacked collaterally in any court — bankrupt can not
surrender or vacate his discharge. In re Shaffer (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 104 Fed., 982; 4 A. B-. R., 728.
Sec. 16. Co-Debtors of Bankrupts.
a [Liability of co-debtor.] The liability of a person who
is a co-debtor with, or guarantor or in any manner a surety
for, a bankrupt shall not be altered by the discharge of such
bankrupt.
In case of a corporation being bankrupt, the court should facilitate
the enforcement by creditors of the stock liability of directors by allow-
ing a judgment where judgment is a necessary pre-requisite. In re
Marshall Paper Co.. Dist. Mass., LoweU, J., 95 Fed., 419; 2 A. B. R., 653;
1 N. B. N., 407.
Liability of bankrupt as maker of note is barred by his discharge against
the payee who paid same after the petition in bankruptcy to the en-
dorsee. Smith V. Wheeler (1900), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Mervin, J.; 5 A. B.
R., 46.
Stockholders not released by bankruptcy of their corporation. El-
shree v. Burt (1902), Sup. Ct. R. I., Douglas, J., 53 Atl., 60.
Surety on lease may plead bankruptcy of the lessor in defense to an
action as the lease determines on adjudication. Bernhardt v. Curtis
(1902), Sup. Ct. La., Provosty, J., 33 So., 125.
Surety on bond released by ■ discharge of principal in bankruptcy.
Hathaway v. Masterson (1902), 111. Court of Apps., 1st Cir., Waterman,
J., 101 lU. App., 626.
§17 a.] DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. 105
Surety on appeal bond released on discharge. Goyer Co. v. Jones
(1901), Sup. Ct., Miss., 79 Miss., 253.
Sec. 17. Debts not Affected by a Discharge.
a A discharge in bankruptcy shall release a bankrupt
from all of his provable debts, except such as
As to provable debts see Sec. 63 and notes.
Where no vendors' lien discharge in bankruptcy is a good defense to
action for purchase price of personalty. Graham v. Richardson (1902),
Sup. Ct. Ga., Fish, J.; 8 A. B. R., 700.
Alimony accrued or subsequent not barred by discharge. Young v.
Young (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 71 N. Y. C. 944; 35 Misc.
Rep., 335; 7. A B. R., 171.
Alimony overdue is a provable debt and barred by discharge. In re
Challoner (1899), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 98 Fed., 82; 3 A. B. R.,
442; 2 N. B. N., 105.
Alimony due not provable or dischargeable. Turner v. Turner (1901),
Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 108 Fed., 785; 6 A. B. R., 289.
Alimony in areaes not provable or dischargeable debt. Maisner v.
Maisner (1901), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Patterson, J.; 6 A. B. R., 295, 3 N. B.
N., 999.
A judgment for breach of promise to marry is a dischargeable debt.
In re McCauley (1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 101 Fed., 223; 4 A.
B. R., 122; 2 N. B. N., 1,089.
Damages for breach of promise to marry (vmaccompanied by seduc-
tion) is dischargeable in bankruptcy. Finnegan v. Hall (1901) , N. Y.
Sup. Ct., Russell, J., 72 N. Y. S., 347; 35 Misc., 773; 6 A. B. R., 648.
Under New York statute judgment for criminal conversation is not
released by discharge in bankruptcy. Colwell v. Tinker (1902), N. Y.
Ct. App., Bartlett, J.; 7 A. B. R., 334.
Discharge must always be pleaded in bar. Collins v. McW alters (1901,)
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 6 A. B. R., 593.
Judgment for breach of promise, though coupled with seduction, is
barred by discharge. Distler v. McCoulay (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Wood-
ward, J.; 73 N. Y. S., 270; 66 App. Div. 42; 7 A. B. R., 138. Revers-
ing lower court.
Discharge of debtor no defense to an action against a sheriff for the
escape of the judgment debtor. Baer v. Grell (1901), Mimicipal Court
of City of New York, Joseph, J.; 6 A. B. R., 428; 3 N. B. N., 1,053.
106 DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. [§l7a.(l)
Discharge does not aflfect liens on exempt property. Evans v. Rounsa-
ville (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 8 A. B. R., 236. To the same effect,
Smith V. Zachry (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 8 A. B. R., 236.
Judgment for money on breach of contract vacated by discharge. In
re Arkell (1901), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Ingraham. J., 72 N. Y. S., 555; 65 App.
Div., 130; 6 A. B. R., 650.
Discharge bars judgment based on note, although it is claimed the note
was founded on fraud. Hargadine-McKittrich Dry Goods Co. v. Hudson
et al. (1901), U. S. Cir. Ct., E. Dist. Mo., Rogers, J., Ill Fed., 361; 6 A.
B. R., 657.
Discharge on second petition no bar to debts scheduled under the
first. In re Clafi (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., Ill Fed., 506; 7 A. B.
R., 128.
Trover not an action for fraud. Burnham et al. v. Pidcock (1900), N.
Y. Sup. Ct. McAdam, J., 68 N. Y. S., 1,107; 58 App. Div. 273; 2 A. B.
R., 42.
Action by creditor after discharge alleging among other things one ac-
count to which the discharge would be a bar, the answer of the dischare
by the bankrupt was good as to the one account, although other accounts
showed embezzlement to which the discharge was no bar. Watertown
Carriage Co. v. Hall (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Smith, J., 7 A. B. R., 716.
Discharge no bar to claims on replevin bond being too contingent to
be provable debt. Clemmons v. Brinn (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., McAdam,
J., 7 A. B. R., 714.
A statement made to a mercantile agency for the ptirpose of securing
credit, if relied on and fraudulent, has precisely the same effect as though
it had been made in person by the debtor to a creditor and relied on by
him. In re Russell & Birkett (1901), N. Dist. N. Y., Hawley, R., 5 A. B.
k., 608.
Debt dischargeable due from retention of money by bankrupt from
sale of goods. Knott et al. v. Putnam (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 107
Fed., 907; 6 A. B. R. 80.
Bankruptcy court will determine as to the fiduciary character of the
debt, irrespective of decision of state courts. Knott v. Putnam (1901)
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 107 Fed., 907; 6 A. B. S. 80.
(1) [Taxes excepted.] Are due as a tax levied by the
United States, the State, county, district, or municipaHty
in which he resides ;
Taxes assessed against exempt property should be paid in full out of
§l7a.(2)] DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. 107
funds in the hands of the trustee. In re Baker (1899) , E. Dist. Tex., Hur-
ley, R., 1 A. B. R., 526; 1 N. B. N., 547.
(2) [Judgments in actions for frauds.] Are * liabilities *
(judgments in actions) for (frauds, or) obtaining property
by false pretenses or false representations, or for willful and
tnalicious injuries to the person or property of another, *or
for alimony due or to become due, or for maintenance or
support of wife or child, or for seduction of an unmarried
female, or for criminal conversation;*
As amended by Act of 1903, Sec. 5 of amendment, page, post. Amendment omits
matter between brackets and adds matter between stars.
Discharge releases a debt where money was received by mistake
Western Cold Storage Co. v. Hurd (1902), W. Dist. Mo., Philips, J.; 8 A.
B. R., 633.
Discharge can not be pleaded in defense to action of trover. Berry
V. Jackson (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Ltmipkin, J.; 8 A. B. R., 485.
Judgment based on fraud will not be cancelled on discharge of the
debtor in bankruptcy. Stevens v. Meyers (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., In-
graham, J., 72 App. Div. 128; 76 N. Y. Supp., 332; 8 A. B. R., 496.
A voluntary conveyance by bankrupt of lands does not necessarily
nvolve a present interest which should be scheduled — such interest must
be shown to bar discharge. In re Countryman (1903) , N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 119 Fed., 639.
Form of a debt is not material, being merged in the judgment which
is only to be considered in actions of tort, and if not in form of tort would
be barred by the discharge. In re Rhutassel (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 96 Fed., 597; 2 A. B. R., 697; 1 N. B. N., 572.
Commingling of bankrupt's fimds with estate of which bankrupt is
administrator, will bar a discharge until funds are separated. In re Wal-
ther (1899), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 95 Fed., 941; 2 A. B. R., 702.
Plea of discharge in bankruptcy is rendered inoperative by showing
that the debt was created by the fraud of the bankrupt. In re Thomas
(1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 92 Fed., 912; 1 A. B. R., 515; 1 N. B. N.,
329.
Debts created by misappropriation are not released by discharge in
bankruptcy, nor are they entitled to priority. Clafiin Co. v. Eason, Trus-
tee (1899), E.Dist. Tex.. White, R., 2 A. B. R., 263; 1 N. B. N., 360.
A debt created by fraud is not merged in the judgment to such an ex-
tent that its nature and origin can not be shown. Packer v. Whittier
108 DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. [§17a.(2)
(1899), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Webb, J., 91 Fed., 1; 511 A. B. R., 621; 1 N.
B. N.. 240.
A judgment for criminal conversation is a judgment for ma-
licious injury and not barred by the statute. Colwell v. Tinker (1901)
N. Y. Sup. Ct., Gildersleeve, J., 71 N. Y. S., 152; 35 Misc., 330; 6 A. B.
R., 434; 62 N. E., 668; 169 N. Y., 531.
Obligation to pay rent is terminated by bankruptcy. Bray v. Cobb
(1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 100 Fed., 270; 3 A. B. R., 788; 2 N.
B. N., 586.
Firm debts not released by individual petition. In re Hartman, N.
Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 593; 3 A. B. R., 65.
To the same effect in re McFaun (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 90
Fed., 592; 3 A. B. R., 66.
Debt of factor for goods sold for principal dischargeable and suit en-
joined. In re Basch (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 761;
3 A. B. R., 235; 2 N. B. N., 122.
Statute of limitations governed on bankruptcy proceedings by state
law. New York law construed. In re Lorillard (1901), C. C. A., 2nd
Cir., Lacombe, J., 108 Fed., 591; 5 A. B. R., 602.
Known debt omitted from schedule not barred by discharge. Tyrrel
V. Hammerstein (1900), Sup. Ct. N. Y., McAdam, J.; 6 A. B. R., 430.
Judgment for seduction and breach of promise not barred by discharge.
Distler v. McCauley (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Dickey, J., 73 N. Y. S., 270;
66 App. Div., 42; 6 A. B. R., 492.
To revive a debt barred by discharge the promise may be oral, but
it must be clear and definite. Smith v. Stansfield (1901), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Lewis, J., 84 Minn., 343; 87 N. W., 917; 7 A. B. R., 498.
Discharge removes the legal obligation to pay the debt, but leaves
the moral obligation and the old debt is siifficient consideration for a new
promise which may be oral. Mutual, &c., Assn. v. Beatty (1899), C. C.
A., 9th Cir., Morrow, J., 93 Fed., 747; 2 A. B. R., 244.
Debts not affected by discharge may not be sued on until after dis-
charge; in the interim bankrupt enjoined from collecting commissions as
administrator earned after adjudication on application of such creditor.
In re Rogers (1899), Dist. Ky., Howard, R., 1 A. B. R., 541; 1 N. B. N.,
211.
Bankruptcy proceedings will not release a bankrupt from the order of
the state court compelling him to support his minor children. In re
Hubbard (1899), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 98 Fed., 710; 3 A. B. R., 528.
General discharge does not affect question as to what debts are affected
by it. In re Tinker (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, 99 Fed., 79; 3 A-
B. R.. 580; 2 N. B. N. 391.
§17 a. (2)] DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. 109
Debts not dischargeable by bankruptcy; only so determined in other
forums after discharge. In re Mussey (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
99 Fed., 71; 3 A. B. R.. 592; 2 N. B. N., 113.
The right to discharge not the effect of discharge will be considered by
the bankruptcy court — fraud used in this section means moral turpitude
and intentional wrong — the fact that certain debts would not be barred
no ground for withholding general discharge. In re Blumberg (1899),
E. Dist. Tenn., Clark, J., 94 Fed., 476; 1 A. B. R., 633; 1 N. B. N., 258.
Clause two reqviires that a judgment shotUd have been rendered.
Morse & Rogers v. Kaufman, Sup. Ct. App. Va.,Whittle, J. (1902), 4 Va.
Sup. Ct. R., 172; 40 S. E., 916; 7 A. B. R., 549.
Judgment on common coimts is one to which clatise 2 does not apply.
Barnes Mfg. Co. v. Norden (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Dixon, J., 51 At., 454;
7 A. B. R., 553.
Discharge no bar to claim against bankrupt banker who received de-
posits while insolvent, tmder New York statute. Frey v. Torrey, Sup.
Ct. N. Y., Laughlin, J. (1902), 75 N. Y. S., 40; 70 App. Div., 166; 8 A.
B. R., 196.
Debt not barred by discharge which is created by the fraud of the
bankrupt. Law of 1867 did not require averment of the scienter. For-
syth V. Vehmeyer (1900), U. S. Sup. Ct., Peckham, J., 177 U. S., 177;
3 A. B. R., 807; 2 N. B. N., 1,142.
New promise to pay debt discharged by bankruptcy must be definite.
Thompkins v. Hazen (1900), N. J. Ct. App., Bartlett, J., 5 A. B. R., 62.
Judgment barred where fraud is the gravamen of the action. An ac-
tion for conversion of goods not essentially one of fraud. Burnham
v. Pidcock (1900), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Rumsey, J., 68 N. Y. S., 1,007; 58 App.
Div., 273; 5 A. B. R., 590.
Judgment for seduction of daughter not barred. In re Freche (1901),
Dist. N. Y., Kirkpatrick, J., 109 Fed., 620; 6 A. B. R., 479.
Failure to schedule property turned over to wife in fraud of creditors
will bar discharge. In re Lafleche (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 109
Fed., 307; 6 A. B. R., 483.
This provision applies only where fraud is the gravamen of the action.
The sale of property previously sold to creditor who did not record deed,
does not exempt from discharge on ground of fraud. Fraud must be
proved. Collins v. McWalters (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J.,
72 N. Y. S., 208; 35 Misc., 648; 6 A. B. R., 593.
Fraud need not be apparent from the judgment itself — an equity suit
based on the fraud of the defendants will not be affected by the discharge.
In re Bullis (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Springer, J., 73 N. Y. S., 1,047; 68
App. Div., 508; 7 A. B. R., 238.
110 DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. [§17a.(3)
(3) [Creditors not scheduled.] Have not been duly
scheduled in time for proof and allowance, with the name
■'of the creditor if known to the bankrupt, unless such cred-
itor had notice or actual knowledge of the proceedings in
bankruptcy; or
Debt not barred where the creditor is not named in schedule. Col-
umbia Bank V. Birkett (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Clark, J., 73 N. Y. S., 704;
36 Misc. Rep., 391; 7 A. B. R., 222.
As to schedules of property and creditors see Sec. 7 (8) ante.
(4). [Created by fraud in fiduciary relation.] Were
created by his fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation,
or defalcation while acting as an officer or in any fiduciary
capacity.
The fiduciary capacity must be that of an expressed, not implied,
trust — not for defalcation of mere factor or agent. Fraud by such agent
prevents the operation of the statute discharging the debt — trustee under
trust, acts under express trust." Bracken v. Milner (1900), W. Dist.
Mo., Phillips, J., 104 Fed., 522; 5 A. B. R., 23.
The fiduciary relation is one existing previously to, or independently
of the particular transaction out of which the debt arose. Bryant v,
Kinyon (1901), Sup. Ct. Mich., Hooker, J., 6 A. B. R., 237.
Judgment against a corporation on accounting on a misappropriation
of partnership funds is not a debt for fraud or in a fiduciaiy capacity.
Gee V. Gee (1901), Sup. Ct. Minn., Lovely J., 84 Minn., 384; 87 N. W.,
1,116; 7 A. B. R., 500.
Clause four requires that the bankrupt must have been an officer or
acting in a fiduciary capacity. Morse & Rogers v. Kaufman, Sup. Ct.
App., Va., Whittle, J. (1901), 40 S. E., 916; 7 A. B. R., 549.
Discharge does not relieve from debt for money received by private
banker after he knew he was insolvent. Pridniore v. Toirey (1902), Sup.
Ct., N. Y.; Gildersleeve, J., 38 N. Y. Misc., 127.
Money received on embezzlement by an agent not barred by discharge.
Ruff V. Milner (1901), Ct. App. of Mo., Bland, J., 92 Mo. App., 620.
A discharge in bankruptcy is analogous in its effect to the statute of
limitations — it neither pays nor discharges the debt but suspends the
right of action. Wenham v. Matin (1902), 111. App., Waterman, J.,
103 111. App., 609.
Where transferee of note scheduled as belonging to maker was not
§ 17 a. (4)] DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. Ill
scheduled but had notice of proceedings, the debt was barred. Fider
V. Manning (1899) Sup. Ct. Minn., Canty, J., 78 Minn., 309.
Fiduciary capacity relates to technical not implied trusts — an ad-
ministrator is a technical trustee — interest as well as principal embraced
in the liability which is not discharged. Johnson's Admr. v. Parmerter
(1901), Sup. Ct. Vt., Rowell, J., 52 Atl., 73.
Petition in state court for leave to file supplemental answer, setting
up discharge in bankruptcy denied for insufficiency, failing to set out
that claim was scheduled, etc. Balk v. Harris (1902), Sup. Ct. N. C,
Furches, J., 41 S. E., 940.
Discharge does not affect liens on property it only relieves the debtor
from the obUgation to pay. Evans v. Staale (1903), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Start, J., 92 N. W., 951.
Knowledge of pending proceeding by an unscheduled creditor bars
his claim. Zimmerman v. Ketchum (1903), Sup. Ct. Kan., Pollock, J.,
71 Pac, 264.
Discharge does not affect lien on property. It is only personal to the
bankrupt. Paxton v. Scott (1902), Sup. Ct. Neb., 92 N. W., 611; Phil-
mon V. Marshall (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Cobb, J., 43 S. E. 48; McCall v.
Hening (1902), Sup. Ct. Ga., Little, J., 42 S. E. 468; Holland v. Cunliff
(1902), Ct. App. Mo., Barclay, J., 69 S. W., 737.
Alimony not a provable debt within the meaning of the bankruptcy
act. Wetty v. Wetty (1900), lU. Ct. of App., 1st Dist., Windes, J., 96 111.
App., 141; Sargent v. Sargent (1901), Ohio Cir. Ct., Phillips, J., 8 Ohio
N. P., 238; 11 Ohio, Dec, S. C. P., 218; Arrington v. Arrington (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. C, Fuches, J., 42 S. E.. 554; Barclay v. Barclay (1900), Sup.
Ct. 111., Phillips, J., 184 111., 375; Wetty v. Wetty (1902), Magruder, J.,
Sup. Ct. 111., 195 111., 335.
Discharge in bankruptcy of one of the parties to a smt covering the
debt in controversy has the same effect as when one of three or more
obligors has died. Seyrnour v. Richardson, etc., Co. (1902), Ct. App. 111.,
Freeman, J., 103 111. App., 625.
Discharge in bankruptcy only available by property pleading it. Lane
v. Holcomh, et al. (1903), Sup. Ct. Mass., Knowlton, J., 65 N. E., 794.
Scheduling creditor as of unknown place of residence does not constitute
such fraud as to bar the debt even when it is shown that bankrupt called
at the creditor's residence two years prior to proceedings. In re Mallner
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Patterson, J., 75 N. Y. App. Div., 441.
Discharge in bankruptcy no proof of insolvency at the time of adju-
dication. Wetmore v. Wetmore (1899), Sup. Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J., 44
N, Y. App. Div., 220.
112 DEBTS NOT AFFECTED BY A DISCHARGE. [§ 17 a. (4)
A discharge in bankruptcy does not purge one from contempt of court
in taking money in defiance of an injunction. In re Meggett (1900) , Sup.
Ct. Wis., Dodge, J., 105 Wis., 291.
Discharge in bankruptcy no defence to an action based on defendant's
fraud or other misconduct in a fiduciary capacity. Gerner v. Yates (1900) ,
Sup. Ct. Neb., SulUvan, J., 61 Neb., 100.
Debt not discharged where schedule gives creditor's name incorrectly,
Lisum V. Kraus (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Hascoll, J., 35 N. Y.. Misc., 376.
Certified copy of adjudication competent evidence. Rosenjeld v.
Siegfried (1901), Ct. App. Mo., Bland, J., 91 Mo. App., 169.
Judgment in favor of wife for alienation of her husband's affection is
not dischargeable — as it is wilful and malicious. Leicester v. Hoadley
(1903), Sup. Ct. Kans., Cunningham, J., 71 Pac, 318.
CHAPTER IV.
COURTS AND PROCEDURE.
Sec. 18. Process, Pleadings and
Adjudication.
a. Service of petition — return
— publication.
h. Time to plead to petition.
c. Verification of pleadings.
d Determining issues of fact —
Jury trials.
e. Where no pleadings filed.
/. Where judge absent reference
to referee.
g. Hearing on voluntary petition
Sec. 19. Jury Trials.
a. When jury may be demanded
— waiver.
b. Attendance of jury — certify-
ing case to other court.
c. Laws as to jury trials ap-
plicable.
Sec. 20. Oaths, Affirmations.
a. ] Who may administer.
(1) Referees.
(2) Officers authorized to admin-
ister.
(3) Diplomatic or consular offi-
cers.
h. Affirmations.
Sec. 21. Evidence.
a. Compulsory attendance of wit-
nesses.
b. Depositions — right to take.
c. Notice of taking depositions.
d. Certified copies as evidence.
e. Copy of order approving trus-
tee's bond.
/. Certified copy of orders.
g. Evidence of revesting title
in bankrupt.
Sec. 22. References of Cases
AFTER Adjudication.
a. Judge may refer cause.
(1) General or special reference.
(2) To any referee within the jur-
isdiction.
b. Transfer of case to different
referee.
Sec. 23. Jurisdiction of United
States and state Courts.
a. Circtiit Courts.
b. Suits by trustees where
brought.
c. Concurrent jurisdiction.
Sec. 24. Jurisdiction of Appel-
late Cotirts.
113
h.
Sec
a.
(1)
(2)
(3)
Courts with Appellate jur-
isdiction— Supreme Court.
Circuit Courts of Appeals.
25. Appeals and "Writs op
Error.
Appeals may be taken.
Judgement on adjudication.
Judgment on discharge.
Judgment allowing or reject-
ing claim. Time for appeal —
hearing.
Appeal to Supreme Cotirt
from Circuit Court of Appeals
(1) Jiuisdictional amount — ques-
tion involved.
(2) Certification of question by
supreme justice.
c. Bond on appeal by trustee.
d. Certificate to Supreme Court
by other courts.
Sec. 26. Arbitration of Con-
troversies.
a. Trustees may submit.
b. Selection of arbitrators.
c. Findings.
Sec. 27. Compromises.
a. When allowed.
Sec. 28. Designation of News-
Papers.
a. To publish notices.
Sec. 29. Offenses.
a. Misappropriating property —
destroying documents.
b. Ptmishment by imprisonment.
(1) Concealing property.
(2) False oath or accounts.
(3) False claims.
(4) Receiving property from the
bankrupt.
(5) Extorting money or property
c. Punishment by fine.
(1) Acting as referee when in-
terested.
(2) Purchasing property.
(3) Refusal to permit inspection
of accounts and papers.
d. One year limitation.
Sec. 30. Rules, Forms and Or-
ders.
a. Supreme Court to make rules.
Sec. 31. Computation of Time.
a. How time computed.
Sec. 32. Transfer of Cases.
114 process, pleadings, and adjudications. [§18a.
Sec. 18. Process, Pleadings, and Adjudications.
a [Service of petition — return — publication.] Upon the
filing of a petition for involuntary bankruptcy, service
thereof, with a writ of subpoena, shall be made upon the
person therein named as defendant in the same manner
that service of such process is now had upon the commence-
ment of a stiit in equity in the cotirts of the United States,
except that it shall be returnable within fifteen days, imless
the judge shall for cause fix a longer time ; but in case per-
sonal service can not be made, then notice shall be given
by publication in the same manner and for the same time
as provided by law for notice by publication in suits in
equity) ,*[to enforce a legal or equitable lien* in courts of
the United States,* except that, unless the judge shall other-
wise direct, the order shall be published not more than once
a week for two consecutive weeks, and the return day shall
be ten days after the last publication unless the judge shall
for cause fix a longer time.*
As amended by Act of 1893. Sec. 6 of Amendment, page poat.
Amendment omits matter between brackets and adds matter between stars.
Petition defined, Sec. 1 (20) and notes. As to service by publication,
see United States Equity Rule 94. As to when suit deemed to be com-
menced, see Sec. 67c and notes. As to computation of time, see Sec.
31 and notes. As to filing petition, see Sec. 59c and notes; see also as to
other creditors joining in petition, Sec. 59/. As to form of Subpoena,
see Form No. 5 and notes. As to designation of newspapers for publica-
tion, see Sec. 28 and notes.
General Order XXXVII makes equity rules prescribed by the United
States Supreme Court control in the matter of service of process. Process
shall be served by the Marshal by delivering a copy to the defendant or
some adult member of his family. United States Eqiiity Rules, 11, 12,
13, 14, 15, 16. Process must issue out of the office of the Clerk and be
tested by the seal of the Clerk. Gen. Order III.
Petition must follow forms. Mahoney v. Ward (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
100 Fed., 278; 3 A. B. R., 770.
Service on foreign corporation sufficient if it follows the state law.
In re Magid-Hope Silk Mfg. Co. (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.. 110
Fed., 352; 6 A. B. R.. 610.
§18b.] PROCESS, PLEADINGS, AND ADJUDICATIONS. 115
Notice by publication desirable where bankrupt a lunatic. In re
Burka (1901), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 107 Fed., 674; 5 A. B. R.,
843.
Adjudication valid, although before the fifteen days — creditor coming
afterwards, but in due season, may plead — only a creditor may so move
to vacate adjudication. In re Coltunbia Real Estate Co. (1900), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 101 Fed., 965; 4 A. B. R., 411.
Failure to get subpoena served on bankrupt in six months does not
deprive the court of jvirisdiction. In re Stein (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.
105 Fed., 749; 5 A. B. R., 288.
Equity practice governs where statute is not specific. In re Columbia
Real Estate Co. (1902), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 112 Fed., 643; 7
A. B. R., 441.
Jurisdiction not lost by delay in service of subpoena. In re Freesch-
berg (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 8 A. B. R.. 607.
Objection to discharge is a pleading and should be sworn to and signed
by the objectar . — if done by attorney, reasons for should appear. —
Defect may be waived by bankrupt failing to raise point. In re Baem-
coflE (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J, 9 A. B. R., 133.
h [Time to plead to petition.] The bankrupt, or any
creditor, may appear and plead to the petition within (ten)
*five* days after the return day, or within such ftirther time
as the court may allow.
Amended by Act of 1893, Sec. 6 of "Amendment, page post.
Amendment omits matter between brackets and adds matter between stars.
Denial of bankruptcy shovdd follow Form 6. Compare with the United
States Equity Rule 17.
Time for bankrupt to plead may not be extended by consent of peti-
tioning creditors. In re Simonson (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 92 Fed.,
904; 1 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N., 230.
Denial of insolvency not confined to any particxilar form. In re Page
N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks, J., 99 Fed., 538; 3 A. B. R., 679; 2 N. B. N., 110.
Formal defects of petition including improper verification waived by
answer. Leidigh, etc., Co. v. Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J.,
95 Fed., 637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 296.
A petition that contains no specific allegations is defective. Defect
is waived by joining issue and going to trial. In re Cliffe (1899) , E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 97 Fed., 540; 2 A. B. R., 317; 1 N. B. N., 509.
116 PROCESS, PLEADINGS, AND ADJUDICATIONS. [§18c.
Denial shotdd follow official form 6. In re Ogles (1899), W. Dist.
Tenn., Hammond, J., 93 Fed., 426; 1 A. B. R., 671; 1 N. B. N., 400.
Original petition being dismissed an amended petition not allowed
as a substitute. In re Hyde & Gload Mfg. Co. (1900), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 103 Fed., 617; 4 A. B. R., 602; 2 N. B. N., 1,122.
Time to plead cannot be extended by agreement among creditors.
Simonson v. Sinsheimer (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 100 Fed.,
426; 5 A. B. R., 537.
Official form No. 6 should be followed in the answer. Amendment of
defective answer. Mather et al. v. Coe, Powers & Co. (1899), N. Dist.
Ohio, Ricks, J., 92 Fed., 333; 1 A. B. R., 504.
Sufficiency of answer cannot be raised by demurrer; it can only be
raised by setting the case for hearing upon the bill and answer. Goldman,
Beckman, Smith & Co. v. Smith (1899), 93 Fed., 182; 1 A. B. R., 266.
Where defending creditor files his answer setting up solvency and the
case was submitted on the pleadings without proofs taken, the answer
is conclusive — petitioning creditors wishing to contest a question raised
by the answer should put in a replication and go to trial before adjudica-
tion. In re Taylor (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Bunn, J., 102 Fed., 728;
4 A. B. R., 515.
Answering waives demurrer even though the answer expressly asserts
an intention not to waive it. Green River Deposit Bank v. Craig Bros.
(1901), West. Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 110 Fed., 137; 6 A. B. R., 381.
Petition for review will not be dismissed for want of necessary parties,
where the same parties are before the coiut that were in the court below.
In re Utt (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Woods, J., 105 Fed., 754; 5 A. B. R..
383.
c [Verification of Pleadings.] All pleadings setting up
matters of fact shall be verified under oath.
As to who may administer oaths and affirmations, Sec. 20 and notes.
Oath includes affirmation. Sec. 1 (17).
Verification of petition shovdd show venue. The attorney of peti-
tioner should not be the notary. In re Bnunelkamp (1899), N Dist.
N. Y., Stone, R.; 2 A. B. R., 318; 1 N. B. N., 360.
Objection to verification of petition comes too late after answer by
bankrupt. In re Simonson, Dist. Ky., Evans, J., (1899) 92 Fed., 904;
1 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N., 230.
Oath administered by attorney, who subsequently appears as attorney
of record for bankrupt, does not invalidate the petition. In re Kindt
(1900), S. Dist. la., 98 Fed., 867; 3 A. B. R., 443; 2 N. B. N., 306,
|lSde.] PROCESS, PLEADINGS, AND ADJUDICATIONS. 117
Verification of specifications of objections to discharge necessary. In
re Brown (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 112 Fed., 49; 7 A. B. R., 252.
No formal affidavit of verification is prescribed, it is sufficient if
verified — verification by a corporation. In re Bellah (1902), Dist. of
Del., Bradford, J., 116 Fed., 69; 8 A. B. R., 310.
Verification should be by petitioner not by the attorney — if facts more
fully within the knowledge of the attorney it may be made by him. In
re Nelson (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 98 Fed., 76; 1 A. B. R., 63,
Defect in verification of petition is waived by answering to the merits.
In re Herzikopf (1902), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J., 118 Fed., 101; 9 A.
B. R., 90.
Attorney may verify involvmtary petition where it appears that he has
the knowledge. In re Hunt (1902), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 118 Fed., 282.
d [Determining issues of fact — Jury trials.] If the bank-
rupt, or any of his creditors, shall appear, within the time
limited, and controvert the facts alleged in the petition, the
judge shall determine, as soon as may be, the issues presented
by the pleadings, without the intervention of a jury, except
in cases where a jury trial is given by this Act, and makes
the adjudication or dismiss the petition.
See ante a and 6 and notes. As to when jury trial may be demanded,
see Sec. 19 and notes. Adjudication defined, Sec. 1 (2). For forms of
adjudication, see Forms 11 and 12. As to costs in contested adjudica-
tions, see Gen. Ord. XXXIV
A creditor may raise the jurisdictional question of bankrupt being in
excepted class (a farmer) ; default of the bankrupt not eqmvalent to a
voltmtary petition. In re Taylor (1900), C. C. A., Brown, J., 102 Fed.'
728; 4 A. B. R., 515.
Guardian ad litem will be appointed for a lunatic bankrupt — eqtiity
practice controls. In re Burka (1901), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J.,
107 Fed., 674; 5 A. B. R., 843.
Jurisdictional question must be taken to be waived if not raised
promptly. In re Mason (1900), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 99 Fed., 266;
3 A. B. R., 599.
e [Where no pleadings filed.] If on the last day within
which pleadings may be filed none are filed by the bankrupt
or any of his creditors, the judge shall on the next day, if
118 PROCESS, PLEADINGS, AND ADJUDICATIONS. [§18f.
present, or as soon thereafter as practicable, make the
adjudication or dismiss the petition.
See a, b, c, d, ante, under this section and notes thereunder. For forms
of adjudication, see Forms 11 and 12.
Adjudication in different districts — answer in one default in another
In re Elmira Steele Co. (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., 109 Fed., 456; 5 A. B,
R., 484.
An involtmtary adjudication of bankruptcy may not be made before,
the expiration of the time allowed. Day v. Beck & Gregg Hardware Co.
(1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby, J., 114 Fed., 834; 8 A. B. R., 175.
Adjudication of corporation by default where petition alleges prefer-
ence while insolvent is res adjudicata to all creditors on all such facts in-
cluding date of insolvency. In re American Brewing Co. (1902), C. C. A.,
7th Cir., 112 Fed., 752; 7 A. B. R., 463.
Adjudication set aside. In re Maples (1901), Dist. Mont., Knowles,
J., 105 Fed., 919; 5 A. B. R., 426.
Adjudication may be vacated on proper showing. In re Ives (1902) .
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Wanty, J., 113 Fed., 911; 7 A. B. R., 692.
/ [Where judge absent reference to referee.] If the
judge is absent from the district, or the division of the dis-
trict in which the petition is pending, on the next day after
the last day on which pleadings may be filed, and none have
been filed by the bankrupt or any of his creditors, the clerk
shall forthwith refer the case to the referee.
As to computation of time, see Sec. 31 and notes. See General Order
XII as to duties of referees. For form of reference in absence of the judge,
see form No. 15.
This section provides for reference by clerk of voltmtary cases in ab-
sence of judge. In partnership cases, filed by one partner, clerk may like-
wise refer it to referee who will proceed under Rule XII tmtil remaining
partner appears and contests, when it goes back to the judge — see draft
of order. In re Murray, Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed., 600; 3 A. B. R.,
601; 1 N. B. N., 570.
The clerk cannot send a case of involuntary bankruptcy to the referee
for adjudication, except in cases wherein no issue is made by the bankrupt
or any creditor. In re L. Htmabert & Co. (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 100 Fed., 439; 4 A. B. R., 76.
A deputy clerk cannot make an order of reference in bankruptcy.
§19a.] JURY TRIALS. llO
Bray et al. v. Cohh (1898), E. Dist. N. C ., Purnell, J., 91 Fed., 102; 1 A.
B. R., 153
g [Hearing on voluntary petition.] Upon the filing of a
voluntary petition the judge shall hear the petition and
make the adjudication or dismiss the petition. If the judge
is absent from the district, or the division of the district in
which the petition is filed at the time of the filing, the clerk
shall forthwith refer the case to the referee.
See notes o, h, c, d, e and /, tinder this section.
As to form of adjudication, see Forms No. 11 and 12. As to duties of
referee on reference, see Gen. Ord. XII. For order of reference in judge's
absence, see form No. 15. "Judge" does not include referee. Sec. 1
(16). "Adjudication" defined. Section 1 (2) ante.
Parties not before the coiirt not affected by decree of adjudication.
Nensiadter v. Chicago Dry Goods Co. (1899), Dist. Wash., Handford, J.,
96 Fed., 830; 3 A. B. R., 96; 2 N. B. N., 552.
The practice of sending petitions directly to the judge is improper —
petitions shovdd be filed with the clerk. In re Sykes (1901), W. Dist.
Tenn., Hammond, J., 106 Fed.. 669; 6 A. B. R., 264.
After involuntary petition is filed and before action thereon, bank-
rupt may file voluntary petition on which adjudication may be entered —
creditor's petition to be held to protect costs or other rights. In re
Stegar (1902) N. Dist. Ala., Jones J., 113 Fed., 978; 7 A. B. R., 665.
Where voltmtary petition filed after involtmtary petition, notice should
be given creditors and subsequent action should depend on the best in-
terest of the estate. In re D-wyer (1902), Dist. North Da., Amidon, J.
112 Fed., 777; 7 A. B. R., 532.
Sec. 19. Jury Trials.
a [Wlien jury may be demanded.] A person against
whom an involuntary petition has been filed shall be entitled
to have a trial by jury, in respect to the question of his
insolvency, except as herein otherwise provided, and any
act of bankruptcy alleged in such petition to have been
committed, upon filing a written application therefor at or
before the time within which an answer may be filed. If
such application is not filed within such time, a trial by
jury shall be deemed to have been waived.
120 JURY TRIALS. [§l9b.
As to time for filing answers, see Sec. 18b. For form of order for jury
trial, see Form No. 7.
Time within which jury may be asked is mandatory. Bray v. Cobb
(1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 91 Fed., 102; 1 A. B. R., 153; 1 N. B.
N., 209.
Claims of creditors do not involve jury trial — proceedings are equitable.
In re Christensen (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 802; 4 A. B.
R.,99;2N. B. N.,670.
Jvuy trial when demanded is a matter of right — is a trial at common
law reviewable only on a writ of error — error must be presented by bill
of exceptions as the proceeding only passes on error and not of fact. El-
liot V. Toeppner (1902), Sup. Ct. U. S., Fuller, J.; 9 A. B. R., 50.
Bankrupt entitled to a jury trial on the question of whether he has
made a general assignment or not. Day v. Beck & Gregg Hardware Co.
(1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby, J., 114 Fed., 834; 8 A. B. R., 175.
Trial by jury matter of right and cannot be denied if seasonably de-
manded. Duncan v. Landis (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 106 Fed.,
839;5A. B.R.,649.
This section does not confer right of jury trial in bankruptcy proceed-
ings. Calling the jury is discretionary with the court. In re Rude
(1900), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 101 Fed., 805; 4 A. B. R., 319; 2 N. B. N.,
493.
Jury trial should be allowed creditors on question of solvency, where
their claims are attacked for preferences. In re Linton (1902), E. Dist.
Pa., Hoffman, R., 7 A. B. R., 676.
Bankrupt's right to trial by jury on issue of act of bankruptcy in-
violable. Day V. Bech & Gregg Hardware Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir.,
Shelby, J., 114 Fed., 834; 8 A. B. R., 175.
h [Attendance of jury — certifying case to other court.]
If a jury is not in attendance upon the court, one may be
specially summoned for the trial, or the case may be post-
poned, or, if the case is pending in one of the district courts
within the jurisdiction of a circuit court of the United States,
it may be certified for trial to the circuit coiut sitting at
the same place, or by consent of parties when sitting at any
other place in the same district, if such circuit court has
or is to have a jury first in attendance.
§20ab.] OATHS, AFFIRMATIONS. 121
c [Laws as to jury trials applicable.] The right to sub-
mit matters in controversy, or an alleged offense under this
Act, to a jury shall be determined and enjoyed, except as
provided by this Act, according to the United States laws
now in force or such as may be hereafter enacted in relation
to trials by jury.
As to trials by jury in United States Courts, see Sections 800-821,
Revised Statutes United States. Also supplement to Revised Statutes
of United States, page 270.
See b and notes ante. See Section VI Amendment to the United
States Constitution.
Sec. 20. Oaths, Affirmations.
a [Who may administer oaths.] Oaths required by this
Act, except upon hearings in court, may be administered by
The attorney of the petitioner should not be the notary who adminis-
ters the oath. In re Brumelkamp (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 95
Fed., 814; 2 A. B. R., 318; 1 N. B. N., 360; In re Kindt (1900), S.Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 98 Fed., 403; 4 A. B. R., 148.
(1) referees;
(2) officers authorized to administer oaths in proceedings
before the courts of the United States, or under the laws of
the State where the same are to be taken ; and
(3) diplomatic or consular officers of the United States in
any foreign country.
A power of attorney authorizing proxies to vote at creditors' meetings
may be executed before the constdar or diplomatic officer of the United
States in a foreign coimtry. In re Sugenheimer (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Brown, J., 91 Fed., 744; 1 A. B. R., 425; 1 N. B. N., 59.
h [Afltanations.] Any person conscientiously opposed
to taking an oath may, in lieu thereof, affirm. Any person
who shall affirm falsely shall be punished as for the making
of a false oath.
For punishment for false oath, see Sec. 29b (2) and notes.
122 EVIDENCE. [§21 a.
Sec. 21. Evidence.
a [Compulsory attendance of witness.] A court of bank-
ruptcy may, upon application of any officer, bankrupt, or
creditor, by order require any designated person, including
the bankrupt,* and his wife,* (who is a competent witness
under the laws of the State in which the proceedings are
pending), to appear in court or before a referee or the judge
of any State court, to be examined concerning the acts,
conduct, or property of a bankrupt whose estate is in
process of administration under this Act :
^Provided, that the wife may be examined only touching
business transacted by her or to which she is a party, and to
determine the fact whether she has transacted or been a
party to any business of the bankrupt.*
As amended by Act 7, 1903, Sec. 7 of Amendment , page post.
Amendment omits matter between brackets and adds matter between stars.
As to examination of bankrupts see Sec. 7 (9) and notes. See also
U. S. Rev. S. 5087.
See d, post, and notes.
Witness living more than one hundred miles from place of hearing
can not be compelled to attend by subpoena. In re Hemstreet (1902),
N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 8 A. B. R., 760.
Third parties who are examined during proceedings are not as a matter
of strict legal right entitled to be represented by counsel. In re Howard
N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 95 Fed., 415; 2 A. B. R., 582; 1 N. B. N.,
488.
Wife of bankrupt may not be compelled to testify. In re Fowler
(1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 93 Fed., 417; 1 A. B. R., 555; 1 N. B.
N., 215.
Referee in bankruptcy may require any designated person who is com-
petent witness under the laws of the State to appear and be examined
concerning the acts, conduct and property of a bankrupt — referee may
examine trustee in insolvency proceedings concerning disposition of
assets. In re Pursell (1902), Dist. of Conn., Piatt, J., 114 Fed., 371; 8
A. B. R., 96.
Competency of the witness is for the court — if witness claims pro-
fessional privilege court may examine him as to relation. Peoples
§21 a.] EVIDENCE. 123
Bank of Buffalov. Broivn (1902), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Dallas, J., 112 Fed.,
652; 7 A. B. R., 475.
Examination of witnesses, who have close business relations with
bankrupt, should be very broad. And objections to its validity should
not be strictly allowed. In re Foerst (1899), S. Dist.N. Y., Brown, J.,
93 Fed., 190; 1 A. B. R., 259.
Other witnesses may not be examined touching matters not relating to
the bankrupt's affairs. In re Carley (1901), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 106
Fed., 862; 5 A. B. R., 554.
Examination under this section is for the benefit of trustee in protec-
tion and preservation of the estate. Notice to the bankrupt not necessary,
nor has he right to participate therein. In re Cobb (1901), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer, R., 7 A. B. R., 104.
Whether a question asked a witness is proper is for the court, not the
witness, to determine — if professional secrets are claimed it is for the cotirt
to determine by preliminary inquiries whether such relation exists and
whether the reason is good. Peoples Bank ef Buffalo v. Brown (1902),
C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Dallas, J., 112 Fed., 652; 7 A. B. R., 475.
Wife of bankrupt is incompetent witness under law of State of Washing-
ton. In re Jefferson (1899), Dist. Wash., Handford, J., 96 Fed., 826;
3 A. B. R., 174; 1 N. B. N., 288.
Wife of bankrupt held not competent witness for examination in
Wisconsin. In re Mayer (1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 97 Fed., 328;
3 A. B. R., 222; 2 N. B. N., 257.
Questions asked bankrupt must relate only to bankrupts present
assets. In re White (1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Mack, R., 2 N. B. N., 536.
Wife not competent witness in Missouri. In re Cohn (1900), E. Dist.
Mo., Adams, J., 104 Fed., 328; 5 A. B. R., 16.
Examination can only extend to acts of bankrupt or acts of third
persons, so interwoven with acts of bankrupt as to make them virtually
the same by reason of commimity of interest. In re Carley (1902),
Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 106 Fed., 862; 5 A. B. R., 554.
Large latitude is allowed in the examination of persons closely con-
nected with the bankrupt in business dealing. In re Horgan & Slattery
(1899), 98 Fed., 414; 3 A. B. R., 253.
Bankrupt cannot be compelled to answer criminating questions. In
re Nachman (1902), Dist. S. C, Brawley, J., 114 Fed., 995; 8 A. B. R., 180.
Order for examination may be made on the simple application or de-
mand of a creditor or interested party — examination of third persons is
to afford full information touching bankrupt's estate. In re Fixen &
Co. (1899), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn, J., 96 Fed., 748; 2 A. B. R., 822.
Bankrupt required to attend whenever reasonably reqtiired by credi-
124 EVIDENCE. [§21 bed.
tors. In re Mellen (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 326; 3
A. B. R., 226.
b [Depositions— right to take.] The right to take depo-
sitions in proceedings under this Act shall be determined
and enjoyed according to the United States laws now
in force, or such as may be hereafter enacted relating to the
taking of depositions, except as herein provided.
Depositions of a witness living more than a hiindred miles from the
place of trial, or who is about to leave the district, or is old and infirm,
may be taken before a judge of any United States court, or commissioner
of the United States, Clerk of a Circtiit or District court. Chancellor,
Justice or Judge of a Supreme or Superior cotirt. Mayor of a City, Judge
of a County court or court of common pleas, or any Notary Public, not
attorney, in the case. Revised Statute of the United States, Sec. 863
and 867. State laws as to taking depositions may be followed. 2 Sup.
R. S. ofU. S.,p. 4.
Examination commission allowed in district other than the one in
which petition filed — practice under U. S. statute. In re Carley (1901),
Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 106 Fed., 862; 5 A. B. R., 554.
c [Notice of talcing depositions.] Notice of the taking
of depositions shall be filed with the referee in every case.
When depositions are to be taken in opposition to the al-
lowance of a claim notice shall also be served upon the
claimant, and when in opposition to a discharge notice shall
also be served upon the bankrupt.
As to allowance of claims, see Sec. 57c. As to what depositions to
prove debts shall contain, see General Order XXI (1) .
d [Certified copies as evidence.] Certified copies of pro-
ceedings before a referee, or of papers, when issued by the
clerk or referee, shall be admitted as evidence v/ith like
force and effect as certified copies of the records of district
courts of the United States are now or may hereafter be
admitted as evidence.
As to evidence, see Sec. 21 and notes; see also as to evidence. Rev.
St. of U. S., Sec. 4,992, 5,119.
Certified copy of record showing petition adjudication and appoint-
§22 a.] REFERENCE OF CASES AFTER ADJUDICATION. 125
ment and qualification of trustee authenticated by certificate of referee
admissible in evidence in suit by trustee to set aside conveyance. Sprallin
V. Colson Bros. (1902), Sup. Ct. Miss., Tennel, J., 80 Miss., 278.
e [Copy of order approving trustees bond.] A certified
copy of the order approving the bond of a trustee shall
constitute conclusive evidence of the vesting in him of the
title to the property of the bankrupt, and if recorded shall
impart the same notice that a deed from the bankrupt to
the trustee if recorded would have imparted had not bank-
ruptcy proceedings intervened.
As to form of order approving trustee's bond, see Form No. 17. As
to time title vests in trustee, see Sec. 70.
/ [Certified copy of orders — evidence.] A certified copy
of an order confirming or setting aside a composition, or
granting or setting aside a discharge, not revoked, shall be
evidence of the jurisdiction of the court, the regularity of the
proceedings, and of the fact that the order was made.
As to evidence, see Sec. 21 and notes; also notes to a,b,c, d and e of
this section.
g [Evidence of revesting of title in the bankrupt.] A
certified copy of an order confirming a composition shall
constitute evidence of the revesting of the title of his prop-
erty in the bankrupt, and if recorded shall impart the same
notice that a deed from the trustee to the bankrupt if re-
corded would impart.
Confirmation of composition revests title in the bankrupt. Sec. 70f
and notes.
Sec. 22. Reference of Cases after Adjudication.
a [Judge may refer cause.] After a person has been ad-
judged a bankrupt the judge may cause the trustee to pro-
ceed with the administration of the estate, or refer it
As to order of reference, see Form 14. As to what the order of ref-
erence shall contain, see Gen. Ord. XII. Proceedings after reference to
126 STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS.— JURISDICTION. [§23 a.
be before referee unless required by act to be before judge, Gen. Ord.
XXII. As to powers and duties of referees, see Sec. 39; also Gen. Ord.
XXXV.
(1) [General or Special Reference.] Generally to the
referee or specially with only limited authority to act in
the premises or to consider and report upon specified is-
sues ; or
. (2) [To any referee within the jurisdiction.] To any
referee within the territorial jurisdiction of the court, if the
convenience of parties in interest will be served thereby, or
for cause, or if the bankrupt does not do business, reside, or
have his domicile in the district.
b [Transfer to different referee.] The judge may, at any
time, for the convenience of parties or for cause, transfer a
case from one referee to another.
See ante Sec. 2 (19) as to transfer of cases. As to fees in case of ref-
erence, see Sec. 40b.
Sec. 23. Jurisdiction of United States and State
Courts.
a [Circuit Courts,] The United States circuit courts
shall have jurisdiction of all controversies at law and in
equity, as distinguished from proceedings in bankruptcy,
between trustees as such and adverse claimants concerning
the property acquired or claimed by the trustees, in the
same manner and to the same extent only as though bank-
ruptcy proceedings had not been instituted and such con-
troversies had been between the bankrupts and such ad-
verse claimants.
As to removal of causes to Circuit Coiirt, Sec. 638 Rev. St., U. S. ; also
1 Sup. Rev., St. 611.
As to jurisdiction of courts of bankruptcy, see Sec. 2. As to suits by
and against bankrupts, see Sec. 11 and notes. As to suits by trustee to
recover property transferred, Sec. 60b.
§23b.] STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS. — ^JURISDICTION. 127
Held, United States Cotirts have jurisdiction to determine validity of
assignments — construes clause to be one relating to the jurisdiction of the
United States Circuit Courts and not applicable to the District Courts,
and not impairing the effect of Chapler II, ante. In re Sievers (1899),
Adams, J., E. Dist. Mo., 91 Fed., 366; 1 A. B. R., 117; 1 N. B. N., 67.
Contra — District court no jurisdiction in replevin where bankrupts
and defendant are citizens of same state. Mitchell v. McClure (1899) ,
W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 91 Fed., 621; 1 A. B. R., 53; 1 N.B.N.,138.
Circuit Covirt of the United States has no jurisdiction of a sviit by a
trustee to set aside conveyance by bankrupt in fraud of creditors where
the parties are outside of the State. Goodier v. Barnes (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Coxe, J., 94 Fed., 798; 2 A. B. R., 328; 1 N. B. N., 383.
After adjudication trustee must be made a party to a subsequent pro-
ceeding for foreclosure. Mills v. Kiernan (1900) , Sup. Ct. N. Y., Birchoff,
J., 1 N. B. N., 410.
h [Suits by trustee — where brought.] Suits by the
trustee shall only be brought or prosecuted in the courts
where the bankrupt, whose estate is being administered by
such trustee, might have brought or prosecuted them if
proceedings in bankruptcy had not been instituted, unless
by consent of the proposed defendant* except suits for the
recovery of property under Section sixty, subdivision b, and
section sixty-seven, subdivision e. c*
Amended by Act of 1903. Section 8 of amendment page -post.
Amendment adds matter between stars.
As to trustees bringing sviits, see Sec. 11 and notes. Suit by trustee
may be prosecuted to set aside a preference, 60b.
The Supreme Court of the United States in discussing this section
settled the question of the jurisdiction of the district courts in suits by
the trustee against third parties — following the notes of these cases are
the notes of sundry courts many of them preceding those decisions in
point of time.
(The amendment of 1903 will be noted supra)
District court no jurisdiction, except by consent of suit by trustee
against third person to collect assets or set aside preferences. Bardes v.
First National Bank ef Hawarden (1900), U. S., Sup. Ct., Gray, J., 175
U. S., 526; 4 A. B. R., 163; 2 N. B. N., 725.
Wall v.Cox (1901), U. S. Sup. Ct., Gray, J.. 181 U. S.. 244; 5 A. B.
128 STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS. — JURISDICTION. [§23b.
R., 727. Mitchell v. McClure (1900), U. S. Sup. Ct., 178 U. S., 539; 4
A. B. R., 177. Hicks v. Knost (1900), U. S. Sup. Ct., 178 U. S., 541; 4
A. B. R., 178; Mueller v. Nugent (1902), Sup. Ct. U. S., Fuller, J.,
184 U. S., 1.
An assignee for the benefit of creditors in the State court has the right
to have his claims for services and attorneys' fees adjudicated in the
State covut — bankruptcy court has no jurisdiction to adjudicate the
merits of his claim tmless by his consent and then only by plenary suit.
Louisville Trust Co. v. Cominger (1902), Sup. Ct. of U. S., Fuller, J., 184
U. S., 18; 7 A. B. R., 421; affirming Sinsheimer v. Simonson (1901), C.
C. A.. 6th Cir., Severens, J., 107 Fed., 898; 5 A. B. R., 537.
Statute of Hmitations of the state applies as to creditor's bill by trustee
This section does not apply to creditors bill brought by trustee. Lehman
v. Crosby (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 99 Fed., 542; 3 A. B. R., 662;
1 N. B. N., 451.
This section is a limitation on Circviit courts of the United States
and not on District coiuls. Cox v. Wall et al. (1900), W. Dist. N. C.
Ewart, J., 99 Fed., 546; 3 A. B. R., 664; 2 N. B. N., 572.
Bill by trustee to set aside fraudulent transfer of personalty is proper
procedure. Cox v. Wall el al. (1900), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 99 Fed.,
546; 3 A. B. R., 664; 2 N. B. N., 572.
Supreme Court of N. Y. has jurisdiction to entertain suit by trustee to
set aside fraudulent conveyance. Silberstein v. Stahl et al. (1900), N.
Y. Sup. Ct., Russell, J.; 4 A. B. R., 626.
Jurisdiction of Circuit court in suit where trustee is party entertained.
Bank v. Iron Co. (1899), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 102 Fed., 755; 3 A.
B. R., 582; 99 Fed., 82.
Jiuisdiction of District court is not restricted by this section and bill
to set aside fraudulent transfer will be entertained. Norcross v. Nathan
(1900), Dist. Nevada, Hawley, J., 99 Fed., 414; 3 A. B. R., 613; 2 N. B.
N., 405.
Subdivision b of this section does not divest the District Court of jur-
isdiction. Carter v. Hobb et al. (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 92 Fed.,
594; 1 A. B. R., 215; 1 N. B. N., 191.
Section 23b does not deprive District court of jurisdiction of suits
by trustee to set aside preferences. Murray v. Beal (1899), Dist. Utah.
Marshall, J., 97 Fed., 567; 3 A. B. R., 284; 2 N. B. N., 164.
Where property is in litigation in State Court parties thereto coming
into district subject themselves to order therein. In re Rik.;r (1901),
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 107 Fed., 96; 5 A. B. R., 720.
A bill by a trustee to set aside a fraudvdent cdbveyance is cognizable
§23b.] STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS. — JURISDICTION. 129
in the District court. Carter v. Hobbs (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 92
Fed., 594; 1 A. B. R., 215; 1 N. B. N., 191.
The District court has jurisdiction over mortgages to inquire into their
validity without the consent of the mortgagee. Carter v. Hobbs (1899),
Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 92 Fed., 594; 1 A. B. R., 215; 1 N. B. N., 191.
The District court cannot entertain jurisdiction of suit by trustee to
set aside conveyance. Burnett v. Morris Mercantile Co. (1899), Dist.
Ore., Bellinger, J., 91 Fed., 365; 1 A. B. R., 229; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Courts of bankruptcy have no jurisdiction of suits by trustee against
third persons to collect money due the bankrupt. Sec. 23 limits Sec. 2.
Hicks v. Knest (1899), S. Dist. Ohio, Thompson, J., 94 Fed., 625; 2 A. B.
R., 153; 1 N. B. N., 336.
Assignment in state court before bankruptcy petition and subsequent
sale by assignee cannot be attacked by summary proceedings in bank-
ruptcy— chancery action necessary. In re Abraham (1899), C. C. A.,
5th Cir., McCormick, J., 93 Fed., 767; 2 A. B. R., 266; 1 N. B. N., 281.
District court no jurisdiction of suit by trustee to set aside fraudulent
transfer. Perkins v. McCauley et al. (1899), S. Dist. Cal., Wellborn,
J., 98 Fed., 286; 3 A. B. R., 445.
Contra, Louisville v. Trust Comingor (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans," J., 98
Fed., 456; 3 A. B. R., 450.
No jurisdiction in District court where third person holds ""property
of bankrupt under fraudulent transfer. In re Sheinbaum (1901), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 107 Fed., 247; 5 A. B. R., 187.
Equity will follow fund created by wrongfvd conversion of stocks
held by bankrupt as broker. Hutchinson v. Leroy (1902), C C.A., 1st.
Cir., Putnam, J., 115 Fed., 937; 8 A. B. R., 20.
No jurisdiction in State Court to entertain bill in equity to preserve
assets until the bankruptcy law will be invoked. Ideal Clothing Co. v.
Hazel (1901), Sup. Ct., Mich.; 6 A. B. R., 265; 3 N. B. N., 630.
State Court no jurisidction of suit againt trustee in bankruptcy for
possession of property, held by him. Turrentine v. Blackwood (1900),
Ala. Sup. Ct., Harralson, J., 28 So., 95; 4 A. B. R., 338.
State Court having obtained jurisdiction by foreclosure before bank-
ruptcy can retain it to the end. In re Gerdes (1900), So. Dist. Ohio,
Thompson, J., 102 Fed., 318; 4 A. B. R., 346; 2 N. B. N., 131.
Section 23b does not deprive District Court of suits by trustee to set
aside preferences. Murray v. Beal (1899), Marshall, J., 97 Fed., 567;
3 A. B. R., 284; 2 N. B. N., 164.
Equitable replevin allowed on rescission of contract of sale for fraud-
130 STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS.— JURISDICTION. [§23b.
In re Weil (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., Ill Fed., 897; 7 A. B. R.
90.
Permission may be given mortgagee to make trustee defendant
In re San. Gabriel S. Co. (1901), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Ill Fed., 892; 7 A
B. R., 206.
District Court has no jurisdiction to set aside a conveyance between
a husband and wife on petition of creditors — remedy is by trustee in
State Court. In re Griffith (1899), E. Dist. Tenn., Grayson, R.; 1 N. B.
N., 645.
Finding as to title of property is res adjudicata until reversed and
should not be re-opened by the cotirt which made it. In re Lemmon &
Gale Co. (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 112 Fed., 296; 7 A. B. R., 291.
Jurisdiction not waived if want of not raised till filing of second amen-
ded petition in suit by trustee. In re Hemby , Hutchinson Pub. Co. (1900)
N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J.. 105 Fed., 909; 5 A. B. R., 569.
Jurisdiction having been given by consent can not be revoked — con-
struction of validity of chattel mortgage. In re Durham (1902), Dist-
Md., Morris, J., 114 Fed., 750; 8 A. B. R., 115
Jurisdiction of United States District Court in bankruptcy paramount
to that of State Covu"t over estate being administered in insolvency pro-
ceedings. Comity can not confer jurisdiction. In re Macon Lvunber
Co. (1901), S. Dist. Ga., Spear, J., 112 Fed., 323; 7 A. B. R., 66.
District Court no jvirisdiction in suit to set aside conveyance by bank-
rupt which is alleged to be fraudulent. In re Carter (1899), S. Dist.
Ga., Myrick, R., 1 A. B. R., 160; 1 N. B. N., 162.
Mere interest of trustee in results of pending litigation in the State
Court, no ground for staying action, or transferring same to United States
court. In re Greater American Exposition (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir.,
Thayer, J.; 4 A. B. R., 486.
The District Court has no jiuisdiction to collect a preferential payment
made to a creditor. In re Goldberg (1899), Dist. Utah, Baldwin, R.,
1 A. B. R., 385; 1 N. B. N.. 266.
Bankruptcy court no jurisdiction to determine by simimary proceed-
ing a controversy between the trustee as such and an adverse claimant
concerning property claipied by the trustee. In re Fowler (1899) , Dist.
Conn. Banks, R., 93 Fed., 417; 1 A. B. R., 637; 1 N. B. N., 215.
Bankruptcy court no power to compel court to reopen a case which
proceeded after bankruptcy to suit on a bail bond against the surety
only. In re Franklin (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 106 Fed., 666; 6
A B. R., 285.
State law governs application of trustee to intervene in suit in State
■ §23b.] STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS. — JURISDICTION. 131
court. Bank of Comtnerce v. Elliott (1901), Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall, J.,
109 Wis., 648; 6 A. B. R., 409.
When court will adjudicate claim to exempt property — liens on prop-
erty set aside as exempt must be adjudicated in other courts. In re
Little (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed., 621; 6 A. B. R., 681.
Title of third person, although a daughter of bankrupt, can only be
tested in plenary suit by trustee, and not by stmmiary process. In re
Cohn (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 75; 3 A. B. R., 421;
2 N. B. N., 299.
Jurisdiction of a State Court which has appointed a receiver of a firm
is not to be assailed in a court of bankruptcy in subsequent proceedings —
no order will be made on the receiver to ttim over the assets — tmstee must
apply to state court for such an order. In re Price & Co. (1899) , S. Dist,
N. Y., Brown, J., 92 Fed., 987; 1 A. B. R., 606; 1 N. B. N.,131.
District court no jurisdiction to sue third party for debt due bankrupt-
cy estate. In re Goldberg (1899), Dist. Utah, Baldwin, R.; 1 A. B. R., 385;
1 N. B. N., 256.
Trustee shotdd obtain consent of court before bringing suit. In re
Mersman (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 7 A. B. R., 46.
Creditor who has voluntarily Utigated in District court validity of
transfer by bankrupt, cannot afterwards deny jurisdiction of the court.
Phillips v. Turner (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 114 Fed., 726; 8 A. B. R., 171.
Court of bankruptcy no power to determine the merits of a controversy
where there is real claim in fact even though fraudtdent. In re Michie
(1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 116 Fed., 749; 8 A. B. R.. 734.
Corporation to whom a debtor transferred all his property, adjudged
bankrupt — District court no jurisdiction to entertain plenary sixit in
equity to determine the vaUdity of the transfer. Real Estate Trust Co.
v. Thompson (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 112 Fed., 945; 7 A. B.
R., 520.
Suit by trustee to set aside fraudulent conveyance brought in state
court. Sheldon v. Parker (1902) , Sup. Ct. Neb., Duffie, J., 92 N. W., 923;
Skillin V. Maihrunn (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J., 78 N. Y. Supp.,
436.
Trustee may bring the action any time within two years to set aside
fraudulent conveyance. Schreck v. Hanlon (1902), Sup. Ct. Neb., Duffie,
J., 92 N. W., 625; Myers v. Hart (1901), C. C. Ohio, Cook. J., 22 Ohio, C.
C, 427; Lyon v. Clark (1900), Sup. Ct., Mich. Moore, J., 124 Mich., 100.
Vacation of judgment against bankrupt not granted trustee as he had
adequate remedy by action to recover the property. Gage v. Bates Mach.
Co. (1902), Sup Ct. N. H., Walker, J., 52 Atl., 457.
132 JURISDICTION OF APPELLATE COURTS. [§24a.
State Courts have concurrent jurisdiction with federal courts of an
action of trover to determine title to goods taken by trustee. Fruda
V. Osgood (1901), Sup. Ct. N. H., Blodget, J., 51 Atl., 663.
Trustee to prosecute suits in State courts or in the U. S. Circuit Court
where diversity of citizenship exists. Robinson v. White (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 97 Fed., 33; Bindseil v. Coshion (1900), Sup. Ct. N. J.,
60 N. J. Eq., 116; Lyon v. Clark (1900), Sup. Ct. Mich., 124 Mich., 100;
Nye v. Hart (1901), 12 Ohio Cir. Dec, 419; Jones v. Schermerhorn (1900),
63 N. Y. App. Div., 143; French v. R. Pets. Co. (1900), 81 Minn., 341.
Where property in hands of the trustee, the bankruptcy court has
jurisdiction on full hearing to determine the question of validity and
amount of a mortgage lien thereon. In re Kellogg (1902) , W. Dist. N.
Y., Hazel, J., 113 Fed., 120; 7 A. B. R., 623.
Claimant of lien on property in lawful possession of trustee must
submit to jurisdiction of bankruptcy court, where it comes in and files
petition submitting to the jurisdiction. In re Durham (1902), Dist. Md.,
Morris, J., 114 Fed., 750; 8 A. B. R., 115.
c [Concurrent jurisdiction of District and Circuit Courts.]
The United States circuit courts shall have concurrent juris-
diction with the courts of bankruptcy, within their respective
territorial limits, of the offenses enumerated in this Act.
As to offenses under Act, see Sec. 29 and notes.
This is limited strictly to offenses and does not extend to civil suits.
Goodier v. Barnes (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 94 Fed., 798; 2 A. B.
R., 328.
Sec. 24. Jurisdiction of Appellate Courts.
a [Courts witti appellate jurisdiction Supreme Court.]
The Supreme Court of the United States, the circuit courts
of appeals of the United States, and the supreme courts of
the Territories, in vacation in chambers and during their
respective terms, as now or as they may be hereafter held,
are hereby invested with appellate jurisdiction of contro-
versies arising in bankruptcy proceedings from the courts
of bankruptcy from which they have appellate jurisdiction
in other cases. The Supreme Court of the United States
shall exercise a like jurisdiction from courts of bankruptcy
§24b.] JURISDICTION OF APPELLATE COURTS, 133
not within any organized circuit of the United States and
from the supreme cotirt of the District of Columbia.
See post Sec. 24b. As to procedure on appeals, see Gen. Order
XXXVI post, and notes. See Sec. 25 for orders from which appeals will
lie.
For procedure in appeals to the Supreme Court of United States, see
Rev. Stat, of U. S., Sec. 687 to 611; see also 2 Sup. R. S. U. S., 79, 209.
541. For proceedings on appeals in Circuit Courts of Appeals, see 1
Sup. Rev. S. U. S., 910; also 2 Sup. Rev. St. U. S., 542.
No appeal lies directly to the Supreme Court of the United States
from a judgment dismissing an involuntary petition entered upon the
finding of a jury that the alleged bankrupt was a farmer. First Nat.
Bank of Denver et al. v. Klug (1902), Sup. Ct. U. S., Fuller, J., 186 U. S.,
203; 8 A. B. R., 12.
In order that an appeal may lie imder this section in cases not enumer-
ated in Sec. 25, it must be a final order or decree order within the mean-
ing of the Act creating the Circiiit Court of Appeals. In re Columbia
Real Estate Co. (1902), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 112 Fed., 643; 7
A. B. R., 441.
h [Circuit Courts of Appeals.] The several circuit courts
of appeal shall have jurisdiction in equity, either inter-
locutory or final, to superintend and revise in matter of law
the proceedings of the several inferior courts of bankruptcy
within their jurisdiction. Such power shall be exercised on
due notice and petition by any party aggrieved.
See as to appeals, Sec. 25 and notes; also as to procedure, Gen. Ord,
XXXVI. See notes to a ante.
Held, that jvirisdiction is by original petition to review matters of law
only. In re Rouse, Hazard Co. (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir., 91 Fed., 96.
1 A. B. R., 234; 1 N. B. N., 75.
The Circuit Court of Appeals only revises the action of the District
Court in matters of law. In re Purvine (1899) , C. C. A., 5th Cir., Newman.
J., 96 Fed., 192; 2 A. B. R., 787.
This section is governed by 25a. In re Good (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir.
Thayer, J., 99 Fed., 389; 3 A. B. R., 605;
This section relates only to questions of law and not of fact. In re
Whitener (1900), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 105 Fed., 180; 5 A. B.
R.. 198.
134 JURISDICTION OF APPELLATE COURTS. [§24b.
Petition for review does not authorize review of questions of fact. In
re Rosser (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sandbom, J., 101 Fed., 562; 4 A. B.
R., 153.
No time limit for petition for review. In re New York Economical
Printing Co. (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Putnam, J., 106 Fed., 839; 5 A.
B. R., 697.
Petition for review does not have the effect of appeal or writ of error
in removing the cause. In re Orman (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 107 Fed.,
101; 5. A B. R., 698.
Only party aggrieved by adverse decision can be heard on appeal there-
from. Bank of Com. v. Elliott (1901), Sup. Ct. Wis., Marshall, J., 109
Wis., 648; 6 A. B. R., 409.
Jurisdiction extends to review of law not facts, and is not on appeal
but by petition. Courier Journal Job. P. Co. v. Scharfer-Meyer-Print-
ing Co. 101 Fed., 699; 4 A. B. R., 183.
Petition for review may be filed inside of six months — questions of law
may be raised by petition for review of facts by appellee. In re Wor-
cester County (1900), C. C. A., 1st Cir., 102 Fed., 808; 4 A. B. R., 496.
Petition for review to court of appeals not allowed in cases between
trustee and third persons — such cases must be brought up by appeal
or writ of error under Clause a. In re Jacobs (1900), C. C. A,, 8th Cir.
Thayer, J., 99 Fed., 539; 3 A. B. R., 671.
Distinction between petition for review and appeal — the former only
applies to law questions, the latter both to the law and the facts. In re
Richards (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 96 Fed., 935; 3 A. B. R.
145; 2 N. B. N., 38.
Compare in re Rouse, Hazard & Co. 1 A. B. R., 231 and in re Purvine
(1899), 2 A. B. R., 787; see ante this section.
Bankruptcy court is not required to make a statement of facts for pur-
pose of appeal. In re Meyers (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 105 Fed.,
353; 5 A. B. R., 4.
The practice on appeal to Appellate Court is by writ of error where a
jury trial has been had, or act of bankruptcy not shown by suffering a
judgment. Some act of acquiescence necessary to be shown. Duncan
et at. v. Landis (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 106 Fed., 839; 5 A. B.
R., 649.
Creditor appealing from the allowance of a claim, when trustee refuses
to so appeal. McDaniel v. Strand (1901), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Simonton,
J., 106 Fed., 486; 5 A. B. R., 685.
Order of dismissal of involuntary petition may under this section be
§25 a.] APPEALS AND WRITS OF ERROR. 135
set aside as regtilations affecting appeals do not apply. In re Jamison
Mercantile Co. (1902), 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 112 Fed., 966; 7 A. B.
R., 588.
Appeal lies directly from District court to the Supreme court in bank-
ruptcy proceedings. First Nat. Bank v. Klug (1902), Sup. Ct. United
States, Fuller, J., 186 U. S., 203; 8 A. B. R., 12.
Sec. 25. Appeals and writs of Error.
a [When appeals may be taken.] That appeals, as in
equity cases, may be taken in bankruptcy proceedings from
the courts of bankruptcy to the circuit court of appeals of
the United States, and to the supreme court of the Terri-
tories, in the following cases, to wit,
(1) [Judgment on adjudication.] From a judgment
adjudging or refusing to adjudge the defendant a bankrupt;
(2) [Judgment on discharge.] From a judgment grant-
ing or denying a discharge ; and
(3) [Ju^ment on claim.] From a judgment allowing or
rejecting a debt or claim of five himdred dollars or over.
Such appeal shall be taken within ten days after the judg-
ment appealed from has been rendered, and may be heard
and determined by the appellate court in term or vacation,
as the case may be.
Held, the jurisdiction of Appellate court includes questions of law
and of fact on appeal taken in ten days. Petition for review covers
questions of law only. In re Rouse, Hazard Co. (1899), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., 91 Fed., 96; 1 A. B. R., 234; 1 N. B. N.. 75.
A petition for review and not an appeal, the proper method of taking
case to covirt of appeals where court issued summary order determining
title to property. In re Abraham (1899), C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick,
J., 93 Fed., 767; 2 A. B. R., 266; 1 N. B. N., 281.
This section applies to appeal from adjudication which must be taken
within ten days. In re Good (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 99
Fed., 389; 3 A. B. R., 605.
No appeal having been taken in ten days after decree court can allow
petition for rehearing, so as to open up time for appeal. In re Wright
136 APPEALS AND WRITS OF ERROR. [§25 a.
(1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 96 Fed., 820; 3 A. B. R., 184; 1 N. B. N.,
428.
Appeal to Circuit court of Appeals on the question of allowance of
attorneys' fees for over $500. In re Curtis (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Jenkins,;., 100 Fed., 784; 4 A. B. R., 17.
Under this section law and fact are both reviewable. Courier Journal
P. Co. V. Scharfer-Meyer-Printing Co., C. C. A., 6th Cir., 101 Fed., 699;
4 A. B. R., 183.
No appeal lies to the Supreme court of the territory for amount under
$500. In re Stumpf (1900), Sup. Okla., Burrell, J., 4 A. B. R., 267.
Creditor no right of appeal from allowance of claims except through
the trustee. District court may order trustee to make appeal. Chat-
field V. O'Dwyer (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., 101 Fed., 797; 4 A. B. R., 313-
Appeal must be perfected in ten days in the lower court. Norcross
V. Nave & McCord Mer. Co. (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., 101 Fed., 796; 4
A. B. R., 317.
Time limit for appeals does not apply to suits outside of the bank-
ruptcy proceedings to recover assets. Silence gives consent to jurisdic-
tion. It is too late to object in the Appellate Court. Boonville Nat,
Bank V. Balkey (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 107 Fed., 891; 6
A. B. R., 13.
The decisions of the federal court of appeals in a district embracing
Indiana construing a federal statute must be regarded as of controlling
authority in a bankruptcy proceeding — discussion of federal court as to
insolvency. Severin v. Robinson (1901), App. Ct. Ind., Wiley, J., 27
Ind. App., 65.
No appeal from interlocutory order reviewing ruling of the referee,
refusing to compel the bankrupt to produce the books for examination.
Goodman v. Brunner (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 109 Fed., 481;
6 A. B. R., 470.
Order sustaining demurrer to petition to vacate order of adjudication
filed by creditors in voluntary proceedings, is not appealable vmder this
section, but reviewable under Section 24. Creditor can not file petition
asking that a voluntary adjudication be set aside. In re Ives (1902),
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Ill Fed., 495; 7 A. B. R., 692.
Where a matter of law is solely involved, petition for review and not
appeal will be allowed. Hutchinson v. Leroy (1902), C. C. A, 1st Cir.
Putnam, J., 115 Fed., 937; 8 A. B. R., 20.
No alteration in the order of the court of appeals can be made in Dis-
trict court. No terms of court in District court as to all interlocutory
§25b.] APPEALS AND WRITS OF ERROR. 137
orders in bankruptcy. In re Henschel (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J.,
114 Fed., 968; 8 A. B. R., 201.
Only trustee can appeal from allowance of claim. Foreman v. Bur-
leigh et al. (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir , Putnam, J., 109 Fed., 489; 6 A.
B. R., 230.
Appeal from allowance of claim may be taken by any one in interest.
In re Roche (1900), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 101 Fed., 956; 4 A. B. R., 369.
The word "claim" means any money demand. In re Whitener (1901),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., 105 Fed., 180; 5 A. B. R., 198.
Bankrupt has no right of appeal from order refusing approval of com-
position where trustee only has opposed the approval. Ross v. Saunders,
C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 5 A. B. R., 350.
h [Appeal to Supreme Court from Circuit Court of
Appeals.] From any final decision of a court of appeals,
allowing or rejecting a claim under this Act, an appeal may-
be had under such rules and within such time as may be
prescribed by the Supreme Court of the United States, in
the following cases and no other:
As to appeals and the procedure prescribed by the Supreme Court,
see Gen. Ord. XXXVI. See Act of 1891 creating Circuit Court of Ap- .
peals, 1 Sup. Rev. S. U. S., p. 901.
1. [Jurisdictional amount — question involved.] Where
the amoimt in controversy exceeds the sum of two thousand
dollars, and the question involved is one which might have
been taken on appeal or writ of error from the highest court
of a State to the Supreme Court of the United States ; or
As to cases from State Court to United States Supreme Court, see Rev.
St. U. S., Sec. 698-705.
2. [Certificate of question by Supreme Court Justice.]
Where some Justice of the Supreme Court of the United
States shall certify that in his opinion the determination of
the question or questions involved in the allowance or re-
jection of such claim is essential to a uniform construction
of this Act throughout the United States.
13S APPEALS AND WRITS OF ERROR. [§25cd.
c. [Tnistee oot required to give bond.] Trustees shall
not be required to give bond when they take appeals or sue
out writs of error.
d [Certificate to Supreme Court by other courts.] Con-
troversies may be certified to the Supreme Court of the United
States from other courts of the United States, and the former
court may exercise jurisdiction thereof and issue writs of
certiorari pursuant to the provisions of the United States
laws now in force or such as may be hereafter enacted.
Sec. 5. That appeals or writs of error may be taken from the district
courts or from the existing circuit courts direct to the supreme coiui; in
the following cases:
In any case in which the jurisdiction of the court is in issue; in such
cases the question of jurisdiction alone shall be certified to the supreme
covul; from the court below for decision.
From the final sentences and decrees in prize causes.
In cases of conviction of a capital or otherwise infamous crime.
In any case that involves the construction or application of the con-
stitution of the United States.
In any case in which the constitutionality of any law of the United
States, or the validity or construction of any treaty made imder its au-
thority, is drawn in question.
In any case in which the constitution or law of a state is claimed
to be in contravention of the constitution of the United States.
Nothing in this act shall affect the jurisdiction of the supreme court
in cases appealed from the highest court of a state, nor the construction
of the statute providing for review of such cases. Act of 1891, 1 Supp
Rev. St., U. S., 901.
Certificate of questions from District to Supreme Court controlled by
Section 5 Judiciary Act of 1891. Final judgment must precede certifi-
cate. Bardesv. First Nat. Bank of Hawarden, U. S. Sup. Ct., Fuller, J.,
175 U. S.. 526; 3 A. B. R., 680; 2 N. B. N., 75.
See ante, note to Sec. 24, practice in petition for review. In re Rich-
ards (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir., 96 Fed., 935; 3 A. B. R., 145; 2 N. B. N., 38.
See the case in re Newberry (1899), W. Dist. Mich., Severans, J.. 97
Fed., 24; 3 A. B. R., 158; 2 N. B. N., 56.
§§ 26, 27, 28] ARBITRATION OF CONTROVERSIES. 1S0
Sec. 26. Arbitration of Controversies.
a [Trustee may submit to arbitration.] The trustee may,
pursuant to the direction of the court, submit to arbitration
any controversy arising in the settlement of the estate.
As to arbitration and what the application should show see Gen. Ord.
XXXIII.
b [Selection of arbitrators.] Three arbitrators shall be
chosen by mutual consent, or one by the trustee, one by the
other party to the controversy, and the third by the two
so chosen, or if they fail to agree in five days after their
appointment the court shall appoint the third arbitrator.
See as to arbitration Gen. Ord. XXXIII.
c [Effect of findings.] The written findings of the arbi-
trators, or a majority of them, as to the issues presented,
may be filed in court axid shall have like force and effect as
the verdict of a jury.
As to procedure in arbitration see Gen. Ord. XXXIII.
Arbitrators must be appointed in the manner prescribed by the statute.
Court may review findings. In re McLam (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J.,
97 Fed., 922; 3 A. B. R., 245.
Sec. 27. Compromises.
a [When allowed.] The trustee may, with the approval
of the court, compromise any controversy arising in the
administration of the estate upon such terms as he may deem
for the best interests of the estate.
Creditors must receive notice of compromises, Sec. 58a (7).
Sec 28. Designation of Newspapers.
a [To publish notices.] Courts of bankruptcy shall by or-
der designate a newspaper published within their respective
territorial districts, and in the county in which the bankrupt
resides or the major part of his property is situated, in which
140 OFFENSES. [§29ab.
notices required to be published by this Act and orders
which the coiirt may direct to be pubHshed shall be inserted.
Any court may in a particular case, for the convenience of
parties in interest, designate some additional newspaper
in which notices and orders in such case shall be published.
As to what notices mtist be published see Sec. 58.
Sec. 29. Offenses.
a [Misappropriating property — destroying documents.]
A person shall be punished, by imprisonment for a period
not to exceed five years, upon conviction of the offense of
having knowingly and fraudulently appropriated to his own
use, embezzled, spent, or imlawfuUy transferred any prop-
erty or secreted or destroyed any docimient belonging to a
bankrupt estate which came into his charge as trustee.
A trustee cannot be compelled to incriminate himself. In re Smith
(1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 112 Fed., 609; 7 A. B. R., 213.
h [Punishment by imprisonment.] A person shall be
punished, by imprisonment for a period not to exceed two
years, upon conviction of the offense of having knowingly
and fraudulently
(1) [Concealing property.] Concealed while a bankrupt,
or after his discharge, from his trustee any of the property
belonging to his estate in bankruptcy; or
See notes under Sec. 3.
Concealment of property must be shown by existence of property in
the bankrupt, or held in trust for him. In re Cornell (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 29; 3 A. B. R., 172.
Withholding money received after filing the petition is not conceal-
ment— it does not belong to the estate in bankruptcy. In re Polakoff
(1899), N. Dist. N.Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 358; 1 N. B. N., 232.
Bankrupt attorney omitting to schedule contingent fees unearned is
not guilty of fraudulent concealment. In re McAdam (1899) , S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 409; 3 A. B. R., 417; 2 N. B. N., 256.
§29C.] OFFENSES. 141
(2) [False oath or account.] Made a false oath or
account in, or in relation to, any proceeding in bankruptcy ;
As to oaths, see Sec. 20.
Reqviirement for indictment for perjury under this section. Barilett
V. United States (1901), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J., 106 Fed., 884; 5
A. B. R., 678.
There must be allegations of fraudulent intent — it must be specific
and definite. In re Wetmore (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Knight, R., 6 A.
B. R., 703.
(3) [False claims.] Presented under oath any false
claim for proof against the estate of a bankrupt, or used any
such claim in composition personally or by agent, proxy,
or attorney, or as agent, proxy, or attorney ; or
As to proof of claim, see Sec. 57 and Gen. Ord. XXI.
(4) [Received property from bankrupt.] Received any
material amount of property from a bankrupt after the
filing of the petition, with intent to defeat this Act ; or
(5) [Extorted money or property.] Extorted or at-
tempted to extort any money or property from any person
as a consideration for acting or forbearing to act in bank-
ruptcy proceedings.
c [Punishment by fine.] A person shall be ptmished by
fine, not to exceed five hundred dollars, and forfeit his office,
and the same shall thereupon become vacant, upon con-
viction of the offense of having knowingly
(1) [Acting as referee when interested.] Acted as a
referee in a case in which he is directly or indirectly in-
terested; or
As to referees, see Sees. 39 to 44.
(2) [Purchased property of estate.] Purchased, while
a referee, directly or indirectly, any property of the estate in
bankruptcy of which he is referee; or
As to when a case is before a referee, see Gen. Ord. XII.
142 COMPUTATION OF TIME. [§§30a,31a.
(3) [Refusal to pennit inspection of accounts and
papers.] Refused, while a referee or trustee, to permit a
reasonable opportunity for the inspection of the accounts
relating to the affairs of, and the papers and records of,
estates in his charge by parties in interest when directed
by the court so to do.
As to accounts of trustee, see Gen. Ord. XXVI. Accounts of trustees,
Gen. Ord. XVII.
d [One year limitation.] A person shall not be prose-
cuted for any offense arising under this Act unless the in-
dictment is found or the information is filed in court with-
in one year after the commission of the offense.
Sec. 30. Rules, Forms, and Orders.
a [Supreme Court to make.] All necessary rules, forms,
and orders as to procedure and for carrying this Act into
force and effect shall be prescribed, and may be amended
from time to time, by the Supreme Court of the United
States.
See Gen. Ord. XXXVIII as to forms.
The general orders are obligatory and binding upon courts of bank-
ruptcy. They confer rights as well as prescribe rules of practice, and must
be followed. In re Scott (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 99 Fed., 404;
3 A. B. R., 625; 2 N. B. N., 440.
Sec 31. Computation of Time.
a [How time computed.] Whenever time is enumerated
by days in this Act, or in any proceeding in bankruptcy, the
nvmiber of days shall be computed by excluding the first
and including the last unless the last fall on a Sunday or
holiday, in which event the day last included shall be the next
day thereafter which is not a Sunday or a legal holiday.
In computation of time with regard to the four months* limitation,
exclude the day when the act of bankruptcy was committed and include
§32 a.] TRANSFER OF CASES. 143
the day when the petition was filed. In re Stevenson (1899), Dist, Del.,
Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R., 66; 1 N. B. N., 313.
Fotir ivSl months after the act of bankruptcy must be allowed for
filing the petition. In re Tonawanda Street Planing Mill Co. (1901), W.
Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 6 A. B. R., 38.
Computation of time — attachment brought September 9th, and bank-
ruptcy January 9th, is within the four months and dissolved by bank-
ruptcy. Jones V. Stevens (1901), Sup. Ct. Maine, Wiswell, J., 48 Atl.,
170; 5 A. B. R., 571.
Sec. 32. Transfer of Cases.
a In the event petitions are filed against the same person,
or against different members of a partnership, in different
courts of bankruptcy each of which has jurisdiction, the
cases shall be transferred, by order of the courts relinquishing
jurisdiction, to and be consolidated by the one of such
courts which can proceed with the same for the greatest
convenience of parties in interest.
For transfer of cases, see General Order VI; also ante Sec. 2 Sub. (19).
Transfer will be made where it operates for greater convenience of
creditors. In re Sears (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 112 Fed., 58;
7 A. B. R., 279.
CHAPTER V.
Officers, their Duties and Compensation.
Sec. 33. Creation of Two
Offices.
a. Referee and trustee.
Sec. 34. Appointment, Removal
and Districts of Ref-
erees.
a. Duties of Courts.
(1) Appoint and remove referees.
(2) Drstricts of referees.
Sec. 35. Qualifications of Ref-
erees.
a. Who eligible.
(1) Competent.
(2) Not office holders.
(3) Not related to judges.
(4) Residents of districts.
Sec. 36. Oaths of office of
Referees.
a. Same oath as judge.
Sec. 37. Number of Referees.
a. Sufficient number to transact
business.
Sec. 38. Jurisdiction of Ref-
erees.
a. Jurisdiction in districts.
(1) Consider petitions.
(2) Administer oaths, etc.
(3) Take possession of property.
(4) Pei-form certain duties of
court.
(5) Authorize employment of
stenographers.
Sec. 39. Duties of Referees.
a. Duties.
(1) Declare divid^ids.
(2) Examine schedules and lists.
(3) Furnish information.
(4) Give notices.
(5 Make up records.
(6) Prepare schedules and lists.
(7) Prescrv'e and transmit rec-
ords.
(8) Transmit papers to clerks.
(9) Preserve evidence.
(4) Disburse money.
(5) Furnish information.
(6) Keep accotmts.
144
(10) Obtain papers,
b. Acts prohibited.
(1) Act where interested.
(2) Practice as attorney.
(3) Purchase from estate.
Sec 40. Compensation of Ref-
erees.
a. Fees and commissions.
b. Division between two referees.
c. Where reference revoked.
Sec 41. Contempts before Ref-
erees.
a. Prohibited acts.
(1) Disobey orders.
(2) Misbehave during hearing.
(3) Withhold documents.
(4) Refuse to appear for examina-
tion.
b. Contempt proceeaings — pen-
alty.
Sec 42. Records of Referees.
o. Manner of keeping.
b. Books and papers.
c. Become part of court records.
Sec 43. Referee's Absence or
Disability.
a. Filling vacancy.
Sec 44. Appointment of Trust-
tees.
a. Creditors appoint — when
court appoints.
Sec 45. Qualifications of Trus-
tees.
a. Who may be trustees.
(1) Individuals.
(2) Corporations.
Sec 46. Death or Removal of
Trustees.
a. Suit not to abate.
Sec 47. Duties op Trustees.
a. Duties.
(1) Account and pay over.
(2) Turn property into money —
close estates.
(3) Deposit money.
h. Fihng of bonds — suit upon
bonds.
§§ 33a, 34a.] appointment of referees.
145
(7) Make detailed statements.
(8) Make final reports.
(9) Pay dividends.
(10) Report condition of estates.
(11) Set apart exemptions.
b. Concurrence of two out of
three.
c. Trustee to file certified copy
of adjudication.
Sec. 48. Compensation of Trus-
tees.
a. Fees and commissions.
b. Where more than one trustee.
c. Compensation withheld.
Sec. 49. Accounts and Papers
OF Trustees.
a. Must be open to inspection.
Sec. 50. Bonds of Referees and
Trustees.
a. Referee's bonds.
b. Trustee's bonds.
c. Creditors fixing amount of
trustees' bond.
d. Sureties' quaUfication.
e. Two sureties.
/. Value of property of sureties.
\ g. Corporations as sureties.
t. Trustees 'personal liability.
i. Joint trustees.
K. Vacancy by failure to give
bond.
/. Limitation of suits on referees'
bonds.
in. Limitation of suits on trustees
bonds.
Sec. 51. Duties of Clerks.
Duties.
Account for fees.
Collect fees.
Deliver papers.
Pay referee's and trustee's
fee.
Sec. 52. Compensation of
Clerks and Marshals.
Clerk's filing fee.
Marshal's fee.
53. Duties of Attorney-
General.
Collect and report statistics of
cases.
54. Statistics of Bank-
ruptcy Proceedings.
Officers to furnish information
to attorney-general.
a.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
a.
b.
Sec
Sec.
Sec. 33. Creation of Two offices.
a [Referee and trustee.] The ofi&ces of referee and
trustee are hereby created.
No official or general trustee to be created. General order XIV. For
qualifications of trustee see Post, Sec. 45. Cotirt may order that no
trustee be appointed in no asset cases. Sec. 45 and notes.
Sec. 34. Appointment, Removal, and Districts op
Referees.
a [Duties of Court.] Courts of bankruptcy shall, within
the territorial limits of which they respectively have juris-
diction,
(1) [Appoint and remove referees.] Appoint referees,
each for a term of two years, and may, in their discretion,
remove them because their services are not needed or for
other cause ; and
As to jurisdiction of courts of bankruptcy see Chapter H. For analo-
146 * QUALIFICATIONS OF REFEREES. [§35a.
gous provisions under act 1800 see Sec. 2 of that act post. See, also, Sec.
5 of act of 1841 and Sec. 3. Act of 1867.
Special referee shotdd not be appointed with consent of parties. Bray
et al. V. Cobb (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 1 A. B. R., 153; 1 N. B.
N., 209; 91 Fed., 102.
(2) [Districts of referees.] Designate, and from time
to time change, the limits of the districts of referees, so that
each county, where the services of a referee are needed,
may constitute at least one district.
As to jurisdiction of referees, see Sec. 38 and notes.
Sec. 35. Qualifications of Referees.
a [Who eligible.] Individuals shall not be eligible to
appointment as referees unless they are respectively
(1) [Competent.] Competent to perform the duties of
that office.
As to duties of referees see Sec. 39.
(2) [Not office holder.] Not holdmg any office of profit
or emolimient under the laws of the United States or of
any state other than commissioners of deeds, justices of the
peace, masters in chancery, or notaries public ;
(3) [Not related to judges.] Not related by consanguin-
ity or affinity, within the third degree as determined by
the common law, to any of the judges of the courts of bank-
ruptcy or circuit courts of the United States, or of the justices
or judges of the appellate courts of the districts wherein
they may be appointed; and
(4) [Residents of district.] Residents of, or have their
offices in, the territorial districts for which they are to be
appointed.
For similar provisions of act of 1867, see Sec. 5 of that act.
§§36,37,38.] jurisdiction of referees. 147
Sec. 36. Oaths of Office of Referees.
a [Same oath as judge.] Referees shall take the same
oath of office as that prescribed for judges of the United
States courts.
As to form of oath see Revised Statutes United States Sec. 1756-1757.
See, also, forms No. 16 and 17.
Sec. 37. Number of Referees.
a [SuflBcient number to transact business.] Such num-
ber of referees shall be appointed as may be necessary to
assist in expeditiously transacting the bankruptcy business
pending in the various courts of bankruptcy.
See, ante Sec. 33, 34 and 35.
Sec. 38. Jurisdiction of Referees.
a [Jurisdiction in districts.] Referees respectively are
hereby invested, subject always to a review by the Judge,
within the limits of their districts as established from time
to time, with jurisdiction to
(1) [Consider petitions.] Consider all petitions refer-
red to them by the clerks and make the adjudications or
dismiss the petitions ;
Referee may in his discretion order amendments to be made to the
petition and schedule of a voluntary bankrupt, and may refuse to call
a first meeting of creditors vmtil the amendments are made. In re
Brumelkamp (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., 95 Fed., 814; 2 A. B. R., 318.
Adjudication must be by judge, imless he is absent from the district.
Sec. 18 g and f reference after adjudication Sec. 22 ante.
(2) [Administer oaths etc.] Exercise powers vested in
courts of bankruptcy for the administering of oaths to and
the examination of persons as witnesses and for requiring
the production of documents in proceedings before them,
except the power of commitment ;
148 JURISDICTION OF REFEREES. [§38.
As to oaths ond aflSrmations see section 20 ante.
(3) [Take possession of property.] Exercise the powers
of the judge for the taking possession and releasing of the
property of the bankrupt in the event of the issuance by the
clerk of a certificate showing the absence of a judge from
the judicial district, or the division of the district, or his
sickness, or inability to act ;
Referee may issue an injunction restraining interference with bank-
rupt's property and appoint a receiver of the same. 7» re Abrahamson &
Bretstein (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Moss. R., 1 A. B. R., 44; 1 N. B. N., 23.
The referee has power to cite bankrupt to show cause why property
should not be surrendered to the trustee. In re Oliver (1899), N. Dist.
Cal., DeHaven, J., 96 Fed., 85; 2 A. B. R., 783; 1 N. B. N., 229.
Referee may restrain the collection of judgments obtained in the state
court. In re Northrop (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R.,
427.
Referee has power to order sale of property free from incumbrances.
In re Sanborn (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 96 Fed., 551; 3 A. B. R., 54.
The referee has power to make a summary order on nile to show cause
why agent of bankrupt should not surrender property of the estate.
Mueller v. Nugent (1902), Sup. Ct. U. S., Fuller, J., 184 U. S. 1; 7 A. B.
R., 224.
Jurisdiction of referee sufficient to order sale of property. In re Styer
(1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 98 Fed., 290; 3 A. B. R., 424; 2 N.
B. N., 205.
See In re McDufE (1900), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 101 Fed., 241;
4 A. B. R., 110.
(4) [Perform certain duties of court.] Perform such
part of the duties, except as to questions arising out of
the applications of bankrupts for compositions or dis-
charges, as are by this Act conferred on courts of bankruptcy
and as shall be prescribed by rules or orders of the courts
of bankruptcy of their respective districts, except as herein
otherwise provided; and
Referee has no jurisdiction to find that debt is provable whether
created by fraud or not. He must allow or disallow. In re Lazarovic
(1898), Dist. Kan., Corey, R., 1 A. B. R., 476.
§39 a.] DUTIES OF REFEREES. 14^
Referee has jurisdiction to issue injunction restraining a creditor
from selling property seized under a writ of detinue and to order the prop-
erty turned over to the trustee. In re Huddleston (1899), N. Dist. Ala
Turner, R., 1 A. B. R., 572; 1 N. B. N., 214.
Referee has jurisdiction to enjoin sale of bankrupt's real estate in state
court. In re Sabine (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R.,
315; 1 N. B.N.,45.
Referee has jurisdiction to entertain motion for dismissal of proceed-
jngs after reference. In re Scott (1902), Dist. Mass., Olmstead, R., 7
A. B. R., 35.
Mandatory injunction should not issue without notice to all parties.
Preliminary injtmction shotdd first issue with a rule to show cause. In
re Tune (1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J. 115 Fed., 906; 8 A. B. R., 285.
(5) [Authorize the employment of stenographers.] Upon
the application of the trustee during the examination of the
bankrupts, or other proceedings, authorize the employment
of stenographers at the expense of the estates at a compensa-
tion not to exceed ten cents per folio for reporting and
transcribing the proceedings.
No authority to employ stenographers, except under this section.
Such fee may be taxed against successful party in contest between claim-
ant and trustee, as part of the necessar>^ expenses of estate. In re Todd
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.. 109 Fed., 265; 6 A. B. R.. 88.
Sec. 39. Duties of Referees.
a [Duties,] Referees shall
See Gen. Ord. XII and XVI.
(1) [Declare dividends.] Declare dividends and pre-
pare and deliver to trustees dividend sheets showing the divi-
dends declared and to whom payable;
As to the declaration and payment of dividends, see Sec. 65 and notes
post. As to duties of referees in general, see Gen. Order XII post.
(2) [Examine all schedules and lists.] Examine all
schedules of property and lists of creditors filed by bank-
rupts and cause such as are incomplete or defective to be
amended ;
150 DUTIES OP REFEREES. [§39a.
As to what schedules to contain and duty of bankrupt to file, see Sec,
7 (8). As to manner of drawing schedules, see Gen. Ord. V. Duty of
petitioning creditor to file, Gen. Ord. IX. As to amendment of schedules,
see Gen. Ord. XI post.
Duty of referee to examine schedules. No abbreviation of names or
addresses not in common use tolerated. In re Mackay & Co. (1899) , N.
Dist. N. Y., Collier, R., 1 A. B. R.. 593.
(3) [Furnish infonnation.] Furnish such information
concerning the estates in process of administration before
them as may be requested by the parties in interest ;
Referee cannot refuse parties in interest a reasonable opportunity
to inspect accotmts, papers and records relating to a bankrupt's estate
Sec. 47 (5) post.
(4) [Give notice.] Give notices to creditors as herein
provided ;
As to notices to creditors, see Sec. 58 and notes post.
(5) [Make up records.] Make up records embodying the
evidence, or the substance thereof, as agreed upon by the
parties in all contested matters arising before them, when-
ever requested to do so by either of the parties thereto, to-
gether with their findings therein, and transmit them to
the judges;
Referee to transmit names of creditors and proven claims to clerk.
Gen. Order XXIV post. See form of list, Form No. 40 post.
On appeal to Court of Appeals, complaint of incomplete record not
sustained when shown that case proceeded from referee on his certificate
and summary of the evidence. Cunningham v. Bank (1900), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Lurton, j], 101 Fed., 977; 4 A. B. R., 192; 2 N.B. N., 589.
Referee's finding of fact on petition for discharge will not be reversed,
except upon clear and convincing proof of error. In re Covington (1901),
W. Dist. N. C, PumeU, J., 110 Fed., 143; 6 A. B. R., 373.
Referee's finding of fact will not be disturbed unless manifestly er-
roneous. In re Stout (1900), W. Dist. M., Phillips, J., 109 Fed., 794;
6A. B. R.,605.
(6) [Prepare scliedules and list.] Prepare and file the
§39b.] DUTIES OF REFEREES. 151
schedules of property and lists of creditors required to be
filed by the bankrupts, or cause the same to be done, when
the bankrupts fail, refuse, or neglect to do so ;
As to duty of bankrupt to file, see Sec. 7 (8) and notes. As to prepara-
tion of schedules in involuntary cases, see Sec. Gen. Order IX.
(7) [Preserve and transmit records.] Safely keep, per-
fect, and transmit to the clerks the records, herein required
to be kept by them, when the cases are concluded ;
See ante (5) and notes.
(8) [Transmit papers to clerk.] Transmit to the clerks
such papers as may be on file before them whenever the
same are needed in any proceedings in courts, and in like
manner secure the return of such papers after they have
been used, or, if it be impracticable to transmit the original
papers, transmit certified copies thereof by mail ;
As to duties of referees, see Gen. Ord. XII; see also ante (6) and (7).
(9) [Preserve Evidence.] Upon application of any party
in interest, preserve the evidence taken or the substance
thereof as agreed upon by the parties before them when a
stenographer is not in attendance ; and
As to taking of testimony, see Gen. Ord. XXII. As to evidence, see
Sec. 21 and notes. As to jurisdiction of referee, see Sec. 38a (2) and notes.
(10) [Obtain papers.] Whenever their respective offices
are in the same cities or towns where the courts of bank-
ruptcy convene, call upon and receive from the clerks all
papers filed in courts of bankruptcy which have been re-
ferred to them.
As to filing of papers, see Gen. Ord. II.
b [Acts proliibited.] Referees shall not
(1) [Act wlien interested.] Act in cases in which they
are directly or indirectly interested;
152 COMPENSATION OP REFEREES. [§40a.
Referee not disqualified because a debtor of the bankrupt. Bray v.
Cobb (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 91 Fed., 102; 1 A. B. R., 153; 1
N. B. N., 209.
(2) [Practice as attorney.] Practice as attorneys and
coiinselors at law in any bankruptcy proceedings ; or
(3) [Purchase from estate.] Purchase, directly or in-
directly, any property of an estate in bankruptcy.
Duties of referee prescribed. Gen. Order XII. Duty or referee to
notify trustee of his appointment. Gen. Order XVI.
Sec. 40. Compensation of Referees.
a [Fees and commissions.] Referees shall receive as full
compensation for their services, payable after they are
rendered, a fee of *fifteen* (ten) dollars deposited with the
clerk at the time the petition is filed in each case, except
when a fee is not required from a volimtary bankrupt,
♦and twenty-five cents for every proof of claim filed for
allowance, to be paid from the estate, if any, as a part of the
cost of administration,* and from estates which have been
administered before them one per centum commissions on
♦all moneys disbursed to creditors by the trustee,* (sums
to be paid as dividends and commissions) or one-half of one
per centum on the amoimt to be paid to creditors upon the
confirmation of a composition.
As amended by Act of 1903 — See Amended, page , post. Matter omitted in
amendment embraced between brackets — additional matter found between stars.
As to limitation of compensation of referees and trustees see Sec. 72
post.
See notes on compensation of trustee, see Sec. 48a.
As to compensation of Referees, see Gen. Order XXXV. Sub. (2).
Referees entitled to commissions on amounts paid unsecured creditors.
In re Coffin (1899), E. Dist. Tex., Dillard, R., 2 A. B. R., 344; 1 N. B. N.,
507.
Payment pro tanto on a secured claim by the trustee does not entitle
§40b.] COMPENSATION OF REFEREES. 153
the referee to an allowance on commissions. In re Fort Wayne Electric
Corporation (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 94 Fed., 109; 1. A. B. R., 706;
1 N. B. R., 356.
Commission should be allowed on money paid out as commissions.
In re Sabine (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R., 322; 1 N.
B. N., 45.
No commissions allowed on payments entitled to priority.
No commission on secured claims, unless security submitted to bank-
rupt court.
No commissions payable on prior or secured claims — discussion [^of
word "dividend." In re Fielding (1899), W. Dist. Mo., Philips, J., 96
Fed., 800; 3 A. B. R., 135; 2 N. B. N., 735.
Commissions not confined to dividends paid unsecured creditors but
allowed on amounts paid secured creditors. Dividend defined. In re
Barber (1899), Dist. Minn., Lochren J., 97 Fed., 547; 3 A. B. R., 306; 1 N.
B. N., 559.
This section is vmconstitutional because the referee's commission is
affected by its judicial decision. In re Gardner (1900) , E. Dist. Va., Wad-
dill, J., 103 Fed., 922; 4 A. B. R., 421; 1 N. B. N., 189.
Referee may not make extra charges for hearing claims, preparing
dividend sheets — his commissions are to be paid only on sums available
for payment of dividends and commissions. In re Barker (1901) , N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., Ill Fed., 501; 7 A. B. R., 132.
Referee's compensation limited to amount prescribed in the Act. In
re Pierce (1901), Dist. Colo., Hallett, J., Ill Fed., 516; 6 A. B. R., 747.
Referee may charge for stationary, publishing notices, etc.. Not for
his own ser\'ices in copying petition for discharge, though he may charge
for what such work costs him. In re Dixon (1902), N. Dist. Cal., De
Haven, J., 114 Fed., 675; 8 A. B. R., 145.
Court has power to refer the question of the application for discharge
to a referee in the capacity of special master and not as referee in bank-
ruptcy, and as this is not among the enumerated duties of the referee, he
is entitled to reasonable allowance therefor vmaffected by the fact that he
also holds the office of referee. Fellows et al. v. FreudentJial (1900), C. C.
A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 731; 4 A. B. R., 490; 2 N. B. N., 97.
Referee allowed reasonable compensation where services outside the
ordinary scope of his duties. In re Todd (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 109 Fed., 265; 6 A. B. R., 88.
b [Division between referees.] Whenever a case is
transferred from one referee to another the judge shall de-
154 CONTEMPTS BEFORE REFEREES. [§4la.
termine the proportion in which the fee and commissions
therefor shall be divided between the referees.
As to transfer of reference, see Sec. 22 (b) and notes, ante.
c [Where reference revoked.] In the event of the refer-
ence of a case being revoked before it is concluded, and
when the case is specially referred, the judge shall determine
what part of the fee and commissions shall be paid to the
referee.
Sec. 41. Contempts before Referees.
a [Prohibited acts.] A person shall not, in proceedings
before a referee,
(1) [Disobey orders.] Disobey or resist any lawful order,
process, or writ;
For analogous provisions, see Act of 1800, Sees. 14 and 15; also Sees.
4, 6 and 7 of Act of 1867, post.
Bankrupt who fails to account for money, or pay over committed until
he accotmted for the same. In re Rosser (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Rogers, J.,
96 Fed., 305; 2 A. B. R., 746; 1 N. B. N., 469.
Referee has power to order bankrupt to turn over assets and on bank-
rupt's refusal to certify the same to the judge an attachment for con-
tempt may issue. In re Miller (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 105 Fed.,
57; 5 A. B. R., 184.
(2) [Misbehave during hearing.] Misbehave during a
hearing or so near the place thereof as to obstruct the same ;
As to when and where hearings had, see Gen. Ord. XII.
(3) [Witliholding documents.] Neglect to produce, after
having been ordered to do so, any pertinent document ; or
As to evidence, see Sec. 21a and notes.
(4) [Refuse to appear for examination.] Refuse to ap-
pear after having been subpoenaed, or, upon appearing,
refuse to take the oath as a witness, or, after having taken
§42a.] RECORDS OF REFEREES. 155
the oath, refuse to be examined according to law : Provided,
That -no person shall be required to attend as a witness before
a referee at a place outside of the State of his residence, and
more than one hundred miles from such place of residence,
and only in case his lawful mileage and fee for one day's
attendance shall be first paid or tendered to him.
See Sec. 21 and notes, ante.
Refusal of bankrupt to accovmt for assets justifies imprisonment for
contempt. In re Rosser (1899), E. Dist. Mo., Rogers, J., 96 Fed., 308;
2 A. B. R.. 746; 1 N. B. N., 469.
It is contempt punishable by imprisonment for the bankrupt to refuse
to turn over property to the trustee. In re Piirvine (1899), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., Newman, J., 96 Fed., 192; 2 A. B. R., 787
Failure to accovmt for property is contempt and punishable by im-
prisonment. In re DueU (1899), W. Dist., Mo. Phillips, J., 100 Fed., 633;
4 A. B. R., 60.
Referee to report to judge the expenses in each case. Gen. Order
XXVI. Sec. 42 post.
b [Contempt proceedings— penalty.] The referee shall
certify the facts to the judge, if any person shall do any of
the things forbidden in this section. The judge shall there-
upon, in a summary manner, hear the evidence as to the
acts complained of, and, if it is such as to warrant him in
so doing, punish such person in the same manner and to the
same extent as for a contempt committed before the court
of bankruptcy, or commit such person upon the same con-
ditions as if the doing of the forbidden act had occurred
with reference to the process of, or in the presence of, the
court.
Bankruptcy courts have jurisdiction to ptmish for contempt. Sec.
2 (16) and notes.
Sec. 42. Records of Referees.
a [Planner of keeping records.] The records of all
proceedings in each case before a referee shall be kept as
156 APPOINTMENT OF TRUSTEES. [§§43a, 44a.
nearly as may be in the same manner as records are now
kept in equity cases in circuit courts of the United States.
Records to be transmitted to clerk after case finished. Sec. 39a (7)
Certified copies of records are evidence. Sec. 21d.
h [Books and papers.] A record of the proceedings in
each case shall be kept in a separate book or books, and
shall, together with the papers on file constitute the records
of the case.
c [Become part of court records.] The book or books
containing a record of the proceedings shall, when the case
is concluded before the referee, be certified to by him, and,
together with such papers as are on file before him, be trans-
mitted to the court of bankruptcy and shall there remain
as a part of the records of the court.
As to duty of the referee to transmit records, see Sec. 39a (7).
Sec. 43. Referee's Absence or Disability.
a [Filling vacancy.] Whenever the office of a referee
is vacant, or its occupant is absent or disqualified to act,
the judge may act, or may appoint another referee, or
another referee holding an appointment under the same
court may, by order of the judge, temporarily fill the
vacancy.
As to appointment of referees, see Sec. 34 and notes.
On disquaHfication of regular referee, judge may appoint a special
referee, and this without regard to wishes of parties. Owing a debt to
the bankrupt is not a disqualification. Bray v. Cobb (1899), E. Div. N.
C, Pumell, J., 91 Fed., 102; 1 A. B. R., 153; 1 N. B. N., 209.
Sec. 44. Appointment of Trustees.
a [Creditors appoint — when court appoint.] The cred-
itors of a bankrupt estate shall, at their first meeting after
the adjudication or after a vacancy has occurred in the
office of trustee, or after an estate has been reopened, or
§44a.] APPOINTMENT OF TRUSTEES. 157
after a composition has been set aside or a discharge revoked
or if there is a vacancy in the office of trustee, appoint one
trustee or three trustees of such estate. If the creditors
do not appoint a trustee or trustees as herein provided, the
court shall do so.
Trustee includes all the trustees of an estate. Sec. 1 Sub. (26) 'a«fe.
As to who appoints trustee, Sec. 2, Sub. (17) ante.
Creation of office, see ante, Sec. 33. See also Sections 46 and 47, post.
See Sec. 55 as to meeting of creditors.
An undischarged bankrupt not competent to serve as trustee in another
estate. In re Smith (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R.,
38; 1 N. B. N., 136.
The appointment of a trustee may be postponed pending an offer
of a composition. In re Rung Bros. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss,
R., 2 A. B. R., 620; 1 N. B. N., 406.
On failure of creditor to appoint trustee, referee may. In re Kuffler
(1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 187; 3 A. B. R., 162; 2 N. B.
N.,29.
Attorney of creditors cannot vote for trustee without special authority.
In re Blankfein (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 191; 3 A. B.
R.. 165; 2 N. B. N., 49.
Trustee's being a creditor no disqualification. In re Lewensohn, S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 576; 3 A. B. R., 299; 2 N. B. N., 871.
Referee may appoint trustee on failure of creditors to select one.~^/n
re Brooks (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 100 Fed., 432; 4 A. B. R.,
50;2N. B. N.,680.
Referee may appoint trustee where creditors do not agree, and may
exercise his discretion in so doing. In re Richards (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Coxe, J., 103 Fed., 849; 4 A. B. R., 631; 2 N. B. N., 1,027.
An attorney at law cannot vote the claim of his client without a duly
executed power of attorney for that purpose. In re Scully (1900) , R., 108
Fed., 372; 5 A. B. R., 716.
Election of trustee set aside where it appears votes were procured by
collusion with the bankrupt. In re Henschel (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise,
R., 6 A. B. R., 25.
Under some circumstances the court will appoint special counsel to
advise the trustee. In re Amett (1901), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J.,
112 Fed.. 770; 7 A. B. R., 522.
158 DUTIES OF TRUSTEES. [§§ 45a, 46a, 47a.
At the election of a trustee it is the duty of the referee to refuse votes
of claims which are held in the interest of the bankrupt. In re Dayville
Woolen Co. (1902), Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 114 Fed., 674; 8 A. B.
R.,85.
On election of trustee objections to claims should not be disregarded
to allow creditors to vote — due consideration should be taken of the ob-
jections and an opportunity given to contest the same before decision. In
re Malino (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 8 A. B. R., 205.
Sec. 45. Qualifications of Trustees.
a [Who may be trustees,] Trustees may be
(1) [Individuals.] Individuals who are respectively
competent to perform the duties of that office, and reside
or have an office in the judicial district within which they are
appointed, or
(2) [Corporations.] Corporations authorized by their
charters or bylaw to act in such capacity and having an office
in the judicial district within which they are appointed.
Sec. 46. Death or Removal of Trustees.
a [Suit not to abate.] The death or removal of a trustee
shall not abate any suit or proceeding which he is prosecuting
or defending at the time of his death or removal, but the
same may be proceeded with or defended by his joint trustee
or successor in the same manner as though the same had
been commenced or was being defended by such joint trustee
alone or by such successor.
Sec. 47. Duties of Trustees.
a [Duties.] Trustees shall respectively
(1) [Account and pay over.] Account for and pay over
to the estates under their control all interest received by
them upon property of such estates ;
§47 a.] DUTIES OF TRUSTEES. 159
(2) [Turn property into money—close estates.] Collect
and reduce to money the property of the estates for which
they are trustees, under the direction of the court, and close
up the estate as expeditiously as is compatible with the best
interests of the parties in interest ;
As to suits by trustees, see Sec. 23b, c, d and Sec. 11 ; see also Sec. 60c
as to suits to set aside preferences.
Title to bankrupt's property vests in trustee . Sec. 70 and notes.
Costs should not be incurred by trustee in selling mortgaged property
nor should he accept burdensome property. In re Cogley (1901) , N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 107 Fed., 73; 5 A. B. R., 731.
Trustee not liable for rent of premises where no demand made by
landlord. In re Wiessner (1902), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 116 Fed.,
68; 8 A. B. R., 415.
Assignee in proceedings prior to bankruptcy who was allowed to
remain in possession of bankrupt's property during several months, is en-
titled to compensation for such services. In re Klein & Co. (1902), S.
Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 116 Fed., 523; 8 A. B. R., 559.
Trustee not permitted to maintain an attachment by a creditor void-
able under the act to attack a mortgage. In re Moore (1901), Dist. Vt.
Wheeler, J., 107 Fed., 264; 6 A. B. R., 175.
Trustees duties discussed at length — right to hire counsel and com-
mence actions for recovery of assets — practice of submitting validity
of declaration and prospects of recovery to covut for instructions con-
demned in that case largely on the groimd of bad faith. In re Baber
(1902), E. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 119 Fed., 520.
Duty of trustee to reftmd money paid bankrupt by mutual mistake.
In re CoUisi, W. Dist. Mich., Blair, R., 1 A. B. R., 625.
He may in the exercise of reasonable judgment employ counsel. In
re Abram (1900), E. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 103 Fed., 272; 4 A. B. R.,
675.
Trustee's counsel must not represent interests adverse to the general
creditors. In re Rtisch (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 105 Fed., 607;
5A. B. R.. 565.
Trustee should pay taxes. In re Conhaim (1900), Dist. Wash., Hand-
ford, J., 100 Fed., 268; 4 A. B. R., 58; 2 N. B. N., 148.
(3) [Deposit money.] Deposit all money received by
them in one of the designated depositories ;
160 DUTIES OF TRUSTEES. [§47a.
As to selection of depositories for money by court. Sec. 61a.
The ftinds should be deposited to the credit of the trustee designa-
ting the estate. In re Carr (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pvimell, J., 116
Fed., 556; 9 A. B. R., 58.
(4) [Disburse money.] Disburse money only by check
or draft on the depositories in which it has been deposited ;
Sees. 60, 61a.
(5) [Furnish information.] Furnish such information
concerning the estates of which they are trustees and their
administration as may be requested by parties in interest;
Accounts are open to inspection of all parties in interest. Sec. 49.
(6) [Keep accounts.] Keep regular accounts showing
all amounts received and from what sources and all amounts
expended and on what accounts ;
See Sec. 5d and notes as to keeping of separate accounts relative to
partnership and individual property.
(7) [Malie detailed statements.] Lay before the final
meeting of the creditors detailed statements of the adminis-
tration of the estates ;
As to meetings of creditors, see Sec. 55. See Sec. 58a (6).
(8) [Make reports.] Make final reports and file final
accounts with the courts fifteen days before the days fixed
for the final meetings of the creditors;
As to notices to creditors, see Sec. 58a (6) .
(9) [Pay dividends.] Pay dividends within ten days
after they are declared by the referees ;
See Section 65 and notes as to the declaration and pajmient of dividends.
(10) [Report condition of estates.] Report to the courts,
in writing, the condition of the estates and the amounts
of money on hand, and such other details as may be re-
quired by the courts, within the first month after their ap-
§47bc,] DUTIES OF TRUSTEES. 161 ^
pointment and every two months thereafter, unless other-
wise ordered by the courts ; and
(11) [Set apart exemptions.] Set apart the bankrupt's
exemptions and report the items and estimated value thereof
to the court as soon as practicable after their appointment.
As to form for report of exempt property, see Form 47. As to exemf>-
tion of bankrupt, see Sec. 6 and notes supra.
Duty of trustee to set aside exemptions, notwithstanding bankrupt's
fraudulent concealment of property. In re Peterson (1899), E. Dist.
Wis., Jones, R., 1 A. B. R., 254; 1 N. B. N., 215.
Although no trustee be appointed an order setting aside the bank-
rupt's exemptions preserves the exemptions to the bankrupt. Smalley
V. Langenower (1902), Sup. Ct.., Wash., Fullerton, J., 70 Pac, 786.
Exemptions must be set aside by trustee and no one can act in his
place. In re Grimes (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96 Fed., 529;
2 A. B. R., 730; 1 N. B. N., 116.
On dispute between trustee and bankrupt as to value of homestead
exemptions, it should be sold and the amount paid out of proceeds. In re
Lynch (1900), S. Dist. Ga., Spear, J., 101 Fed., 579; 4 A. B. R., 262; 1
N. B. N., 182.
Bankruptcy court has exclusive jurisdiction to determine exemptions.
Homestead acquired while insolvent from proceeds of property unpaid for,
not allowable — burden of proving solvency at time of purchase on the
bankrupt. McGahan v. Anderson (1902), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Jackson, J.,
llSFed., 115;7A. B. R.,641.
h [Concurrence of two out of three.] Whenever three
trustees have been appointed for an estate, the concurrence
of at least two of them shall be necessary to the validity of
their every act concerning the administration of the estate.
See Sees. 44 and 45.
*c [Trustee to file certified copy of adjudication.] The
trustee shall, within thirty days after adjudication, file
a certified copy of the decree of adjudication in the office
where conveyances of real estate are recorded in every coun-
ty where the bankrupt owns real estate not exempt from
execution, and pay the fee for such filing, and he shall re-
162 COMPENSATION OF TRUSTEES. [§48a.
ceive a compensation of fifty cents for each copy so filed,
which, together with the fiHng fee, shall be paid out of the
estate of the bankrupt as a part of the cost and disburse-
ments of the proceedings.*
As amended by Act of 1903. See amended, page — post. Additional matter found
between stars.
As to duties of trustees, see Gen. Order XVII. As to bonds of joint
trustees, see Sec. 50j.
Sec. 48. Compensation of Trustees.
a [Fees and commissions.] Trustees shall receive (as
full compensation) for their services, payable after they
are rendered, a fee of five dollars deposited with the clerk
at the time the petition is filed in each case, except when a
fee is not required from a voluntary bankrupt, and from
estates which they have administered, such commissions
(on sums to be paid as dividends and commissions) *on all
moneys disbursed by them* as may be allowed by the courts,
not to exceed (three) *six* per centtmi on the first five
(thousand) *hundred* dollars or less, *four per centum on
moneys in excess of five himdred dollars and less than
fifteen *htmdred *dollars, twopercentiun on moneys in ex-
cess of fifteen hundred dollars and less than ten thousand
dollars,* (two per centum on the second five thousand dollars
or a part thereof) and one per centimi on (such sums)
*moneys* in excess of ten thousand dollars. *And in case
of the confirmation of a composition after the trustee has
qualified the court may allow him, as compensation, not to
exceed one-half of one per centum of the amount to be paid
the creditors on such composition.*
As to compensation of trustees, see Gen. Order XXXV. See also
notes as to compensation of referees, ante Sec.' 40.
As amended by Act of 1903. See Amendment page , post. Matter
found in Act of 1898 and omitted in Amendment contained between
brackets-new matter found between stars. See Sec. 72 post, as tq
\imitation on compensation of trustees and referees.
§48a.] COMPENSATION OF TRUSTEES. 163
Trustee is entitled to commissions on amounts paid secured creditors.
In re Coffin (1899), E. Dist. Tenn., Dillard, R., 2 A. B. R., 344; 1 N. B.
N., 507.
Commissions payable on claims having priority. In re Gerson, E.
Dist. Pa., Mason, R., 2 A. B. R., 352; 1 N. B. N., 315.
No commission payable on prior or secured claims — discussion of
word "dividend." In re Fielding (1899), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 91
Fed., 800; 3 A. B. R., 135; 2 N. B. N., 735.
Trustee cannot receive Ivunp sum greater than his commissions of
three per cent., nor can he be allowed for services as agent prior to his ap-
pointment as trustee. In re Carolina Cooperage Co. (1899), E. Dist.
N. C, Pumell., J., 96 Fed., 950; 3 A. B. R., 154; 1 N. B. N., 534.
No fees allowed trustee as commissions on dividends to secured creditors.
In re Utt (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Woods, J., 105 Fed., 754; 5 A. B.
R., 383.
No extra compensation allowed trustee, no matter how valuable his
services. In re Epstein (1901), W.Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 109 Fed., 878;
6 A. B. R., 191.
Sale by trustee for invoice price — fact that bankrupt had purchased
some of the goods originally for less than the invoice price constitutes no
ground for rebate to purchaser. Owens v. Bruce (1901) , C. C. A., 4th Cir.,
Waddill, J., 109 Fed., 72; 6 A. B. R., 322.
Trustee's commissions not earned where the creditor after commencing
suit in trustee's name, compromised the same and assigned the claim to
a friend of the bankrupt and dismissed the suit. In re Kaiser (1902),
Dist. Mont., Knowles, J., 112 Fed., 955; 8 A. B. R., 108.
Trustee who is an attorney may defend in person suits against property
in his hands, and will be allowed the same compensation as he would if he
had employed other competent counsel. In re Mitchell (1899), W. Dist.
Pa., Van Wormer, R., 1 A. B. R., 687; 1 N. B. N., 264.
Trustee allowed extra fees for unusual services for carrying on a busi-
ness. In re Plummer (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 3 A. B. R.,
320; 2 N. B. N., 292.
"Dividends " comprehends payments made to priority and secured cred-
itors, as well as out of funds passing through the trustees hands. In re
Muhlhouser Company (1902), N. Dist. O., Remington, R., 9 A. B. R., 80.
Fees and expenses of trustee of sale of mortgaged property should be
allowed only as connected with the sale — not then allowed as fees incurred
in bankruptcy proceeding. In re Utt (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Woods,
J., 105 Fed., 754; 5 A. B. R., 383.
164 BONDS OF REFEREES AND TRUSTEES. [§§49a, 50a
b [When more thao one trustee.] In the event of an
estate being administered by three trustees instead of one
trustee or by successive trustees, the court shall apportion
the fees and commissions between them according to the
services actually rendered, so that there shall not be paid
to trustees for the administering of any estate a greater
amount than one trustee would be entitled to.
As to how and when trustees appointed, see Sec. 44.
c [Compensation withheld.] The court may, in its dis-
cretion, withhold all compensation from any trustee who
has been removed for cause.
See Gen. Qrd.XXXV as to compensation; also Sec. 48. As to removal
of trustee, see Gen. Ord. XIII.
Sec. 49. Accounts and Papers of Trustees.
a [Must be open to inspection.] The accounts and papers
of trustees shall be open to the inspection of officers and all
parties in interest..
On accoimting by the trustee, it is the duty of the referee to examine
the details of the trustee's account. In re Baginsky, Michael & Co. (1899) ,
E. Dist. La., Gurley, R., 2 A. B. R., 243; 1 N. B. N., 360.
It is an offense vmder this act for a referee or trustee to refuse to permit
a reasonable opportimity for the inspection of accounts of estates. Sec.
29c (3).
Sec. 50. Bonds of Referees and Trustees.
a [Referees bonds.] Referees, before assimiing the duties
of their offices, and within such time as the district courts
of the United States having jurisdiction shall prescribe,
shall respectively qualify by entering into bond to the United
States in such sum as shall be fixed by such courts, not to
exceed five thousand dollars, with such sureties as shall
be approved by such courts, conditioned for the faithful
performance of their official duties.
As to form of bond of referee, see Form No. 17.
§50bcdef] bonds of referees and trustees. 165
One surety only is necessary on a bond, where it is a svirety company.
In re Max Kalter (1899), E. Dist. Pa., Mason, R., 2 A. B. R., 590; 1 N.
B. N., 384.
h [Trustees' bond.] Trustees, before entering upon the
performance of their official dutie^, and within ten days after
their appointment, or within such further time, not to exceed
five days, as the court may permit, shall respectively qualify
by entering into bond to the United States, with such sureties
as shall be approved by the courts, conditioned for the
faithful performance of their official duties.
As to form of bond, see Form No. 25. Order approving trustee's
bond, see form No. 26.
c [Creditors fixing amount of trustees' bond.] The cred-
itors of a bankrupt estate, at their first meeting after the
adjudication, or after a vacancy has occurred in the office of
trustee, or after an estate has been reopened, or after com-
position has been set aside or a discharge revoked, if there
is a vacancy in the office of trustee, shall fix the amoimt of
the bond of the trustee ; they may at any time increase the
amount of the bond. If the creditors do not fix the
amount of the bond of the trustee as herein provided the
court shall do so.
As to meeting of creditors. Sec. 55. Creditors appoint trustees, see
Sec. 44.
d [Sureties qualification.] The court shall require evi-
dence as to the actual value of the property of sureties.
e [Two sureties required.] There shall be at least two
sureties upon each bond.
/ [Value of property of sureties.] The actual value of
the property of the siu-eties, over and above their liabilities
and exemptions, on each bond shall equal at least the
amoimt of such bond.
166 BONDS OF REFEREES AND TRUSTEES. [§50g-m.
g [Corporations as sureties.] Corporations organized for
the purpose of becoming sureties upon bonds, or authorized
by law to do so, may be accepted as sureties upon the bonds
of referees and trustees whenever the courts are satisfied
that the rights of all parties in interest will be thereby amply
protected.
h [Filing of bonds — suit on bonds.] Bonds of referees,
trustees, and designated depositories shall be filed of record
in the office of the clerk of the court and may be sued upon
in the name of the United States for the use of any person
injured by a breach of their conditions.
Trustee may bring stiit on bond of former trustee in District Court.
United States v. Union Surety and Guaranty Co. (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Adams, J., 118 Fed., 482; 9 A. B. R., 114.
i [Trustees' personal liability.] Trustees shall not be
liable, personally or on their bonds, to the United States,
for any penalties or forfeitures incurred by the bankrupts
imder this act, of whose estates they are respectively
trustees.
/ [Joint trustees.] Joint trustees may give joint or
several bonds.
k [Vacancy by failure to give bond.] If any referee or
trustee shall fail to give bond, as herein provided and within
the time limited, he shall be deemed to have declined his
appointment, and such failtu"e shall create a vacancy in his
office.
/ [Limitation of suits on referees' bonds.] Suits upon
referees' bonds shall not be brought subsequent to two years
after the alleged breach of the bond.
m [Limitation to suits on trustees' bonds.] Suits upon
trustees' bonds shall not be brought subsequent to two years
after the estate has been closed.
§51 a.) DUTIES OF CLERKS. 16*?
Sec. 51. Duties of Clerks.
a [Duties.] Clerks shall respectively
(1) [Account for fees.] Account for, as for other fees
received by them, the clerk's fee paid in each case and such
other fees as may be received for certified copies of records
which may be prepared for persons other than officers ;
(2) [Collect fees.] Collect the fees of the clerk, referee,
and trustee in each case instituted before filing the petition
except the petition of a proposed volimtary bankrupt which
is accompanied by an affidavit stating that the petitioner
is without, and can not obtain, the money with which to pay
such fees ;
See Sec. 52 as to compensation of clerks.
Petitioner in forma pauperis must show he cannot obtain money for
costs — he cannot pay his counsel and then make the affidavit. In re
Collier (1899), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 93 Fed., 191; 1 A. B. R.;
182; 1 N. B. N., 257.
In pauper cases the costs of the bankrupt are not a charge on his
exemptions — he need not be expected to borrow the costs. ^Sellers, et
al V. Bell, 1899 Circuit Ct. of Appeals, 5th. Cir. McCormick, J., 94 Fed.,
801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
One fee only can be charged a partnership petition. In re Langslow
et al. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 98 Fed. 869; 1 A. B. R., 258; 1 N.
B. N., 232.
Partnership and individual petitions may be joined, and one fee only
charged for filing. In re Gay, (1899), Dist. N. H. Aldrich, J., 98,jFed.,
870; 3 A. B. R., 529.
The statutory fees on proper affidavit may be waived by the clerk
to the extent of filing the petition, but the subsequent proceedings will
not ensue until those fees are paid by the bankrupt, unless from pe-
culiar circumstances he is an object of charity. In re Anonymous
(1899), Dist. Washington, Handford, J., 2 A. B. R., 527.
The costs advanced are not to be refunded under rule 10. In re
Matthews (1899), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 97 Fed. 772; 3 A. B. R., 265.
Clerk should collect filing fees separately for partnership and indi-
168 COMPENSATION OF CLERKS AND MARSHALS. [§52a.
vidual partners. In re Harden (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Purnell, J., 101
Fed., 553; 4 A. B. R., 31; 2 N. B. N., 741.
Poverty affidavit establishes prima facie right to file petition without
the costs. In re Levy (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 101 Fed., 247;
4 A. B. R., 108.
On poverty affidavit referee not authorized to rule the bankrupt to
advance costs before discharge. — Such orders being for the judge. In re
Plimpton (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 103 Fed., 775; 4 A. B. R., 614; 3
N. B. N.. 14.
In pauper cases the costs of the bankrupt are not a charge on his ex-
emptions— he need not be expected to borrow the costs. Sellers v. Bell
(1899), C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 94 Fed., 801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
• (3) [Deliver papers.] Deliver to the referees upon appli-
cation all papers which may be referred to them, or, if the
offices of such referees are not in the same cities or towns
as the offices of such clerks, transmit such papers by mail,
and in like manner return papers which were received from
such referees after they have been used;
Duty of referees to call for papers. Section 59 Sub. (8) .
(4) [Pay referee's and trustees' fees.] And within ten
days after each case has been closed pay to the referee, if
the case was referred, the fee collected for him, and to
the trustee the fee collected for him at the time of filing
the petition.
As to keeping of clerk's docket see Gen. Order I. post.
As to filing of papers, see Gen. Order II.
See Sec. 40 a as to compensation of referees; as to compensation of
trustees see Sec. 48, see also Gen. Ord. XXXV.
Sec. 52. Compensation of Clerks and Marshals.
a [Clerks' filing fee.] Clerks shall respectively receive
as full compensation for their services to each estate, a
filing fee of ten dollars, except when a fee is not required
from a volimtary bankrupt.
As to fees of clerks see Gen. Order XXXV post. See as to pauper
petitions, Sec. 51 a (2).
§ § 53a, 54a.] statistics.-duties of attorney general. 169
b [Marshals fee.] Marshals shall respectively receive
from the estate where an adjudication in bankruptcy is
made, except as herein otherwise provided, for the perform-
ance of their services in proceedings in bankruptcy, the
same fees, and account for them in the same way, as they
are entitled to receive for the performance of the same or
similar services in other cases in accordance with laws now
in force, or such as may hereafter be enacted, fixing the
compensation of marshals.
As to accounts to be kept by Marshals see Gen. Order XXIX post.
Marshal permitted to charge fee for serving petitioner where no
statutory provision is made. In re Damon, W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J.,
5 A. B. R., 133.
Sec. 53. Duties of Attorney General.
a [Collect and report statistics of cases.] The Attorney
General shall annually lay before Congress statistical tables
showing for the whole country, and by States, the number
of cases during the year of volimtary and involtmtary bank-
ruptcy; the amount of the property of the estates; the
dividends paid and the expenses of administering such
estates; and such other like information as he may deem
important.
Sec. 54. Statistics of Bankruptcy Proceedings.
a [Officers to furnish infonnation to attorney generaL]
Officers shall furnish in writing and transmit by mail such
information as is within their knowledge, and as may be
shown by the records and papers in their possession, to
the Attorney General, for statistical purposes, within ten
days after being requested by him to do so.
CHAPTER VI.
Creditors.
Sec. 55. Meetings of Credit-
ors.
a. Place and time.
b. Presiding officers — duties.
c. Creditors duty.
d Subsequent meetings of cred-
itors.
e. Meeting at call of court.
/. Final meeting.
Sec. 56. Voters at Meetings
OF Creditors.
a. Method of voting.
b. Voting by secured creditors.
Sec. 57. Proof and Allowance
OF Claims.
a. Of what to consist.
b. When claim founded upon
writing.
c. Filing claims.
d. When claims allowed.
e. Claims of secured creditors.
f. Objections to claims.
f Preferred creditors.
Securities held by secured
creditors.
i. Claims secured by individ-
ual undertakings.
/. Debts owing to the United
States, etc.
k. Reconsideration of claims.
/. Recovery of dividend by
trustee.
m. Claims by one estate against
another.
Time for proving claims.
58. Notice to Creditors.
Ten days notice.
Examinations.
Hearings.
Meetings.
Sales.
Dividends.
Final accounts.
Compromises.
Dismissal of proceedings.
First meetings — other notices.
Notices given by referee.
59. Who May File anc
Dismiss Petitions.
Voluntary bankrupt.
Involuntary bankrupt.
Petitions in duplicate.
Notice to other creditors.
e Computing number of credit-
ors.
/. Appearance of creditors.
g. Notice of dismissal.
Sec. 60. Preferred Creditors.
What constitutes preference.
Preferences voidable. Juris-
diction to recover.
Set-off of new credit after
preference,
Payment to attorneys — exam-
ination.
n.
Sec
a.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
b.
c.
Sec
a.
b.
c.
d.
a.
b.
Sec. 55. Meetings of Creditors.
a [Place and time.] The court shall cause the first
meeting of the creditors of a bankrupt to be held, not less
than ten nor more than thirty days after the adjudication,
at the county seat of the county in which the bankrupt has
had his principal place of business, resided, or had his domi-
cile ; or if that place would be manifestly inconvenient as a
place of meeting for the parties in interest, or if the bank-
170
§55 a be] MEETINGS OF CREDITORS. Vti
nipt is one who does not do business, reside, or have his
domicile within the United States, the court shall fix a place
for the meeting which is the most convenient for parties in
interest. If such meeting should by any mischance not be
held within such time, the court shall fix the date, as soon
as may be thereafter, when it shall be held.
As to examinations of bankrupt, see Gen. Order XXII. For analogous,
provisions, see Sec. 6, 29 and 30 Act of 1800, Sec. 7 Act of 1841, and Sec
11, 12, 17, 26, 28 Act of 1867.
As to notices of first meetings of creditors, see Sec. 58 and Gen. Ord.
XXI. For form of notice of first meeting, see Form No. 18
Cotut may call special meeting of creditors. Gen. Order XXV.
Conduct of meetings of creditors under Sections 55 and 57 discussed
and construed. In re Eagles & Crisp (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J.,
99 Fed., 695; 3 A. B. R., 733; 2 N. B. N.. 462.
Surprise occasioned by oversight of legal provision no ground for
adjournment. In re Finlay (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 104 Fed.,
675; 3 A. B. R., 738.
h [Presiding oflScer — duties.] At the first meeting of
creditors the judge or referee shall preside, and, before
proceeding with the other business, may allow or disallow
the claims of creditors there presented, and may publicly
examine the bankrupt or cause him to be examined at the
instance of any creditor.
Court may order that no trustee be appointed, Gen. Ord. XV.
Attorney of creditor has a lien on the claim allowed for his fees and
the District Court will enforce it for him. In re Rude (1900), Dist. Ky.,
Evans, J., 101 Fed. 805; 4 A. B. R., 319; 2 N. B. N., 493.
The interference by bankrupt in procuring proxies will justify referee
in throwing out such proxies in the election. In re McGill (1901), C. C.
A. 6th. Cir. Day, J., 106 Fed. 57; 5 A. B. R., 155.
See notes under Sec. 56 post. Form of order for examination of
bankrupt, form No. XXVIII. As to examination of the bankrupt see
Sec. 7 (9) and 21 a.
c [Creditor's duty.] The creditors shall at each meeting
take such steps as may be pertinent and necessary for the
172 MEETINGS OF CREDITORS. — VOTERS. [§56a.
promotion of the best interests of the estate and the en-
forcement of this Act.
d [Subsequent meetings of creditors.] A meeting of
creditors, subsequent to the first one, may be held at any
time and place when all of the creditors who have secured
the allowance of their claims sign a written consent to hold
a meeting at such time and place.
e [Meeting at caU of court.] The court shall call a meet-
ing of creditors whenever one-fourth or more in number of
those who have proven their claims shall file a written re-
quest to that effect ; if such request is signed by a majority
of such creditors, which number represents a majority in
amount of such claims, and contains a request for such
meeting to be held at a designated place, the court shall call
such meeting at such place within thirty days after the
date of the filing of the request.
As to proof of claims see Sec. 57 post, see as to voters at creditors*
meetings Sec. 56 post.
/ [Final meeting.] Whenever the affairs of the estate
are ready to be closed a final meeting of creditors shall be
ordered.
Notices of final meetings, Sec. 58. Trustees duties to lay statement
of condition of the estate before the meeting of creditors. Sec. 47 a (7) .
Notice of final meeting of creditors may be included in notice of pay-
ment of dividend. In re Smith (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.,
2 A. B. R., 648; 1 N. B. N., 404.
Sec. 56. Voters at Meetings of Creditors.
a [Metliod of voting,] Creditors shall pass upon matters
submitted to them at their meetings by a majority vote
in ntunber and amoimt of claims of all creditors whose claims
have been allowed and are present, except as herein other-
wise provided.
§57a.] CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. 173
As to proof and allowance of claims see Sec. 57 and notes.
Referee may reject proxy which is procured in the interest of the
bankrupt. In re Henschel (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 109 Fed.,
861; 6 A. B. R., 305. In re McGill (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir. Day, J.,
106 Fed. 57; 5 A. B. R., 155.
Claims that are not allowed cannot vote. In re Henschel, (1902),
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 114 Fed., 968; 7 A. B. R., 662.
b [Voting by secured creditors.] Creditors holding claims
which are secured or have priority shall not, in respect to
such claims, be entitled to vote at creditors meetings, nor
shall such claims be cotmted in computing either the num-
ber of creditors or the amount of their claims, tinless the
amounts of such claims exceed the values of such securities
or priorities, and then only for such excess.
See Sec. 57 as to securities and finding value of.
For definition of secured creditor see Sec. 1 (23), and notes.
Creditors who recovered twenty per cent, dividend under an assign-
ment prior to the passage of the bankruptcy act, are not held to be secured
creditors or barred from proving claim, and voting for trustee. In re
Folb (1899), E. Dist. N. C. Pumell, J., 91 Fed., 107; 1 A. B. R.,22; 1 N.
B. N. 34.
Absent creditors not to be considered in voting for trustee, though their
claims have been allowed. Referee who disapproves of creditors' choice
of trustee must call another meeting. In re Mac Keller (1902) , Middle
Dist. Pa., Archibald, J., 116 Fed., 547; 8 A. B. R., 669.
In partnership cases creditors of the firm may vote the full amount
of the claim irrespective of the securities furnished by individual mem-
bers to such creditors. In re Coe (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R.,
1 A. B. R., 275; 1 N. B. N., 294.
The provisions of this section apply to partnership creditors only
in case of a joint petition. In re Beck (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
110 Fed., 140; 6 A. B. R., 554.
Sec. 57. Proof and allowance of Claims.
a [Of what to consist.] Proof of claims shall consist
of a statement under oath, in writing, signed by a creditor
setting forth the claim, the consideration therefor, and
174 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§57a.
whether any, and, if so what, securities are held therefor,
and whether any, and, if so what, payments have been made
thereon, and that the sum claimed is justly owing from the
bankrupt to the creditor.
See Gen. Order XXI as to proof and allowance of claim.
See debts not barred by discharge, Sec. 17.
For forms for proof of debt see Form No. 31, 32, 33, 34, 35 and 36.
See debts not barred by discharge, Sec. 17.
Proof of claim should state consideration and defective claim may
be expunged when so defective. In re Scott (1899), N. Dist. Tex., Meek,
J., 99 Fed., 404; 1 A. B. R., 553; 1 N. B. N., 226.
The proof of claim and evidence should correspond — amaterial variance
may justify its diallowance — where claimant is found guilty of combining
with bankrupt in scheme to defraud the creditors his claim will be dis-
allowed. In re Lanshaw (1902), Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 9 A. B. R., 167.
An outlawed claim may be expunged after proof. Scheduling such
claim does not revive it. In re Lipman (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.
94 Fed., 353; 2 A. B. R., 46; 1 N. B. N., 310.
When a claim is proved it must be allowed upon filing unless objections
are made by the parties in interest, or unless continued for cause by the
court upon its own motion. In re Ankenny (1899), N. Dist. la., James,
R. . 1 N. B. N., 482.
Duty of referee to allow claim even though it is bad pleading, when
it conforms with bankruptcy forms, orders and statute. Idem.
Amendments of claims allowed where justice will be done. In re
Meyers & Chami (1900), Dist. Ind., Barker, J., 99 Fed., 691; 3 A. B. R.,
760; 2 N. B. N., 765.
Creditor who has instituted replevin against the assignee tmder general
assignment not estopped from proving his claim for balance of claim
in bankruptcy. In re Wilcox & V7right (1899), Dist. Tenn., Grayson, R.,
1 A. B. R., 544.
Contract for annuity provable up to expiration of one year from
adjudication. Bray v. Cobb (1900). E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 91 Fed.,
102; 3 A. B. R., 788; 1 N. B. N., 209.
A mortgagee not boimd to prove claim in ordinary way. Omission to
do so merely forfeits rights to claim as general creditor. He may by peti-
tion have his lien allowed and paid out of fund obtained by sale of the
property. In re Goldsmith, N. Dist. Texas. Meek, J., 118 Fed., 763.
Affidavit to claim administered by the attorney will not prevent the
§57a.] CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. 176
allowance of the claim. In re Kimball (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
100 Fed., 777; 4 A. B. R., 144; 1 N. B. N., 515.
Oral admissions uncorroborated by circumstances not sufficient to
prove claim. In re Kaldenberg (1900), S. Dist. N, Y., Brown, J., 105
Fed., 232; 5 A. B. R., 6.
Proof of claim must be made within the year. Setting up of adverse
claim for preferences not proof of claim. In re Rhodes (1900), W. Dist.
Pa., Buffington, J., 105 Fed., 231; 5 A. B. R., 197.
Rent accruing after bankruptcy not a provable claim. Atkins v.
Wilcox (1900), C. C. A., McCormick, J., 105 Fed., 595; 5 A. B. R., 313.
Judgment inside of four months on a creditor's bill begun before four
months gives no preference to the complainants in the bill. In re Lesser
Bros. (1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir, Shipman, J., 5 A. B. R., 320.
Judgment on attachment -nnthin the four months vacated although
the attachment was more than four months old. In re Tobias Lesser
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 108 Fed., 201; 5 A. B. R., 326.
Bankrupt stock broker, who has pledged stock bought by him for
a customer, is not guilty of conversion. Customer may prove claim
for damages as of date of adjudication. In re Swi ft (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Lowell, J., 106 Fed., 65; 5 A. B. R., 335.
Alimony whether due or accruing not a provable debt or a discharge-
able debt. Audubon v. Shufeldt (1901), U. S. Sup. Ct., Gray, J., 181 U. S.,
575; 5 A. B. R., 829.
Proof of claim may be made by holder of note against both maker
and endorser for full amount of note. In re Swift (1900), Dist. Mass.,
106 Fed., 65; 5 A. B. R., 415.
Only trustee can appeal from allowance of claim. Foreman v. Burley
(1901), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 109 Fed., 313; 6 A. B. R., 230.
Claim of corporation which was de facto a partner of bankrupt not
allowed as the contract was ultra vires. In re Ervin (1901), E. Dist.
Pa., McPherson, J., 109 Fed., 135; 6 A. B. R., 356.
Proof of claim where bankrupt dead cannot be by claimant in Penn.
although if no objection be made claim must be allowed. In re Shaw
(1901), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 109 Fed., 780; 6 A. B. R., 499.
A wife's claim for money advanced bankrupt husband cannot be
proved against his estate in Mass. hire Talbot (1901), Dist., Mass.,
Lowell, J. 110 Fed. 924, 7 A. B. R., 29.
Proof of claims against estate of bankrupt by member of his
family should be scrutinized with great care. In re Brewster, (1902)
N. Dist. N. Y., Smith, R. 7 A. B. R. 486.
176 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§57b.
Money deposited with bankrupt for margins not a provable claim. In
rg Knott. (1901) Dist. Vt. Wheeler, J., 109 Fed. 626; 6 A. B. R., 749.
Expenses of an agreement of liquidation entered into by creditors
cannot be proved as a claim against the estate. In re Wertheimer,
(1900) S. Dist. N. Y. Adams, J., 6 A. B. R. 756;
Claim for rent under lease providing that in the event lessee became
bankrupt rent for unexpired term should become due and payable —
doubted whether such clause enforcible in bankruptcy — priority of
lien upheld. Wilson v. Penn. Trust Co., (1902) C. C. A. 3rd. Cir. Ache-
son, J. 114 Fed. 742; 8 A. B. R. 169;
Claiment who fraudvdently pads his claim not allowed to prove for
anything. In re Flick (1900), S. Dist. Ohio, Thompson, J., 105 Fed. 603;
5 A. B. R. 465;
Note given by bankrupt to former partner for partnership assets not
enforcible against individual estate of bankrupt. In re Gerson (1901),
E. Dist. Pa., Mason, R., 5 A. B. R., 480.
Claim for tort may be waived as to the tort and allowed. Amoimt being
certain is liquidated. In re Filer (1901) , S. Dist. N. Y., Dexter, R., 5 A. B.
R., 582.
Coiirt on failure of creditors to apply a payment on either of two claims
exercises its equitable powers to direct the application. Zartman v.
Mines (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hawley, R., 6 A. B. R., 139.
In Alabama wife may be claimant against her bankrupt husband's
estate. Blumherg v. Bryan (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 107
Fed., 673; 6 A. B. R., 20.
A secured claim is preferred only to the extent that it covers a past con-
sideration. City Nat. Bank of Greenville v. Bruce (1901), C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Waddill, J., 109 Fed., 69; 6 A. B. R., 311.
Claim of a surety on contract of bankrupt is provable. Bryce v. Guar-
anty Co., C. C. A., 6th Cir., Sevems, J., 7 A. B. R., 6.
Claim for damages for breach of promise to marry assessable in bank-
ruptcy. In re Crocker (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 8 A. B. R., 188.
Proof of the assigned claim should be sufficient as to the assignee to
estop the assignor. In re Miner (1902), Dist. Ore., Billinger, J., 114 Fed.,
998; 8 A. B. R., 248.
b [When claim founded upon writing.] Whenever a
claim is founded upon an instrument of writing, such instru-
ment, imless lost or destroyed, shall be filed with the proof
of claim. If such instrument is lost or destroyed, a state-
[§57cde.] CLAIMS — proof and allowance. 177
ment of such fact and of the circumstances of such loss or de-
struction shall be filed under oath with the claim. After
the claim is allowed or disallowed, such instrument may be
withdrawn by permission of the court, upon leaving a copy
thereof on file with the claim.
As to form of affidavit of lost instrument, see Form No. 37.
Contesting claim — creditor moving to re-examine claim of another has
the burden of proof. In re Howard (1900), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J.,
100 Fed., 630; 4 A. B. R., 69; 1 N. B. N., 488.
Proceedings on proofs of claim, burden of proof on objectors (A) , (B),
(C), (D) and (F), construed. In re Sumner (1900), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Thomas, J., 101 Fed., 224; 4 A. B. R., 123; 2 N. B. N., 68.
Creditors may examine the bankrupt without first proving claim. In
re Jehu (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 94 Fed., 638; 2 A. B. R., 498; 1 N.
B. N., 509.
Where lost note was payable to a bank the note having been given by
bankrupt, the bank was enjoined from indorsing it, but allowed as a claim.
In re Jackson (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 94 Fed., 797; 2^A. B. R., 501.
c [Filing claims.] Claims after being proved may, for
the purpose of allowance, be filed by the claimants in the
court where the proceedings are pending or before the ref-
eree if the case has been referred.
As to proof of debts, see Gen. Ord. XXI (3).
d [When claims allowed.] Claims which have been duly
proved shall be allowed, upon receipt by or upon presenta-
tion to the court, unless objection to their allowance shall be
made by parties in interest, or their consideration be con-
tinued for cause by the court upon its own motion.
Bankrupt may file objections to claims. In re Ankenny (1899), N.
Dist. la., James, R., 1 N. B. N., 511.
e [Claims of secured creditors.] Claims of secured cred-
itors and those who have priority may be allowed to enable
such creditors to participate in the proceedings at creditors'
meetings held prior to the determination of the value of
their securities or priorities, but shall be allowed for such
178 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§57fg.
sums only as to the courts seem to be owing over and above
the value of their seciirities or priorities.
Secured creditor defined. Sec. 1 (23) and notes.
Filing proof of unsecured claim is not an irrevocable waiver of security.
Proof may be withdrawn if no dividend declared and rights of third
parties have not intervened. In re Friedman (1899), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Holt, R., 1 A. B. R., 510; 1 N. B. N., 208.
Full particulars concerning notes on which claims are based, must be
furnished. In re Stevens (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 104 Fed., 323;
5 A. B. R., 11.
/ [Objections to claims.] Objections to claims shall be
heard and determined as soon as the convenience of the
court and the best interests of the estates and the claimants
will permit.
Where proof shows claim was for money loaned bankrupt for purpose
of gambling for mutual benefit, claim not aUowable. Marden v. Phillips
et at. (1900), Dist. Mass., Brown, J., 103 Fed., 196; 4 A. B. R., 566.
g [Preferred creditors must smrender preference before
proving claim.] The claims of creditors who have received
preferences, *voidable under section sixty, subdivision b,
or to whom conveyances, transfers, assignments, or incum-
brances, void or voidable, under section sixty-seven, subdi-
vision e, have been made or given,* shall not be allowed un-
less such creditors shall surrender *such* (their) prefer-
ences, *conveyances, transfers, assignments, or incum-
brances.*
Omitted matter from Act of 1898 between brackets. New matter fouMl between
stars.
As amended by Act of 1903, see amended page pott.
Sec. 60 a b c and notes.
The unpopularity of this clause was largely instrumental in procuring
the amendments of 1903.
Note the controlling case of Pirie v. Chi. T. & T. Co. post by the
Supreme Court.
Note the amendment of 1903 in this clause removing the penalizing of
the "innocent" preferential creditor, so called, supra .
§57g.] CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. 179
Preferences received without knowledge of insolvency must be re-
turned before creditor may prove claim. Innocent creditor on the same
footing with guilty. Pirie etc. Co. v. Chicago Title & Trust Co., U. S.
Sup. Ct., McKcnna, J., 102 Fed., 1005; 5 A. B. R., 814.
Creditor may not prove a claim on notes given for indebtedness in-
curred after the giving a note in full of indebtedness without surrendering
payments received on first note. In re Meyer (1902), N. Dist. Texas,
Meek, J., 115 Fed., 997; 8 A. B. R., 598.
Bank discounting a note in good faith otherwise preferential need not
surrender preference before proving claim. In re Wyly (1902), N. Dist.
Texas, Meek, J., 116 Fed., 38; 8 A. B. R., 604; in re Bullock (1902). E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 116 Fed., 667; 8 A. B. R., 646.
Claim for damages for conversion of stock cannot be proved until pay;
ments received on accovmt are surrendered. In re Graff (1902), E. Dist.
N. Y., Thomas, J., 117 Fed., 343; 8 A. B. R., 744.
No preference shown in receipt of payment from third person on which
bankrupt was also liable — referee's practice is governed by rules in equity
in taking testimony and he cannot excuse a witness from answering ques-
tions on objections, but should note the answer and report the facts.
Dressel v. North State Lumber Co. (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 119
Fed., 531.
Where all creditors whose claims were allowed have received one
hundred per cent, creditors whose claims have been disallowed for prefer-
ence should be paid. In re Morton (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 118
Fed., 908.
Creditors who have received a preference must refund before proving
claims. Worden v. Columbus Electric Co. (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
96Fed., 803;3 A. B. R., 186.
An innocent creditor receiving preferences allowed to elect whether he
will surrender or not. In re Conhaim, Dist. Wash., Handford, J., 100
Fed., 268; 3 A. B. R., 249; 2 N. B. N., 521.
Fraudulent combination of creditors with bankrupt will justify court
in postponing claim. In re Headley (1899), W. Dist. M., Phillips, J., 97
Fed., 765; 3 A. B. R., 272; 2 N. B. N., 250.
Preference, although more than four months old, must be surrendered
before proof. In re Jones (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 100 Fed., 781;
4 A. B. R.,563;2N. B. N., 961.
Clerk's wages covering more than three months' time — payment to be
made thereon within four months. In re Henry C. King Co. (1902) , Dist.
Mass., Lowell, J., 113 Fed., 110; 7 A. B. R., 619.
No preference shown in payment which closed the account where a new
180 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§57g.
transaction is subsequently occurring. In re Seay (1902), N. Dist. Ga.,
Newman, J., 113 Fed., 969; 7 A. B. R., 700.
Payments in four months which are followed by new credits are to be
rendered thereby in estimating the amovmt of preference. Kimball v.
E. A. Rosenham Co. (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 114 Fed., 85;
7 A. B. R., 718.
Payment to a bank on note discounted by creditor is a preference as to
such creditor. In re Waterbury Furniture Co. (1902) , Dist. Conn., Town-
send, J., 114 Fed., 255; 8 A. B. R., 79.
To avoid liability on preference creditors turned over note of bank-
rupt to a bank to make proof thereon — claim of bank was disallowed. In
re Levi (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Van Vorhis, R., 8 A. B. R., 244.
The fact that the estate was enriched as a whole by the dealings with the
creditor in the four months will not relieve him from the duties of sur-
rendering preferences, there being no subsequent credits. In re Colton
Ex. & Import Co. (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 115 Fed., 158; 8
A. B. R., 257.
Claim of bank which issued due bill on draft of debtor who had al-
ready made assignment held it might retain the money and apply it to
another proceeding in bankruptcy, which was filed separately — set-off
allowed in bankruptcy though not tmder state law. In re Meyer & Dick-
inson (1901), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 106 Fed., 828; 5 A. B. R.,S593.
Specific application of payments to outstanding accotmts does not
prevent payments from being preferences. In re Bashline (1901), W.
Dist. Pa., Buffington, J., 109 Fed., 965; 6 A. B. R., 194.
r General creditor must surrender his security before his claim may be
allowed. In re Leeman (1899) , Dist. Me., Sprague, R., 1 N. B. N., 331.
Payment of rent to landlord not a preferred claim, he not being in
same class as other creditors. In re Barrett (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise,
R., 6 A. B. R., 199.
There is no time Umit of four months to these preferences. A tran-
saction closed by a payment in full is not to be carried over to affect new
credits and payments. Labor payment is not a]"transfer". In re Abra-
ham Steers Lumber Co. (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 110 Fed.,
738; 6 A. B. R., 315.
A creditor receiving preference on one of several claims of the same
class must surrender it before he may prove any of his claims. Swarts v.
Fourth Nat. Bank of St. Louis (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 117
Fed., 1; 8 A. B. R, 673.
A creditor who received preference innocently may not prove his
claim without surrender. In re Schafer (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., 105 Fed.,
352;5A. B. R.,146,
§57g.] CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE iSl
As to right to set off new credits by the creditor, McKey v. Lee (1901) ,
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Grosscup, J., 105 Fed., 923; 5 A. B. R.. 267.
Payment by a firm to its creditor preferentially made will prevent
him from proving against the estate of one of the members in bankruptcy.
In re Kellar (1901) , N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed., 348; 6 A. B. R., 487.
Payment to servants, clerks and laborers not a preference under
this section. In re Read & Knight (1901), S. Dist., N. Y. Dexter, R.,7
A. B. R., 111.
A fraudulent settlement by an insolvent with his creditors can be
urged to defeat allowance of claims of such creditors in subsequent
bankruptcy proceedings who participated in the fraud. In re Knox, S.
Dist. N. Y., Coxe. J., 98 Fed., 585; 3 A. B. R., 371.
Burden of proof is on those attacking validity of claim. Hill v.
Levy (1900), Dist. Va., Waddill, J., 98 Fed., 94; 3 A. B. R., 374; 2 N. B.
N., 180.
The creditor receiving payment within the four months innocently,
must refvmd before proving claim. Citing Columbus Electric Co. v.
Warden (1899), 96 Fed., 803; 3 A. B. R., 634. In re Fixen & Co. (1900),
C. C. A., 9th Cir., Morrow, J., 102 Fed., 295; 4 A. B. R., 10; 1 N. B. N.,
668.
Construing this section with 60 (a) and (b), innocent creditors who
receive preferences within four months must siurender before proving
claims. Strobel v. Knost (1900), S. Dist. la., Thompson, J., 99 Fed., 409;
3 A. B. R., 631.
See to same effect as Strobel v. Knost, Columbus Electric Co. v. Warden
(1900), C. C. A., 7th Cit., Jenkins, J., 96 Fed., 803; 3 A. B. R., 634.
Creditors must come into court and submit their claims. In re Coffin
(1899), E. Dist. Tex., Dillard, R., 2 A. B. R., 344; 1 N. B. N., 507.
A creditor who has been given a preference must surrender it before
he can prove his claim. In re Knost & Wilhelmy (1899), S. Dist. Ohio,
Waite, R., 2 A. B. R., 471; 1 N. B. N., 403.
In absence of proof of insolvency no preference can be found to exist
In re Alexander (1900), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 102 Fed., 464; 4 A. B.
R., 376; 2 N. B. N., 997.
This section and 60 (a) do not apply where the creditor did not know
he was insolvent at the time of making the payment. In re Smoke
(1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 4 A. B. R., 434; 2 N. B. N., 831.
Creditor who has received preference not entitled to file petition in
involuntary bankruptcy. In re Rogers Milling Co. (1900) W. Dist. Ark.,
Rogers, J., 102 Fed., 982; 4 A. B. R., 540; 2 N. B. N., 973.
182 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§57h.
An innocent preferential creditor may not be compelled to surrender
his mortgage, nor be deprived of the proceeds on sale of property free
rom liens. McNair v. Mclntyre (1902), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Simonton,
J., 113 Fed., 113; 7 A. B. R., 638.
Payment otherwise preferential subject to set ofif by subsequent
credits. The entire claim is not divisable so as to affect preferences.
C. S. Morey Mer. Co. v. Schiffer, C. C. A., 8 Cir., Sanborn, J., 114 Fed., 447 ;
7 A. B. R., 670.
■ Preference found in a composition many years prior to the bank-
ruptcy fraudulent in equity in the amovmt thereof must be surrendered
before proof of claim. In re Chaplin (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 115
Fed., 162; 8 A. B. R., 121.
Pa)mient by notes discounted by creditor, payee becomes preference
£rom time of discovmt, unless it comes back to his hands from failure of
bankrupt to meet it. Credits given subsequent to the preference may
be proved without surrender. In re Weissner (1902), E. Dist. N. Y.,
Whomas. J., 115 Fed., 421; 8 A. B. R., 177.
To bar claim on account of preference, it must appear that there has
been a preference. In re Hickey (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 112 Fed.
287; 7 A. B. R., 282.
Innocent creditor must surrender before proof where a new debt is
not coupled with it, nor will the payment on the former be a preferences
In re Abraham Steers Lumber Co. (1901), C. C. A., 112 Fed., 406; 7 A.
B. R., 332.
A stock broker and customer are merely ordinary debtor and creditor
and the cvistomer must surrender preferences. In re Gaylord (1902),
E. Dist. M., Adams, J., 112 Fed.. 668; 7 A. B. R., 577.
Judgment by confession within four months and on suit by trustee
held a preference creditor must surrender before proof of claim. In re
Greth (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 112 Fed., 978; 7 A. B. R., 598.
Payment to laborers, clerks and servants within four months not
preference imder 57 g, such persons constituting a distinct class.
In Read & Knight (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Dexter, R., 7 A. B. R., 111.
h [Securities held by secured creditors — value deter-
mined.] The value of securities held by secured creditors
shall be determined by converting the same into money ac-
cording to the terms of the agreement pursuant to which
such securities were delivered to such creditors or by such
creditors and the trustee, by agreement, arbitration, com-
§57ijk.] CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. 183
promise, or litigation, as the court may direct, and the
amount of such value shall be credited upon such claims,
and a dividend shall be paid only on the unpaid balance.
"Secured creditor" defined Sec. 1 (23) ante and notes.
Secvired creditor must deduct value of security before claim proved.
In re Little (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed.. 621; 6 A. B. R., 681.
i [Claims secured by individual undertaldng.] When-
ever a creditor, whose claim against a bankrupt estate is
secured by the individual imdertaking of any person, fails
to prove such claim, such person may do so in the creditor's
name, and if he discharge such imdertaking in whole or in
part he shall be subrogated to that extent to the rights of
the creditor.
The creditor has a preference over a surety in proving a claim. In re.
Heyman (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 97 Fed., 195; 2 A. B. R.. 651.
A retiring partner, who pays a prior debt which the remaining partner
agreed to pay, is a surety as regards him, and is subrogated to the claim
of that creditor. In re Dillon (1900) , Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 100 Fed.,
627; 4 A. B. R, 63.
Equitable subrogation allowed where no injustice will be done to other
creditors. Courier Journal Job Printing Co. v. Schaefer Meyer Brewing
Co. (1900), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Liu-ton, J., 101 Fed., 699; 4 A. B. R., 183.
Those coming imder this section not allowed the set-off of section 60
(c). In re Christensen (1900), N. Dist. la., James, R., 4 A. B. R., 202;
2 N. B. N., 670.
j [Debts owing to United States, etc.] Debts owing to
the United States, a State, a county, a district, or a munici-
pality as a penalty or forfeitiu*e shall not be allowed, except
for the amount of the pecuniary loss sustained by the act,
transaction, or proceeding out of which the penalty or for-
feiture arose, with reasonable and actual costs occasioned
thereby and such interest as may have accrued thereon ac-
cording to law.
k [Reconsideration of claims.] Claims which have been
allowed may be reconsidered for cause and reallowed or re-
184 CLAIMS. — PROOF AND ALLOWANCE. [§571inn.
jected in whole or in part, according to the equities of the
case, before but not after the estate has been closed.
Burden on objectors to claim — proof must be offered before expunging
claim on objections. In re Doty (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Dexter, R., 5
A. B. R., 58.
This clause limits right to apply by petition to trustee and to creditors
who are dissatisfied with the amount allowed to some creditors of the
bankrupt. In re Chambers, Calder & Co. (1901), Dist. R. I., Littlefield,
R.,6A. B. R.,707.
/ [Recovery of dividend on rejected claim by trustee.]
Whenever a claim shall have been reconsidered and re-
jected, in whole or in part, upon which a dividend has been
paid, the trustee may recover from the creditor the amount
of the dividend received upon the claim if rejected in whole,
or the proportional part thereof if rejected only in part.
As to payment of dividends, see Sec. 65 and notes.
m. [Claims by one estate against another.] The claim
of any estate which is being administered in bankruptcy
against any like estate may be proved by the trustee and
allowed by the court in the same manner and upon like
terms as the claims of other creditors.
Ownership of fund in two estates will be determined by court and dis-
tributed to one set of creditors or the other according to the equities.
In re Rosenberg (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 116 Fed., 402; 8 A.
B. R., 624.
n [Time for proving claims.] Claims shall not be proved
against a bankrupt estate subsequent to one year after the
adjudication ; or if they are liquidated by litigation and the
final judgment therein is rendered within thirty days before
or after the expiration of such time, then within sixty days
after the rendition of such judgment: Provided, That the
right of infants and insane persons without guardians, with-
out notice of the proceedings, may continue six months
longer.
§58a.] NOTICE TO CREDITORS. 185
As to procedure in proof of claim, see Gen. Order XXI.
Refusal to re-open case for proof of claim is discretionary. In re
Wood (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 95 Fed., 946; 2 A. B. R., 695;
1 N. B. N., 430.
This is not an enlargement of creditors' rights, but a restriction on
them. In re Stein (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 94 Fed., 124; 1 A. B. R.,
662; 1 N. B. N., 339.
This section must be construed with section 65 (a), (b) and (c), and
sections 47 (a) , 2 and 8 Subd., 55 (b) , 58 (a) , (b) , (c) and 66 (a) and (b) . In
re Stein (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 94 Fed., 124; 1 A. B. R., 662; 1
N. B. N., 339.
No limitation for filing claims imder composition. In re Simon Fox
(1901), N. Dist. Ohio., Remington, R., 6 A. B. R., 525.
Notice to creditors must be sent — bankrupt must show he has used
diligence to find the debtors. In re Dvorak (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 107 Fed., 76; 6 A. B. R., 66.
Claims must be filed before one year, irrespective of the discharge of
the bankrupt. In re Liebowitz (1901), N. Dist. Tex., Meek. J., 108 Fed.,
617; 6 A. B. R., 268.
Sec. 58. Notices to Creditors.
a [Ten days' notice.] Creditors shall have at least ten
days* notice by mail, to their respective addresses as they
appear in the list of creditors of the bankrupt, or as after-
wards filed with the papers in the case by the creditors, un-
less they waive notice in writing, of
(1) [Examinations.] All examinations of the bank-
rupt;
(2) [Hearings.] All hearings upon applications for the
confirmation of compositions or the discharge of bankrupts ;
(3) [Meetings of creditors.] All meetings of creditors ;
(4) [Sales.] All proposed sales of property ;
(5) [Dividends,] The declaration and time of payment
of dividends ;
186 NOTICE TO CREDITORS. [§58bc.
(6) [Final accounts.] The filing of the final accounts of
the trustee, and the time when and the place where they will
be examined and passed upon ;
(7) [Compromises.] The proposed compromise of a ny
controversy, and
(8) [Dismissal of proceedings.] The proposed dismissal
of the proceedings.
For notice of first meeting of creditors, see Form No. 18.
For form of notice of dividend, see Form 41. As to sales of property,
see Gen. Order XVIII.
Notice to creditors not essential when officer of the covirt desire im-
mediate information for preservation of the estate and examination of
bankrupt for that ptirpose. In re Abrahamson & Bretstein (1899) , Moss,
R., N. Dist. N. Y., 1 A. B.R ., 44; 1 N. B. N., 23.
Applicants for examination of bankrupt subsequent to first meeting
of creditors must pay all costs of examination including cost of notices
and maiUngthe same. In re Price (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.,
91 Fed., 635; 1 A. B. R., 419; 1 N. B. N., 131.
Sections 58 and 59 relate to dismissals. Neustadter v. Chicago Dry
Goods Co. (1899), Dist. Wash., 96 Fed., 830; 3 A. B. R., 96, 1 N. B. N., 552.
Examination of bankrupt prior to first meeting Umited to preparation
of schedule. In re Franklin Syndicate (1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas.
J., 101 Fed., 402; 4 A. B. R., 244; 2 N. B. N., 522.
h [First meetings— otlier notices.] Notice to creditors of
the first meeting shall be published at least once and may be
published such number of additional times as the court may
direct; the last publication shall be at least one week prior
to the date fixed for the meeting. Other notices may be
published as the court shall direct.
As to selection of newspapers, see Sec. 28a.
c [Notices given by referee.] All notices shall be given by
the referee, unless otherwise ordered by the judge.
§59ab.] PETITIONS — WHO MAY FILE. 187
Sec. 59. Who may File and Dismiss Petitions.
a [Voluntary bankrupt.] Any qualified person may file
a petition to be adjudged a voltintary bankrupt.
As to who may become bankrupts, see Sec. 4a and notes ante.
Creditors of a voluntary bankrupt can not oppose the adjudication.
In re Jehu (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 94 Fed., 638; 2 A. B. R., 498; 1
N. B. N., 509.
Individual petition cannot be so amended as to include partnership.
A new petition shovdd be filed. In re Mercur (1902), E. Dist. Pa., Arch-
bald, J., 116 Fed., 655; 8 A. B. R., 275.
Members of firm desiring to be adjudicated bankrupt individually
shovdd each file petition. In re Farley & Co. (1902), W. Dist. Va., Mc-
Dowell, J., 115 Fed., 359; 8 A. B. R., 266.
A petition in bankruptcy may not be amended in order to insert a fur-
ther and later act of bankruptcy. In re Sears (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
117 Fed., 294; 8 A. B. R., 713.
Lunatic cannot file his petition by his committee. In re Eisenberg
(1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 117 Fed., 786; 8 A. B. R., 551.
h [Involuntary bankrupt.] Three or more creditors who
have provable claims against any person which amoimt in
the aggregate, in excess of the value of securities held by
them, if any, to five hundred dollars or over ; or if all of the
creditors of such person are less than twelve in number, then
one of such creditors whose claim equals such amoimt may
file a petition to have him adjudged a bankrupt.
As to claims which may be proved, see Sec. 57 ante.
As to form of involuntary petition, see Form No. 3 post.
Creditors, parties to general assignment proceedings, estopped from
filing involuntary petition. In re Simonson (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans,
J., 92 Fed., 904; 1 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N., 549.
Bankruptcy courts are reluctant to admit estoppel against creditors
and there must be weighty reasons for invoking it. In re Simoncon
(1899), Dist. of Ky., Evans, J., 92 Fed., 904; 1 A. B. R., 197; 1 N. B. N.,
549.
A second creditor may join in an involuntary petition after filed —
all rights of amendment are in the second credit ox In re D.A. Taylor (1899)
N. Dist. N. Y., King, R.; 1 N. B. N., 412.
l§g PETITIONS — WHO MAY FILE. [§59 b.
Debt attempted to be satisfied by a void transfer should be counted
when determining jurisdictional facts. In re Tirre (1899), Sou. Dist.
N. Y., Brown, J., 96 Fed., 425; 1 N. B. N., 402; 2 A. B. R., 493.
A creditor whose claim is unliquidated can not file petition. In re
Brinckman (1900), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 103 Fed., 65; 4 A. B. R., 551;
3 N. B. N., 28.
Adjudication which was based on proof of claim of petitioners after the
contest of such claim is res ad judicata against the estate and not open to
attack by creditors. Creditors have right to contest adjudication and
are concluded by all matters directly in issue and determined by the
decree. Collateral matters although proved are not res adjudicata. In re
Henry Ulfelder Clothing Co. (1899), N. Dist. Cal., De Haven, J., 98 Fed..
409; 3 A. B. R., 425.
See the cases of in re Moyer (1899), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 1 A.
B. R., 577; in re Arnold (1899), 94 Fed., 1001; 2 A. B. R., 180; 1 N. B. N..
334; in re Richards, 2 A. B. R., 518.
Involuntary bankruptcy of corporation which executes written admis-
sion and consent — rule 12 mtist be observed, subpCEna issued and rule
entered to allow any creditor to appear and object. In re Humbert Co.
(1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.. 100 Fed.. 439; 4 A. B. R., 76.
Duplicate copy of petition must be filed within the four months;
clerk's docket should show the filing of the same. In re Dupree (1899) ,
E. Dist. N. C, PumeU, J., 97 Fed., 28; 1 N. B. N., 513.
Creditor who assented to a general assigimient not permitted to be-
come petitioning creditors in involuntary bankruptcy proceedings against
the assignor. In re Romanow & Feingold (1899), N. Dist., Mass., Lowell,
J., IN. B. N., 213.
Creditors may join in the petition subsequent to its original filing
though doing so more than four months after the act of bankruptcy. In
re Romanow & Feingold (1899), N. Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 1 N. B. N.,
213.
An Indian may file petition in bankruptcy. An interest in tribal land
not such as may be reached by creditors of bankrupt. In re Rennie, Dist.
I. T. (1899), 2 A. B. R., 182; 1 N. B. N., 385.
Dismissal of involvmtary petitions on appUcation of majority of peti-
tioning creditors cannot be allowed against objection of minority cred-
itors. In re Cronin (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 98 Fed., 584; 3 A. B.
R., 652.
Petitioning creditors who file claims in assignment proceedings in the
state court are not estopped where they were not in possession of full
knowledge of the fraudtUent conduct of the bankrupt at the time they
§59 b.] PETITIONS — WHO MAY FILE. 189
acquiesced in the assignment. In re Curtis (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
94 Fed., 630; 2 A. B. R., 226; I N. B. N., 357.
Where the number of creditors petitioning for adjudication in bank-
ruptcy are insufficient at the time of filing to support the same creditors
may join any time before adjudication. In re Romanow (1899), Dist.
Mass., Lowell, J., 92 Fed., 510; 1 A. B. R., 461; 1 N. B. N., 213.
A petition may not be amended so as to insert acts of bankruptcy sub-
sequent to one originally set up. In re Sears (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir.,
117 Fed., 294; 8 A. B. R., 559.
When there are more than twelve creditors three creditors are required
to join in the petition in order to give the court jurisdiction. The suffi-
ciency of the number of creditors is a jurisdictional fact which may be
questioned collaterally. Buckingham v. Schuylkill Plush & Silk Co.
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Blanchard, J., 38 N. Y., Misc., 305.
Act of bankruptcy committed before November 1, 1898, injunction in
State Court to restrain creditor from disposing of goods received as a
preference voidable vmtil involtintary provisions of the act came into
effect, denied. Ellis v. L. Hays Saddlery & Leather Co. (1902), Sup. Ct.
Kans., Smith, J., 69 Pac, 165.
Involuntary petition can not be filed by attacking creditor without
first abandoning an attachment lien. One petitioner can not buy up
claims to file as co-petitioners. In re Burlington Malting Co. (1901), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 109 Fed., 777; 6 A. B. R., 369.
Petition must be signed by at least three creditors where there are
twelve or more — no cause of complaint that bankrupt has solicited his
creditors not to join in petition. In re Brown (1901) , E. Dist. Mo., Rogers,
J., Ill Fed., 979; 7 A. B. R., 102.
After filing involuntary petition debtor reduced his indebtedness to
the petitioners to less than five hundred dollars by payment. Held
that the jurisdiction was not thereby lost. Spencer v. Duplan Silk Co.
(1902), E. Dist. Pa., 115 Fed., 689; 7 A. B. R., 563.
Unliquidated disputed claim may not be used for filing involuntary
petition. In re Big Meadows Gas Co. (1902), W. Dist. Pa., Buffington,
J., 113 Fed., 974; 7 A. B. R., 697.
Petitioner in involuntary proceedings may not withdraw so as to
prevent adjudication. In re Beddingfield (1899), N. Dist. Ga., Newman
J., 96 Fed., 190; 2 A. B. R., 355; 1 N. B. N., 385.
Other creditors may join by agreement and create the necessary
amount. In re Beddingfield (1899), 96 Fed., 190; 2 A. B. R., 355; 1 N.
B N., 385.
Debts paid by bankrupt in fraud of the act included in computing the
190 PETITIONS — WHO MAY FILE. [§59c.
requisite amount for adjudication. Re F. F. Cain (1899), N. Dist. 111.
Eastman, R., 1 N. B. N., 389.
Allegations of involimtary petition must be allegations of fact and
made with reasonable and sufficient certainty. It must allege that
preferential payments to a creditor were made with intent to prefer such
creditor. In re Ewing (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 115 Fed,, 707; 8 A. B.
R., 269.
Petition held sufficient if it did not specify the business an alleged
bankrupt was engaged in where question was raised on demurrer, and
the demurrer filed as part of the answer on which the parties went to a
final hearing. In re Stem (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Townsend, J., 116
Fed., 604; 8 A. B. R., 569.
Manner and details of concealment need not be averred. In re Bellah
(1902), Dist. of Del., Bradford, J., 116 Fed., 69; 8 A. B. R., 310.
Defective petition which does not allege an act of bankruptcy cannot
be amended so as to state statutory grounds. White v. Bradley Timber
Co. (1902), S. Dist. Ala., Toulmin, J., 116 Fed., 768.
Application for reinstatement of involuntary petition which was dis-
missed denied. In re Jemison Mercantile Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir.,
McCormick, J., 112 Fed., 966; 7 A. B. R., 588.
Jurisdiction in involuntary bankruptcy attaches to cotirt in which
petition was first filed in point of time. In re Elmira Steel Co. (1901),
N. Dist. N. Y., 109 Fed., 456; 5 A. B. R., 484.
Verification of petition sufficient if made by coudsel, if counsel more
familiar with facts than c.ient. In re Chequasset Lumber Co. (1901),
S. Dist. N. Y. Adams, J., 112 Fed., 56; 7 A. B. R. 87.
Petitioner who has a preference disqualified tmless he make restitution.
In re Gillette & Prentice (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 769;
5 A. B. R., 119.
c [Petitions in duplicate.] Petitions shall be filed in
duplicate, one copy for the clerk and one for service on the
bankrupt.
The filing of a duplicate copy of the petition is necessary to confer jur-
isdiction. A suit may be dismissed on a failure to do so. In re Steven-
son, (1899) Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R., 66; 1 N.
B. N., 313.
If duplicates not filed time permit of act does not begin to run. In re
Stevenson (1899). Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R., 66;
1 N. B. N., 313.
§59def.] PETITIONS — WHO MAY FILE. 191
d [Notice to other creditors.] If it be averred in the
petition that the creditors of the bankrupt are less than
twelve in number, and less than three creditors have joined
as petitioners therein, and the answer avers the existence
of a larger number of creditors, there shall be filed with the
answer a list under oath of all the creditors, with their ad-
dresses, and thereupon the court shall cause all such cred-
itors to be notified of the pendency of such petition and
shall delay the hearing upon such petition for a reasonable
time, to the end that parties in interest shall have an oppor-
timity to be heard ; if upon such hearing it shall appear that
^ sufficient ntimber have joined in such petition, or if prior
to or during such hearing a sufficient ntimber shall join
therein, the case may be proceeded with, but otherwise it
shall be dismissed.
Petitions in involuntary cases may be amended so as to include suf-
ficient number of creditors. In re Mercur, E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J.,
95 Fed., 634; 2 A. B. R.. 626.
As to preparation of schedules in involuntary cases see Gen. Order
IX.
e [Computing number of creditors.l In computing the
number of creditors of a bankrupt for the purpose of de-
termining how many creditors must join in the petition,
such creditors as were employed by him at the time of the
filing of the petition or are related to him by consanguinity
or affinity within the third degree, as determined by the
common law, and have not joined in the petition, shall not
be counted.
/ [Appearance of creditors.] Creditors other than orig-
inal petitioners may at any time enter their appearance and
join in the petition, or file an answer and be heard in oppo-
sition to the prayer of the petition.
This section construed in re Stein, C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 5 A. B. R., 288.
Petition of insufficient number of creditors gives jurisdiction that may
192 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60a.
be fortified by other creditors by joining in later. In re Mammoth Pine
Lumber Co. (1901), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 109 Fed., 308; 6 A. B. R.,84.
g [Notice of dismissal.] A voluntary or involuntary
petition shall not be dismissed by the petitioner or peti-
tioners or for want of prosecution or by consent of parties
until after notice to the creditors.
As to priority of petitions, see Gen. Order VII.
Dismissal of voluntary petition allowed in absence of estate. In re
Hebbart (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 104 Fed., 322; 5 A. B. R., 8.
Application for reinstatement of proceedings in involuntary proceed-
ings on the ground of want of notice may after a year be denied on
accovmt of unreasonable delay. 7« r^ Jenison Mer. Co. (1902), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., McCormick J., 112 Fed., 966; 7 A. B. R., 588.
Sec. 60. Preferred Creditors.
a [What constitutes a preference.] A person shall be
deemed to have given a preference if, being insolvent, he
has, *within four months before the filing of the petition, or
after the filing of the petition and before the adjudication*,
procured or suffered a judgment to be entered against him-
self in favor of any person, or made a transfer of any of his
property, and the effect of the enforcement of such judg-
ment or transfer will be to enable anyone of his creditors to
obtain a greater percentage of his debt than any other of
such creditors of the same class. *Where the preference
consists in a transfer, such period of four months shall not
expire until four months after the date of the recording or
registering of the transfer, if by law such recording or reg-
istering is required.*
As amended by law of 1903, see Amendment, page , post. New
matter found between stars.
See 57 g, ante.
Subdivisions a and b should be construed together. A preference
cannot be set aside if the creditor had no reasonable cause to believe the
debtor was insolvent. In re Ebert (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Lewis, R., 1
A. B. R., 340.
§60a.] PREFERRED CREDITORS. 193
A preference is a payment made by a debtor within four months, the
result of which would be to give the payee a greater percentage, although
innocently received. In re ICnost & Wilhelmy (1899), S. Dist. Ohio,
Waite, R., 2 A. B. R., 471; 1 N. B. N., 403.
The assignment of fire insurance policies as collateral to secure present
of future advances of money or goods, is not giving a preference within
the meaning of the bankruptcy act. Sections 60 and 67 compared.
In re Little River Lumber Co. (1899), W. Dist. Ark., Rodgers, J., 92 Fed..
585; 1 A. B. R., 483; 1 N. B. N., 306.
Payment of money to a creditor on account constitutes a transfer.
In re Christenson (1900), N. Dist. la., James, R., 101 Fed., 243; 4 A.
B. R., 202; 2 N. B. N., 695.
No set-off allowed those coming under Section 59 (g) . In re Christen-
sen, N. Dist. la., James, R., 4 A. B. R., 262; 2 N. B. N., 695.
Payment on claim for wages not preference. In re Fewerlicht (1902)
S. Dist. N. Y., Smith, J., 8 A. B. R., 550.
Liability of bankrupt not a claim tmless liability fixed by notice and
protest. In re Edson (1902) , Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 119 Fed., 487.
In pleading it is sufficient to allege that the transfer had the prohibited
effect and the defendant had reasonable cause to know — matters tending
to prove need not be set out in detail — transfer of securities by bankrupt
to one who thereupon endorses bankrupt's note within four months,
which is delivered to a creditor is preferential payment where knowledge
is brought home to the creditor. Crooks v. Peoples National Bank (1899) ,
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Herrick, J., 46 N. Y., App., Div. 335; see the same case
(1902), 72 N. Y. App., Div. 331.
Creditor must have had actual knowledge of insolvency or such cir-
cumstances as would make reasonably prudent man suspect insolvency.
Sirrine v. Stoner-Mar shall Co. (1902), Sup. Ct. S. C, Jones, J., 42 S. E.,
432.
Payment no preference unless creditor had knowledge. Sherman v.
Luckhardt (1902), Sup. Ct. Kans., Doster, J., 70 Pac, 702.
The date of delivery of deed not the date of recording is date of trans-
fer in case of preference. Dean v. Plane el al. (1902), Sup. Ct. 111., Cart-
wright, J., 195 111., 495.
There must be an intent to give a preference — facts showing. Benedict
V. Duhel (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., McLaughlin, J., 79 N. Y., Supp., 205.
Adjudication on ground of fraudulent preference is res adjudicata as to
insolvency and notice of bankrupt, but not as to the creditor. Laundry
V. First Nat. Bank of Junction City (1903), Sup. Ct. Kans., 71 Pac, 259.
A chattel mortgage held for a year unrecorded but possession taken
194 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60a.
within four months' is a preferential transfer dating as of the possession.
Landis v. McDonald (1901), Ct. App., Mo., Ellison, J., 80 Mo.. App., 335;
Babbitt v. Kelly (1902), Ct. App., Mo., Good., J., 70 S. W., 385.
If transferee, as a reasonably prudent business man, believed debtor
was insolvent or intended to give an advantage to one creditor over
another a preference is given. Johnson v. Cohn (1902) , Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Gildersleeve, J., 39 N. Y., Misc., 189.
Merely giving a renewal chattel mortgage does not constitute a prefer-
ence. Intent to give is a question of fact. Deland v. Mittur and Cliany
Bank (1903), Sup. Ct. Iowa, Diemer, J., 93 N. W., 304.
Preference not shown by procuring of judgment and levy tmless some
fraud appears — query whether a confession of judgment made but not
entered before the passage of the act is open to challenge. Jones v.
Roch and Maloy (1898), Dist. Ct. of Pa., Clayton, J., 8 Pa., Dist. Rep.,
714.
Knowledge on the part of bank of the insolvency of the debtor will make
the payment recoverable. Pepperdine v. Nat. Exchange Bank (1900),
Ct. of App. of Mo., Bland, J., 84 Mo. App., 234.
No preference vmder the Bankruptcy Act by assignment of book ac-
counts as collateral security. Young v. Upson (1902), S. Dist. N. Y.,
Hazel, J., 115 Fed., 192; 8 A. B. R., 377.
There can be no preference unless the one receiving preference had rea-
sonable cause to believe a preference was intended. Levor v. Setter
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Patterson, J., 8 A. B. R., 459; Peck v. Council
(1902) , Superior Ct. Pa., Porter, J., 8 A. B. R., 500. In re Harpke (1902),
C. C. A., 7th Cir., Grosscup, J., 116 Fed., 295; 8 A. B. R., 535.
Sec 60a controUs 57g. Swarts v. Fourth Nat. Bank of St. Louis (1902),
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 117 Fed., 1 ; 8 A. B. R., 673.
Test of a preference is one creditor receiving more than others of the
same class with knowledge idem.
"Creditors of the same class discussed idem.
Lien may be a pfeference. In re Belding (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J., 116 Fed., 1016; 8 A. B. R., 718.
No preference shown where transaction between bankrupt and cred-
itor during the four months swells the bankrupt's estate, the payment to
the creditor having been made ^vithout knowledge of insolvency. Ja-
quith V. Alden (1902), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.. 118 Fed., 270; 9 A. B. R.,
165.
Claim by bank as endorser of note of bankrupt taken in due course of
business is not effectual by preferences which exist against the endorser.
In re Levi (1903), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 9 A. B. R., 175.
§60a.] PREFERRED CREDITORS. 195
Creditor must surrender paj'ment on a note discounted at a bank
within the four months. In re Waterbury Furniture Co. (1902), Dist.
Conn., Townsend, J., 114 Fed., 255; 8 A. B. R., 79.
Mortgage cannot be attached if both parties believed the bankrupt to
be solvent and he was apparently solvent. Stratton v. Lawson (1902),
Sup. Ct. Wash., Mount, J., 27 Wash., 310.
Facts held not to show conveyance in contemplation of bankruptcy.
Harmon v. Feldheim et al. (1902), Sup. Ct. Mich., 91 N. W., 744.
Complainant must allege that the effect of the transfer is to give the
creditor a greater percentage of his debt. Schryer v. Citizens Nat. Bank
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., LaughUn, J., 74 N. Y., App., Div. 478.
Debtor must have had reasonable cause to believe in the insolvency of
the bankrupt or had reasonable cause so to do. Taft v. Fourth Nat.
Bank (1900), C. C. Ohio, S Ohio N. P., 59; 10 Ohio Die, Sup. C. P., 405.
Harrison v. Walker (1902), Sup. Ct. Mich., Montgomery, J., 91 N. W.,
1025.
If a bankrupt gives an innocent person security for an accommodation
indorsement of his note there is such consideration flowing from the act of
endorsement that even if bankruptcy occurs within the four months the
endorser can hold the securities to the extent of reimbursing himself to
the amount of the note which he has become liable to pay. Cooks v. Peo-
ples Nat. Bank (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Houghton, J., 34 N. Y. Misc., 450.
Payment of debt in money within four months held a transfer which a
trustee could set aside. Sherman v. Luckhardt (1902), Mo. Ct. App.,
Smith, J., 70 S. W., 388.
Delivery of security by insolvent to a third person to guaranty notes on
which he is liable is not a preference. Crook v. Peoples Nat. Bank (1899) ,
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Russell, J., 29 N. Y., Misc., 30.
Execution of judgment notes and permitting same to be entered against
him is not act of bankruptcy. In re Anderson (1900) , W. Dist. Pa., Buff-
ington, J., 9 Pa. Dist. Rep., 504.
Transfer of property constituting a preference — facts showing. Allen
V. French (1901), Sup. Ct. Mass., Barker, J., 178 Mass., 539.
Whether debtor has reasonable cause to believe his debtor insolvent
is a question of fact. Bondinote v. Hamann (1902), Sup. Ct. la., Water-
man, J., 90 N. W.,497.
Innocent creditors receiving preferences not prejudiced. In re Rat-
lifi (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 107 Fed., 80; 5. A. B. R., 713.
Preference to be unlawful must be given for antecedent debt. In re
Davidson (1901), S. Dist. la., McPherson, J., 109 Fed., 882; 5 A. B.
R., 528.
196 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60a.
A creditor who by execution collects part of his claim has obtained
such a preference as forbids his proving his claim without first remitting
In re Gallagher (1901), Dist. Mass., Farmer, R., 6 A. B. R., 255.
A transfer of an insolvent which enables the creditor to obtain a greater
privilege, is a preference. In re Keller (1901), Dist. la., Shiras, J., 109
Fed., 118; 6 A. B. R., 334.
The nile which starts the time running from the date of the record ap-
plies only to preferences which are acts of bankruptcy, and not to pref-
erences which are voidable under section 60 (a) and (b) . In re Mersman
(1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 7 A. B. R., 46.
Proceeds of execution collected before bankruptcy not recoverable by
trustee unless creditor had reasonable cause to believe insolvency. In re
Blair et al. (1900), S. Dist. N. Y , Brown, J., 99 Fed., 76; 4 A. B. R., 220.
2 N. B. N., 890.
Surrender of firm note and acceptance of individual note of one member
more than four months before filing of petition, and subsequent judgment
not a preference by the firm. In re Lehigh Lumber Co, et al. (1900), W;
Dist. Pa., Buflington, J., 101 Fed., 216; 4 A. B. R., 221; 2 N. B. N., 512.
Preference shown in surrendering goods sold to bankrupt under pro-
vision that vendors retain lien for piu-chase price. In re Klingman (1900) ,
S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 691; 4 A. B. R., 254; 1 N. B. N., 294.
Where there are several accounts it cannot be claimed that the pref-
erence is to be disregarded because the account is closed. In re Sloan
(1900), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 102 Fed., 116; 4 A. B. R., 356.
Creditor holding security urder Section 60 which was cut off by fore.
closxu"e of a prior mortgage need not surrender security before proving
claim. In re Stendts (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 N. B.
N., 609.
No preference fotmd in a transfer by the bankrupt to a judgment
creditor of such property because the transferee was not a firm creditor.
In re Rudnick (1900), Dist. Wash., Hanforu, J., 102 Fed., 750; 4 A. B.
R., 531;2N. B. N., 769;
It is no preference for one partner to buy out his co-partner's in-
terest although the proceeds may have been used in the making of pref-
erential payments. In re Kindt (1900), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed.,
107; 4 A. B. R., 148; 2 N. B. N., 306.
If acts tend to defeat delay or hinder the operation of the bankrupt
law a preference will be created. In re D. A. Taylor (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., King, R.; 1 N. B. N., 412.
Rent payment is not ordinarily a preference. In re Lange (1900).
S. Dist. N. G., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 197; 3 A. B. R., 231; 2 N. B. N., 85,
§60b.] PREFERRED CREDITORS. 197
Preference not found where the effect of the joint operation was to
increase the estate, although the creditor did receive sundry payments
within the four months. The credits need not be subsequent to the pay-
ments to the creditor. In re Topliff (1902"), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
114 Fed., 323; 8 A. B. R., 141.
Preference created by fraudulent scheme between debtor and sundry
creditors who obtain payments before bankruptcy by an assignee's
collusive sale. Stern, Falk & Co. v. Louisville Trust Co. (1901), C. C.
A., 6th Cir., 112 Fed., 501; 7 A. B. R., 305.
The giving of checks by a bankrupt to its president for present advances
to pay wage claims due from the corporation, does not constitute a prefer-
ence within the meaning of the bankruptcy act. In re Union Feather
6 Wool Mfg. Co. (1902), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 112 Fed., 774;
7 A. B. R., 472.
Payment of accotmt in full within four months does not prejudice
new debt subsequently created. In re Champion (1902), S. Dist. Ala.,
Ervin, R., 7 A. B. R., 560.
Four months limitation for preferential payment is fraud in the ex-
ercise of equitable discretion based on analogious limitation in the law.
In re Dickinson (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Moss, R., 7 A. B. R., 679.
Money received by sheriff on execution within four months in a
preference. In re Metzger Toy & Novelty Co. (1902), W. Dist. Ark.,
Rogers, J.. 114 Fed., 957; 8 A. B. R.. 307.
There can be no preferences unless there is insolvency. In re Wittenl
berg Veneer & Panel Co., E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 108 Fed., 593; 6
A. B. R., 271.
The test whether a creditor received a preference with knowledge is a
question of fact, rather shan of law, and not reached by petition for re-
view. In re Eggert (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 4 A. B. R.,
449.
To avoid a preference it must appear that the bankrupt first was in-
solvent, second intended to give a preference, third, the creditor must
have known or had reasonable cause to know of the insolvency. In re
Ebert (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Lewis, R., 1 A. B. R., 340.
b [Preference voidable — jurisdiction to recover.] If a
bankrupt shall have given a preference (within fotir months
before the filing of a petition, or after the filing of the peti-
tion and before the adjudication), and the person receiving
it, or to be benefited thereby, or his agent acting therein,
198 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60b.
shall have had reasonable cause to beHeve that it was in-
tended thereby to give a preference, it shall be voidable by
the trustee, and he may recover the property or its value
from such person. *And, for the purpose of such recovery,
any court of bankruptcy, as hereinbefore defined, and any
State court which would have had jurisdiction if bank-
ruptcy had not intervened, shall have concurrent jurisdic-
tion.*
As amended by Act of 1903. See Amendment, page , post.
Omitted matter from Act of 1898 between brackets. New matter
between stars.
Knowledge of insolvency is not found from fact of discounting a bil
and accepting assignment of an accoimt in payment. In re Eggert
(1900). E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 98 Fed., 843; 3 A. B. R., 541; 2 N. B.
N., 185.
Where suit is brought to recover preference and allegation that the
bankrupt paid such money on his claim — not essential to allege it was out
of the bankrupt's estate. Richter v. Nimmo (1901) , N. Y. Supt. Ct. , Jenks
J., 63 App. Div., 422; 71 N. Y. Supp., 501; 6 A. B. R., 680.
The test whether creditors received a preference with knowledge is a
question of fact rather than of law and not reached by petition for re-
view. In re Eggert (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., 102 Fed., 735; 4 A. B. R.,
449.
Preference obtained by proceedings within the four months avoided and
the surrender by summary order of possession of the goods by the sheriff
to the trustee granted. In re Fellerath (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks,
J., 95 Fed., 121; 2 A. B. R., 40; 1 N. B. N., 292.
Preferences by giving of mortgages and lease set aside by decree of
district court at the suit of trustee, and creditors made to account for
the profits of one of the premises. Carter v. Goodykoontz (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 94 Fed., 108; 2 A. B. R., 224; 1 N. B. N., 196.
Agreement made more than four months prior to bankruptcy pro-
viding that creditor might have option to purchase, applying his claims
thereon, not a preference, thought right put in force within the four
months. Savin v. Camp (1900), Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 98 Fed., 974;
3 A. B. R., 578; 2 N. B. N., 375.
Creditor has reasonable cause to believe preference was intended if he
has knowledge of facts and circumstances which would put a pi-udcnt
man upon inquiry. In re Jacobs (1899), W. Dist. la., Jones, R., 1 A. B.
R., 518; 1 N. B. N., 183.
§60b.] PREFERRED CREDITORS. l99
Action by trustee to set aside preference — erroneous instruction — harm-
less will be disregarded. Whitely Grocery Co. v. Roach (1902), Sup. Ct.
Ga., Fish, J., 42 S. E., 282; 8 A. B. R., 505.
Trustee can sue without first obtaining order to do so. Chism v. Citi-
zens Bank of Clarksdale (1900), Sup. €t. Miss., Terrell, J., 77 Miss., 599.
Action by trustee to set aside fraudulent conveyance — fraud of bank-
rupt— bankrupt not necessary party (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J.,
78 N. Y. Supp., 369.
Trustee may avoid preference where there was reasonable cause on part
of creditor to believe insolvency — may follow fund. Lampkin v. Poeples
Nat. Bank (1902), Sup. Ct. Mo , Ellison, J., 71 S. W., 715.
Setting aside conveyance — trustee represents creditors. Oliver v.
Hilgers et al. (1902), Sup. Ct. Minn., Lewis, J., 92 N. W., 511.
Trustee permitted to file a bill in eqtiity to set aside a preference enacted
by orders for goods taken in by a nominal partnership within four months.
Margden v. Sugden (1902), Sup. Ct. N. H., Renwick, J., 52 Atl., 74.
Law, not chancery, the former for a suit by a trustee to set aside amount
of a fraudulent preference — the transaction involving one item. McCor-
mick V. Page (1901), 111. Ct. App., Dibell, J., 96 lU. App., 447.
Trustee must bring action to set aside a preference in the state court —
intent, not an essential element. Gabriel v. Tonner (1902), Sup. Ct. Cal.,
Gray, J., 70 Pac, 1021.
Complaint sustained by the trustee's mense assignee to set aside a
transfer made by the bankrupt to his wife. Bryan v. Madden (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Russell, J., 38 N. Y., Misc., 638.
Fraudulent intent to prefer — burden of proof of inso.vency and intent
on isiue is on creditor — intent is so s/wwn when insolvency is proved
and the fact of transfer burden of intent then rests on the bankrupt —
value of property determined by the receivers is evidence on question of
insolvency. In re Blocy (1901). C. C. A. 2nd Cir. Shipman, J., 109.
Fed., 790; 6 A. B. R., 300; 3 N. B. N., 894.
In suit by trustee proof what goods bought at private sale subsequent to
auction is incompetent to establish value. Seebrigv. Wellington ( 1901),
N. Y. Sup. App., Div., Adams, J., 6 A. B. R., 671.
A party to be liable to a suit of a trustee for receiving preference must
have been a creditor. Mere liability as endorser for bankrupt does not
constitute such relation. Swartz v. Siegel (1902), E. Dist. M., Adams,
J., 114 Fed., 1,001; 8 A. B. R., 220.
This section is limited to cases where the creditor had reasonable cause
to believe that a preference was intended. Blakey, Receiver, v. Boone-
200 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60c.
ville Nat. Bank (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 95 Fed., 267; 2 A. B. R.
459; 1 N. B. N.. 411.
Where preference is merely voidable trustee can not maintain with-
out previous demand and refusal, but where under Section 67 (e) trans-
er is fraudulent it is void and demand tmnecessary . In re Phelps (1899) ,
N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 3 A. B. R., 396; 2 N . B. N., 484.
Preferential inctmibrance before passage of act not affected thereby
/nreTerrill, (1900), Dist. Vt.. Wheeler, J., 100 Fed., 778; 4 A. B. R., 145.
No preference foimd where bankrupt's wife lent money obtained from
mortgaging her property to pay decree to turn over trust ftmds. Fry
V. Penn. Trust Co. (1900), Sup. Ct., Pa., Green, J., 5 A. B. R., 51.
Pleading in action to set aside preference — consent of bankruptcy
court not essential prerequisite to maintaining suit. Chism, Trustee, v.
Bank (1900), Sup Ct. Miss., Terrel, J.; 5 A. B. R., 56.
Set-off allowed from preferential payment on claim secured partially
by mortgage — claim allowed for the deficiency. In re Tanner (1901),
W. Dist. N. Y., McMaster, R., 6 A. B. R., 196.
A mortgage which is executed in blank and in which subsequently
the blanks are filled up does not take effect tmtil the latter date and if
such date falls within the four months prior to bankruptcy, is invaUd-
In re Barrett (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R., 6 A. B. R., 48.
c [Set-oflf of new credit after preference.] If a creditor
has been preferred, and afterwards in good faith gives the
debtor further credit without sectirity of any kind for prop-
erty which becomes a part of the debtor's estates, the amount
of such new credit remaining unpaid at the time of the ad-
judication in bankruptcy may be set off against the amount
which would otherwise be recoverable from him.
See 57 g and notes; also b supra.
Creditors innocently receiving preferential payments are entitled to
set-off under this section. In re Thompson's Sons (1901), E. Dist. Pa.
Hunter, R.; 6 A. B. R., 663.
Creditor innocently receiving preference is entitled to a sett-off.
In re Soldosky (1901), Dist. Mont., Lochren, J., Ill Fed., 511; 7 A. B.
R., 123; in re Dundas (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., Ill Fed., 500; 7
A. B. R., 129.
Preferences entitled to set-off in cases under Section 60 (a) and (b)
Peterson v. Nash Bros (1901), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Adams, J., 112 Fed., 311;
7 A. B. R., 181.
§60C.] PREFERRED CREDITORS. 201
Set-off allowed of credits within four months, although made before
the preference. In re Dickson v. Wyman {In re Jourdan), C. C. A., 1st
Cir., Putnam, J.; 7 A. B. R., 186.
Set-off allowed the innocent preferee. In re Thompson's Sons, Mc-
Pherson, J., E. Dist. Pa., 112 Fed., 651; 7 A. B. R., 214.
Pleadings on suit to set aside preference must allege insolvency. Mar-
tin V. Bigelow (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Scott, J.; 7 A. B. R., 218.
The set-off provided in Section 60 (c) was intended to apply only to
cases arising under Section 60 (b). Payment in full is a preference.
In re Rosenberg (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Pendleton, R., 7 A. B. R., 316.
Rebate allowed bankrupt on claim from course of business. In re
B. H. Douglas & Sons Co. (1902), Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 114 Fed.,
772; 8 A. B. R., 113.
Preferences reduced by subsequent credits. Cans v. Ellison, C. C.
A., 3rd Cir., Acheson, J.; 8 A. B. R., 153; also the same effect, Kahn v.
Export & Commission Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 115 Fed., 290; 8 A.
B. R., 157.
Set-off allowed innocent creditor following McKee v. Lee, et al. ; 5 A.
B. R., 267 supra. See the cases collected on this point in re Bothwell
(1902), Dist. N. J., Lewis, R.; 8 A. B. R., 213.
Right of set-off exists in favor of a preferred creditor who received the
preference innocently. McKee v. Lee, et al. (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Grosscup, J., 105 Fed., 923; 5 A. B. R., 267.
This section applies to the innocent as well as the guilty preferential cred-
itor. In re Ryan (1901), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 105 Fed., 760; 5. A
B. R., 396. (Being same case as McKee v. Lee, supra.)
No set-offs allowed where mutual credits subsequently given. Cases
restricted to 60 (b) ante. In re Keller (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.,
109 Fed., 118; 6 A. B. R., 334.
No set-off allowed the creditor who has received a preference under
Section 57 (g) and received preferential payments for subsequent credits.
In re Oliver (1901), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 109 Fed., 784; 6 A. B. R.,
626. In re Christensen, N Dist. la., James, R., 4 A. B. R., 202; 2 N. B-
N., 695.
This section and Sec. 68 must be interpreted as applicable to incidental
proceedings in bankruptcy and does not change the principles of set-off
in actions. Pearsall v. Nassau Nat. Bank (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Jenks,
J., 74 N. Y., App., Div., 89.
Where the dealings between the bankrupt and the creditor during the
four months' time has enhanced the value of the estate there is no room
for preference. Peterson v. Nash Bros. (1901), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Adams,
S02 PREFERRED CREDITORS. [§60d.
J., 112 Fed., 311; 7 A. B. R., 181. In re Jordan (Dickson v. Wynmn)
(1901), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., Ill Fed.. 726; 7 A. B. R., 186.
Morey v. Schtffer (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J., 114 Fed., 447; 7
A. B. R., 670. Kimball v. Rosenbeam (1902), C. C. A., Sanborn, J., Ill
Fed., 85; 7 A. B. R., 718. Cans v. Ellison (1902) , C. C. A., 3 Cir., Acheson,
J., 114 Fed., 734; 8 A. B. R., 153. In re Topliff (1902), Dist. of Mass.,
Lowell, J., 114 Fed., 323; 8 A. B. R., 141. Jacquith v. Alden (1902),
C. C. A., 1st Cir., Lowell, J., 9 A. B. R., 165.
d [Payment to attorney — Examination.] If a debtor
shall, directly or indirectly, in contemplation of the filing
of a petition by or against him, pay money or transfer prop-
erty to an attorney and counselor at law, solicitor in equity,
or proctor in admiralty for services to be rendered, the
transaction shall be re-examined by the court on petition
of the trustee or any creditor and shall only be held valid to
the extent of a reasonable amount to be determined by the
court, and the excess may be recovered by the trustee for the
benefit of the estate.
CHAPTER VII.
ESTATES.
Sec. 61. Depositories for Money
a. Courts to designate.
Sec. 62. Expenses of Adminis-
tration.
a. Expenses reported under oath.
Sec. 63. Debts which may be
Proved.
a. Provable debts.
(1) Fixed Uability.
(2) Costs of stiit.
(3) Claim for taxable costs.
(4) Open account or contract.
(5) Judgment after filing petition.
b. Unliquidated claims.
Sec. 64. Debts which have
priority.
a. Taxes.
b. Order of payment.
(1) Costs of preserving estate.
(2) Filing fees — expense of credi-
tor.
(3) Costs of administration.
(4) Employe's wages.
(5) Debts to persons entitled to
priority.
c. After composition set aside
or discharge revoked.
Sec 65. Declaration and Pay-
ment OF Dividends.
a. On allowed claims.
b. First and subsequent divi-
dends.
c. Claims subsequent to pay-
ment of dividends.
d. When person adjudged bank-
rupt outside the United
States.
e. Limit to amount collectable
by claimant.
Sec. 66. Unclaimed Dividends.
a. Payment into court.
b. Distribution after one year.
Sec 67. Liens.
a. Claims which are not valid
liens.
b. Trustee subrogated to rights
of creditors.
c. Certain liens dissolved.
(1) Defendant insolvent.
(2) Knowledge of insolvency.
(3) Fraud-trustee subrogated.
203
d. Liens given in good faith.
e. Conveyances within four
months — when void.
Liens created through legal
proceedings.
68. Set-offs and Counter-
claims.
Mutual debts and credits.
When not allowed.
Not provable.
Purchased with knowledge of
bankrupt's insolvency.
69. Possession of Prop-
erty.
a. Warrant may issue to mar-
shal to seize and hold prop-
erty.
Sec 70. Title to Property.
Title vested in trustee.
Documents.
Patents, copyrights and
trade-marks.
Powers.
Property transferred in fraud.
Property which might have
been transferred or levied on.
Policy of insurance.
Rights of Action.
Appraisal and sale of prop-
erties.
Trustee to convey title.
Composition set aside — vest-
ing title in trustee.
e. Avoiding certain transfers —
recovery of property.
/. Revestment of title on con-
firmation of composition.
Sec 71. Clerks to keep indexes
and issue Certificates or
SEARCH.
Sec. 72. Referee and Trustee
not to receive extra Com-
pensation.
Time when this act shall
GO into effect.
a. Force and effect.
b. Cases pending under State
laws.
Act OF Ffb. 5th, 1903,, not
TO efffct pending cases.
/■
Sec
a.
b.
(1)
(2)
Sec
a.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
6.
c.
d.
204 expenses of administering estates. [§§ 61 a, 62a.
Sec. 61. Depositories for Money.
a [Courts to designate.] Courts of bankruptcy shall
designate, by order, banking institutions as depositories
for the money of bankrupt estates, as convenient as may
be to the residences of trustees, and shall require bonds to
the United States, subject to their approval, to be given
by such banking institutions, and may from time to time
as occasion may require, by like order increase the number
of depositories or the amount of any bond or change such
depositories.
Trustees must deposit money in depositories. Sec. 47a (3) ante. As
to payment of money deposited, see Gen. Order XXIX.
Sec. 62. Expenses of Administering Estates.
a [Expenses reported under oath.] The actual and
necessary expenses incurred by officers in the adminis-
tration of estates shall, except where other provisions are
made for their payment, be reported in detail, imder oath,
and examined and approved or disapproved by the court.
If approved, they shall be paid or allowed out of the estates
in which they were incurred.
As to what are expenses of estates, see Gen. Ord. XXXV. As to in-
demnity for expense to be deposited by the bankrupt, see Gen. Order X
As to indemnity for expenses of traveling by referee, see Gen. Ord.
XXVI. See Sec. 5e as to payment of expenses from individual and firm
estates.
Trustee refused allowance of attorney's fee for preparation of accoimt
— this is among the ordinary duties which he should perform. In re
Averill (1899). N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R.. 1 N. B. N., 544.
Assignee in insolvency proceedings not entitled to allowance as cus-
todian in preserving the estate prior to filing petition in t)ankruptcy,
In re Peter Paul Book Co. (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed.,
786; 5 A. B. R., 105.
§63a.] debts which may be proved. 205
Sec. 63. Debts which may be Proved.
a [Provable debts.] Debts of the bankrupt may be
proved and allowed against his estate which are
For analogous provisions of act of 1800 see Sec. 39 of that act; of act of
1841 see Sec. 5 of that act; also Sec. 19 of act of 1867.
See notes under Sec. 17, "debts not barred a discharge."
(1) [Fixed liability.] A fixed liability, as evidenced
by a judgment or an instrument in writing, absolutely
owing at the time of the filing of the petition against him,
whether then payable or not, with any interest thereon
which would have been recoverable at that date or with a
rebate of interest upon such as were not then payable
and did not bear interest;
See notes under Sec. 17.
Bankrupt not liable on notes where protest and notice not given. Such
contingent liability not provable. In re Edson (1902) , Dist. Vt., Wheeler,
J., 119 Fed., 487.
Alimony over-due is provable debt in bankruptcy and a court of bank-
ruptcy may release the bankrupt from arrest under state authority for
non-payment. In re Houston (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 94 Fed., 119.
12 A. B. R., 107; 1 N. B. N., 205.
Alimony due not a provable debt and not barred. In re Smith (1899) ,
N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 3 A. B. R., 67; 1 N. B. N., 471.
Alimony over-due is a provable debt. Fite v. Fite (1901), Ct. of App.
Ky., Guffy, J., 5 A. B. R., 461.
Rent accruing after adjudication is not a claim against the estate.
Bankruptcy bars future liability on a lease. Lien of landlord tmder state
law not recognized in bankruptcy. In re Jefferson (1899), Dist. Ky.
Evans, J., 93 Fed., 948; 2 A. B. R., 206; 1 N. B. N., 288.
Judgment more than ten years old not a provable debt in North Caro-
lina. In re Farmer (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 9 A. B. R., 19.
Judgment for fine in criminal prosecution is a provable debt. In re
Alderson (1900), Dist. W. Va., Jackson, J., 98 Fed., 588 3 A. B. R., 544.
Landlord's claim for future rent not a provable debt. In re Ells
(1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 98 Fed., 967; 3 A. B. R., 564; 2 N. B.
N., 357.
206 DEBTS WHICH MAY BE PROVED. [§63 a.
Contract of endorsement is aprovable claim In re Schaeffer (1900),
E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 104Fed.973; 5A. B. R., 248; reversed In re
Gerson (1901), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 107 Fed., 897; 5 A. B. R., 89.
Rent accruing after bankruptcy not a provable claim. In re Mahler.
(1900), E. Dist. Mich., Swan, J., 105 Fed., 428; 5 A. B. R., 453.
Contingent liability of bankrupt as endorser cannot be changed to ab-
solute liability shortly before bankruptcy without adequate consideration,
In re Marks & Garson(1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Van Vooris, R., 6 A. B. R.,
641.
Claim of surety of debt of bankrupt is dischargeable where principal
is provable. Hoyer v. Conistock (1901), Sup. Ct. la.. Given, J., 7 A. B.
R., 493.
Alimony is a provable debt and proceedings therefor in state court
may be joined. In re Van Orden (1899), Dist. N. J., Kirkpatrick
J., 96 Fed., 86; 2 A. B. R., 801 ; 1 N. B. N., 475.
Deficiency must appear on face of deficiency decree in order to be
recognized in a court of bankruptcy. In re Hxiber et al. (1899), N. Dist,
N. Y., Judson, R., 1 N. B. N., 512.
Rent accruing after bankruptcy not a provable debt. In re Colling-
non (1900), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 4 A. B. R., 250; 2 N. B.N., 660
Rent of premises due prior to the filing of the petition in bankruptcy
is a preferred claim. In re ShiUiday (1899), W. Dist. Pa., Blair, R., 1
N. B. N., 475. See the case of Sinsheimer v. Simonson (1900), C. C. A.,
6th Cir., Taft, J., 92 Fed., 904; 3 A. B. R., 824.
Debt barred by statute of limitations revived by bond and mortgage,
even though mortgage void. In re Stendts (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotch-
kiss, R., 1 N. B. N.. 509.
After divorce in Arkansas a wife has one-third of her husband's person-
alty. Before such decree she has no claim provable in bankruptcy
against her estate. Hawk v. Hawk (1900), W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J.,
102 Fed., 679; 4 A. B. R., 463; 2 N. B. N., 940.
A bond given by bankrupt to secure payment of annuity is a provable
debt. Cobb v. Overman (1901), C. C. A., 4th Cir., Waddill, J., 109 Fed.,
65; 6 A. B. R., 324.
(2) [Costs of suit.] Due as costs taxable against an
involuntary bankrupt who was at the time of the filing
of the petition against him plaintiff in a cause of action
which would pass to the trustee and which the trustee
declines to prosecute after notice;
§63a.] DEBTS WHICH MAY BE PROVED. 207
See Sec. 11 as to suits by and against trustees.
Costs taxed against bankrupt in suit pending at time of filing the
petition are not provable. In re Marcus et al. (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell,
J., 104 Fed., o31; 5 A. B. R., 19.
(3) [Claim for taxable costs.] Founded upon a claim
for taxable costs incurred in good faith by a creditor before
the filing of the petition in an action to recover a provable
debt;
Where petition filed before judgment for costs rendered, costs are
not provable or dischargeable in bankruptcy. In re Marcus et al. (1901),
C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 105 Fed., 909; 5 A. B. R., 365.
Costs incurred in case under lien. In re Allen (1899), N. Dist. CJal.,
DeHaven, J., 96 Fed., 512; 3 A. B. R., 38.
An assignee under voluntary assigimient by reason whereof an adjudica-
tion in bankruptcy followed is entitled to no compensation for ser\'ices
nor for disbursements for rent, etc., prior to the bankruptcy. After
bankruptcy he may be allowed for as a receiver until trustee takes pos-
session. In re B. H. Gladding Co. (1902), Dist. R. I., Barrows, R., 9
A. B. R., 117.
(4) [Open account or contract.] Founded upon an
open account, or upon a contract express or implied ; and
See Sec. 17 and notes.
Costs of attachment incurred before bankruptcy allowed as a prior
claim. In re Lewis (1900), Dist. Mass., 91 Fed., 632; 4 A. B. R., 51; 1
N. B. N.. 556.
A stockholder's liability under state statutes is a provable claim in
bankruptcy, as it is fotmded on implied contract. Bankruptcy cotui:
may direct payment to liquidate claim or make the computation itself.
In re Rouse (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 1 A. B. R., 393; 1
N. B. N., 48.
A liability of bankrupt as endorser accruing after petition is provable
claim. In re Gerson (1901), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Acheson, J., 107 Fed.,
897; 6 A. B. R., 11.
Money in hands of trustee which but for the finding bankruptcy would
have been taxable vmder state law is still taxable. In re Sims (1902),
W. Dist. Ga., Speer, J., 9 A. B. R., 162.
Lien of landlord for rent tmder Delaware law is entitled to priority
In re MitcheU (1902), Dist. of Del., Bradford, J., 116 Fed., 87.
208 DEBTS WHICH MAYBE PROVED. [§63a.
Lanalord given prior claim for rent under Pennsylvania lavr. In re
Duble (1902), Middle Dist. Pa., Archbald, J., 117 Fed.. 794; 9 A. B. R.,
121.
Claim for trust fvmd not entitled to priority tmless the fund can be
traced to the estate of the bankrupt in the hands of the trustee. I ft re
Marsh (1902), Dist. of Conn., Piatt, J., 116 Fed., 390; 8 A. B. R., 576.
Claim for rent accruing after bankruptcy not a provable claim — notes
given therefor invalid for lack of consideration. In re Hays, Foster &
Ward (1902), W. Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 117 Fed., 879; 9 A. B. R., 144.
Labor claims allowed priority by state statute protected by this clause
and not Umited by b (4.) In re Slomka (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams,
J., 117 Fed.. 688; 9 A. B. R., 124.
Contingent claim — agreement by divorced man to pay his vriie for her
and the children's support until certain events or her remarriage or until
the children arrive at maturity is not provable. Dunbar v. Dunbar
(1901), Sup. Ct. Mass., Barber, J., 180 Mass., 170.
Claims for damages for failure to deliver ice according to contract are
provable. In re Stem (1902), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Townsend, J., 116 Fed.,
604; 8 A. B. R., 569.
An attorney's fee stipulated for in an unmatured note is not a provable
claim. In re GasUngton (1902), N. Dist. Texas, Meek, J., 115 Fed., 999;
8 A. B. R., 602.
Judgment more than ten years old not a provable claixH in North Caro-
Una. In re Farmer (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J.. 110 Fed., 703; 6
A. B. R., 19.
Demand for conversion of property not a provable debt. Specifica-
tions in this section not extended except by necessary construction.
Watertoum Carriage Co. v. Hall (1902). Sup. Ct. N. Y., Smith, J., 75 N. Y.,
App. Div., 201.
Right of landlord to proceed with a dispossessing warrant and as an
incident thereto to obtain a judgment for double rent is not affected by a
discharge of the tena.nt in bankruptcy obtained during pendency of the
dispensary proceedings as such a claim is not provable debt. Hamilton
V. McCrosky (1900), Sup. Ct. Ga., Lewis, J., 112 Ga., 651.
A sublessee of the bankrupt has no claim provable ba^ed on an action
or breach of covenant for quiet enjoyment having been evicted by the
landlord after bankruptcy. In re Pennewell (1902), C. C. A., 6th Cr.,
Severens, J., 119 Fed., 139.
Liability of bankrupt as endorser of a note not provable imless notice
of protest duly given. In re Edson (1902), Dist. W. V., Wheeler, J. ,.119
Fed., 487.
§63b.] DEBTS WHICH MAYBE PROVED. 209
Wife's contract with bankrupt husband for her services not basis for
claim. In re Kaufmann (1900), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 104 Fed.,
768; 5 A. B. R., 104.
(5) [Judgment after filing petition.] Founded upon
provable debts reduced to judgments after the filing of the
petition and before the consideration of the bankrupt's
application for a discharge, less costs incurred and interests
accrued after the filing of the petition and up to the time of
the entry of such judgments.
Judgment pending bankruptcy is provable debt less costs — In re
McBr>'de (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pximell, J., 99 Fed., 686; 3 A. B. R.,
729; 2 N. B. N., 345.
Entry of judgment between adjudication and discharge for less amount
that the debt does not forfeit the diflEerence; full claim allowed in bank,
ruptcy. In re Pinkell (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 N. B. N.,
138; 1 A. B. R., 333.
b [Unliquidated claims.] Unliquidated claims against
the bankrupt may, pursuant to application to the court,
be liquidated in such manner as it shall direct, and may
thereafter be proved and allowed against his estate.
Unliquidated claim not provable until it is first liquidated under
directions. In re Cushing( 1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Moss, R., 6 A. B. R., 22.
Claim for wages on contract for future employment basis of computa-
tion. In re Silverman Bros. (1899), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 97 Fed.,
325; 4 A. B. R., 83; 2 N. B. N.. 760.
Claim for taxes has priority and shovdd be paid as claim prior to se-
cured creditors. In re Hilberg (1901), W. Dist. Pa., Mears, R.,6A. B.
R., 714.
An action for damages by father for seduction of daughter is provable
debt and barred by discharge. In re Sullivan (1899), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 2 A. B. R., 30; 1 N. B. N., 380.
A claim not due or owing at the filing of the petition not provable.
In re Burka (1900), E. Dist Mo., Adams, J., 104 Fed., 326; 5 A. B. R., 12.
Breach of contract to marry is a provable debt. In re Fife (1901),
W. Dist. Pa., Buffington, J.. 109 Fed., 880; 6 A. B. R., 258.
An tmdischarged bankrupt can prove claim arising since his adjudica-
210 DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. [64a.
tion against another bankrupt's estate. In re Smith (1899), Hotchkiss;
R., N. Dist. N. Y., 1 A. B. R., 37.
Claim by wife is provable in state court where disability of married
woman to own property separately has been removed. In re Neiman
(1901), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 109 Fed., 113; 6 A. B. R., 329.
A creditor is one who owns a demand or claim provable in bankruptcy;
claims for tort not liquidated not provable and owner not creditor. Beers
v. Hamlin, (1900) Dist. Ore., Bellinger, J., 99 Fed., 695; 3 A. B. R., 745.
Whether a debt is provable or not turns on its status at the time of
filing the petition. In re Bingham (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 94
Fed., 796; 2 A. B. R., 223; 1 N. B. N., 351.
An unliquidated claim for tort for injttries to a person not provable
tmder section 63. In re Yates (1902), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 114
Fed., 365; 8 A. B. R., 69.
Sec. 64. Debts which have Priority.
a [Taxes.] The court shall order the trustee to pay
all taxes legally due and owing by the bankrupt to the
United States, State, county, district, or mtinicipality in
advance of the payment of dividends to creditors, and
upon filing the receipts of the proper public officers for such
payment he shall be credited with the amoimt thereof,
and in case any question arises as to the amoimt or legality
of any such tax the same shall be heard and determined
by the covut.
For analogous provisions, see Sec. 62, Act of 1800; Sec. 5, Act of 1841,
and Sec. 28, Act of 1867.
Taxes on exempt property payable by trustee out of general fund.
/nr^Tilden (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 91 Fed., 500; lA. B. R., 300.
A judgment not a lien held not a prior claim. In re Wood (1899), E.
Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 95 Fed., 946; 2 A. B. R., 695; 1 N. B. N., 430.
Taxes on exempt property to be paid out of assets. In re Baker (1899) ,
E. Dist. Texas, Hurley, R., 1 A. B. R, 526; 1 N. B. N., 202.
Taxes which are a prior secured lien on real estate will not be paid out
of the general fund, so as to benefit the mortgagee. In re Veitch (1900),
Dist. Conn., Townsend, J., 101 Fed., 251; 4 A. B. R., 112.
Taxes chargeable on life estate of bankrupt advanced by remainder-
§64b.] DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. 211
man should be refunded by trustee. In re Force (1900), Dist. Mass.,
Farmer, R., 4 A. B. R., 114.
Iowa " Mulct " is not a tax but a license, and not a preferred claim.
In re Ott (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 95 Fed., 274; 2 A. B. R., 637;
1 N. B. N., 294.
b [Order of payment.] The debts to have priority,
except as herein provided, and to be paid in full out of
bankrupt estates, and the order of payment shall be
(1) [Costs of preserving estates.] The actual and nec-
essary cost of preserving the estate subsequent to filing the
petition ;
As to costs in involuntary cases, see Gen. Ord. XXXIV.
Attorneys' fees for bankrupt's lawyer allowed only for actual services.
In re Terrill (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 100 Fed., 778; 4 A. B. R., 625.
Attorney's fee not allowed bankrupt out of assets collected by trustee,
which had been fraudulently transferred. In re O'Connell (1899), S.
Dist. N. Y., Bro'svTi, J., 98 Fed., 83; 3 A. B. R., 422; 2 N. B. N., 237.
Clerk in store has priority of payment for his claim for wages, but not
where he loaned his full wages to the bankrupt. In re Flick (1900), S.
Dist. Ohio, Thompson, J., 105 Fed., 503; 5 A. B. R., 465.
This section is a rvde of priority and does not over-ride the provisions
of sections 5 (f) and (h). In re Daniels (1901), Dist. R. I., Brown, J.,
110 Fed., 745; 6 A. B. R., 699.
(2) [Filing fees — Expense of creditors.] The filing
fees paid by creditors in involuntary cases, *and, where
property of the bankrupt, transferred or concealed by
him either before or after the filing of the petition, shall
have been recovered for the benefit of the estate of the
bankrupt by the efforts and at the expense of one or more
creditors, the reasonable expenses of such recovery ;*
Ab amended by Act of 1903. See Amendment, page , pos<. New matter between
stars.
As to filing fees, see Sec. 51a.
(3) [Costs of administration.] The cost of administra-
tion, including the fees and mileage payable to witnesses
212 DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. [§64b.
as now or hereafter provided by the laws of the United
States, and one reasonable attorney's fee, for the profes-
sional services actually rendered, irrespective of the number
of attorneys employed, to the petitioning creditors in
involimtary cases, to the bankrupt in involuntary cases
while performing the duties herein prescribed, and to
the bankrupt in volutary cases, as the court may allow ;
Fee of bankrupt's attorney of $25 allowed for preparing schedules.
In re Carolina Cooperage Co. (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 96 Fed.,
950; 3 A. B. R., 154; 2 N. B. N., 23.
The services of the bankrupt attorney for which allowance should be
made, are not necessarily of direct benefit to the estate. In re Kross
(1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 96 Fed., 816; 3 A. B. R., 187; 1 N. B.
N., 566.
Fees allowed attorney of creditors who opposed claims of other credi-
tors, trustee refusing to act. In re Little River Ltunber Co, (1900) , W
Dist. Ark. Rogers, J., 101 Fed., 558; 3 A. B. R., 682; 1 N. B. N., 306.
Notice to creditors not essential before allowing fees to counsel for
bankrupt or trustee. In re Stotts (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 93
Fed.. 438; 1 A. B. R., 641; 1 N. B. N., 326.
The bankrupt's attorney may be allowed fees in involuntary cases for
services for drawing schedules, making copies of the same and expenses
of attending before referee, etc. In re Michel (1899), E. Dist. Wis.,
Jones, R., 1 A. B. R., 665; 1 N. B. N., 265.
Where mortgaged chattels are sold by trustee free from liens and
amotmt realized not enough to satisfy mortgage debt, the fees of bank-
rupt's attorney cannot be allowed. In re Frick (1899), N. Dist. Ohio,
Fay, R., 1 A. B. R., 719; 1 N. B. N., 214.
Seventy-five dollars a reasonable fee for bankrupt's attorney; no
special benefit accruing to the trustee — after trustee appointed creditors,
attorney not allowed fees. In re Silberman & Schoor (1899), S. Dist.
N. Y., Brown J., 97 Fed., 325; 3 A. B. R., 227; 2 N. B. N., 18.
Allowance of fee for bankrupt's attorney not forfeited by subsequent
misconduct of the bankrupt. In re Mayer (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman,
J., 101 Fed., 227; 4 A. B. R., 238; 2 N. B. N., 257.
Services of attorney must be such as inure to the benefit of the estate
and not personally to the bankrupt. In re Mayer (1900), E. Dist. Wis.,
Seaman, J., 101 Fed., 227; 4 A. B. R., 238; 2 N. B. N., 257.
Twenty- five dollars per day for examination and fifty dollars for pre-
§64b.] DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. Sl3
paring schedules allowed attorney for bankrupt. In re Mayer (1900),
E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 101 Fed., 227; 4 A. B. R., 238; 2 N. B. N., 257.
Attorney for receiver who is also attorney for creditors of bankinipt
cannot be allowed for services. In re Kelly Dry Goods Co. (1900), E.
Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 747; 4 A. B. R., 528.
Rent incurred by the trustee is an expense of administration and
entitled to priority. In re Grimes (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96
Fed., 529; 2 A. B. R., 730; 1 N. B. N., 426.
In involtmtary cases attorneys' fees may be allowed the bankrupt's
attorney for services rendered the bankrupt while performing statutory
duties — no allowance for preparing schedules and petition — allowance
entirely within the jurisdiction of the court. In re Averill (1899), N.
Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 1 N. B. N., 544.
On sale of mortgaged property by a trustee on request of mortgagee,
attorney fee not allowed as on foreclosure. In re Roche (1900), C. C.
A., 5th Cir., 101 Fed., 956; 4 A. B. R., 369.
Attorney's fee allowed for filing petition for an injunction but not for
sending notices, attending meetings and contesting claims, nor for pro-
curing bids. In re Harrison Mer. Co. (1899), Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 95
Fed., 123; 2 A. B. R., 419; 1 N. B. N., 382.
In a voluntary proceeding attorney's services are a general debt to be
proved as other debts, but where services preserve the estate they are
a prior claim. In re Beck (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 92 Fed., 889;
1 A. B. R., 535; 1 N. B. N., 338.
The fee allowed classed b-3 is prior lien of landlord for rent. In re
Duncan (1899), N. Dist. Tex., Meek, J., 2 A. B. R., 321; 1 N. B. N., 339
In general in assignment preceding bankruptcy no allowance made
assignee for services — custodian's fee allowable. In re Peter Paul Book
Co. (1900), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 104 Fed., 786; 5 A. B. R., 105.
No fee allowed attorney for creditor in a voluntary case. The fee for
attorney of bankrupt must be determined by the size of the estate. In re
Smith (1901), W. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 108 Fed., 39; 5 A. B. R., 559.
Order of priority in distribution is to be governed by equity rules in
contest between claimants. In re Bvurke (1901), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington,
ington, R., 6 A. B. R., 502.
Fees for bankrupt's attorney for services in procuring discharge not
allowable. In re Bnmdin (1901), Dist. Minn., Lochren, J., 112 Fed.,
306; 7 A. B. R., 296.
Expenses of referee including clerk hire, fall within this section. In re
Tebo (1900), Dist. W. Va., Jackson J.. 101 Fed., 419; 4 A. B. R., 235.
214 DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. [§64b.
Allowance of covinsel fees rests largley within the discretion of referee,
Idem.
Costs of administration take precedence of specific liens. Idem.
Only one fee allowed for bankrupt's attorney, although indi\'idual
partners are represented by separate counsel. In re Eschwege & Cohn
(1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Willis, R., 8 A. B. R., 282.
Attorney's fee for bankrupt — discretionary to delay allowance of, await-
ing evidence as to value of. In re Dreebin (1900), Dist. Tex., Meek., J.,
101 Fed., 110; 4 A. B. R., 146.
Costs of attachment incurred before bankruptcy allowed as a prior
claim. In re Lewis (1900), Dist. Mass., Lowell., J. 99 Fed., 935; 4 A. B.
R., 51; 1 N. B. N., 556.
Allowance of attorney's fees for petitioning creditor reduced from
$12,500 to $2,000. In re Curtis (1900), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J.,
100 Fed., 784; 4 A. B. R., 17.
Reasonableness of attorney's fees in the discretion of the court gov-
erned by the circiunstances of the case. In re Burrus (1899) , Dist. W. Va.
Jackson J., 97 Fed., 926; 3 A. B. R., 296.
(4) [Employes' wages.] Wages due to workmen, clerks,
or servants which have been earned within three months
before the date of the commencement of proceedings,
not to exceed three htmdred dollars to each claimant ; and
Salary of a managing director is not a preferred claim. In re Grabbs-
Wiley Grocery Co. (1899), Dist. Mo., Rathbun, R., 2 A. B. R., 442; 1
N. B. N., 381.
Creditors must prove their claims before they can petition for prefer-
ence. In re Ogles, W. Dist. Tenn., Walker, R., 2 A. B. R., 514; 1
N. B. N., 400.
Wages blended with contract emp loying capital and machinery not a
prior claim. In re Rose (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Hunter, R., 1 A. B. R.
68; 1 N. B. N., 212.
Wages earned after filing the petition in bankruptcy entitled to prior-
ity under clause B(4). In re Gerson (1899), E. Dist. Penn., Mason, R.,
1 A. B. R.. 251; 1 N. B. N., 1 90.
The limitation as to time and amount must prevail. B (5) held to re-
late to other and different debts. In re Rouse Hazard & Co. (1899),
C. C. A., 7th Circuit, 91 Fed., 96; 1 A. B. R., 234; 1. B. N., 75.
traveling salesman does not come under this clause. In re Seaman
§64b.] DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. 215
Co. (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans. J., 97 Fed., 547; 3 A. B. R., 202; 2 N. B.
N., 58.
Traveling salesman's wage not entitled to priority. In re Greenewald
& Co. (1900), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J.. 99 Fed., 705; 3 A. B. R.,
696; 2 N. B. N., 791.
Assignee of wage claim not entitled to priority. In re Westlund,
1899) Dist. Minn., Lochren, J., 99 Fed., 399; 3 A. B. R., 646.
Where mortgaged chattels are ordered sold free from lien of mort-
gagee and amount realized is not enough to satisfy the mortgage debt,
wages will not be paid out of proceeds. In re Frick (1899), N. Dist. O.
Fay. R.. 1 A. B. R., 719; 1 N. B. N.. 214.
Priority of a wage claim not lost by merging it in a judgment. In re
Anson (1900), N. Dist. Cal., DeHaven, J., 101 Fed., 698; 4 A. B, R., 231;
2 N. B. N.. 567.
Labor claims prior to specific liens. In re Teho, (1900), Dist. W. Va.,
Jackson, J., 101 Fed., 419; 4 A. B R., 235.
Wage claims assigned after bankruptcy have priority in assignee's
hands. In re Campbell (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 686;
4 A. B. R., 535.
Commissions due as wages not entitled to priority. In re Mayer
(1900), Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 101 Fed.. 227; 4 A. B. R., 119; 2 N. B. N.,
257.
President of bankrupt corporation cannot claim salary as prior claim.
In re Carolina Cooperage Co. (1899), E. Dist. N. Car., Pximell, J., 96 Fed.
950; 3 A. B. R., 154; 2 N. B. N., 23.
Wage claims assigned after bankruptcy have priority in assignee's
hands. In re Campbell (1900), E. Dist. Wis.. Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 686;
4 A. B. R.. 535.
Priority given to traveling salesman in Washington under provision
of state law. In re Lawlor (1901), Dist. Wash., Hanford, J., 110 Fed.,
135; 6 A. B. R., 184.
Sale by trustee free and clear of liens will require the trustee to pay
tax liens. In re Keller (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 110 Fed., 348;
6 A. B. R., 351.
Wage claim comes tinder clause b. 4, not under clause b. 5. In re
Shaw (1901), E. Dist. Penn. McPherson, J., 109 Fed., 780; 6 A. B. R.,
501.
Contract of employment for a term unexpired at the time of bank-
ruptcy does not entitle employe to prove claim for the balance of the
unexpired term. In re Silverman Bros, (1899), West Dist. Mo., Critten-
den, R., 2 A. B. R., 15; 1 N. B. N., 286.
216 DEBTS WHICH HAVE PRIORITY. [§64b.
(5) [Debts to persons entitled to priority.] Debts owing
to any person who by the laws of the States or the United
States is entitled to priority.
Debts due the United States prior, Sec, 3,466 Rev. St. of U. S.
Debts created by misappropriation not entitled to priority. Credi-
tors who are entitled to priority lose their privilege by suffering the es-
tate to be distributed without protest. Claflin, etc. Co. v. Eason, Trus-
tee, (1899), E. Dist. Tex., White, R., 2 A. B. R.. 263; 1 N. B. N., 360.
A claim due a county for wages of its convicts is provable and being
a preferred claim under the State Law, is so in bankruptcy. In re Wright,
et al. (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 95 Fed., 807; 2 A. B. R., 592; 1 N.
B. N., 428.
By Penn. law landlord's lien is a prior claim even for future rent. In
re Goldstein (1899), W. Dist. Penn., Van Wormer, R.; 2 A. B. R., 603;
1 N. B. N., 422.
Judgments for fines on criminal proceedings recovered by the State
are not preferred claims. In re Alderson (1900), Dist. W. Va., J^kson,
J., 98 Fed., 588; 3 A. B. R., 544.
Bankrupt act recognizes liens as fixed by state law — limitation of time
for filing such claims governed by the U. S. law. In re Fall City Shirt
Mfg. Co. (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 98 Fed., 592; 3 A. B. R., 437; 1 N.
B. N., 565.
Commissions are payable on claims having priority. In re Gerson
(1900), E. Dist. Penn., Mason, R.; 4 A. B. R., 480; 2 N. B. N., 860.
No priority of claim allowed where trust funds were commingled by
bankrupt so as identity is lost. idem.
A broker borrowed money on collateral left with him, which was sold
by his creditor becoming bankrupt. No priority of claim allowed the
depositor. In re Swift (1901) , Dist. Mass., Olmstead, R. ; 5 A. B. R., 232.
Claim for rent given priority under Penn. statutes. Applies only to
rent accruing prior to date of adjudication. Reasonable rent during
trustee's occupancy allowed. In re Cronson (1899), W. Dist. Penn.,
1 N. B. N., 474.
Debt due a county for convict labor a preferred claim. In re Wor-
cester County (1900), C. C. A., First Cir., Putnam, J., 102 Fed., 808; 4
A. B. R., 496.
Lien for laborer's wages secvu-ed by Ohio statute preserved in bank-
ruptcy. In re Coe-Powers & Co. et al. (1901), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day
J., 109 Fed., 550; 6 A. B. R., 1.
§65 a.] DECLARATION AND PAYMENT OF DIVIDENDS. 2l7
Wage claims may be given preference tmder this clause or State law
may give and control. In re Lawlor (1901), Dist. Wash., Hanford, J.,
6, 110 Fed., 135; 6 A. B. R., 184.
Where the state law gives debt due by guardian a priority it will be
respected as such in bankruptcy. In re Crow (1902), W. Dist. Ky.,
Dean, R.; 7 A. B. R., 545.
Insolvency law in State in force for ptirpose of determining priority.
In re Daniels (1901), Dist. R. I., Brown, J., 110 Fed., 745; 6 A. B. R., 699.
Lien claims tmder Va. law for supplies discussed.
Insurance by mortgagor does not iniire to benefit mortgagee or lienor
imless by contract. In re West Norfolk Lvmiber Co. (1902), East Dist.
Va., Waddill, J., 112 Fed., 759; 7 A. B. R., 648.
(c) [After composition set aside or discharge revoked.]
In the event of the confirmation of a composition being set
aside, or a discharge revoked, the property acquired by the
bankrupt in addition to his estate at the time the compo-
sition was confirmed or the adjudication was made shall
be applied to the payment in full of the claims of creditors
for property sold to him on credit, in good faith, while
such composition or discharge was in force, and the residue
if any, shall be applied to the payment of the debts which
were owing at the time of the adjudication.
As to revocation of discharge see ante Sec. 15; as to setting aside a com-
position see ante Sec. 13, also Sec. 12. As to when compositions may
be offered.
For analogoiis provisions of Act of 1800, see 29 and 30 of that act; of
Act of 1841, see Sec. 10 of that act; also Sees. 27 and 28 of Act of 1867.
Sec. 65. Declaration and Payment of Dividends.
a [On allowed claims.] Dividends of an equal per cen-
ttim shall be declared and paid on all allowed claims, ex-
cept such as have priority or are secured.
See Sec. 64 and note as to debts which have priority.
Discussion of word "dividend" in re Fielding (1899), W. Dist. Mo.,
Phillips. J., 96 Fed., 800; 3 A. B. R., 135; 2 N. B. N., 735.
218 DECLARATION AND PAYMENT OF DIVIDENDS. [§65bc.
b [First and subsequent dividends.] The first dividend
shall be declared within thirty days after the adjudication,
if the money of the estate in excess of the amount neces-
sary to pay the debts which have priority and such claims
as have not been, but probably will be, allowed equals five
per centum or more of such allowed claims. Dividends
subsequent to the first shall be declared upon like terms as
the first and as often as the amount shall equal ten per
centum or more and upon closing the estate. Dividends
may be declared oftener and in smaller proportions if the
judge shall so order : * Provided, That the first dividend shall
not include more than fifty per centum of the money of the
estate in excess of the amount necessary to pay the debts
which have priority and such claims as probably will be al-
lowed: And provided further, That the final dividend
shall not be declared within three months after the first
dividend shall be declared.*
As amended by act of 1903. See amendment page Post. New matter found between
stars.
Commissions may be paid referees and trustees on money paid out on,
first, unsecured debts; second, on commissions; third, on the surplus to
the bankrupt after all creditors are paid in ftill, but not on payments on
claims entitled to priority; if secured creditor submits his security to the
bankruptcy court and receives his due, commission should be allowed on
amount paid. In re Sabine (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.,1A.
B. R., 322; 1 N. B. N., 312.
The referee should hold back from the amoimt of the first dividend
enough to cover expenses of administration and to cover such claims as
he has intimation will probably be presented and allowed. Attorneys
have a right to priority out of any funds that may be in the hands of
trustee at the time claim is allowed. In re Scott (1899), E. Dist. Tex.,
Meek, J., 96 Fed., 607; 2 A. B. R., 324; 1 N. B. N., 353.
Dividend defined. In re Barber (1899), Dist. Minn., Lochren, J.,
97 Fed., 517; 3 A. B. R., 306; 1 N. B. N., 559.
c [Claims filed subsequent to payment of dividends.]
The rights of creditors who have received dividends, or in
whose favor final dividends have been declared, shall not be
§66ab.] UNCLAIMED DIVIDENDS. 219
affected by the proof and allowance of claims subsequent
to the date of such payment or declarations of dividends ;
but the creditors proving and securing the allowance of
such claims shall be paid dividends equal in amount to those
already received by the other creditors if the estate equals
so much before such other creditors are paid any further
dividends.
Money ready for distribution should be paid to creditors who have filed
their claims. No money should be retained for schedule creditors who
have not filed their claims. In re Stein (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.,
94 Fed., 124; 1 A. B. R., 662; 1 N. B. N., 339.
d [When person adjudged bankrupt without the United
States.] Whenever a person shall have been adjudged a
bankrupt by a court without the United States and also by
a court of bankruptcy, creditors residing within the United
States shall first be paid a dividend equal to that received
in the court without the United States by other creditors
before creditors who have received a dividend in such courts
shall be paid any amounts.
e [Limit to amount collectable by claimant.] A claimant
shall not be entitled to collect from a bankrupt estate any
greater amount than shall accrue pursuant to the provis-
ions of this Act.
Sec. 66. Unclaimed Dividends.
a [Payment into court.] Dividends which remain un-
claimed for six months after the final dividend has been
declared shall be paid by the trustee into court.
b [Distribution after one year.] Dividends remaining
unclaimed for one year shall, under the direction of the
court, be distributed to the creditors whose claims have
been allowed but not paid in full, and after such claims
have been paid in full the balance shall be paid to the bank-
220 LIENS. [§6?a.
rupt : Provided, That in case unclaimed dividends belong
to minors such minors may have one year after arriving at
majority to claim such dividends.
Sec. 67. Liens.
a [Claims which are not valid liens.] Claims which for
want of record or for other reasons would not have been
valid liens as against the claims of the creditors of the
bankrupt shall not be liens against his estate.
State law giving vendor of property the right to subject the same tu
levy for purchase money gives no lien superior to the trustee. In re
Wilkes, E. Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 7 A. B. R., 574.
No lien where purchase price of goods not secured by chattel mortgage.
In re Tatem, Mann & Co., E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 6 A. B. R., 426.
Unrecorded chattel mcrtgage avoided as to trustee. In re Leigh
Bros. Dist. Colo., Harrison, R., 2 A. B. R., 606; 1 N. B. N., 425.
An unrecorded chattel mortgage is void as to creditors who became
such between making and the filing of the same. Znr^Loud (1899), E,
Dist. Mich., Davock, R., 1 N. B. N., 502.
A mortgage executed more than four months prior to bankruptcy
proceedings, but recorded in less than four months, is nevertheless a valid
lien. In r^ Wright (1899) , N. Dist. Ga., Newman,]., 96 Fed., 187; 2 A.
B. R., 364; 1 N. B. N., 381.
Lien of a mechanic enforced provided he has complied with the statu-
tory conditions. In re Kirby-Dennis Co., (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir.,
Jenkins, J., 95 Fed., 116; 2 A. B. R., 402; 1 N. B. N., 399.
A lien not perfected at the time of proceedings in bankruptcy is lost —
a tnistee does not represent lien claimants as against vmsecured creditors.
Goldman, Beckman & Co. v. Smith (1899), Dist. of Ky., Durett, R., 2
A. B. R.. 104; 1 N. B. N, 291.
An unrecorded chattel mortgage avoided as to trustee. In re Leigh
Bros. (1899), Dist. Colo., Harrison, R., 96 Fed., 806, 2 A. B. R., 606; 1
N. B. N., 526.
This section and subdivisions c and f refers to existing liens, not
those merged in judgment. Property sold and proceeds distributed
before power of bankruptcy court invoked. Botts v. Hammond (1900),
C. C. A., 4th Cir., Simonton, J., 99 Fed., 916; 3 A. B. R., 775.
Mortgage hens — facts establishing fraud. In re Steininger Mercan-
tile Co. (1900), C. C. A., 5th Circt., Pardee, J., 107 Fed., 669; 6 A. B. R., 68.
§67a.] LIENS. 22j
Purchaser having notice of insolvency of bankrupt not a bona fide
purchaser within the meaning of the act. Brown v. Case, Sup. Jud. Ct.,
Mass., Lathrop, J., 61 N. E., 279; 6 A. B. R., 744.
Pledge without delivering or recording valid in Georgia and good
against trustee — trustee takes property as the innocent piu-chaser.
Chattanooga Nat. Bank v. Rome Iron Co. (1900) Cir. Ct., Nor. Dist. Ga.
Newman, J., 102 Fed., 755; 4 A. B. R., 441.
A chattel mortgage which for want of re cording or refiling became
invalid as to creditors is so invalid only as to judgment creditors, and
good as against general creditors represented by the trustee. In re
New York Economical Printing Co. (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace,
J., 110 Fed., 514; 6 A. B. R., 615.
Trustee as against unrecorded conditional sale is in the position of a
judgment creditor. Logan v. Nebraska Moline Plow Co (1902) , Sup. Ct.
Neb., Day, J., 92 N. W., 129.
Chattel mortgage given in good faith cannot be questioned by the
trustee. In re Standard Laimdrj- Co. (1902), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Hawley,
J., 116 Fed., 476; 8 A. B. R., 538.
Conditional sale void under state law as to creditors is void as to
trustee — all creditors of the bankrupt have the status through the trustee
of attaching creditors, as well in voluntary as in involuntary cases. In re
Fraizer (1902), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 9 A. B. R., 21.
A conditional sale not allowed as a preferred claim where it appears
that the claimant delivered goods to the bankrupt under contract for re-
taining title, but the circumstances showed it to be a conditional sale.
Tn re Robinson (1902), W. Dist. Mo., Phillips, J., 118 Fed., 471; 9 A. B.
R., 180.
Lien of chattel mortgage in Wisconsin which was not filed for record
until after a general assignment is lost as to the trustee in bankruptcy
subsequently appointed — question of rights of trustee generally to assail
mortgage defective as to creditors not determined. In re Yi. G. Andrae
Co. (1902), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 9 A. B. R., 135.
Unrecorded mechanic's lien not invalid where security given to secure
former advances. Duplan Silk Co v. Spencer (1902), C. C. A., 3rd Cir.,
Gray, J., 115 Fed., 689; 8 A. B. R., 367.
Trustee entitled to be substituted to rights of attachment creditors as
party plaintiff. Patten v. Corley (1902), Sup. Ct. N. V., Bartlett, J., 8
A. B. R., 482.
Trustee may be subrogated to rights of a creditor having judgment
against bankrupt on note containing waiver of personal property exemp-
tion. In re W. G. Jackson (1902), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 116 Fed.,
46; 8 A. B. R., 594.
222 - LIENS. [§67 be.
This section does not extend to a judgment or decree enforcing a pre*
existing lien, but is confined to judgments creating liens. Metcalf v.
Barker (1902), Sup. Ct. of U. S., Fuller, J., 9 A. B. R., 36.
Sale on fraudulent representations as to solvency may be disafBnned
and goods recovered for trustee. In re Hamilton Furniture 8c Carpet
Co. (1902), Pist. of Ind., Baker, J., 9 A. B. R., 65.
A deed by a bankrupt to his mother who had no knowledge of his in-
solvency is not affected by the bankruptcy act. Craft v. Morrow (1901),
Penn. County Court, Taylor, J., 25 Pa., Co., C. 487.
A lien acquired by a creditor's bill on real estate allowed to stand-
Arnold v. Trevianns (1903), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Jenks, J., 79 N. Y. Supp.,
732.
Trustee takes property subject to existing liens —effect of mechanic's
liens. South End Improvement Co. v. Harden (1902), Stip. Ct. N. J. (Eq.),
Reed, J., 52 Atl.. 1127.
h [Trustee subrogated to rights of creditors.] When-
ever a creditor is prevented from enforcing his rights as
against a lien created, or attempted to be created, by
his debtor, who afterwards becomes a bankrupt, the trustee
of the estate of such bankrupt shall be subrogated to and
may enforce such rights of such creditor for the benefit
of the estate.
Creditor's bill in state court long pending against bankrupt is not
abated by bankruptcy. Trustee may intervene and pursue the remedy
for benefit of general or secured creditors. Taylor v. Taylor et al (1900) ,
N. J. Chancery, Reed, J., 45 Atl., 440; 4 A. B. R., 211.
Section 67 f applies to both voluntary and involuntary cases. In re;
Vaughan (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 560; 3 A. B. R., 362.
2 N. B. N., 101.
This section covers voluntary as well involuntary bankruptcies
In re Richards (1899), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 96 Fed., 935;
3 A. B. R., 145; 2 N. B. N., 38.
In conditional sale title goes to the trustee — contract of sale that
title remain in the vendor till paid is conditional. In re Rowland (1901) ,
N. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 109 Fed., 869; 6 A. B. R., 495.
c [Certain liens dissolved.] A lien created by or ob-
tained in or pursuant to any suit or proceeding at law
or in equity, including an attachment upon mesne process
§67c.] LIENS. 223
or a judgment by confession, which was begiin against
a person within four months before the fiHng of a petition
in bankruptcy by or against such person shall be dissolved
by the adjudication of such person to be a bankrupt if
(1) [Defendant insolvent.] It appears that said lien
was obtained and permitted while the defendant was
insolvent and that its existence and enforcement will
work a preference, or
"Insolvency" defined. Sec. 1 (15). Preference defined Sec. 60 a.
Knowledge of insolvency not necessary to be shown. In re Burros
(1899), W. Dist. Va., Jackson, J., 97 Fed., 926; 3 A. B. R., 296.
Proceeds of execution in the hands of the sheriff for levy inside of
four months goes to the trustee. In re Tenney, S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 97 Fed., 554; 3 A. B. R., 353; 2 N. B. N., 140.
Lien acquired more than four months prior not affected by bank-
ruptcy proceedings. In re Dunavant (1899), E. Dist. N. C, 96 Fed.,
542; 3 A. B. R., 41; 1 N. B. N., 542.
Mechanic's lien in N. Y. obtained for antecedent debt is dissolved
by petition filed within four months after notice of lien filed. In re
EmsHe & Son (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 102 Fed., 291; 3 A. B. R.,
516; 2 N. B. N., 324.
The time of the entry of the judgment, not the time of giving the
note counted as to the validity of the lien. In re Richards] (1890), C. C.
A., 7th Cir., Jenkins, J., 96 Fed., 935; 3 A. B. R., 145;2|N. B. N., 38.
Mortgage of property shortly before bankruptcy avoided. In re
McLam (1899), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 97 Fed., 922; 3 A. B. R., 245.
(2) [Knowledge of Insolvency.] The party or parties
to be benefited thereby had reasonable cause to believe
the defendant was insolvent and in contemplation of
bankruptcy, or
Costs and disbixrsements of an attachment suit pending against the
bankrupt are not collectable out of the bankrupt's estate. In re Yotmg
(1899), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 96 Fed., 606; 2 A . B. R., 673; 1 N. B.
N. 428.
(3) [Fraud — trustee subrogated.] That such lien was
sought and permitted in fraud of the provisions of this
224 LIENS. [§67d.
Act ; or if the dissolution of such lien would militate against
the best interests of the estate of such person the same
shall not be dissolved, but the trustee of the estate of such
person, for the benefit of the estate, shall be subrogated
to the rights of the holder of such lien and empowered
to perfect and enforce the same in his name as trustee
with like force and effect as such holder might have done
had not bankruptcy proceedings intervened.
Judgments obtained preferentially will be set aside and the sheriff
be required to turn over to trustee all the proceeds of execution thereunder.
Such creditors may, however, prove their claims as general creditors.
In re Richard (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 94 Fed., 633; 2 A. B. R.,
506; 1 N. B. N., 487.
Trustee subrogated to lien of a tt aching creditors and District Court
held jurisdiction. Inre Hammond (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 98 Fed..
845; 3 A. B. R., 466.
d [Liens given in good faith.] Liens given or accepted
in good faith and not in contemplation of or in fraud upon
this Act, and for a present consideration, which have
been recorded according to law, if record thereof was
necessary in order to impart notice, shall not be affected
by this Act.
See notes to e and f , -post.
Lien of mortgage creditor after foreclosure does not attach to the rents
received by the trustee pending redemption, nor should the trustee be
reqtdred to pay the taxes. In re HoUenfeltz (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 94 Fed., 629; 2 A. B. R., 499; 1 N. B. N., 503.
Statutory liens of landlord may be lost by mixing the claim therefor,
with other claims for which no lien is given. In re Wolf (1899), N
Dist. la., Shiras, J., 98 Fed., 74; 3 A. B. R., 558; 2 N. B. N., 908.
Chattel mortgage imder Ohio law unrecorded becomes valid by re-
cording against creditors who have not acquired liens in the interval. In
re Schmitt, Dist. Ohio, Wing, J., 6 A. B. R., 150.
Burden of proof of showing lien is on the creditor making the claim.
In re Wood (1899), E. Dist. N, C, Pumell, J.. 95 Fed., 946; 2 A. B. R.,
695; 1 N. B. N., 430.
Bankruptcy court has no power to issue injvmction restraining mortga- .
§67d.J LIENS. 225
gees from foreclosing liens — the liens to attach to the proceeds of the
property sold in bankruptcy. In re Pittlekow (1899), E. Dist. Wis,,
Seaman, J., 92 Fed., 901; 1 A. B. R., 472; 1 N. B. N., 234.
Court of bankruptcy may order property sold divested of all liens, the
liens to be transferred to the proceeds. In re Worland (1899), N. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 92 Fed., 893; 1 A. B. R., 450; 1 N. B. N., 316.
Lien of attachment obtained within four months of filing a petition
is annulled by proceedings in bankruptcy even if suit was begun more
than fotir months prior to proceedings. In re Friedman (1899), S.
Dist. N. Y., Holt, R.; 1 A. B. R., 510; 1 N. B. N., 208.
District cotut will extend equity powers to enforce state liens — wages
preferred by state law superior to landlord's lien. In re Byrne & Co.
(1899), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 97 Fed., 762; 3 A. B. R., 268; 2 N. B. N.,
246.
Landlord has no lien for overdue rent tinder Penn. statute. In re
Rupple (1899), W. Dist. Penn., Buffington, J., 97 Fed., 778; 3 A. B. R.,
233; 2 N. B. N., 88.
Fictitious sales for increasing the business of a corporation are con-
trary to public policy and parties thereto cannot nlaintain liens thereon
in bankruptcy. In re Fort Wayne Electric Corp. (1899), Dist. Ind.,
Baker, J., 95 Fed., 264; 2 A. B. R., 503; 1 N. B. N., 356.
Bankruptcy does not affect liens given by local law. In re Oconee
Milling Co. (1901), C. C. A., 5th Cir., 109 Fed., 866; 6 A. B. R., 475.,
Where there is no value to the estate for creditors from the proceed-
ings liens will not be adjudicated in bankruptcy. In re Gibbs (1901),
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., X09 Fed., 627; 6 A. B. R., 485.
Withholding chattel mortgage from record is not per se proof of fraud
and mortgage is good from date of record. In re Shirley (1901), C. C.
A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 112 Fed., 801; 7 A. B. R., 299.
If a transferee has reasonable cause to believe that a preference was
intended by making the transfer it will be void. In re Jacobs (1899).
W. Dist. La., Jones, R., 99 Fed., 539; 1 A. B. R., 518; 1 N. B. N., 183.
Idem.
Section 60 and 67 e. of the Act construed and compared. Idem.
Transferee has reasonable cause to suspect a preference when slight-
est inquiry wovdd inform him as to the facts. Idem.
Tailor who has taken goods from the bankrupt to make up on the
piece plan, held to have a lien on the goods as against the trustee. In re
Lowensohn (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 100 Fed., 776; 4 A. B. R.,
79; 2 N. B. N.. 71.
226 LIENS. [§67(1.
Chattel mortgage void for tincertainty which describes stock of mer-
chandise merely as such. Stroud v. Mc Daniel (1901), C. C. A., 4th Cir.,
Puniell, J., 106 Fed., 493; 5 A. B. R., 695.
Costs of administration and wage claims prior to specific liens. In re
Tebo (1900), Dist. W. Va.. Jackson, J., 101 Fed., 419; 4 A. B. R., 235.
Lien relinquished by creditor of a bankrupt under mistake of law
or fact may be restored if without loss to the estate. In re Swift (1900) ,
Dist. Mass., LoweU, J., 5 A. B. R, 232.
The rights of a mortgagee to foreclose a chattel mortgage are not
affected by bankruptcy of mortgagor. Harvey v. Smith (1901), Supreme
Ct., Mass., Knowlton, J., 7 A. B. R., 497.
Lien on property set aside as exempt must be adjudicated in other,
courts. 7«rgLittle(1901),N. Dist.Ia.,Shiras,J., llOFed., 621; 6A. B.
R., 681.
Renewal of chattel mortgage within four months period is not for
past consideration, and good in the absence of other intervening liens.
In re Shepherd (1901), N. Dist. lU., Eastman, R., 6 A. B. R., 725.
To rescind sale on ground of fraud there must be some known false
misrepresentation on which seller of goods relied. In re Roalswick (1901) ,
Dist. Mont., Knowles, J., 110 Fed., 639; 6 A. B. R., 752.
Lien given by state law on clothing sold by bankrupt is lost by neglect
to have the same sold separately — it is no lien on the general funds. In re
Klopholtz & Brien (1902), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 113 Fed., 1002;
7 A. B. R.,703.
Mortgage for present consideration is valid where mortgage was in
good faith although the bankrupt used proceeds of loan to make prefer-
ences. In re Soudans Mfg. Co. (1902), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Seaman, J., 113
Fed., 804; 8 A. B. R, 45.
Discharge in bankruptcy does not affect liens on exempt property.
Evans v. Rounsaville, Supreme Ct., Ga., Little, J., 8 A. B. R., 236; Smith
V. Zachry (1902), Sup. Ct., Ga., Little, J., 8 A. B. R., 240.
Lien of mortgage not affected by bankruptcy xmless creditor proves his
claim. Reed v. Equitable Trust Co. (1902), Sup. Ct., Ga., Lxmipkin, J.,
Little, J., 8 A. B.R., 242.
Pledge without delivery or recording valid in Georgia, good against
tnistee — trustee takes property as the debtor had, subject to valid liens,
not as an innocent purchaser. Bank v. Rome Iron Co. (1900), N. Dist.
Ga., Newman, J., 4 A. B. R., 441.
Mortgaged property may be sold free of liens and the mortgage tested
§is to its jurisdiction in bankruptcy to determine — distinction between
§67e.] LIENS. 227
Bardes v. Bank case. In re Kellogg (1902), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J.,
112 Fed., 52; 7 A. B. R., 623.
e [Conveyances within four months — when void..] That
all conveyances, transfers, assignments, or incumbrances of
his property, or any part thereof, made or given by a person
adjudged a bankrupt imder the provisions of this Act subse-
quent to the passage of this Act and within four months
prior to the filing of the petition, with the intent and pur-
pose on his part to hinder, delay, or defraud his creditors,
or any of them, shall be null and void as against the creditors
of such debtor, except as to purchasers in good faith and for
a present fair consideration ; and all property of the debtor
conveyed, transferred, assigned, orencumbered as aforesaid
shall, if he be adjudged a bankrupt, and the same is not ex-
empt from execution and liability for debts by the law of
his domicile, be and remain a part of the assets and estate
of the bankrupt and shall pass to his said trustee, whose duty
it shall be to recover and reclaim the same by legal pro-
ceedings or otherwise for the benefit of the creditors. And
all conveyances, transfers, or inciimbrances of his property
made by a debtor at any time within four months prior to
the filing of the petition against him, and while insolvent,
which are held null and void as against the creditors of such
debtor by the laws of the State, Territory, or District in
which such property is situate, shall be deemed null and void
under this Act against the creditors of such debtor if he be
adjudged a bankrupt, and such property shall pass to the
assignee (trustee) and be by him reclaimed and recovered
for the benefit of the creditors of the bankrupt.
*For the purpose of such recovery any court of bank-
ruptcy as hereinbefore defined, and any state court which
would have had jurisdiction if bankruptcy had not inter-
vened shall have concurrent jurisdiction.
As amended by Act of 1903, see amendment, page post.
228 LIENS. [§67e.
New and additional matter found between stars.
As to jurisdiction of suits, see Sec. 11 and Sec. 23b ante.
As to assignment, see Sec. 3 (4).
General assignment is act of bankruptcy and voidable. In re Gray
(1900), N. Y. Sup. Ct., Barrett, J., 3 A. B. R., 647.
Section 67 e and Section 70 construed and compared. In re Gray (1900) ,
N. Y. Sup. Ct., Barrett, J., 3 A. B. R., 647.
A preference is created by the pledge of property by the bankrupt
shortly before bankruptcy, although the agreement therefor was more
than four months antecedent to the filing of the petition. In re Sheridan
(1899), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 98 Fed., 406; 3 A. B. R., 554.
Sureties on appeal bond who receive mortgages to repay them for
disbursements made on the defalcation of the bankrupt occupy no
superior equitable position. In re Richards (1899), W. Dist. Wis.,
Bunn, J., 95 Fed., 258; 2 A. B. R., 518.
Intent of the mortgagee immaterial, and if for post debt within the
prohibited period, trustee may recover. Cullinane v. State Bank of Wa-
verley (1902), Sup. Ct. Iowa, Bishop, J.; 91 N. W., 783.
Claimants to property seized under an attachment within four months
of the debtor's adjudication as a bankrupt, cannot, on mere motion to
that end, sectire the delivery of the property to them on the theory that
the title was not in the debtor but in his trustee in bankruptcy. New
Orleans Acid and Fertilizer Co. v. Grissom & Suggs (1901), Sup. Ct. Miss.,
Calhoun, J., 79 Miss., 662.
Mortgage securing present advancements as well as antecedent debts
creates a preference only as to the latter. In re "Wolf (1899), N. Dist. la.,
SHras, J., 98 Fed., 84; 3 A. B. R., 555; 2 N. B. N., 908.
Replevin by creditor for goods bought at a fraudulent sale discussed
and the question of unliquidated damages and proceedingsto ascertain the
same in bankruptcy outlined. In re Heinsfurter (1899), S. Dist. la.,
Woolson J., 97 Fed., 198; 3 A. B. R, 113; 1 N. B. N., 504.
Bankruptcy court has jurisdiction of property pledged by the bank-
rupt and will dispose of same subject to right of lienors. In re Cobb
(1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 96 Fed., 821; 3 A. B. R., 129; 1 N. B.
N., 557.
Creditors receiving collateral within the four months must surrender
the same as preferential. In re Cobb (1899), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J.,
96 Fed., 821; 3 A. B. R., 129; 1 N. B. N., 557.
Chattel mortgage given within the four months allowing the mort-
gagor to retain possession and sell the goods mortgaged is void under the
§67f.] LIENS. 229
bankruptcy law. In re Platts (1901), Dist. S. D., Garland, J., 110 Fed ,
126; 6 A. B. R., 568.
Chattel mortgage in part for antecedent debt void pro tanto. In re
Ronk (1901). Dist. Ind.. Baker, J., Ill Fed., 154; 7 A. B. R., 31.
Conditional sale upheld in Kentucky. Title of trustee in bankruptcy
same as that of the bankrupt. In re Sewell, E. Dist. Ky., Cochran, J.,
Ill Fed., 791; 7 A. B. R., 133.
Where members of insolvent partnership divide the partnership assets
between the members the agreement will be treated as void, and the assets
held as firm assets. In re Head & Smith (1902) , W. Dist. Ark., Rogers, J.,
114 Fed., 489; 7 A. B.R., 556.
Bankruptcy court may enjoin assignee under general assignment from
interfering with property assigned and may direct the marshal to take
charge and hold such property pending adjudication. Dams v. Bohle
et al. (1899), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Thayer, J., 92 Fed., 325; 1 A. B. R., 412;
1 N. B. N., 216.
Bankruptcy court acquires jurisdiction the moment petition is filed
and failure to issue the subpcEna within four months does not affect right
to have preferential confessions of judgment set aside. In re Lewis &
Bro. (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 91 Fed., 632; 1 A. B. R., 458; 1 N.
B. N., 556.
Bankrupt court may order sale of bankrupt's property free of liens,
Southern Loan & Trust v. Benbow (1899), W. Dist. N. C, Ewart, J., 96
Fed., 514, 3 A. B. R., 9; 1 N. B. N., 499.
Wife's equitable interest in lands of the bankrupt husband which he
conveyed to her before bankruptcy not fraud on creditors. In re Gamer,
N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 110 Fed., 123; 6 A. B. R., 596.
This section applies to transfers, etc., other than money which were not
made in good faith for present, fair consideration. Blakely v. Boonville
Nat. Bank (1899). Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 95 Fed., 267; 2 A. B. R., 459; 1
N. B. N..411.
Judgment within the four months void and trustee may recover of the
plaintiff — proof of insolvency at time of recovery necessary — allegations
in petition on which adjudication was had of such fact of insolvency is
sxifBcient. Levor v. Seiter (1901). Sup. Ct. N. Y., Leventritt, J., 34 N. Y.
Misc., 382.
/ [Liens created through legal proceedings.] That all
levies, judgments, attachments, or other liens, obtained
through legal proceedings against a person who is insolvent,
230 LIENS. [§67f.
at any time within four months prior to the filing of a peti-
tion in bankruptcy against him, shall be deemed null and
void in case he is adjudged a bankrupt, and the property
affected by the levy, judgment, attachment, or other lien
shall be deemed wholly discharged and released from the
same, and shall pass to the trustee as a part of the estate of
the bankrupt, unless the court shall, on due notice, order
that the right imder such levy, judgment, attachment, or
other lien shall be preserved for the benefit of the estate;
and thereupon the same may pass to and shall be preserved
by the trustee for the benefit of the estate as aforesaid. And
the court may order such conveyance as shall be necessary
to carry the purposes of this section into effect :
Provided, That nothing herein contained shall have the
effect to destroy or impair the title obtained by such levy,
judgment, attachment, or other lien, of a bona fide pur-
chaser for value who shall have acquired the samewithout
notice or reasonable cause for inquiry.
For method of computing time vmder this act, see Sec. 31 a and notes
ante.
Judgment within four months not void but merely the lien is armulled
by the bankruptcy proceedings. In re Pease (1900), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 4 A. B. R., 547; 2 N. B. N., 1108.
The trustee has only the rights of the bankrupt's creditors to all acts
and transfers; such rights do not enable the trustee to defeat a prior
attachment of creditors of transferee. In re Mullen (1900), Dist. Mass.,
101 Fed., 413; 4 A. B. R., 224; 2 N. B. N., 701.
Trustee may maintain action to set aside transfer made by a firm and
its members of which he is trustee. Barber v. Franklin (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 37 Misc., 292; 75 N. Y., Supp., 305; 8 A. B. R., 468.
A chattel mortgage with permission for mortgagee to make sales of the
property is void in South Dakota as to creditors and is void in bank-
ruptcy. Elgin State Bank v. Rice (1902), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Lochren, J.,
119 Fed., 107.
Preferential conveyance six months old but recorded within four
months is valid and not affected by the bankruptcy act. Miller v.
Shiver (1900), Sup. Ct. Pa., Fell, J., 197 Pa. St., 191.
§67f.] LIENS. ^31
Injunction to restrain attaching creditor and sheriff preliminary to ap-
pointment of trustee is proper. In re Goldberg (1902), N. Dist. N. Y.,
Ray, J., 117 Fed., 692; 9 A. B. R., 156.
This section applies to voluntary cases. Judgment transferred by a
testatum fi fa to another cotmty within the four months period comes tinder
the statute so far as that new county is concerned. Mencke v. Rosen-
berg (1902), Sup. Ct. Pa., Mestrezot, J., 202 Pa. St. Rep., 131; 9 A. B. R.,
323.
Execution on old judgment issued within the four months cannot be
enjoined by bankruptcy court. White v. Thompson et al. (1903) , C. C. A.,
5th Cir., 119 Fed., 868.
Lien on seat in stock exchange held good though acqiiired within the
four months no knowledge of insolvency being shown on part of claimant.
Hutchinson v. Otis (1902), C. C. A., 1st Cir., Putnam, J., 115 Fed., 937; 8
A. B. R., 382.
Claims for sheriff's fees for attachment within the four months period
rendered void by bankruptcy. In re Jennings (1902), W. Dist. N. Y.,
Hotchkiss, R., 8 A. B. R., 358.
Money paid to execution creditors before filing of petition within the
four months does not come within this section. Levor v. Setter (1902),
Sup. Ct. N. Y., Patterson, J., 8 A. B. R., 459.
Trustee should apply to the coiirt granting the attachment for dissolu-
tion of the attachment rendered void under this section. Hardt v.
Schuylkill Plush & Silk Co. (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Ingraham, J., 69 App.
Div., 90; 74 N. Y. Supp., 549; 8 A. B. R., 479.
Garnishment judgment void where made within the four months and
garnishee ordered to pay into court the amotmt owing the bankrupt.
In re Beals (1902), Dist. Ind., Baker, J., 116 Fed., 530; 8 A. B. R., 639.
Levy made within the four months void, though judgment on which
the execution issued more than six years old. In re Darwin (1902),
C. C. A., 6th Cir., Day, J., 117 Fed., 407; 8 A. B. R., 703.
Mechanic's lien — sub-contractors held to have no right to. Ludowice
Rootling Tile Co. v. Penn. Inst, for the Blind (1902), C. C. E., Dist. Pa.,
Archbald, J., 116 Fed., 661; 8 A. B. R., 739.
Lien of chattel mortgage inside of four months good only for that part
of the consideration that was present. Stedman v. Bank of Monroe (1902) ,
C. C. A., 8th Cir., Lochren, J., 117 Fed., 237; 9 A. B. R., 4.
The lien given by attachment or judgment on creditors' bill which is
merged in the judgment is the lien here indicated by the statute and the
four months commences with the date of the attachment and not of the
judgment. Metcalf v. Barker (1902) , Sup. Ct. U. E., Fuller J., 9 A. B. R.,
36.
232 LIENS. [§67f.
Lien filed after debtor is adjudged a bankrupt is void. Loggori v.
Haven (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gildersleeve, J., 79 N. Y.. Supp.. 395.
Loan given under a promise of a mortgage which was not delivered
imtil subsequent and within four months is not a preference. Murray v.
Beal (1901), Sup. Ct. Utah, Miner, J., 23 Utah, 548.
Banker has no lien on deposits before maturity of notes. Pearsoll v.
Nassau Nat. Bank (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Jenks, J., 74 N. Y. App., Div.,
89.
Lien of execution on exempt property not divested by bankruptcy pro-
ceedings where exemption law requires debtor to file schedule with officer
within ten days ; he must do so irrespective of his filing petition in bank-
ruptcy. Doyle V. Hall (1899), App. Ct. 111., 1st Dist., Horton, J., 86 111.
App., 163.
The eflfect of this clause is not felt where a Uen by attachment was
acquired more than four months before proceedings although the judg-
ment was within the four months. Wakeman v. Throckmorton (1902),
Sup. Ct. Conn., Baldwin, J., 51 Atl., 554.
Trustee may bring trespass against constable who sold property after
adjudication of bankruptcy of owner where the property had been seized
on attachment within the four months. Wallal v. Camp (1901), Sup.
Ct. Pa., Beaver, J., 200 Pa. St., 220.
Judgment obtained within four months is void. Clause c does not
limit f. National Bank and Loan Co. v . S pencer {1900) , Sup. Ct. N. Y.,
Spring, J., 53 N. Y. App., Div., 547.
Attachments %\4thin fotir months are good (1) where attmchment
action was brought without knowledge of the debtor; (2) the creditor had
no knowledge of the insolvency of his debtor; (3) attachment is not predi-
cated upon insolvency or attempts of the debtor to conceal and dispose
of his property, and (4) the creditor no reason to believe his debtor con-
templated bankruptcy. Ex parte Chase (1900), Sup. Ct., S. C. ; Pope, J.;
62 S. C, 353.
Mortgagor who receives a discharge in bankruptcy pending foreclostire
proceedings is not liable to a decree for deficiency. Prcntis v. Richard-
son's estate (1898), Sup. Ct. Mich., Moore, J., 118 Mich., 259.
Lien dissolved by bankruptcy proceeding — stay of judgment. Pink-
hard V. Willis & Bro. (1900), Sup. Ct. Tex., Gill, J., 24 Tex., Civ. App.,
69.
A foreign attachment dissolved by bankruptcy proceedings. Keeler v.
Ft. Wayne Electric Co. (1899), Cir. Ct. la., Craig, J., 23 Pa. C. C, 637.
Bankrupt may testify on behalf of his estate that conveyance made by
§67f.] LIENS. 233
him was made when he knew himself to be in failing circumstances.
Supple V. Hall (1902), Sup. Ct. Conn., Hamersby, J., 52 Atl., 407.
Attachment lien levied more than four months before proceedings up-
held. Stickney and Babcock Coal Co. v. Goodwin (1901), Sup. Ct.
Me., Wiswell, J., 75 Me., 246.
This section only affects liens against the trustee as to the rest of the
world thus involved. Frazee et al. v. Nelson (1901), Sup. Ct. Mass., Mor-
ton, J., 179 Mass., 456.
Attachment within four months dissolved by bankruptcy proceedings.
In re Kemp (1900), Dist. Colo., Hallet, J., 101 Fed., 689; 4 A. B. R., 242;
2 N. B. N., 565.
The preferential giving of a mortgage within the four months with
knowledge on the part of the mortgagee of the intent will be declared void
and set aside by decree of the district court. In re Teague (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 2 A. B. R., 168; 1 N. B. N., 310.
Lien by attachment within four months of adjudication vacated — word
"permitted" synonomous with "suffered," or "allowed." In re Arnold
(1899), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 94 Fed., 1001; 2 A. B. R., 180; 1 N. B. N.,
334.
Judgment levy in four months nvdlified and creditor compelled to return
money in plenary suit. Levor v. Setter et al. (1901), N. Y. Sup. Ct.,
Leventritt, J., 5 A. B. R., 576.
This section does not relate to judgments after petition but a stay of
proceedings will be ordered. Kinmouth v. Brarutigan (1900) , N. Y. Sup.
Ct., 46 Atlantic, 769; 4 A. B. R., 344.
Suits under 67e may be brought in the Supreme Court of N. Y. Jones
v. Schermerhorn (1900), Sup. Ct., N. Y., Adams, J., 53 N. Y. App. Div.,
494.
Where evidence does not show gross inadequacy of consideration by the
purchaser, nor knowledge of insolvency, the purchaser is not open to
attack. Dunlap v. Thomas (1902), Sup. Ct. Wash., White, J., 68 Pac,
909.
Agreement to make payment out of a particular ftmd or to give a lien
if done within the four months, is void. Torrence v. Win-field Nat. Bank
(1903), Sup. Ct. Kans., Greene, J., 71 Pac, 235.
Nothing need be shown except the fact of insolvency and subsequent
adjudication. Severin v. Robinson (1901), App. Ct. of Ind., Wiley, J., 27
Ind. App., 55.
Judgment procured after adjudication will not be vacated on motion in
state court quaere. The bankrupt may deem the judgment void. Kin-
mouth V. Braeniigam (1900), Sup. Ct. N. J., CoUins, J., 65 N. J. L., 165.
234 LIENS. [§67f.
Lien of workingmen on goods in their hands recognized. In re Loiven-
sohn (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 100 Fed., 776; 4 A. B. R., 79; 2 N.
B. N., 871.
This section does not include mechanic's liens. In re Emslie & Co.
(1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace J., 98 Fed., 716; 4 A. B. R., 126; 2 N.
B. N., 324.
This clause (f) controls clause C — lien obtained by legal proceedings
within four months void. In re Rhoads 1899), W. Dist. Penn., Buffing-
ton, J., 98 Fed., 399; 3 A. B. R., 380; 2 N. B. N., 301.
This section applies only to involuntary cases. In r/Easley, (1898)
W. Dist. Va., Paul, J., 93 Fed., 419; 1 A. B. R., 715; 1 N. B. N., 230.
Section f includes both voluntary and involuntary petitions. In re
Dobson (1899), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 98 Fed., 86; 3 A. B. R., 420;
2N. B. N., 514.
Mortgaged property should not be sold free of liens tmless it appears
that the sale will be for the benefit of the estate. In re Styer (1899), E.
Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 98 Fed., 290; 3 A. B. R., 424; 2 N. B. N.,
205.
A garnishee who has paid before bankruptcy proceedings is not to be
disturbed. In re Sharp (1899), Dist. of Ky., Durett, R., 1 A. B. R.,
379.
Attachment issued in pending case within the fotir months rendered
void by bankruptcy act. In re Higgins (1899), Dist. Ky., Evans, J., 97
Fed., 775; 3 A. B. R., 364; 1 N. B. N., 992.
A mechanic's lien which is created by notice and which is given within
the fotu- months is avoided. In re Emslie & Sons, S. Dist., Brown, J.,
98 Fed., 716; 3 A. B. R., 282; 2 N. B. N., 992.
Lien of creditor disallowed, being part of a fraudulent transaction. In
re Hugill (1899), N. Dist. O., 100 Fed., 616; 3 A. B. R., 686; 2 N. B. N.,
433.
Attachments levied within the fotw months and prosecuted to judg-
ment set aside by bankruptcy court and proceeds taken by trustee; sum-
mary proceedings and rule to show cause appropriate. Such creditors
are not third parties claiming estate adversely. Bear & Co. v. Chase
(1899), C. C. A., Waddill, J., 3 A. B. R., 746.
General assignment held void as against trustee in bankruptcy pro-
ceedings. In re Gutwillig (1899), C. C. A., Wallace, J., 92 Fed.. 337; 1
A. B. R., 388; 1 N. B. N., 554.
Lien of attachment within four months will not be destroyed by the
adjudication of the defendant in bankruptcy where the action was begun
§67f.] LIENS. 235
more than four months prior to the filing of the petition. The act looks to
the beginning of the suit. In re De Lue (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
91 Fed., 510; 1 A. B. R., 387; 1 N. B. N., 555.
The lien of an unrecorded chattel mortgage is good even as to creditors
who gave credit after execution and before recording. In re Adams (1899)
E. Dist. Mich., Swan, J., 97 Fed., 188; 2 A. B. R., 415; 1 JN. B. N.,
530.
Judgment as used in this section is sufficiently broad to include judg-
ment of state court appointing a receiver and adjudication of bankruptcy
nullifies such judgment. Mauran v. Crown Carpet Lining Co. (1901) , Sup.
Ct. R. I., Rogers, J., 6 A. B. R., 734.
Receiver holding property under appointment from state cotirt en-
titled to expenses and fees incurred before adjudication. Idem.
This clause applies to voluntary and involvmtary petitions. Brown v.
Case, Sup. Jud. Ct., Mass., Lathrop, J., 61 N. E., 279; 6 A. B. R., 744.
Adjudication defined, Sec. 1, Sub. (2). When a person is deemed to be
insolvent. Sec. 1 (15). "f " of this section destroys and supersedes "c."
In re Tune (1902), N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 115 Fed., 906; 8 A. B. R., 285.
Adjudication in bankruptcy annuls a levy on attachment in state
court on property claimed as exempt, even though there is waiver of ex-
emption in judgment notes. In re Time, N. Dist. Ala., Jones, J., 115
Fed., 906; 8 A. B. R., 285.
Preferential payment is not shown where it was necessary to procvu-e
consent of landlord to effect a sale of the property and if sale was not
made so much less would have been realized. In re Pearson (1899), S.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 95 Fed., 425; 2 A. B. R., 482; 1 N. B. N., 474.
"f" applies only to involuntary petitions. " c " applies to either. If
suit was commenced more than four months prior to the filing of the peti-
tion the judgment will be a prior claim. In re CoUins (1899), S. Dist.
la.. Sawyer, R., 2 A. B. R., 1; 1 N. B. N., 290.
Title to property levied on by the sheriff on execution obtained within
four months is rendered void by the adjudication, and the sheriff may by
summary process be ordered to surrender the same. In re Francis Valen-
tine (1899), N. Dist. Cal., Haven, J., 93 Fed., 953; 2 A. B. R., 188; 1 N,
B. N., 532.
"c" and "f " do not remove a mechanic's lien given by statute, but
statutory provisions must be strictly compUed with. In re Kerby-Denis
Co. (1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 94 Fed., 818; 2 A. B. R., 218; 1
N. B. N., 399.
Levy after passage of act on judgment recovered prior to the enact-
236 LIENS. [§67f.
ment vacated by the adjudication. In re Adams (1899), Moss, R., N. Dist.
N. Y., 1 A. B. R., 94; 1 N. B. N., 167.
Judgment obtained within the three months; Hen thereof avoided by
the act. In re Hopkins (1899), N. Dist. Ala., Turner, R., 1 A. B. R., 209;
IN. B. N.,71.
This section appHes to both volvmtary and involuntary bankrupts. In
re Richards (1899), W. Dist. Wis., Bunn, J., 95 Fed., 258; 2 A. B. R.,
518.
Variations of the terms of promissory notes by agreement between
parties without consideration void as against existing creditors. In re
Powers (1899), Dist. Vt., Mott, R., 1 A. B. R., 432.
Preferences within four months preceding adjudication are void and
the plaintiff treated as an unsecured creditor. In re Huffman (1899), W.
Dist. Penn., Myers, R., 1 A. B. R., 587; 1 N. B. N., 215.
An attachment execution issued within four months prior to adjudica-
tion is void. Peck Lumber Mfg. Co. v. Mitchell, Lackawanna Co. Ct.,
Common Pleas, Edwards, J., 1 A. B. R., 701; 1 N. B. N., 262.
This section relates to voltmtary as well as involvmtary proceedings.
Idem.
Right to join tmder Section 59 exists only during pendency of case.
Neustadier v. Chicago Dry Goods Co. (1899), Dist. Wash., 96 Fed., 830; 3
A. B. R., 96; 1 N. B. N., 552.
To the same effect see Worden v. Columbus Electric Co. (1899), Dist.
Ind., Baker, J., 96 Fed., 803; 3 A. B. R., 186.
An attachment on mesne process in Vermont constitutes only an in-
choate hen which is merged in the subsequent judgment, and if within
four months of bankruptcy the lien is cut off. In re Johnson (1901).
Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 108 Fed., 373; 6 A. B. R., 202.
To avoid such liens it must appear the bankrupt was insolvent. Simp-
son V. Van Etten, C. Ct., E. Dist. Penn., Dallas, J., 108 Fed., 199; 6 A.
B. R., 204.
Lien created by attachment more than four months old is not avoided.
In re Blair (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 108 Fed., 529; 6 A. B. R., 206.
Referee has jurisdiction to order sale of property free and clear of liens.
Construction of mechanic's lien law of Ark. In re Matthews (1901) , W.
Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 109 Fed., 603; 6 A. B. R., 96.
On sale of property free and clear of liens the order of distribution
should be first costs of sale, then the liens according to priority. In re
SanderUn, E. Dist. N. C, PumeU, J., 109 Fed., 857; 6 A. B. R., 384.
Validity of liens may be inquired into by bankruptcy covirt and the
§67f.] LIENS. 237
property sold free and clear. In re Kellogg, McMasters, R., W. Dist.
N. Y., 6 A. B. R., 389.
Lien of attachment more than foiir months old remains although judg-
ment therevmder is within the five months period. Sheriff allowed his
fee although case commenced more than four monthsjbefore. In re
Beaver Coal Co. (1901), Dist. Or., Bellinger, J., 110 Fed., 630; 6 A. B.
R., 404.
Lien of creditor's bill in state court filed more than four months does
not come under this clause and the proceedings may not be interrupted by
the district court. Metcalf Bros. v. Barker (Dec, 1902), U. S. Sup.
Ct., Fuller, C. J., 6 A. B. R.,36,
Sheriff required to turn over to trustee proceeds of execution made
within four months. In re Kenney (1900), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Lacombe,
J., 105 Fed., 897; 5 A. B. R., 355.
Contra the doctrine of last case. In re Seebold (1901), C. C. A., 5th
Cir., McCormick, J., 105 Fed., 910; 5 A. B. R., 358.
This section does not apply to judgments entered after date of adjudica-
tion— no lien can be acquired after adjudication by a judgment. In re
Engle (1901), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 105 Fed., 893; 5 A. B. R.,
372.
Liens by distraint dissolved by bankruptcy proceedings. In re
Doughtery & Co. (1901), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 109 Fed., 480; 6
A. B. R., 457.
Trustee must obtain an order to restrain the attachment of property
belonging to the bankrupt. Watschke v. Thompson (1901), Sup. Ct.
Minn., Lewis, J., 7 A. B. R., 504.
Lien of attachment may continue to exist after the debt is barred by
bankruptcy. Powers Dry Goods v. Nelson (1901), Sup. Ct. N. D., Yotmg
J., 7 A. B. R., 506.
A lien on exempt property is subject to the jurisdiction of the State
court solely. Idem.
A lien on exempt property is subject to the jurisdiction of the State
court solely Attachment lien more than four months old not merged
in the judgment and remains a valid lien. In re Beaver Coal Co. (1902) ,
C. C. A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J., 113 Fed., 889; 7 A. B. R., 542.
See contra to this doctrine in re Lesser, C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Shipman,
J., 5 A. B. R., 326.
238 SET-OFFS AND COUNTERCLAIMS. [§68ab.
Sec. 68. Set-Offs and Counterclaims.
a [Mutual debts and credits.] In all cases of mutual
debts or mutual credits between the estate of a bankrupt
and a creditor the accoimt shall be stated and one debt
shall be set off against the other, and the balance only shall
be allowed or paid.
As to cases of mutual credit after preference, see Section 60c ante.
See also notes under Sec. .57g.
Unpaid subscription to stock of a bankrupt corporation due from
payee of bankrupt's note will bar proof of claim either in his hands or in
the hands of assignee, same being non-negotiable. In re Albert Goodman
Shoe Co. (1899), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 3 A. B. R., 200.
Separate debt due trustee cannot be set off against a liability due
creditors jointly with others. In re Chrystal Spring Bottling Co. (1900) ,
Dist. Va., Wheeler, J., 96 Fed., 945; 4 A. B. R., 55; 3 N. B. N., 179.
b [When not allowed.] A set-off or counterclaim shall
not be allowed in favor of any debtor of the bankrupt which
(1) [Not provable.] is not provable against the estate;
or
As to provable debts see Sec. 63 and notes, and Sec. 17.
(2) [Purchased after petition.] was purchased by or
transferred to him after the filing of the petition, or
within four months before such filing, with a view to such
use and with knowledge or notice that such bankrupt was
insolvent, or had committed an act of bankruptcy.
Payment on money accounts not allowed as set-off. In re Christen-
sen, N. Dist. la., James, R., 4 A. B. R., 202; 2 N. B. N., 695.
Set off allowed in bankruptcy though not imder State law. In re
Meyer & Dickinson (1901), E. Dist. N. Y., Thomas, J., 107 Fed., 86; 5
A. B. R., 593.
Set-off denied in favor of maker of notes endorsed by bankrupt for
his accommodation unmatured and held by a bank as against claim due
the bankrupt on advances made by him to such maker. Idem.
Set-off by defendant in suit by trustee of claim arising by payment of
§69 a.] POSSESSION OF PROPERTY. 239
debt which bankrupt had covenanted to pay, allowed as a mutual credit,
although not provable in bankruptcy by reason of preferences received
by the original creditor. Morgan v. Worc/e// (1901), Sup. Ct. Mass.,
Holmes, J., 59 N. E., 1,037; 6 A. B. R., 167.
Sec. 69. Possession of Property.
a [Warrant may issue to seize and hold property.] A
judge may, upon satisfactory proof, by affidavit, that a
bankiiipt against whom an involimtary petition has been
filed and is pending has committed an act of bankruptcy,
or has neglected or is neglecting, or is about to so neglect
his property that it has thereby deteriorated or is thereby
deteriorating or is about thereby to deteriorate in value,
issue a warrant to the marshal to seize and hold it subject
to further orders. Before such warrant is issued the peti-
tioners applying therefor shall enter into a bond in such an
amoimt as the judge shall fix, with such sureties as he shall
approve, conditioned to indemnify such bankrupt for such
damages as he shall sustain in the event such seizure shall
prove to have been wrongfully obtained. Such property
shall be released, if such bankrupt shall give bond in a sum
which shall be fixed by the judge, with such sureties as he
shall approve, conditioned to turn over such property, or
pay the value thereof in money to the trustee, in the event
he is adjudged a bankrupt pursuant to such petition.
For form of warrant to seize goods and return thereon, see form No.
S post.
Affidavits vmder this section should be as specific as possible in the
statement of all essential facts. In re Kelley (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 91 Fed., 504; 1 A. B. R., 306; 1 N. B. N., 240.
The marshal may not seize property in hands of third person claim-
ing adversely on the claim that it was fraudulently conveyed by the
bankrupt. In re Kelley (1899), W. Dist. Tenn.. Hammond, J., 91 Fed.,
504; 1 A. B. R., 300; 1 A. B. N., 240.
Stunmary process to compel bankrupt to strrrender property in an in-
volimtary case is not favored. In re Ogles (1899) , W. Dist. Tenn., Walk-
HT, R., 2 A. B. R., 514; 1 N. B. N., 326.
240 POSSESSION OF PROPERTY. [§69 a.
A sheriff who has seized property under writs of attachment within
the four months may not retain custody to secure his fees. The court
will give them in due season. In re Francis Valentine Co. (1899), C.
C. A., 9th Cir., Gilbert, J., 93 Fed., 953; 2 A. B. R., 522; 1 N. B. N., 529.
Proceedings to compel bankrupt to pay over money to trustee must
be in name of trustee. In re Rothschild (1901), S. Dist. Ga., Crovatt,
R., 5 A. B. R., 587;
Injunction will issue to stay sale tmder foreclosiire where it appears
there is margin over the mortgage debt. In re Sabine (1899), N. Dist.
N. Y., Hotchkiss, J., 1 A. B. R., 315; 1 N. B. N., 45.
This section does not authorize the marshal to seize property not in
the bankrupt's possession. In re Rockwood (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 91 Fed., 363; 1 A. B. R., 272; 1 N. B. N., 134.
The trustee in bankruptcy may appear in County Court and contest
the accotmt of the bankrupt who is administrator of his father's estate.
In re Clute (1899), Superior Ct., SanFrancisco, Coffey, J.; 2 A. B. R., 376;
1 N. B. N., 386.
It is contempt for bankrupt to refuse to turn over property to trustee
on the order of the referee — practice therein. In re Pearson (1899) E.
Dist. Penn., Coffin, R.; 2 A. B. R., 819; 1 N. B. N., 475.
Bankruptcy court may order its Marshal to take possession of prop-
erty in the hands of assignee under general assignment pending appoint-
ment of trustee, and may restrain assignee from disposing of or interfering
with the property. Davis v. Bohle (1899), C. C. A., »th Cir., Thayer,
J., 92 Fed., 325; 1 A. B. R., 412; 1 N. B. N., 216.
A creditor who subsequent to petition levies replevin writ is liable
to injtmction and order to return property. In re Huddleston (1899),
N. Dist. Ala., Turner, R.; 1 A. B. R., 572; 1 N. B. N., 214.
Where property is in hands of agent of bankrupt, summary process
appropriate. Mullet v. Nugent, supra.
Section 69 does not authorize the seizure of property which is in the
hands of third person. In re Rockwood (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J.,
91 Fed., 363; 1 A. B. R., 272; 1 N. B. N., 134.
Trustee may take possession by summary process of property in
bankrupt's possession but claimed by the wife, where claim proves fraudu-
lent. In re Smith (1899), S. Dist. Ga., Speer, J., 100 Fed., 795; 3 A.
B. R., 95; 1 N. B. N., 533.
Parties holding property of estate not tmder adverse title may be
compelled to surrender to trustee on summary order. In re Moore, Dist
W. Va., Jackson, J., 104 Fed., 869; 5 A. B. R., 151.
§70 a.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. 241
Property transferred after filing of involuntary' petition must be re-
stored to trustee. In re Corbett (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 104
Fed., 872; 5 A. B. R., 224.
Improper meddling with assets by either bankrupt or creditor after
petition filed is contempt of court. In re Amett (1901), W. Dist. Tenn.
Hammond, J., 112 Fed., 770; 7 A. B. R., 522.
Property secured by the bankrupt vmder fraudtilent representations
can be reclaimed by the vendor. Bloomingdale v. Empire Rubber Mfg.
Co. (1902), E. Dist N. Y., Thomas, J., 114 Fed., 1016; 8 A. B. R., 74.
Jurisdiction of the property of the bankrupt is not obtained by the filing
of the petition alone. A replevin suit brought after the filing and prior
to adjudication in the State court will give priority of jurisdiction to
the latter court. In re Wells (1902), W. Dist. Mo., McPherson, J., 114
Fed., 222; 8 A. B. R., 75.
Mortgagee took possession after petition in involuntary bankruptcy
was filed against the mortgagor. The receiver in bankruptcy ousted
him and he brought suit in the State court — held he should be enjoined.
In re Gutman & Wenk (1902), S. Dist. N. Y., Adams, J., 114 Fed., 1009;
8 A. B. R., 252.
Sec. 70. Title to Property.
a [Title vested in trustee.] The trustee of the estate of
a bankrupt, upon his appointment and qualification, and
his successor or successors, if he shall have one or more, upon
his or their appointment and qualification, shall in turn be
vested by operation of law with the title of the bankrupt,
as of the date he was adjudged a bankrupt, except in so
far as it is to property which is exempt, to all
(1) [Documents.] Documents relating to his prop-
erty;
The bankrupt may be compelled to deliver to the trustee his books
of accovmt although they contain incriminating evidence. In re Sapiro
(1899), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 92 Fed., 340; 1 A. B. R., 296; 1 N. B.
N., 137.
(2) [Patents, copyrights and trademarks.] Interest in
patents, patent rights, copyrights, and trademarks ;
242 TITLE TO PROPERTY. [§70a.
Application for letters patent does not pass to trustee. In re Mc-
Donnell (1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 239; 4 A. B. R., 92.
(3) [Powers.] Powers which he might have exercised
for his own benefit, but not those which he might have ex-
ercised for some other person ;
Tenancy by cottrtesy in the husband after issue bom does not pass
to trustee — is it not an asset. Hessletine v. Prince, Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.,
95 Fed., 802; 2 A. B. R., 600, 1 N. B. N., 528.
A liquor license is an asset and bankrupt compelled to surrender the
same to be sold by the .trustee. In re Fisher (1899), Dist. Mass., 01m-
stead, R.; 1 A. B. R., 557; 1 N. B. N., 209.
Right to apply for liquor license passes from the bankrupt to the trus-
tee— siunmary process to compel nominal co-owner to surrender same
not proper, but equitable petition may preserve it. In re Brodbine,
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J.. 93 Fed., 643; 2 A. B. R., 53; 1 N. B. N., 279.
Under Penn. laws a liquor license is not distrainable for rent, nor can
a landlord claim a prior lien on the proceeds, nor can bankrupt claim ex-
emption therein. In re Myers (1900), E. Dist. Pa., McPherson, J., 102
Fed., 869; 4 A. B. R.. 536.
License to occupy stall in city market is property of trustee. In re
Emerich, W. Dist. Penn., Buffington, J., 101 Fed., 231; 4 A. B. R., 89;
2 N. B. N., 656.
Liquor license an asset which trustee takes. In re Fisher (1899), Dist.
Mass., Lowell, J., 98 Fed., 89; 3 A. B. R., 406; 2 N. B. N., 221.
Right of action for tort committed against the bankrupt does not
pass to the trustee. In re Haensel (1899), Dist. Col., DeHaven, J., 91
Fed., 355; 1 A. B. R.. 286; 1 N. B. N., 240.
Unpaid balance of legacy goes to trustee — also liquor license. In re
May, Dist. Minn., Merriman, R.; 5 A. B. R., 1.
Seat in stock exchange is an asset. In re Page (1901), C. C. A., 3rd
Cir.. Bradford, J., 107 Fed., 89; 5 A. B. R., 707. Also Page v. Edmunds
(Oct., 1902), U. S. Sup. Ct., McKenna, J.
Membership in stock exchange is property subject to constitution
of the exchange and passes to trustee. In re Gaylord (1901), E. Dist.
Mo., Shiras, J., Ill Fed., 717; 7 A. B. R., 195.
Membership in stock exchange is asset which passes to trustee. In re
Page, E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 102 Fed., 746; 4 A. B. R., 467; 2.
N. B. N., 1,069
Transfer of certificate of membership of Chamber of Commerce after
§70a.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. 243
discharge of holder in bankruptcy by the trustee cannot be blocked by
objection of fellow-member creditor whose claims are barred, there being
no lien on the membership conferred by the laws by. State ex rel Crane
et al. V. Chamber of Commerce of Minneapolis (1899), Sup. Ct. Minn.,
Canty, J., 77 Minn., 308.
(4.) [Property^ transferred in fraud.] Property trans-
ferred by him in fraud of his creditors;
(5) [Property which might have been transferred or
levied on.] Property which prior to the filing of the peti-
tion he could by any means have transferred or which might
have been levied upon and sold under judicial process
against him:
Fraudulent transfer avoided by trustee — third persons innocent of
the fraud not proper parties. North v. Taylor et al.. Sup. Ct. N. Y., Parker
J.; 6 A. B. R., 233.
State insolvency laws suspended by the operation of the bankrupt
act and no title remains in a trustee in insolvency to avoid preferential
conveyance made by the debtor while in failing circumstances with in-
tent to defraud his creditors. Ketcham v. McNamara, Sup. Ct. Conn.,
Baldwin, J.; 6 A. B. R., 160.
Partnership assignment by one member of firm followed by adjudica-
tion in bankruptcy of the firm — court will issue summary order com-
pelling assignee to surrender assets to trustee. In re Stokes et al. (1901),
E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 106 Fed., 312; 6 A. B. R., 262.
Wife under no estoppel to claim furniture which was appraised in her
presence as that of her husband. In re Jamieson (1901), Dist. R. I.,
Littlefield, R.; 6 A. B. R., 601.
Trustee of bankrupt contractor receiving satisfaction of mechanic's
lien must pay out of amount received a sub-contractor who had perfected
his lien. In re Huston (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Holt, R.; 7 A. B. R., 92-
Law of the United States and not of State prevails as to validity of
chattel mortgage. In re Hull (1902), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 115 Fed.,
858; 8 A. B. R., 302.
Trustee takes no title to policy of insitrance which has no cash sur-
render value — cannot maintain action to set aside transfer of same.
Morris et al. v. Dodd (1900), Sup. Ct. Ga., Fish, J., 110 Ga., 606.
The surplus income of a trust fund beyond the amount necessary to
support the beneficiary is an asset of the bankrupt's estate, which passes
244 TITLE TO PROPERTY. [§70a.
to the trustee. Brown v. Barker (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Hiscock, J., 68
App. Div., 594; 74 N. Y. Supp., 43; 8 A. B. R., 450.
Property of a corporation for which bankrupt works cannot be reached
by trustee even where all the stock is owned by his wife. Campbell v.
Thompson (1902), Sup. Ct. Colo., Thompson, J., 70 Pac, 161.
Money deposited in bank by insolvent partnership to be pro rated
among the creditors of the firm as their interests appear is on bank-
ruptcy proceedings a trust fund that passes to the trustee. In reDavis
(1903), W. Dist. Texas, Moxey, J., 119 Fed., 950.
The holder of an imrecorded bill of sale of chattels given for security for
loan has title against the trustee. Haskell v. Merrill et al. (1900), Sup.
Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 179 Mass., 120.
Growing crops are assets which pass to trustee. In re Barrows,
W. Dist. Va., Paul, J., 98 Fed., 582; 3 A. B. R., 414.
An inalienable contingent remainder does not vest in the trustee. In
re Hoadley & Munroe (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 97 Fed., 765;
3 A. B. R., 780; 2 N. B. N., 704.
The prohibition by Congress on conveyance by certain Indians of lands
for a term of years will preclude creditors claiming such land in volun-
tary proceedings by such Indian. In re Russie (1899), Dist. Or., Bell-
inger, J., 96 Fed., 609; 3 A. B. R., 6.
All the assets of the bankrupt pass to the trustee whether named in
this section or not — surplus of life income by will under N. Y. law is
available to creditors and can in bankruptcy proceedings be reached by
summary process. In re Baudoine (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.
96 Fed., 536; 3 A. B. R., 55; 1 N. B. N., 506.
Liability of stockholders to bankrupt corporation is an asset — trustee
should make the call. In re Chrystal Springs Bottling Co. (1899) , Dist.
Vt., Wheeler, J., 96 Fed., 945; 3 A. B. R., 194.
Income of bankrupt under will providing it should not be alienable
or subject to claim of creditors, does not pass to trustee. Munroe v.
Dewey (1900), Sup. Ct. Mass., Holmes, J., 4 A. B. R., 264; 2 N. B. N.,
840.
Trustee no interest in estate created by will where estate has not vested
In re Wetmore, E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 99 Fed., 703; 4 A. B. R.
335; 3 N. B. N., 143.
Bankrupt ordered to turn over money to trustee. In re Kuntz (1899) ,
Dist. Minn., Dovan, R., 1 N. B. N., 256.
Money in hands of sheriff arising from execution sale ordered
paid to trustee. Rose v. Vinton (1900), Penn., Court Com. Pleas,
WE^llace, J., 1 N. B. N., 544.
1 70a.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. ^45
Contingent remainder not a vested estate and does not pass to trustee
[n re Ehle (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 6 A. B. R., 476.
Where husband has possession of wife's lands by courtesy the pro-
ducts of that land pass to trustee as part of husband's estate in bank-
i-uptcy. In re Ehle (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 109 Fed., 625; 6 A.
B. R., 476.
Rent accruing after bankruptcy part of estate going to trustee In
re Case (1901), N. Dist. Ohio, Remington, R., 6 A. B. R., 721.
Trustee's title is no better than the bankrupt — a defective mortgage
good as to the creditors is good as to the trustee. In re Ohio Co-operative
Shear Co. (1899), N. Dist. O., Fay, R., 2 A. B. R., 775; 1 N. B. N., 477.
In conditional sales title to property passes to the trustee. In re
Yukon Woolen Co. ei al. (1899), Dist. Conn., Thompson, J., 2 A. B. R.,
805; 1 N. B. N., 420.
Where property held by bankrupt imder contract of conditional sale
bankrupt's title vests in the trustee subject to all equities. In re Boze-
man (1899), S. Dist. Ga., Myrick, R., 2 A. B. R., 809; 1 N. B. N., 479.
Title to property passes to trustee whether or not lien on same is
affected by bankruptcy proceedings. In re Benedict (1902), Sup. Ct.
N. Y., Houghton, J., 8 A. B. R., 463.
Building materials belonging to a contractor on the grotmd for con-
struction of building for bankrupt, whose contract provided that in case
of default by the contractor bankrupt might go on and furnish bvdlding
materials are not subject to a lien, and trustee takes no title to the same.
Duplan Silk Co. v. Spencer (1902), C. C. A., 3rd Cir., Gray, J., 115 Fed.,
689; 8 A. B. R., 367.
Bankrupt may give a title by transfer after the day of filing the pe-
tition (involuntary) before the date of adjudication. Bankrupt owns
all he may acquire after the date of filing the petition. In re Gany, W.
Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 103 Fed., 930; 4 A. B. R., 576; 2 N. B. N., 1,082.
Section 70 construed in re Burka, E. Dist. Mo., Adams, J., 104 Fed.,
326; 5 A. B. R., 12.
Trustee takes no title to exempt property. In re Wells (1900), W.
Dist. Ark., Rogers, J., 105 Fed., 762; 5 A. B. R., 308.
Mortgaged property should not be brought into bankruptcy proceed-
ings vmless there is an equity of value. In re Utt, C. C, A., 7th Cir.,
Woods, J., 105 Fed., 754; 5 A. B. R., 383.
Trustee takes same title as bankrupt to assets subject to equitable
liens. In re KUngeman (1899), S. Dist. la., Galer, R., 2 A. B. R., 44;
1 N. B. N., 294.
246 TITLE TO PROPERTY. [§70a.
The trustee gets no title to property held by the bankrupt under con-
ditional sales not completed. In re McKay (1899), N. Dist. O., Wheeler,
R.; 1 A. B. R., 292; 1 N. B. N., 133.
Title of trustee siurendered to creditor where goods were obtained by
false representations of the bankrupt, which constituted the material
consideration for the credit. In re Gany (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown,
J., 133 Fed., 930; 4 A. B. R., 576; 2 N. B. N., 1,082.
Title held by receiver vmder State proceedings to property fraudu-
lently conveyed more than four months before does not vest in the trustee.
In re Meyers & Co. (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R., 1 A. B. R.,347;
1 N. B. N., 293.
Where the unsupported evidence of the bankrupt as to his disposi-
tion of large svuns of money is improbable he may be ordered to turn the
money over to a trustee. In re Friedman (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Holt,
R., 2 A. B. R., 201; 1 N. B. N., 332.
Trustee occupies the position of purchase- for value without notice
— ^unrecorded lien void as to him. In re Booth (1899), Dist. Or., Bel-
Unger, J., 96 Fed., 942; 3 A. B. R., 574; 2 N. B. N., 377.
A conditional sale where vendee is expected to consume or sell the
property is fraudulent and void — title of trustee is same as bankrupt
except in cases tainted with fraud. In re Gracewich (1902), C. C. A.,
2nd Cir., WaUace, J., 8 A. B. R., 149.
Mortgage covering part of goods not sold at time by mortgagee to mort-
gagor— such goods pass to trustee. In re Hull (1902) , Dist. Vt., Wheeler,
J.. 115 Fed., 858; 8 A. B. R., 302.
Title of trustee to property purchased by bankrupt subject to a chattel
mortgage which he assvunes to pay is the same as that of bankrupt and
imder the same estoppel. In re Standard Laundry Co., (1901), N. Dist.
Gal., DeHaven, J., 112 Fed., 126; 7 A. B. R., 254.
Trustee of bankrupt grantee of deed of trust who received same without
beneficial interest gets no title. In re Davis (1901), Dist. Mass., Lowell
J., 112 Fed., 129; 7 A. B. R., 258.
Wife of bankrupt may not redeem from sale by trustee under order of
referee. In re Novak, N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., Ill Fed., 161; 7 A. B. R.,
267.
Trustee has no better title to property than the bankrupt, and in case
of conditional sale title remaining in vendor, trustee of bankrupt vendee
gets title. In re Kellogg (1901), W. Dist. N. Y., Hazel, J., 112 Fed.,
52; 7 A. B. R., 270.
Equitable replevin by creditors claiming fraudulent representation
pass title, facts not justifying restoration. In re Davis (1901), S. Dist. N.
Y., Adams, J., 112 Fed., 294; 7 A. B. N., 276.
§70a.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. 247
Improper meddling with assets by either bankrupt or creditor after
petition filed is contempt of court. In re Amett (1901), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 112 Fed., 770; 7 A. B. R.. 522.
Equity of redemption of bankrupt not enlarged by bankruptcy pro-
ceeding. In re Goldman (1900), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 102 Fed.,
122; 4 A. B. R., 100; 2 N. B. N., 818.
Trustee does not take title to contingent remainder. In re Wetmore
(1900), S. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 102 Fed., 290; 4 A. B. R., 335;
3 N. B. N., 443.
Title of trustee in vested remainder — statement of under New York
Statute. In re St. John, N. Dist. N.. Y., Coxe, J., 105 Fed., 234; 5 A.
B. R., 190.
Where the property is in the possession of the trustee the court will
enjoin an interference by an adverse claimant. In re Whitener (1900),
C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 105 Fed., 180; 5 A. B. R., 198.
Proceeds of property levied on tmder State proceedings within four
months prior to the bankruptcy vest in the trustee. Schmilovitz v.
Bernstein (1901), Sup. Ct. R. I., Douglass, J., 5 A. B. R., 265.
Contingent remainder does not vest title in trustee. In re Gardiner
(1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 106 Fed., 670; 5 A. B. R., 432.
No claim against the estate by wife where gift has not been delivered.
In re Chapman (1900), N. Dist. 111., Kohlsaat, J., 105 Fed., 901; 5 A. B.
R., 570.
Contingent estate not vested in trustee. In re Wetmore, C. C. A., 4th
Cir., Bradford, J., 108 Fed.. 991; 6 A. B. R., 210.
Trustee holding property where facts show it to be in custodia legis
and subject to inter\'ening claims. AIcFarland Carriage Co. v. Solanas
et al, (1901), E. Dist. La., Boarman, J., 108 Fed., 532; 6 A. B. R., 221.
Rescission of contract on grotmd of fraudulent representation — vendor
may avoid the sale irrespective of contract of vendee not to pay for them.
In re Epstein (1901), E. Dist. Ark., Trieber, J., 109 Fed., 874; 6 A. B. R.,
60.
Trustee's title to contingent interest to estate imder clause of contin-
gency where contingency relates to an event and not to person taken
by devisee as vested interest and passes to trustee in bankruptcy. In re
Twaddell (1901), Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 110 Fed., 145; 6 A. B. R., 539.
Mere agreement by mortgagee to collect rent for mortgagee not suffi-
cient to vest title. In re Dole (1901) , Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 110 Fed., 926;
7 A. B. R., 21.
Trustee succeeds to the interest of the bankrupt in the eqmty of re-
demption. In re Novak (1901), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., Ill Fed., 161,
7 A. B. R.. 27.
248 TITLE TO PROPERTY. [§70a.
State law prevails as to assignment of dower. Expenses must be
first paid where land is sold free of dower with wife's consent. In re
Forbes (1901), N. Dist. O., Doyle, R.; 7 A. B. R., 42.
Vested remainder passes to trustee. (ILL. law) as to what is a vested
remainder. In re McHarry (1901), C. C. A., 7th Cir., Grosscup, J., Ill
Fed., 498; 7 A. B. R., 83.
Property held under conditional sale does not pass to trustee. In
re Hinsdale (1901), Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., lll^Fed., 502; 7 A. B. R., 85.
Tnistee's title not that of attaching creditor, idem .
[Policy of Insurance.] Promded, That when any bank-
rupt shall have any insurance policy which has a cash sur-
render value payable to himself, his estate, or personal rep-
resentatives, he may, within thirty days after the cash
surrender value has been ascertained and stated to the
trustee by the company issuing the same, pay or secure to
the trustee the sum so ascertained and stated, and continue
to hold, own, and carry such policy free from the claims of
the creditors participating in the distribution of his estate
under the bankruptcy proceedings, otherwise the policy
shall pass to the trustee as assets ; and
Where bankrupt conveys an insurance policy which has a cash sur-
render value to his wife more than four months prior to filing of petition
the trustee must first institute proceedings to set aside conveyance of the
policy. In re Graks (1899), S. Dist. O., Geiger, R., 1 A. B. R., 465; 1
N. B. N., 164.
This provision applies only to insurance policy that has a cash surrender
value to the bankrupt. A policy the value of which is dependent on the
release by the bankrupt's wife of her interest does not come within this
section. In re Henrich (1899), Dist. Md., Hisky, R., 1 A. B. R., 713.
Policies of insiirance ha\'ing a surrender value payable to the bank-
rupt's estate are assets in spite of the State law declaring them exempt.
In re Steel & Co. (1899), S. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 98 Fed., 78; 3 A. B. R.,
549; 2 N. B. N., 281.
Tontine insurance policy payable to bankrupt on a date named, and
if he die before, payable to his wife, has a cash surrender value and belongs
to the trustee. In re Boardman, Dist. Mass.. Lowell, J., 103 Fed., 783;
4 A. B. R., 620; 2 N. B. N., 821.
Advance for premiiuns made by wife of bankrupt on endowment
§70 a.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. 240
policy protected. In re Diack (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 100 Fed.,
770; 3 A. B. R.. 723; 2 N. B. N., 664.
It is proper to require the bankrupt to execute an assignment of his
insurance policies. In re Madden, (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., 110 Fed.,
34&; 6 A. B. R., 614.
A policy of insurance which is transferrable and has a market value
passes to the trustee, although it has no surrender value. In re Sling-
luff (1900), Dist. Md., Morris, J., 105 Fed., 502; 5 A. B. R., 76.
Although State law permits exemption of life insurance policy, one
that has a cash surrender value is controlled by Section 70 and passes
to the trustee. In re Scheld (1900), C. C. A., 9th Cir., Ross, J., 104 Fed.,
870; 5 A. B. R., 102.
A policy of insurance which has a cash sturender value does not pass
as exempt although State law may so provide. In re Holden (1902) ,
C. C. A. 9th Cir., McKenna, J., 113 Fed., 141; 7 A. B. R., 615.
Policy of insurance to benefit of assured goes to the trustee. In re
Lange, N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 91 Fed., 631; 1 A. B. R., 189; 1 N. B. N., 44.
(6) [Rights of action] rights of action arising upon
contracts or from the unlawful taking or detention of, or
injury to, his property.
Bankrupt is guilty of contempt for failing to turn over property to
the trustee on the order the referee. In re Tudor (1899), Dist. Colo.,
Hallett, J., 96 Fed., 361; 2 A. B. R., 808; 1 N. B. N., 339.
Trover against a trustee may be maintained in state court for invading
the possession of chattels purchased from the bankrupt a short time prior
to the bankruptcy. Weeks v. Fowler (1902), Sup. Ct. N. H., Chase, J.,
51 Atl.. 543.
A cause of action which wotdd survive and pass to the personal repre-
sentative of the plaintiff will pass to the trustee. So does a claim for
damages against a Itmiber dealer's association for unlawful conversion.
Cleland v. Anderson (1902), Sup. Ct. Neb., Pound, J., 92 N. W., 306.
Bankrupt cannot after discharge prosecute a claim which he failed to
schedule as an asset as the trustee took title to all his property and title
did not invest in him after discharge. Scruhy v. Norman (1901), Ct. of
App., of Mo., Smith, J., 91 Mo. App., 517.
Trustee has no title to property acquired after the filing of the petition.
In re Harris (1899), N. Dist. 111., Wean, R., 2 A. B. R., 359; 1 N. B. N.,
384.
Section 70 is controlled by Section 6 in the matter of exemptions.
250 TITLE TO PROPERTY. (§70bcde.
In re Steel & Co. (1899), S. Dist. Iowa, Shiras, J., 98 Fed., 78; 3 A. B.
R., 549; 2 N. B. N., 281.
b [Approval and sale of property.] All real and per-
sonal property belonging to bankrupt estates shall be
appraised by three disinterested appraisers; they shall be
appointed by, and report to, the court. Real and personal
property shall, when practicable, be sold subject to the ap-
proval of the court ; it shall not be sold otherwise than sub-
ject to the approval of the court for less than seventy-five
per centum of its appraised value.
As to sales of property see general order XVIII. As to appointment
of appraisers, oath, see form No. 13 post.
Sale by trustee does not carry wife's inchoate right of dower — a sale
of realty will not be ordered imless it appears that it will produce re-
sults to the estate. In re Shaeflfer (1900), E. Dist. Perm., McPherson,
J., 104 Fed., 973; 5 A. B. R., 248.
Title to real estate vests in trustee after appointment. In re Stoner,'
(1901), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J.. 105 Fed., 752; 5 A. B. R., 402.
c [Trustee to convey title.] The title to property of a
bankrupt estate which has been sold, as herein provided,
shall be conveyed to the purchaser by the trustee.
d [Composition set aside — vesting title in trustee.]
Whenever a composition shall be set aside, or discharge re-
voked, the trustee shall, upon his appointment and quali-
fication, be vested as herein provided with the title to all of
the property of the bankrupt as of the date of the final de-
cree setting aside the composition or revoking the dis-
charge.
e [Avoiding certain transfers — recovery of property.]
The trustee may avoid any transfer by the bankrupt of his
property which any creditor of such bankrupt might have
avoided, and may recover the property so transferred,
or its value, from the person to whom it was transferred,
unless he was a bona fide holder for value prior to the data
§70f.] TITLE TO PROPERTY. 251
of the adjudication. vSuch property may be recovered or
its value collected from whoever may have received it, ex-
cept a bona fide holder for value.
*For the purpose of such recovery any court of bank-
ruptcy as hereinbefore defined, and any state court which
would have had jurisdiction if bankruptcy had not inter-
vened, shall have concurrent jurisdiction.*
As amended by Act of 1903. See Amendment page , post, new additional matter
found between stars.
As to suits by trustee see Sec. 11 and Sec. 23.
As to title which trustee takes see tn re Gray, N. Y. Sup. Ct., Barrett,
J.; 3 A. B. R., 647. Also in re Adams, N. Dist. N. Y., Moss. R.; 1 A. B.
R., 94.
Trustee has only the rights of bankrupt's creditors. In re Miller (1900)
Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 101 Fed., 413; 4 A. B. R., 224; 2 N. B. N., 701.
A trustee has no better title than the bankrupt of his creditors have.
In re New York Economical Printing Co. (1901), C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wal-
lace, J., 110 Fed., 514; 6 A. B. R., 615.
/ [Revestment of title on confirmation of composition.]
Upon the confirmation of a composition offered by
a bankrupt, the title to his property shall thereupon revest
in him.
As to compositions see Sec. 12 and 13 ante.
An involimtary petition filed November 1st, 1899, was not premature,
Leidigh Carriage Co. v. Stengel (1899), C. C. A., 6th Cir., Taft, J., 95 Fed.,
637; 2 A. B. R., 383; 1 N. B. N., 296.
An act of bankruptcy committed before November 1st, 1898, when
involuntary petitions could be filed may be the basis for petition. Idem.
Between July 1st, 1898, and November 1st, 1898, while no involuntary
petition could be filed no equity for injtanction to restrain disposal of
goods by mortgagee under mortgage which was assailable under the
bankruptcy act. Ellis v. L. Hayes Saddlery & Leather Co. (1902), Sup.
Ct. Kas., Smith, J.; 8 A. B. R., 110.
252 time act in effect.
The Time when this Act shall go into Effect.
a [Force and effect.] This Act shall go into full force
and effect upon its passage: Provided, however, That
no petition for voluntary bankruptcy shall be filed within
one month of the passage thereof, and no petition for
involuntary bankruptcy shall be filed within four months
of the passage thereof.
Act became operative July 1, 1898, and deprived the state courts of all
^wer and jurisdiction except to wind up the estate in its hands. First
'Nca. Bank of Griljord v. Ware (1901), Sup. Ct. Me., Emery, J., 388.
Bankruptcy law did not suspend state insolvency laws in respect to
j/HJceedings already commenced — subsequent filing of petition in bank-
ruptcy, the administration of the estate in that court and the insolvent's
discharge does not deprive the state court of jurisdiction to entertain
suit by assignee to recover property fraudulently conveyed. Oshornv.
Tender (1903), Sup. Ct. Minn., Lewis, J., 92 N. W., 1114.
Bankruptcy act does not affect proceedings begun under state in-
solvency law before its passage. Hood v. Blair State Bank (1902) , Sup.
Ct. Neb., Barnes, J., 91 N. W., 701.
Creditor's bill filed prior to passage of the act does not abate by pro-
ceedings in bankruptcy subsequently instituted by judgment creditors —
proceedings to recover assets fraudulently conveyed permitted to be
carried on. National Bank of the Republic v. Hobbs (1901), C. C. S., Dist.
Ga., Speer, J., 9 A. B. R., 190. To the same effect Metcalf v. Barker (1902)
Sup. Ct. of U. S., Fuller, J., 9 A. B. R., 3i.
State insolvency law abrogated by the act. Parmentier Mfg. Co. v.
Hamilton (1899), Sup. Ct. Mass., Knowlton, J.; 1 A. B. R., 39; 1 N. B.
N., 8.
State insolvency law suspended by act — act operates from July 1st.
The dates for filing petitions in voluntary and individual cases merely
matter of procedtire. In re Bruss-Ritter Co. (1899) , Seaman, J., E. Dist.
Wis., 90 Fed., 651; 1 A. B. R., 58; 1 N. B. N., 39.
Jurisdiction of State courts ousted immediately on commencement
of proceedings in bankruptcy. In re McKee (1899), Jefferson Co. Ct.,
Gregory, J., Ky.; 1 A. B. R., 311; 1 N. B. N., 139.
General assignment imder State law act of bankruptcy and voidable.
Lea Bros. v. West (1899), E. Dist. Va., Waddill, J., 91 Fed., 237; 1 A. B.
R., 261; 1 N. B. N., 79.
Jurisdiction of bankruptcy court exclusive, not concurrent with State
TIME ACT IN EFFECT. 253
courts — receiver will be appointed to take property from assignee im-
mediately and before adjudication. In re John A. Etheridge Furniture
Co. (1899), Barr, J., Dist. Ky., 92 Fed., 329; 1 A. B. R., 112; 1 N. B. N.,
139.
Distinction between general insolvency and general assignment stat-
utes; former derives its potency from the law, latter from deed of deb-
tor— former and not latter procedure is superseded by the act. The
general assignment is voidable on the adjudication only. In re Sievers
(1899), Adams, J., E. Dist. Mo., 91 Fed., 366; 1 A. B. R., 117; 1 N. B. N.,
69.
Indiana law for general assignments declared in effect an insolvency
statute and made void by the act, and assignee by simimary process
ordered to surrender assets to the bankruptcy court. In re Smith &
Dodson (1899), Dist. Ind., Baker, J.; 2 A. B. R., 9; 1 N. B. N., 356.
Assignee under general assignment allowed no compensation or at-
torney's fees. In re Kingman (1899), Dist. Mass., Farmer, R.; 5 A.
B. R., 251.
b [Cases pending under state laws.] Proceedings com-
menced under State insolvency laws before the passage
of this Act shall not be affected by it.
Prior to the commencement of bankruptcy proceedings the State law
for winding up corporations is not suspended. State v. Sup. Ct. of King
Co. (1899), Sup. Ct. of Wash., Beavis, J.; 2 A. B. R., 92; 1 N. B. N., 309.
Bankruptcy act suspends general insolvency law and proceedings
thereunder are void. In re Curtis (1899), S. Dist. 111., Allen, J., 91 Fed.,
737; 1 A. B. R., 440; 1 N. B. N., 163.
Before the expiration of the four months when involimtary petitions
could be filed injunction may issue to restrain attaching creditors. Blake
et al. V. Francis Valentine Co. (1898) , N. Dist. Cal., Hawlet, J., 89 Fed., 691 ;
1 A. B. R., 372; 1 N. B. N., 47.
A general insolvency law is suspended by the bankruptcy act and
proceedings under it are void, not merely voidable — law of 111. governs
general assignment-, held to be a general insolvency law. In re Curtis,
(1899), S. Dist. 111., Allen, J., 91 Fed., 737; 1 A. B. R., 440; 1 N. B. N., 163.
Court of bankruptcy may restrain the further administration of the
estate assignee under State law and complete administration of the es-
tate through its own officers. Lea Bros. v. West (1899), E. Dist. Va.,
Waddill, J., 91 Fed., 237; 1 A. B. R., 261; 1 N. B. N., 79.
Trustee may sue either in law or equity to set aside fraudulent con-
veyance. Four months time does not affect. Andrews v. Mathes (1902) .
Sup. Ct. Ala., Harolson, J., 32 So., 738.
254 TIME ACT IN EFFECT.
Trustee may set aside sale of mortgaged chattels with the consent of
the mortgagee as mortgagee not a bona fide holder. Skillum v. Edelman
(1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gilderslieve, J., 79 N. Y., Supp., 413.
See 70e.
Trustee not a purchaser for value without notice — has no better right
to property than bankrupt. Goodyear Rubber Co. v. Schreiber (1902),
Sup. Ct. Wash., Fullerton, J., 69 Pac, 648.
Action sustained by trustee in bankruptcy to set aside conveyance of
real estate made by the bankrupt in fraud of creditors six months before
the filing of the petition in bankruptcy. Mueller v. Bruss (1901), Sup.
Ct. Wis., Bardun, J., 8 A. B. R., 442.
Where chattel mortgage and bill of sale were fraudulent and void,
trustee may bring action in state court to set the same aside. Small v.
Mueller (1901), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Bartlett, J., 67 App. Div., 143; 8 A. B.
R., 448.
Trustee un*der this section must give security for costs. Joseph v.
Raff (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., O'Brien, J., 9 A. B. R., 227; Barber v. Frank-
jin (1902), Sup. Ct. N. Y., Gilderslieve, J., 37 Misc., 292; 75 N. Y. Sup.,
305; 8 A. B. R., 468.
State insolvency laws suspended by the passage of the bankruptcy
act and proceedings thereunder staid. In re McKee (1899), Jefferson
Co., Ky., Ct., Gregory, J.; 1 A. B. R., 311; 1 N. B. N., 139.
Bankruptcy court has jurisdiction to preserve assets of estate from
seizure on attachment proceedings pending filing of petition. Blake
et al. V. Valentine & Co. (1899), N. Dist. Cal., Hawley, J., 89 Fed., 691;
1 A. B. R., 372; 1 N. B. N., 47.
An action by receiver under State proceedings to set aside a convey-
ance is not a proceeding under State insolvency law. In re Meyers & Co.
(1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 1 A. B. R., 347; 1 N. B. N., 293.
An assignee under general assignment is not entitled to fee as such,
nor is he entitled to fee for his attorney, but he should be paid for his
services as custodian and should be allowed his expenses in preserving
the estate. In re Pauley (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 2 A. B.
R., 333; 1 N. B. N., 405.
The Pennsylvania statute as to domestic attachments is not suspended
by the bankruptcy act. McCollough & Linn v. Goodheart, Cumberland
Co. (1899),Com. PleasCt.,Biddle, J.;3A. B. R., 85; 1 N. B. N., 512.
State insolvency proceedings commenced before bankruptcy not
affected, nevertheless claims provable in bankruptcy irrespective of
such proceedings. In re Bates, Dist. Vt., Wheeler, J., 100 Fed., 263;
4 A. B. R., 56; 2 N. B. N., 208.
§ 71.] TIME ACT IN EFFECT. 255
State insolvency proceedings commenced after July 1, 1898, are
void. Westcott Co. v. Berry et al. (1899), Sup. Ct., N. H. Young, J., 45
Atl., 352; 4 A. B. R., 264.
To entitle assignee under general assignment to compensation for
services rendered they must have been beneficial to the estate — no dupli-
cation of charges permitted. In re Kingman (1899), Dist. Mass., Far-
mer, R.; 1 N. B. N., 618.
When goods are stored under general assignments landlord is entitled
to fuU rent for a reasonable period during assignment. In re Kingman,
Dist. Mass., Farmer, R.; 1 N. B. N., 518.
A fraudulent assignment of a claim long prior to passage of bankruptcy
act held void. Scot v. Devlin et dl. (1898), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.,
89 Fed., 970; 1 N. B. N., 561.
The statute of fraud of California not abrogated by bankruptcy act.
In re Taylor, N. Dist. Cal., Holland, R.; 1 N. B. N., 412.
Assignee of creditors tmder voluntary assignment allowed no fees
for services but is allowed his disbursements and fees as custodian, but
no attorney's fees. In re Bussey (1901), W. Dist. Mo., Crittenden, R.;
6 A. B. R., 603.
Assignment for creditors does not warrant paying assignee compensa-
tion for services. In re Tatem, Mann & Co. (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pur-
neU, J., 110 Fed., 519; 7 A. B. R., 52; Wilbur v. Watson (1901), Dist. R.
I., Brown, J., Ill Fed., 493; 7 A. B. R., 54.
State insolvency laws suspended by the bankruptcy act — neverthe-
less proceedings in State Cotirt to foreclose a mortgage combined with
allegations in petitions which would have invoked the State insolvency
law does not vitiate that part which covers the foreclosure. Carling
V. Seymour Lumber Co. (1902), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Shelby, J., 113 Fed.,
483; 8 A. B. R., 29.
The bankruptcy receiver will take possession of all property not covered
by the foreclosure. Comity reqviires that bankruptcy receiver first
apply to State court. Idem.
Proceedings for winding up a corporation imder State insolvency law
does not deprive the bankruptcy court of jurisdiction. In re Storck Lum-
ber Co. (1902), Dist. Md., Morris, J., 114 Fed., 360; 8 A. B. R., 86.
*Sec. 71. [Clerks to keep indexes and issue certifieates of
search.] That the clerks of the several district courts
of the United States shall prepare and keep in their respective
offices complete and convenient indexes of all petitions
and discharges in bankruptcy heretofore or hereafter
256 COMPENSATION OF REFEREE AND TRUSTEE. [§72.
filed in said courts, and shall when requested so to do,
issue certificates of search certifying as to whether or not
any such petitions or discharges have been filed; and said
clerks shall be entitled to receive for such certificates
the same fees as now allowed by law for certificates as to
judgments in said courts; Provided, that said bankruptcy
indexes and dockets shall at all times be open to inspection
and examination by all persons or corporations without
any fee or charge therefor.*
Ab amended by Act of Feb. 5, 1903. Amendment inserts' entire new section.
*Sec. 72. [Referee and trustee not to receive extra com-
pensation.] That neither the referee nor the trustee shall
in any form or guise receive, nor shall the coiurt allow
them, any other or further compensation for their services
than that expressly authorized and prescribed in this act.*
As amended by Act of Feb. 5,1903. Amendment inserts new section.
[Time amendment of Feb. 5, 1903, goes into effect]
*That the provisions of this amendatory act shall not apply
to bankruptcy cases pending when this act takes effect
but such cases shall be adjudicated and disposed of con-
formably to the provisions of the said Act of July first,
eighteen hundred and ninety-eight.*
As amended by Sec. 19 of act of Feb. 5, 1903.
[This act was signed by the President at 4:30 p. m., of Feb. 5th, 1903.]
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
Supreme Court of United States.
October Term, 1898.
I. Docket.
Clerk to keep Docket. Memo-
randum of Proceedings.
II. Filing of Papers.
Time of filing noted.
III. Process.
Process to issue out of Court —
tested by clerk.
IV. Conduct of Proceedings.
May be in person or by attorney.
V. Frame of Petition.
Petition to be without abbre-
viations.
VI. Petitions in Different
Districts.
Hearing in district of debtor's
domicile.
VII. Priority op Petitions.
Petition alleging earliest act
of bankruptcy to be heard first.
VIII. Proceedings in Partner-
ship Cases.
Partner may contest — notice of
filing.
IX. Schedule in Involuntary
Cases.
When creditors to file.
X. Indemnity for Expenses.
Officers may require advance
payment.
XI. Amendments.
Court may allow — practice.
XII. Duties of Referee.
(1) Bankrupt subject to orders
of referee after reference.
(2) Time and place where refer-
ee acts.
(3) What matters heard by
judge — reference on facts.
XIII. Appointment and Remo-
val OF Trustees.
Appointed by creditors — removal
by judge.
XIV. No Official or General
Trustee.
Court not to appoint.
XV. Trustees not Appointed
IN Certain Cases.
No assets and no creditors, no
trustee.
257
XVI. Notice to Trustee op his
Appointment.
Referee to notify trustee of
appointment ; acceptance .
XVII. Duties of Trustee.
Prepare inventory — make report
— duty of referee to compel.
XVIII. Sales of Property.
(1) To be at public auction.
(2) When trustee authorized
to sell.
(3) Sale of perishable property.
XIX. Accounts of Marshal.
Accounts vmder oath.
XX. Papers filed after Ref-
erence.
Filed either with referee or clerk.
XXI. Proof of Debts.
(1) Depositions — what to show.
(2) Creditor may have notices
sent to his address.
(3) Assigned claims — notice to
claimant.
(4) Contingent claims.
(5) Acknowledgement of letters
of attorney.
(6) Re-examination of claims
— practice.
XXII. Taking of Testimony.
Examinations — how conducted.
XXIII. Orders of Referee.
What order to recite.
XXIV. Transmission of Proved
Claims to Clerk.
Referee to transmit list to clerk.
XXV. Special Meeting of Cred-
itors.
Court may call when necessary.
XXVI. Accounts of referee.
Referee to keep account of ex-
penses.
XXVII. Review by Judge.
Petition for review to be filed
with the referee.
XXVIII. Redemption of Prop-
erty and Compounding of
Claims.
Trustee or creditor may file
petition for.
XXIX. Payment of Moneys De-
258
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
Money drawn on check; counter-
signed by the judge or referee.
XXX. Imprisoned Debtor.
Court may issue writ of habeas
corpus for imprisoned debtor —
practice.
XXXI. Petition for Discharge
What to state.
XXXII. Opposition to Dis-
charge OR Composition.
Creditor must enter appearance —
must file specifications of ground.
XXXIII. Arbitration.
What appUcation for authority
to shall state.
XXXIV. Costs in Contested
Adjudications.
Successful petitioning creditor
to recover costs — debtor to re-
cover when.
XXXV. Compensation of Clerk
Referees and Trustees.
(1) What clerk's fees to cover —
copies and notices.
(2) What referee's fees to cover
— not expenses.
(3) What compensation of trus-
tee to cover; not expenses.
(4) Fees in pauper cases — how
collected.
XXXVI. Appeals.
(1) Appeals to Circuit Court
of Appeals — equity practice
governs.
(^) Appeals to Supreme Court
of United States — thirty day
limit.
(3) Record on appeal to Su-
preme Court of United States.
XXXVII. General Provisions.
Equity rules to control in equity
cases — law rules in law cases —
time for process, etc.
XXXVIII. Forms.
Official forms to be used in pro-
ceedings.
In pursuance of the powers conferred by the Constitution and laws
upon the Supreme Court of the United States, and particularly by the
act of Congress approved July 1, 1898, entitled "An act to estabUsh
a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," it
is ordered, on this 28th day of November, 1898, that the following rules
be adoped and established as general orders in bankruptcy, to take
effect on the first Monday, being the second day, of January, 1899. And
it is further ordered that all proceedings in bankruptcy had before that
day, in accordance with the act last aforesaid, and being in substantial
conformity either with the provisions of these general orders, or else
with the general orders established by this court under the bankrupt
act of 1867 and with any general niles or special orders of the courts
in bankruptcy, stand good, subject, however, to such ftuther regulation
by rule or order of those courts as may be necessary or proper to carry
into force and effect the bankrupt act of 1898 and the general orders of
this covirt.
Section 30 provides that all rules, forms and orders prescribed by
the Supreme Court govern as to procedure.
Where rules differ from statutes, statute controls. In re Sop>er & Slada
(1899). N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 1 A. B. R., 193; 1 N. B. N., 182.
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 259
I.
DOCKET.
[Clerk to keep docket — Memorandum of proceedings.] The
clerk shall keep a docket, in which the cases shall be entered
and niimbered in the order in which they are commenced.
It shall contain a memoranditm of the filing of the petition
and of the action of the court thereon, of the reference of
the case to the referee, and of the transmission by him
to the clerk of his certified record of the proceedings, with
the dates thereof, and a memorandtim of all proceedings in
the case except those duly entered on the referee's certified
record aforesaid. The docket shall be arranged in a man-
ner convenient for reference, and shall at all times be open
to public inspection.
As to duties of clerks see ante Section 51. See Gen. Ord. II as to filing
of papers. As to reference, see Sec. 22a, also Form No. 14 for order of
reference. As to referee's records, see Sec. 42a and b.
11.
FILING OF PAPERS.
[Time of filing noted.] The clerk or the referee shall in-
dorse on each paper filed with him the day and hour of
filing, and a brief statement of its character.
See ante as to duties of clerk, Section 51. As to filing of papers after
reference see Gen. Ord. XX.
Petition delivered to the clerk and endorsed filed, after office hours
and not in his office, is filed according to law. In re Wolf (1899) , Dist.
N. J., Kirkpatrick, J., 98 Fed., 84; 2 A. B. R., 322; 1 N. B. N., 505.
m.
PROCESS.
[Process to issue out of court — tested by derk.] All process,
summons and subpoenas shall issue out of the court, tmder
the seal thereof, and be tested by the clerk; and blanks,
260 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
with the signature of the clerk and seal of the court, may,
upon application, be furnished to the referees.
As to process see United States equity rules 7 to 16 inclusive.
IV.
CONDUCT OF PROCEEDINGS.
[May be in person or by attorney.] Proceedings in bank-
ruptcy may be conducted by the bankrupt in person in his
own behalf or by a petitioning or opposing creditor ; but a
creditor will only be allowed to manage before the court his
individual interest. Every party may appear and conduct
the proceedings by attorney, who shall be an attorney or
coimselor authorized to practice in the circuit court or
district court. The name of the attorney or coimselor,
with his place of business, shall be entered upon the docket,-
with the date of the entry. All papers or proceedings
offered by an attorney to be filed shall be indorsed as above
required, and orders granted on motion shall contain the
name of the party or attorney making the motion. Notices
and orders which are not, by the act or by these general
orders, required to be served on the party personally may
be served upon his attorney.
Appearance of attorney for the baokrupt who has not been admitted
to district court will not vitiate petition. In re Kindt (1900), S. Dist.
la., Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 107; 3 A. B. R., 546; 2 N. B. N., 306.
Attorney for the bankrupt should not be the attorney for claimant.
In re Kimball (1899), Dist. Mass., Lowell, J., 97 Fed., 29; 4 A. B. R., 144;
2 N. B. N., 46.
V.
FRAME OF PETITIONS.
(Petition to be without abbreviations.] All petitions and
the schedules filed therewith shall be printed or written
out plainly, without abbreviation or interlineation, except
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 261
where such abbreviation and interlineation may be for the
purpose of reference.
As to form of petitions and schediiles see Form No. 1.
A petition praying adjudication, seizure by the Marshal of goods
of bankrupt, and injunction is multifarious and should be dismissed —
official form No. 3 must be followed. In re Ogles (1899), W. Dist.Tenn.
Hammond, J., 93 Fed., 426; 1 A. B. R., 672; 1 N. B. N., 400.
The only prayer that should be contained in a petition in bankruptcy
is that the insolvent debtor be adjudged a bankrupt. A petition con-
taining more than this is multifarious. Mather v. Coe, Powers & Coe
(1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Rick, J., 92 Fed., 133; 1 A. B. R., 504; 1 N. B.,
N., 554.
VI.
PETITIONS IN DIFFERENT DISTRICTS.
[Hearing to be in district of debtor's domicile.] In case
two or more petitions shall be filed against the same in-
dividual in different districts, the first hearing shall be had
in the district in which the debtor has his domicil, and the
petition may be amended by inserting an allegation of an
act of bankruptcy committed at an earlier date than that
first alleged, if such earlier act is charged in either of the
other petitions ; and in case of two or more petitions against
the same partnership in different courts, each having jur-
isdiction over the case, the petition first filed shall be first
heard, and may be amended by an insertion of an allegation
of an earlier act of bankruptcy than that first alleged, if
such earlier act is charged in either of the other petitions ;
and, in either case, the proceedings upon the other petitions
may be stayed until an adjudication is made upon the
petition first heard; and the court which makes the first
adjudication of bankruptcy shall retain jurisdiction over
all proceedings therein until the same shall be closed. In
case two or more petitions shall be filed in different districts
by different members of the same partnership for an ad-
judication of the bankruptcy of said partnership, the court
262 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
in which the petition is first filed having jurisdiction shall
take and retain jurisdiction over all proceedings in such
bankruptcy, until the same shall be closed ; and if such peti-
tions shall be filed in the same district, action shall be first
had upon the one first filed. But the court so retaining
jurisdiction shall, if satisfied that it is for the greatest
convenience of parties in interest, that another of said
courts should proceed with the cases, order them to be
transferred to that court.
Petitions may be amended on leave granted. Gen. Ord. XI.
Petitions in different districts — practice concerning. In re Waxel-
baum (1899)), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J., 98 Fed., 689; 3 A. B. R., 392;
2 N. B. N., 103.
VII.
PRIORITY OF PETITIONS .
[Petition alleging earliest act of bankruptcy to be first
heard.] Whenever two or more petitions shall be filed by
creditors against a common debtor, alleging separate acts
of bankruptcy committed by said debtor on different days
within four months prior to the filing of said petitions, and
the debtor shall appear and show cause against an adjudica-
tion of bankruptcy against him on the petitions, that
petition shall be first heard and tried which alleges the com-
mission of the earliest act of bankruptcy; and in case the
several acts of bankruptcy are alleged in the different
petitions to have been committed on the same day, the
court before which the same are pending may order them to
be consoldiated, and proceed to a hearing as upon one
petition; and if an adjudication of bankruptcy be made
upon either petition, or for the commission of a single act
of bankruptcy, it shall not be necessary to proceed to a
hearing upon the remaining petitions, imless proceedings be
taken by the debtor for the purpose of causing such ad-
judication to be annulled or vacated.
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 263
VIII.
proceedings' IN PARTNERSHIP CASES.
[Partner may contest notice of filing.] Any member of a
partnership, who refuses to join in a petition to have the
partnership declared bankrupt, shall be entitled to resist
the prayer of the petition in the same manner as if the
petition had been filed by a creditor of the partnership
and notice of the filing of the petition shall be given to him
in the same manner as provided by law and by these rules
in the case of a debtor petitioned against ; and he shall have
the right to appear at the time fixed by the court for the
hearing of the petition and to make proof, if he can, that
the partnership is not insolvent or has not committed an
act of bankuptcy, and to make all defenses which any debtor
proceeded against is entitled to take by the provisions of the
act ; and in case an adjudication of bankruptcy is made upon
the petition, such partner shall be required to file a schedule
of his debts and an inventory of his property in the same
manner as is required by the act in cases of debtors against
whom adjudication of bankruptcy shall be made.
See Sec, 5 as to partners ante.
Prayer of partnership petition should be to have firm adjudicated
bankrupt. Defective petition may be amended. In re Meyers (1899),
S. Dist. N. Y., Brown. J., 96 Fed., 408; 2 A. B. R., 770; 2 N. B. N., 111.
Notice must be given to all members of a partnership before firm ad-
judication. In re Murray, et al. (1899), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 96 Fed.,
600; 3 A. B R., 601; 1 N. B. N., 532.
All partners must be notified. In re Russell (1899), N. Dist. la.,
Shiras, J., 101 Fed., 248; 3 A. B. R., 91; 1 N. B. N., 532.
IX.
SCHEDULE IN INVOLUNTARY BANKRUPTCY.
[Wlien creditor to file.] In all cases of involimtary bank-
ruptcy in which the bankrupt is absent or cannot be found,
264 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
it shall be the duty of the petitioning creditor to file, within
five days after the date of the adjudication, a schedule
giving the names and places of residence of all the creditors
of the bankrupt, according to the best information of the
petitioning creditor. If the debtor is found, and is served
with notice to furnish a schedule of his creditors and fails
to do so, the petitioning creditor may apply for an attach-
ment against the debtor, or may himself ftimish such
schedule as aforesaid.
Addresses of creditors should state street and number or schedules
will be defective. If street and ntunber not given it must be shown that
a diligent effort was made to obtain them. In re Brumelkamp (1899) ,
N. Dist. N. Y., Stone, R., 95 Fed., 814; 2 A. B. R., 318; 1 N. B. N., 360.
X.
INDEMNITY FOR EXPENSES.
[Officers may require advance payment.] Before incurring
any expense in publishing or mailing notices or in traveling
or in procuring the attendance of witnesses, or in perpetuat-
ing testimony, the clerk, marshal or referee may require,
from the bankrupt or other person in whose behalf the duty
is to be performed, indemnity for such expense. Money
advanced for this purpose by the bankrupt or other person
shall be repaid him out of the estate as part of the cost of
administering the same.
As to expenses of administration see Section 62.
XL
AMENDMENTS.
[Court may allow — practice.] The court may allow amend-
ments to the petition and schedule on application of the
petitioner. Amendments shall be printed or written,
signed and verified, like original petitions and schedules.
If amendments are made to separate schedules, the same
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 265
must be made separately, with proper references. In the
appHcation for leave to amend, the petitioner shall state
the cause of the error in the paper originally filed.
No summons, writ, declaration, return, process, judgment,
or other proceedings in civil causes, in any court of the United States
shall be abated, arrested, quashed or reversed for any defect or want of
form; but such court shall proceed and give judgment according as the
right of the cause and matter in law shall appear to it, without regarding
any such defect, or want of form, except those which, in cases of de-
murer, the party demurringspeciallysetsdown,togetherwithhisdemurrer,
as the cause thereot; and such court shall amend every such defect and
want of form, other than those which the party demurring so expresses;
and may at any time permit either of the parties to amend any defect
in the process or pleadings, upon such conditions as it shall, in its dis-
cretion and by its rules, prescribe. Rev. Stat. U. S. sec. 954.
Amendments to specifications of objection to discharge allowed liberal-
ly; even new grounds of objection may come in by amendment. In re
Glass (1902), W. D. Tenn., Hammond, J., 119 Fed., 509.
Amendments to a petition of involuntary bankruptcy alleging causes
arising more than four months prior to the petition allowed. The bank-
rupt's attorney's fees were, however, assessed against the petitioners.
In re Strait (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., King, R.; 2 A. B. R., 308; 1 N. B. N.,
354.
An amended schedule should be filed as of the date of filing the origi;
nal petition. In re Harris (1899), N. Dist. Ills., Wean, R.; 1 N. B. N., 384.
XII.
DUTIES OF REFEREE.
1. [Bankrupt subject to orders of referee after reference.]
The order referring a case to a referee shall name a day upon
which the bankrupt shall attend before the referee; and
from that day the bankrupt shall be subject to the orders
of the court in all matters relating to his bankruptcy, and
may receive from the referee a protection against arrest,
to continue until the final adjudication on his application
for a discharge, unless suspended or vacated by order of
the court. A copy of the order shall forthwith be sent by
mail to the referee, or be delivered to him personally by the
^66 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
clerk or other officer of the court. And thereafter all the
proceedings, except such as are required by the act or by
these general orders to be had before the judge, shall be
had before the referee.
As to form of order of reference see form No. 14.
2. [Time and place when referee acts.] The time when
and the place where the referees shall act upon the matters
arising under the several cases referred to them shall be
fixed by special order of the judge, or by the referee; and
at such times and places the referees may perform the
duties which they are empowered by the act to perform.
Referee's finding as to fact will not be disturbed unless manifestly
wrong.
In re Waxelbaura (1900), N. Dist. Ga., Newman, J., 101 Fed., 228.
3. [What matters heard by judge — refference on facts.]
Applications for a discharge, or for the approval of a com-
position, or for an injunction to stay proceedings of a court
or officer of the United States or of a State, shall be heard
and decided by the judge. But he may refer such an ap-
plication, or any specified issue arising thereon, to the
referee to ascertain and report the facts.
This rule must be followed in involuntary cases. In re Humbert Co.
(1900), N. Dist. la., Shiras, J., 100 Fed., 439; 4 A. B. R., 76.
Questions arising on discharge may be referred to referee by the judge.
In re McDuff (1900), C. C. A., 5th Cir., Pardee, J., 101 Fed., 241; 4 A.
B. R., 110.
Sufficiency of answer to an involuntary petition can not be raised by
demurrer. Case should be set for hearing on bill and answer. Goldman,
Beck & Co. V. Smith (1899), Dist. Ky., Barr., J., 93 Fed., 682; 1 A. B. R.,
266; 1 N. B. N., 160.
A creditor may be allowed to oppose an adjudication by intervening
petition. Goldman, Beck & Co. v. Smith (1899), Dist. Ky., Barr., J.,
93 Fed., —682; 1 A. B. R.. 266; 1 N. B. N., 160.
Petition for review of proceedings before the referee on a certificate
by the referee to the judge is the only mode of bringing the ruling of th.e
referee before the court. In re Kelley Dry Goods Co. (1900), E. Dist.
Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 747; 4 A. B. R., 528.
General orders in bankruptcy. 267
XIII.
appointment and removal of trustee.
[Appointed by creditors — removed by judge.] The ap-
pointment of a trustee by the creditors shall be subject to
be approved or disapproved by the referee or by the judge ;
and he shall be removable by the judge only.
XIV.
no official or general trustee.
[Court not to appoint.] No official trustee shall be ap-
pointed by the court, nor any general trustee to act in
classes of cases.
As to appointment of trustee see Section 2, sub. 17.
XV.
TRUSTEE NOT APPOINTED IN CERTAIN CASES.
[No assets and no creditors no trustee.] If the schedule
of a volimtary bankrupt discloses no assets, and if no
creditor appears at the first meeting, the court may, by
order setting out the facts, direct that no trustee be ap-
pointed; but at any time thereafter a trustee may be ap-
pointed, if the court shall deem it desirable. If no trustee
is appointed as aforesaid, the court may order that no
meeting of the creditors other than the first meeting shall
be called.
Estate will not be opened except for good cause. In re Soper & Slade
(1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss. R.; 1 A. B. R., 193; 1 N. B. N., 182.
On the discovery of assets after the first meeting of creditors at which
no trustee was appointed, a tnistee should be appointed. In re Smith
(1899), W. Dist. Tex., Maxey, J., 93 Fed., 791; 2 A. B. R., 190; 1 N. B.
N., 532.
268 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
XVI.
NOTICE TO TRUSTEE OF HIS APPOINTMENT.
[Referee to notify trustee of appointment — acceptance.]
It shall be the duty of the referee, immediately upon the
appointment and approval of the trustee, to notify him in
person or by mail of his appointment ; and the notice shall
require the trustee forthwith to notify the referee of his
acceptance or rejection of the trust, and shall contain
a statement of the penal sum of the trustee's bond.
For form of notice, see form No. 24.
XVII.
DUTIES OP TRUSTEE.
[Prepare inventory — make report — duty of referee to
compel.] The trustee shall, immediately upon entering
upon his duties, prepare a complete inventory of all the
property of the bankrupt that comes into his possession.
The trustee shall make report in the court, within twenty
days after receiving the notice of his appointment, of the
articles set off to the bankrupt by him, according to the
provisions of the forty-seventh section of the act, with the
estimated value of each article, and any creditor may take
exceptions to the determination of the trustee within twenty
days after the filing of the report The referee may re-
quire the exceptions to be argued before him, and shall
certify them to the court for final determination at the
request of either party: In case the trustee shall neglect
to file any report or statement which it is made his duty to
file or make by the act, or by any general order in bankruptcy
within five days after the same shall be due, it shall be the
duty of the referee to make an order requiring the trustee
to show cause before the judge, at a time specified in the
order, why he should not be removed from office. The
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 269
referee shall cause a copy of the order to be served upon the
trustee at least seven days before the time fixed for the
hearing, and proof of the service thereof to be delivered to
the clerk. All accounts of trustees shall be referred as of
course to the referee for audit, unless otherwise specially
ordered by the court.
This rule must be observed as to appointment of trustee, etc., before
the court can test the question of exemptions. In re Smith (1899), W.
Dist. Tex., Maxey, J., 93 Fed., 791; 2 A. B. R., 190; 1 N. B. N., 532.
The 20 day limitation to contest exemptions does not apply to the
bankrupt but only to creditors. In re White (1900), Dist. Vt., Wheeler,
J., 103 Fed., 774; 4 A. B. R., 613; 3 N. B. N., 27.
Trustee must specify and separately appraise articles set off as ex.
empt. In re Manning (1902), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 112 Fed.,
948; 7 A. B. R., 571.
XVIII.
SALE OF PROPERTY.
1. [To be at public auction.] All sales shall be by public
auction unless ordered otherwise by the court.
2. [Wlien trustee autliority to selL] Upon application
to the court, and for good cause shown, the trustee may be
authorized to sell any specified portion of the bankrupt's
estate at private sale ; in which case he shall keep an accurate
accoimt of each article sold, and the price received therefors
and to whom sold ; which accoimt he shall file at once with
the referee.
3. [Sale of perishable property.] Upon petition by a
bankrupt, creditor, receiver or trustee, setting forth that a
part or the whole of the bankrupt's estate is perishable,
the nature and location of such perishable estate, and that
there will be loss if the same is not sold immediately, the
court, if satisfied of the facts stated and that the sale is
required in the interest of the estate, may order the same to.
270 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
be sold, with or without notice to the creditors, and the
proceeds to be deposited in court.
XIX.
ACCOUNTS OF MARSHAL.
[Accounts to be under oath.] The marshal shall make
return, under oath of his actual and necessary expenses in
the service of every warrant addressed to him, and for
custody of property, and other services, and other actual
and necessary expenses paid by him, with vouchers therefor
whenever practicable, and also with a statement that the
amoimts charged by him are just and reasonable.
XX.
PAPERS FILED AFTER REFERENCE,
[Filed either with the referee or clerk.] Proofs of claims
and other papers filed subsequently to the reference, ex-
cept such as call for action by the judge, may be filed
either with the referee or with the clerk.
See general order II as to filing of petition.
XXI.
PROOF OF DEBTS.
1. [Depositions — what to show.] Depositions to prove
claims against a bankrupt's estate shall be correctly en-
titled in the court and in the cause. When made to prove
a debt due to a partnership, it must appear on oath that the
deponent is a member of the partnership ; when made by an
agent, the reason the deposition is not made by the claimant
in person must be stated ; and when made to prove a debt
due to a corporation, the deposition shall be made by the
treasurer, or, if the corporation has no treasurer by the
ofiicer whose duties most nearly correspond to those of
treasurer. Depositions to proved debts existing in open
account shall state when the debt became or will become
due; and if it consists of items maturing at different dates
the average due date shall be stated, in default of which it
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 271
shall not be necessary to compute interest upon it. All
such depositions shall contain an averment that no note
has been received for such account, nor any judgment
rendered thereon. Proofs of debt received by any trustee
shall be delivered to the referee to whom the cause is re-
ferred.
As to proof of claims see Section 67.
Proof of claim should state consideration and defective claims may
be expunged when so defective. In re Scott (1899), N. Dist. Tex., Meek,
J.; 1 A. B. R., 553; 1 N. B. N., 226.
Creditors whose claims are disallowed should file petition for review
of order of referee. Claims not reexamined after a year. In re Chambers,
Calder & Co., Dist. R. I., Littlefield, R.; 6 A. B. R., 707.
Proof of claim good although acknowledgment contains no venue, if it
was on the form prescribed by the Supreme Court. In re Henschel, (1901)
C. C. A., 2nd Cir., Wallace, J., 109 Fed., 861; 7 A. B. R., 305.
This rtde refers only to claims arising before the petition was filed,
not to expenses of administration — practice for creditors objecting to
expenses of administration. In re Reliance Co. (1900), E. Dist. Penn.,
McPherson, J., 100 Fed., 619; 4 A. B. R., 49.
Notices of special meetings to reexamine claims should be sent by
referee. In re Stoever, E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 105 Fed., 355;
5 A. B. R., 250.
Bankrupt may not ask for examination of claims under this clause, nor
will the trustee be required so to do when the resixlt would be to bar all
claims against the estate. In re Lyon (1901), S. Dist. N. Y., Wise, R.;
7 A. B. R., 61.
Petition for review to revive claim should be filed. Jury trial should
be allowed creditor on question of solvency when their claims are at-
tacked for preferences. In re Linton (1902), E. Dist. Penn., Hoffman,
R.; 7 A. B. R., 676.
2. [Creditor may have notices sent to his address.] Any
creditor may file with the referee a request that all notices
to which he may be entitled shall be addressed to him at
any place, to be designated by the postoffice box or street
number, as he may appoint; and thereafter, and until
some other designation shall be made by such creditor, all
notices shall be so addressed; and in other cases notices
shall be addressed as specified to the proof of debt.
As to notices to creditors see Section 58.
272 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
3. [Assigned claims — notice to claimant.] Claims which
have been assigned before proof shall be supported by a
deposition of the owner at the time of the commencement
of proceedings, setting forth the true consideration of the
debt and that it is entirely imsecured, or if secured, the
security, as is required in proving accrued claims. Upon
the filing of satisfactory proof of the assignment of a claim
proved and entered on the referee's docket, the referee shall
immediately give notice by mail to the original claimant of
the filing of such proof of assignment ; and, if no objection be
entered within ten days, or within further time allowed
by the referee, he shall make an order subrogating the as-
signee to the original claimant. If objection be made, he
shall proceed to hear and determine the matter.
4. [Contingent claims.] The claims of persons contin-
gently liable for the bankrupt may be proved in the name
of the creditor when known by the party contingently
liable. When the name of the creditor is unknown, such
claim may be proved in the name of the party contingently
liable; but no dividend shall be paid upon such claim, ex-
cept upon satisfactory proof that it will diminish pro tanto
the original debt.
5. [Acknowledgment of letter of attorney.] The execu-
tion of any letter of attorney to represent a creditor, or of
an assignment of claim after proof, may be proved or ac-
knowledged before a referee, or a United States commis-
sioner, or a notary public. When executed on behalf of a
partnership or of a corporation, the person executing the
instrument shall make oath that he is a member of the
partnership, or a duly authorized officer of the corporation
on whose behalf he acts. When the person executing is not
personally known to the officer taking the proof or acknowl-
edgment, his identity shall be established by satisfactory
proof.
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 273
Power of attorney to vote by a partnership must be supported by oath
that he is a member of the firm. In re Finley (1900), S. Dist. N. Y.,'
Coxe, J.; 3 A. B. R., 738.
Wide discretion is left with referee over allowance of claims — ^his
decisions on questions of fact have great weight with the covirt. In re
Rider (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Cox, J., 96 Fed., 811; 3 A. B. R., 192; 1
N. B. N., 483.
Proof of claims of foreign creditors not within this rule. In re Suggen-
heimer (1899), S. Dist. N. Y., Brown, J.; 1 A. B. R., 425; 1 N. B. N., 59
6. [Re-examination of claims — practice.] When the
trustee or any creditor shall desire the re-examination of any
claim filed against the bankrupt's estate, he may apply
by petition to the referee to whom the case is referred for
an order for such re-examination, and thereupon the referee
shall make an order fixing a time for hearing the petition,
of which due notice shall be given by mail addressed to the
creditor. At the time appointed the referee shall take the
examination of the creditor, and of any witnesses that may
be called by either party, and if it shall appear from such
examination that the claim ought to be expimged or dimin-
ished, the referee may order accordingly.
XXII.
TAKING OF TESTIMONY.
[Examinations — liow conducted.] The examination of
witnesses before the referee may be conducted by the party
in person or by his counsel or attorney, and the witnesses
shall be subject to examination and cross-examination,
274 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
which shall be had in conformity with the mode now
adopted in courts of law. A deposition taken upon an
examination before a referee shall be taken down in writing
by him, or under his direction, in the form of narrative,
imless he determines that the examination shall be by
question and answer. When completed it shall be read over
to the witness and signed by him in the presence of the
referee. The referee shall note upon the deposition any
question objected to, with his decision thereon; and the
court shall have power to deal with the costs of incompetent,
immaterial, or irrelevant depositions, or parts of them, as
may be just.
See as to evidence Section 21. Also Section 39. As to examination
of witnesses see Section 55.
Transactions prior to the passage of the act if tending to show fraud
occtirring subsequent may be inquired into. In re Headley, W. Dist.
Mo., PhilUps, J., 97 Fed., 765; 5 A. B. R.. 272; 2 N. B. N., 250.
XXIII. -
ORDERS OF REFEREE.
[What order to recite.] In all orders made by a referee, it
shall be recited, according as the fact may be, that notice
was given and the manner thereof; or that the order was
made by consent; or that no adverse interest was repre-
sented at the hearing; or that the order was made after
hearing adverse interests.
XXIV.
TRANSMISSION OF PROVED CLAIMS TO CLERK.
[Referee to transmit list to the clerli.] The referee shall
forthwith transmit to the clerk a list of the claims proved
against an estate, with the names and addresses of the prov-
ing creditors.
For form of list of claims see Form No. 19.
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 275
XXV.
SPECIAL MEETINGS OF CREDITORS.
[Court may call when necessary.] Whenever, by reason of
a vacancy in the office of trustee, or for any other cause, it
becomes necessary to call a special meeting of the creditors
in order to carry out the purposes of the act, the court may
call such a meeting, specifying in the notice the purpose for
which it is called.
As to meetings of creditors see Section 55.
It is not the proper practice~to except to referee's decision — there
must be a petition for review. In re Russell (1900),N.Dist.Cal., DeHaven,
J., 105 Fed., 501; 5 A. B. R., 566.
Referee's findings are conclusive on review where no exceptions are
filed to the report. In re Carver & Co. (1902), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell.
J., 113 Fed., 113; 7 A. B. R., 539.
XXVI.
ACCOUNTS OF REFEREE.
[Referee to keep account of expenses.] Every referee
shall keep an accurate account of his traveling and inci-
dental expenses, and of those of any clerk or other officer
attending him in the performance of his duties in any case
which may be referred to him ; and shall make return of the
same under oath to the judge, with proper vouchers when
vouchers can be procured, on the first Tuesday in each month
Referee's expenses may include clerk hire. In re Tebo (1900) , Dist.
West. Va.. Jackson, J., 101 Fed., 419; 4 A. B. R., 235.
XXVII.
REVIEW BY JUDGE.
[Petition for review to be filed with the referee.] When a
bankrupt, creditor, trustee, or other person, shall desire
a review by the judge of any order made by the referee,
he shall file with the referee his petition therefor, setting
276* GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
out the error complained of ; and the referee shall forthwith
certify to the judge the question presented, a summary
of the evidence relating thereto, and the finding and order
of the referee thereon.
Ruling of the referee to which an exception is desired to be made to
the judge should be followed by an order — petition for review should
also be filed. In re Smith (1899), W. Dist. Tex., Maxey, J., 93 Fed.,
791; 2 A. B. R., 190.
This rule must be followed before a referee's decision can be re-
viewed. In're Schiller, W. Dist. Va., Paul, J., 96 Fed., 400; 2 A. B. R.;
704.
This rule must be followed in reviewing referee's findings. In re Scott,
E Dist N. C, Pumell, J., 93 Fed., 418; 3 A. B. R., 625; 2 N. B. N., 440.
On appeal to court of appeals complaint of incomplete record not sus-
tained, when shown that case proceeded from referee on his certificate
and svunmary of the evidence. Cunningham v. Bank (1900), 101
Fed., 977; C. C. A., 6th Cir.; 4 A. B. R., 192; 2 N. B. N., 689.
Petition for review of proceedings before the referee for a certificate
by the referee to the judge are the only modes of bringing his proceedings
before the judge. No general assignment of errors permissible. In re
Kelly Dry Goods Co. (1900), E. Dist. Wis., Seaman, J., 102 Fed., 747;
4 A. B. R., 528.
XXVIII.
REDEMPTION OF PROPERTY AND COMPOUNDING OP CLAIMS.
[Trustee or creditors may file petition for.] Whenever it
may be deemed for the benefit of the estate of a bankrupt
to redeem and discharge any mortgage or other pledge,
or deposit or lien, upon any property, real or personal, or
to relieve said property from any conditional contract, and
to tender performance of the conditions thereof, or to com-
pound and settle any debts or other claims due or belong-
ing to the estate of the bankrupt, the trustee, or the bank-
rupt, or any creditor who has proved his debt, may file his
petition therefor; and thereupon the court shall appoint
a suitable time and place for the hearing thereof, notice of
which shall be given as the court shaU direct, so that all
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 277
creditors and other persons interested may appear and show
cause, if any they have, why an order should not be passed
by the court upon the petition authorizing such act on the
part of the trustee.
XXIX.
PAYMENT OF MONEYS DEPOSITED.
[Money drawn on check — countersigned by judge or ref-
eree.] No moneys deposited as required by the act shall
be drawn from the depository imless by check or warrant,
signed by the clerk of the court, or by a trustee, and coimter-
signed by the judge of the court, or by a referee designated
for that purpose, or by the clerk or his assistant imder an
order made by the judge, stating the date, the sum, and the
accoimt for which it is drawn ; and an entry of the substance
of such check or warrant, with the date thereof, the sum
drawn for, and the accoimt for which it is drawn, shall be
forthwith made in a book kept for that purpose by the
trustee or his clerk; and all checks and drafts shall be en-
tered in the order of time in which they are drawn, and shall
be numbered in the case of each estate. A copy of this
general order shall be furnished to the depository, and also
the name of any referee or clerk authorized to cotmtersign
said checks.
As to deposits and depositories for money see Section 61.
Referee must not order payment of ftmd without authority from the
judge. In re Cobb (1901), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 112 Fed., 655; 7
A. B. R., 202.
XXX.
IMPRISONED DEBTOR.
[Court may issue writ of habeas corpus for imprisoned
debtor.] If, at the time of preferring his petition, the debtor
shall be imprisoned, the court, upon application, may order
him to be produced upon habeas corpus, by the jailer or
27S GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
any officer in whose custody he may be, before the referee,
for the purpose of testifying in any matter relating to his
bankruptcy ; and, if committed after the fiHng of his petition
upon process in any civil action foimded upon a claim prov-
able in bankruptcy, the court may, upon like application,
discharge him from such imprisonment. If the petitioner,
during the pendency of the proceedings in bankruptcy, be
arrested or imprisoned upon process in any civil action,
the district court, upon his application, may issue a writ
of habeas corpus to bring him before the court to ascertain
whether such process has been issued for the collection of
any claim provable in bankruptcy, and if so provable he
shall be discharged ; if not, he shall be remanded to the cus-
tody in which he may lawfully be. Before granting the
order for discharge the court shall cause notice to be served
upon the creditor or his attorney, so as to give him an
opportimity of appearing and being heard before the
granting of the order.
XXXI.
PETITION FOR DISCHARGE.
[What to state.] The petition of a bankrupt, for a dis-
charge shall state concisely, in accordance with the provis-
ions of the act and the orders of the court, the proceedings
in the case and the acts of the bankrupt.
For forms of petitions for discharge see Form 57.
XXXII.
OPPOSITION TO DISCHARGE OR COMPOSITION.
[Creditor must enter appearance, must file specifications
of grounds.] A creditor opposing the application of a bank-
rupt for his discharge, or for the confirmation of a composi-
tion, shall enter his appearance in opposition thereto on the
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCV. 27^
day when the creditors are required to show cause, and
shall file a specification in writing of the grounds of his
opposition within ten days thereafter, unless the time shall
be enlarged by special order of the judge.
See as to discharge Section 14b.
Objections to discharge may be signed by attorneys at law authorized
to practice in the United States District Court without showing written
authorization. In re Gasser (1900), C. C. A., 8th Cir., Sanborn, J. ,104
Fed., 537; 5 A. B. R., 32. Contra in re Glass (1902), N. D., Dis. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 119 Fed., 501 (excepting under special order showing rea-
sons) .
Specifications of objections to discharge must be filed in due season.
In re Albrecht (1900), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson, J., 104 Fed., 974; 5
A. B. R., 223.
Objection to discharge must de specific, not general. In re Hixon
(1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 93 Fed., 440; 1 A. B. R., 610; 1 N. B. N.,
326.
Specifications on objections to discharge must contain a scienter,
but need not be with the certainty of an indictment. In re Kaiser (1900) ,
Dist. Minn., Lochren, J., 99 Fed., 689; 3 A. B. R., 767; 2 N. B. N., 123.
Costs may be awarded against creditors who file objections to dis-
charge. In re Wolpert (1899), N. Dist. N. Y., Hotchkiss, R.; 1 A. B. R.,
436; 1 N. B. N., 238.
Specifications of objections to discharge must be statements of is-
suable facts, not mere conclusions of law. In re Holman, S. Dist. la.,
Woolson, J., 92 Fed., 512; 1 A. B. R., 600; 1 N. B. N., 553.
Specifications on objections to discharge may in the discretion of the
court be filed nunc pro tunc. In re Frice (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson,
J., 96 Fed., 611; 2 A. B. R., 674; 1 N. B. N., 432.
Specifications of objections to discharge must be definite and certain
and allege statutory grounds. In re Peacock (1900), E. Dist. N. C,
Pumell, J., 101 Fed., 560; 4 A. B. R., 136; 2 N. B. N., 758.
For form of specifications on objection see form 58. Specifications
may be verified nunc pro tunc. In re Wolfstein (1899), N. Dist., N. Y.,
Brown, J.; 1 N. B. N., 202.
Specifications on opposition to discharge must be clear, positive and
direct. In re McGum (1900), Dist. Nev., Hawley, J., 102 Fed., 743; 4
A. B. R., 459; 2 N. B. N., 877.
Failure to file supplemental specifications with the time limit will en-
280 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
title to dismissal. In re Clothier (1901), E. Dist. Penn., McPherson,
J., 108 Fed., 199; 6 A. B. R., 203.
Specifications on objections to discharge in nature of pleadings. In
re Wetmore, W. Dist. N. Y., Knight, R.; 6 A. B. R., 703.
Specifications on objections to discharge may be made after the ten days
for filing objections, provided they do not allege new matter — omitting
to allege the facts complained of were done knowingly and fraudulently
if not raised by the bankrupt on the hearing is waived if hearing is had
on the merits. In re Osborne, C. C. A., 1st Circt., Putnam, J.; 8 A. B.
R., 165.
Amendments liberally allowed even to introducing new grounds of
objections in the specifications. In re Glass (1902), W. Dist. Tenn.,
Hammond, J., 119 Fed., 509.
XXXIII.
ARBITRATION.
[What application for authority to shall state.] When-
ever a trustee shall make application to the court for au-
thority to submit a controversy arising in the settlement of
a demand against a bankrupt's estate, or for a debt due to
it, to the determination of arbitrators, or for authority to
compound and settle such controversy by agreement with
the other party, the application shall clearly and distinctly
set forth the subject-matter of the controversy, and the
reasons why the trustee thinks it proper and most for the
interest of the estate that the controversy should be settled
by arbitration or otherwise.
XXXIV.
COSTS IN CONTESTED ADJUDICATIONS.
[Successful petitioning creditor to recover costs — debtor
to recover when.] In cases of voluntary bankruptcy, when
the debtor resists an adjudication, and the court, after
hearing, adjudges the debtor a bankrupt, the petitioning
creditor shall recover, and, be paid out of the estate, the
same costs that are allowed to a party recovering in a suit
GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY. 281
in equity; and if the petition is dismissed, the debtor shall
recover like costs against the petitioner.
Attorney fee of bankrupt not allowed when he has opposed proceedings.
In re Woodard, E. Dist. N. Carolina, Purnell, J.; 2 A. B. R., 692; 1 N.
B. N., 385.
XXXV.
COMPENSATION OF CLERKS, REFEREES AND TRUSTEES.
1. [What clerk's fees to cover — copies and notices.] The
fees allowed by the act to clerks shall be in full compensa-
tion for all services performed by them in regard to filing
petitions or other papers required by the act to be filed
with them, or certifying or delivering papers or copies of
records to referees or other officers, or in receiving or pay-
ing out money; but shall not include copies furnished to
other persons, or expenses necessarily incurred in publish-
ing or mailing notices or other papers.
As to compensation of clerks see Section 52a. See Sec. 72 of bank-
ruptcy act.
2. [What referees' fees to cover — expenses.] The com-
pensation of referees, prescribed by the act, shall be in ftdl
compensation for all services performed by them under the
act, or under these general orders, but shall not include ex-
penses necessarily incurred by them in publishing or mailing
notices, in traveling, or in perpetuating testimony, or other
expenses necessarily incurred in the performance of their
duties under the act and allowed by special order of the
judge.
As to referees' expenses see general order 26; also Section 62. As to
compensation of referees, see Section 40.
Compensation not allowed referees for clerk hire. In re Carolina Cop-
perage Co. (1899), E. Dist. N. C, PumeU, J., 96 Fed., 950; 3 A. B. R.,
154; 1 N. B. N., 534.
3. [What compensation of trustees to cover — not ex-
penses.] The compensation allowed to trustees by the act
2S2 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
shall be in full compensation for the services performed by
them ; but shall not include expenses necessarily incurred in
the performance of their duties and allowed upon the
settlement of their accounts.
As to compensation of tnxstees, see Section 48. See as to trustee
compensation rate Sec. 72.
4. [Fees in pauper eases — how collected.] In any case
in which the fees of the clerk, referee and trustee are not
required by the act to be paid by a debtor before filing his
petition to be adjudged a bankrupt, the judge, at any time
during the pendency of the proceedings in bankruptcy, may
order those fees, to be paid out of the estate ; or may, after
notice to the bankrupt, and satisfactory proof that he then
has or can obtain the money with w^hich to pay those fees,
order him to pay them within a time specified, and, if he
fails to do so, may order his petition to be dismissed.
Petitioner can not pay his lawyer and then make the affidavit in forma
pauperis. In re Collier (1899) , W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 93 Fed., 191
1 A. B. R.. 182; 1 N. B. N., 257.
As to filing petitions in forma pauperis see Section 51, sub. (2).
In pauper cases the costs of the bankrupt are not a charge on his ex-
emption— ^he can not be expected to borrow the costs. Sellers v. Bell,
C. C. A., 5th Cir., McCormick, J., 94 Fed., 801; 2 A. B. R., 529.
XXXVI.
APPEALS.
[Appeals to Circuit Court of Appeals — equity practice
governs.] Appeals from a cotirt of bankruptcy to a circuit
court of appeals, or to the supreme court of a Territory,
shall be allowed by a judge of the court appealed from or
of the court appealed to, and shall be regulated, except as
otherwise provided in the act, by the rules governing ap-
peals in equity in the courts of the United States.
6en£ral orders in bankruptcy. 283
As to appeals see Section 25. As to methods of perfecting appeals
see supplement to Revised Statutes of United States, page 902, 903.
See also U. S. Eq. Rules post.
2. [Appeals to Supreme Court of U. S. — thirty day limit.]
Appeals under the act to the Supreme Court of the United
States from a circuit court of appeals, or from the supreme
court of a Territory, or from the supreme court of the District
of Coliunbia, or from any court of bankruptcy whatever,
shall be taken within thirty days after the judgment or de-
cree, and shall be allowed by a judge of the court appealed
from, or by a justice of the Supreme Coiut of the United
States.
3. [Record on appeal to Supreme Court of U.S.] In
every case in which either party is entitled by the act to
take an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States,
the court from which the appeal lies shall, at or before the
time of entering its judgment or decree, make and file a
finding of the facts, and its conclusions of law thereon,
stated separately; and the record transmitted to the Sup-
preme Court of the United States on such an appeal shall
consist only of the pleadings, the judgment or decree, the
finding of facts, and the conclusions, of law.
XXXVII.
GENERAL PROVISIONS.
[Equity rules govern in equity cases — law rules in law eases
— time for process.] In proceedings in equity, instituted for
the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the act,
or for enforcing the rights and remedies given by it, the rules
of equity practice established by the Supreme Coiut of the
United States shall be followed as nearly as may be. In
proceedings at law, instituted for the same ptirpose, the
practice and procedure in cases at law shall be followed as
284 GENERAL ORDERS IN BANKRUPTCY.
nearly as may be. But the judge may, by special order in
any case, vary the time allowed for return of process, for
appearance and pleading, and for taking testimony and
publication, and may otherwise modify the rules for the
preparation of any particular case so as to facilitate a
speedy hearing.
As to forms see Section 30 and title Forms in bankruptcy.
XXXVIII.
Forms.
[Official forms to be used.] The several forms annexed to
these general orders shall be observed and used, with such
alterations as may be necessary to suit the circimistances
of any particular case.
As amended by Act of 1903. See 4 of amendment, page , pott:
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[N. B. — Oaths reqtured by the act, except upon hearings in coitrt, may
be administered by referees and by officers authorized to administer
oaths in proceedings before the courts of the United States, or vmder
the laws of the State where the same are to be taken. Bankrupt
Act of 1898, c. 4, Sec. 20.]
These forms to be followed. Gen. Ord. XXXVIII. Sec, 30.
[Form No. 1.]
DEBTOR'S PETITION.
To the Honorable ,
Judge of the District Court of the United States
for the District of :
The petition of , of , in the county of ,
and district and State of , [state occupation], respectfully
represents:
That he has had his principal place of business [or has resided, or has
had his domicil] for the greater portion of six months next immediately
preceding the filing of this petition at , within said judicial dis-
trict; that he owes debts which he is iinable to pay in full; that he is
willing to surrender all his property for the benefit of his creditors except
such as is exempt by law, and desires to obtain the benefit of the acts
of Congress relating to bankruptcy.
That the schedule hereto annexed, marked A, and verified by your
petitioner's oath, contains a full and true statement of all his debts, and
(so far as it is possible to ascertain) the names and places of residence
of his creditors, and such further statements concerning said debts as
are required by the provisions of said acts:
That the schedule hereto annexed, marked B, and verified by your
petitioner's oath, contains an acctirate inventory of all his property,
both real and personal, and such further statements concerning said
property as are required by the provisions of said acts:
Wherefore your petitioner prays that he may be adjudged by the
court to be a bankrupt within the purview of said acts.
-, Attorney.
United States of America, District of
285
286 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
I, , the petitioning debtor mentioned and described in
the foregoing petition, do hereby make solemn oath that the statements
contained therein are^true according to the best of my knowledge, in-
formation, and belief.
, Petitioner.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D
19—.
(Official character.)
Notes,
Petition defined Sec. 1 (20).
As to petitions see Sec. 59, ante, and notes.
Petitions and schedules to be printed or written out plainly without
abbreviation or interlineation. Gen. Ord. V.
Addresses of creditors should state street and number or schedules
will be defective. If street and number not given it must be shown
that a diligent effort was made to obtain them. Re Brumelkamp, (1899)
Nor. Dist. N. Y., Coxe, J., 95 Fed., 814; 2 A. B. R., 318; 1 N. B. N., 360.
As to who may become bankrupts see Sec. 4.
When petitions are filed against the same person in different districts
Gen. Ord. VI.
As to Residence of Petitioner within the District see Sec. 2 (1) ante.
As to bankrupt's duty to file schedules see Sec. 7 (8).
As to verification of petition see Sec. 18c and notes.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
287
CM S
« i
O .3
CO a
\K-
:^e
op S
o
B
<
o
1 !
1
«9
1
1
Nature and consideration of the debt,
and whether contracted as partner
or j oint contractor ; and if so, with
whom.
•3
1
3
Residence (if un-
known, that fact
must be stated.)
1
s
a
e3
Reference to ledger
or voucher.
Claims which have pri-
ority.
(3.)
Taxes and debts due
ajid owing to the
Uniited States.
(2.)
Taxes due and owing
to the State of ,
or to any county, dis
trict, or municipality
thereof.
(3.)
Wages due workmen,
clerks or servants, to
an amount not exceed
ing $300 each, earned
within three months
before filing the pe-
tition.
a
c
'>
* >
-0 >.
t- *^
a.-r
•s °
O
^S
rt wyj
a
288
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
>.S
0) o
•a o
S»-
9 Hi
e S
8 -2^
I ""2
^ ^ IS
§ o >;
K *» O
^ MO
< OS
!> *-
I |5
I ^1
d a>
■^i
s§
"3 «_,
" oj ^
* 3'
•pa"
SO..
I on S
CQs a
-.2 i<
ao
0
o
I
M
•sl
11
6
t»
2 o
4) « 2
I
Description of securities.
'
Hi
« .«
2 0-°
1"'
1
o
i
1
Is
©
Pi
w
13
o
I
c^
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
289
•S >>
11
k
St
.a
12
§1
V V
2o
•sf §
CO ' o o
"-^ »"Oja
O "^
"I-
mn
k s
O L.
li
!l
25 g
SS a
s|l
§s|
a|8
* _
• **■"
7 C8-3
ffl§te
1-0
- 0-f ': a
5-0 O.tJ
0-0 * S o
o »
•S 3 o b a
St? a -3
S>s o g
^ P V o eS
si
a--S
o "
fl so
^ «
rs
■2-
w
a
o
•a
o
c:
.^■m
290
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
S-3
> e § h
2
"!o-§
*»
u
§
o
S
<
••
i fc-
fl 0
8^5
S2'5
^sg-
ESJ!
go--
0) ^T3
►• o ..
»■" IT
loi
^ufe
^.gtt
>>«' t.
■£?>:«>
— S5-a
^
-s Qi-w
J3 O
■5
JS>.
§
re of
cted
h an
om.
3 os.-sja
HH^^
S5
a
o
S-o
«> s
b-S
Co
.0 at
^^3
«
u
«
0^
^
CS
•<3 .
--■o
a o
IS
a <a
•SJ
=5**
•*3 2
«a
"•»»
C o
c ea
^<s
a>
tf
s
00
(m
1"^
O o
■a a
*
•xJd
o«
■) 09
» .
a^
CS —
iz;
ki
o
■>
o
M
13 .
« L.
— o
OJCJ
'
■w u
si
a >
1 '
a>
u
o
1
"S
1 1
tf
.tr
3
TS
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
291
«*• o
I" 5
a
9
i
<
0
«•
Whether liability was contracted as
partner of joint contractor, or with
any other person; and if bo, with
whom.
•3
1
Place where con-
tracted.
is
S eS
! 1
l-sa
0OJ3-S
a a-cs
:25|
t
"o
.a
"o
S
B
03
1.
S-3
|S
> o
t) 08
S.a
Oof
.2-3
o
.a
5
M
S® .
.
O
5:3 S
O
~ o8
§1 -^
s
g-
•
■<
c-e
o
^^ "^
i
>i
n >, 0
.3 -^
3
.. l-o
So>t?
'-< £
.<rt
Qo „
<-;^ ;£
3 ^
C.
•C ha a"a
1 <J
, Dist
of —
who,
ankru
^ -3
73
erica
day
and
to b
5 ^
1 y
l|«^
o
~'isi
CO
lited States
On this
regoing ach
Congress r
Si
S
1
t=
o«a
•M a
292
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
o w
H
tJ 1
1
s
u
§.>
«1
••
i
1.
a o
.Ho
•^ Ui
u o
e8j3
a«
»3
P
i
o
o
rt
H
m
««
^««j
aJ3
J3-^
■
-'S
-,*»
§^
Ot3
f
fi a
i§
;
s>;
i
ag
u 09
a
1^
s
3
1
>>
«§
2
ja
•§
>>
•s
o
«
Is
S
1
a
09
"o
a
_o
a
B
•o
■ta
s
1
g
o
1
hJ
C^
a
o
a
^
3
o
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
293
si?
>>
" oj O
fell
a? I
- . N s-2 a -
s s £ 0-3 a £ S s-o S.3
o o
OP9 tt!
I MINI. I i
o
0
CO
294
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
a,
OS'S
tf
c
„ J,
■si
■" o
-" >
■2-
0
T
3-2
s«
"3
'1^
T ,
1
V
01 U
4) >*
Q
1
CO
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
295
a
>,
H
«
^
s
.a
>
a
0
o
u]
&
T)
^
o
g
>,
■a
b
s
>.a
axi
o
1
1
s
,«J
^
;g
1
>
§
a
o
fe^2
O 0) o, J*
&■" 5 a
X _
£ « o o
3J5 o
O O BQ CO
■§2*2
« o 2 =2
g"o»
■s
ISC
op
m pk
o «
tj**
OJ.S
12
o o
2o
o
B
> s
* £
E"" a
■tf ® c
,£3 ^J2
CO
o
to
V
a.
o
o
-t->
<u
a
3
5
J5
a
0
rt
C/3J3
n
<*-i
■»j
w
<i)
0
(d
c
0
<u
♦J
<d
eo
296
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
1^
13 Ooo
•2 g OS
"■^ a
13 •- O
aa a
.a o a*;
a
claimed
h ether r
- and re
; the ex
>>^$a
C
t -'^'^
si
S a^ «
• g-.2 a £
o 5 V u
s
(^
03
&
SH
O
4J
<dco
y
>
<u
0)
C/3
ft{
00 T)
10 Tf
^
>>M
«
01
d
M
O
a
]^
*i
2
(U
a
"o
a
B
M
J3
<u
«
u
s
o
^
o
-«->
-t-"
+J
g
(/]
o
<
c
■»-»
ai
^^
w
1— 1
ti
ts
N—-'
o
<
o
I/}
4)
CO
&
u
m
3
a
^^
•o
"3
c
o
o
X
"o
O
w
-<->
CO
L+-I
a
o
O
S
+J
■t->
(U
-t->
s
6
o
0)
3
cr
Si
WWW
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
297
SCHEDULE B. (6)
BOOKS, PAPEBS, DEEDS, AND WSITINGS RELATING TO BANKBtTPTS B17SINESS AND E8TATD.
The following is a true list of all books, papers, deeds, and writings relating to my trade,
business, dealings, estate, and eflfects, or any part thereof, which, at the date of this pe-
tition, are in my possession or under my custody and control, or which are in the possession
or custody of any person in trust for me, or for my use, benefit, or advantage; and also
of all others which have been heretofore, at any time, in my possession, or under my
custody or control, and which are now held by the parties whose names are hereinafter
set forth, with the reason for their custody of the same.
Booki.
Deeds.
Papers.
-, Petitioner.
Oath to Schedule B.
United States of America, District of , ss.
On this day of , A. D. 19 — , before me personally came
, the person mentioned in and who was subscribed to
the foregoing schedule, and who, being by me first duly sworn, did de-
clare the said schedule to be a statement of all his estate, both real and
personal, in accordance with the acts of Congress relating to bankruptcy.
[Official character. "l
Note.
See notes to schedule A.
As to title to property see Sec. 70.
298
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
I SUMMARY OF DEBTS AND ASSETS.
[From the statements of the bankrupt in Schedules A and B.]
Schedule A..
Schedule A..
Schedule A..
Schedule A..
Schedule A..
Schedule B..
Schedule B..
Schedule B..
Schedule B..
Schedule B..
Schedule B..
1 (1) Taxes and debts due United States
1 (2) Taxes due States, counties, districts, and
municipalities „
1 (3) Wages
1(4) ' -
1
2-a
2-b
2-c
2-d
2-e
2-f
I:!
2-i
2-k
2-1
2-ni
3-a
3-b
3-c
3-d
3-«
4
5
6
Other debts preferred by law
Secured claims »
Unsecured claims
Notes and bills which ought to be paid by
other parties thereto
Accommodation paper
Schedule A, total
Real estate
Cash on hand
Bills promissory notes, and securities
Stock in trade _
Household goods, &c
Books, prints, and pictures
Horses, cows, and other animals....
Carriages and other vehicles .
Farming stock and implements .
Shipping and shares in vessels
Machinery, tools, &c
Patents, copywrights, and trade-marks
Other personal property
Debts due on open accounts
Stocks, negotiable bonds, &c
Policies of insurance
Unliquidated claims
Deposits of money in banks and elsewhere....
Property in reversion, remainder, trust, &c..
Property claimed to be excepted ,
Books, deeds, and papers
Schedule B, total..
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 299
[Form No. 2.]
Partnership Petition.
To the Honorable ,
Judge of the District Court of the United States
for the District of :
The petition of respectfully represents:
That your petitioners and have been partners under the
firm name of , having their principal place of business at
, in the county of , and district and State of , for
the greater portion of the six months next immediately preceding the
filing of this petition ; that the said partners owe debts which they are tm-
able to pay in fvtll ; that your petitioners are willing to surrender aU their
property for the benefit of their creditors, except such as is exempt by
law, and desire to obtain the benefit of the acts of Congress relating to
bankruptcy.
That the schedule hereto annexed, marked A, and verified by oath
contains a full and true statement of all the debts of said partners, and,
as far as possible, the names and places of residence of their creditors, and
such further statements concerning said debts as are required by the
provisions of said acts.
That the schedule hereto annexed, marked B, verified by oath ,
contains an accurate inventory of all the property, real and personal,
of said partners, and such further statements concerning said property
as are required by the provisions of said acts.
And said further states that the schedvde hereto annexed,
marked C, verified by his oath, contains a full and true statement of all
his individual debts, and, as far as possible, the names and places of
residence of his creditors, and such further statements concerning said
debts as are required by the provisions of said acts; and that the schedule
hereto annexed, marked D, verified by his oath, contains an accurate
inventory of all his individual property, real and personal, and such fur-
ther statements concerning said property as are required by the provisions
of said acts.
And said further states that the schedule hereto annexed
marked E, verified by his oath, contains a fuU and true statement of aU
his individual debts, and, as far as possible, the names and places of
residence of his creditors, and such further statements concerning said
debts as are required by the provisions of said acts; and that the schedule
hereto annexed, marked F, verified by his oath, contains an accurate
inventory of all his individual property, real and personal, and such fxir-
ther statements concerning said property as are required by the provisions
of said acts.
And said further states that the schedule hereto an-
300 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
nexed, marked G, verified by his oath, contains a full and true statement
of all his individual debts, and, as far as possible, the names and places
of residence of his creditors, and such further statements concerning said
debts as are required by the provisions of said acts; and that the schedule
hereto annexed, marked H, verified by his oath, contains an accurate
inventory of all his individual property, real and personal, and such fur-
ther statements concerning said property as are required by the provisions
of said acts.
And said further states that the schedule hereto an-
nexed, marked J, verified by his oath, contains a full and true statement
of all his individual debts, and, as far as possible, the names and places
of residence of his creditors, and such further stateinents concerning said
debts as are required by the provisions of said acts, and that the schedule
hereto annexed, marked K, verified by his oath, contains an accurate
inventory of all his individual property, real and personal, and such fur-
ther statements concerning said property as are required by the provisions
of said acts.
Wherefore your petitioners pray that said firm may be adjudged by a
decree of the court to be bankrupts within the purview of said acts.
Petitioners.
, Attorney .
, the petitioning debtors mentioned and described in
the foregoing petition, do hereby make solemn oath that the statements
contained therein are true according to the best of their knowledge, in-
formation, and belief.
Petitioners.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D.
19—.
[Official character.}
[Schedules to be annexed corresponding with schedules under Form
No. 1.]
Notes.
As to partnership petitions see ante Sec. 5.
As to priority of petitions see Gen. Ord. VII.
For proceedings in partnership cases Gen. Ord. VIII.
For involuntary petitions in different districts, Gen. Ord. VI. As to
domicile and residence and court's jurisdiction to adjudicate in bank-
ruptcy, Sec. 2 (1). See notes to Form No. 1, ante.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 301
[Form No. 3.]
Creditor's Petition.
To the Honorable , judge of the District Court of the
United States for the District of :
The petition of , of , and , of ,
and , of , respectfully shows:
That , of , has for the greater portion of six months
next preceding the date of filing this petition, had his principal place of
business, [or resided, or had his domicil] at , in the county of
and State and district aforesaid, and owes debts to the amotint of SI, 000.
That your petitioners are creditors of said , having
provable claims amounting in the aggregate, in excess of securities held
by them, to the sum of $500. That the nature and amoxmt of your pe-
titioners' claims are as follows:
And your petitioners further represent that said
solvent, and that within four months next preceding the date of this
petition the said committed an act of bankruptcy, in that
he did heretofore, to wit, on the day of ■
Wherefore your petitioners pray that service of this petition, with a
subpoena, may be made upon , as provided in the acts of
Congress relating to bankruptcy, and that he may be adjudged by the
coxirt to be a bankrupt within the purview of said acts.
Petitioners.
Attorney.
United States of America, District of , ss:
, , , being three of the pe-
titioners above named, do hereby make solemn oath that the statements
contained in the foregoing petition, subscribed by them, are true.
Before me, , this day of , 19 — .
(Official character.)
[Schedules to be annexed corresponding with schedules vmder Form
No. 1.]
302 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
Notes.
As to creditors in involuntary petitions see ante Sec. 59. Duty to
file schedules Gen. Ord. XI. As to schedules in involuntary cases, see
G^en. Ord. IX and notes.
See notes to Form No. 1.
As to insolvency and acts of bankruptcy, see sec. 3. As to issuance and
return of the subpoena, see Sec. 18 (a) and notes.
The schedules may be annexed to the petition when it is filed, but
the petition and schedules may be filed separately, the latter written four
days after the date of adjudication, Gen. Ord. XI.
This form must be strictly followed. The petition is bad if it asks for
more than to have the insolvent debtor declared bankrupt. Mather v.
Coe, Powers & Co. (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks, J., 90 Fed., 333; 1 A. B.
R., 504; 1 A. B. N., 554.
Where rules of court prescribe printed form it must bemused. Mahoney
V. Ward (1900), E. Dist. N. C, Pumell, J., 100 Fed., 278; 3 A. B. R.,
770; 2. N. B. N., 538.
Unless duplicate copy required by 59c filed within four months of acts
of bankruptcy proceeding of no force even if original was filed in time,
/n re Stevenson (1899), Dist. Del., Bradford, J., 94 Fed., 110; 2 A. B. R.
66; 1 N. B. N., 313.
Alleging more than found in this petition is multifariousness. Mather
v. Coe (1899), Nor. Dist. O., Richs, J., 92 Fed., 333; 1 A. B. R., 504; 1 N.
B. N., 294; In re Ogles (1899), W. Dist. Tenn., Hammond, J., 93 Fed.,
426; 1 A. B. R., 671; 1 N. B. N., 326.
Where creditor answers involuntary petition and alleges that defendant
is not insolvent, the allegations of the answer must be taken as true if
the case is submitted on pleadings. In re Taylor (1900), C. C. A., 7th
Cir., Btmn, J., 102 Fed., 728; 4 A. B. R., 415.
Form 3 was clearly intended for a creditor's petition against a partner-
ship, Mather v. Coe, Powers & Co. (1899), N. Dist. Ohio, Ricks, J.,
92 Fed., 333; 1 A. B. R., 504; 1 N. B, N., 554.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 303
fFORM No. 4.]
Order to show Cause upon Creditor's Petition.
In the District Coixrt of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
In Bankruptcy.
Upon consideration of the petition of that •
be declared a bankrupt, it is ordered that the said do
appear at this court, as a court of bankruptcy, to be holden at , in
the district aforesaid, on the day of , at — o'clock in the
noon, and show cause, if any there be, why the prayer of said
petition should not be granted; and
It is further ordered that a copy of said petition, together with a writ
of subpcEna, be served on said , by delivering the same to
him personally or by leaving the same at his last usual place of abode in
said district, at least five days before the day aforesaid.
Witness the Honorable , judge of the said court, and the
seal thereof, at , in said district on the day of , A. D.
19—.
SEAL OP
I THE COURT. ) Clerk.
Note.
As to pleadings and process see ante Sec. 18 and notes, Gen. Ord. Ill
and XXXVII, and Equity Rules 13-16.
304 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 5.]
Subpoena to Alleged Bankrupt.
United States of America, District of .
To , in said district, greeting:
For certain causes offered before the District Court of the United States
of America within and for the district of , as a court of bank-
ruptcy, we command and strictly enjoin you, laying all other matters
aside and notwithstanding any excuse, that you personally appear before
our said District Court to be holden at , in said district, on the
day of , A. D. 19 , to answer to a petition
filed by in our said court, praying that you may be ad-
judged a bankrupt; and to do fvu-ther and receive that which our said
District Court shall consider in this behalf. And this you are in no wise
to omit, under the pains and penalties of what may befall thereon.
Witness the Honorable , judge of said court, and the
seal thereof, at , this day of A. D. 19 .
f Seal op the \ ' Clerk
\ Court, j z,i*r>^.
Note.
See Sec. 18a and notes thereto, together with Gen. Ord. XXXVII and
Equity rules 12-21. relative to the issuance of, service of and seal
on process.
.^ -„..^.^t^ ^-_ _._._.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
305
[Form No. 6.]
Denial of Bankruptcy.
In the District Court of the United States for the —
District of
In the matter of
At
And now the said
-, in said district, on the
■ In Bankruptcy.
day of
A. D. 19-
appears, and denies that he has com-
mitted the act of bankruptcy set forth in said petition, or that he is in-
solvent, and avers that he should not be declared bankrupt for any cause
in said petition alleged ; and this he prays may be inquired of by the court
[or, he demands that the same may be inquired of by a jury].
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
19—.
day of
-. A. D.
[Official character.]
Note.
As to denial of bankruptcy see Sec. 18b ante. Trials by jury See
Sec. 19.
306
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No 7.]
Order for Jury Trial.
In the District Court of the United States for the -
District of ■
In the matter of
■ In Bankruptcy.
At
-, in said district, on the
day of
Upon the demand in writing filed by
19—
, alleged to be a
bankrupt, that the fact of the commission by him of an act of bankruptcy
and the fact of his insolvency may be inquired of by a jury, it is ordered
that said issue be submitted to a jury.
J Seal op the {.
J Cgcrt. f
Clerk.
Note.
As to when a jury trial may be demanded see Sec. 19 post and notes.
See Gen. Ord. Ill as to seal of court on process.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 307
[Form No. 8.)
Specui. Warrant to Marshal.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of-
In the matter of
■ In Bankruptcy.
To the marshal of said district or to either of his deputies, greeting:
Whereas a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy was, on the day
of , A. D. 19 — , filed against , of the Cotmty
of and State of , in said district, and said petition is still
pending; and whereas it satisfactorily appears that said has
committed an act of bankruptcy [or has neglected or is neglecting, or is
about to so neglect his property that it has thereby deteriorated or is
thereby deteriorating or is about thereby to deteriorate in value], you
are therefore authorized and required to seize and take possession of all
the estate, real and personal, of said , and of all his deeds,
books of accovmt, and papers, and to hold and keep the same safely sub-
ject to the further order of the court.
Witness the Honorable , judge of the said court, and
the seal thereof, at , in said district, on the of , A. D.
19 .
1 Seal or the \
( COUBT. J
Clerk.
RETURN BY MARSHAL THEREON.
By virtue of the within warrant, I have taken possession of the estate
of the within-named , and of all his deeds, books of accotmt,
and papers which have come to my knowledge.
Marshal [or Deputy Marshal.}
308 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
Fees and expenaet.
1. Service of warrant
2. Neceasary travel, at the rate of six cents a mile each way
3. Actual expenses in custody of property and other services as fol-
Here state the particulars.}
Marshal or Deputy Marshal].
District of
A. D. 19—.
Personally appeared before me the said
and made oath
that the above expenses returned by him have been actually inctirred and
paid by him, and are just and reasonable.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
Sec. 2, (3) , (5) , gives authority to bankruptcy courts to appoint mar-
shals. As to seizure of bankrupt's property prior to adjudication Sec.
3e and Sec. 69. See also Sec. 18a, Gen. Ord. Ill, and Equity Rule XV
as to issuance and service of process.
Before the issuing of the warrant the petitioners must file aflfidavits
showing that property is deteriorating in value and file a bond to in-
demnify the bankrupt for any loss he may suffer. Sec. 69 ante. See
also notes to above.
Gen. Ord. XIX covers return of marshal under oath as to his actual
and necessary expenses. Oath may be administered by persons specified
in Sec 20.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 309
[Form No. 9]
Bond of Petitioning Creditor.
Know all men by these presents; That we , , as principal,
and , as sureties, are held and firmly bound unto
, in full and just sum of dollars, to be paid to the said
, executors, administrators, or assigns, to which payment,
well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, oxxr heirs, executors, and
administrators, jointly and severally, by these presents.
Signed and sealed this day of A. D., 19 — .
The condition of this obligation is such that whereas a petition in bank-
ruptcy has been filed in the district court of the United States for the
district of against the said , and the said has
applied to that court for a warrant to the marshal of said district directing
him to seize and hold the property of said , subject to the
further orders of said district coixrt.
Now, therefore, if such a warrant shall issue for the seizure of said prop-
erty, and if the said shall indemnify the said
for such damages as he shall sustain in the event such seizure shall prove
to have been wrongfluly obtained, then the above obligation to bejvoid;
otherwise to remain in full force and virtue.
Sealed and delivered in
presence of — [seal.]
[seal.]
[seal.]
Approved this day of , A. D. 19 — .
District Judge.
Note.
See Sec. 69 as to bond given on seizure of bankrupts property prior to
adjudication. See also Sec. 3e as to sureties on bonds see Sec. 50.
310 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 10.]
Bond to Marshal.
Know all men by these presents: That we, , as principal,
and , as sureties, are held and firmly bound unto
, marshal of the United States for the district of ,
in the full and just sum of dollars, to be paid to the said
, his executors, administrators, or assigns, to which payment,
well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, our heirs, executors, and
administrators, jointly and severally, by these presents.
Signed and sealed this day of A. D. 19 — .
The condition of this obligation is such that whereas a petition in bank-
ruptcy has been filed in the district court of the United States for the
district of , against the said , and the said
court has issued a warrant to the marshal of the United States for said
district, directing him to seize and hold property of the said ,
subject to the further order of the court, and the said property has been
seized by said marshal as directed, and the said district court upon a
petition of said has ordered the said property to be re-
leased to him.
Now, therefore, if the said property shall be released accordingly to
the said , and the said , being adjudged a
bankrupt, shall turn over said property or pay the value thereof in money
to the trustee, then the above obligation to be void; otherwise to remain
in full force and virtue.
Sealed and delivered in the
presence of — [seal].
[seal].
[seal.]
Approved this day of , A. D. 19 — .
District Judge,
Note.
As to release of seizure of the bankrupt's property prior to adjudica-
tion see Sec. 69 relative to the bond required to be given by him.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 3ll
[Form No. 11.]
Adjudication that Debtor is not Bankrupt.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
1
In the matter of
In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district, on day of , A. D. 19 — , before
the Honorable , judge of the district of .
This cause came on to be heard at , in said court, upon the
petition of that be adjudged a bankrupt within the true
intent and meaning of the acts of congress relating to bankruptcy, and
[Here state the proceedings, whether there was no opposition, or, if opposed,
state what proceedings were had.]
And thereupon, and upon consideration of the proofs in said cause [and
the arguments of counsel thereon, if any], it was found that the facts set
foi'th in said petition were not proved; and it is therefore adjudged that
said was not a bankrupt, and that said petition be dismissed,
with costs.
Witness the Honorable , judge of said court, and the
seal thereof, at , in said district, on the day of , A. D.
19—.
Clerk.
J Seal of the j.
( C!OURT. J
Note.
For definition of adjudication see Sec. 1, (2).
As to acts of bankruptcy see Sec. 3; as to who may become bankrupts
Sec. 4; as to adjudications in bankruptcy Sec. 2 (1), and Sec. 18. See
Gen. Ord. XXXIV as to costs in contested cases.
312 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 12.]
Adjudication op Bankruptcy.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
in the matter of
Bankrupt.
In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district, on the day of , A. D. 19 — ,
before the Honorable , judge of said court in bankruptcy,
the petition of that be adjudged a bankrupt,
within the true intent and meaning of the acts of Congress relating to
bankruptcy, having been heard and duly considered, the said
is hereby declared and adjudged bankrupt accordingly.
"^Witness the Honorable , judge of said court, and the
seal thereof, at , in_said district, on the day of , A. D.
19—.
Clerk,
I Seal of the )
1 CiOUBT. J
Note.
See notes to Form No. 11.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
313
[Form No. 13.]
Appointment, Oath, and Report of Appraisers.
In the District coiirt of the United States for the district of •
In the matter of
In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
It is ordered that
and , of
-,of
of
-, three disinterested persons, be, and they
are hereby, appointed appraisers to appraise the real and personal prop-
erty belonging to the estate of the said bankrupt set out in the schedules
now on file in this court, and report their appraisal to the court, said
appraisal to be made as soon as may be, and the appraisers to be duly
sworn.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
District of ■
Personally appeared the within named •
Referee in Bankruptcy.
and severally made
oath that they will fully and fairly appraise the aforesaid real and per-
sonal property according to their best skill and judgment.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
19—.
day of
-, A. D.
[Official character.]
We, the undersigned, having been notified that we were appointed to
estimate and appraise the real and personal property aforesaid, have
attended to the duties assigned us, and after a strict examination and
careful inquiry, we do estimate and appraise the same as follows:
314
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
Dollars.
Cents.
In witness whereof we herexmto set our hands, at , this
day of , A. D. 19—.
Note.
As to appointment of appraisers see Sec. 70b; as to oaths see Sec. 20.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 315
[Form No. 14.]
Order of Reference.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■
"1
In the matter of
In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
Whereas , of , in the county of and district
aforesaid, on the day of , A. D. 19 — . was duly adjudged a
bankrupt upon a petition filed in this court by [or, against] him on the
day of , A. D. 19 , according to the provisions of the acts of
Congress relating to bankruptcy.
It is thereupon ordered, that said matter be referred to ,
one of the referees in bankruptcy of this court, to take such further pro-
ceedings therein as are required by said acts ; and that said
shall attend before said referee on the day of at , and
thenceforth shall submit to such orders as may be made by said referee
or by this court relating to said bankruptcy.
Witness the Honorable , judge of the said court, and the
seal thereof, at , in said district, on the day of , A.
D. 19—.
Clerk.
J Seai. op THB I
} Ck)DRT. J
Note.
As to reference of cases after adjudication see Sec. 22, and notes. See
also Gen. Ord. XII.
As to order of reference in the judges absence see Form 15.
316 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 15]
Order of Reference in Judge's Absence.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
In Bankruptcy.
Whereas on the day of , A. D. 19 — , a petition was filed
to have , of , in the cotmty of and district
aforesaid, adjudged a bankrupt according to the provisions of the acts of
Congress relating to bankruptcy ; and whereas the judge of said court was
absent from said district at the time of filing said petition [or, in case of
involuntary bankruptcy, on the next day after the last day on which plead-
ings might have been filed, and none have been filed by the bankrupt
or any of his creditors], it is thereupon ordered that said matter be referred
to , one of the referees in bankruptcy of this court, to con-
sider said petition and take such proceedings therein as are required by
said acts ; and that the said shall attend before said referee
on the day of , A. D. 19 — , at .
Witness my hand and the seal of the said court, at , in said
district, on the day of , A. D. 19 — .
Clerk.
I Seal or the )
1 - COUBT. )
Note.
As to reference in the judge's absence see Sec. 18f, g. See Form 14.
Use of this form considered. In Re Munny, (1899) N. Dist. la., Shiras,
J., 96 Fed., 600. 3 A. B. R., 601; 2 N. B. N., 164.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 317
[Form No. 16.]
Referee's Oath op Office.
I, , do solemnly swear that I will administer justice with-
out respect to persons, and do equal right to the poor and to the rich, and
that I will faithfully and impartially discharge and perform all the duties
incumbent on me as referee in bankruptcy, according to the best of my
abilities and understanding, agreeably to the Constitution and laws of the
United States. So help me God.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19-
District Judge.
Note.
As to oaths of office of referees see Sec. 36. As to Duties of Referee
see Sees. 33 to 50, inclusive.
318 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 17.]
Bond of Referee.
Know all men by these presents: That we of
as principal, and of and
of , as sureties are held and firmly bound to the
United States of America in the sum of dollars, lawful money of
the United States, to be paid to the said United States, for the payment
of which, well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, our heirs, ex-
ecutors, and administrators, jointly and severally, by these presents.
Signed and sealed this day of A. D. 19 — .
The condition of this obligation is such that whereas the said
, has been on the day of , A. D. 19 — , appointed by the
Honorable , judge of the district court of the United States
for the district of , a referee in bankruptcy, in and for the
county of , in said district, under the acts of Congress relating to
bankruptcy.
Now, therefore, if the said shall well and faithfully
discharge and perform all the duties pertaining to the said office of referee
in bankruptcy, then this obUgation to be void; otherwise to remain in
full force and virtue.
Signed and sealed
in the presence of
,[l. s.]
.[L.S.]
.[L.S.]
Approved this day of , A. D. 19 — .
District Judge.
Note.
As to bonds of referees and trustees see Sec. 50.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 319
|F0RM No. 18.]
Notice op First Meeting op Creditors.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
In Bankruptcy.
In the matter of
>• In|Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
To the creditors of , of , in the county of ', and
district aforesaid, a bankrupt.
Notice is hereby given that on the day of , A. D. 19 — , the
said was duly adjudicated bankrupt; and that the first
meeting of his creditors will be held at in , on the day
of , A. D. 19 — , at o'clock in the noon, at which time
the said creditors may attend, prove their claims, appoint a trustee, ex-
amine the bankrupt, and transact such other business as may properly
come before said meeting.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
-,19-.
Note.
As to meetings of creditors see Sec. 58 and Gen. Ord. XXI (a). As to
proof and allowance of claims see Sec. 55, 57. As to appointment of
trustees see Sec. 2 (17) 44, and general Ord. XIII. As to examinations
of bankrupts see Sec. 7a (1, 9).
320
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 19.]
Lists op Debts Proved at First Meeting.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■
In the matter of
Mn Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
J
At
fore -
-. A. D. 19—, be-
— , in said district, on the day of —
, referee in bankruptcy.
The following is a list of creditors who have this day proved their debts:
Names of creditors.
Residenc3.
Debts, proved.
Dolls. Cts.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
Referee to keep record of all proceedings in each case before him, see
Sec. 42. Referee's duty to transmit list of proved claims to Clerk.
Gen. Ord. XXIV.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 321
[Form No. 20.]
General letter of attorney in Fact when Creditor is not Repre-
sented BY Attorney at Law.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
To
I, , of , in the county of and State of
do hereby authorize you, or any one of you, to attend the meeting or
meetings of creditors of the bankrupt aforesaid at a comt of bankruptcy,
wherever advertised or directed to be holden, on the day and at the hoiu*
appointed and notified by said court in said matter, or at such other place
and time as may be appointed by the court for holding such meeting or
meetings, or at which such meeting or meetings, or any adjournment or
adjournments thereof may be held, and then and there from time to
time, and as often as there may be occasion, for me and in my name to
vote for or against any proposal or resolution that may be then sub-
mitted under the acts of Congress relating to bankruptcy; and in the
choice of trustee or trustees of the estate of the said bankrupt, and for
me to assent to such appointment of trutsee; and with like powers to
attend and vote at any other meeting or meetings of creditors, or sitting
or sittings of the court, which may be held therein for any of the purposes
aforesaid; also to accept any composition proposed by said bankrupt in
satisfaction of his debts, and to receive payment of dividends and Of
money due me under any composition, and for any other purpose in my
interest whatsoever, with full power of substitution.
In witness whereof I have hereunto signed my name and aflixed my
seal the day of , A. D. 19—.
.[L.S.]
Signed, sealed, and delivered in the presence of —
Acknowledged before me this day of , A. D. 19-
[Ofpcial character.]
Note.
As to definition of "creditor" see Sec. 1 (19). As to who may conduct
proceedings Gen. Ord. IV.
322 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
For execution of Letters of Attorney to represent creditors see Gen.
Ord. XXI (5).
As to persons who may take acknowledgments see Sec. 20 and notes.
[Form No. 21.]
Special Letter of Attorney in Fact.
In the matter of
>In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
To
I hereby authorize you, or any one of you, to attend the meeting of cred-
itors in this matter, advertised or directed to be holden at , on the
day of , before , or any adjournment thereof, and
then and there for and in name to vote for or
against any proposal or resolution that may be lawfully made or passed
at such meeting or adjourned meeting, and in the choice of trustee or
trustees of the estate of the said bankrupt.
. [L.S.]
In witness whereof I have hereunto signed my name and affixed my
seal the day of , A. D. 19 — .
Signed, sealed, and delivered in presence of —
Acknowledged before me this day of , A. D. 19 — .
(Official character.)
See notes to Form 20.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
323
[Form No. 22]
Appointment of Trustee by Creditors.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
>'In Bankruptcy.
At
fore -
-, in said district, on the
day of
-, A. D. 19—, be-
-, referee in bankruptcy.
This being the day appointed by the court for the first meeting of
creditors in the above bankruptcy, and of which due notice has been given
in the [here insert the names of the newspapers in which notice was pub-
lished], we, whose names are hereunder written, being the majority in nimi-
ber and in amoimt of claims of the creditors of the said bankrupt, whose
claims have been allowed, and who are present at this meeting, do hereby
appoint — , of , in the cotmty of and State of
, to be the trustee — of the said bankrupt's estate and effects.
Signatiires of creditors.
Residences of the same.
Amount of debt.
Dolls.
Ctfl.
Ordered that the above appointment of trustee — be, and the same is
hereby approved.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
Definition of trustee Sec. 1 (26).
As to appointment of trustees see Sec. 2 (17), 44, Gen. Ord. XIII, XIV,
XV. As to their qualifications see Sec. 44. As to meetings of creditors
see Sec. 55. As to voters at creditors' meetings see Sec. 56. As to notices
to which creditors entitled see Sec. 68, Gen. Ord. XXI (2) .
324 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 23.]
Appointment op Trustee by Referee.
In the District Cotirt of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt
In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district, on the day of , A.[D. 19 — ,|be-
fore , referee in bankruptcy.
This being the day appointed by the coxirt for the first meeting of
creditors under the said bankruptcy, and of which due notice has been
given in the [here insert the names of the newspapers in which notice was pub-
lished] I, the imdersigned referee of the said court in bankruptcy, sat at
the time and place above mentioned, pursuant to such notice, to take the
proof of debts and for the choice of trustee imder the said bankruptcy;
and I do hereby cretify that the creditors whose claims had been allowed
and were present, or duly represented, failed to make choice of a trustee
of said bankrupt's estate, and therefore I do hereby appoint
of , in the coimty of and State of , as trustee of the
same.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
See notes to Form 22.
See also Form 24.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 325
[Form No. 24.]
Notice to Trustee op His Appointment.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■
In the matter of
■ In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
To , of , in the county of , and district afore-
said:
I hereby notify you that you were duly appointed trustee [or one of the
trustees] of the estate of the above named bankrupt at the first meeting
of the creditors, on the day of , A, D. 19 — , and I have app-
proved said appointment. The penal sum of yotir bond as such trustee
has been fixed at dollars. You are required to notify me forth-
with of your acceptance or rejection of the trust.
Dated at the day of , A. D. 19—.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
Referee's duty to notify trustee of his appointment Gren. Ord. XVI.
As to bond of trustee Sec. 50b and Form 25.
326 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 25.]
Bond op Trustee.
Know all men by these presents; That we, , of , as
principal, and , of , and , of , as
sureties, are held and firmly bound unto the United States of America
in the sum of dollars, in lawful money of the United States, to be
paid to the said United States, for which payment, well and truly to be
made, we bind ourselves and our heirs, executors and administrators,
jointly and severally, by these presents.
Signed and sealed this day of A. D. 19 — .
The condition of this obligation is such, that whereas the above-named
was, on the day of , A. D. 19 , appointed
trustee in the case pending in bankruptcy in said court, wherein
is the bankrupt, and he, the said , has accepted said
trust with all the duties and obligations pertaining thereunto:
Now, therefore, if the said , trustee as aforesaid, shall
obey such orders as said court may make in relation to said trust, and
shall faithfully and truly accoimt for all the moneys, assets, and effects
of the estate of said bankrupt which shall come into his hands and pos-
session, and shall in all respects faithfully perform all his official duties as
said trustee, then this obligation to be void; otherwise, to remain in full
force and virtue.
Signed and sealed in
presence of —
, [seal.]
, [seal.]
, [seal.]
Note.
See Sec. 50b and Form 26.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 327
[Form No. 26.]
Order Approving Trustee's Bond.
At a court of bankruptcy, held in and for the District of ,
at , , this day of , 19 — .
Before , referee in bankruptcy, in the District Court of
the United States for the District of .
In the matter of
^In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
It appearing to the Court , of , and in said dis-
trict, has been duly appointed trustee of the estate of the above-named
bankrupt, and has given a bond with sureties for the faithful perform-
ance of his ofl&cial duties, in the amount fixed by the creditors [or by
order of the court], to wit, in the sum of dollars, it is ordered that
the said bond be, and the same is hereby approved.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
As to trustee's bond see Sec. 50b and Form 25.
[Form No. 27.]
Order that no Trustee be Appointed.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of-
In the matter of
/■In Bankruptcy,
Bankrupt.
It appearing that the schedule of the bankrupt discloses no assets, and
that no creditor has appeared at the first meeting, and that the appoint-
ment of a trustee of the bankrupt's estate is not now desirable, it is hereby
ordered that, until further order of the court, no trustee be appointed and
no other meeting of the creditors be called.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
No trustee cases Gen. Ord. XV.
328 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 28]
Order for Examination op Bankrupt.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
yin Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At , on the day of , A. D. 19—.
Upon the application of , trustee of said bankrupt, it is
ordered that said bankrupt, attend before , one of the
referees in bankruptcy of this court, at on the day of ,
at — o'clock in the noon, to submit to examination under the acts
of Congress relating to bankruptcy, and that a copy of this order be
delivered to him, the said bankrupt,, forthwith.
, Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
Duty of bankrupt to attend meetings of creditors and submit to ex-
amination Sec. 7a (1, 9). Duties to appear in covu-t as witness Sec. 21a:
Gen. Ord. XII (1).
[Form No. 29]
Examination op Bankrupt or Witness.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
"s
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At , in said district, on the day of , A. D. 19 — , be-
fore , one of the referees in bankruptcy of said court.
, of , in the county of ,and State of ,
being duly sworn and examined at the time and place above mentioned,
upon his oath says. [Here insert substance of examination of party.]
, Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
Examination and testimony of bankrupts, Sec. 7a (1, 9), 21, Gen. Ord,
XXII and notes.
For contempts before referees. Sec. 41. See also Forms 28, 30l
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
329
[Form No. 30.]
Summons to Witness.
To
-.of
-, in the county of
-, and State
Whereas
of , has been duly adjudged bankrupt, and the proceeding in
bankruptcy is pending in the District Coxirt of the United States for the
District of ,
These are to require you, to whom this summons is directed, personally
to be and appear before , one of the referees in bankruptcy
of the said court, at , on the day of , at — o'clock in
the noon, then and there to be examined in relation to said bank-
ruptcy.
Witness the Honorable —
at , this day of
Judge of said court and the seal thereof
-, A. D. 19—.
, Clerk.
Return of Summons to Witness.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt .
> In Bankruptcy.
On this day of , A. D. 19 — , before me came
, in the county of and State of , and makes oath,
and says that he did, on , the day of , A. D. 19 — ,
of
-, of
-, in the county of
and
personally serve
State of , with a true copy of the summons hereto annexed, by
delivering the same to him; and he further makes oath, and says that he
is not interested in the proceeding in bankruptcy named in said summons.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19-
NOTES.
Orders to require attendance of witnesses, Sec. 21; test and process
Gen. Ord. III. Oaths, Sec. 20.
330 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 31.]
Proof op Unsecured Debt.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
— 1
In the matter of
Bankrupt
In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district of , on the day of , A. D.
19 — , came ,of , in the county of , in said
district of , and made oath, and says that , the person
by [or against] whom a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy has been
filed, was at and before the filing of said petition, and still is, justly and
truly indebted to said deponent in the sum of dollars; that the
consideration of said debt is as follows:
that no part of said debt has been paid [except-
that there are no set-offs or counterclaims to the same [except-
];
and that deponent has not, nor has any person by his order, or to his
knowledge or belief, for his use, had or received any manner of security
for said debt whatever.
Creditor.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19 — .
[Official character.]
Notes.
Proof and allowance of claims Sec. 57, Gen. Ord. XXI (1).
If note given it should be filed with proof, Sec. 57b. If it is desired to
compute interest on the claim, then a further allegation should be made
setting out the time when debt became due, Gen. Ord. XXI (1).
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 331
[Form No. 32.]
Proof op Secured Debt.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
^
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
► In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district of , on the day of , A. D.
19 — , came , of , in the county of , in said
district of , and made oath, and says that , the person
by [or against] whom a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy has been
filed, was at and before the filing of said petition, and still is, justly and
truly indebted to said deponent, in the sum of dollars; that the
consideration of said debt is as follows -;
that no part of said debt has been paid [except ];
that there are no set-offs or counterclaims to the same [except ];
and that the only securities held by this deponent for said debt are the
following :
Creditor.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of A. D. 19 — .
[Official character.]
Notes.
As to secured debts see Sec. 57 and Gen. Ord. XXI. See notes to Form
No. 31.
332 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 33.]
Proof of Debt Due Corporation.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
>-In Bankruptcy.
At , in said district of , on the day of , A. D.
19 — , came , of , in the county of and State
of , and made oath and says that he is of the , cor-
poration incorporated by and under the laws of the State of , and
carrying on business at , in the cotmty of and State of
, and that he is duly authorized to make this proof, and says that
the said , the person by [or against] whom a petitioner for
adjudication of bankruptcy has been filed, was at and before the filing
of the said petition, and still is justly and truly indebted to said corpora-
tion in the sum of dollars ; that the consideration of said debt is as
follows: — — — —
that no part of said debt has been paid [except-
claims to the same [except-
-] ; that there are no set-oflfs or counter
-]; and that said corporation has not, nor has
any person by its order, or to the knowledge or belief of said deponent,
for its use, had or received any manner of security for said debt whatever.
■ of said corporation.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19 — .
[Offictal character.]
Notes.
See notes to Forms 31, 32.
As to proofs of claim by corporation, Gen. Ord. XXI(l).
As to definition of corporation, Sec. 1(b) and notes.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 333
[Form No. 34.1
Proof of Debt by Partnership.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■
In the matter of
Vln Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At , in said district of , on the day of , A. D
19 — , came , of , in the county of , in sai^
district of , and made oath and says that he is one of the firm of
, consisting of himself and , of , in
the county of and State of ; that the said , the
person by [or against] whom a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy has
been filed, was at and before the filing of said petition, and still is, justly
and truly indebted to this deponent's said firm in the sum of dol-
lars; that the consideration of said debt is as follows:
that no part of said debt has been paid [except ];
that there are no set-offs or cotmterclaims to the same [except ];
and this deponent has not, nor has his said firm, nor any person by their
order, or to this deponent's knowledge or belief, for their use, had or re-
ceived any manner of security for said debt whatever.
Creditor.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19 — .
[Official character.]
Notes.
See notes to forms 31, 32, 33. See Gen. Ord. XXI.
334 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
' fFoRM No. 35.1
Proof of Debt by Agent or Attorney.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
> In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At in said district of on the day of , A. D.
19 — , came , of , in the coimty of , and State
of , attorney [or authorized agent] of , in the county of
, and State of , and made oath and says that ,
the person by [or against] whom a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy
has been filed, was at and before the filing of said petition, and still is,
justly and truly indebted to the said , in the sum of
dollars; that the consideration of said debt is as follows:
that no part of said debt has been paid [except
]:
and that this deponent has not, nor has any person by his order, or to this
deponent's knowledge or belief, for his use had or received any manner of
sectirity for said debt whatever. And this deponent further says, that
this deposition can not be made by the claimant in person because
and that he is duly authorized by his principal to make this affidavit,
and that it is within his knowledge that the aforesaid debt was incurred
as and for the consideration above stated, and that such debt, to the best
of his knowledge and belief, still remains unpaid and unsatisfied.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Notes.
See notes to Forms No. 31, 32, 33, 34.
[Official character.]
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 335
[Form No. 36.]
Proof op Secured Debt by Agent.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of .
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
y
At , in said district of ,on the day of , A. D.
19 — , came , of , in the county of , and State
of , attorney [or authorized agent] of , in the county of
, and State of , and made oath, and says that ,
tha person by [or against] whom a petition for adjudication of bankruptcy
has been filed, was, at and before the fiUng of said petition, and still is,
justly and truly indebted to the said in the sum of
dollars; that the consideration of said debt is as follows:
that no part of said debt has been paid [except-
that there are no set-offs or coimter claims to the same [except-
. . ];
and that the only securities held by said for said debt are the fol-
lowing:
and this deponent further says that this deposition can not be made by
the claimant in person because
and that he is duly authorized by his principal to make this deposition,
and that it is within his knowledge that the aforesaid debt was incvured as
and for the consideration above stated.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19-
[Official character.]
Notes.
See notes to Forms 31, 32, 33, 34. ]
336
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 37.]
Affidavit of Lost Bill, or Note.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
/•In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
day of •
-, A. D. 19— , at
-, came
-, and State of
-, and makes oath
On this
of , in the county of
and says that the bill of exchange [or note], the particulars whereof are
underwritten, has been lost under the following circumstances, to wit.
and that he, this deponent, has not been able to find the same; and this
deponent further says that he has not, nor has the said , or
any person or persons to their use, to this deponent's knowledge or belief,
negotiated the said bill [or note], nor in any manner parted with or as-
signed the legal or beneficial interest therein, or any ; . ir thereof; and that
he, this deponent, is the person now legally and beneficially interested
in the same.
Bill or note above referred to.
Date.
Drawer or maker.
Acceptor.
Sum.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of , A. D. 19-
NOTES,
See notes to Forms 31, 32, 33, 34.
(Official character.)
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 337
[Form No. 38.]
Order Reducing Claim.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ' ■ ".
In the matter of
>'In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At , in said district, on the day of , A. D. 19 — .
Upon the evidence submitted to this court the claim of against
said estate [and if the fact be so, upon hearing coxmsel thereon], it is
ordered, that the amount of said claim be reduced from the sum of
as set forth in the affidavit in proof of claim filed by said creditor in said
case, to the sum of , and that the latter-named sum be entered
upon the books of the trustee as the true sum upon which a dividend
shall be computed [if with interest, with interest thereon from the day
of , A. D. 19—].
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
As to re-examination, reduction, or disallowance of claims, see Sec. 3
(2), 57d, f, k, 1, and Gen. Ord. XXI (6).
[Form No. 39]
Order Expunging Claim.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■ ■"-■".
In the matter of
>"In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
/
At , in said district, on the day of , A. D. 19-
Upon the evidence submitted to the court upon the claim of
against said estate [and, if the fact be so, upon hearing conusel thereon],
it is ordered that said claim be disallowed and exptmged from the list of
claims upon the trustee's record in said case.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
See notes to Form 3S.
338
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 40.]
List of Claims and Dividends to be Recorded by Repbreb and by
HIM Delivered to Trustee.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of .
In the matter of
Bankrupt .
>'In Bankruptcy.
At
, in said district, on the <
iay of
A.D.
19—.
No.
Creditors.
[To be placed alphabetically, and the names
of all the parties to the proof to be care-
fully set forth.]
Sum proved.
Dividend.
-
Dollars.
Cents.
Dollars.
Cents.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
Duty of referee to declare dividends, Sec. 39a(l) .
Declaration and payments of dividends. Sec. 47a, 55.
As to notices to creditors of the declaration and time of payment, Sec.
58a(5).
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
339
[Form No. 41.]
Notice of Dividend.
In the District Court of the United States for the
District of ■
In the matter of
Bankrupt .
►-In Bankruptcy.
At
-, on the
day of
-, A. D. 19—.
To
Creditor of
-, bankrupt:
I hereby inform you that you may, on application at my office, ,
on the day of , or on any day thereafter, between the hours of
-, receive a warrant for the
dividend due to you out of the
above estate. If you can not personally attend, the warrant will be de-.
Uvered to yotir order on yoiu" filling up and signing the subjoined letter
, Trustee.
Creditor's Letter to Trustee.
To
-, bankrupt:
Trustee in bankruptcy of the estate of
Please deliver to the warrant for dividend payable out
of the said estate to me.
Notes.
Notices to be given by referee, 58.
See as to notices, Gen. Ord. XXI.
See notes to Form No. 40.
Creditor.
340 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 42.]
Petition and Order for Sale by Auction of Real Estate.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of —
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
J
Respectfully represents , trustee of the estate of said bankrupt
that it would be for the benefit of said estate that a certain portion of the
real estate of said bankrupt, to wit; [here describe it and its estimated value]
should be sold by auction, in lots or parcels, and upon terms and con-
ditions as follows:—— — — —
Wherefore he prays that he may be authorized to make sale by auction
of said real estate as aforesaid.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
, Trustee.
The foregoing petition having been duly filed, and having come on for
hearing before me, of which hearing ten day's notice was given by mail to
creditors of said bankrupt, now, after due hearing, no adverse interest
being represented thereat [or after hearing in favor of said
petition and in opposition thereto], it is ordered that the
said trustee be authorized to sell the portion of the bankrupt's real estate
specified in the foregoing petition, by auction, keeping an accurate accotmt
of each lot or parcel sold and the price received therefor and to whom sold;
which said account he shall file at once with the referee.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
As to sale of real and personal property, see Sec. 70b and Gen. Ord.
XVIII.
As to notices to creditors of sales of property, Sec, 58a (4),
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 341
|F0RM No. 43.]
Petition and Order for Redemption of Property from Lien.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
.y
Respectfully represents , trustee of the estate of said
bankrupt, that a certain portion of said bankrupt's estate, to wit: [here
describe the estate or property and its estimated value] is subject to a mort-
gage [describe tJie mortgage], or to a conditional contract [describing it], or
to a lien [describe the origin and nature of the lien], [or, if the property be
personal property, has been pledged or deposited and is subject to a lien]
for [describe the nature of the lien], and that it would be for the benefit of
the estate that said property should be redeemed and discharged from
the lien thereon. Wherefore he prays that he may be empowered to
pay out of the assets of said estate in his hands the sum of , being
the amount of said hen, in order toredeem said property therefrom.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
, Trustee.
The foregoing petition having been duly filed and having come on for
a hearing before me, of which hearing ten days' notice was given by mail
to creditors of said bankrupt, now, after due hearing, no adverse interest
being represented thereat [or after hearing in favor of said
petition and in opposition thereto], it is ordered that the
said trustee be authorized to pay out of the assets of the bankrupt's
estate specified in the foregoing petition the sum of , being the
amoiint of the lien, in order to redeem the property therefrom.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
Redemption of property and compovmding of claims. Gen. Ord. XXVIII
Notice to creditors, 58a(4),
342 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No 44.]
Petition and Order for Sale Subject to Lien.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt
>'In Bankruptcy.
Respectfully represents , trustee of the estate of said
bankrupt, that a certain portion of said bankrupt's estate, to wit: [here
describe the estate or property and its estimated value] is subject to a mort-
gage [describe mortgage], or to a conditional contract [describe it], or to
a lien [describe the origin and nature of tlie lien], or [if the property be personal
property] has been pledged or deposited and is subject to a lien for [describe
the nature of the lien], and that it would be for the benefit of the said estate
that said property shoidd be sold, subject to said mortgage, lien, or other
Incumbrance. "Wherefore he prays that he may be authorized to make
sale of said property, subject to the incumbrance thereon.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
, Trustee.
The foregoing petition having been duly filed and having come on for
a hearing before me, of which hearing ten days' notice was given by mail
to creditors of said bankrupt, now, after due hearing no adverse interest
being represented thereat [or after hearing in favor of said
petition and in opposition thereto], it is ordered that the
said trustee be authorized to sell the portion of the bankrupt's estate
specified in the foregoing petition, by auction [or, at private sale], keeping
an accurate account of the property sold and the price received therefor
and to whom sold; which said accotmt he shall file at once with the referee.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
As to sale of property see Sec. 70b, Gen. Ord. XVIII.
Notices to creditors, Sec. 58a(4).
As to liens on property, see Sec. 67 and notes.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 343
[Form No. 45.]
Petition and Order for Private Sale.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>• In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
.J
Respectfully represents , duly appointed trustee of the
estate of the aforesaid bankrupt.
That for the following reasons, to wit — —
it is desirable and for the best interest of the estate to sell at private sale
a certain portion of the said estate, to wit:
Wherefore he prays that he may be authorized to sell the said property
at private sale.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
, Trustee.
The foregoing petition having been duly filed and having come on for
a hearing before me, of which hearing ten days' notice was given by mail
to creditors of said bankrupt, now, after due hearing, no adverse interest
being represented thereat \pr after hearing in favor of said
petition and in opposition thereto], it is ordered that the
said trustee be authorized to sell the portion of the bankrupt's estate
specified in the foregoing petition, at private sale, keeping an accurate
account of each article sold and the price received therefor and to whom
sold ; whJch said account he shall file at once with the referee.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
See notes to Form 44.
344 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 46.]
Petition and Order for Sale of Perishable Property.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of -
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
.y
Respectfully represents the said bankrupt, [or, a creditor,
or the receiver, or the trustee of the said bankrupt's estate.]
That a part of the said estate, to wit,
-, is perishable, and that there will be a loss if the same is
not sold immediately.
Wherefore, he prays the court to order that the same be sold immedi-
ately as aforesaid.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
The foregoing petition having been duly filed and having come on for
a hearing before me, of which hearing ten days' notice was given by mail
to the creditors of the said bankrupt, [or without notice to the creditors],
now, after due hearing, no adverse interest being represented thereat, [jr
after hearing in favor of said petition and
in opposition thereto] I find that the facts are as above stated, and that
the same is required in the interest of the estate, and it is therefore ordered
that the same be sold forthwith and the proceeds thereof deposited in
court.
Witness my hand this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
See notes to Form 44.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY..
345
EFoRM No. 47.3
Trustee's Report op Exempted Property.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ■
In the matter of
>In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
At
-, on the
day of
-.19—.
The following is a schedule of property designated and set apart to
be retained by the bankrupt aforesaid, as his own property, under the
provisions of the acts of Congress relating to bankruptcy.
General head.
Particular description.
Value.
Military uniforms, arms, and.
Dolls.
Cts.
Property exempted by State laws.
Trustee.
Note.
As to exemptions of bankrupts, see Sec. 6.
Bankrupt's duty to claim exemptions, Sec. 7a(8.)
Trustees' duty to set aside exemptions, Sec. 47a(ll), and Gen. Ord.
XVII.
346
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 48.]
Trustee's Return op no Assets.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt .
►In Bankruptcy.
At
-, in said district, on the
day of
, A. D. 19—.
, of , in the
On the day aforesaid, before me comes
cotmty of and State of , and makes oath, and says that he,
as trustee of the estate and effects of the above-named bankrupt , neither
received nor paid any moneys on account of the estate.
Subscribed and sworn to before me at , this day of ,
A. D. 19—.
Note.
Duties of trustees, Sec. 47 and Gen. Ord. XVII.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
347
[Form No. 49.]
Account of Trustee.
1
« 1
^ .S
« 1
H
fe "8.
t «
5
o
>
-a
5
^4
On
•*^ .
§8
goQ
•o.s
II
ooo
. u
t) V
o u
s*
o "
348 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 50.]
Oath to Final Account of Trustee.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
> In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt.
On this day of , A. D. 19 — , before me comes
of , in the county of and State of , and makes oath
and says that he was, on the day of , A. D. 19 — , appointed
trustee of the estate and effects of the above named bankrupt, and that
as such trustee he has conducted the settlement of the said estate. That
the account hereto annexed containing sheets of paper, the first
sheet whereof is marked with the letter [reference may here also be made
to any prior account -filed by said trustee} is true, and such accoimt contains
entries of every sum of money received by said trustee on account of the
estate and effects of the above-named bankrupt , and that the payments
purporting in such account to have been made by said trustee have been
so made by him. And he asks to be allowed for said payments and for
commissions and expenses as charged in said accounts.
-, Trustee.
Subscribed and sworn to before me at in said district of
, this day of , A. D. 19—.
[Official Character.]
Note.
See notes to Form 49; also Sec. 20 as to oaths.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 349
[Form No, 51.]
Order Allowing Account and Discharging Trustbb.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of ,
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
►In Bankruptcy.
The foregoing account having been presented for allowance, and having
been examined and fovmd correct, it is ordered, that the same be allowed,
and that the said trustee be discharged of his trust.
Referee in Bankruptcy.
Note.
See notes to Form 49.
[Form No. 52.]
Petition for Removal of Trustee.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
>ln Bankruptcy.
To the Honorable ,
Judge of the District Court for the District of :
The petition of , one of the creditors of said bankrupt,
respectfully represents that it is for the interest of the estate, of said
bankrupt that , heretofore appointed trustee of said bankrupt's
estate, should be removed from his trust, for the causes following, to wit:
[here set forth the particular cause or causes for which such removal is re-
quested.]
Wherefore pray that notice may be served upon said
, trustee as aforesaid, to show cause, at such time as may be fixed
by the court, why an order should not be made removing him from said
trust.
Note.
Appointment and removal of trustees, Sec. 2(17), 44, 46, Gen. Ord.
XIII. Notices to be given creditors. Sec. 58 and Gen. Ord. XXI (2).
350
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 53.]
Notice of Petition for Removal of Trustee.
In the District Cotut of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>'In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
At
-, on the
day of
A. D. 19—.
To
Trustee of the estate of ■
-, bankrupt;
You are hereby notified to appear before this court, at , on the
— day of , A. D. 19 — , at — o'clock — . m., to show cause (if any
you have) why you should not be removed from your trust as trustee as
aforesaid, according to the prayer of the petition of , one
of the creditors of said bankrupt, filed in this court on the day of
A. D. 19 — , in which it is alleged [here insert the allegation of the
petition].
Note.
See notes to Form 52.
-, Clerk.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 351
[Form No. 54.]
Order for Removal of Trustee.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
►In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
Whereas , of , did, on the day of , A.
D. 19 — , present his petition to this court, praying that for the reasons
therein set forth, , the trustee of the estate of said
, bankrupt, might be removed:
Now, therefore, upon reading the said petition of the said
and the evidence submitted therewith, and upon hearing counsel on be-
half of said petitioner and counsel for the trustee, and upon the evidence
submitted on behalf of said trustee,
It is ordered that the said be removed from the trust
as trustee of the estate of said bankrupt, and that the costs of the said
petitioner incidental to said petition be paid by said , trustee
[or, out of the estate of the said , subject to prior charges].
Witness the Honorable , judge of the said court, and
the seal thereof, at , in said district, on the day of , A.
D. 19—.
j Seal of the )
J Court, f
Clerk.
Notes.
See notes to Form 52.
352
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 55.]
Order for Choice of New Trustee.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
In the matter of
^In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
-, on the
day of
-, A. D. 19—.
At-
Whereas by reason of the removal [or the death or resignation] of
, heretofore appointed trustee of the estate of said bank-
rupt, a vacancy exists in the office of said trustee,
It is ordered that a meeting of the creditors of said bankrupt be held
at , in , in said district, on the day of , A. D.
18 — , for the choice of a new trustee of said estate.
And it is further ordered that notice be given to said creditors of the
time, place, and purpose of said meeting, by letter to each, to be deposited
in the mail at least ten days before that day.
, Referee in Bankruptcy.
Notes.
See notes to Form 52 and see Form 54.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 353
[Form No. 56.]
Certificate by Referee to Judge.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
I, , one of the referees of said court in bankruptcy, do
hereby certify that in the course of the proceedings in said cause before
me the following question arose pertinent to the said proceedings: [Here
state the question, a summary of the evidence relating thereto, and tlie finding
and order of the referee thereon."]
And the said question is certified to the judge for his opinion thereon.
Dated at , the day of , A. D. 19—.
Referee in bankruptcy.
Notes.
See as to certificate Sec. 2(10) and notes.
As to petition for review by judge, see Sec. 24f, 38a and Gen. Ord.
XXVII.
As to referee's return with certificate Sec. 39a (5).
354 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 57.]
Bankrupt's Petition for Discharge.
In the matter of
>■ In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
To the Honorable ,
Judge of the District Court of the United States for the District
of .
, of , in the county of and State of ,
in said district, respectfully represents that on the day of ,
last past, he was duly adjudged bankrupt under the acts of Congress
relating to bankruptcy; that he has duly surrendered all his property
and rights of property, and has fully complied with all the requirements
of said acts and of the orders of the court touching his bankruptcy.
Wherefore he prays that he may be decreed by the court to have a
full discharge from all debts provable against his estate under said bank-
rupt acts, except such debts as are excepted by law from such discharge.
Dated this day of , A. D. 19—.
, Bankrupt.
Order of Notice Thereon.
District of , ss.
On this day of , A. D. 19 — . on reading the foregoing
petition, it is
Ordered by the court, that a hearing be had upon the same on the
day of , A. D. 19 — , before said court, at , in said district,
at o'clock in the noon ; and that notice thereof be published
in , a newspaper printed in said district, and that all known
creditors and other persons in interest may appear at the said time and
place and show cause, if any they have, why the prayer of the said peti-
tioner should not be granted.
And it is further ordered by the court, that the clerk shall send by mail
to all known creditors copies of said petition and this order, addressed to
them at their places of residence as stated.
Witness the Honorable , judge of the said court, and the
seal thereof, at , in said district, on the day of , A. D.
19—.
Clerk.
/ Seal op the \
\ Court. J
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 355
hereby depose, on oath, that the foregoing order was published
in the on the following days, viz:
On the day of and on the day of , in the year
19—.
District of .
, 19—.
Personally appeared , and made oath that the foregoing
statement by him subscribed is true.
Before me.
[Official character.]
I hereby certify that I have on this day of , A. D. 19 — ,
sent by mail copies of the above order, as therein directed.
Clerk.
Notes.
As to discharges in general, see Sec. 14 and notes.
Revocation of discharges, see Sec. 16 and notes.
Discharges granted by judge only, 38a(4).
Notices to be given creditors, Sec. 58 and Gen. Ord. XXI (2).
'*} ■■l»
.,rfi»' •Mil
356 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 58.]
Specification of Grounds of Opposition to Bankrupt's Discharge.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of .
In the matter of
>'In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
-, of , in the county of and State of
a party interested in the estate of said , banlcrupt, do here-
by oppose the granting to him of a discharge from his debts, and for the
grounds of such opposition do file the following specification : [Here specify
the grounds of opposition.]
, Creditor.
Notes.
Opposition to discharge or composition, see Sec. 14b and Gen. Ord.
XXXII and notes.
Specifications must be circumstantial and show statutory grounds of
opposition, in re Price (1899), S. Dist. la., Woolson, J., 96 Fed., 611;
1 N. B. N., 18.
Specification may be amended to show scienter. In re Pierce (1900),
N. D. N. Y., Coxe, J., 103 Fed. 64; 4 A. B. R., 554; 2 N. B. N., 984.
[Form No. 59.]
Discharge of Bankrupt.
District Court of the United States,
District'of ■
"Whereas, of in said district, has been duly ad-
judged a bankrupt, under the acts of Congress relating to bankruptcy,
and appears to have conformed to all the reqtiirements of law in that
behalf, it is therefore ordered by this court that said be
discharged from all debts and claims which are made provable by said
acts against his estate, and which existed on the day of , A. D.
19 — , on which day the petition for adjudication was filed him;
excepting such debts as are by law excepted from the operation of a dis-
charge in bankruptcy.
Witness the Honorable , judge of said district court,
and the seal thereof this day of , A. D. 19 — .
Clerk.
) Sbai, op the J
( COOBT. J
Note.
See references to Form 57.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 357
[Form No. 60.]
Petition for Meeting to Consider Composition.
District Court of the United States for the District of -
^In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt
To the Honorable , Judge of the District Court of the
United States for the District of :
The above-named bankrupt respectfully represent that a composition
of per cent, upon all unsecured debts, not entitled to priority
in satisfaction of debts has been proposed by
to creditors as provided by the acts of Congress relating to bank-
ruptcy, and verily believe that the said composition will be accepted
by a majority in number and in value of creditors whose claims
are allowed.
Wherefore, he pray that a meeting of creditors may be duly called
to act upon said proposal for a composition, according to the provisions
of said acts and the rules of court.
Bankrupt.
358 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 61.]
Application for Confirmation of Composition.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of
In the matter of
>-In Bankruptcy.
Bankrupt .
.J
To the Honorable , Judge of the District Court of^the
United States for the District of .
At , in said district, on the day of , A. D. 19 — , now
comes , the above-named bankrupt, and respectfully repre-
sents to the court that, after he had been examined in open court \pr at a
meeting of his creditors] and had filed in court a schedule of his property
and a list of his creditors, as required by law, he offered terms of composi-
tion to his creditors, which terms have been accepted in writing by a
majority in number of all creditors whose claims have been allowed, which
number represents a majority in amount of such claims; that the con-
sideration to be paid by the bankrupt to his creditors, the money neces-
sary to pay all debts which have priority, and the costs of the proceedings
amounting in all to the siim of dollars, has been deposited, subject
to the order of the judge, in the National Bank, of , a
designated depository of money in bankruptcy cases.
Wherefore the said respectfully asks that the said com-
position may be confirmed by the court.
, Bankrupt.
Note. ^
As to compositions, see Sec. 12 and 13, and Gen. Ord. XII(3). See
also notes to Form 58 as to opposition to confirmation.
See notes to Form 62.
OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY. 359
[Form No. 62.] \
Order Confirming Composition.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of .
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
In Bankruptcy.
An application for the confirmation of the composition offered by" the
bankrupt having been filed in court, and it appearing that the composi-
tion has been accepted by a majority in number of creditors whose claims
have been allowed and of such allowed claims; and the consideration and
the money required by law to be deposited, having been deposited as
ordered, in such place as was designated by the judge of said court, and
subject to his order; and it also appearing that it is for the best interests
of the creditors ; and that the bankrupt has not been guilty of any of the
acts or failed to perform any of the duties which would be a bar to his
discharge, and that the offer and its acceptance are in good faith and have
not been made or procured by any means, promises, or acts contrary to
the acts of Congress relating to bankruptcy : It is therefore hereby ordered
that the said composition be, and it hereby is, confirmed.
Witness the Honorable , judge of said court, and the
seal thereof, this day of , A. D. 19 — .
, Clerk.
Seal of the
Court.
)
Notes.
As to confirmation of compositions, see Sec. 12 and 13. Debts released
on confirmation of a composition, Sec. 14b.
Opposition to composition, Gen. Ord. XXXII.
Notices on composition, 58a (2) and Gen. Ord. XXI (2).
360 OFFICIAL FORMS IN BANKRUPTCY.
[Form No. 63.]
Order of Distribution on Composition.
United States of America:
In the District Court of the United States for the District of •
In the matter of
Bankrupt.
In Bankruptcy.
The composition oflEered by the above named bankrupt in this case
having been duly confirmed by the judge of said court, it is hereby ordered
and decreed that the distribution of the deposit shall be made by the clerk
of the court as follows, to wit: 1st, to pay the several claims which have
priority; 2d, to pay the costs of proceedings; 3d, to pay, according to the
terms of the composition, the several claims of general creditors which
have been allowed, and appear upon a list of allowed claims, on the files
in this case, which list is made a part of this order.
Witness the Honorable , judge of said court, ahd the
seal thereof, this day of , A. D. 19 — .
, Clerk.
i Seal of the |
\ Court. J
Note.
See notes to Forms 60, 61, 62.
EUIES OF PEACTICE
FOR THE
COURTS OF EQUITY OF THE
UNITED STATES.
[See Gen. Ord. XXVII.]
PRELIMINARY REGULATIONS.
Rule 1. — [Courts always Open] The circmt courts,
as court of equity, shall be deemed always open for the
purpose of filing bills, answers, and other pleadings; for
issuing and returning mesne and final process and com-
missions; and for making and directing all interlocutory
motions, orders, rules, and other proceedings, preparatory
to hearing of all causes upon their merits.
Rule 2. [Clerk] The clerk's office shall be open, and
the clerk shall be in attendance therein, on the first Monday
of every month, for the purpose of receiving, entering, en-
tertaining, and disposing of all motions, rules, orders, and
other proceedings, which are grantable of course and ap-
plied for, or had by the parties or their solicitors, in all
causes pending in equity, in pursuance of the rules hereby
prescribed.
Rule 3. [Judge may exercise powers of court.] Any
judge of the circuit court, as well in vacation as in
term, may, at chambers, or on the rule-days at the clerk's
■office, make and direct all such interlocutory orders, rules,
361
362 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
and other proceedings, preparatory to the hearing of all
causes upon their merits in the same manner and with the
same effect as the circuit court could make and direct the
same in term, reasonable notice of the appHcation therefor
being first given to the adverse party, or his solicitor, to
appear and show cause to the contrary, at the next rule-day
thereafter, unless some other time is assigned by the judge
for the hearing.
Rule 4. [Entry of motions — Notice to parties] All mo-
tions, rules, orders, and other proceedings, made and
directed at chambers, or on rule-days at the clerk's office,
whether special or of course, shall be entered by the clerk
in an order-book, to be kept at the clerk's office, on the day
when they are made and directed ; which book shall be open
at all office hours to the free inspection of the parties in any
suit in equity, and their solicitors. And, except in cases
where personal or other notice is specially required or
directed, such entry in the order-book shall be deemed suffi-
cient notice to the parties and their solicitors, without fur-
ther service thereof, of all orders, rules, acts, notices, and
other proceedings entered in such order book, touching any
and all the matters in the suits to and in which they are
parties and solicitors. And notice to the solicitors shall
be deemed notice to the parties for whom they appear and
whom they represent, in all cases where personal notice on
the parties is not otherwise specially required. ^ Where the
solicitors for all the parties in a suit reside in or near the
same town or city, the judges of the circuit court may, by
rule, abridge the time for notice of rules, orders, or other
proceedings not requiring personal service on the parties, in
their discretion.
Rule 5 — [Motions of course] All motions and appli-
cations in the clerk's office for the issuing of mesne pro-
cess and final process to enforce and execute decrees; for
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 363
filing bills, answers, pleas, demurrers, and other pleadings ;
for making amendments to bills and answers, for taking
bills pro confesso; for filing exceptions; and for other pro-
ceedings in the clerk's office which do not, by the rules here-
inafter prescribed, require any allowance or order of the
court or of any judge thereof, shall be deemed motions and
applications grantable of course by the clerk of the court.
But the same may be suspended, or altered, or rescinded by
any judge of the court, upon special cause shown.
Rule 6. — [Motions not of course] All motions for rules
or orders and other proceedings, which are not grant-
able of course or without notice, shall, imless a different time
be assigned by a judge of the court, be made on a rule-day,
and entered in the order-book, and shall be heard at the rule-
day next after that on which the motion is made. And if
the adverse party, or his soHcitor, shall not then appear, or
shall not show good cause against the same, the motion may
be heard by any judge of the court ex parte, and granted,
as if not objected to, or refused, in his discretion.
PROCESS.
Rule 7. — [Subpoena] The process of subpoena shall
constitute the proper mesne process in all suits in equity,
in the first instance, to require the defendant to appear and
answer the exigency of the bill; and, unless otherwise pro-
vided in these rules, or specially ordered by the circuit court,
a writ of attachment, and, if the defendant can not be foimd,
a writ of sequestration, or a writ of assistance to enforce a
delivery of possession, as the case may require, shall be
the proper process to issue for the purpose of compelling
obedience to any interlocutory or final order or decree of the
court.
Rule 8. — [Final process] Final process to execute
any decree may, if the decree be solely for the payment of
364 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
money, be by a writ of execution, in the form used in the cir-
cuit court in suits at common law in actions of assumpsit.
If the decree be for the performance of any specific act, as,
for example, for the execution of a conveyance of land or
the delivering up of deeds or other documents, the decree
shall, in all cases, prescribe the time within which the act
shall be done, of which the defendant shall be bound, with-
out further service, to take notice ; and upon affidavit of the
plaintiff, filed in the clerk's office, that the same has not
been complied with within the prescribed time, the clerk
shall issue a writ of attachment against the delinquent
party, from which, if attached thereon, he shall not be dis-
charged, unless upon a full compliance with the decree and
the payment of all costs, or upon a special order of the
court, or of a judge thereof, upon motion and affidavit, en-
larging the time for the performance thereof. If the de-
linquent party can not be found, a writ of sequestration shall
issue against his estate upon the return of non est inventus,
to compel obedience to the decree.
Rule 9. — [Writ of assistance] When any decree or
order is for the delivery or possession, upon proof made by
affidavit of a demand and refusal to obey the decree or order,
the party prosecuting the same shall be entitled to a VTrit of
assistance from the clerk of the court.
Rule 10. — [When person not a party Is entitled
to an order] Every person, not being a party in any
cause, who has obtained an order, or in whose favor an
order shall have been made, shall be enabled to enforce
obedience to such order by the same process as if he were a
party to the cause; and every person, not being a party in
any cause, against whom obedience to any order of the
court may be enforced, shall be liable to the same process
for enforcing obedience to such orders as if he were a party
in the cause.
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 365
SERVICE OF PROCESS.
Rule 11. — [Bill must be filed before process.] No process
of subpoena shall issue from the clerk's office in any suit in
equity until the bill is filed in the office.
Rule 12. — [What process to contain.] Whenever a
bill is filed, the clerk shall issue the process of subpoena
thereon, as of course, upon the application of the plaintiff,
which shall contain the Christian names as well as the sur-
names of the parties, and shall be returnable into the
clerk's office the next rule day, or the next rule day but one
at the election of the plaintiff, occurring after twenty days
from the time of issuing thereof. At the bottom of the
subpoena shall be placed a memorandum, that the defend-
ant is to enter his appearance in the suit in the clerk's office
on or before the day at which the writ is returnable ; other-
wise the bill may be taken pro confesso. Where there are
more than one defendant, a writ of subpoena may, at the
election of the plaintiff, be sued out separately for each de-
fendant, except in the case of husband and wife defendants,
or a joint subpoena against all the defendants.
Rule 13. — [Service by copy.] The service of all sub
poenas shall be by a delivery of a copy thereof by the officei
serving the same to the defendant personally, or by leaving
a copy thereof at the dwelling-house or usual place of abode
of each defendant, with some adult person who is a member
or resident in the family.
Rule 14. — [Second subpoena.] Whenever any sub-
poena shall be returned not executed as to any defendant,
the plaintiff shall be entitled to another subpoena, toties
quoiies, against such defendant, if he shall require it, until
due service is made.
Rule 15. — [Marshal to serve process — return.] The
service of all process, mesne and final, shall be by the
366 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
marshal of the district, or his deputy, or by some other
person specially appointed by the court for that purpose,
and not otherwise. In the latter case, the person serving
the process shall make affidavit thereof.
Rule 16. — [Suit docketed on return of subpoena.] Upon
the return of the subpoena as served and executed upon
any defendant, the clerk shall enter the suit upon his
docket as pending in the court, and shall state thetime of
the entry.
APPEARANCE.
Rule 17. — Defendant to enter appearance — when.] The
appearance day of the defendant shall be the rule-day to
which the subpoena is made rettunable, provided he has
been served with the process twenty days before that
day ; otherwise his appearance-day shall be the next rule-
day succeeding the rule-day when the process is return-
able.
[Appearance entered on order book.] The appearance of
the defendant, either personally or by his solicitor, shall be
entered in the order book on the day thereof by the
clerk.
BILLS TAKEN PRO CONFESSO.
Rule 18. — [Defendant must answer — default.] It shall
be the duty of the defendant, unless the time shall be
otherwise enlarged, for cause shown, by a judge of the
court, upon motion for that purpose, to file his
plea, demurrer, or answer to the bill, in the clerk's office, on
the rule-day next succeeding that of entering his appear-
ance. In default thereof, the plain tiif may, at his election,
enter an order (as of cotirse) in the order-book, that the bill
be taken pro confesso; and thereupon the cause shall be pro-
ceeded in ex parte, and the matter of the bill may be decreed
by the coiirt at any time after the expiration of thirty days
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 367
from and after the entry of said order, if the same can be
done without an answer, and is proper to be decreed ; or the
plaintiff, if he requires any discovery or answer to enable
him to obtain a proper decree, shall be entitled to process of
attachment against the defendant to compel an answer, and
the defendant shall not, when arrested upon such process,
be discharged therefrom, unless upon filing his answer, or
otherwise complying with such order as the court or a judge
thereof may direct as to pleading to or fully answering the
bill, within a period to be fixed by the court or judge, and
undertaking to speed the cause.
Rule 19. — [Decree on pro confesso — setting order aside.]
When the bill is taken pro confesso the court may pro-
ceed to a decree at any time after the expiration of
thirty days from and after the entry of the order
to take the bill pro confesso, and such decree rendered shall
be deemed absolute, imless the court shall, at the same term,
set aside the same, or enlarge the time for filing the answer,
upon cause shown upon motion and affidavit of the defend-
ant. And no such motion shall be granted, imless upon the
payment of the cost of the plaintiff in the suit up to that
time, or such part thereof as the court shall deem reasonable,
and imless the defendant shall undertake to file his answer
within such time as the court shall direct, and submit to
such other terms as the court shall direct, for the purpose of
speeding the same.
FRAME OF BILLS,
Rule 20. — [Wliat bill to contain.] Every bill, in the
introductory part thereof, shall contain the names,
places of abode, and citizenship of all parties, plaintiffs and
defendants, by and against whom the bill is brought. The
form, in substance, shall be as follows: "To the judges of
the circuit court of the United States for the district of :
A. B., of , and a citizen of the State of , brings this
368 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
his bill against C. D., of , and a citizen of the State of
, and E. F., of , and a citizen of the State of — — .
And thereupon your orator complains and says that," &c.
Rule 21, — [Charging^confederating and jurisdiction
clause may be omitted.] The plaintiff, in his bill, shall
be at liberty to omit, at his option, the part which is
usually called the common confederacy clause of the
bill, averring a confederacy between the defendants to
injure or defraud the plaintiff ; also what is commonly called
the charging part of the bill, setting forth the matters or
excuses which the defendant is supposed to intend to set up
by way of defense to the bill ; also what is commonly called
the jurisdiction clause of the bill, that the acts complained
of are contrary to equity, and that the defendant is without
any remedy at law; and the bill shall not be demurrable
therefor. And the plaintiff may, in the narrative, or stating
part of his bill, state and avoid, by counter-averments, at
his option, any matter or thing which he supposes will be
insisted upon by the defendant by way of defense or ex-
cuse to the case made by the plaintiff for relief. The prayer
of the bill shall ask the special relief to which the plaintiff
supposes himself entitled, and also shall contain a prayer
for general relief; and if an injunction, or a writ of ne exeat
regno, or any other special order, pending the suit, is re-
quired, it shall also be specially asked for.
Rule 22. — [Bill must show why necessary or proper
parties, omitted.] If any persons, other than those named
as defendants in the bill, shall appear to be necessary
or proper parties thereto, the bill shall aver the reason why
they are not made parties, by showing them to be without
the jurisdiction of the court, or that they can not be joined
without ousting the jurisdiction of the court as to the other
parties. And as to persons who are without the juris-
diction and may properly be made parties, the bill may
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 369
pray that process may issue to make them parties to the bill
if they should come within the jurisdiction.
Rule 23. — [What prayer for process to contain.] The
prayer for process of subpoena in the bill shall con-
tain the names of all the defendants named in the intro-
ductory part of the bill, and if any of them are known to be
infants under age, or otherwise under guardianship, shall
state the fact, so that the court may take order thereon,
as justice may require upon the return of the process. If an
injunction, or a writ of tie exeat regno, or any other special
order, pending the suit, is asked for in the prayer for relief,
that shall be sufficient, without repeating the same in the
prayer for process.
Rule 24.— [Counsel must sign bilL] Every bill shall
contain the signature of covmsel annexed to it, which
shall be considered as an affirmation on his part that, upon
the instructions given to him and the case laid before him,
there is good ground for the suit, in the manner in which
it is framed.
Rule 25. — [State taxable costs to be followed.] In order
to prevent unnecessary costs and expenses, and to
promote brevity, succinctness, and directness in the allega-
tions of bills and answers, the regular taxable costs, for
every bill and answer shall in no case exceed the sum which
is allowed in the State court of chancery in the district, if
any there be ; but if there be none, then it shall not exceed
the sum of three dollars for every bill or answer.
SCANDAL AND IMPERTINENCE IN BILLS.
Rule 26. — [Scandal and impertinence to be expunged —
reference for.] Every bill shall be expressed in as brief and
succinct terms as it reasonably can be, and shall contain
no tinnecessary recitals of deeds, documents, contracts, or
other instruments, in hcBC verba, or any other impertinent
370 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
matter or any scandalous matter, not relevant to the suit.
If it does, it may, on exceptions, be referred to a mas-
ter, by any judge of the court, for impertinence or scan-
dal ; and if so f oimd by him, the matter shall be expunged
at the expense of the plaintiff, and he shall pay to the de-
fendant all his costs in the suit up to that time, unless the
court or a judge thereof shall otherwise order. If the
master shall report that the bill is not scandalous or im-
pertinent, the plaintiff shall be entitled to all costs oc-
casioned by the reference
Rule 27. — [Exceptions for scandal and impertinence.]
No order shall be made by any judge for referring
any bill, answer, or pleading, or other matter or
proceeding, depending before the court, for scandal
or impertinence, unless exceptions are taken in writing
and signed by cotmsel, describing the particular passages
which are considered to be scandalous or impertinent; nor
unless the exceptions shall be filed on or before the next
rule-day after the process on the bill shall be returnable, or
after the answer or pleading is filed. And such order, when
obtained, shall be considered as abandoned, imless the party
obtaining the order shall, without any unnecessary delay,
procure the master to examine and report for the same on
or before the next succeeding rule-day, or the master shall
certify that further time is necessary for him to complete
the examination.
AMENDMENT OF BILLS.
Rule 28. [Amendment — when matter of course.] The
plaintiff shall be at liberty, as a matter of course,
and without payment of costs, to amend his bill,
in any matters whatsoever, before any copy has been taken
out of the clerk's office, and in any small matters afterwards
such as filing blanks, correcting errors of dates, misnomer of
parties, misdescription of premises, clerical errors, and gen-
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
371
erally in matters of form. But if he amend in a material
point ( as he may do of course) after a copy has been so
taken, before any answer or plea or demurrer to the bill, he
shall pay to the defendant the costs occasioned thereby, and
shall, without delay, furnish him a fair copy thereof, free of
expense, with suitable references to the places where the
same are to be inserted. And if the amendments are num-
erous, he shall furnish, in like manner, to the defendant, a
copy of the whole bill as amended ; and if there be more than
one defendant, a copy shall be furnished to each defendant
affected thereby.
Rule 29. — [Plaintiff may amend bill — notice — order.]
After an answer, or plea, or demurrer is put in, and be-
fore replication, the plaintiff may, upon motion or peti-
tion, without notice, obtain an order from any judge
of the court to amend his bill on or before the next
succeeding rule-day, upon payment of costs or with-
out payment of costs, as the court or a judge thereof
may in his discretion direct. But after replication filed, the
plaintiff shall not be permitted to withdraw it and to amend
his bill, except upon a special order of a judge of the court,
upon motion or petition, after due notice to the other party,
and upon proof by affidavit that the same is not made for
the purpose of vexation or delay, or that the matter of the
proposed amendment is material, and could not with rea-
sonable diligence have been sooner introduced into the bill,
and upon the plaintiff's submitting to such other terms as
may be imposed by the judge for speeding the cause.
Rule 30. — [Amendment filed before next rule day.] If
the plaintiff so obtaining any order to amend his bill after
answer, or plea, or demurrer, or after replication, shall
not file his amendments or amended bill, as the case may re-
quire, in the clerk's office on or before the next succeeding
rule-day, he shall be considered to have abandoned the
372 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
same, and the cause shall proceed as if no application for
any amendment had been made.
DEMURRERS AND PLEAS.
Rule 31. — [Certificate of council must accompany de-
murrer.] No demurrer or plea shall be allowed to be
filed to any bill, unless upon a certificate of counsel, that
in his opinion it is well foimded in point of law, and sup-
ported by the affidavit of the defendant; that it is
not interposed for delay; and, if a plea, that it is true in
point of fact.
Rule 32. [Fraud or combination cliarged must be an-
swered.] The defendant may at any time before the bill
is taken for confessed, or afterward with the leave of
the court, demur or plead to the whole bill, or to
part of it, and he may demur to part, plead to part, and
answer as to the residue ; but in every case in which the bill
specially charges fraud or combination, a plea to such part
must be accompanied with an answer fortifying the plea
and explicitly denying the fraud and combination, and the
facts on which the charge is founded.
Rule 33. [Setting down plea or demurrer for argument
— issue taken.] The plaintiff may set down the demiirrer
or plea to be argued, or he may take issue on the
plea. If, upon an issue, the fact stated in the plea
be determined for the defendant, they shall avail him
as far as in law and equity they ought to avail him.
Rule 34. [Costs on overruling plea.] If, upon the
hearing, any demurrer or plea is overruled, the plaintiff
shall be entitled to his costs in the cause up to that period
imless the court shall be satisfied that the defendant has
good grotmd, in point of law or fact, to interpose the same,
and it was not interposed vexatiously or for delay. And,
upon the overruling of any plea or demurrer, the defendant
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 373
shall be assigned to answer the bill, or so much thereof as
is covered by the plea or demurrer, the next succeeding rule-
day, or at such other period as, consistently with justice and
the rights of the defendant, the same can, in the judgment
of the court, be reasonably done ; in default whereof, the bill
shall be taken against him pro confesso, and the matter
thereof proceeded in and decreed accordingly.
Rule 35. [Costs on allowance of plea.] If, upon the
hearing, any demurrer or plea shall be allowed, the defend-
ant shall be entitled to his costs. But the court may, in its
discretion, upon motion of the plaintiff, allow him to amend
his bill, upon such terms as it shall deem reasonable.
Rule 36. [Demurrer or plea not overruled because too
broad.] No demurrer or plea shall be held bad and over-
ruled upon argtunent, only because such demurrer or plea
shall not cover so much of the bill as it might by law have
extended to.
Rule 37. — [Not overruled because answer covers same
matter.] No demurrer or plea shall be held bad and over-
ruled upon argument, only because the answer of the defend-
ant may extend to some part of the same matter as may
be covered by such demurrer or plea.
Rule 38. [Bill dismissed unless plea set down or replied
to.] If the plaintiff shall not reply to any plea, or set
down any plea or demurrer for argument on the rule-day
when the same is filed, or on the next succeeding rule-day,
he "shall be deemed to admit the truth and sufficiency
thereof, and his bill shall be dismissed as of course, unless
a judge of the court shall allow him fiirther time for that
purpose.
ANSWERS.
Rule 39. — [Defendant may file plea and answer.] The
rule, that if a defendant submits to answer he shall an-
swer fully to all matters of the bill, shall no longer apply
374 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
in cases where he might by plea protect himself from such
answer and discovery. And the defendant shall be entitled
in all cases by answer to insist upon all matters of defense
(not being matters of abatement, or to the character of the
parties, or matters of form) in bar of or to the merits of the
bill, of which he may be entitled to avail himself by a plea
in bar; and in such answer he shall not be compellable to
answer any other matters than he would be compellable to
answer and discover upon filing a plea in bar and an answer
in support of such plea, touching the matters set forth in the
bill to avoid or repel the bar or defense. Thus, for example,
a bona fide purchaser, for a valuable consideration without
notice, may set up that defense by way of answer instead of
plea, and shall be entitled to the same protection, and shall
not be compellable to make any further answer or discovery
of his title than he would be in any answer in support of
such plea.
Rule 40. — [Answer required only to interrogatories.] A
defendant shall not be bound to answer any statement
or charge in the bill, unless specially and particularly
interrogated thereto ; and a defendant shall not be bound
to answer any interrogatory in the bill, except those in-
terrogatories which such defendant is required to an-
swer ; and where a defendant shall answer any statement
or charge in the bill to which he is not interrogated, only by
stating his ignorance of the matter so stated or charged,
such answer shall be deemed impertinent.
Ordered, (December Term, 1850). That the fortieth
rule, heretofore adopted and promulgated by this court as
one of the rules of practice in suits in equity in the circuit
courts, be, and the same is hereby, repealed and annulled.
And it shall not hereafter be necessary to interrogate a de-
fendant specially and particularly upon any statement in
the bill, unless the complainant desires to do so, to obtain
a discovery.
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 375
Rule 41. [How interrogatories arranged.] The inter-
rogatories contained in the interrogating part of the bill
shall be divided as conveniently as may be from each other
and numbered consecutively 1, 2, 3, etc. ; and the interro-
gatories which each defendant is required to answer shall
be specified in a note at the foot of the bill, in the form
or to the effect following, that is to say : "The defendant
(A. B.) is required to answer the interrogatories nimib-
ered respectively 1, 2, 3," etc. : and the office copy of
the bill taken by each defendant shall not contain any in-
terrogatories except those which such defendant is so re-
quired to answer, tmless such defendant shall require to be
furnished with a copy of the whole bill.
(Amendment to 41st Equity Rule December Term, 1871.)
[Answer evidence.] If the complainant, in his bill, shall
waive an answer imder oath, or shall only require
an answer under oath with regard to certain speci-
fied interrogatories, the answer of the defendant, though
imderoath, except such part thereof as shall be directly
responsive to such interrogatories, shall not be evidence in
his favor, imless the cause be set down for hearing on bill
and answer only ; but may nevertheless be used as an affid-
avit, with the same effect as heretofore, on a motion to
grant or dissolve an injimction, or on any other incidental
motion in the cause ; but this shall not prevent a defendant
from becoming a witness in his own behalf imder section 3
of the act of Congress of Jtily 2, 1864.
[Rev. Stat. U. S., Sec. 385.)
Rule 42. [Note concerning interrogatories part of bill.]
The note at the foot of the bill, specifying the interroga-
tories which each defendant is required to answer, shall
be considered and treated as part of the bill, and the ad-
dition of any such note, after the bill is filed, shall be con-
sidered and treated as an amendment of the bill.
376 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
Rule 43. [Frame of interrogating part.] Instead of
the words of the bill now in use, preceding the interrogat-
ing part thereof, and beginning with the words " To the end
therefore," there shall hereafter be used words in the form
or to the effect following: "To the end, therefore, that the
said defendants may, if they can, show why your orator
should not have the relief hereby prayed, and may, upon
their several and respective corporal oaths, and according to
the best and utmost of their several and respective knowl-
edge, remembrance, information, and belief, full, true, direct,
and perfect answers make to such of the several interroga-
tories hereinafter numbered and set forth, as by the note
hereunder written they are respectively required to answer ;
that is to say : —
"1. Whether, &c.
"2. Whether, &c."
Rule 44. [Defendant may decline to answer interrogat-
ory.] A defendant shall be at liberty, by answer, to de-
cline answering any interrogatory, or part of an interrogat-
ory, from answering which he might have protected him-
self by demurrer ; and he shall be at liberty so to decline,
notwithstanding he shall answer other parts of the bill
from which he might have protected himself by demurrer.
Rule 45. [Special replication not necessary.] No spe-
cial replication to any answer shall be filed. But if any
matter alleged in the answer shall make it necessary for the
plaintiff to amend his bill, he may have leave to amend the
same with or without the payment of costs, as the court, or
a judge thereof, may in his discretion direct.
Rule 46. [Supplemental answer.] In every case where
an amendment shall be made after answer filed, the de-
fendant shall put in a new or supplemental answer on or
before the next succeeding rule-day after that on which
the amendment or amended bill is filed, unless the time is en-
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 377
larged or otherwise ordered by a judge of the court ; and upon
his default, the Hke proceedings may be had as in cases of
an omission to put in an answer.
PARTIES TO BILLS.
Rule 47. [Proper parties may be omitted on cause
shown.] In all cases where it shall appear to the court
that persons, who might otherwise be deemed necessary
or proper parties to the suit, can not be made parties
by reason of their being out of the jurisdiction of the
court, or incapable otherwise of being made parties
or because their joinder would oust the jurisdiction of the
court as to the parties before the court, the court may, in
their discretion, proceed in the cause without making such
persons parties ; and in such cases the decree shall be without
prejudice to the rights of the absent parties.
Rtde 48. [Parties may be omitted.} Where the parties
on either side are very numerous, and can not, with-
out manifest inconvenience and oppressive delays in the
suit, be all brought before it, the court in its discretion may
dispense with making all of them parties, and may proceed
in the suit, having stifficient parties before it to represent all
the diverse interest of the plaintiffs and the defendants in
the suit properly before it. But, in such cases, the decree
shall be without prejudice to the rights and claims of all the
absent parties.
Rule 49. [Trustees parties — when.] In all suits con-
cerning real estate which is vested in trustees by devise,
and such trustees are competent to sell and give discharges
for the proceeds of the sale, and for the rents and profits of
the estate, such tinistees shall represent the persons bene-
ficially interested in the estate, or the proceeds, or the rents
and profits, in the same manner and to the same extent as
the executors or administrators in suits concerning personal
estate represent the persons beneficially interested in such
378 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
personal estate ; and in such cases it shall not be necessary
to make the persons benefically interested in such real
estates, or rents and profits, parties to the suit ; but the court
may, upon consideration of the matter on the hearing, if it
shall so think fit, order such persons to be made parties.
Rule 50. [Parties in suits to execute trusts of a will.] In
suits to execute the trusts of a will, it shall not be neces-
sary to make the heir at law a party ; but the plain-
tiffs shall be at liberty to make the heir at law a party
where he desires to have the will established against him.
Rule 51. [Defendants jointly and severally liable.] In all
cases in which the plaintiff has a joint and several de-
mand against several persons, either as principals or
sureties, it shall not be necessary to bring before the court
as parties to a suit concerning such demand all the persons
liable thereto ; but the plaintiff may proceed against one or
more of the persons severally liable.
Rule 52. [Setting down for argument on ground of de-
fective parties.] Where the defendant shall, by his an-
swer, suggest that the bill is defective for want of
parties, the plaintiff shall be at liberty, within fourteen
days after answer filed, to set down the cause for argu-
ment upon that objection only; and the purpose for which
the same is so set down shall be notified by an entry, to
be made in the clerk's order-book, in the form or to the effect
following, (that is to say) "Set down upon the defendant's
objectionforwhat of parties." And where the plaintiff shall
not so set down his cause, but shall proceed therewith to
a hearing, notwithstanding an objection for want of parties
taken by the answer, he shall not, at the hearing of the
cause, if the defendant's objection shall then be allowed be
entitled as of course to an order for liberty to amend his bill
by adding parties. But the court, if it thinks fit, shall be at
liberty to dismiss the bill.
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 379
Rule 53. [Objection of want of proper parties.] If a
defendant shall, at the hearing of a cause, object that a
suit is defective for want of parties not having by plea or
answer taken the objection, and therein specified by name
or description of parties to whom the objection applies, the
court (if it shall think fit) shall be at liberty to make a decree
saving the rights of the absent parties.
NOMINAL PARTIES TO THE BILLS.
Rule 54. [When defendant need not answer.] Where
no account, payment, conveyance, or other direct re-
lief is sought against a party to a suit, not being an infant,
the party, upon service of the subpoena upon him, need not
appear and answer the bill, unless the plaintiff specially re-
quires him so to do by the prayer of his bill ; but he may ap-
pear and answer at his option ; and if he does not appear and
answer he shall be boimd by all the proceedings in the cause.
If the plaintiff shall require him to appear and answer he
shall be entitled to the costs of all the proceedings against
him unless the court shall otherwise direct
Rule 55. [Injunction to stay proceedings at law — when
granted as of course.] Whenever an injunction is asked
for by the bill to stay proceedings at law, if the defendant
do not enter his appearance and plead, demur, or answer
to the same within the time prescribed therefor by these
niles, the plaintiff shall be entitled as of course, upon motion,
without notice, to such injunction. But special injunctions
shall be grantable only upon due notice to the other
party by the court in term, or by a judge thereof
in vacation, after a hearing, which may be ex parte,
if the adverse party does not appear at the time and place
ordered. In every case where an injunction — either the
common injunction or a special injunction — is awarded in
vacation, it shall, unless previously dissolved by the judge
380 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
grantiiig the same, continue until the next term of the court,
or until it is dissolved by some other order of the court.
BILLS OF REVIVOR AND SUPPLEMENTAL BILLS.
Rule 56. [Bill of revivor on death of party.] When-
ever a suit in equity shall become abated by the death
of either party, or by any other event, the same may be re-
vived by a bill of revivor or a bill in the nature of a bill of
revivor, as the circumstances of the case may require, filed
by the proper parties entitled to revive the same, which bill
may be filed in the clerk's office at any time ; and, upon sug-
gestion of the facts, the proper process of subpoena shall, as
of course, be issued by the clerk, requiring the proper repre-
sentatives of the other party to appear and show cause, if
any they have, why the cause should not be revived. And
if no cause shall be shown at the next rule-day which shall
occur after fourteen days from the time of the service of the
same process, the suit shall stand revived, as of course.
Rule 57. [Supplemental bill may be filed.] Whenever
any suit in equity shall become defective from any
event happening after the filing of the bill (as, for example,
by change of interest in the parties), or for any other reason
a supplemental bill, or a bill in the nature of a supplemental
bill, may be necessary to be filed in the cause, leave to file
the same may be granted by any judge of the court on any
rule-day upon proper cause shown and due notice to the
other party. And if leave is granted to file such supple-
mental bill, the defendant shall demur, plead, or answer
thereto on the next succeeding rule-day after the supple-
mental bill is filed in the clerk's office, imless some other
time shall be assigned by a judge of the court.
Rule 58. [What necessary to state in supplemental bill.]
It shall not be necessary in any bill of revivor or supple-
mental bill to set forth any of the statements in the original
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 381
suit, unless the special circumstances of the case niay re-
quire it.
ANSWERS.
Rule 59. [Verification of answer.] Every defendant
may swear to his answer before any justice or judge of
any court of the United States, or before any commissioner
appointed by any circuit court to take testimony or depo-
sitions, or before any master in chancery appointed by any
circuit court, or before any judge of any court of a State or
Territory, or before any notary public.
AMENDMENT OF ANSWERS.
' Rule 60. [Answer — liow amended.] After an an-
swer is put in, it may be amended, as of course, in any
matter of form, or by filling up a blank, or correcting a date,
or reference to a document, or other small matter, and be re-
sworn, at any time before a replication is put in, or the
cause is set down for a hearing upon bill and answer. But
after replication, or such setting down for a hearing, it shall
not be amended in any material matters, as by adding new
facts or defenses, or qualifying or altering the original state-
ments, except by special leave of the court, or of a judge
thereof, upon motion and cause shown, after due notice to
the adverse party, supported, if required, by affidavit ; and
in every case where leave is so granted, the court or the
judge granting the same may, in his discretion, require that
the same be separately engrossed, and added as a distinct
amendment to the original answer, so as toj^e distinguish-
able therefrom.
EXCEPTIONS TO ANSWERS.
Rule 61. [Time for exceptions to answers.] After an
answer is filed on any rule-day, the plaintiff shall be allowed
until the next succeeding rule-day to file in the clerk's office
exceptions thereto for insufficiency, and no longer, unless a
382 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
longer time shall be allowed for the purpose, upon cause
shown to the court, or a judge thereof ; and if no exception
shall be filed thereto within that period, the answer shall
be deemed and taken to be sufficient.
Rule 62. [Same solicitor for different defendants.] When
the same solicitor is employed for two or more defendants,
and separate answers shall be filed, or other proceedings
had, by two or more of the defendants separately, costs
shall not be allowed for such separate answers, or other
proceedings, imless a master, upon reference to him, shall
certify that such separate answers and other proceedings
were necessary or proper, and ought not to have been
joined together.
Rule 63. [Exceptions set down for hearing.] Where
exceptions shall be filed to the answer for insufficiency,
within the period prescribed by these rules, if the defendant
shall not submit to the same and file an amended answer on
the next succeeding rule-day, the plaintiff shall forthwith
set them down for a hearing on the next succeeding rule-
day thereafter, before a judge of the court, and shall enter,
as of course, in the order-book, an order for that purpose;
and if he shall not so set down the same for a hearing, the
exceptions shall be deemed abandoned, and the answer
shall be deemed sufficient; provided, however, that the
court, or any judge thereof, may, for good cause shown
enlarge the time for filing exceptions, or for answering the
same, in his discretion, upon such terms as he may deem
reasonable.
Rule 64. [Answer after exceptions allowed.] If, at the
hearing, the exceptions shall be allowed, the defendant shall
be bound to put in a full and complete answer thereto on
the next succeeding rule-day ; otherwise the plaintiff shall,
as of course, be entitled to take the bill, so far as the matter
of such exceptions is concerned, as confessed, or, at his
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 383
election, he may have a writ of attachment to compel the
defendant to make a better answer to the matter of the
exceptions ; and the defendant, when he is in custody upon
such writ, shall not be discharged therefrom but by an
order of the court, or of a judge thereof, upon his putting in
such answer, and complying with such other terms as the
court or judge may direct.
Rule 65. [Costs on overruling answer.] If, upon argu-
ment, the plaintiff's exceptions to the answer shall be over-
ruled, or the answer shall be adjudged insufficient, the pre-
vailing party shall be entitled to all the costs occasioned
thereby, unless otherwise directed by the court, or the judge
thereof, at the hearing upon the exceptions.
REPLICATION AND ISSUE.
Rule 66. [General replication when filed.] Whenever
the answer of the defendant shall not be excepted to, or
shall be adjudged or deemed sufficient, the plaintiff shall
file the general replication thereto on or before the next
succeeding rule-day thereafter; and in all cases where the
general replication is filed, the cause shall be deemed, to all
intents and purposes, at issue, without any rejoinder or
other pleading on either side. If the plaintiff shall omit or
refuse to file such replication within the prescribed period,
the defendant shall be entitled to an order, as of course, for
a dismissal of the suit; and the suit shall thereupon stand
dismissed, unless the court, or a judge thereof, shall, upon
motion, for cause shown, allow a replication to be filed nunc
pro tunc, the plaintiff submitting to speed the cause, and to
such other terms as may be directed.
TESTIMONY — HOW TAKEN.
Rule 67. [Commissions to take testimony.] After the
cause is at issue, commissions to take testimony may be
taken out in vacation as well as in term, jointly by both
384 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
parties, or severally by either party, upon interrogatories
filed by the party taking out the same in the clerk's office,
ten days' notice thereqf being given to the adverse party
to file cross-interrogatories before the issuing of the com-
mission; and if no cross-interragatories are filed at the ex-
piration of the time the commission may issue ex parte.
In all cases the commissioner or commissioners may be
named by the court or by a judge thereof; and the presiding
judge of the court exercising jurisdiction may, either in
term time or in vacation, vest in the clerk of the court
general power to name commissioners to take testimony.
[Testimony may be taken orally.] Either party may
give notice to the other that he desires the evidence to be
adduced in the cause to be taken orally, and thereupon all
the witnesses to be examined shall be examined before one
of the examiners of the court, or before an examiner to be
specially appointed by the court. The examiner, if he so
request, shall be furnished with a copy of the pleadings.
[Cross-examination.] Such examination shall take place
in the presence of the parties or their agents, by their coimsel
or solicitors, and the witnesses shall be subject to cross-ex-
amination and re-examination, all of which shall be con-
ducted as near as may be in the mode now used in common-
law courts.
[Depositions reduced to writing.] The depositions taken
upon such oral examination shall be reduced to writing by
the examiner, in the form of question put and answer given ;
provided, that, by consent of parties, the examiner may take
down the testimony of any witness in the form of narrative.
[Stenographer may be employed.] At the request of
either party, with reasonable notice, the deposition of any
witness shall, under the direction of the examiner, be taken
down either by a skillful stenographer or by a skillful type-
writer, as the examiner may elect, and when taken steno-
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 385
graphically shall be put into typewriting or other writing ;
provided, that such stenographer or typewriter has been
appointed by the court, or is approved by both parties.
[Testimony signed by witness.] The testimony of each
witness, after such reduction to writing, shall be read over
to him and signed by him in the presence of the examiner
and of such of the parties or counsel as may attend ; provided
that if the witness shall refuse to sign his deposition so taken,
then the examiner shall sign the same, stating upon the
record the reasons, if any, assigned by the witness for such
refusal.
[Competency of evidence not;passed]on by examiner.] The
examiner may, upon all examinations, state any special mat-
ters to the cotirt as he shall think fit; and any question or
questions which may be objected to shall be noted by the
examiner upon the deposition, but he shall not have power
to decide on the competency, materiality, or relevancy, of
the questions ; and the court shall have power to deal with
the costs of incompetent, immaterial, or irrelevant deposi-
tions, or parts of them, as may be just.
[Refusal of witnesses to attend.] In case of refusal of wit-
nesses; to: attend, to be sworn, or to answer any question put
by the examiner, or by coimsel or solicitor, the same practice
shall be adopted is as now practiced with respect to witnesses
to be produced on examination before an examiner of said
court on written interrogatories.
[Notice of examination.] Notice shall be given by the
respective counsel or solicitors to the opposite counsel or
solicitors, or parties, of the time and place of the examination
for such reasonable time as the examiner may fix by order
in each case.
[Depositions transmitted to clerlf.] When the examina-
tion of witnesses before the examiner is concluded, the origi-
nal depositiqns, authenticated by the signature of the ex-
386 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
aminer, shall be transmitted by him to the clerk of the court,
to be there filed of record, in the same mode as prescribed
in section 865 of the Revised Statutes.
[Testimony by written interrogatories.] Testimony may
be taken on commission in the usual way, by written in-
terrogatories and cross-interrogatories, on motion to the
court in term time, or to a judge in vacation, for special
reasons, satisfactory to the court or judge.
[Time for talcing testimony assigned by court.] Where
the evidence to be adduced in a cause is to be taken orally
as before provided, the court may, on motion of either
party, assign a time within which the complainant shall
take his evidence in support of the bill, and a time thereafter
within which the defendant shall take his evidence in de-
fense, and a time thereafter within which the complainant
shall take his evidence in reply; and no further evidence
shall be taken in the cause, unless by agreement of the parties
or by" leave of court first obtained on motion for cause
shown.
[Expenses of depositions.] The expense of the taking down
of depositions by a stenographer and of putting them into
typewriting or other writing shall be paid in the first in-
stance by the party calling the witness, and shall be imposed
by the court, as part of the costs, upon such party as the
court shall adjudge should ultimately bear them.
[Evidence in open court.] Upon due notice given as pre-
scribed by previous order, the court may, at its discretion
permit the whole, or any specific part, of the evidence to be
adduced orally in open court on final hearing.
Rule 68. [Deposition according to Act of Congress.]
Testimony may also be taken in the cause, after it is at
issue, by deposition, according to the act of Congress. But
in such case, if no notice is given to the adverse party of the
time and place of taking the deposition, he shall, upon mo-
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 387
tion and affidavit of the fact, be entitled to a cross-examina-
tion of the witness, either under a commission or by a new
deposition taken under the acts of Congress, if a court or
judge thereof shall, under all the circumstances, deem it
reasonable.
See Sec. 865-870 Revised S. of U. S. as to modes of taking deposi-
tions. By act of March 9th, 1892, state law as to taking depositions
maybe followed. 2 Supp. to R. S. of U. S., 4.
Rule 69. [Time for taking testimony after cause at issue.]
Three months, and no more, shall be allowed for the taking
of testimony after the cause is at issue, unless the court, or a
judge thereof, shall, upon special cause shown by either
party, enlarge the time ; and no testimony taken after such
period shall be allowed to be read in evidence at the hearing.
Immediately upon the return of the commissions and deposi-
tions containing the testimony into the clerk's office, publica-
tion thereof may be ordered in the clerk's office, by any
judge of the court, upon due notice to the parties, or it may
be enlarged, as he may deem reasonable, imder all the cir-
cimistances ; but, by consent of the parties, publication of
the testimony may at any time pass into the clerk's, office
such consent being in writing, and a copy thereof entered
in the order-books, or indorsed upon the deposition or
testimony.
TESTIMONY DE BENE ESSE.
Rule 70. [Conmiission to take testimony de bene esse
may issue.] After any bill filed and before the defendant
hath answered the same, upon affidavit made that any of
the plaintiff's witnesses are aged and infirm, or going out
of the country, or that any one of them is a single witness to
a material fact, the clerk of the court shall, as of course, upon
the application of the plaintiff, issue a commission to such
commissioner or commissioners as a judge of the court may
direct, to take the examination of such witness or witnesses
388 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
de bene esse, upon giving due notice to the adverse party of
the time and place of taking his testimony.
FORM OF THE LAST INTERROGATORY.
Rule 71. [Form of written interrogatory,] The last
interrogatory in the written interrogatories to take testimony
now commonly in use shall in the future be altered and
stated in substance thus: "Do you know, or^can you set
forth, any other matter or thing which may be a benefit or
advantage to the parties at issue in this cause, or either of
them, or that may be material to the subject of this your
examination, or the matters in question in this cause?"
If yea, set forth the same fully and at large in your answer."
CROSS-BILL.
Rule 72. [Answer to original bill before answer to cross
bill.] Where a defendant in equity files a cross-bill for dis-
covery only against the plaintiff in the original bill, the de-
fendant to the original bill shall first answer thereto before
the original plaintiff shall be compellable to answer the cross-
bill. The answer of the original plaintiff to such cross-bill
may be read and used by the party filing the cross-bill at
the hearing, in the same manner and under the same
restrictions as the answer praying relief may now be read
and used.
REFERENCE TO AND PROCEEDINGS BEFORE MASTERS.
Rule 73. [What decree for account to contain.] Every
decree for an account of the personal estate of a testator or
intestate shall contain a direction to the master to whom
it is referred to take the same to inquire and state to the court
what parts, if any, of such personal estate are outstanding or
undisposed of, unless the court shall otherwise direct.
Rule 74. [When matter presented to master.] Whenever
any reference of any matter is made to a master to examine
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 389
and report thereon, the party at whose instance or for
whose benefit the reference is made shall cause the same to be
presented to the master for a hearing on or before the next
rule-day succeeding the time when the reference was made ;
if he shall omit to do so, the adverse party shall be at liberty
forthwith to cause proceedings to he had before the mastisr,
at the costs of the party procuring the reference.
Rule 75. [Duty of Master to hear expeditiously.] Upon
every such reference, it shall be the duty of the master, as
soon as he reasonably can after the same is brought before
him, to assign a time and place for proceedings in the same,
and to give due notice thereof to each of the parties, or their
solicitors ; and if either party shall fail to appear at the time
and place appointed, the master shall be at liberty to pro-
ceed ex parte, or, in his discretion, to adjourn the examina-
tion and proceedings to a future day, giving notice to the ab-
sent party or his solicitor of such adjournment ; and it shall
be the duty of the master to proceed with all reasonable
diligence in every such reference, and with the least practi-
cable delay, and either party shall be at liberty to apply
to the court, or a judge thereof, for an order to the master
to speed the proceedings and to make his report, and to
certify to the court or judge the reason for any delay.
Rule 76. [What Master's report to contain.] In the re-
ports made by the master to the coiut, no part of any state
of facts, charge, affidavit, deposition, examination or answer
brought in or used before them shall be stated or recited.
But such state of facts, charge, affidavit, deposition, ex-
amination, or answer shall be identified, specified, and re-
ferred to, so as to inform the court what state of facts, charge,
affidavit, deposition, examination, or answer were so brought
in or used.
Rule 77. [Hearing before Master.] The master shall
regulate all the proceedings in every hearing before him.
390 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
Upon every such reference ; and he shall have full authority
to examine the parties in the cause, upon oath, touching
all matters contained in the reference; and also to require
the production of all books, papers, writings, vouchers, and
other documents, applicable thereto; and also to examine
on oath, viva voce^ all witnesses produced by the parties
before him, and to order the examination of other witnesses
to be taken, under a commission to be issued upon his cer-
tificate from the clerk's office or by deposition, according to
the act of Congress, or otherwise, as hereinafter provided;
and also to direct the mode in which the matters requiring
evidence shall be proved before him; and generally to do
all other acts, and direct all other inquiries and proceedings
in the matters before him, which he may. deem necessary
and proper to the justice and merits thereof and the rights
of the parties.
Rule 78. [Witnesses before Master — how summoned.]
Witnesses who live within the district may, upon due notice
to the opposite party, be simimoned to appear before the
commissioner appointed to take testimony, or before a mas-
ter or examiner appointed in any cause, by subpoena in the
usual form, which may be issued by the clerk in blank, and
filled up by the party praying the sariie, or by the commis-
sioner, master, or examiner, requiring the attendance of the
witnesses at the time and place specified, who shall be allowed
for attendance the same compensation as for attendance
in court; and if any witness shall refuse to appear or give
evidence it shall be deemed a contempt of the court, which
being certified to the clerk's office by the commissioner,
master, or examiner, an attachment may issue thereupon
by order of the court or of any judge thereof, in the same
manner as if the contempt were for not attending, or for re-
fusing to give testimony in the court. But nothing herein
contained shall prevent the examination of witnesses viva
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 391
voce when produced in open court, if the court shall, in it
discretion, deem it advisable.
Rule 79. [Account, how taken.] All parties accounting
before a master shall bring in their respective accoimts in
the form of debtor and creditor ; and any of the other par-
ties who shall not be satisfied with the account so brought
in shall be at liberty to examine the accounting party viva
voce, or upon interrogatories, in the master's office, or by
deposition, as the master shall direct.
Rule 80. [Evidence previously taken to be used before
the Master.] All affidavits, depositions, and documents
which have been previously made, read, or used in the cotu*t
upon any proceeding in any cause or matter may be used
before the master.
Rule 81. [Evidence — how taken.] The master shall be
at liberty to examine any creditor or other person coming
in to claim before him, either upon written interrogatories
or viva voce, or in both modes, as the nature of the case may
appear to him to require. The evidence upon such exami-
nations shall be taken down by the master, or by some other
person by his order and in his presence, if either party re-
quires it, in order that the same may be used by the court
if necessary.
Rule 82. [Appointment of Masters in Chancery.] The
Circuit Courts may appoint standing masters in chancery
in their respective districts (a majority of all the judges
thereof, including the justice of the Supreme Court, the cir
cuit judges, and the district judge for the district, concur-
ring in the appointment), and they may also appoint a mas-
ter pro hac vice in any particular case. The compensation
to be allowed to every master m chancery for his services
in any particular case shall be iixed by the circuit court,
in its discretion, having regard to all the circumstances
thereof, and the compensation shall be charged upon and
392 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
borne by such of the parties in the cause as the court shall
direct. The master shall not retain his report as security
for his compensation ; but when the compensation is allowed
by the court, he shall be entitled to an attachment for the
amount against the party who is ordered to pay the same, if,
upon notice thereof, he does not pay it within the time pre-
scribed by the court.
EXCEPTIONS TO REPORT OF MASTER.
Rule 83. [Return of Masters report — exceptions.] The
master, as soon as his report is ready, shall return the same
into the clerk's office, and the day of the return shall be
entered by the clerk in the order book. The parties shall
have one month from the time of filing the report to file ex-
ceptions thereto; and, if no exceptions are within that period
filed by either party, the report shall stand confirmed on
the next rule-day after the month is expired. If exceptions
are filed, they shall stand for hearing before the coiut, if the
court, is then in session ; or, if not, then at the next sitting
of the court which shall be held thereafter, by adjournment
or otherwise.
Rule 84. [Costs on overruling exceptions.] And, in
order to prevent exceptions to reports from being filed for
frivolous causes, or for mere delay, the party whose excep-
tions are overruled shall, for every exception overruled, pay
costs to the other party, and for every exception allowed
shall be entitled to costs; the cost to be fixed in each case
by the coiu-t, by a standing rule of the Circuit Court.
DECREES.
Rule 85. [Correcting decrees.] Clerical mistakes in de-
crees or decretal orders, or errors arising from any accidental
slip or omission, may, at any time before an actual enroll-
ment thereof, be corrected by order of the court or a judge
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 393
thereof, upon petition, without the form or expense of a
rehearing.
Rule 86. [Form of decrees.] In drawing up decree
and orders, neither the bill, nor answer, nor other pleadings
nor any part thereof, nor the report of any master, nor any
other prior proceeding, shall be recited or stated in the de-
cree or order ; but the decree and order shall begin, in sub-
stance, as follows: "This cause came on to be heard (or to
be further heard, as the case may be) at this term, and was
argued by counsel ; and thereupon, upon consideration there-
of, it was ordered, adjudged, and decreed as follows, viz:"
[Here insert the decree or order.]
GUARDIANS AND PROCHEIN AMIS.
Rule 87. [Appointment of guardians..] Guardians ad
litem to defend a suit may be appointed by the court, or by
any judge thereof, for infants or other persons who are under
guardianship, or otherwise incapable to sue for themselves.
All infants and other persons so incapable may sue by their
guardians, if any, or by their prochein ami ; subject, however,
to such orders as the court may direct for the protection
of infants and other persons.
Rule 88. [Petition for reliearing — verification.] Every
petition for a rehearing shall contain the special matter
or cause on which such rehearing is applied for, shall be
signed by counsel, and the facts therein stated, if not appar-
ent on the record, shall be verified by the oath of the party or
by some other person. No hearing shall be granted after
the term at \vhich the final decree of the court shall have
been entered and recorded, if an appeal lies to the Supreme
Coiu*t. But if no appeal lies, the petition may be admitted
at any time before the end of the next term of the court, in
the discretion of the court.
Rule 89. [Rules in several circuits.] The circuit courts
394 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
(a majority of all the judges thereof, including the justice
of the Supreme Court, the circuit judges, and the district
judge for the district, cor. ?urring therein) may make any
other and further rules and regulations for the practice,
proceedings, and process, mesne and final, in their respect-
ive districts, not inconsistent with the rules hereby pre-
scribed, in their discretion, and from time to time alter and
amend the same.
Rule 90. [English chancery practice to govern.] In all
cases where the rules prescribed by this court or by the cir-
cuit court do not apply, the practice of the circuit court
shall be regulated by the present practice of the high court
of chancery in England, so far as the same may reasonably
be applied consistently with the local circumstances and
local conveniences of the district where the court is held,
not as positive rules, but as ftimishing just analogies to
regulate the practice.
Rule 91. [Oath or affirmation.] Whenever, under these
rules, an oath is or may be required to be taken, the party
may, if conscientiously scrupulous of taking an oath, in lieu
thereof make solemn affirmation to the truth of the facts
stated by him.
Rule 92. [Deficiency decree.] Ordered, December term,
1863, That in suits in equity for the foreclosin"e of mort-
gages in the Circuit Courts of the United States, or in any
court of the Territories having jurisdiction of the same, a
decree may be rendered for any balance that may be foimd
due to the complainant over and above the proceeds of the
sale or sales, and execution may issue for the collection of
the same, as is provided, in the eight rule of this court regu-
lating the equity practice where the decree is solely for the
payment of money.
UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES. 395
INJUNCTIONS.
Riile 93. October Term, 1878. [Injunction pending
appeal.] When an appeal from a final decree, in an equity
suit, granting or dissolving an injunction, is allowed by a
justice or judge who took part in the decision of the cause,
he may, in his discretion, at the time of such allowance,
make an order suspending or modifying the injimction dur-
ing the pendency of the appeal, upon such terms, as to bond
or otherwise, as he may consider proper for the security
of the rights of the opposite party.
Rule 94. October Term, 1881. [Bill by stockholder of
corporation.] Every bill brought by one or more stock-
holders in a corporation against the corporation and other
parties, foimded on rights which may properly be asserted
by the corporation, must be verified by oath, and must
contain an allegation that the plaintiff was a shareholder at
the time of the transaction of which he complains, or that
his share had devolved on him since by operation of law,
and that the suit is not a collusive one to confer on a court
of the United States jurisdiction of a case of which it would
not otherwise have cognizance. It must also set forth with
particularity the efforts of the plaintiff to secure such action
as he desires on the part of the managing directors or trus-
tees, and, if necessary, of the shareholders, and the causes
of his failure to obtain such action.
The folloiving provisions relating to equity practice are to
be found in the Act of ist of June, 1872:
Sec. 7. [Granting injunction on motion.] That whenever
notice is given of a motion for an injimction out of a
Circuit or District Cotut of the United States, the court
or judge thereof may, if there appear to be danger of irrep-
arable injury from delay, grant an order restraining the act
sought to be enjoined until the decision upon the motion.
Such order may be granted with or without security, in
396 UNITED STATES EQUITY RULES.
the discretion of the court or judge: Provided That no
justice of the Supreme Court shall hear or allow any appli-
cation for an injunction or restraining order except within
the circuit to which he is allotted, and in causes pending
in the circuit to which he is allotted, or in such causes at
such place outside of the circuit as the parties may in writ-
ing stipulate, except in causes where such application can
not be heard by the circuit judge of the circuit, or the dis-
trict judge of the district.
Sec. 13. [Bringing in absent defendants.] That when
in any suit in equity, commenced in any court in the United
States, to enforce any legal or equitable lien or claim against
real or personal property within the district where such
suit is brought, one or more of the defendants therein shall
not be an inhabitant of or found within the said district,
or shall not voluntarily appear thereto, it shall be lawful
for the court to make an order directing such absent defend-
ant to appear, plead, answer, or demiu* to the complainant's
bill at a certain day therein to be designated, which order
shall be served on such absent defendant, if practicable,
wherever found ; or where such personal service is not practi-
cable, such order shall be published in such a manner as
the court shall direct; and in case such absent defendant
shall not appear, plead, answer, or demur within the time
so limited, or within some further time to be allowed by the
court, in its discretion, and upon proof of the service or
publication of such order, and of the performance of the
directions contained in the same, it shall be lawful, for the
court to entertain jurisdiction, and proceed to the hearing
and adjudication of such suit in the same manner as if such
absent defendant had been served with process within the
said district; but such adjudication shall, as regards such
absent defendant without appearance, affect his property
within such district only.
AMENDMENT TO THE LAW OF JULY i, A. D.
1898-PASSED FEBRUARY 5,
A. D. 1903.
AN ACT to amend an Act entitled "An Act to establish a uniform
system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," approved
Jvily first, eighteen hundred and ninety-eight.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of
the United States of America in Congress assembled, That
clause five of section two of said Act be, and the same is
hereby, amended so as to read as follows :
" (5) Authorize the business of bankrupts to be con-
ducted for limited periods by receivers, the marshals, or
trustees, if necessary in the best interests of the estates and
allow such officers additional compensation for such serv-
ices, but not at a greater rate than in this Act allowed trus-
tees for similar services;"
Sec. 2. That clause four, subdivision a, of section three
of said Act, be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to
read as follows :
" or (4) made a general assignment for the benefit of his
creditors, or, being insolvent, applied for a receiver or
trustee for his property or because of insolvency a receiver
or trustee has been put in charge of his property imder the
laws of a State, of a Territory, or of the United States."
Sec. 3. That subdivision b of section four of said Act be,
and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as follows :
"b Any natural person, except a wage-earner, or a per-
son engaged chiefly in farming or the tillage of the soil, any
unincorporated company, and any corporation, engaged
397
398 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
principally in manufacturing, trading, printing, publishing,
mining, or mercantile pursuits, owing debts to the amoimt
of one thousand dollars or over, may be adjudged an in-
voluntary bankrupt upon default or an impartial trial, and
shall be subject to the provisions and entitled to the bene-
fits of this Act. Private bankers, but not national banks
or banks incorporated under State or Territorial laws, may
be adjudged involuntary bankrupts.
"The bankruptcy of a corporation shall not release its
officers, directors, or stockholders, as such, from any lia-
bility under the laws of a State or Territory or of the
United States."
Sec. 4. That subdivision b of section fourteen of said
Act be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as
follows :
"b The judge shall hear the application for a discharge,
and such proofs and pleas as may be made in opposition
thereto by parties in interest, at such time as will give
parties in interest a reasonable opportunity to be fully
heard, and investigate the merits of the application and dis-
charge the applicant unless he has (1) committed an offense
punishable by imprisonment as herein provided ; or (2) with
intent to conceal his financial condition, destroyed, con-
cealed, or failed to keep books of account or records from
which such condition might be ascertained ; or (3) obtained
property on credit from any person upon a materially false
statement in writing made to such person for the purpose
of obtaining such property on credit ; or (4) at any time sub-
sequent to the first day of the four months immediately
preceding the filing of the petition transferred, removed, de-
stroyed, or concealed, or permitted to be removed, de-
stroyed, or concealed any of his property with intent to
Note. See post the Report of the Judiciary Committee of the House
concerning this amendment.
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 399
hinder, delay, or defraud his creditors; or (5) in voluntary
proceedings been granted a discharge in bankruptcy within
six years; or (6) in the course of the proceedings in bank-
ruptcy refused to obey any lawful order of or to answer any
material question approved by the court."
Sec. 5. That section seventeen of said Act, be, and the
same is hereby amended so as to read as follows :
"Sec. 17. Debts not Affected by a Discharge. — a A
discharge in bankruptcy shall release a bankrupt from all of
his provable debts, except such as (1) are due as a tax
levied by the United States, the State, county, district, or
municipality in which he resides; (2) are liabilities for ob-
taining property by false pretenses or false representations,
or for wilful and malicious injuries to the person or prop-
erty of another, or for alimony due or to become due, or for
maintenance or support of wife or child, or for seduction
of an immarried female, or for criminal conversation; (3)
have nat been duly scheduled in time for proof and allow-
ance, with the name of the creditor if known to the bank-
rupt, imless such creditor had notice or actual knowledge of
the proceedings in bankruptcy; or (4) were created by his
fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation, or defalcation while
acting as an officer or in any fiduciary capacity."
Sec. 6. That subdivisions a and b of section eighteen of
said Act be, and the same are hereby, amended so as to
read as follows :
"a Upon the filing of a petition for involimtary bank-
ruptcy, service thereof, with a writ of subpoena, shall be
made upon the person therein named as defendant in the
same manner that service of such process is now had upon
the commencement of a suit in equity in the courts of the
United States, except that it shall be returnable within fif-
teen days, unless the judge shall for cause fix a longer time ;
but in case personal service cannot be made, then notice
400 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
shall be given by publication in the same manner and for
the same time as provided by law for notice by publication
in suits to enforce a legal or equitable Hen in courts of the
United States, except that, imless the judge shaU other-
wise direct, the order shall be published not more than once
a week for two consecutive weeks, and the return day shall
be ten days after the last pubHcation imless the judge shall
for cause fix a longer time."
"b The bankrupt, or any creditor, may appear and plead
to the petition within five days after the return day, or
within such further time as the court may allow."
Sec. 7. That subdivision a of section twenty-one of said
Act ^e, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as
follows :
"a A court of bankruptcy may, upon application of any
officer, bankrupt, or creditor, by order require any desig-
nated person, including the bankrupt and his wife, to appear
in court or before a referee or the judge of any State court,
to be examined concerning the acts, conduct, or property of
a bankrupt whose estate is in process of administration imder
this Act: Provided: That the wife may be examined only
touching business transacted by her or to which she is a
party, and to determine the fact whether she has transacted
or been a party to any business of the bankrupt."
Sec. 8. That subdivision b of section twenty-three of
said Act be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read
as follows:
"b Suits by the trustee shall only be brought or prose-
cuted in the coiirts where the bankrupt, whose estate is
being administered by such trustee, might have brought or
prosecuted them if proceedings in bankruptcy had not been
instituted, unless by consent of the proposed defendant,
except suits for the recovery of property under section
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 401
sixty, subdivision b, and section sixty-seven, subdivision
e."
Sec. 9. That subdivision a of section forty of said Act
be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as fol-
lows :
"a Referees shall receive as full compensation for their
services, payable after they are rendered, a fee of fifteen
dollars deposited with the clerk at the time the petition is
filed in each case, except when a fee is not required from a
voluntary bankrupt, and twenty-five cents for every proof
of claim filed for allowance, to be paid from the estate, if
any, as a part of the cost of administration, and from estates
which have been administered before them one per centum
commissions on all moneys disbursed to creditors by the
trustee, or one-half of one per centum on the amoimt to be
paid to creditors upon the confirmation of a composition."
Sec. 10. That section forty-seven is hereby amended
by adding thereto the following subdivision:
"c The trustee shall, within thirty days after the ad-
judication, file a certified copy of the decree of adjudication
in the office where conveyances of real estate are recorded
in every coimty where the bankrupt owns real estate not
exempt from execution, and pay the fee for such filing, and
he shall receive a compensation of fifty cents for each copy
so filed, which, together with the filing fee, shall be paid out
of the estate of the bankrupt as a part of the cost and dis-
bursements of the proceedings."
Sec. 11. That subdivision a of section forty-eight of said
Act be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as
follows :
"a Trustees shall receive for their services, payable after
they are rendered, a fee of five dollars deposited with the
clerk at the time the petition is filed in each case, except
402 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
when a fee is not required from a voluntary bankrupt, and
from estates which they have administered such com-
missions on all moneys disbursed by them as may be allowed
by the courts, not to exceed six per centum on the first five
himdred dollars or less, four per centum on moneys in ex-
cess of five hundred dollars and less than fifteen hundred
dollars, two per centum on moneys in excess of fifteen
htmdred dollars and less than ten thousand dollars, and one
per centum on moneys in excess of ten thousand dollars.
And in case of the confirmation of a composition after the
trustee has quaHfied the court may allow him, as compensa-
tion, not to exceed one-half of one per centum of the amount
to be paid the creditors on such composition."
Sec. 12. That subdivision g of section fifty-seven of said
Act be, and the same is hereby, amended so as to read as
follows :
"g The claims of creditors who have received preferences,
voidable under section sixty, subdivision b, or to whom con-
veyances, transfers, assignments, or incumbrances, void or
voidable imder section sixty-seven, subdivision e, have been
made or given, shall not be allowed unless such creditors
shall surrender such preferences, conveyances, transfers,
assignments, or incumbrances."
Sec. 13. That subdivisions a and b of section sixty of
said Act be, and the same are hereby, amended so as to read
as follows:
** a A person shall be deemed to have given a preference if,
being insolvent, he has, within four months before the filing
of the petition, or after the filing of the petition and before
the adjudication, procured or suffered a judgment to be
entered against himself in favor of any person, or made a
transfer of any of his property, and the effect of the en-
forcement of such judgment or transfer will be to enable
any one of his creditors to obtain a greater percentage of his
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 403
debt than any other of such creditors of the same class.
Where the preference consists in a transfer, such period of
four months shall not expire until four months after the
date of the recording or registering of the transfer, if by law
such recording or registering is required."
"b If a bankrupt shall have given a preference, and the
person receiving it, or to be benefited thereby, or his agent
acting therein, shall have had reasonable cause to believe
that it was intended thereby to give a preference, it shall be
voidable by the trustee, and he may recover the property
or its value from such person. And, for the purpose of such
recovery, any court of bankruptcy, as hereinbefore defined,
and any State court which would have had jurisdiction if
bankruptcy had not intervened, shall have concurrent
jurisdiction."
Sec. 14. That clause two of subdivision b of section
sixty-four of said Act be, and the same is hereby, amended
so as to read as follows :
" (2) the filing fees paid by creditors in involuntary cases,
and, where property of the bankrupt, transferred or con-
cealed by him either before or after the filing of the petition,
shall have been recovered for the benefit of the estate of the
bankrupt by the efforts and at the expense of one or more
creditors, the reasonable expenses of such recovery."
Sec. 15. That subdivision b of section sixty-five be, and
the same is hereby, amended so as to read as follows :
"The first dividend shall be declared within thirty days
after the adjudication, if the money of the estate in excess
of the amount necessary to pay the debts which have
priority and such claims as have not been, but probably will
be, allowed equals five per centum or more of such allowed
claims. Dividends subsequent to the first shall be de-
clared upon like terms as the first and as often as the amount
404 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
shall equal ten per centum or more and upon closing the
estate. Dividends may be declared oftener and in smaller
proportions if the judge shall so order : Provided: That the
first dividend shall not include more than fifty per centum
of the money of the estate in excess of the amount necessary
to pay the debts which have priority and such claims as
probably will be allowed. And provided further: That the
final dividend shall not be declared within three months
after the first dividend shall be declared."
Sec. 16. That subdivision e of section sixty-seven and
subdivision e of section seventy of said Act be, and the
same are hereby, amended by adding at the end of each
such subdivision the words :
"For the purpose of such recovery any court of bank-
ruptcy as hereinbefore defined, and any State court which
would have had jurisdiction if bankruptcy had not inter-
vened, shall have concurrent jurisdiction."
Sec. 17. That said Act is also amended by adding
thereto a new section, section seventy-one, to read as
follows :
"Sec. 71. That the clerks of the several district courts
of the United States shall prepare and keep in their re-
spective offices complete and convenient indexes of all peti-
tions and discharges in bankruptcy heretofore or hereafter
filed in the said courts, and shall, when requested so to do,
issue certificates of search certifying as to whether or not
any such petitions or discharges have been filed; and said
clerks shall be entitled to receive for such certificates the
same fees as now allowed by law for certificates as to judg-
ments in said courts: Provided: That said bankruptcy
indexes and dockets shall at all times be open to inspection
and examination by all persons or corporations without any
fee or charge therefor."
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 405
Sec. 18. That said Act is also amended by adding
thereto a new section as follows :
"Sec. 72. That neither the referee nor the trustee shall
in any form or guise receive, nor shall the court allow them,
any other or further compensation for their services than
that expressly authorized and prescribed in this Act."
Sec. 19. That the provisions of this amendatory Act
shall not apply to bankruptcy cases pending when this
Act takes effect, but such cases shall be adjudicated and
disposed of conformably to the provisions of the said Act
of July first, eighteen hundred and ninety-eight.
Approved, February 5, 1903.
406 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
REPORT OF THE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ON
THE AMENDMENT TO THE BANKRUPTCY ACT.
57th Congres., ) g^^^^ ^^ Representatives. [ ^ ^^^
ist Session. > '^ ' No. 1698.
AMENDING THE BANKRUPTCY LAW.
Mr. Ray, from the Committee on the Judiciary, submitted
the following
RBPORT.
The Committee on the Judiciary, to which was referred
the bill (H. R. 13,679) amending the bankruptcy law, has
carefully considered the same and reports the bill back
with the recommendation that it pass.
There have been laid before the committee resolutions
and commtmications from more than 20,000 manufactur-
ing and producing industries, merchants, wholesale and re-
tail ; credit men's and other business associations, lawyers,
judges, and business men generally, representing whole-
sale and retail dealers, emphatically approving the law,
asking its retention, and approving the amendments sug-
gested by this bill.
Of all commimications received on the subject less than
10 per cent, are opposed to the bankruptcy law, and these
in the main place their opposition on the ground of the de-
NoTE. Courts frequently in constniing statutes refer to the speeches
and reports of the legislators which accompany the passage of the act as
a source of information. {Exparte Milligan, 4 Wall., 114.) It has been
thought desirable to print the report of the Judiciary Committee and
the Analysis of the Amendment accompanying the same when the bill
was before the House. A foot note will call attention to the changes
which the house bill received in its passage through the Senate,
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 407
fects in the law sought to be remedied and which will be
remedied if these amendments are adopted.
These communications are not the result of concerted
action for the retention of the law, but are the result of a
desire on the part of the Judiciary Committee to fuUy as-
certain the sentiment of the cotmtry on the question of the
retention or repeal of the law. Near the close of the Fifty-
sixth Congress the chairman of the Committee on the
Judiciary sent out something like 15,000 inquiries indis-
criminately throughout the United States addressed to all
business interests, wholesale and retail, merchants, lawyers
judges, etc., asking their opinion of the law and the ad-
visability of its retention and also asking their approval
or disapproval of the amendments proposed, and which
amendments are in substance those reported by the com-
mittee. There was no selection except to direct inquiries
to the leading business houses, wholesale and retail, and the
leading lawyers and business men of the cotmtry. It is
conclusively proved that the business interests |and the
people of the United States approve and demand the re-
tention of the bankruptcy law and also desire these amend-
ments which are in the interest of honest dealing. The
amendments proposed are not niunerous, but are such as
experience has demonstrated to be essential.
The first amendment will make the law more uniform and
equitable by providing that where insolvency is the ques-
tion at issue assets claimed to be exempt shall not be
coimted in ascertaining the aggregate of the debtor's prop-
erty^.
The second amendment simply authorizes what is now
done by the courts ; that is, it authorizes the court to allow
additional compensation when the business of a bankrupt
Note. 1 omitted by the Senate.
408 AMENDMENTS OF 1903,
is conducted for a limited period by the receiver, marshal
or trustee in the interest of the creditors.
The next amendment makes the equivalent acts of a
general assignment by an insolvent person, a voluntary
accoimting of an insolvent partnership by action brought
by one of the partners, and an application for a receivership
of an insolvent corporation each acts of bankruptcy. This
makes the law more uniform and will reduce many of the
inequities now practiced on creditors.
The next amendment simply provides that those copor-
rations which can now be adjudged involuntary bankrupts
may become voluntary bankrupts on the petition of an
officer or stockholder duly authorized at a meeting called
for that purpose by a vote of the majority in amotmt of the
total stock of the corporation, and adds mining corpora-
tions to those now covered by the law^.
As a safeguard and to prevent injustice it is provided
by a further amendment that the bankruptcy of a cor-
poration shall not release its officers, directors, or stock-
holders as such from any liability under the laws of a State
or Territory or of the United States. That is, if these
officers or any of them by wrongdoing or violating the law
of the State have incurred any liability they are not to be
discharged from such obligations or liabilities.
The next amendment, section 5 of the bill, makes definite
and certain the purpose of the law as it was framed, to wit :
That the words "in contemplation of bankruptcy," mean a
present or future state of insolvency and purpose to take
advantage of the law. The amendment is necessary be-
cause the courts have held that the words "in contemplation
of bankruptcy" mean with a view to the actual filing of
a petition, and therefore many men have been discharged
who ought not to have been, because it was impossible to
Note. 2 omitted by the Senate.
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 409
prove that they committed the fraudulent acts mentioned
at a time when they had in mind the filing of a petition in
bankruptcy, although they did have in mind a present or
future state of insolvency and committed the acts for the
purpose of defrauding their creditors.
This amendment also provides four additional grounds for
refusing a discharge in bankruptcy: (1) Obtaining prop-
erty on credit on materially false statements; (2) making
a fraudident transfer of property ;' (3) having been granted
or denied a discharge in bankruptcy within six years, and
(4) having refused to obey the lawful orders of the cotirt or
having refused to answer material questions approved by
the court. No person who has been guilty of any of these
fraudulent acts should be discharged, and a person who has
refused to obey the order of the court ought not to be dis-
charged, and it is quite clear that no person should have the
benefit of the act as a voluntary bankrupt oftener than once
in six years. Some men in some of the large cities have
made bankruptcy a profession, and it is proposed by the
amendment to stamp out these practices.
The next amendment provides that liabilities for frauds* ,
etc., as described in the act shall not be released by the
discharge. As the law now is, these liabilities must have been
reduced to judgment or else the bankrupt is discharged.
This amendment is in the interest of justice and honest
dealing and honest conduct. This amendment further
provides that a discharge in bankruptcy shall not release
the bankrupt from liability for alimony due or to become
due the wife, or for maintenance or support of wife
or child, or for seduction of an unmarried female, or for
criminal conversation. It seems to the committee, and
this is the universal sentiment,' that the bankrupt ought
not to be discharged from liabilties of this description.
Note. 3 Altered and amplified by the Senate.
4. Altered by Senate omitting word "fraud."
410 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
The next amendment shortens the time for joining issue
in involuntary cases. The expeditious disposition of an
estate in bankruptcy is what all creditors desire, and this
amendment is in the interest of all parties and simply,
prevents tmdue delay.
The next amendment permits the wife to be examined
as a witness as to business transactions to w^hich she is or
has been a party. In some of the States the wife may now
be examined the same as any other witness. In other
States she cannot be, and this amendment, carefully guarded
by a proviso, simply allows her examinations as to business
transactions to which she has been a party. To this there
can be no reasonable objection.
The next amendment is in the interest of the speedy
settlement of bankrupt estates. It has been held that
actions to recover property belonging to the estate and
fraudulently withheld or disposed of must be brought in
the local courts. In great cities this works a practical
denial of justice, as the calendars of the State courts are
many times years behind, and it is conceded that in the
City of New York a case cannot be reached for trial in less
than from two to three years after the action is brought
unless for some reason it is preferred.
The next amendment gives a larger fee to the clerk*.
It is conceded on all hands that the present fee is so small
that the clerk cannot afford to do the work required of him.
The increase given by this amendment is very small, in-
deed, and cannot be reasonably objected to.
The same remarks apply to the next amendment.
The next amendment, section 12 of the bill, is the most
important of all. Under the holding of the Supreme
Court of the United States in Pirie v. Chicago Title and Trust
Cmnpany (182 U. S., 438), that section 60, subdivision
5. Presumably a misprint for "referee."
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 411
A, is a definition of a preference, it followed that payments
made in good faith and other bona fide transactions after
actual insolvency, though in due course of trade and busi-
ness and without knowledge or reasonable cause to believe
that a preference was intended, must be, under section 57g,
surrendered before a creditor who received such a payment
could prove the balance of his debt. This was never
intended by the framers of the law, and it works obvious
injustice and is the source of 99 per cent, of the objections
to the law. The amendments proposed by section 12 of
the bill and the other sections remedy all this.
The next amendment puts the four months' clause in
subdivision A instead of subdivision B, and where it ought
to be. As the law now stands, a preferential mortgage
may be given and the creditor preferred, by withholding
it from record four months, be able to dismiss the trustees'
suit to recover the same, although it was recorded within
the four months' period.
The next amendment simply provides that the trustee shall
not be compelled to pay the accrued taxes on the home-
stead set-off to the bankrupt from the balance of the estate*.
The further amendment to Section 64 of the act simply
provides that the creditor may be allowed the reasonable
expense of reclaiming property illegally transferred or con-
cealed.
The next amendment is in line with the others, providing
concurrent jurisdiction in the State and United States courts,
and is in the interest of a speedy settlement of estates.
The last amendment is one generally demanded, and is
in the interest of all persons who deal with property. It
requires the clerks to prepare and keep indexes of all petitions
and discharges in bankruptcy and to issue certificates in re-
lation thereto when required. It also requires that these
6. Omitted by the Senate.
412 AMENDMENTS OP 1903.
be kept open to inspection and examination. It is frequently
desirable to know whether a person [has filed a petition
in bankruptcy, and also whether he has been discharged
and it is many times impossible within a reasonable time to
ascertain these facts in the absence of convenient indexes,
Annexed hereto is a more complete analysis of these pro-
posed amendments, useful and convenient to the lawyer,
and in same attention is called to the decisions of the courts
relating to the amended sections.
In proper cases and under proper restrictions those who
have been unfortimate in business should be released from
their debts on surrendering all their property to their credi-
tors. But the law should be so framed as to prevent in-
justice and improper and indiscriminate discharges, and
should also prevent its being availed of by the professional
bankrupt or the dishonest debtor.
The involuntary features are most commendable, for
through their instrumentalities fraudulent and unjust pref-
erences are prohibited and there is greater confidence in the
business world. Much of the fault finding with the bankruptcy
law has come from those who having claims against some
insolvent person, have been imable to collect for years (and
these persons knew that they could not collect), but they
have seen the debtor discharged imder the bankruptcy
law and have seen him re-enter the business world, and by
the exercise of his talent and industry become a valuable
factor in the business world. These debtors could never
have thus re-entered business had it not been for the bank-
ruptcy law, and this fact the creditor overlooks. He seems
to think that but for the bankruptcy law he would have
been paid imder this improved condition of the debtor.
That dishonest men do avail themselves of the law and
by fraud and perjury secure discharges can not be denied,
but these instances are very rare, and when we contrast the
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 413
great army of honest and industrious men who have been
put upon their feet through the instrumentalities of the
bankruptcy law with the very few dishonest persons who
have been discharged imder it, we must all concede that the
law is wise and productive of great good and ought to be
retained, and amended when experience shows that amend-
ments are necessary in the interest of the business world.
ANALYSIS OP BILL TO AMEND THE BANKRUPTCY LAW.
Section 1 : Amends clause (15) of Section 1 of the laws
so that where insolvency is' the question at issue assets
claimed to be exempt shall not be counted in ascertaining
the "aggregate of his (the debtor's) property," thus doing
away with an injustice growing out of the new definition
of insolvency in States that allow large exemptions. (See
In re Baumann (Term.), 96 Fed., 946.) ^
Section 2: Designed to permit the allowance of extra
compensation to trustees when they do more than merely
collect and distribute (as, for instance, when they are ordered
to continue a going business for a considerable period of time)
their fees being now limited by Section 48 to commissions
on dividends to imsecured creditors. (See In re Epstein
(Ark.), 109 Fed., 879, and the cases cited.) *
Section 3: Intended to bring about the result that the
equivalent acts of (1) a general assignment by an insolvent
person, (2) a volimtary accoimting of an insolvent partner-
ship by action brought by one of the partners, and (3) an
application for a receivership of an insolvent corporation
shall each be acts of bankruptcy, instead of the first (1) only,
as now. Besides making the law more imiform, this change
will reduce to a minimum present notorious inequities prac-
ticed on creditors through in-the-family accountings and
Note 1. Omitted by the Senate. 2. The Senate added a proviso
that the compensation should not exceed the rate allowed trustees.
414 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
directorial receiverships iinder State laws. (See In re Em-
pire Metallic Bedstead Co. (N. Y.), 95 Fed., 957; Id., on ap-
peal, 98 Fed., 981, and subsequent cases uniformly holding
the same doctrine.)
Section 4 : Amends Section 4 of the law by (1) providing
that those corporations which can now be adjudged invol-
untary bankrupts may, on a vote of stockholders represent-
ing a majority of the stock, petition for voluntary bank-
ruptcy,' (2) adding mining corporations to those that are
affected by the law, and (3) affirmatively declaring that the
bankruptcy of a corporation shall not release its officers, as
such, from any liability created by law.
The first (1) restores that portion of the first paragraph
of Section 37 of the bankruptcy law of 1867 which permitted
business corporations to file volimtary petitions, with, how-
ever, some additional restrictions for the protection of stock-
holders— a change the necessity of which is emphasized by
the prevailing tendency in important commercial States
to supersede partnerships completely by small corporations.
The second (2) is made necessary by the uniform holdings
of the courts that mining corporations, which are of primary
importance in some parts of the country, are not among
those now enumerated in Section 4b. (See In re Chicago-
Joplin Lead and Zinc Co. (Mo.), 104 Fed., 67; McNamara
v. Helena Coal Co. (Ala.), 5 Am. B. R., 48; In re Keystone
Coal Co. (Pa.), 6 Am. B. R., 377.)
The third (3) is merely precautionary — that there may
be no doubt about the effect of the discharge of a corpora-
tion. (See In re Marshall Paper Co., 102 Fed., 872.)
Section 5: Modifies one of the present objections to a
discharge and adds four new objections.
It has been uniformly held tinder the present law that
Note 3. Omitted by Senate.
AMENDMENTS OF 1903: 415
"in contemplation of bankruptcy" (Sec. 14b, 2) means with
a view to the actual filing of a petition, and not merely a
present or future state of insolvency. (In re Holman (Iowa) .
92 Fed., 512; In re Carmichael (Iowa), 96 Fed., 594; In re
Morgan (Ark.), 101 Fed., 982.) This has made this object-
ion to a discharge practically valueless. The amendment
drops this element of proof out, as well as two or three other
words which are either tautological or imnecessary.
The very general complaint that the present law lets too
many rogues escape from their debts — that it is weak in its
discharge features — is met by four additional objections,
carefully selected from a multitude of suggestions made.
The first (3) is almost identical with that proposed by S.
1035, Fifty-fifth Congress, first session (section 51 b (3), the
Lindsay bill), and adopted by the House substitute. (See
Congressional Record, Fifty-fifth Congress, vol. 31, p.
2039, sec. 13 b, 3.) *
The second (4) is a rephrasing of an objection to discharge
found in section 29 of the law of 1867, and "transfer," now
including "conveyance," "mortgage," "payment," etc.
means the same thing. In effect it is the same as section 51
b (4) of the Lindsay bill and as section 13 b (4) of the House
substitute, above. ^
The third (5) will put an end to the possibility of debtors
going through bankruptcy every month. The new period,
six years, is an average arrived at from the suggestions re-
ceived. (Compare Report of National Association of Ref-
erees in Bankruptcy, published in March, 1900, for other
ways of solving this problem.)
The fourth (6) is intended to meet a defect which grows out
of decisions that, following Counselman v. Hitchcock (142
U. S., 547), declare that the protection afforded a bankrupt
by the last clause of section 7 a (9) does not amoimt to the
4. Altered by Senate. 5. Omitted by the Senate.
416 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
immunity guaranteed by the fifth amendment to the Con-
stitution. (See In re Rosser (Mo.), 96 Fed., 305, and com-
pare In re Marx (Ky.), 102 Fed., 676.) The suggestion that
the immunity clause inserted in the interstate-commerce
law and held constitutional in Brown v. Walker, 161 U. S.,
591, be also inserted here is met by the objection that such
clause would in effect grant pardon in advance to bankrupts
called to testify, and might result in a general amnesty to all
bankrupts amenable to punishment under section 29. A
discharge is a boon, not a right. He who asks it should tell
what he knows of his assets and his past dealings. If he does
not, the discharge should be denied him. It is thought that
this new objection to discharge will accomplish much that
would be accomplished by the clause in the interstate-com-
merce law, without amounting to freedom from criminal
prosecution too.
Section 6: The changes in section 17 of the law are to
settle questions arising from antagonistic decisions of the
court and to exclude beyond perad venture certain liabilities
growing out of offenses against good morals from the effect
of a discharge. (Compare a similar amendment to the
English act of 1883 by section 10 of the amendatory act of
1890.
The substitution of "liabilities" for "judgments in ac-
tions" makes the clause broader. Now claims created by
fraud but not reduced to judgment are discharged. Neither
the claim nor the judgment should be. (Compare In re
Rhutalssel (Iowa), 96 Fed., 567, with In re Lewenson (N.
Y.), 99 Fed., 73.).«
The reasons for the other changes are too patent to re-
quire statement. (As to the dischargeability of aHmony
compare In re Houston (Ky.), 94 Fed.), 119, with In re
Nowell (Mass.), 99 Fed., 931; of judgments for seduction,
6. Liabilities for frauds omitted by the Senate.
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 417
In re Sullivan (N. Y.), 2 Am. B. R., 30, with In re Freche
(N. J.), 109 Fed., 620; of judgments for criminal conversa-
tion, In re Tinker (N. Y.), 99 Fed., 79, with Colwellv. Tinker
(N. Y.), 6 Am. B. R., 434.
Section 7 : It is conceded that too much time was given
by the law for the joining of issue in involuntary cases, and
that the law was silent as to the method and time of service
where the bankrupt had absconded. As changed, section
18 provides for a short service by publication, and not only
shortens the time within which a debtor personally served
must appear and plead, but provides that time to plead shall
expire when time to appear does, and not ten days later as
now. All this is in the interest of the rapid administration
of asset cases and the consequent reduction of expenses.**
Section 8. Intended to make a wife, who is often the de-
positary of property belonging really to the bankrupt a
compellable witness in every State as to certain transactions
to which she is or has been a party. Without her evidence
it is sometimes practically impossible to trace property.
Neither principle nor policy entitles her to her privilege
when the transaction imder investigation is a business one
between her and her husband. For evils growing out of
section 21 a, as now phrased, see In re Jefferson (Wash.),
96 Fed., 826; In re Fowler (Wis)., 93 Fed., 417.
Section 9 : Under the law of 1867, the Federal and State
courts had concurrent jurisdiction of suits to recover prop-
erty fraudulently or preferentially transferred. Bardes v.
Bank of Hawarden (la.), 178 U. S., 524, has so construed
section 23 b, of the law as to deny such jurisdiction to the
district courts, save with the consent of the proposed de-
fendant. In commercial centers this amoimts to a denial
of justice, the calendars of the State courts being years
7. The Senate restored the words fifteen days for return day in lieu
of ten proposed by the House.
418 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
behind hand; while, growing out of Bardes v. Bank, have
come decisions which have crippled the administration of
the law to a marked degree. (See in re Ward (Mass.), 5
Am. B. R., 215 ; Mueller v. Nugent (Ky.), 105 Fed., 581 ; this
latter, however, recently reversed by the Supreme Court.)
There is a very general demand for a return to the policy
of the law of 1867. Were it not for section 23 b, section 2
(7), would probably confer ample jurisdiction on the dis-
trict courts. The change in section 23, b, proposed by the
bill simply excepts from the operation of it all suits which
can, under the specific words of the law, be brought to re-
cover property, and this merely by referring to the three
sections under which alone such suits can be brought. To
remove all doubt, also, section 13 and 16 of the bill confer
concurrent jurisdiction of all such suits on the State courts
and the Federal district courts, by adding appropriate
words to each of the three sections ; section 60 b, section 67 e
and section 70 e.
Sections 10 and 11: These changes in section 40 and
section 48 are in response to the very general opinion that
the referees and the trustees are not now adequately paid.
The fiHng fee of each officer is doubled, making the deposit
required at the inception of bankruptcy proceedings $40
instead of $25. It is thought this will prove sufficient in all
no-asset cases. Since, under the law, it has been quite imi-
formly held that the commissions of these officers must be
computed on moneys paid out by way of dividends only,
this species of compensation has, in the large majority of
cases, amoimted to little. The change suggested rests on
the analogy of the State laws, which reckon the commissions
of executors, receivers, etc., on moneys received and paid
out, and is fairer. The other changes are in the line of in-
creasing efficiency and the securing of the best talent for the
important work committed to these officers ; thus, the large
- ^ AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 419
commissions to trustees in small cases, that they may have
greater incentive to search for and recover property, and
the 50-cent filing fee for referees, as probably the fairest way
properly to compensate them for the great amount of extra
work in hearing contests on claims, etc. The collection of
this filing fee in advance seems to be permitted by the rules
in many districts, though without apparent sanction of law.
The suggested amendment ratifies this practice, which has
not proven burdensome, while removing the chief objec-
tion to it — the requirement that the fee be paid as a condi-
tion of filing a claim at all — ^by requiring that such fee be paid
as a cost of administration. The trustee is also given the
same commission in composition cases as is the referee.
This was an oversight when the law was framed. 8.
Section 12: Piriev. Chicago Title and Trust Co. (182
U. S., 438), having held that section 60 a is a definition of
"preference," it necessarily followed that payments and
other bona fide transactions after actual insolvency, though
in due course of trade and without knowledge or reasonable
cause to believe that a preference was intended, must be,
under section 57 g, surrendered before a creditor who re-
ceived such a payment could prove the balance of his debt.
This was not what was intended by the framers of the law.
There is a very urgent and widespread demand for such an
amendment as will obviate this menace to trade. The Ray
bill (H. R. 4310) attempts to do this, but leaves a loophole
in that only voidable preferences, as defined in section 60 a
and b, must be siurendered, whereas some fraudulent trans-
fers (section 67 e and section 70 e) might be retained and the
debt still proven. This clause, section 57 g, has therefore
been modified by adding words referring specifically to
creditors who have received an advantage, void or voidable,
under section 67 c or section 70 e. There are no other sec-
8. The Senate materially reduced the increase in the fees for both
referees and trustees as provided by the House.
420 AMENDMENTS OF 1903.
tions in the law which provide for suits to recover back
from creditors or other persons property (which includes
money) improperly transferred. The change results there-
fore in that only those payments or transfers which could
be recovered back by suit must be surrendered under sec-
tion 57 g. This change will also settle the animated and
imfortunate controversy over the meaning and effect of sec-
tion 60 c; compare in re Keller (la.), 109 Fed., 118, where a
district court refuses to follow a court of appej i, in McKey
V. Lee (la.), 105 Fed., 923; also in re Dickson (Mass.), Ill
Fed., 726, wherein a circuit court of appeals apparently re-
fuses to follow the Supreme Court in Pirie v. Chicago Title
and Trust Co., above.
It is not thought expedient at this time to attempt to
frame a clause specifying what transactions are protected
(compare section 49 of the English act of 1883 for such a
clause) or to change the so-called definition of insolvency.
The simpler the changes in the present law the fewer will be
the controversies in the courts ; and especially in a question
which, like this, is at the root of our credit system, the less
the disturbance of business.
Section 13 : Section 60 a and b is amended in three ways :
First, by replacing the four months' clause in a, where it
was in the Lindsay bill, instead of in b, as now, and where
a casual reading of the law indicates it should have been
left. (See in re Jones (Mass.), 4 Am. B. R., 563, for the far-
reaching result of this transposition.)
Second, by adding to a clause which shall be equivalent
to that foimd in section 3 b (1). It seems that as section
60 a now stands, a preferential mortgage may be given, and
the creditor preferred by withholding it from record four
months be able to dismiss the trustee's suit to recover the
same, though the paper was actually recorded within the
AMENDMENTS OF 1903. 4^1
four months' period. (See in re Wright (Ga.), 96 Fed., 187;
in re Mersman (N. Y.), 7 Am. B. R., 46.)
Third, by adding the clause as to jurisdiction of suits pre-
viously explained under section 9.
Section 14: Where homestead exemptions are allowed,
it has been held that a bankrupt may insist on the trustee
paying the accrued taxes on the homestead set off to him.
(See in re Tilden (la.), 91 Fed., 500; contra, in re Veitsch
(Conn.), 101 Fed., 251.) This is an injustice to creditors
which calls for amendment. That suggested will accomp-
lish the desired result.'
It frequently happens that the action of individual cred-
itors in suing, as, for instance, by creditor's bill before the
bankruptcy, inures to the benefit of the trustee, and almost
as frequently that, through the efforts of certain creditors,
property is recovered after the bankruptcy begins. It is
only fair that their disbursements, by which all creditors
have profited, should be accoimted for to them. The
change in section 64 b (2), would accomplish this.
Section 15: Adds the clause on jurisdiction of suits to
section 67 a and 70 e previously explained under section 9.
Section 16 provides for indexes, etc.
9. The Senate omitted this proposed amendment.
BANKRUPTCY ACTS OF UNITED STATES.
Act of April 4th, 1800.
Chap. [19.] An act to establish an uniform system of bankruptcy
throughout the United States.
§ 1. Be it enacted, &c. That from and after the first day of Jane
next, if any merchant, or other person residing within the United States,
actually using the trade of merchandise, by buying and selling in gross,
or by retail, or dealing in exchange, or as a banker, broker, factor, under-
writer, or marine ensurer, shall, with intent unlawfully to delay or defraud
his or her creditors, depart from the state in which such person usually
resides, or remain absent therefrom, or conceal him or herself therein, or
keep his or her house, so that he or she cannot be taken, or served with
process, or willingly or fraudulently procure him or herself to be arrested,
or his or her lands, goods, money, or chattels, to be attached, sequestered,
or taken in execution, or shall secretly convey his or her goods out of
his or her house, or conceal them to prevent their being taken in execu-
tion, or make, or cause to be made, any fraudulent conveyance of his
or her lands, or chattels, or make or admit any false or fraudulent
security, or evidence of debt, or being arrested for debt, or having
surrendered him or herself in discharge of bail, shall remain in prison
two months, or more, or escape therefrom, or whose lands or efifects
being attached by process issuing out of, or returnable to, any court of
common law, shall not, within two months after written notice thereof,
enter special bail and dissolve the same, or in districts in which attach-
ments are not dissolved by the entry of special bail, being arrested for
debt after his or her lands and effects, or any part thereof, have been
attached for a debt or debts amounting to one thousand dollars or
upwards, shall not, upon notice of such attachment, give sufficient security
for the payment of what may be recovered in the suit in which he or she
shall be arrested, at or before the return day of the same, to be approved
by the judge of the district, or some judge of the court out of which
the process issued upon which he is arrested, or to which the same shall
be returnable, every such person shall be deemed and adjudged a bank-
rupt: Provided, That no person shall be liable to a commission of bank-
ruptcy, if the petition be not preferred, in manner hereinafter directed,
within six months after the act of bankruptcy committed.
§ 2. That the judge of the district court of the United States, for
the district where the debtor resides, or usually resided, at the time of
423
424 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
committing the act of bankruptcy, upon petition, in writing, against such
person or persons being bankrupt, to him to be exhibited by any one
creditor, or by a greater number, being partners, whose single debt
shall amount to one thousand dollars, or by two creditors, whose debts
shall amount to one thousand five hundred dollars, or by more than two
creditors, whose debts shall amount to two thousand dollars, shall have
power, by commission under his hand and seal, to appoint such good
and substantial persons, being citizens of the United States, and resident
in such district, as such judge shall deem proper, not exceeding three,
to be commissioners of the said bankrupt, and in case of vacancy or
refusal to act, to appoint others, from time to time, as occasion may
require: Provided always. That before any commission shall issue, the
creditor or creditors petitioning shall make affidavit, or solemn affirma-
tion, before the said judge, of the truth of his, her, or their debts, and
give bond, to be taken by the said judge, in the name and for the benefit
of the said party so charged as a bankrupt, and in such penalty, and
with such surety, as he shall require, to be conditioned for the proving
of his, her, or their, debts, as well before the commissioners as upon a
trial at law, in case the due issuing forth of the said commission shall be
contested, and also for proving the party a bankrupt, and to proceed on
such commission, in the manner herein prescribed. And if such debt
shall not be really due, or, after such commission taken out, it cannot
be proved that the party was a bankrupt, then the said judge shall, upon
the petition of the party aggrieved, in case there be occasion, deliver
such bond to the said party, who may sue thereon, and recover such
damages, under the penalty of the same, as, upon trial at law, he shall
make appear he has sustained, by reason of any breach of the condition
thereof.
§ 3. That before the commissioners shall be capable of acting, they
shall, respectively, take and subscribe the following oath or affirmation,
which shall be administered by the judge issuing the commission, or by
any of the judges of the supreme court of the United States, or any
judge, justice, or chancellor, of any state court, and filed in the office of
the clerk of the district court : "/, A B, do swear (or afUrm,) that I will
faithfully, impartially, and honestly, according to the best of my skill and
knowledge, execute the several powers and trusts reposed in me, as a
commissioner in a commission of bankruptcy against and
that without favor or affection, prejudice or malice." And the commis-
sioners, who shall be sworn as aforesaid, shall proceed, as soon as may
be, to execute the same; and, upon due examination, and sufficient cause
appearing against the party charged, shall and may declare him or her
to be a bankrupt: Provided, That before such examination be had, rea-
sonable notice thereof, in writing, shall be delivered to the person charged
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 425
as a bankrupt; or if he, or she, be not found at his or her usual place
of abode, to some person of the family, above the age of twelve years, or
if no such person appear, shall be fixed at the front or other public door
of the house, in which he or she usually resides, and thereupon it shall
be in the power of such person, so charged as aforesaid, to demand before,
or at the' time appointed for, such examination, that a jury be empan-
nelled to inquire into the fact or facts alleged as the causes for issuing
the commission, and on such demand being made, the inquiry shall be
had before the judge granting the commission, at such time as he may
direct, and in that case such person shall not be declared bankrupt,
unless, by the verdict of the jury, he or she shall be found to be within
the description of this act, and shall be convicted of some one of the
acts described in the first section of this act: Provided also, That any
commission which shall be taken out as aforesaid, and which shall not
be proceeded in as aforesaid, within thirty days thereafter, may be super-
seded by the said judge, who shall have granted the same, upon the
application of the party thereby charged as a bankrupt, or of any creditor
of such person, unless the delay shall have been unavoidable, or upon a
just occasion.
§ 4. That the commissioners so to be appointed, shall have power,
forthwith after they have declared such person a bankrupt, to cause to
be apprehended, by warrant under their hands and seals, the body of such
bankrupt, wheresoever to be found within the United States: Provided,
They shall think that there is reason to apprehend that the said bankrupt
intends to abscond, or conceal him or herself : and in case it be necessary,
in order to take the body of the said bankrupt, shall have power to cause
the doors of the dwelling house of such bankrupt to be broken, or the
doors of any other house in which he or she shall be found.
§ 5. That it shall be the duty of the commissioners so to be appointed,
forthwith after they have declared such person a bankrupt, and they shall
have power to take into their possession, all the estate, real and personal,
of every nature and description, to which the said bankrupt may be enti-
tled, either in law or equity, in any manner whatsoever, and cause the
same to be inventoried and appraised to the best value, (his or her neces-
sary wearing apparel, and the necessary wearing apparel of the wife and
children, and necessary beds and bedding, of such bankrupt, only ex-
cepted), and also to take into their possession, and secure, all deeds and
books of account, papers and writings, belonging to such bankrupt; and
shall cause the same to be safely kept, until assignees shall be chosen or
appointed, in manner hereafter provided.
§ 6. That the said commissioners shall, forthwith after they have
declared such person a bankrupt, cause due and sufficient public notice
thereof to be given, and in such notice shall appoint some convenient time
426 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
and place for the creditors to meet, in order to choose an assignee or
assignees of the said bankrupt's estate and effects; at which meeting the
said commissioners shall admit the creditors of such bankrupt to prove
their debts; and where any creditor shall reside at a distance from the
place of such meeting, shall allow the debt of such creditor to be proved
by oath or affirmation, made before some competent authority, and duly
certified, and shall permit any person, duly authorized by letter of attorney
from such creditor, due proof of the execution of such letter of attorney
being first made, to vote in the choice of an assignee or assignees of such
bankrupt's estate and effects, in the place and stead of such creditor : And
the said commissioners shall assign, transfer, or deliver over, all and
singular the said bankrupt's estate and effects aforesaid, with all muni-
ments and evidences thereof, to such person or persons as the major part,
in value, of such creditors, according to the several debts then proved,
shall choose as aforesaid: Provided always, That in such choice, no vote
shall be given by, or in behalf of, any creditor whose debt shall not
amount to two hundred dollars.
§ 7. That it shall be lawful for the said commissioners, as often as
they shall see cause, for the better preserving and securing the bankrupt's
estate, before assignees shall be chosen as aforesaid, immediately to
appoint one or more assignee or assignees of the estate and effects afore-
said, or any part thereof; which assignee or assignees aforesaid, or any
of them, may be removed at the meeting of the creditors, so to be
appointed as aforesaid, for the choice of assignees, if such creditors,
entitled to vote as aforesaid, or the major part, in value, of them, shall
think fit; and such assignee or assignees as shall be so removed, shall
deliver up all the estate and effects of such bankrupt, which shall have
come to his or their hands or possession, unto such other assignee or
assignees as shall be chosen by the creditors as aforesaid; and all such
estate and effects shall be, to all intents and purposes, as effectually and
legally vested in such new assignee or assignees, as if the first assignment
had been made to him or them by the said commissioners; and if such
first assignee or assignees shall refuse or neglect, for the space of ten days,
next after notice in writing from such new assignee or assignees, of their
apportionment, as aforesaid, to deliver over as aforesaid, all the estate
and effects as aforesaid, every such assignee or assignees shall, respect-
ively, forfeit a sum not exceeding five thousand dollars, for the use of the
creditors, and shall moreover be liable for the property so detained.
§ 8. That at any time, previous to the closing of the accounts of the
said assignee or assignees so chosen as aforesaid, it shall be lawful for
such creditors of the bankrupt as are hereby authorized to vote in the
choice of assignees, or the major part of them, in value, at a regular
meeting of the said creditors, , to be called for that purpose, by the said
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 427
commissioners, or by one fourth, in value, of such creditors, to remove
all or any of the assignees chosen as aforesaid, and to choose one or more
in his or their place and stead: and such assignee or assignees as shall
be so removed, shall deliver up all the estate and effects of such bankrupt,
which shall have come into his or their hands or possession, unto such
new assignee or assignees as shall be chosen by the creditors at such
meeting; and all such estate and effects shall be, to all intents and pur-
poses, as effectually and legally vested in such new assignee or assignees,
as if the first assignment had been made to him or them by the said
commissioners: And if such former assignee or assignees shall refuse
or neglect, for the space of ten days, next after notice in writing from
such new assignee or assignees, of their appointment, as aforesaid, to
deliver over, as aforesaid, all the estate and effects aforesaid, every such
former assignee or assignees shall, respectively, forfeit a sum not exceed-
ing five thousand dollars, for the use of the creditors, and shall moreover
be liable for the property so detained.
§ 9. That whenever a new assignee or 'assignees shall be chosen as
aforesaid, no suit at law or in equity shall be thereby abated ; but it shall
and may be lawful for the court in which any suit may depend, upon
the suggestion of a removal of a former assignee or assignees, and of
the appointment of a new assignee or assignees, to allow the name of
such new assignee or assignees, to be substituted in place of the name
or names of the former assignee or assignees, and thereupon the suit
shall be prosecuted in the name or names of the new assignee or
assignees, in the same manner as if he or they had originally commenced
the suit in his or their own names.
§ 10. That the assignment or assignments of the commissioners of the
bankrupt's estate and effects as aforesaid, made as aforesaid, shall be
good at law or in equity, against the bankrupt; and all persons claiming
by, from, or under, such bankrupt, by any act done at the time, or
after, he shall have committed the act of bankruptcy upon which the
commission issued : Provided always, That in case of a bona fide purchase,
made before the issuing of the commission from or under such bankrupt,
for a valuable consideration, by any person having no knowledge, informa-
tion, or notice, of any act of bankruptcy committed, such purchase shall
not be invalidated or impeached.
§ 11. That the said commissioners shall have power, by deed or deeds,
under their hands and seals, to assign and convey to the assignee or
assignees, to be appointed or chosen as aforesaid, any lands, tenements,
or hereditaments, which such bankrupt shall be seised of, or entitled to,
in fee tail, at law, or in equity, in possession, remainder, or reversion,
for the benefit of the creditors; and all such deeds, being duly executed,
and recorded, according to the laws of the state within which such lands,
428 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACT§.
tenements, or hereditaments, may be situate, shall be good and effectual
against all persons whom the said bankrupt, by common recovery, or
other means, might or could bar of any estate, right, title, or possibility,
of or in the said lands, tenements, or hereditaments.
' § 12 That if any bankrupt shall have conveyed or assured any lands,
goods, or estate, unto any person, upon condition or power of redemp-
tion, by payment of money or otherwise, it shall be lawful for the com-
missioners, or for any person by them duly authorized for that purpose,
by writing, under their hands and seals, to make tender of money, or
other performance, according to the nature of such condition, as fully as
the bankrupt might have done; and the commissioners, after such per-
formance or tender, shall have power to assign such lands, goods, and
estate, for the benefit of the creditors, as fully and effectually as any
other part of the estate of such bankrupt.
§ 13. That the commissioners aforesaid shall have power to assign,
for the use aforesaid, all the debts due to such bankrupt, or to any other
person for his or her use or benefit; which assignment shall vest the
property and right thereof in the assignee or assignees of such bankrupt,
as fully as if the bond, judgment, contract, or claim, had originally
belonged or been made to the said assignees; and after the said assign-
ment, neither the said bankrupt, nor any person acting as trustee for him
or her, shall have power to recover or discharge the same, nor shall the
same be attached as the debt of the said bankrupt; but the assignee or
assignees aforesaid shall have such remedy to recover the same, in his
or their own name or names, as such bankrupt might or could have had
if no commission of bankruptcy had issued: And when any action in
the name of such bankrupt shall have been commenced, and shall be pend-
ing for the recovery of any debt or effects of such bankrupt, which shall
be assigned, or shall or might become vested in the assignee or assignees of
such bankrupt as aforesaid, then such assignee or assignees may claim
to be, and shall be thereupon, admitted to prosecute such action in his
or their name, for the use and benefit of the creditors of such bankrupt ;
and the same judgment shall be rendered in such action, and all attach-
ments or other security taken therein, shall be in like manner holden and
liable, as if the said action had been originally commenced in the name
of such assignee or assignees, after the original plaintiff therein had be-
come a bankrupt as aforesaid : Provided, That where a debtor shall have,
bona fide, paid his debt to any bankrupt, without notice that such person
was bankrupt, he or she shall not be liable to pay the same to the assignee
or assignees.
§ 14. That if complaint shall be made, or information given, to the
commissioners, or if they shall have good reason to believe or suspect,
that any of the property, goods, chattels, or debts, of the bankrupt, are
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 429
in the possession of any other person, or that any person is indebted to,
or for the use of, the bankrupt, then the said commissioners shall have
power to summon, or cause to be summoned by their attorney or other
person duly authorized by them, all such persons before them, or the judge
of the district where such person shall reside, by such process, or other
maens, as they shall think convenient, and upon their appearance, to exam-
ine them by parole, or by interrogatories, in writing, on oath or affirma-
tion, which oath or afl5rmation they are hereby empowered to administer,
respecting the knowledge of all such property, goods, chattels, and debts ;
and if such person shall refuse to be sworn or affirmed, and to make
answer to such questions or interrogatories as shall be administered, and
to subscribe the said answers, or, upon examination, shall not declare the
whole truth, touching the subject matter of such examination, then it shall
be lawful for the commissioners, or judge, to commit such person to
prison, there to be detained until they shall submit themselves to be
examined in manner aforesaid, and they shall, moreover, forfeit double
the value of all the property, goods, chattels, and debts, by them con-
cealed.
§ 15. That if any of the aforesaid persons shall, after legal summons
to appear before the commissioners or judge, to be examined, refuse to
attend, or shall not attend at the time appointed, having no such impedi-
ment as shall be allowed of by the commissioners or judge, it shall be
lawful for the said commissioners or judge to direct their warrants to
such person or persons as by them shall be thought proper, to apprehend
such persons as shall refuse to appear, and to bring them before the com-
missioners or judge, to be examined, and upon their refusal to come, tO'
commit them to prison, until they shall submit themselves to be exam-
ined, according to the directions of this act: Provided, That such wit-
nesses as shall be so sent for, shall be allowed such compensation as the
commissioners, or judge, shall think fit, to be rateably borne by the cred-
itors; and if any person, other than the bankrupt, either by subornation
of others, or by his or her own act, shall, wilfully or corruptly, commit
perjury on such examination, to be taken before the commissioners as
aforesaid, the party so offending, and all persons who shall procure any
person to commit such perjury, shall, on conviction thereof, be fined, not
exceeding four thousand dollars, and imprisoned, not exceeding two
years, and moreover shall, in either case, be rendered incapable of being
a witness in any court of record.
§ 16. That if any person or persons shall fraudulently or collusively,
claim any debts, or claim or detain any real or personal estate of the
bankrupt, every such person shall forfeit double the value thereof, to and
for the use of the creditors.
§ 17. That i* any person, prior to his or her becoming a bankrupt,
shall convey to any of his or her children, or other persons, any lands
430 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
or goods, or transfer his or [her] debts or demands into other persons'
names, with intent to defraud his or her creditors, the commissioners
shall have power to assign the same, in as effectual a manner as if the
bankrupt had been actually seised or possessed thereof.
§ 18. That if any person or persons, who shall become bankrupt
within the intent and meaning of this act, and against whom a commission
of bankruptcy shall be duly issued, upon which commission such person
or persons shall be declared bankrupt, shall not, within forty-two days
after notice thereof, in writing, to be left at the usual place of abode of
such person or persons, or personal notice, in case such person or persons
be then in prison, and notice given in some gazette, that such commission
hath been issued, and of the time and place of meeting of the commis-
sioners, surrender him or herself to the said commissioners, and sign or
subscribe such surrender, and submit to be examined, from time to time,
upon oath or solemn affirmation, by and before such commissioners, and
in all things conform to the provisions of this act, and also, upon such
his or her examination, fully and truly disclose and discover all his or her
effects and estate, real and personal, and how and in what manner, to
whom and upon what consideration, and at what time or times, he or
she hath disposed of, assigned, or transferred, any of his or her goods,
wares, or merchandise, moneys, or other effects and estate, and of all
books, papers, and writings, relating thereunto, of which he or she was
possessed or in or to which he or she was any ways interested or entitled,
or which any person or persons shall then have, or shall have had, in trust
for him or her, or for his or her use, at any time before or after the issu-
ing of the said commission, or whereby such bankrupt, or his or her
family then hath, or may have, or expect, any profit, possibility of profit,
benefit, or advantage whatsoever, except only such part of his or her estate
and effects as shall have been really and bona fide before sold and disposed
of, in the way of his or her trade and dealings, and except such sums
of money as shall have been laid out in the ordinary expenses of his or
her family, and also upon such examination, execute, in due form of law,
such conveyance, assurance, and assignment of his or her estate, whatso-
ever and wheresoever, as shall be devised and directed by the commis-
sioners, to vest the same in the assignees, their heirs, executors, admin-
istrators, and assigns, forever, in trust, for the use of all and every the
creditors of such bankrupt, who shall come in and prove their debts under
the commission ; and deliver up unto the commissioners, all such part of his
or her, the said bankrupt's goods, wares, merchandises, money, effects,
and estate, and all books, papers, and writings, relating thereunto, as, at
the time of such examination, shall be in his or her possession, custody,
or power, his or her necessary wearing apparel, and the necessary wearing
apparel of the wife and children, and necessary beds and bedding, of such
bankrupt, only excepted, then he or she, the said bankrupt, upon the con-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 431
viction of any wilful default or omission in any of the matters or things
aforesaid, shall be adjudged a fraudulent bankrupt, and shall suflfer
imprisonment for a term not less than twelve months, nor exceeding ten
years, and shall not, at any time after, be entitled to the benefits of this
act: Provided always, That in case any bankrupt shall be in prison, or
custody, at the time of issuing such commission, and is willing to sur-
render and submit to be examined, according to the directions of this act,
and can be brought before the said commissioners and creditors for that
purpose, the expense thereof shall be paid out of the said bankrupt's
effects; and in case such bankrupt is in execution, or cannot be brought
before the commissioners, that then the said commissioners, or some one
of them, shall, from time to time, attend the said bankrupt in prison or
custody, and take his or her discovery, as in other , cases ; and the
assignees, or one of them, or some person appointed by them, shall attend
such bankrupt in prison or custody, and produce his or her books, papers,
and writings, in order to enable him or her to prepare his or her dis-
covery; a copy whereof the said assignees shall apply for, and the said
bankrupt shall deliver to them, or their order, within a reasonable time
after the same shall have been required.
§ 19. That the said commissioners shall appoint, within the said forty-
two days, so limited as aforesaid, for the bankrupt to surrender and con-
form as aforesaid, not less than three several meetings, for the purposes
.aforesaid, the third of which meetings shall be on the last of the said
forty-two days: Provided always, That the judge of the district within
which such commission issues, shall have power to enlarge the time so
limited as aforesaid, for the purposes aforesaid, as he shall think fit, not
exceeding fifty days, to be computed from the end of the said forty-two
days, so as such order for enlarging the time be made at least six days
before the expiration of said term.
§ 20. That it shall be lawful for the commissioners, or any other
person or officers, by them to be appointed, by their warrant, under their
hands and seals, to break open, in the day time, the houses, chambers,
shops, warehouses, doors, trunks, or chests, of the bankrupt, where any
of his or her goods or estate, deeds books of account, or writings, shall
be, and to take possession of the goods, money, and other estate, deeds,
books of account, or writings, of such bankrupt.
§ 21. That if the bankrupt shall refuse to be examined, or to answer
fully, or to subscribe his or her examination, as aforesaid, it shall be
lawful for the commissioners to commit the offender to close imprison-
ment, until he or she shall conform him or herself; and if the said bank-
rupt shall submit to be examined, and, upon his or her examination, it
shall appear that he or she hath committed wilful or corrupt perjury,
he or she may be indicted therefor, and, being thereof convicted, shall
432 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
suffer imprisonment for a term not less than two years, nor exceeding
ten years.
§ 22. That every bankrupt, having surrendered, shall at all seasonable
times, before the expiration of the said forty-two days, as aforesaid, or
of such further time as shall be allowed to finish his or her examina-
tion, be at liberty to inspect his or her books and writings, in the pres-
ence of some person to be appointed by the commissioners, and to bring
with him or her, for his or her assistance, such persons as he or she
shall think fit, not exceeding two at one time, and to make extracts and
copies to enable him or her to make a full discovery of his or her effects;
and the said bankrupt shall be free from arrests in coming to surrender,
and after having surrendered to the said commissioners, for the said
forty-two days, or such further time as shall be allowed for the finish-
ing of his or her examination ; and in case such bankrupt shall be arrested
for debt, or taken on any escape warrant or execution, coming to sur-
render, or after his surrender, within the time before mentioned, then,
on producing such summons or notice under the hand of the commission-
ers, and giving the officer a copy thereof, he or she shall be discharged;
and in case any officer shall afterwards detain such bankrupt, such officer
shall forfeit to such bankrupt, for his or her own use, ten dollars for
every day he shall detain the bankrupt.
§ 23. That every person who shall, knowingly or wilfully, receive or
keep concealed any bankrupt, so as aforesaid summoned to appear, or
who shall assist such bankrupt in concealing him or herself, or in abscond-
ing, shall suffer such imprisonment, not exceeding twelve months, or pay
such fine to the United States, not exceeding one thousand dollars, as
upon conviction thereof shall be adjudged.
§ 24. That the said commissioners, shall have power to examine, upon
oath or affirmation, the wife of any person lawfully declared a bankrupt,
for the discovery of such part of his estate as may be concealed or dis-
posed of by such wife, or by any such person; and the wife shall incur
such penalties for not appearing before the said commissioners, or refus-
ing to be sworn or affirmed or examined, and to subscribe her examina-
tion, or for not disclosing the truth, as by this act is provided against
any other person in like cases.
§ 25. That in case any person shall be committed by the commissioners
for refusing to answer, or for not fully answering any question, or for
any other cause, the commissioners shall in their warrant specify such
question or other cause of commitment.
§ 26. That if after the bankrupt shall have finished his or her final ex-
amination, any other person or persons shall voluntarily make discovery
of any part of such bankrupt's estate, before unknown to the commis-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 433
sioners, such person or persons shall be entitled to five per cent, out of
the effects so discovered, and such further reward as the commissioners
shall think proper; and any trustee having notice of the bankruptcy, wil-
fully concealing the estate of any bankrupt for the space of ten days
after the bankrupt shall have finished his final examination, as aforesaid,
shall forfeit double the value of the estate so concealed, for the benefit
of the creditors.
§ 27. That if any bankrupt, after the issuing any commission against
him or her, pay to the person who sued out the same, or give or de-
liver to such person, goods, or any other satisfaction or security for his
or her debt, whereby such person shall privately have and receive a greater
proportion of his or her debt than the other creditors, such preference
shall be a new act of bankruptcy, and on good proof thereof such com-
mission may and shall be superseded, and it shall and may be lawful for
either of the judges having authority to grant the commission as afore-
said, to award any creditor petitioning another commission, and such
person, so taking such undue satisfaction as aforesaid, shall forfeit and lose,
as well his or her whole debts, as the whole he or she shall have taken
and received, and shall pay back or deliver up the same, or the full value,
thereof, to the assignee or assignees who shall be appointed or chosen
under such commission, in manner aforesaid, in trust for, and to be divided
among, the other creditors of the said bankrupt, in proportion to their
respective debts.
§ 28. That if any bankrupt, after the issuing any commission against
him or her, pay to the person who sued out the same, or give or deliver
to such person, goods, or any other satisfaction or security, for his or
her debt, whereby such person shall privately have and receive a greater
proportion of his or her debt than the other creditors, such preference
shall be a new act of bankruptcy, and on good proof thereof, such com-
mission shall and may be superseded, and it shall and may be lawful for
either of the judges, having authority to grant the commission as afore-
said, to award any creditor petitioning another commission; and such
person, so taking such undue satisfaction as aforesaid, shall forfeit and
lose, as well his or her whole debts, as the whole he or she shall have
taken and received, and shall pay back, or deliver up the same, or the
full value thereof, to the assignee or assignees who shall be appointed
or chosen under such commission in manner aforesaid, in trust for, and
to be divided amongst the other creditors of the said bankrupt, in pro-
portion to their respective debts.
§ 29. That every person who shall be chosen assignee of the estate
and effects of a bankrupt shall, at some time after the expiration of four
months, and within twelve months from the time of issuing the commis-
sion, cause at least thirty days public notice to be given of the time and
434 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
place the commissioners and assignees intend to meet, to make a dividend
or distribution of the bankrupt's estate and effects; at which time the
creditors who have not before proved their debts shall be at liberty to
prove the same; and upon every such meeting the assignee or assignees
shall produce to the commissioners and creditors then present fair and
just accounts of all his or their receipts and payments, touching the bank-
rupt's estate and effects, and of what shall remain outstanding, and the
particulars thereof, and shall, if the creditors then present, or a major
part of them, require the same, be examined upon oath or solemn affirma-
tion before the same commissioners, touching the truth of such accounts;
and in such accounts the said assignee or assignees shall be allowed and
retain all such sum and sums of money as they shall have paid or ex-
pended in the suing out and prosecuting the commission, and all other
just allowances on account of or by reason or means of their being
assignee or assignees; and the said commissioners shall order such part
of the net produce of all the said bankrupt's estate as by such accounts
or otherwise shall appear to be in the hands of the said assignees, as
they shall think fit, to be forthwith divided among such of the bank-
rupt's creditors as had duly proved their debts under such commission,
in proportion to their several and respective debts ; and the commissioners
shall make such their order for a dividend in writing, under their hands,
and shall cause one part of such order to be filed amongst the proceed-
ings under the said commission, and shall deliver to each of the assignees
under such commission a duplicate of such their order, which order of
distribution shall contain an account of the time and place of making
such order, and the sum total or quantum of all the debts proved under
the commission, and the sum total of the money remaining in the hands
of the assignee or assignees to be divided, and how many per cent in
particular is there ordered to be paid to every creditor of his debt; and
the said assignee or assignees, in pursuance of such order, and without
any deed or deeds of distribution to be made for the purpose, shall forth-
with make such dividend and distribution accordingly, and shall take
receipts in a book to be kept for the purpose, from each creditor, for the
part or share of such dividend or distribution which he or they shall
make and pay to each creditor respectively; and such order and receipt
shall be a full and effectual discharge to such assignee for so much as he
shall fairly pay, pursuant to such order as aforesaid.
§ 30. That within eighteen months next after the issuing of the com-
mission the assignee or assignees shall make a second dividend of the bank-
rupt's estate and effects, in case the same were not wholly divided upon the
first dividend, and shall cause due public notice to be given of the time and
place the said commissioners intend to meet to make a second distribution
of the bankrupt's estate and effects, and for the creditors who shall not
before have proved their debts, to come in and prove the same; and at
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 435
said meeting the said assignees shall produce, on oath or solemn aflSrma-
tion, as aforesaid, their accounts of the bankrupt's estate and effects, and
what, upon the balance thereof, shall appear to be in their hands, shall,
by like order of the commissioners, be forthwith divided amongst such
of the bankrupt's creditors as shall have made due proof of their debts,
in proportion to their several and respective debts; which second divi-
dend shall be final, unless any suit at law, or equity, be depending, or
any part of the estate standing out, that could not have been dis-
posed of, or that the major part of the creditors shall not have agreed
to be sold or disposed of, or unless some other or future estate or
effects of the bankrupt shall afterwards come to, or vest in, the said
assignees, in which cases the said assignees shall, as soon as may be,
convert such future or other estate and effects into money, and shall,
within two months after the same be converted into money, by like order
of the commissioners, divide the same among such bankrupt's creditors
as shall have made due proof of their debt under such commission.
§ 31. That in the distribution of the bankrupt's effects, there shall
be paid to every of the creditors a portion rate, according to the amount
of their respective debts, so that every creditor having security for his
debt by judgment, statute, recognisance, or specialty, or having an attach-
ment under any of the laws of the individual states, or of the United
States, on the estate of such bankrupt, {Provided, there be no execution
executed upon any of the real or personal estate of such bankrupt, before
the time he or she became bankrupts) shall not be relieved upon any
such judgment, statute, recognisance, specialty, or attachment, for more
than a rateable part of his debt, with the other creditors of the bank-
rupt.
§ 32. That the assignees shall keep one or more distinct book, or
books, of account, wherein he or they shall duly enter all sums of money
or effects which he or they shall have received, or got into his or their
possession, of the said bankrupt's estate, to which books of account, every
creditor, who shall have proved his or her debt, shall, at all reasonable
times, have free resort, and inspect the same as often as he or she shall
think fit.
§ 33. That every bankrupt, not being in prison or custody, shall, at all
times after his surrender, be bound to attend the assignees, upon every
reasonable notice, in writing, for that purpose given, or left at the
usual place of his or her abode, in order to assist in making out the ac-
counts of the said bankrupt's estate and effects, and to attend any court
of record, to be examined touching the same, or such other business as
the said assignees shall judge necessary, for which he shall receive three
dollars per day.
§ 34. That all and every person and persons who shall become bank-
436 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
rupt as aforesaid, and who shall, within the time limited by this act,
surrender him or herself to the commissioners, and in all things con-
form as in and by this act is directed, shall be allowed five per cent,
upon the nett produce of all the estate that shall be recovered in and
received, which shall be paid unto him or her by the assignee or as-
signees, in case the nett produce of such estate, after such allowance
made, shall be sufficient to pay the creditors of said bankrupt, who shall
have proved their debts under such commission, the amount of fifty per
cent, on their said debts, respectively, and so as the said five per cent,
shall not exceed, in the whole, the sum of five hundred dollars; and iri
case the nett produce of the said estate shall, over and above the allow-
ance hereafter mentioned, be sufficient to pay the said creditors seventy-
five per cent, on the amount of their said debts, respectively, that then
the said bankrupt shall be allowed ten per cent, on the amount of such
nett produce, to be paid as aforesaid, so as such ten per cent, shall not.
in the whole, exceed the sum of eight hundred dollars; and every such
bankrupt shall be discharged from all debts by him or her due or owing,
at the time he or she became bankrupt, and all which were or might
have been proved under the said commission ; and in case any such bank-
rupt shall afterwards be arrested, prosecuted, or impleaded, for or an ac-
count of any of the said debts, such bankrupt may appear without bail,
and may plead the general issue, and give this act, and the special mat-
ter, in evidence: And the certificate of such bankrupt's conforming, and
the allowance thereof, according to the directions of this act, shall be and
shall be allowed to be sufficient evidence, prima facie, of the party's
being a bankrupt within the meaning of this act, and of the
commission, and other proceedings precedent to the obtaining such
certificate, and a verdict shall thereupon pass for the defendant, unless
the plaintiff in such action can prove the said certificate was obtained
unfairly, and by fraud, or unless he can make appear any concealment
of estate or effects, by such bankrupt, to the value of one hundred dol-
lars: Provided, That no such discharge of a bankrupt shall release or
discharge any person who was a partner with such bankrupt at the
time he or she became bankrupt, or who was then jointly held or bound
with such bankrupt, for the same debt or debts from which such bank-
rupt was discharged as aforesaid.
§ 35. That if the net proceeds of the bankrupt's estate, so to be dis-
covered, recovered, and received, shall not amount to so much as will
pay all and every of the creditors of the said bankrupt, who shall have
proved their debts under the said commission, the amount of fifty per
cent, on their debts, respectively, after all charges first deducted, that
then, and in such case, the bankrupt shall not be allowed five per centum
on such estate as shall be recovered in, but shall have and be paid by the
assignees so much money as the commissioners shall think fit to allow.
Former bankruptcy acts, 437
not more than three hundred dollars, nor exceeding three per centum
on the nett proceeds of the said bankrupt's estate.
§ 36. That no person becoming a bankrupt according to the intent
and provisions of this act, shall be entitled to a certificate of discharge,
or to any of the benefits of the act, unless the commissioners shall certify
under their hands, to the judge of the district within which such com-
mission issues, that such bankrupt hath made a full discovery of his or
her estate and effects, and in all things conformed him or herself to the
directions of this act, and that there doth not appear to them any reason
to doubt of the truth of such discovery, or that the same was not a full
discovery of the said bankrupt's estate and effects; or unless the said
judge should be of opinion that the said certificate was unreasonably
denied by the commissioners; and unless two thirds, in number and in
value, of the creditors of the bankrupt, who shall be creditors for not
less than fifty dollars, respectively, and who shall have duly proved their
debts under the said commission, shall sign such certificate to the judge,
and testify their consent to the allowance of a certificate of discharge,
in pursuance of this act ; which signing and consent shall be also certified
by the commissioners; but the said commissioners shall not certify the
same till they have proof, by affidavit or information, in writing, of such
creditors, or of the persons respectively authorized for that purpose, sign-
ing the said certificate; which affidavit or affirmation, together with the
letter or power of attorney to sign, shall be laid before the judge of the
district within which such commission issues, in order for the allowing
the certificate of discharge; and the said certificate shall not be allowed,
unless the bankrupt make oath or affirmation, in writing, that the certifi-
cate of the commissioners, and consent of the creditors thereunto, were
obtained fairly and without fraud; and any of the creditors of the said
bankrupt are allowed to be heard, if they shall think fit, before the respec-
tive persons aforesaid, against the making or allowing of such certifi-
cates by the commissioners or judge.
§ 37. That if any creditor, or pretended creditor, of any bankrupt, shall
exhibit to the commissioners any fictitious or false debt, or demand, with
'intent to defraud the real creditors of such bankrupt, and the bankrupt
shall refuse to make discovery thereof, and suffer the fair creditors to be
imposed upon, he shall lose all title to the allowance upon the amount of
his effects, and to a certificate of discharge as aforesaid; nor shall he
be entitled to the said allowance or certificate, if he has lost, at any one
time, fifty dollars, or, in the whole, three hundred dollars, after the pass-
ing of this act, and within twelve months before he became a bankrupt,
by any manner of gaming or wagering whatever.
§ 38. That if any bankrupt, who shall have obtained his certificate,
shall be taken in execution or detained in prison, on account of any
438 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
debts owing before he became a bankrupt, by reason that judgment was
obtained before such certificate was allowed, it shall be lawful for any
of the judges of the court wherein judgment was so obtained, or for any
court, judge, or justice, within the district in which such bankrupt shall be
detained, having powers to award or allow the writ of habeas corpus, on
such bankrupt producing his certificate so as aforesaid allowed, to order any
sheriff or gaoler who shall have such bankrupt in custody, to discharge
such bankrupt, without fee or charge, first giving reasonable notice to the
plaintiff, or his attorney, of the motion for such discharge.
§ 39. That every person who shall have, bona fide, given credit to,
or taken securities, payable at future days, from persons who are, or
shall become, bankrupts, not due at the time of such persons' becom-
ing bankrupt, shall be admitted to prove their debts and con-
tracts, as if they were payable presently, and shall have a dividend in
proportion to the other creditors, discounting, where no interest is pay-
able, at the rate of so much per centum per annum, as is equal to the
lawful interest of the state where the debt is payable; and the obligee
of any bottomry or respondentia bond, and the assured in any policy of
ensurance, shall be admitted to claim, and after the contingency or loss,
to prove the debt thereon, in like manner as if the same had happened
before issuing the commission ; and the bankrupt shall be discharged from
such securities, as if such money had been due and payable before the
time of his or her becoming bankrupt; and such creditors may petition
for a commission, or join in petitioning.
§ 40. That in case any person, committed by the commissioners' war-
rant, shall obtain a habeas corpus, in order to be discharged, and there
shall appear any insufficiency in the form of the warrant, it shall be
lawful for the court or judge before whom such party shall be brought
by habeas corpus, by rule or warrant, to commit such persons to the
same prison, there to remain until he shall conform as aforesaid, unless
it shall be made to appear that he had fully answered all lawful questions
put to him by the commissioners; or in case such person was committed
for not signing his examination, unless it shall appear that the party had
good reason for refusing to sign the same, or that the commissioners
had exceeded their authority in making such commitment. And in case
the gaoler to whom such person shall be committed, shall wilfully or
negligently suffer such person to escape, or go without the doors or walls
of the prison, such gaoler shall, for such offense, being convicted thereof,
forfeit a sum not exceeding three thousand dollars, for the use of the
creditors.
§ 41. That the gaoler shall upon the request of any creditor, having
proved his debt, and showing a certificate thereof, under the hands of
the commissioners, which the commissioners shall give without fee or
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 439
reward, produce the person so committed; and in case such gaoler shall
refuse to show such person to such creditor requesting the same, such
person shall be considered as having escaped, and the gaoler or sheriff
so refusing shall be liable as for a wilful escape.
§ 42. That where it shall appear to the said commissioners that there
hath been mutual credit given by the bankrupt, and any other person
or mutual debts between them, at any time before such person
became bankrupt, the assignee or assignees of the estate shall state the
account between them, and one debt may be set off against the other, and
what shall appear to be due on either side, on the balance of such ac-
count, after such set off, and no more, shall be claimed or paid on either
side, respectively.
§ 43. That it shall and may be lawful to and for the assignee or as-
signees of any bankrupt's estate and effects, under the direction of the
commissioners, and by and with the consent of the major part in value
of such of the said bankrupt's creditors as shall have duly proved their
debts under the commission, and shall be present at any meeting of the
said creditors, to be held in pursuance of due and public notice for
that purpose given, to submit any difference or dispute for, on account
of, or by reason or means of, any matter, cause, or thing whatsoever, re-
lating to such bankrupt, or to his or her estate or effects, to the final
end and determination of arbitrators, to be chosen by the said commis-
sioners and the major part in value of such creditors as shall be pres-
ent at such meeting as aforesaid, and the party or parties with whom
they shall have such difference or dispute, and to perform the award
of such arbitrators, or otherwise to compound and agree the matter in
difference and dispute as aforesaid, in such manner as the said assignee
or assignees, under the direction and with the consent aforesaid, shall
think fit and can agree; and the same shall be binding on the several
creditors of the said bankrupt; and the said assignee or assignees are
hereby indemnified for what they shall fairly do, according to the direc-
tions aforesaid.
§ 44. That the assignees shall be, and hereby are, vested with full
power to dispose of all the bankrupt's estate, real and personal, at pub-
lic auction or vendue, without being subject to any tax, duty, imposition,
or restriction, any law to the contrary notwithstanding.
§ 45. That if, after any commission of bankruptcy sued forth, the
bankrupt happen to die before the commissioners shall have distributed
the effects, or any part thereof, the commissioners shall, nevertheless,
proceed to execute the commission, as fully as they might have done if
the party were living.
§ 46. That where any commission of bankruptcy shall be delivered
440 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
to the commissioners therein named, to be executed, it shall and may be
lawful for them, before they take the oath or affirmation of qualifica-
tion, to demand and take from the creditor or creditors prosecuting such
commission, a bond, with one good security, if required, in the penalty
of one thousand dollars, conditioned for the payment of the costs, charges,
and expenses, which shall arise and accrue upon the prosecution of the
said commission: Provided always. That the expenses, so as aforesaid
to be secured and paid by the petitioning creditor or creditors, shall be
repaid to him or them by the commissioners or assignees, out of the first
moneys arising from the bankrupt's estate or effects, if so much be re-
ceived therefrom.
§ 47. That the district judges, in each district, respectively, shall fix
a rate of allowance to be made to the commissioners of bankruptcy, as
compensation of services to be rendered under the commission, and it
shall be lawful for any creditor, by petition to the district judge, to ex-
cept to any charge contained in the account of the commissioners: And
the said judge, after hearing the commissioners, may, in a summary way,
decide upon the validity of such exception.
§ 48. That all penalties given by this act for the benefit of the
creditors, shall be recovered by the assignee or assignees by action of
debt, and the money so recovered, the charges of suit being deducted,
shall be distributed towards payment of the creditors.
§ 49. That if any action shall be brought against any commissioner,
or assignee, or other person, having authority under the commission, for
any thing done or performed by force of this act, the defendant may
plead the general issue, and give this act, and the special matter, in evi-
dence; and in case of a nonsuit, discontinuance, or verdict or judg-
ment for him, he shall recover double costs.
§ 50. That if any estate, real or personal shall descend, revert to,
or become vested in any person, after he or she shall be declared a
bankrupt, and before he or she shall obtain a certificate, signed by the
judge as aforesaid, all such estate shall, by virtue of this act, be vested
in the said commissioners, and shall be by them assigned and conveyed
to the assignee or assignees, in fee simple, or otherwise, in like manner
as above directed, with the estate of the said bankrupt, at the time of
the bankruptcy, and the proceeds thereof shall be divided among the
creditors.
§ 51. That the said commissioners shall, once in every year, carefully
file, in the clerk's office of the district court, all the proceedings had in
every case before them, and which shall have been finished; including
the commissions, examinations, dividends, entries, and other determina-
tions, of the said commissioners, in which office the final certificate of the
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 441
said bankrupt may also be recorded; all which proceedings shall remain
of record in the said office, and certified copies thereof shall be admitted
as evidence in all courts in like manner as the copies of the proceedings
of the said district court are admitted in other cases.
§ 52. That it shall and may be lawful for any creditor of such bank-
rupt, to attend all or any of the examinations of said bankrupt, and the
allowance of the final certificate, if he shall think proper, and then and
there to propose interrogatories, to be put by the judge or commissioners
to the said bankrupt and others, and also to produce and examine wit-
nesses and documents before such judge or commissioners, relative to
the subject matter before them. And in case either the bankrupt or
creditor shall think him or herself aggrieved by the determination of the
said judge or commissioners, relative to any material fact, in the com-
mencement or progress of the said proceedings, or in the allowance of
the certificate aforesaid, it shall and may be lawful for either party to
petition the said judge, setting forth such facts, and the determination
thereon, with the complaint of the party, and a prayer for trial by a jury
to determine the same, and the said judge shall, in his discretion, make
order thereon, and award a venire facias to the marshal of the district,
returnable within fifteen days, before him, for the trial of the facts men-
tioned in the said petition, notice whereof shall be given to the com-
missioners and creditors concerned in the same; at which time the said
trial shall be had, unless, on good cause shown, the judge shall give fur-
ther time; and judgment being entered on the verdcit of the jury, shall
be final on the said facts, and the judge or commissioners shall proceed
agreeably thereto.
§ 53. That the commissioners, before the appointment of assignees,
and the assignees after such appointment, may, from time to time, make
such allowance, out of the bankrupt's estate, until he shall have obtained
his final discharge, as, in their opinion, may be requisite for the neces-
sary support of the said bankrupt and his family.
§ 54. That it shall be lawful for the major part, in value, of the
creditors, before they proceed to the choice of assignees, to direct in
what manner, with whom, and where, the moneys arising by, and to be
received from time to time out of, the bankrupt's estate, shall be lodged,
until the same shall be divided among the creditors, as herein provided;
to which direction every such assignee and assignees shall conform, as
often as three hundred dollars shall be received.
§ 55. That every matter and thing, by this act required to be done
by the commissioners of any bankrupt, shall be valid to all intents
and purposes, if performed by a majority of them.
§ 56. That in all cases where the assignees shall prosecute any debtor
442 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
of the bankrupt for any debt, duty, or demand, the commission, or a
certified copy thereof, and the assignment of the commissioners of the
bankrupt's estate, shall be conclusive evidence of the issuing the commis-
sion, and of the person named therein being a trader and bankrupt, at
the time mentioned therein.
§ 57, That every person obtaining a dischaige from his debts, by
certificate as aforesaid, granted under a commission of bankruptcy, shall
not, on any future commission, be entitled to any other certificate than a
discharge of his person only; unless the nett proceeds of the estate anil
effects of such person, so becoming bankrupt a second time, shall be suf-
ficient to pay seventy-five per cent, to his or her creditors, on the
amount of their debts, respectively.
§ 58. That any creditor of a person, against whom a commission of
bankruptcy shall have been sued forth, and who shall lay his claim before
the commissioners appointed in pursuance of this act, may, at the same
time, declare his unwillingness to submit the same to the judgment of
the said commissioners, and his wish that a jury may be empannelled to
decide thereon: And in like manner, the assignee or assignees of such
bankrupt, may object to the consideration of any particular claim by the
commissioners, and require that the same should be referred to a jury.
In either case, such objection and request shall be entered on the books
of the commissioners, and thereupon an issue shall be made up between
the parties, and a jury shall be empannelled, as in other cases, to try the
same in the circuit court for the district in which such bankrupt has
usually resided. The verdict of such jury shall be subject to the contrcJ
of the court, as in suits originally instituted in the said court, and when
rendered, if not set aside by the court, shall be certified to the commis-
sioners, and shall ascertain the amount of any such claim, and such
creditor or creditors shall be considered in all respects as having proved
their debts under the commission.
§ 59. That the lands and effects of any person becoming bankrupt,
may be sold on such credit, and on such security, as a major part in
value of the creditors may direct: Provided, nothing herein contained
shall be allowed so to operate, as to retard the granting the bankrupt's
certificate.
§ 60. That if any person becoming bankrupt shall be in prison, it
shall be lawful for any creditor or creditors, at whose suit he or she shall
be in execution, to discharge him or her from custody, or if such creditor
or creditors shall refuse to do so, the prisoner may petition the com-
missioners to liberate him or her, and thereupon, if, in the opinion of the
commissioners, the conduct of such bankrupt shall have been fair, so as
to entitle him or her, in their opinion, to a certificate, when by law such
certificate might be given, it shall be lawful for them to direct the dis-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 443
charge of such prisoner, and to enter the same in their books, which be-
ing notified to the keeper of the gaol in which such prisoner may be
confined, shall be a sufficient authority for his or her discharge: Pro-
vided, That in either case, such discharge shall be no bar to another exe-
cution, if a certificate shall be refused to such bankrupt: And provided
also. That is shall be no bar to a subsequent imprisonment of such bank-
rupt by order of the commissioners, in conformity with the provisions
of this act.
§ 61. That this act shall not repeal or annul, or be construed to repeal
or annul, the laws of any state now in force, or which may be hereafter
enacted, for the relief of insolvent debtors, except so far as the same
may respect persons who are, or may be, clearly within the purview of
this act, and whose debts shall amount, in the cases specified in the sec-
ond section thereof, to the sums therein mentioned. And if any person
within the purview of this act, shall be imprisoned for the space of three
months, for any debt, or upon any contract, unless the creditors of such
prisoner shall proceed to prosecute a commission of bankruptcy against
him or her, agreeably to the provisions of this act, such debtor may and
shall be entitled to relief, under any such laws for the relief of insol-
vent debtors, this act notwithstanding.
§ 62. That nothing contained in this law shall, in any manner, af-
fect the right of preference to prior satisfaction of debts due to the United
States, as secured or provided by any law heretofore passed, nor shall
be construed to lessen or impair any right to, or security for, money due
to the United States, or to any of them.
§ 63. That nothing contained in this act shall be taken or construed to
invalidate, or impair, any lien existing at the date of this act, upon the
lands or chattels of any person who may become a bankrupt.
§ 64. That this act shall continue in force during the term of five
years, and from thence to the end of the next session of congress there-
after, and no longer: Provided, That the expiration of this act shall not
prevent the complete execution of any commission which may have been
previously thereto issued. [Approved, April 4, 1800.]
AMENDMENT OF FEBRUARY 13th, 1801.
Sec. 12 of "An Act to provide for the more convenient organization
of Courts of the United States." Approved, February 13th, 1801.
§ 12. That the said Circuit Courts, respectively, shall have cogniz-
ance, concurrently with the District Courts, of all cases, which shall
arise, within their respective circuits, under the act to establish a uniform
system of bankruptcy throughout the United States; and that each
circuit judge, within his respective circuit, shall and may perform all
and singular the duties enjoined by the said act, upon a judge of a
444 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS,
District Court; and that the proceedings under a commission of bank-
ruptcy, which shall issue from a circuit judge, shall, in all respects,
be conformable to the proceedings under a commission of bankruptcy
which shall issue from a district judge, mutatis mutandis.
AMENDMENT OF APRIL 29, 1802.
Cognizance of pending cases was transferred to the district judge by
Sec. 11 of "An Act to Amend the judicial system of the United States."
§ 11. That in all cases in which proceedings shall, on the said first
day of July next, be pending under a commission of bankruptcy, issued
in pursuance of the aforesaid act, entitled "An act to provide for the
more convenient organization of the courts of the United States," the
cognizance of the same shall be, and hereby is, transferred to, and vested
in, the district judge of the district within which such commission shall
have issued, who is hereby empowered to proceed therein, in the game
manner, and to the same effect, as if such commission of bankruptcy had
been issued by his order.
AN ACT TO REPEAL BANKRUTCY ACT.
Chapter 6, par. i. Approved Dec. igth, 1803.
§ 1. Be it enacted, &c. That the act of congress, passed on the fourth
day of April, one thousand eight hundred, entitled "An act to establish
an uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," shall
be and the same is hereby, repealed: Provided, nevertheless. That the
repeal of the said act shall, in nowise, affect the execution of any com-
mission of bankruptcy which may have been issued prior to the passing
of this act, but every such commission may and shall be proceeded on
and fully executed, as though this act had not passed. ^Approved, De-
cember 19, 1803.]
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 445
BANKRUPTCY ACT OF AUGUST 19th, 1841.
An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the
United States.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That there be, and
hereby is, established throughout the United States, a uniform system of
bankruptcy, as follows: All persons whatsoever, residing in any State,
District or Territory of the United States, owing debts, which shall not
have been created in consequence of a defalcation as a public officer; or
as executor, administrator, guardian or trustee, or while acting in any
other fiduciary capacity, who shall, by petition, setting forth to the best
of his knowledge and belief, a list of his or their creditors, their re-
spective places of residence, and the amount due to each, together with
an accurate inventory of his or their property rights, and credits, of
every name, kind, and description, and the location and situation of each
and every parcel and portion thereof, verified by oath, or, if conscien-
tiously scrupulous of taking an oath, by solemn affirmation apply to the
proper court, as hereinafter mentioned, for the benefit of this act and
therein declare themselves to be unable to meet their debts and engage-
ments, shall be deemed bankrupts within the purview of this act, and
may be so declared accordingly by decree of such court; all persons, be-
ing merchants, or using the trade of merchandise, all retailers of mer-
chandise, and all bankers, factors, brokers, underwriters, or marine in-
surers, owing debts to the amount of not less than two thousand dollars,
shall be liable to become bankrupts within the true intent and meaning
of this act, and may, upon the petition of one or more of their creditors,
to whom they owe debts amounting in the whole to not less than five
hundred dollars, to the appropriate court, be so declared accordingly, in
the following cases, to wit: whenever such person, being a merchant, or
actually using the trade of merchandise, or being a retailer of merchan-
dise, or being a banker, factor, broker, underwriter or marine insurer,
shall depart from the State, District, or Territory, of which he is an in-
habitant, with intent to defraud his creditors; or shall conceal himself
to avoid being arrested; or shall willingly or fraudulently procure him-
self to be arrested, or his goods and chattels, lands, or tenements, to be
attached, distrained, sequestered, or taken in execution; or shall remove
his goods, chattels, and effects, or conceal them to prevent their being
levied upon, or taken in execution, or by other process; or make any
fraudulent conveyance, assignment, sale, gift, or other transfer of his
lands, tenements, goods or chattels, credits, or evidence of debt: Pro-
vided, however, That any person so declared a bankrupt, at the instance
of a creditor, may, at his election, by petition to such court within ten
446 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
days after its decree, be entitled to a trial by jury before such court,
to ascertain the fact of such bankruptcy; or if such person shall reside
at a great distance from the place of holding such court, the said judge,
in his discretion, may direct such trial by jury to be had in the county
of such person's residence, in such manner, and under such directions,
as the said court may prescribe and give; and all such decrees passed by
such court, and not so re-examined, shall be deemed final and conclusive
as to the subject-matter thereof.
Sec 2. And be it further enacted, That all future payments, secur-
ities, conveyances, or transfers of property, or agreements made or given
by any bankrupt, in contemplation of bankruptcy, and for the purpose
of giving any creditor, endorser, surety, or other person, any prefer-
ence or priority over the general creditors of such bankrupts; and all
other payments, securities, conveyances, or transfers of property, or
agreements made or given by such bankrupt in contemplation of bank-
ruptcy, to any person or persons whatever, not being a bona fide credi-
tor or purchaser, for a valuable consideration, without notice, shall be
deemed utterly void, and a fraud upon this act; and the assignee under
the bankruptcy shall be entitled to claim, sue for, recover, and receive
the same as part of the assets of the bankruptcy; and the person mak-
ing such unlawful preferences and payments shall receive no discharge
under the provisions of this act: Provided, That all dealings and trans-
actions by and with any bankrupt, bona fide made and entered into more
than two months before the petition filed against him, or by him, shall
not be invalidated or affected by this act : Provided, That the other party
to any such dealings or transactions had no notice of a prior act of
bankruptcy, or of the intention of the bankrupt to take the benefit of
this act. And in case it shall be made to appear to the court, in the
course of the proceedings in bankruptcy, that the bankrupt, his appli-
cation being voluntary, has, subsequent to the first day of January last,
or at any other time, in contemplation of the passage of a bankrupt law,
by assignments or otherwise, given or secured any preference to one
creditor over another, he shall not receive a discharge unless the same
be assented to by a majority in interest of those of his creditors who
have not been so preferred: /Ind provided, also. That nothing in this
act contained shall be construed to annul, destroy, or impair any lawful
rights of married women, or minors, or any liens, mortgages, or other
securities on property, real or personal, which may be valid by the laws
of the States respectively, and which are not inconsistent with the pro-
visions of the second and fifth sections of this act.
Sec. 3. "And be it further enacted. That all the property, and rights
of property, of every name and nature, and whether real, personal, or
mixed, of every bankrupt, except as is hereinafter provided, who shall
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 447
by a decree of the proper court, be declared to be a bankrupt within
this act, shall by mere operation of law, ipso facto, from the time of
such decree, be deemed to be divested out of such bankrupt, without
any other act, assignment, or other conveyance whatsoever; and the
same shall be vested, by force of the same decree, in such assignee as
from time to time shall be appointed by the proper court for this purpose,
which power of appointment and removal such court may exercise at its
discretion, toties quoties; and the assignee so appointed shall be vested
with all the rights, titles, powers, and authorities to sell, manage, and
dispose of the same, and to sue for and defend the same, subject to
the orders and directions of such court, as fully, to all intents and pur-
poses, as if the same were vested in, or might be exercised by, such bank-
rupt before or at the time of his bankruptcy declared as aforesaid; and
all suits in law or in equity, then pending, in which such bankrupt is a
party may be prosecuted and defended by such assignee to its final
conclusion, in the same way, and with the same effect as they might
have been by such bankrupt; and no suit commenced by or against any
assignee shall be abated by his death or removal from office, but the
same may be prosecuted or defended by his successor in the same office;
Provided, however. That there shall be excepted from the operation of
the provisions of this section the necessary household and kitchen furni-
ture, and such other articles and necessaries of such bankrupt as the
said assignee shall designate and set apart, having reference in the
amount to the family, condition, and circumstances of the bankrupt,
but altogether not to exceed in value, in any case, the sum of three hun-
dred dollars; and, also, the wearing apparel of such bankrupt, and that
of his wife and children; and the determination of the assignee in the
matter shall, on exception taken, be subject to the final decision of said
court.
Sec 4. And be it further enacted. That every bankrupt, who shall
bona fide surrender all his property, and rights of property, with the
exception before mentioned, for the benefit of his creditors, and shall
fully comply with and obey all the orders and directions which may
from time to time be passed by the proper court, and shall otherwise
conform to all the other requisitions of this act, shall (unless a majority
in number and value of his creditors who have proved their debts, shall
file their written dissent thereto) be entitled to a full discharge from all
his debts, to be decreed and allowed by the court which has declared
him a bankrupt, and a certificate thereof granted to him by such court
accordingly, upon his petition filed for such purpose; such discharge
and certificate not, however, to be granted until after ninety days from
the decree of bankruptcy, nor until after seventy days' notice in some
public newspaper, designated by such court, to all creditors who have
proved their debts, and other persons in interest, to appear at a particu-
448 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
lar time and place, to show cause why such discharge and certiiicate
shall not be granted; at which time and place any such creditors, or
other persons in interest, may appear and contest the right of the bank-
rupt thereto: Provided, That in all cases where the residence of the
creditor is known, a service on him personally, or by letter addressed
to him at his known usual place of residence, shall be prescribed by the
court, as in their discretion shall seem proper, having regard to the dis-
tance at which the creditor resides from such court. And if any such
bankrupt shall be guilty of any fraud or wilful concealment of his prop-
erty or rights of property, or shall have preferred any of his creditors
contrary to the provisions of this act, or shall wilfully omit or refuse to
comply with any orders or directions of such court, or to conform to
any other requisites of this act, or shall, in the proceedings under this
act, admit a false or fictitious debt against his estate, he shall not be
entitled to any such discharge or certificate; nor shall any person, being
a merchant, banker, factor, broker, underwriter, or marine insurer, be
entitled to any such discharge or certificate, who shall become bankrupt,
and who shall not have kept proper books of account, after the passing
of this act; nor any person who, after the passing of this act, shall
apply trust funds to his own use: Provided, That no discharge of any
bankrupt under this act shall release or discharge any person who may
be liable for the same debt as a partner, joint contractor, endorser, surety,
or otherwise, for or with the bankrupt. And such bankrupt shall at all
times be subject to examination, orally, or upon written interrogatories,
in and before such court, or any commission, appointed by the court
therefor, on oath, or, if conscientiously scrupulous of taking an oath,
upon his solemn affirmation, in all matters relating to such bankruptcy,
and his acts and doings, and his property and rights of property, which
in the judgment of such court, are necessary and proper for the pur-
poses of justice; and if in any such examination, he shall wilfully and
corruptly answer, or swear, or affirm, falsely, he shall be deemed guilty
of perjury, and shall be punishable therefor in like manner as the crime
of perjury is now punishable by the laws of the United States; and
such discharge and certificate, when duly granted, shall, in all courts
of justice, be deemed a full and complete discharge of all debts, con-
tracts, and other engagements of such bankrupt, which are proveable
under this act, and shall be and may be pleaded as a full and complete
bar to all suits brought in any court of judicature whatever, and the
same shall be conclusive evidence of itself in favor of such bankrupt,
unless the same shall be impeached for some fraud or wilful conceal-
ment by him of his property or rights of property, as aforesaid, contrary
to the provisions of this act, on prior reasonable notice specifying in
writing such fraud or concealment; and if, in any case of bankruptcy,
a majority, in number and value, of the creditors who shall have proved
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 449
Iheir debts at the time of hearing of the petition of the bankrupt for a
discharge as hereinbefore provided, shall at such hearing file their writ-
ten dissent to the allowance of a discharge and certificate to such
bankrupt, or if, upon such hearing, a discharge shall not be decreed to
him, the bankrupt may demand a trial by jury upon a proper issue to
be directed by the court, at such time and place, and in such manner,
as the court may order; or he may appeal from that decision, at any
time within ten days thereafter, to the circuit court next to be held for
the same district, by simply entering in the district court, or with the
clerk thereof, upon record, his prayer for an appeal. The appeal shall
be tried at the first term of the circuit court after it be taken, unless,
for sufficient reason, a continuance be granted; and it may be heard
and determined by said court summarily, or by a jury, at the option of
the bankrupt; and the creditors may appear and object against a decree
of discharge and the allowance of the certificate, as hereinbefore pro-
vided. And if, upon a full hearing of the parties, it shall appear to the
satisfaction of the court, or the jury shall find that the bankrupt has
made a full disclosure and surrender of all his estate, as by this act
required, and has in all things conformed to the directions thereof, the
court shall make a decree of discharge, and grant a certificate, as pro-
vided in this act.
Sec 5. And be it further enacted, That all creditors coming in and
proving their debts under such bankruptcy, in the manner hereinafter
prescribed, the same being bona fide debts, shall be entitled to share in
the bankrupt's property and effects, pro rata, without any priority or
preference whatsoever, except only for debts due by such bankrupt to
the United States, and for all debts due by him to persons who, by the
laws of the United States, have a preference, in consequence of having
paid moneys as his sureties, which shall be first paid out of the assets;
and any person who shall have performed any labor as an operative in
the service of any bankrupt shall be entitled to receive the full amount
of the wages due to him for such labor, not exceeding twenty-five dol-
lars: Provided, That such labor shall have been performed within six
months next before the bankruptcy of his employer; and all creditors
whose debts are not due and payable until a future day, all annuitants,
holders of bottomry and respondentia bonds, holders of policies of in-
surances, sureties, endorsers, bail, or other persons, having uncertain
or contingent demands against such bankrupt, shall be permitted to
come in and prove such debts or claims under this act, and shall have a
right, when their debts and claims become absolute, to have the same
allowed them; and such annuitants and holders of debts payable in
future may have the present value thereof ascertained, under the direc-
tion of such court, and allowed them accordingly, as debts in presenti;
and no creditor or other person, coming in and proving his debt or other
450 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
claim shall be allowed to maintain any suit at law or in equity therefor,
but shall be deemed thereby to have waived all right of action and suit
against such bankrupt; and all proceedings already commenced, and
all unsatisfied judgments already obtained thereon, shall be deemed to
be surrendered thereby; and in all cases where there are mutual debts
or mutual credits between the parties, the balance only shall be deemed
the true debt or claim between them, and the residue shall be deemed
adjusted by the set-oflf; all such proof of debts shall be made before the
court decreeing the bankruptcy, or before some commissioner appointed
by the court for that purpose; but such court shall have full power to
set aside and disallow any debt, upon proof that such debt is founded in
fraud, imposition, illegality, or mistake; and corporations to whom any
debts are due, may make proof thereof by their president, cashier, treas-
urer, or other officer, who may be specially appointed for that purpose;
and m appointing commissioners to receive proof of debts, and perform
other duties, under the provisions of this act, the said court shall ap-
point such persons as have their residence in the county in which the
bankrupt lives.
Sec 6. And be it further enacted, That the district court in every
district shall have jurisdiction in all matters and proceedings in bank-
ruptcy arising under this act, and any other act which may hereafter be
passed on the subject of bankruptcy; the said jurisdiction to be exer-
cised summarily, in the nature of summary proceedings in equitj-; and
for this purpose the said district court shall be deemed always open.
And the district judge may adjourn any point or question arising in any
case in bankruptcy into the circuit court for the district, in his discre-
tion, to be there heard and determined; and for this purpose the circuit
court of such district shall also be deemed always open. And the
jurisdiction hereby conferred on the district court shall extend to all
cases and controversies in bankruptcy arising between the bankrupt and
any creditor or creditors who shall claim any debt or demand under the
bankruptcy; to all cases and controversies between such creditor or
creditors and the assignee of the estate, whether in office or removed;
to all cases and controversies between such assignee and the bankrupt,
and to all acts, matters, and things to be done under and in virtue of
the bankruptcy, until the final distribution and settlement of the estate
of the bankrupt, and the close of the proceedings in bankruptcy. And
the said courts shall have full authority and jurisdiction to compel obe-
dience to all orders and decrees passed by them in bankruptcy, by pro-
cess of contempt and other remedial process, to the same extent the
circuit courts may now do in any suit pending therein in equity. And
it shall be the duty of the district court in each district, from time to
time, to prescribe suitable rules and regulations, and forms of proceed-
ings, in all matters of bankruptcy; which rules, regulations, and forms,
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 451
shall be subject to be altered, added to, revised, or annulled, by the cir-
cuit court of the same district, and other rules and regulations, and
forms, substituted therefor; and in all such rules, regulations and
forms, it shall be the duty of the said courts to make them as simple
and brief as practicable, to the end to avoid all unnecessary expenses,
and to facilitate the use thereof by the public at large. And the said
courts shall, from time to time, prescribe a tariff or table of fees and
charges to be taxed by the officers of the court or other persons, for
services under this act, or any other on the subject of bankruptcy;
which fees shall be as low as practicable, with reference to the nature
and character of such services.
Sec 7. And be it further enacted, That all petitions by any bankrupt
for the benefit of this act, and all petitions by a creditor against any
bankrupt under this act, and all proceedings in the case to the close
thereof, shall be had in the district court within and for the district in
which the person supposed to be a bankrupt shall reside, or have his
place of business at the time when such petition is filed, except where
otherwise provided in this act. And upon every such petition, notice
thereof shall be published in one or more public newspapers printed i«
such district, to be designated by such court at least twenty days before
the hearing thereof; and all persons interested may appear at the time
and place where the hearing is thus to be had, and show cause, if any
they have, why the prayer of the said petitioner should not be granted;
all evidence by witnesses to be used in all hearings before such court
shall be under oath, or solemn affirmation, when the party is conscien-
tiously scrupulous of taking an oath, and may be oral or by deposition,
taken before such court, or before any commissioner appointed by such
court, or before any disinterested State judge of the State in which the
deposition is taken; and all proof of debts or other claims, by creditors
entitled to prove the same by this act, shall be under oath or solemn
affirmations as aforesaid, before such court or commissioner appointed
thereby, or before some disinterested State judge of the State where the
creditors live, in such form as may be prescribed by the rules and regu-
lations hereinbefore authorized to be made and estabished by the courts
having jurisdiction in bankruptcy. But all such proofs of debts and
other claims shall be open to contestation in the proper court having
jurisdiction over the proceedings in the particular case in bankruptcy;
and as well the assignee as the creditor shall have a right to a trial by
jury, upon an issue to be directed by such court, to ascertain the valid-
ity and amount of such debts or other claims; and the result therein,
unless a new trial shall be granted, if in favor of the claims, shall be
evidence of the validity and amount of such debts or other claims. And
if any person or persons, shall falsely and corruptly answer, swear, or
affirm, in any hearing or on trial of any matter, or in any proceeding ia
452 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
such court in bankruptcy, or before any commissioner, he and they shall
be deemed guilty of perjury, and punishable therefor in the manner and
to the extent provided by law for other cases.
Sec. 8. And be it further enacted. That the circuit court within
and for the district where the decree of bankruptcy is passed, shall have
concurrent jurisdiction with the district court of the same district of all
suits at law and in equity which may and shall be brought by any
assignee of the bankrupt against any person or persons claiming an
adverse interest, or by such person against such assignee, touching any
property or rights of property of said bankrupt transferable to, or vested
in, such assignee; and no suit at law or in equity shall, in any case, be
maintainable by or against such assignee or by or against any person
claiming an adverse interest touching the property and rights of property
aforesaid, in any court whatsoever, unless the same shall be brought
within two years after the declaration and decree of bankruptcy, or after
the cause of suit shall first have accrued.
Sec 9. And be it further enacted. That all sales, transfers, and other
conveyances of the assignee of the bankrupt's property and rights of
property, shall be made at such times and in such manner as shall be
ordered and appointed by the court in bankruptcy; and all assets re-
ceived by the assignee in money, shall, within sixty days afterwards,
be paid into the court, subject to its order respecting its future safe-
keeping and disposition; and the court may require of such assignee a
bond, with at least two sureties, in such sum as it may deem proper,
conditioned for the due and faithful discharge of all his duties, and his
compliance with the orders and directions of the court; which bond shall
be taken in the name of the United States, and shall, if there be any
breach thereof, be sued and sueable, under the order of such court, for
the benefit of the creditors and other persons in interest.
Sec. 10. And be it further enacted. That in order to ensue a speedy
settlement and close of the proceedings in each case in bankruptcy, it
shall be the duty of the court to order and direct a collection of the
assets, and a reduction of the same to money, and a distribution thereof
at as early periods as practicable, consistently with a due regard to the
interests of the creditors: and a dividend and distribution of such assets
as shall be collected and reduced to money, or so much thereof as can
be safely so disposed of, consistently with the rights and interests of
third persons having adverse claims thereto, shall be made among the
creditors who have proved their debts, as often as once in six months
from the time of the decree declaring the bankruptcy; notice of such
dividends and distribution to be given in some newspaper or newspapers
in the district, designated by the court, ten days at least before the order
therefor is passed; and the pendency of any suit at law or in equity, by
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 453
or against such third persons, shall not postpone such division and dis-
tribution, except so far as the assets may be necessary to satisfy the same ;
and all the proceedings in bankruptcy in each case shall, if practicable,
be finally adjusted, settled, and brought to a close, by the court, within
two years after the decree declaring the bankruptcy. And where any
creditor shall not have proved his debt until a dividend or distribution
shall have been made and declared, he shall be entitled to be paid the
same amount, pro rata, out of the remaining dividends or distributions
thereafter made, as the other creditors have already received, before the
latter shall be entitled to any portion thereof.
Sec 11. And be it further enacted. That the assignee shall have full
authority, by and under the order and direction of the proper court in
bankruptcy, to redeem and discharge any mortgage or other pledge, or
deposite, or lien upon any property, real or personal, whether payable
in presenti or at a future day, and to tender a due performance of the
conditions thereof. And such assignee shall also have authority, by and
under the order and direction of the proper court in bankruptcy, to
compound any debts, or other claims, or securities due or belonging to
the estate of the bankrupt; but no such order or direction shall be made
until notice of the application is given in some public newspaper in the
district, to be designated by the court, ten days at least before the hear-
ing, so that all creditors and other persons in interest may appear and
show cause, if any they have, at the hearing, why the order or direction
should not be passed.
Sec 12. And be it further enacted, That if any person, who shall
have been discharged under this act, shall afterward become bankrupt,
he shall not again be entitled to a discharge under this act, unless his
estate shall produce (after all charges) sufficient to pay every creditor
seventy-five per cent, on the amount of the debt which shall have been
allowed to each creditor.
Sec 13. And be it further enacted. That the proceedings in all cases
in bankruptcy shall be deemed matters of record; but the same shall
not be required to be recorded at large, but shall be carefully filed,
kept, and numbered, in the office of the court, and a docket only, or
short memorandum thereof, with the numbers, kept in a book by the
clerk of the court; and the clerk of the court, for aEBxing his name and
the seal of the court to any form, or certifying a copy thereof, when
required thereto, shall be entitled to receive, as compensation, the sum
of twenty-five cents and no more. And no officer of the court, or com-
missioner, shall be allowed by the court more than one dollar for taking
the proof of any debt or other claim of any creditor or other person
against the estate of the bankrupt; but he may be allowed, in addition,
his actual travel expenses for that purpose.
454 FORMER BARKRUPTCY ACTS.
Sec 14. And be it further enacted. That where two or more persons,
who are partners in trade, become insolvent, an order may be made in
the manner provided in this act, either on the petition of such partners,
or any one of them, or on the petition of any creditor of the partners;
upon which order all the joint stock and property of the company, and
also all the separate estate of each of the partners, shall be taken, ex-
cepting such parts thereof as are herein exempted; and all the creditors
of the company, and the separate creditors of each partner, shall be
allowed to prove their respective debts; and the assignees shall also
keep separate accounts of the joint stock or property of the company,
and of the separate estate of each member thereof; and after deducting
out of the whole amount received by such assignees the whole of the
expenses and disbursements paid by them, the nett proceeds of the joint
stock shall be appropriated to pay the creditors of the company, and the
nett proceeds of the separate estate of each partner shall be appropriated
to pay his separate creditors; and if there shall be any balance of the
separate estate of any partner, after the payment of his separate debts,
such balance shall be added to the joint stock, for the payment of the
joint creditors; and if there shall be any balance of the joint stock, after
payment of the joint debts, such balance shall be divided and appropriated
to and among the separate estates of the several partners, according to
their respective rights and interests therein, and as it would have been
if the partnership had been dissolved without any bankruptcy; and the
sum so appropriated to the separate estate of each partner shall be ap-
plied to the payment of his separate debts ; and the certificate of discharge
shall be granted or refused to each partner, as the same would or ought
to be if the proceedings had been against him alone under this act;
and in all other respects the proceedings against partners shall be con-
ducted in the like manner as if they had been commenced and prosecuted
against one person alone.
Sec. 15. And be it further enacted, That a copy of any decree of
bankruptcy, and the appointment of assignees, as directed by the third
section of this act, shall be recited in every deed of lands belonging to
the bankrupt, sold and conveyed by any assignees under and by virtue
of this act; and that such recital, together with a certified copy of such
order, shall be full and complete evidence both of the bankruptcy and
assignment therein recited, and supersede the necessity of any other proof
of such bankruptcy and assignment to validate the said deed; and all
deeds containing such recital, and supported by such proof, shall be
as eflfectual to pass the title of the bankrupt, of, in, and to the lands
therein mentioned and described to the purchaser, as fully, to all intents
and purposes, as if made by such bankrupt himself, immediately before
such order.
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 455
Sec. 16. And be it further enacted, That all jurisdiction, power, and
authority, conferrred upon and vested in the district court of the United
States by this act, in cases in bankruptcy, are hereby conferred upon
and vested in the circuit court of the United States for the District of
Columbia, and in and upon the supreme or superior courts of any of
the Territories of the United States, in cases in bankruptcy, where the
bankrupt resides in the said District of Columbia, or in either of the
said Territories.
Sec. 17. And be it further enacted, That this act shall take eflfect from
and after the first day of February next.
Approved, August 19, 1841.
Act of March 3rd, 1843. Repealing Bankruptcy Statute.
An Act to repeal the bankrupt act.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That the act entitled,
"An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the
United States," approved on the nineteenth day of August, eighteen
hundred and forty-one, be, and the same hereby is, repealed: Provided,
That this act shall not aflfect any case or proceeding in bankruptcy com-
menced before the passage of this act, or any pains, penalties, or for-
feitures, incurred under the said act; but every such proceeding may
be continued to its final consummation in like manner as if this act had
not been passed.
Approved, March 3, 1843.
456 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
BANKRUPTCY ACT OF MARCH 2nd, 1867.
AN ACT to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the
United States.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled, That the several dis-
trict courts of the United States be, and they hereby are, constituted
courts of bankruptcy, and they shall have original jurisdiction in their
respective districts in all matters and proceedings in bankruptcy, and
they are hereby authorized to hear and adjudicate upon the same accord-
ing to the provisions of this act. The said courts shall be always open
for the transaction of business under this act, and the powers and juris-
diction hereby granted and conferred shall be exercised as well in vaca-
tion as in term time, and a judge sitting at chambers shall have the same
powers and jurisdiction, including the power of keeping order and of
punishing any contempt of his authority, as when sitting in court. And
the jurisdiction hereby conferred shall extend to all cases and contro->
versies arising between the bankrupt and any creditor or creditors who
shall claim any debt or demand under the bankruptcy; to the collection
of all the assets of the bankrupt; to the ascertainment and liquidation
of the liens and other specific claims thereon; to the adjustment of the
various priorities and conflicting interests of all parties; and to the
marshaling and disposition of the different funds and assets, so as to
secure the rights of all parties and due distribution of the assets among
all the creditors; and to all acts, matters, and things to be done under
and in virtue of the bankruptcy, until the final distribution and settle-
ment of the estate of the bankrupt, and the close of the proceedings in
bankruptcy. The said courts shall have full authority to compel obedi-
ence to all orders and decrees passed by them in bankruptcy, by process
of contempt and other remedial process, to the same extent that the
circuit courts now have in any suit pending therein in equity. Said
courts may sit for the transaction of business in bankruptcy at any place
in the district, of which place, and the time of holding court, they shall
have given notice, as well as at the places designated by law for holding
such courts.
Sec 2. And be it further enacted, That the several circuits courts of
the United States within and for the districts where the proceedings in
bankruptcy shall be pending shall have a general superintendence and
jurisdiction of all cases and questions arising under this act; and, except
when special provision is otherwise made, may, upon bill, petition, or other
proper process, of any party aggrieved, hear and determine the case as
a court of equity. The powers and jurisdiction hereby granted may be
exercised either by said court, or by any justice thereof, in term time
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 457
or vacation. Said circuit courts shall also have concurrent jurisdiction
with the district courts of the same district, of all suits at law or in
equity, which may or shall be brought by the assignee in bankruptcy
against any person claiming an adverse interest, or by such person against
such assignee, touching any property or rights of property of said bank-
rupt transferable to or vested in such assignee; but no suit at law or in
equity shall, in any case, be maintainable by or against such assignee,
or by or against any person claiming an adverse interest, touching the
property and rights of property aforesaid, in any court whatsoever, unless
the same shall be brought within two years from the time the cause of
action accrued, for or against such assignee: Provided, That nothing
herein contained shall revive a right of action barred at the time such
assignee is appointed.
OF THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE LAW IN COURTS OF BANKRUPTCY.
Sec 3. And be it further enacted. That it shall be the duty of the
judges of the district courts of the United States within and for the
several districts to appoint in each congressional district in said districts,
upon the nomination and recommendation of the Chief Justice of the
Supreme Court of the United States, one or more registers in bank-
ruptcy, to assist the judge of the district court in the performance of
his duties under this act. No person shall be eligible to such appoint-
ment unless he be a counsellor of said court, or of some one of the
courts of record of the State in which he resides. Before entering upon
the duties of his office, every person so appointed a register in bank-
ruptcy shall give a bond to the United States, with condition that he
will faithfully discharge the duties of his office, in a sum not less than
one thousand dollars, to be fixed by said court, with sureties satisfactory
to said court, or to either of the said justices thereof; and he shall, in
open court, take and subscribe the oath prescribed in the act entitled,
"An act to prescribe an oath of office, and for other purposes," approved
July second, eighteen hundred and sixty-two; and also that he will not
during his continuance in office be, directly or indirectly, interested in
or benefited by the fees or emoluments arising from any suit or matter
pending in bankruptcy in either the district or circuit court in his district.
Sec. 4. And be it further enacted, That every register in bankruptcy,
so appointed and qualified, shall have power, and it shall be his duty,
to make adjudication of bankruptcy, to receive the surrender of any bank-
rupt, to administer oaths in all proceedings before him, to hold and pre-
side at meetings of creditors, to take proof of debts, to make all com-
putations of dividends, and all orders of distribution, and to furnish the
assignee with a certified copy of such orders, and of the schedules of
creditors and assets filed in each case, to audit and pass accounts of
assignees, to grant protection, to pass the last examination of any bank-
458 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
rupt in cases whenever the assignee or a creditor do not oppose, and to
sit in chambers and despatch there such part of the administrative busi-
ness of the court and such uncontested matters as shall be defined in
general rules and orders, or as the district judge shall in any particular
matter direct; and he shall also make short memoranda of his proceed-
ings in each case in which he shall act, in a docket to be kept by him
for that purpose, and he shall forthwith, as the proceedings are taken,
forward to the clerk of the district court a certified copy of said memo-
randa, which shall be entered by said clerk in the proper minute-book
to be kept in his office, and any register of the court may act for any
other register thereof: Provided, however. That nothing in this section
contained shall empower a register to commit for contempt, or to hear
a disputed adjudication, or any question of the allowance or suspension
of an order of discharge; but in all matters where an issue of fact or
of law is raised and contested by any party to the proceedings before
him, it shall be his duty to cause the question or issue to be stated by the
opposing parties in writing, and he shall adjourn the same into court
for decision by the judge. No register shall be of counsel or attorney,
either in or out of court, in any suit or matter pending in bankruptcy
in either the circuit or district court of his district, nor in an appeal
therefrom; nor shall he be executor, administrator, guardian, commis-
sioner, appraiser, divider, or assignee, of or upon any estate within the
jurisdiction of either of said courts of bankruptcy, nor be interested in
the fees or emoluments arising from either of said trusts. The fees of
said registers, as established by this act, and by the general rules and
orders required to be framed under it, shall be paid to them by the
parties for whom the services may be rendered in the course of proceed-
ings authorized by this act.
Sec. 5. And be it further enacted, That the judge of the district court
may direct a register to attend at any place within the district, for the
purpose of hearing such voluntary applications under this act as may not
be opposed, of attending any meeting of creditors, or receiving any proof
of debts, and, generally, for the prosecution of any bankruptcy or other
proceedings under this act ; and the travelling and incidental expenses of
such register, and of any clerk or other officer attending him, incurred
in so acting, shall be settled by said court in accordance with the rules
prescribed under the tenth section of this act, and paid out of the assets
of the estate in respect of which such register has so acted; or, if there
be no such assets, or if the assets shall be insufficient, then such expenses
shall form a part of the costs in the case or cases in which the register
shall have acted in such journey, to be apportioned by the judge; and
such register, so acting, shall have and exercise all powers, except the
power of commitment, vested in the district court for the summoning
and examination of persons or witnesses, and for requiring the produc-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 459
tion of books, papers, and documents : Provided always. That all deposi-
tions of persons and witnesses taken before said register, and all acts
done by him, shall be reduced to writing and be signed by him, and shall
be filed in the clerk's oflSce as part of the proceedings. Such register
shall be subject to removal by the judge of the [circuit] district court,
and all vacancies accurring by such removal, or by resignation, change
of residence, death, or disability, shall be promptly filled by other fit
persons, unless said court shall deem the continuance of the particular
office unnecessary.
Sec. C. And be it further enacted, That any party shall, during the
proceedings before a register, be at liberty to take the opinion of the
district judge upon any point or matter arising in the course of such
proceedings, or upon the result of such proceedings, which shall be stated
by the register in the shape of a short certificate to the judge, who shall
sign the same if he approve thereof; and such certificate, so signed, shall
be binding on all the parties to the proceedings; but every such cer-
tificate may be discharged or varied by the judge at chambers or in open
court. In any bankruptcy, or in any other proceedings within the juris-
diction of the court under this act, the parties concerned, or submitting
to such jurisdiction, may at any stage of the proceedings, by consent,
state any question or questions in a special case for the opinion of the
court; and the judgment of the court shall be final, unless it be agreed
and stated in such special case that either party may appeal, if, in such
case, an appeal is allowed by this act. The parties may also, if they
think fit, agree, that upon the question or questions raised by such special
case being finally decided, a sum of money, fixed by the parties, or to
be ascertained by the court, or in such manner as the court may direct,
or any property, or the amount of any disputed debt or claim, shall be
paid, delivered, or transferred by one of such parties to the other of
them, either with or without costs.
Sec. 7. And be it further enacted. That parties and witnesses sum-
moned before a register shall be bound to attend in pursuance of such
summons at the place and time designated therein, and shall be entitled
to protection, and be liable to process of contempt in like manner as
parties and witnesses are now liable thereto in case of default in attend-
ence under any writ of subpoena; and all persons wilfully and corruptly
swearing or afiirming falsely before a register shall be liable to all the
penalties, punishments, and consequences of perjury. If any person ex-
amined before a register shall refuse or decline to answer, or to swear
to or sign his examination when taken, the register shall refer the matter
to the judge, who shall have power to order the person so acting to pay
the costs thereby occasioned, if such person be compellable by law to
answer such question, or to sign such examination, and such person shall
also be liable to be punished for contempt.
460 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
OF APPEALS AND PRACTICE.
Sec 8. And be it further enacted. That appeals may be taken from
the district to the circuit courts in all cases in equity, and writs of error
may be allowed to said circuit courts from said district courts in cases
at law under the jurisdiction created by this act when the debt or dam-
ages claimed amount to more than five hundred dollars; and any sup-
posed creditor, whose claim is wholly or in part rejected, or an assignee
who is dissatisfied with the allowance of a claim, may appeal from the
decision of the district court to the circuit court for the same district;
but no appeal shall be allowed in any case from the district to the
circuit court unless it is claimed, and notice given thereof to the clerk
of the district court, to be entered with the record of the proceedings,
and also to the assignee or creditor, as the case may be, or to the
defeated party in equity, within ten days after the entry of the decree
or decision appealed from. The appeal shall be entered at the term of
the circuit court which shall be first held within and for the district next
after the expiration of ten days from the time of claiming the same.
But if the appellant in writing waives his appeal before any decision
thereon, proceedings may be had in the district court as if no appeal had
been taken, and no appeal shall be allowed unless the appellant at the
time of claiming the same shall give bond in manner now required by
law in cases of such appeals. No writ of error shall be allowed unless
the party claiming it shall comply with the statutes regulating the grant-
ing of such writs.
Sec 9. And be it further enacted, That in cases arising under this act
no appeal or writ of error shall be allowed in any case from the circuit
courts to the Supreme Court of the United States, unless the matter in
dispute in such case shall exceed two thousand dollars.
Sec. 10. And be it further enacted, That the justices of the Supreme
Court of the United States subject to the provisions of this act shall frame
general orders for the following purposes:
For regulating the practice and procedure of the district courts in
bankruptcy, and the several forms of petitions, orders, and other pro-
ceedings to be used in said courts in all matters under this act;
For regulating the duties of the various officers of said courts;
For regulating the fees payable, and the charges and costs to be
allowed, except such as are established by this act or by law, with respect
to all proceedings in bankruptcy before said courts, not exceeding the
rate of fees now allowed by law for similar services in other proceedings ;
For regulating the practice and procedure upon appeals;
For regulating the filing, custody, and inspection of records;
And generally for carrying the provisions of this act into effect.
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 461
After such general orders shall have been so framed, they, or any of
them, may be rescinded or varied, and other general orders may be
framed in manner aforesaid, and all such general orders so framed shall,
from time to time, be reported to Congress, with such suggestions as
said justices may think proper.
VOLUNTARY BANKRUPTCY — COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS.
Sec 11. And be it further enacted. That if any person residing
within the jurisdiction of the United States, owing debts provable under
this act exceeding the amount of three hundred dollars, shall apply by
petition, addressed to the judge of the judicial district in which such
debtor has resided or carried on business for the six months next im-
mediately preceding the time of filing such petition, or for the longest
period during such six months, setting forth his place of residence, his
inability to pay all his debts in full, his willingness to surrender all his
estate and effects for the benefit of his creditors, and his desire to obtain
the benefit of this act, and shall annex to his petition a schedule, verified
by oath before the court, or before a register in bankruptcy, or before
one of the commissioners of the circuit court of the United States, con-
taining a full and true statement of all his debts, and, as far as possible,
to whom due, with the place of residence of each creditor, if known to
the debtor, and if not known the fact to be so stated, and the sum due
to each creditor, also the nature of each debt or demand, whether founded
on written security, obligation, contract, or otherwise, and also the true
cause and consideration of such indebtedness in each case, and the place
where such indebtedness accrued, and a statement of any existing mort-
gage, pledge, lien, judgment, or collateral or other security given for
the payment of the same ; and shall also annex to his petition an accurate
inventory, verified in like manner, of all his estate, both real and personal,
assignable under this act, describing the same, and stating where it is
situated, and whether there are any, and if so, what incumbrances thereon,
the filing of such petition shall be an act of bankruptcy, and such peti-
tioner shall be adjudged a bankrupt: Provided, That all citizens of the
United States petitioning to be declared bankrupt shall, on filing such
petition and before any proceedings thereon, take and subscribe an oath
of allegiance and fidelity to the United States, which oath shall be filed
and recorded with the proceedings in bankruptcy. And the judge of
the district court, or, if there be no opposing party, any register of said
court, to be designated by the judge, shall forthwith, if he be satisfied
that the debts due from the petitioner exceed three hundred dollars,
issue a warrant, to be signed by such judge or register, directed to the
marshal of said district, authorizing him forthwith, as messenger, to
publish notices in such newspapers as the warrant specifies; to serve
written or printed notice, by mail or personally, on all creditors upon the
462 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
schedule filed with the debtor's petition, or whose names may be given
to him, in addition, by the debtor, and to give such personal or other
notice to any persons concerned as the warrant specifies, which notice
shall state —
First That a warrant in bankruptcy has been issued against the
estate of the debtor.
Second. That the payment of any debts and the delivery of any
property belonging to such debtor to him or for his use, and the transfer
of any property by him, are forbidden by law.
Third. That a meeting of the creditors of the debtor, giving the
names, residences, and amounts, so far as known, to prove their debts
and choose one or more assignees of his estate, will be held at a court
of bankruptcy, to be holden at a time and place designated in the war-
rant, jiot less than ten nor more than ninety days after the issuing of
the same.
OF ASSIGNMENTS AND ASSIGNEES,
Sec 12. And be it further enacted. That at the meeting, held in pur-
suance of the notice, one of the registers of the court shall preside, and
the messenger shall make return of the warrant and of his doings thereon ;
and if it appears that the notice to the creditors has not been as required
in the warrant, the meeting shall forthwith be adjourned, and a new
notice given as required. If the debtor dies after the issuing the war-
rant, the proceedings may be continued and concluded in. like manner
as if he had lived.
Sec. 13. And be it further enacted, That the creditors shall, at the
first meeting held after due notice from the messenger, in presence of
a register designated by the court, choose one or more assignees of the
estate of the debtor ; the choice to be made by the greater part in value and
in number of the creditors who have proved their debts. If no choice is
made by the creditors at said meeting, the judge, or, if there be no oppos-
ing interest, the register, shall appoint one or more assignees. If an
assignee, so chosen or appointed, fails within five days to express in writ-
ing his acceptance of the trust, the judge or register may fill the vacancy.
All elections or appointments of assignees shall be subject to the approval
of the judge; and when in his judgment it is for any cause needful or
expedient, he may appoint additional assignees, or order a new election.
The judge at any time may, and, upon the request in writing of any
creditor who has proved his claim, shall, require the assignee to give
good and sufficient bond to the United States, with a condition for the
faithful performance and discharge of his duties; the bond shall be ap-
proved by the judge or register by his indorsement thereon, shall be
filed with the record of the case, and inure to the benefit of all creditors
proving their claims, and may be prosecuted in the name and for the
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 463
benefit of any injured party. If the assignee fails to give the bond
within such time as the judge orders, not exceeding ten days after notice
to him of such order, the judge shall remove him and appoint another
in his place.
Sec. 14. And be it further enacted, That as soon as said assignee is
appointed and qualified, the judge, or, where there is no opposing interest,
tha-^register, shall, by an instrument under his hand, assign and convey
to tKe assignee all the estate, real and personal, of the bankrupt, with all
his deeds, books, and papers relating thereto, and such assignment shall
relate back to the commencement of said proceedings in bankruptcy, and
thereupon, by operation of law, the title to all such property and estate,
both real and personal, shall vest in said assignee, although the same is
then attached on mesne process as the property of the debtor, and shall dis-
solve any such attachment made within four months next preceding the
commencement of said proceedings Provided, however, That there shall
be excepted from the operation of the provisions of this section the nec-
essary household and kitchen furniture, and such other articles and
necessaries of such bankrupt as the said assignee shall designate and set
apart, having reference in the amount to the family, condition, and cir-
cumstances of the bankrupt, but altogether not to exceed in value, in any
case, the sum of five hundred dollars; and also the wearing apparel of
such bankrupt, and that of his wife and children, and the uniform, arms,
and equipments of any person who is or has been a soldier in the milita
or in the service of the United States; and such other property as now
is, or hereafter shall be, exempted from attachment, or seizure, or levy
on execution by the laws of the United States, and such other property
not included in the foregoing exceptions as is exempted from levy and
sale upon execution or other process or order of any court by the laws
of the State in which the bankrupt has his domicile at the time of the
commencement of the proceedings in bankruptcy, to an amount not ex-
ceeding that allowed by such State exemption laws in force in the year
eighteen hundred and sixty-four. Provided, That the foregoing exception
shall operate as a limitation upon the conveyance of the property of the
bankrupt to his assignees, and in no case shall the property hereby ex-
cepted pass to the assignees, or the title of the bankrupt thereto be im-
paired or affected by any of the provisions of this act; and the deter-
mination of the assignee in the matter shall, on exception taken, be sub-
ject to the final decision of the said court: And provided further. That
no mortgage of any vessel or of any other goods or chattels, made as
security for any debt or debts, in good faith and for present considera-
tions, and otherwise valid, and duly recorded, pursuant to any statute of
the United States, or of any State, shall be invalidated or affected hereby ;
and all the property conveyed by the bankrupt in fraud of his creditors;
all rights in equity, choses in action, patents and patent rights and copy-
464 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
rights; all debts due him, or any person for his use, and all liens and
securities therefor; and all his rights of action for property or estate,
real or personal, and for any cause of action which the bankrupt had
against any person arising from contract or from the unlawful taking
or detention of or injury to the property of the bankrupt; and all his
rights of redeeming such property or estate, with the like right, title,
power, and authority to sell, manage, dispose of, sue for, and recover
or defend the same, as the bankrupt might or could have had if no
assignment had been made, shall, in virtue of the adjudication of bank-
ruptcy and the appointment of his assignee, be at once vested in such
assignee; and he may sue for and recover the said estate, debts, and
effects, and may prosecute and defend all suits at law or in equity, pend-
ing at the time of the adjudication of bankruptcy, in which such bank-
rupt is a party in his own name, in the same manner and with the like
effect as they might have been presented or defended by such bankrupt;
and a copy, duly certified by the clerk of the court under the seal thereof,
of the assignment made by the judge or register, as the case may be, to
him as assignee, shall be conclusive evidence of his title as such assignee
to take, hold, sue for, and recover the property of the bankrupt, as here-
inbefore mentioned; but no property held by the bankrupt in trust shall
pass by such assignment. No person shall be entitled to maintain an
action against an assignee in bankruptcy for anything done by him as
such assignee, without previously giving him twenty days' notice of such
action specifying the cause thereof, to the end that such assignee may
have an opportunity of tendering amends, should he see fit to do so.
No person shall be entitled, as against the assignee, to withhold from
him possession of any books of account of the bankrupt, or claim any
lien thereon; and no suit in which the assignee is a party shall be abated
by his death or removal from office, but the same may be prosecuted
and defended by his successor, or by the surviving or remaining assignee,
as the case may be. The assignee shall have authority, under the order
and direction of the court, to redeem or discharge any mortgage or con-
ditional contract, or pledge or deposit, or lien upon any property, real or
personal, whenever payable, and to tender due performance of the condi-
tion thereof, or to sell the same subject to such mortgage, lien or other
incumbrances. The debtor shall also, at the request of the assignee, and
at the expense of the estate, make and execute any instruments, deeds,
and writings which may be pi"0per, to enable the assignee to possess him-
self fully of all the assets of the bankrupt. The assignee shall immedi-
ately give notice of his appointment by publication at least once a week
for three successive weeks, in such newspapers as shall, for that purpose,
be designated by the court, due regard being had to their general cir-
culation in the district, or in that portion of the district in which the
bankrupt and his creditors shall reside, and shall, within six months.
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 465
cause the assignment to him to be recorded in every registry of deeds
or other office within the United States where a conveyance of any lands
owned by the bankrupt ought by law to be recorded; and the record
of such assignment, or a duly certified copy thereof, shall be evidence
thereof in all courts.
Sec. 15. And be it further enacted, That the assignee shall demand
and receive from any and all persons holding the same all the estate
assigned, or intended to be assigned, under the provisions of this act;
and he shall sell all such unincumbered estate, real and personal, which
comes to his hands, on such terms as he thinks most for the interest
of the creditors ; but upon petition of any person interested, and for cause
shown, the court may make such order concerning the time, place, and
manner of sale, as will, in his opinion, prove to the interest of the
creditors; and the assignee shall keep a regular account of all money
received by him as assignee, to which every creditor shall, at reasonable
times, have free resort.
Sec 16. And be it further enacted, That the assignee shall have the
like remedy to recover all said estate, debts, and effects, in his own name,
as the debtor might have had if the decree in bankruptcy had not been
rendered and no assignment had been made. If, at the time of
the commencement of proceedings in bankruptcy, an action is pending
in the name of the debtor for the recovery of a debt or other
thing which might or ought to pass to the assignee by the assign-
ment, the assignee shall, if he requires it, be admitted to prosecute the
action in his own name, in like manner and with like effect, as if
it had been originally commenced by him. No suit pending in the
name of the assignee shall be abated by his death or removal ; but upon
the motion of the surviving, or remaining, or new assignee, as the case
may be, he shall be admitted to prosecute the suit, in like manner and
with like effect as if it had been originally commenced by him. In suits
prosecuted by the assignee, a certified copy of the assignment made to
him by the judge or register shall be conclusive evidence of his authority
to sue.
Sec 17. And be it further enacted, That the assignee shall, as soon
as may be after receiving any money belonging to the estate, deposit the
same in some bank in his name as assignee, or otherwise keep it distinct
and apart from all other money in his possession; and shall, as far as
practicable, keep all goods and effects belonging to the estate separate
and apart from all other goods in his possession, or designated by appro-
priate marks, so that they may be easily and clearly distinguished, and
may not be exposed or liable to be taken as his property or for the pay-
ment of his debts. When it appears that the distribution of the estate
may be delayed by litigation or other cause, the court may direct the
466 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
temporary investment of the money belonging to such estate in securities
to be approved by the judge or a register of said court, or may authorize
the same to be deposited in any convenient bank, upon such interest,
not exceeding the legal rate, as the bank may contract with the assignee
to pay thereon. He shall give written notice to all known creditors, by
mail or otherwise, of all dividends, and such notice of meetings, after
the first, as may be ordered by the court He shall be allowed, and may
retain, out of money in his hands, all the necessary disbursements made
by him in the discharge of his duty, and a reasonable compensation for
his services, in the discretion of the court. He may, under the direction
of the court, submit any controversy arising in the settlement of demands
against the estate, or of debts due to it, to the determination of arbitrators,
to be chosen by him and the other party to the controversy, and may,
under such direction, compound and settle any such controversy by agree-
ment with the other party, as he thinks proper and most for the interest
of the creditors.
Sec 18. And be it further enacted, That the court, after due notice
and hearing, may remove an assignee for any cause which, in the judg-
ment of the court, renders such removal necessary or expedient. At a
meeting called by order of the court in its discretion for the purpose,
or which shall be called upon the application of a majority of the
creditors in number and value, the creditors may, with consent of the
court, remove any assignee by such a vote as is hereinbefore provided
for the choice of assignee. An assignee may, with the consent of the
judge, resign his trust and be discharged therefrom. Vacancies caused
by death or otherwise in the office of assignee may be filled by appoint-
ment of the court, or, at its discretion, by an election by the creditors,
in the manner hereinbefore provided, at a regular meeting, or at a meet-
ing called for the purpose, with such notice thereof in writing to all
known creditors, and by such person, as the court shall direct. The
resignation or removal of an assignee shall in no way release him from
performing all things requisite on his part for the proper closing up of
his trust and the transmission thereof to his successors, nor shall it affect
the liability of the principal or surety on the bond given by the assignee.
When, by death or otherwise, the number of assignees is reduced, the
estate of the debtor not lawfully disposed of, shall vest in the remaining
assignee or assignees, and the persons selected to fill vacancies, if any,
with the same powers and duties relative thereto as if they were originally
chosen. Any former assignee, his executors, or administrators, upon re-
quest, and at the expense of the estate, shall make and execute to the
new assignee all deeds, conveyances, and assurances, and do all other
lawful acts requisite to enable him to recover and receive all the estate.
And the court may make all orders which it may deem expedient to
secure the proper fulfilment of the duties of any former assignee, and
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 467
the rights and interests of all persons interested in the estate. No person
who has received any preference contrary to the provisions of this act
shall vote for or be eligible as assignee; but no title to property, real
or personal, sold, transferred, or conveyed by an assignee, shall be
affected or impaired by reason of his ineligibility. An assignee refusing
or unreasonably neglecting to execute an instrument when lawfully re-
quired by the court, or disobeying a lawful order or decree of the court
in the premises, may be punished as for a contempt of court.
OF DEBTS AND PROOF OF CLAIMS.
Sec 19. And be it further enacted. That all debts due and payable
from the bankrupt at the time of the adjudication of bankruptcy, and all
debts then existing, but not payable until a future day, a rebate of interest
being made when no interest is payable by the terms of contract, may be
proved against the estate of the bankrupt. All demands against the bank-
rupt for or on account of any goods or chattels wrongfully taken, con-
verted, or withheld by him, may be proved and allowed as debts to the
amount of the value of the property so taken or withheld, with interest.
If the bankrupt shall be bound as drawer, indorser, surety, bail, or
guarantor upon any bill, bond, note, or any other specialty or contract,
or for any debt of another person, and his liability shall not have be-
come absolute until after the adjudication of bankruptcy, the creditor
may prove the same after such liability shall have become fixed, and
before the final dividend shall have been declared. In all cases of con-
tingent debts and contingent liabilities contracted by the bankrupt, and
not herein otherwise provided for, the creditor may make claim therefor,
and have his claim allowed, with the right to share in the dividends, if
the contingency shall happen before the order for the final dividend; or
he may at any time apply to the court to have the present value of the
debt or liability ascertained and liquidated, which shall then be done in
such manner as the court shall order, and he shall be allowed to prove
for the amount so ascertained. Any person liable as bail, surety, guar-
antor, or otherwise for the bankrupt, who shall have paid the debt or
any part thereof in discharge of the whole, shall be entitled to prove such
debt, or to stand in the place of the creditor if he shall have proved
the same, although such payments shall have been made after the pro-
ceedings in bankruptcy were commenced. And any person so liable for
the bankrupt, and who has not paid the whole of said debt, but is still
liable for the same or any part thereof, may, if the creditor shall fail
or omit to prove such debt, prove the same either in the name of the
creditor or otherwise, as may be provided by the rules, and subject to
such regulations and limitations as may be established by such rules.
Where the bankrupt is liable to pay rent, or other debt falling due at
fixed and stated periods, the creditor may prove for a proportionate part
468 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
thereof up to the time of the bankruptcy, as if the same grew due from
day to day, and not at such fixed and stated periods. If any bankrupt
shall be liable for unliquidated damages arising out of any contract or
promise, or on account of any goods or chattels wrongfully taken, con-
verted or withheld, the court may cause such damages to be assessed in
such mode as it may deem best, and the sum so assessed may be proved
against the estate. No debts other than those above specified shall be
proved or allowed against the estate.
Sec. 20. And be it further enacted. That, in all cases of mutual debts
or mutual credits between the parties, the account between them shall be
stated, and one debt set off against the other, and the balance only shall
be allowed or paid, but no set-off shall be allowed of a claim in its nature
not provable against the estate : Provided, That no set-off shall be allowed
in favor of any debtor to the bankrupt of a claim purchased by or trans-
ferred to him after the filing of the petition. When a creditor has a
mortgage or pledge of real or personal property of the bankrupt, or a
lien thereon for securing the payment of a debt owing to him from the
bankrupt, he shall be admitted as a creditor only for the balance of the
debt after deducting the value of such property, to be ascertained by
agreement between him and the assignee, or by a sale thereof, to be made
in such manner as the court shall direct; or the creditor may release
or convey his claim to the assignee upon such property, and be admitted
to prove his whole debt. If the value of the property exceeds the sum
for which it is so held as security, the assignee may release to the creditor
the bankrupt's right of redemption therein on receiving such excess; or
he may sell the property, subject to the claim of the creditor thereon;
and in either case the assignee and creditor, respectively, shall execute
all deeds and writings necessary or proper to consummate the transaction.
If the property is not so sold or released and delivered up, the creditor
shall not be allowed to prove any part of his debt.
Sec. 21. And be it further enacted, That no creditor proving his debt
or claim shall be allowed to maintain any suit at law or in equity therefor
against the bankrupt, but shall be deemed to have waived all right of
action and suit against the bankrupt, and all proceedings already com-
menced, or unsatisfied judgments already obtained thereon, shall be
deemed to be discharged and surrendered thereby ; and no creditor whose
debt is provable under this act shall be allowed to prosecute to final
judgment any suit at law or in equity therefor against the bankrupt, until
the question of the debtor's discharge shall have been determined; and
any such suit or proceedings shall, upon the application of the bank-
rupt, be stayed to await the determination of the court in bankruptcy
on the question of the discharge, provided there be no unreasonable
delay on the part of the bankrupt in endeavoring to obtain his discharge.
FORME?. BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 469
and provided, also, that if the amount due the creditor is in dispute, the
suit, by leave of the court in bankruptcy, may proceed to judgment, for
the purpose of ascertaining the amoimt due, which amount may be proved
in bankruptcy, but execution shall be stayed as aforesaid. If any bank-
rupt shall, at the time of adjudication, be liable upon any bill of exchange,
promissory note, or other obligation in respect of distinct contracts as
a member of two or more firms carrying on separate and distinct trades,
and having distinct estates to be wound up in bankruptcy, or as a sole
trader and also as a member of a firm, the circumstance that such firms
are in whole or in part composed of the same individuals, or that the
sole contractor is also one of the joint contractors, shall not prevent proof
and receipt of dividend in respect of such distinct contracts against the
estates respectively liable upon such contracts.
Sec 22. And be it further enacted, That all proofs of debts against
the estate of the bankrupt, by or in behalf of creditors residing within
the judicial districts where the proceedings in bankruptcy are pending,
shall be made before one of the registers of the court in said district,
and by or in behalf of non-resident debtors before any register in bank-
ruptcy in the judicial district where such creditors, or either of them,
reside, or before any commissioner of the circuit court authorized to
administer oaths in any district. To entitle a claimant against the estate
of a bankrupt to have his demand allowed, it must be verified by a deposi-
tion in writing on oath or solemn affirmation before the proper register
or commissioner, setting forth the demand, the consideration thereof,
whether any and what securities are held therefor, and whether any and
what payments have been made thereon; that the sum claimed is justly
due from the bankrupt to the claimant; that the claimant has not, nor
has any other person for his use, received any security or satisfaction
whatever other than that by him set forth; that the claim was not pro-
cured for the purpose of influencing the proceedings under this act, and
that no bargain or agreement, express or implied, has been made or
entered into, by or on behalf of such creditor, to sell, transfer, or dis-
pose of the said claim, or any part thereof, against such bankrupt, or
take or receive, directly or indirectly, any money, property, or consid-
eration whatever, whereby the vote of such creditor for assignee, or any
action on the part of such creditor or any other person in the proceedings
under this act, is or shall be in any way affected, influenced, or controlled,
and no claim shall be allowed unless all the statements set forth in such
deposition shall appear to be true. Such oath or solemn affirmation shall
be made by the claimant testifying of his own knowledge, unless he is
absent from the United States or prevented by some other good cause
from testifying, in which cases the demand may be verified in like manner
by the attorney or authorized agent of the claimant testifying to the best
of his knowledge, information, and belief, and setting forth his means
470 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
of knowledge, or, if in a foreign country, the oath of the creditor may
be taken before any minister, consul, or vice-consul of the United States ;
and the court may, if it shall see fit, require or receive further perti.ient
evidence, either for or against the admission of the claim. Corporations
may verify their claim by the oath or solemn affirmation of their presi-
dent, cashier, or treasurer. If the proof is satisfactory to the register or
commissioner, it shall be signed by the deponent, and delivered or sent
by mail to the assignee, who shall examine the same and compare it
with the books and accounts of the bankrupt, and shall register, in a
book to be kept by him for that purpose, the names of creditors who
have proved their claims, in the order in which such proof is received,
stating the time of receipt of such proof, and the amount and nature
of the debts, which books shall be open to the inspection of all the
creditors. The court may, on the application of the assignee, or of any
creditor, or of the bankrupt, or without any application, examine upon
oath the bankrupt, or any person tendering or who has made proof of
claims, and may summon any person capable of giving evidence concern-
ing such proof, or concerning the debt sought to be proved, and shall
reject all claims not duly proved, or where the proof shows the claim to
be founded in fraud, illegality, or mistake.
Sec 23. And be it further enacted. That when a claim is presented
for proof before the election of the assignee, and the judge entertains
doubts of its validity, or of the right of the creditor to prove it, and
is of opinion that such validity or right ought to be investigated by the
assignee, he may postpone the proof of the claim until the assignee is
chosen. Any person who, after the approval of this act, shall have
accepted any preference, having reasonable cause to believe that the same
was made or given by the debtor, contrary to any provision of this act,
shall not prove the debt or claim on account of which the preference
was made or given, nor shall he receive any dividend therefrom, until
he shall first have surrendered to the assignee all property, money, benefit,
or advantage, received by him under such preference. The court shall
allow all debts duly proved, and shall cause a list thereof to be made
and certified by one of the registers; and any creditor may act at all
meetings by his duly constituted attorney the same as though personally
present.
Sec 24. And be it further enacted, That a supposed creditor who
takes an appeal to the circuit court from the decision of the district court
rejecting his claim, in whole or in part, shall, upon entering his appeal
in the circuit court, file in the clerk's office thereof a statement in writing
of his claim, setting forth the same, substantially, as in a declaration
for the same cause of action at law and the assignee shall plead or answer
thereto in like manner, and like proceedings shall thereupon be had in
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 471
the pleadings, trial, and determination of the cause, as in an action at
law commenced and prosecuted, in the usual manner, in the courts of
the United States, except that no execution shall be awarded against the
assignee for the amount of a debt found due to the creditor. The final
judgment of the court shall be conclusive, and the list of debts shall,
if necessary, be altered to conform thereto. The party prevailing in the
suit shall be entitled to costs against the adverse party, to be taxed and
recovered as in suits at law; if recovered against the assignee, they shall
be allowed out of the estate. A bill of exchange, promissory note, or
other instrument, used in evidence upon the proof of a claim, and left
in court, or deposited in the clerk's office, may be delivered, by the
register or clerk having the custody thereof, to the person who used it,
upon his filing a' copy thereof, attested by the clerk of the court, who
shall indorse upon it the name of the party against whose estate it has
been proved, and the date and amount of any dividend declared thereon.
OF PROPERTY PERISHABLE AND IN DISPUTE.
Sec 25. And be it further enacted, That when it appears to the satis-
faction of the court that the estate of the debtor, or any part thereof, is
of a perishable nature, or liable to deteriorate in value, the court may order
the same to be sold, in such manner as may be deemed most expedient,
under the direction of the messenger or assignee, as the case may be, who
shall hold the funds received in place of the estate disposed of; and
whenever it appears to the satisfaction of the court that the title to any
portion of an estate, real or personal, which has come into possession
of the assignee, or which is claimed by him, is in dispute, the court may,
upon the petition of the assignee, and after such notice to the claimant,
his agent or attorney, as the court shall deem reasonable, order it to be
sold, under the direction of the assignee, who shall hold the funds re-
ceived in place of the estate disposed of; and the proceeds of the sale
shall be considered the measure of the value of the property in any suit
or controversy between the parties in any courts. But this provision shall
not prevent the recovery of the property from the possession of the
assignee by any proper action commenced at any time before the court
orders the sale.
EXAMINATION OF BANKRUPTS.
Sec. 26. And be it further enacted, That the court may, on the applica-
tion of the assignee in bankruptcy, or of any creditor, or without any
application, at all times require the bankrupt, upon reasonable notice, to
attend and submit to an examination, on oath, upon all matters relating
to the disposal or condition of his property, to his trade and dealings
with others, and his accounts concerning the same, to all debts due to
or claimed from him, and to all other matters concerning his property
and estate and the due settlement thereof according to law, which ex-
472 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACES.
amination shall be in writing, and shall be signed by the bankrupt and
filed with the other proceedings; and the court may, in like manner,
require the attendance of any other person as a witness, and if such person
shall fail to attend, on being summoned thereto, the court may compel
his attendance by warrant directed to the marshal, commanding him to
arrest such person and bring him forthwith before the court, or before
a register in bankruptcy, for examination as such witness. If the bank-
rupt is imprisoned, absent, or disabled from attendance, the court may
order him to be produced by the jailer, or any officer in whose custody
he may be, or may direct the examination to be had, taken, and certified,
at such time and place and in such manner as the court may deem
proper, and with like effect as if such examination had been had in court.
The bankrupt shall, at all times, until his discharge, be subject to the
order of the court, and shall, at the expense of the estate, execute all
proper writings and instruments, and do and perform all acts required
by the court touching the assigned property or estate, and to enable the
assignee to demand, recover, and receive all the property and estate
assigned, wherever situated ; and for neglect or refusal to obey any order
of the court, such bankrupt may be committed and punished as for a
contempt of court, if the bankrupt is without the district, and unable
to return and personally attend at any of the times or do any of the acts
which may be specified or required pursuant to this section, and if it ap-
pears that such absence was not caused by wilful default, and if, as soon
as may be after the removal of such impediment, he offers to attend and
submit to the order of the court in all respects, he shall be permitted so
to do, with like effect as if he had not been in default. He shall also
be at liberty, from time to time, upon oath, to amend and correct his
schedule of creditors and property, so that the same shall conform to
the facts. For good cause shown the wife of any bankrupt may be te-
quired to attend before the court, to the end that she may be examined
as a witness; and if such wife do not attend at the time and place speci-
fied in the order, the bankrupt shall not be entitled to a discharge unless
he shall prove to the satisfaction of the court that he was unable to procure
the attendance of his wife. No bankrupt shall be liable to arrest during the
pendency of the proceedings in bankruptcy in any civil action, unless
the same is founded on some debt or claim from which his discharge in
bankruptcy would not release him.
OF THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE BANKRUPT'S ESTATE.
Sec. 27. And he it further enacted, That all creditors whose debts are
duly proved and allowed shall be entitled to share in the bankrupt's prop-
erty and estate pro rata, without any priority or preference whatever,
except that wages due from him to any operative, or clerk, or house ser-
vant, to an amount not exceeding fifty dollars for labor performed within
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 473
six months next preceding the adjudication of bankruptcy, shall be en-
titled to priority, and shall be first paid in full : Provided, That any debt
proved by any person liable as bail, surety, guarantor, or otherwise,
for the bankrupt shall not be paid to the person so proving the same
until satisfactory evidence shall be produced of the payment of such
debt by such person so liable, and the share to which such debt would
be entitled may be paid into court, or otherwise held for the benefit of
the party entitled thereto, as the court may direct. At the expiration of
three months from the date of the adjudication of bankruptcy in any
case, or as much earlier as the court may direct, the court, upon request
of the assignee, shall call a general meeting of the creditors, of which due
notice shall be given, and the assignee shall then report, and exhibit to
the court and to the creditors just and true accounts of all his receipts
and payments, verified by his oath, and he shall also produce and file
vouchers for all payments for which vouchers shall be required by any
rule of the court; he shall also submit the schedule of the bankrupt's
creditors and property as amended, duly verified by the bankrupt, and
a statement of the whole estate of the bankrupt as then ascertained, of
the property recovered and of the property outstanding, specifying the
cause of its being outstanding, also what debts or claims are yet undeter-
mined, and stating what sum remains in his hands. At such meeting
the majority in value of the creditors present shall determine whether
any and what part of the net proceeds of the estate, after deducting and
retaining a sum sufficient to provide for all undetermined claims which,
by reason of the distant residence of the creditor, or for other sufficient
reason, have not been proved, and for other expenses and contingencies,
shall be divided among the creditors; but unless at least one-half in
value of the creditors shall attend such meeting, either in person or by
attorney, it shall be the duty of the assignee so to determine. In case a
dividend is ordered the register shall, within ten days after such meet-
ing, prepare a list of creditors entitled to dividend, and shall calculate
and set opposite to the name of each creditor who has proved his claim
the dividend to which he is entitled out of the net proceeds of the es-
tate set apart for dividend, and shall forward by mail to every creditor
a statement of the dividend to which he is entitled, and such creditor
shall be paid by the assignee in such manner as the court may direct.
Sec. 28. And be it further enacted, That the like proceedings, shall
be had at the expiration of the next three months, or earlier, if prac-
ticable, and a third meeting of creditors shall then be called by the court,
and a final dividend then declared, unless any action at law or suit in
equity be pending, or unless some other estate or effects of the debtor
afterwards come to the hands of the assignee, in which case the assignee
shall, as soon as may be, convert such estate or effects into money, and
within two months after the same shall be so converted the same shall
474 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
be divided in manner aforesaid. Further dividends shall be made in like
manner as often as occasion requires; and after the third meeting of
creditors no further meeting shall be called unless ordered by the court.
If at any time there shall be in the hands of the assignee any outstand-
ing debts or other property, due or belonging to the estate which can-
not be collected and received by the assignee without unreasonable or
inconvenient delay or expense, the assignee may, under the direction of
the court, sell and assign such debts or other property in such manner as
the court shall order. No dividend already declared shall be disturbed
by reason of debts being subsequently proved, but the creditors proving
such debts shall be entitled to a dividend equal to those already received
by the other creditors before any further payment is made to the latter.
Preparatory to the final dividend, the assignee shall submit his account
to the court and file the same, and give notice to the creditors of such
filing, and shall also give notice that he will apply for a settlement of
his account, and for a discharge from all liability as assignee, at a time
to be specified in such notice; and at such time the court shall audit and
pass the accounts of the assignee, and such assignee shall, if required by
the court, be examined as to the truth of such account, and if found
correct he shall thereby be discharged from all liability as assignee to
any creditor of the bankrupt. The court shall thereupon order a divi-
dend of the estate and effects, or of such part thereof as it sees fit,
among such of the creditors as have proved their claims, in proportion to
the respective amount of their said debts. In addition to all expenses
necessarily incurred by him in the execution of his trust, in any case,
the assignee shall be entitled to an allowance for his services in such
case, on all moneys received and paid out by him therein, for any sum not
exceeding one thousand dollars, five per centum thereon; for any larger
sum, not exceeding five thousand dollars, two and a half per centum on
the excess over one thousand dollars ; and for any larger sum one per cen-
tum on the excess over five thousand dollars; and if, at any time, there
shall not be in his hands a sufficient amount of money to defray the necessary
expenses required for the further execution of his trust, he shall not be
obliged to proceed therein until the necessary funds are advanced or satis-
factorily secured to him. If, by accident, mistake, or other cause, without
fault of the assignee, either or both of the said second and third meetings
should not be held within the times limited, the court may, upon mo-
tion of an interested party, order such meetings, with like effect as to
the validity of the proceedings, as if the meeting had been duly held.
In the order for a dividend, under this section, the following claims shall
be entitled to priority or preference, and to be first paid in full in the
following order:
First. The fees, costs and expenses of suits, and the several pioceed-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 475
ings in bankruptcy under this act, and for the custody of property, as
herein provided.
Second. All debts due to the United States, and all taxes and assess-
ments under the laws thereof.
Third. All debts due to the State in which the proceedings in bank-
ruptcy are pending, and all taxes and assessments made under the laws
of such State.
Fourth. Wages due to any operative, clerk, or house servant, to an
amount not exceeding fifty dollars for labor performed within six months
next preceding the first publication of the notice of proceedings in bank-
ruptcy.
Fitfh. All debts due to any persons who> by the laws of the United
States, are or may be entitled to a priority or preference, in like man-
ner as if this act had not been passed: Always provided, That nothing
contained in this act shall interfere with the assessment and collection of
taxes by the authority of the United States or any State.
OF THE bankrupt's DISCHARGE AND ITS EFFECT.
Sec 29. And be it further enacted, That at any time after the expira-
tion of six months from the adjudication of bankruptcy, or if no
debts have been proved against the bankrupt, or if no assets have come
to the hands of the assignee, at any time after the expiration of sixty
days, and within one year from the adjudication of bankruptcy, the bank-
rupt may apply to the court for a discharge from his debts, and the
court shall thereupon order notice to be given by mail to all creditors
who have proved their debts, and by publication at least once a week in
such newspapers as the court shall designate, due regard being had to
the general circulation of the same in the district, or in that portion of
the district in which the bankrupt and his creditors shall reside, to ap-
pear on a day appointed for that purpose, and show cause why a dis-
charge should not be granted to the bankrupt. No discharge shall be
granted, or, if granted, be valid, if the bankrupt has wilfully sworn falsely
in his affidavit annexed to his petition, schedule, or inventory, or upon any
examination in the course of the proceedings in bankruptcy, in relation
to any material fact concerning his estate or his debts, or to any other
material fact; or if he has concealed any part of his estate or effects, or
any books or writings relating thereto, or if he has been guilty of any fraud
or negligence in the care, custody, or delivery to the assignee of the property
belonging to him at the time of the presentation of his petition and inven-
tory, excepting such property as he is permitted to retain under the pro-
visions of this act, or if he has caused, permitted, or suffered any loss,
waste, or destruction thereof; or if, within four months before the com-
mencement of such proceedings, he has procured his lands, goods, money.
476 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
or chattels to be attached, sequestered, or seized on execution; or if,
since the passage of this act, he has destroyed, mutilated, altered, or falsi-
fied any of his books, documents, papers, writings, or securities, or has
made or been privy to the making of any false or fraudulent entry in
any book of account or other document, with intent to defraud his credi-
tors; or has removed or caused to be removed any part of his property
from the district, with intent to defraud his creditors; or if he has given
any fraudulent preference contrary to the provisions of this act, or made
any fraudulent payment, gift, transfer, conveyance, or assignment of any
part of his property, or has lost any part thereof in gaming, or has ad-
mitted a false or fictitious debt against his estate; or if, having knowl-
edge that any person has proved such false or fictitious debt, he has not
disclosed the same to his assignee within one month after such knowl-
edge; or if, being a merchant or tradesman, he has not, subsequently to
the passage of this act, kept proper books of account; or if he, or any
person in his behalf, has procured the assent of any creditor to the dis-
charge, or influenced the action of any creditor at any stage of the pro-
ceedings, by any pecuniary consideration or obligation; or if he has, in
contemplation of becoming bankrupt, made any pledge, payment, transfer,
assignment, or conveyance of any part of his property, directly or in-
directly, absolutely or conditionally, for the purpose of preferring any
creditor or person having a claim against him, or who is or may be
under liability for him, or for the purpose of preventing the property from
coming into the hands of the assignee, or of being distributed under this
act in satisfaction of his debts; or if he has been convicted of any mis-
demeanor under this act, or has been guilty of any fraud whatever con-
trary to the true intent of this act; and before any discharge is granted,
the bankrupt shall take and subscribe an oath to the effect that he has
not done, suffered, or been pri\^ to any act, matter, or thing specified in
this act as a ground for withholding such discharge, or as invalidating
such discharge if granted.
Sec 30. And be it further enacted, That no person who shall have
been discharged under this act, and shall afterwards become bankrupt,
on his own application shall be again entitled to a discharge, whose estate
is insufficient to pay seventy per centum of the debts proved against it,
unless the assent in writing of three-fourths in value of his creditors
who have proved their claims is filed at or before the time of application
for discharge. But a bankrupt who shall prove to the satisfaction of the
court that he has paid all the debts owing by him at the time of any
previous bankruptcy, or who has been voluntarily released therefrom by
his creditors, shall be entitled to a discharge in the same manner and
with the same effect as if he had not previously been bankrupt.
Sec 31. And be it further enacted, That any creditor opposing the
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 477
discharge of any bankrupt may file a specification in writing of the grounds
of his opposition, and the court may in its discretion order any question
of fact so presented to be tried at a stated session of the district court.
Sec. 32. And be it further enacted. That if it shall appear to the
court that the bankrupt has in all things conformed to his duty under
this act, and that he is entitled, under the provisions thereof, to receive a
discharge, the court shall grant him a discharge from all his debts except
as hereinafter provided, and shall give him a certificate thereof under the
seal of the court, in substance as follows:
District court of the United States, District of
Whereas has been duly adjudged a bankrupt under the act af
Congress establishing a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the
United States, and appears to have conformed to all the requirements of
law in that behalf, it is therefore ordered by the court that said be
forever discharged from all debts and claims which by said act are made
provable against his estate, and which existed on the day of
,on which day the petition for adjudication was filed by (or
against) him; excepting such debts, if any, as are by said act excepted
from the operation of a discharge in bankruptcy. Given under my hand
and the seal of the court at , in the said district, this day
of . A. D.
[Seal.] , Judge.
Sec. 33. And be it further enacted. That no debt created by the
fraud or embezzlement of the bankrupt, or by his defalcation as a public
oflBcer, or while acting in any fiduciary character, shall be discharged
under this act; but the debt may be proved, and the dividend thereon
shall be a payment on account of said debt; and no discharge granted
under this act shall release, discharge or affect any person liable for the
same debt for or with the bankrupt, either as partner, joint contractor,
indorser, surety, or otherwise. And in all proceedings in bankruptcy com-
menced after one year from the time this act shall go into operation,
no discharge shall be granted to a debtor whose assets do not pay fifty
per centum of the claims against his estate, unless the assent in writing
of a majority in number and value of his creditors who have proved their
claims is filed in the case at or before the time of application for dis-
charge.
Sec. 34. And be it further enacted, That a discharge duly granted
under this act shall, with the exceptions aforesaid, release the bankrupt
from all debts, claims, liabilities, and demands which were or might have
been proved against his estate in bankruptcy, and may be pleaded, by
a simple averment that on the day of its date such discharge was granted
to him, setting the same forth in haec verba, as a full and complete bar
to all suits brought on any such debts, claims, liabilities, or demands.
478 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
and the certificate shall be conclusive evidence in favor of such bankrupt
of the fact and the regularity of such discharge: Always provided, That
any creditor or creditors of said bankrupt, whose debt was proved or
provable against the estate in bankruptcy, who shall see fit to contest
the validity of said discharge on the ground that it was fraudulently
obtained, may, at any time within two years after the date' thereof, apply
to the court which granted it to set aside and annul the same. Said ap-
plication shall be in writing, shall specify which, in particular, of the
several acts mentioned in section twenty-nine it is intended to give evi-
dence of against the bankrupt, setting forth the grounds of avoidance,
and no evidence shall be admitted as to any other of the said acts; but
said application shall be subject to amendment at the discretion of the
court The court shall cause reasonable notice of said application to be
given to said bankrupt, and order him to appear and answer the same,
within such time as to the court shall seem fit and proper. If, upon the
hearing of said parties, the court shall find that the fraudulent acts, or
any of them, set forth as aforesaid by said creditor or creditors against
the bankrupt are proved, and that said creditor or creditors had no
knowledge of the same until after the granting of said discharge, judg-
ment shall be given in favor of said creditor or creditors, and the dis-
charge of said bankrupt shall be set aside and annulled. But if said
court shall find that said fraudulent acts, and all of them, set forth as
aforesaid, are not proved, or that they were known to said creditor or
creditors before the granting of said discharge, then judgment shall be
rendered in favor of the bankrupt, and the validity of his discharge shall
not be affected by said proceedings.
PREFERENCES AND FRAUDtH-ENT CONVEYANCES DECLARED VOID.
Sec 35. And be it further enacted. That if any person, being in-
solvent, or in contemplation of insolvency, within four months before
the filing of the petition by or against him, with a view to give a prefer-
ence to any creditor or person having a claim against him, or who is
under any liability for him, procures any part of his property to be at-
tached, sequestered, or seized on execution, or makes any payment,
pledge, assignment, transfer, or conveyance of any part of his property
either directly or indirectly, absolutely or conditionally, the person re-
ceiving such payment, pledge, assignment, transfer or conveyance, or
to be benefited thereby, or by such attachment, having reasonable cause
to believe such person is insolvent, and that such attachment, payment,
pledge, assignment, or conveyance is made in fraud of the provisions of
this act, the same shall be void, and the assignee may recover the prop-
erty, or the value of it, from the person so receiving it, or so to be bene-
fited; and \1 any person being insolvent, or in contemplation of insol-
vency or bankruptcy, within six months before the filing of the petition
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 479
by or against him, makes any payment, sale, assignment, transfer, con-
veyance, or other disposition of any part of his property to any person
who then has reasonable cause to believe him to be insolvent, or to be
acting in contemplation of insolvency, and that such payment, sale, as-
signment, transfer, or other conveyance, is made with a view to prevent
his pioperty from coming to his assignee in bankruptcy, or to prevent the
same from being distributed under this act, or to defeat the object of,
or in any way impair, hinder, impede or delay the operation and effect
of, or to evade any of the provisions of this act, the sale, assignment,
transfer, or conveyance shall be void, and the assignee may recover the
property, or the value thereof, as assets of the bankrupt. And if such
sale, assignment, tr.-.nsfer, or conveyance is not made in the usual and
ordinary course of business of the debtor, the fact shall be prima facie
evidence of fraud. Any contract, covenant, or security made or given by
a bankrupt or other person with, or in trust for, any creditor for securing
the payment of any money as a consideration for or with intent to in-
duce the creditor to forbear opposing the application for discharge of
the bankrupt shall be void; and if any creditor shall obtain any sum of
money or other goods, chattels, or security from any person as an induce-
ment for forbearing to oppose, or consenting to such application for
discharge, every creditor so offending shall forfeit all right to any share
or dividend in the estate of the bankrupt, and shall also forfeit double
the value or amount of such money, goods, chattels, or security so ob-
tained, to be recovered by the assignee for the benefit of the estate.
BANKRUPTCY OF PARTNERSHIPS AND OF CORPORATIONS.
Sec. 36. And be it further enacted. That where two or more persons
who are partners in trade shall be adjudged bankrupt, either on the peti-
tion of such partners or any one of them, or on the petition of any creditor
of the partners, a warrant shall issue in the manner provided by this act,
upon which all the joint stock and property of the copartnership, and also
all the separate estate of each of the partners, shall be taken, excepting
such parts thereof as are hereinbefore excepted; and all the creditors of
the company, and the separate creditors of each partner, shall be allowed
to prove their respective debts ; and the assignee shall be chosen by the
creditors of the company, and shall also keep separate accounts of the
joint stock or property of the copartnership and of the separate estate
of each member thereof; and after deducting out of the whole amount
received by such assignee the whole of the expenses and disbursements,
the net proceeds of the joint stock shall be appropriated to pay the credi-
tors of the copartnership, and the net proceeds of the separate estate of
each partner shall be appropriated to pay his separate creditors; and if
there shall be any balance of the separate estate of any partner, after the
pajmen": of his separate debts, such balance shall be added to the joint
480 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
stock for the payment of the joint creditors; and if there shall be any bal-
ance of the joint stock after payment of the joint debts, such balance
shall be divided and appropriated to and among the separate estates of the
several partners, according to their respective right and interest therein,
and as it would have been if the partnership had been dissolved without
any bankruptcy; and the sum so appropriated to the separate estate of
each partner shall be applied to the payment of his separate debts; and
the certificate of discharge shall be granted or refused to each partner
as the same would or ought to be if the proceedings had been against
him alone under this act ; and in all other respects the proceedings against
partners shall be conducted in the like manner as if they had been com-
menced and prosecuted against one person alone. If such copartners re-
side in different districts, that court in which the petition is first filed shall
retain exclusive jurisdiction over the case.
Sec 37. 'And be it further enacted, That the provisions of this act
shall apply to all moneyed, business, or commercial corporations and
joint-stock companies, and that upon the petition of any officer of any
such corporation or company, duly authorized by a vote of a majority
of the corporators present at any legal meeting called for the purpose,
or upon the petition of any creditor or creditors of such corporation
or company, made and presented in the manner hereinafter provided in
respect to debtors, the like proceedings shall be had and taken as are
hereinafter provided in the case of debtors; and all the provisions of
this act which apply to the debtor, or set forth his duties in regard to
furnishing schedules and inventories, executing papers, submitting to ex-
aminations, disclosing, making over, secreting, concealing, conveying, as-
signing, or paying away his money or property, shall in like manner, and
with like force, effect and penalties, apply to each and every officer of
such corporation or company in relation to the same matters concerning
the corporation or company, and the money and property thereof. All
payments, conveyances, and assignments declared fraudulent and void
by this act when made by a debtor, shall in like manner, and to the like
extent, and with like remedies, be fraudulent and void when made by
a corporation or company. No allowance or discharge shall be granted
to any corporation or joint-stock company, or to any person or officer
or member thereof: Provided, That whenever any corporation by pro-
ceedings under this act shall be declared bankrupt, all his property and
assets shall be distributed to the creditors of such corporation in the
manner provided in this act in respect to natural persons.
OF DATES AND DEPOSITIONS.
Sec. 38. 'And be it further enacted, That the filing of a petition for
adjudication in bankruptcy, either by a debtor in his own behalf, or by
any creditor against a debtor, upon which an order may be issued by
^'ORMER BANltRUPTCY ACTS. 481
the court, or by a register in the manner provided in section four, shall
be deemed and taken to be the commencement of proceedings in bank-
ruptcy under this act ; the proceedings in all cases in bankruptcy shall
be deemed matters of record, but the same shall not be required to be
recorded at large, but shall be carefully filed, kept, and numbered in the
office of the clerk of the court, and a docket only, or short memorandum
thereof, kept in books to be provided for that purpose which shall be
open to public inspection. Copies of such records, duly certified under
the seal of the court, shall in all cases be prima facie evidence of the
facts therein stated.* Evidence or examinations in any of the proceedings
under this act may be taken before the court, or a register in bank-
ruptcy, viva voce, or in writing, before a commissioner of the circuit
court, or by affidavit, or on commission, and the court may direct a
reference to a register in bankruptcy, or other suitable person, to take
and certify such examination, and may compel the attendance of wit-
nesses, the production of books and papers, and the giving of testimony,
in the same manner as in suits in equity in the circuit court.
INVOLUNTARY BANKRUPTCY.
Sec. 39. And be it further enacted, That any person residing and
owing debts as aforesaid, who, after the passage of this act, shall depart
from the State, District, or Territory, of which he is an inhabitant, with
intent to defraud his creditors, or, being absent, shall, with such intent,
remain absent; or shall conceal himself to avoid the service of legal
process in any action for the recovery of a debt or demand provable un-
der this act; or shall conceal or remove any of his property to avoid its
being attached, taken, or sequestered on legal process; or shall make
any assignment, gift, sale, conveyance or transfer of his estate, property,
rights, or credits, either within the United States or elsewhere, with in-
tent to delay, defraud, or hinder his creditors; or who has been ar-
rested and held in custody under or by virtue of mesne process of exe-
cution, issued out of any court of any State, District, or Territory, within
v;hich such debtor resides or has property, founded upon a demand in
its nature provable against a bankrupt's estate under this act, and for
a sum exceeding one hundred dollars, and such process is remaining in
force and not discharged by payment, or in any other manner provided
by the law of such State, District, or Territory applicable thereto, for a
period of seven days; or has been actually imprisoned for more than
seven days in a civil action, founded on contract, for the sum of one
hundred dollars or upwards; or who, being bankrupt or insolvent, or
in contemplation of bankruptcy or insolvency, shall make any payment,
gift, grant, sale, conveyance or transfer of money, or other property, es-
tate, rights or credits, or give any warrant to confess judgment, or
procure or suffer his property to be taken on legal process, with intent to
482 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
give a preference to one or more of his creditors, or to any person or
persons who are or may be liable for him as indorsers, bail, sureties, or
otherwise, or with the intent, by such disposition of his property, to
defeat or delay the operation of this act; or who, being a banker, mer-
chant, or trader, has fraudulently stopped or suspended and not resumed
payment of his commercial paper, within a period of fourteen days, shall
be deemed to have committed an act of bankruptcy, and, subject to the
conditions hereinafter prescribed, shall be adjudged a bankrupt, on the
petition of one or more of his creditors, the aggregate of whose debts
provable under this act amount to at least two hundred and fifty dollars,
provided such petition is brought within six months after the act of bank-
ruptcy shall have been committed. And if such person shall be adjudged
a bankrupt, the assignee may recover back the money or other property
so paid, conveyed, sold, assigned, or transferred contrary to this act,
provided the person receiving such payment or conveyance had reasonable
cause to believe that a fraud on this act was intended, or that the debtor
was insolvent, and such creditor shall not be allowed to prove his debt
in bankruptcy.
Sec 40. And be it further enacted, That upon the filing of the peti-
tion authorized by the next preceding section, if it shall appear that suf-
ficient grounds exist therefor, the court shall direct the entry of an order
requiring the debtor to appear and show cause, at a court of bankruptcy
to be holden at a time to be specified in the order, not less than five
days from the service thereofj why the prayer of the petition should not
be granted; and may also, by its injunction, restrain the debtor, and any
other person, in the mean time, from making any transfer or disposition
of any part of the debtor's property not excepted by this act from the
operation thereof and from any interference therewith; and if it shall
appear that there is probable cause for believing that the debtor is about
to leave the district, or to remove or conceal his goods and chattels or
his evidence of property, or make any fraudulent conveyance or dispo-
sition thereof, the court may issue a warrant to the marshal of the dis-
trict, commanding him to arrest the alleged bankrupt and him safely
keep, unless he shall give bail to the satisfaction of the court for his ap-
pearance from time to time, as required by the court, until the decision
of the court upon the petition or the further order of the court, and forth-
with to take possession provisionally of all the property and eflfects of the
debtor, and safely keep the same until the further order of the court. A
copy of the petition and of such order to show cause shall be served on such
debtor by delivering the same to him personally, or leaving the same at
his last or usual place of abode; or, if such debtor cannot be found, or
his place of residence ascertained, service shall be made by publication,
in such manner as the judge may direct. No further proceedings, un-
less the debtor appear and consent thereto, shall be had until proof
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 483
shall have been given, to the satisfaction of the court, of such service
or publication ; and if such proof be not given on the return day of such
order, the proceedings shall be adjourned and an order made that the
notice be forthwith so served or published.
Sec 41. And be it further enacted, That on such return day or ad-
journed day, if the notice has been duly served or published, or shall be
waived by the appearance and consent of the debtor, the court shall pro-
ceed summarily to hear the allegations of the petitioner and debtor, and
may adjourn the proceedings from time to time, on good cause shown,
and shall, if the debtor on the same day so demand in writing, order
a trial by jury at the first term of the court at which a jury shall be in
attendance, to ascertain the fact of such alleged bankruptcy; and if, upon
such hearing or trial, the debtor proves to the satisfaction of the court
or of the jury, as the case may be, that the facts set forth in the petition
are not true, or that the debtor has paid and satisfied all liens upon
his property in case the existence of such liens were the sole ground of
the proceeding, the proceedings shall be dismissed and the respondent
shall recover costs.
Sec 42. Atid be it further enacted, That if the facts set forth in the
petition are found to be true, or if default be made by the debtor to ap-
pear pursuant to the order, upon due proof of service thereof being made,
the court shall adjudge the debtor to be a bankrupt, and, as such, sub-
ject to the provisions of this act, and shall forthwith issue a warrant to
take possession of the estate of the debtor. The warrant shall be di-
rected, and the property of the debtor shall be taken thereon, and shall
be assigned and distributed in the same manner and with similar pro-
ceedings to those hereinbefore provided for the taking possession, as-
signment, and distribution of the property of the debtor upon his own
petition. The order of adjudication of bankruptcy shall require the bank-
rupt forthwith, or within such number of days, not exceeding five after
the date of the order or notice thereof, as shall by the order be pre-
scribed, to make and deliver, or transmit by mail, post paid, to the mes-
senger, a schedule of the creditors and an inventory of his estate in the
form and verified in the manner required of a petitioning debtor by sec-
tion thirteen. If the debtor has failed to appear in person, or by at-
torney, a certified copy of the adjudication shall be forthwith served on
him by delivery or publication in the manner hereinbefore provided for
the service of the order to show cause; and if the bankrupt is absent or
cannot be found, such schedule and inventory shall be prepared by the
messenger and the assignee from the best information they can obtain.
If the petitioning creditor shall not appear and proceed on the return
day, or adjourned day, the court may, upon the petition of any other
creditor, to the required amount, proceed to adjudicate on such petition,
without requiring a new service or publication of notice to the debtor.
484 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
OF SUPERSEDING THE BANKRUPT PROCEEDINGS BY ARRANGEMENT.
Sec 43. And be it further enacted, That if at the first meeting of
creditors, or at any meeting of creditors to be specially called for that
purpose, and of which previous notice shall have been given for such
length of time and in such manner as the court may direct, three-fourths
in value of the creditors whose claims have been proved shall determine
and resolve that it is for the interest of the general body of the creditors
that the estate of the bankrupt should be wound up and settled, and dis-
tribution made among the creditors by trustees, under the inspection and
direction of a committee of the creditors, it shall be lawful for the credi-
tors to certify and report such resolution to the court, and to nominate
one or more trustees to take and hold and distribute the estate, under
the direction of such committee. If it shall appear to the court, after
hearing the bankrupt and such creditors as may desire to be heard, that
the resolution was duly passed and that the interests of the creditors
will be promoted thereby, it shall confirm the same; and upon the execu-
tion and filing by or on behalf of three-fourths in value of all the credi-
tors whose claims have been proved of a consent that the estate of the
bankrupt be wound up and settled by said trustees according to the terms
of such resolution, the bankrupt, or his assignee in bankruptcy, if ap-
pointed, as the case may be, shall, under the direction of the court, and
under oath, convey, transfer, and deliver all the property and estate of
the bankrupt to the said trustee or trustees, who shall, upon such con-
veyance and transfer, have and hold the same in the same manner, and
with the same powers and rights, in all respects, as the bankrupt would
have had or held the same if no proceedings in bankruptcy had been
taken, or as the assignee in bankruptcy would have done had such reso-
lution not been passed; and such consent and the proceedings thereunder
shall be as binding in all respects on any creditor whose debt is prov-
able, who has not signed the same, as if he had signed it, and on any
creditor, whose debt, if provable, is not proved, as if he had proved
it; and the court, by order, shall direct all acts and things needful to
be done to carry into effect such resolution of the creditors, and the
said trustees shall proceed to wind up and settle the estate under the di-
rection and inspection of such committee of the creditors, for the equal
benefit of all such creditors, and the winding up and settlement of any
estate under the provisions of this section shall be deemed to be pro-
ceedings in bankruptcy under this act; and the said trustees shall have
all the rights and powers of assignees in bankruptcy. The court, on the
application of such trustees, shall have power to summon and examine,
on oath or otherwise, the bankrupt, and any creditor, and any person
indebted to the estate, or known or suspected of having any of the es-
tate in his possession, or any other person whose examination may be
material or necessary to aid the trustees in the execution of their trust,
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 485
and to compel the attendance of such persons and the production of books
and papers in the same manner as in other proceedings in bankruptcy
under this act; and the bankrupt shall have the like right to apply for
and obtain a discharge after the passage of such resolution and the ap-
pointment of such trustees as if such resolution had not been passed,
and as if all the proceedings had continued in the manner provided in
the preceding sections of this act. If the resolution shall not be duly
reported, or the consent of the creditors shall not be duly filed, or if,
upon its filing, the court shall not think fit to approve thereof, the bank-
ruptcy shall proceed as though no resolution had been passed, and the
court may make all necessary orders for resuming the proceedings. And
the period of time which shall have elapsed between the date of the
resolution and the date of the order for resuming proceedings shall not
be reckoned in calculating periods of time prescribed by this act.
PENALTIES AGAINST BANKRUPTS.
Sec 44. And be it further enacted, That from and after the passage
of this act, if any debtor or bankrupt shall, after the commencement of
proceedings in bankruptcy, secrete or conceal any property belonging to
his estate, or part with, conceal, or destroy, alter, mutilate, or falsify,
or cause to be concealed, destroyed, altered, mutilated, or falsified, any
book, deed, document, or writing relating thereto, or remove, or cause
to be removed, the same or any part thereof, out of the district, or other-
wise dispose of any part thereof, with intent to prevent it from com-
ing into the possession of the assignee in bankruptcy, or to hinder, im-
pede, or delay either of them in recovering or receiving the same, or
make any payment, gift, sale, assignment, transfer, or conveyance of any
property belonging to his estate with the like intent, or spends any part
thereof in gaming; or shall, with intent to defraud, wilfully and fraudu-
lently conceal from his assignee or omit from his schedule any property
or effects whatsoever; or if, in case of any person having, to his knowl-
edge or belief, proved a false or fictitious debt against his estate, he
shall fail to disclose the same to his assignee within one month after
coming to the knowledge or belief thereof, or shall attempt to account
for any of his property by fictitious losses or expenses; or shall, within
three months before the commencement of proceedings in bankruptcy,
under the false color and pretense of carrying on business and dealing in
the ordinary course of trade, obtain on credit from any person any goods
or chattels with intent to defraud; or shall, with intent to defraud his
creditors, within three months next before the commencement of pro-
ceedings in bankruptcy, pawn, pledge, or dispose of, otherwise than by
bona fide transactions in the ordinary way of his trade, any of his goods
or chattels which have been obtained on credit and remain unpaid for,
he shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction thereof
486 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
in any court of the United States, shall be punished by imprisonment,
with or without hard labor, for a term not exceeding three years.
PENALTIES AGAINST OFFICERS.
Sec 45. "And be it further enacted, That if any judge, register, clerk,
marshal, messenger, assignee, or any other officer of the several courts
of bankruptcy, shall, for anything done or pretended to be done under this
act, or under color of doing an>-thing thereunder, wilfully demand or
take, or appoint or allow any person whatever to take for him or on his
account, or for or on account of any other person, or in trust for him
or for any other person, any fee, emolument, gratuity, sum of money,
or anything of value whatever, other than is allowed by this act, or which
shall be allowed under the authority thereof, such person, when convicted
thereof, shall forfeit and pay the sum of not less than three hundred dol-
lars and not exceeding five hundred dollars, and be imprisoned not ex-
ceeding three years.
Sec. 46. And be it further enacted, That if any person shall forge
the signature of a judge, register, or other officer of the court, or shall
forge or counterfeit the seal of the court, or knowingly concur in using
any such forged or counterfeit signature or seal, for the purpose of au-
thenticating any proceeding or document, or shall tender in evidence any
such proceeding or document with a false or counterfeit signature of any
such judge, register, or other officer, or a false or counterfeit seal of the
court, subscribed or attached thereto, knowing such signature or seal
to be false or counterfeit, any such person shall be guilty of felony, and
upon conviction thereof shall be liable to fine of not less than five hun-
dred dollars, and not more than five thousand dollars, and to be impris-
oned not exceeding five years, at the discretion of the court.
FEES AND COSTS.
Sec 47. And be it further enacted, That in each case there shall be
allowed and paid, in addition to the fees of the clerk of the court as
now established by law, or as may be established by general order, un-
der the provisions of this act, for fees in bankruptcy, the following fees,
which shall be applied to the payment for the services of the registers:
For issuing every warrant, two dollars.
For each day in which a meeting is held, three dollars.
For each order for a dividend, three dollars.
For every order substituting an arrangement by trust deed for bank-
ruptcy, two dollars.
For every bond with sureties, two dollars.
For every application for any meeting in any matter under this act,
one dollar.
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 487
For every day's service while actually employed under a special order
of the court, a sum not exceeding five dollars, to be allowed by the
court
For taking depositions, the fees now allowed by law.
For every discharge when there is no opposition, two dollars.
Such fees shall have priority of payment over all other claims out of
the estate, and before a warrant issues the petitioner shall deposit with
the senior register of the court, or with the clerk, to be delivered to
the register, fifty dollars as security for the payment thereof; and if
there are not sufficient assets for the payment of the fees, the person
upon whose petition the warrant is issued shall pay the same, and the
court may issue an execution against him to compel payment to the
register.
Before any dividend is ordered the assignee shall pay out of the es-
tate to the messenger the following fees, and no more:
First. For service of warrant, two dollars.
Second. For all necessary travel, at the rate of five cents a mile,
each way.
Third. For each written note to creditor named in the schedule, ten
cents.
Fourth. For custody of property, publication of notices, and other
services, his actual and necessary expenses upon returning the same in
specific items, and making oath that they have been actually incurred and
paid by him, and are just and reasonable, the same to be taxed or ad-
justed by the court, and the oath of the messenger shall not be conclusive
as to the necessity of said expenses.
For cause shown, and upon hearing thereon, such further allowance
may be made as the court, in its discretion, may determine.
The enumeration of the foregoing fees shall not prevent the judges,
who shall frame general rules and orders in accordance with the provis-
ions of section ten, from prescribing a tariff of fees for all other services
of the officers of courts of bankruptcy, or from reducing the fees pre-
scribed in this section in classes of cases to be named in their rules and
orders.
OF MEANING OF TERMS AND COMPUTATION OF TIME.
Sec 48. 'And be it further enacted, That the word "assignee" and
the word "creditor" shall include the plural also; and the word "mes-
senger" shall include his assistant or assistants, except in the provision
for the fees of that officer. The word "marshal" shall include the mar-
shal's deputies, the word "person" shall also include "corporation," and
the word "oath" shall include "affirmation." And in all cases in which
488 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
any particular number of daj's is prescribed by this act, or shall be men-
tioned in any rule or order of court or general order which shall at any
time be made under this act, for the doing of any act, or for any other
purpose, the same shall be reckoned, in the absence of any expression to
the contrary, exclusive of the first and inclusive of the last day, unless
the last day, shall fall on a Sunday, Christmas day, or on any day ap-
pointed by the President of the United States as a day of public fast or
thanksgiving, or on the fourth of July, in which case the time shall be
reckoned exclusive of that day also.
Sec 49. And be it further enacted. That all the jurisdiction, power,
and authority conferred upon and vested in the district court of the
United States by this act in cases in bankruptcy are hereby conferred
upon and vested in the supreme court of the District of Columbia, and
in and upon the supreme courts of the several Territories of the United
States, when the bankrupt resides in the said District of Columbia or
in either of the said Territories. And in those judicial districts which
are not within any organized circuit of the United States the power and
jurisdiction of a circuit court in bankruptcy may be exercised by the
district judge.
Sec 50. And be it further enacted. That this act shall commence and
take effect, as to the appointment of the officers created hereby and the
promulgation of rules and general orders, from and after the date of
its approval: Provided, That no petition or other proceeding under this
act shall be filed, received, or commenced before the first day of June,
aimo Domini eighteen hundred and sixty-seven.
AMENDMENT OF JULY 27th, 1868.
AN ACT in amendment of an act entitled "An act to establish a uniform
system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," approved March
second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That the provisions
of second clause of the thirty-third section of said act shall not apply to
the cases of proceedings in bankrup[t]cy commenced prior to the first
day of January, eighteen hundred and sixty-nine, and the time during
which the operation of the provisions of said clause is postponed shall
be extended until said first day of January, eighteen hundred and sixty-
nine. And said clause is hereby so amended as to read as follows: In
all proceedings in bankruptcy commenced after the first day of January,
eighteen hundred and sixty-nine, no discharge shall be granted to a
debtor whose assets shall not be equal to fifty per centum of the claims
proved against his estate upon which he shall be liable as the principal
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 489
debtor, unless the assent in writing of a majority in number and value
of his creditors to whom he shall have become liable as principal debtor,
and who shall have proved their claims, be filed in the case at or before
the time of the hearing of the application for discharge.
Sec. 2. And be it further enacted, That said act be further amended
as follows: The phrase "presented or defended" in the fourteenth sec-
tion of said act shall read "prosecuted or defended;" the phrase "non-
resident debtors" in line five, section twenty-two, of the act as printed
in the Statutes at Large, shall read "non-resident creditors;" that the
word "or" in the next to the last line of the thirty-ninth section of the
act shall read "and;" that the phrase "section thirteen" in the forty-sec-
ond section of said act shall read "section eleven;" and the phrase "or
spends any part thereof in gaming" in the forty-fourth section of said act
shall read "or shall spend any part thereof in gaming;" and that the
words "with the senior register, or" and the phrase "to be delivered to
the register" in the forty-seventh section of said act be stricken out.
Sec. 3. And be it further enacted, That registers in bankruptcy shall
have power to administer oaths in all cases and in relation to all matters
in which oaths may be administered by commissioners of the circuit courts
of the United States, and such commissioners may take proof of debts
in bankruptcy in all cases, subject to the revision of such proofs by the
register and by the court according to the provisions of said act.
AMENDMENT OF JUNE 30th, 1870.
AN ACT to amend an act entitled "An act to establish a uniform sys-
tem of bankruptcy throughout the United States," approved March 2,
1867.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That the jurisdiction
conferred upon the supreme courts of the Territories by the act to which
this is in amendment may be exercised, upon petitions regularly filed in
that court, by either of the justices thereof while holding the district
court in the district in which the petitioner or the alleged bankrupt re-
sides, and said several supreme courts shall have the same supervisory
jurisdiction over all acts and decisions of each justice thereof as is con-
ferred upon the circuit courts of the United States over proceedings in
the district courts of the United States by the second section of said act
Sec. 2. And be it further enacted, That in case of a vacancy in the
office of district judge in any district, or in case any district judge shall,
from sickness, absence, or other disability, be unable to act, the circuit
judge of the circuit in whicli such district in included may make, during
such disability or vacancy, all necessary rules and orders preparatory to
490 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
the final hearing of all causes in bankruptcy, and cause the same to be
entered or issued, as the case may require, by the clerk of the district
court.
AMENDMENT OF JULY 14th, 1870.
AN ACT in amendment of the act entitled "An act establishing an uni-
form system of bankruptcy throughout the United States."
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That the provisions of
the second clause of the thirty-third section of said act, as amended by
the first section of an act in amendment thereof, approved July twenty-
seven, eighteen hundred and sixty-eight, shall not apply to those debts
from which the bankrupt seeks a discharge which were contracted prior
to the first day of January, eighteen hundred and sixty-nine.
Sec. 2. And be it further enacted. That the clause in the thirty-ninth
section of said act which now reads "or who, being a banker, merchant,
or trader, has fraudulently stopped or suspended and not resumed pay-
ment of his commerical paper within a period of fourteen days," shall
be amended so as to read as follows: "or who, being a banker, broker,
merchant, trader, manufacturer, or miner, has fraudulently stopped pay-
ment, or who has stopped or suspended and not resumed payment of his
commercial paper within a period of fourteen days."
1.
AMENDMENTS OF JUNE 8th, 1872.
AN ACT to amend an act entitled "An act to establish a uniform system
of bankruptcy throughout the United States."
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled. That the first proviso
in section fourteen of an act approved March second, eighteen hundred
and sixty-seven, entitled "An act to establish a uniform system of bank-
ruptcy throughout the United States," be amended by striking out the
words "eighteen hundred and sixty-four," and inserting in lieu thereof
"eighteen hundred and seventy-one."
AN ACT to declare the true intent and meaning of section two of an
act entitled "An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy
throughout the United States," approved March two, eighteen hun-
dred and sixty-seven.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 491
States of America in Congress assembled, That the powers and jurisdic-
tion granted to the several circuit courts of the United States, or any
justice thereof, by section two of an act entitled "An act to establish a
uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," approved
March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, may be exercised in
any district in which the powers or jurisdiction of a circuit court have
been or may be conferred on the district court for such district, as if no
such powers or jurisdiction had been conferred on such district court;
it being the true intent and meaning of said act that the system of
bankruptcy thereby established shall be uniform throughout the United
States.
AMENDAIENT OF FEBRUARY 13th, 1873.
AN ACT to amend an act entitled "An act to establish a uniform system
of bankruptcy throughout the United States," approved March second,
eighteen hundred and sixty-seven.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled. That whenever a corporation
created by the laws of any State, whose business is carried on wholly
within the State creating the same, and also any insurance company so
created, whether all its business shall be carried on in such State or not,
has had proceedings duly commenced against such corporation or com-
pany before the courts of such State for the purpose of winding up the
affairs of such corporation or company and dividing its assets ratably
among its creditors and lawfully among those entitled thereto prior to
proceedings having been commenced against such corporation or com-
pany undc- the bankrupt laws of the United States, any order made,
or that shall be made, by such court agreeably to the State law for the
ratable distribution or payment of any dividend of assets. to the cred-
itors of such corporation or company while such State court shall remain
actually or constructively in possession or control of the assets of such
corporati)!! or company shall be deemed valid notwithstanding proceed-
ings in bankruptcy may have been commenced and be pending against
such corporation or company.
AMENDMENT OF MARCH 3rd, 1873.
AN ACT to declare the true intent and meaning of the act approved
June eight, eighteen hundred and seventy-two, amendatory of the
general bankrupt law.
Beit enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled. That it was the true intent and
meaning of an act approved June eighth, eighteen hundred and seventy-
492 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
two, entitled "An act to amend an act entitled 'An act to establish a
uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United States/ approved
March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven," that the exemptions
allowed the bankrupt by the said amendatory act should, and it is hereby
enacted that they shall, be the amount allowed by the constitution and
laws of each State, respectively, as existing in the year eighteen hun-
dred and seventy-one; and that such exemptions be valid against debts
contracted before the adoption and passage of such State constitution
and laws, as well as those contracted after the same, and against liens
by judgment or decree of any State court, any decision of any such court
rendered since the adoption and passage of such constitution ^nd laws
to the contrary notwithstanding.
AMENDMENT OF JUNE 22nd 1874.
AN ACT to amend and supplement an act entitled "An act to establish
a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United States," ap-
proved March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, and for other
purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled, That the act entitled "An act
to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout the United
States," approved March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, be
and the same is hereby, amended and supplemented as follows: That
the court may, in its discretion, on sufficient cause shown, and upon
notice and hearing, direct the receiver or assignee to take possession
of the property, and carry on the business of the debtor, or any part
thereof, under the direction of the court, when, in its judgment, the
interest of th«: estate as well as of the creditors will be promoted thereby,
but not for a period exceeding nine months from the time the debtor
shall have been declared a bankrupt: Provided, That such order shall
not be made until the court shall be satisfied that it is approved by a
majority in value of the creditors.
Sec 2. That section one of said act be, and it is hereby, amended by
adding thereto the following words: "Provided, That the court having
charge of the estate of any bankrupt may direct that any of the legal
assets or debts of the bankrupt, as contradistinguished from equitable
demands, shall, when such debt does not exceed five hundred dollars,
be collected in the courts of the State where such bankrupt resides
having jurisdiction of claims of such nature and amount."
Sec. 3. That section two of said act be, and it hereby is, amended by
striking out, in line ten, the words "the same," and inserting the word
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 493
"any"; and by adding next after the words "adverse interest," in line
twelve, the words "or owing any debt to such bankrupt."
Sec. 4. That unless otherwise ordered by the court, the assignee shall
sell the property of the bankrupt, whether real or personal, at public
auction, in such parts or parcels and at such times and places as shall
be best calculated to produce the greatest amount with the least
expense. All notices of public sales under this act by any assignee or
officer of the court shall be published once a week for three consecu-
tive weeks in the newspaper or newspapers, to be designated by the
judge, which, in his opinion, shall be best calculated to give general
notice of the sale. And the court, on the application of any party in
interest, shall have complete supervisory power over such sales, includ-
ing the power to set aside the same and to order a re-sale, so that the
property sold shall realize the largest sum. And the court may, in its
discretion, order any real estate of the bankrupt, or any part thereof,
to be sold for one-fourth cash at the time of sale, and the residue within
eighteen months in such installments as the court may direct, bearing
interest at the rate of seven per centum per annum, and secured by
proper mortgage or lien upon the property so sold. And it shall be the
duty of every assignee to keep a regular account of all moneys received
or expended by him as such assignee, to which account every creditor
shall, at reasonable times, have free access. If any assignee shall fail
or neglect to well and faithfully discharge his duties in the sale or dis-
position of property as above contemplated, it shall be the duty of the
court to remove such assignee, and he shall forfeit all fees and emolu-
ments to which he might be entitled in connection with such sale. And
if any assignee shall, in any manner, in violation of his duty aforesaid,
unfairly or wrongfully sell or dispose of, or in any manner fraudulently
or corruptly combine, conspire, or agree with any person or persons
with intent to unfairly or wrongfully sell or dispose of the property com-
mitted to his charge, he shall, upon proof thereof, be removed, and for-
feit all fees or other compensation for any and all services in connection
with such bankrupt's estate, and, upon conviction thereof before any
court of competent jurisdiction, shall be liable to a fine of not more than
ten thousand dollars, or imprisonment in the penitentiary for a term of
not exceeding two years, or both fine and imprisonment, at the discre-
tion of the court. And any person so combining, conspiring, or agree-
ing with such assignee for the purpose aforesaid shall, upon conviction,
be liable to a like punishment. That the assignee shall report, under
oath, to the court, at least as often as once in three months, the con-
dition of the estate in his charge, and the state of his accounts in de-
tail, and at all other times when the court, on motion or otherwise, shall
so order. And on any settlement of the accounts of any assignee, he
shall be required to account for all interest, benefit, or advantage re-
494 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
ceived, or in any manner agreed to be received directly or indirectly,
from the use, disposal, or proceeds of the bankrupt's estate. And he
shall be required, upon such settlement, to make and file in court an
aflSdavit declaring, according to the truth, whether he has or has not, as
the case may be, received, or is or is not, as the case may be, to receive,
directly or indirectly, any interest, benefit, or advantage from the use
or deposit of such funds; and such assignee may be examined orally
upon the same subject, and if he shall wilfully swear falsely, either in
such affidavit or examination, or to his report provided for in this sec-
tion, he shall be deemed to be guilty of perjury, and, on conviction
thereof, be punished by imprisonment in the penitentiary not less than
one and not more than five years.
Sec 5. That section eleven of said act be amended by striking out
the words "as the warrant specifies," where they first occur, and insert-
ing the words "as the marshal shall select, not exceeding two" ; and in-
serting after the word "specifies" where it last occurs the words "But
whenever the creditors of the bankrupt are so numerous as to make any
notice now required by law to them, by mail or otherwise, a great and
disproportionate expense to the estate, the court may, in lieu thereof, in
its discretion, order such notice to be given by publication in a news-
paper or newspapers, to all such creditors whose claims, as reported, do
not exceed the sums, respectively, of fifty dollars."
Sec 6. That the first clause of section twenty of said act be amended
by adding, at the end thereof, the words "or in cases of compulsory bank-
ruptcy, after the act of bankruptcy upon or in respect of which the ad-
judication shall be made, and with a view of making such set-off."
Sec 7. That section twenty-one of said act be amended by inserting
the following words in line six, immediately after "thereby" : "But a
creditor proving his debt or claim shall not be held to have waived his
right of action or suit against the bankrupt where a discharge has been
refused or the proceedings have been determined without a discharge."
Sec 8. That the following words shall be added to section twenty-
six of said act: "That in all causes and trials arising or ordered under
this act, the alleged bankrupt, and any party thereto, shall be a competent
witness."
Sec 9. That in cases of compulsory or involuntary bankruptcy, the
provisions of said act, and any amendment thereof, or of any supple-
ment thereto, requiring the payment of any proportion of the debts of
the bankrupt, or the assent of any portion of his creditors, as a condition
of his discharge from his debts, shall not apply; but he may, if other-
wise entitled thereto, be discharged by the court in the same manner
and with the same effect as if he had paid such per centum of his dd)ts.
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 495
or as if the required proportion of his creditors had assented thereto.
And in cases of voluntary bankruptcy, no discharge shall be granted to
a debtor whose assets shall not be equal to thirty per centum of the
claims proved against his estate, upon which he shall be liable as principal
debtor, without the assent of at least one-fourth of his creditors in num-
ber, and one-third in value; and the provision in section thirty-three of
said act of March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, requiring
fifty per centum of such assets, is hereby repealed.
Sec 10. That in cases of involuntary or compulsory bankruptcy, the
period of four months mentioned in section thirty-five of the act to which
this is an amendment is hereby changed to two months; but this pro-
vision shall not take effect until two months after the passage of this
act. And in the cases aforesaid, the period of six months mentioned
in said section thirty-five, is h'^reby changed to three months; but this
provision shall not take effect until three months after the passage of
this act.
Sec. 11. That section thirty-five of said act be, and the same is hereby,
amended as follows:
First. After the word "and" in line eleven, insert the word
"knowing."
Secondly. After the word "attachment," in the same line, insert the
words "sequestration, seizure."
Thirdly. After the word "and," in line twenty, insert the word "know-
ing." And nothing in said section thirty-five shall be construed to in-
validate any loan of actual value, or the security therefor, made in good
faith, upon a security taken in good faith on the occasion of the making
of such loan.
Sec. 12. That section thirty-nine of said act of March second, eigh-
teen hundred and sixty-seven, be amended so as to read as follows:
"Sec. 39. That any person residing, and owing debts, as aforesaid
who, after the passage of this act, shall depart from the State, District,
or Territory of which he is an inhabitant, with intent to defraud his
creditors; or, being absent, shall, with such intent, remain absent; or
shall conceal himself to avoid the service of legal process in any action
for the recovery of a debt or demand provable under this act; or shall
conceal or remove any of his property to avoid its being attached, taken,
or sequestered on legal process; or shall make any assignment, gift, sale,
conveyance, or transfer of his estate, property, rights, or credits, either
within the United States or elsewhere, with intent to delay, defraud, or
hinder his creditors ; or who has been arrested and held in custody under
or by virtue of mesne process or execution, issued out of any court of
the United States or of any State, District, or Territory within which
496 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
such debtor resides or has property, founded upon a demand in its nature
provable against a bankrupt's estate under this act, and for a sum ex-
ceeding one hundred dollars, and such process is remaining in force and
not discharged by payment, or in any other manner provided by the law
of the United States or of such State, District, or Territory, applicable
thereto, for a period of twenty days, or has been actually imprisoned
for more than twenty days in a civil action founded on contract for the
sum of one hundred dollars or upward; or who, being bankrupt or in-
solvent, or in contemplation of bankruptcy or insolvency, shall make any
payment, gift, grant, sale, conveyance, or transfer of money or other
property, estate, rights, or credits, or confess judgment, or give any
warrant to confess judgment, or procure his property to be taken on
legal process, with intent to give a preference to one or more of his
creditors, or to any person or persons who are or may be liable for him
as indorsers, bail, sureties, or otherwise, or with the intent, by such dis-
position of his property, to defeat or delay the operation of this act; or
who, being a bank, banker, broker, merchant, trader, manufacturer, or
miner, has fraudulently stopped payment, or who being a bank, banker,
broker, merchant, trader, manufacturer, or miner, has stopped or sus-
pended and not resumed payment, within a period of forty days, of his
commercial paper (made or passed in the course of his business as such),
or who, being a bank or banker, shall fail for forty days to pay any
depositor upon demand of payment lawfully made, shall be deemed to
have committed an act of bankruptcy, and, subject to the conditions here-
inafter prescribed, shall be adjudged a bankrupt on the petition of one or
more of his creditors, who shall constitute one-fourth thereof, at least, in
number, and the agreegate of whose debts provable under this act
amounts to at least one-third of the debts so provable: Provided, That
such petition is brought within six months after such act of bankruptcy
shall have been committed. And the provisions of this section shall
apply to all cases of compulsory or involuntary bankruptcy commenced
since the first day of December, eighteen hundred and seventy-three,
as well as to those commenced hereafter. And in all cases commenced
since the first day of December, eighteen hundred and seventy-three,
and prior to the passage of this act, as well as those commenced here-
after, the court shall, if such allegation as to the number or amount of
petitioning creditors be denied by the debtor, by a statement in writing
to that effect, require him to file in court forthwith a full list of his
creditors, with their places of residence and the sums due them respect-
ively, and shall ascertain, upon reasonable notice to the creditors,
whether one-fourth in number and one-third in amount thereof, as afore-
said, have petitioned that the debtor be adjudged a bankrupt. But if
such debtor shall, on the filing of the petition, admit in writing that the
requisite number and amount of creditors have petitioned, the court (if
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 497
satisfied that the admission was made in good faith,) shall so adjudge,
which judgment shall be final, and the matter proceed without fur-
ther steps on that subject. And if it shall appear that such num-
ber and amount have not so petitioned, the court shall grant rea-
sonable time, not exceeding, in cases heretofore commenced, twenty
days, and, in cases hereafter commenced, ten days, within which
other creditors may join in such petition. And if, at the expiration
of such time so limited, the number and amount shall comply with
the requirements of this section, the matter of bankruptcy may proceed;
but if, at the expiration of such limted time, such number and amount
shall not answer the requirements of this section, the proceedings shall
be dismissed, and, in cases hereafter commenced, with costs. And if
such person shall be adjudged a bankrupt, the assignee may recover
back the money or property so paid, conveyed, sold, assigned, or trans-
ferred contrary to this act: Provided, That the person receiving such
payment or conveyance had reasonable cause to believe that the debtor
was insolvent, and knew that a fraud on this act was intended; and
such person, if a creditor, shall not, in cases of actual fraud on his part,
be allowed to prove for more than a moiety of his debt; and this limita-
tion on the proof of debts shall apply to cases of voluntary as well as
involuntary bankruptcy. And the petition of creditors under this sec-
tion may be sufficiently verified by the oaths of the first five signers
thereof, if so many there be. And if any of said first five signers shall
not reside in the district in which such petition is to be filed, the same
may be signed and verified by the oath or oaths of the attorney or
attorneys, agent or agents, of such signers. And in computing the num-
ber of creditors, as aforesaid, who shall join in such petition, creditors
whose respective debts do not exceed two hundred and fifty dollars
shall not be reckoned. But if there be no creditors whose debts exceed
said sum of two hundred and fifty dollars, or if the requisite number of
creditors holding debts exceeding two hundred and fifty dollars fail to
sign the petition, the creditors having debts of a less amount shall be
reckoned for the purposes aforesaid".
Sec. 13. That section forty of said act be amended by adding at the
end thereof the following words: "And if, on the return-day of the
order to show cause as aforesaid, the court shall be satisfied that the
requirement of section thirty-nine of said act as to the number and
amount of petitioning creditors has been complied with, or if, within the
time provided for in section thirty-nine of this act, creditors sufficient
in number and amount shall sign such petition so as to make a total of
one-fou»th in number of the creditors and one-third in the amount of
the provable debts against the bankrupt, as provided in said section,
the court shall so adjudge, which judgment shall be final; otherwise it
498 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
shall dismiss the proceedings, and, in cases hereafter commenced, with
costs."
Sec. 14. That section forty-one of said act be amended as follows:
After the word "bankruptcy," in line eight, strike out all of said section
and insert the words, "Or, at the election of the debtor, the court may, in
its discretion, award a venire facias to the marshal of the district, return-
able within ten days before him for the trial of the facts set forth in the
petition, at which time the trial shall be had, unless adjourned for cause.
And unless, upon such hearing or trial, it shall appear to the satisfaction
of said court, or of the jury, as the case may be, that the facts set forth in
said petition are true, or if it shall appear that the debtor has paid and
latisfied all liens upon his property, in case the existence of such liens
was the sole ground of the proceedings, the proceedings shall be dismissed,
and the respondent shall recover costs; and all proceedings in bank-
ruptcy may be discontinued on reasonable notice and hearing, with the
approval of the court, and upon the assent, in writing, of such debtor,
and not less than one-half of his creditors in number and amount; or,
in case all the creditors and such debtor assent thereto, such discontinu-
ance shall be ordered and entered; and all parties shall be remitted, in
either case, to the same rights and duties existing at the date of the
filing of the petition for bankruptcy, except so far as such estate shall
have been already administered and disposed of. And the court shall
have the power to make all needful orders and decrees to carry the fore-
going provision into effect".
Sec 15. That section eleven of said act be amended by inserting the
words "and valuation" after the word "inventory" in the twenty-first
line; and that section forty-two of said act be amended by inserting
the words "and valuation" after the word "inventory" in the fifteenth
line.
Sec. 16. That section forty-nine of said act be amended by striking
out after the word "the" in line five, the words "supreme courts", and
inserting in lieu thereof "district courts," and in line six, after the word
"States", inserting the words "subject to the general superintendence
and jurisdiction conferred upon circuit courts by section two of said act."
COMPOSITION WITH CREDITORS.
Sec. 17. That the following provisions be added to section forty-three
of said act : That in all cases of bankruptcy now pending, or to be here-
after pending, by or against any person, whether an adjudication in
bankruptcy shall have been had or not, the creditors of such alleged
bankrupt may, at a meeting called under the direction of the court, and
upon not less than ten days' lotice to each known creditor of the time,
places and purpose of such meeting, such notice to be personal or other-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 499
wise, as the court may direct, resolve that a composition proposed by
the debtor shall be accepted in satisfaction of the debts due to them
from the debtor. And such resolution shall, to be operative, have been
passed by a majority in number and three-fourths in value of the credi-
tors of the debtor assembled at such meeting either in person or by
proxy, and shall be confirmed by the signatures thereto of the debtor
and two-thirds in number and one-half in value of all the creditors of
the debtor. And in calculating a majority for the purposes of a compo-
sition under this section, creditors whose debts amount to sums not
exceeding fifty dollars shall be reckoned in the majority in value, but
not in the majority in number; and the value of the debts of secured
creditors above the amount of such security, to be determined by the
court, shall, as nearly as circumstances admit, be estimated in the same
way. And creditors whose debts are fully secured shall not be entitled
to vote upon or to sign such resolution without first relinquishing such
security for the benefit of the estate.
The debtor, unless prevented by sickness or other cause satisfactory
to such meeting, shall be present at the same, and shall answer any in-
quiries made of him; and he, or, if he is so prevented from being at
such meeting, some one in his behalf, shall produce to the meeting a
statement showing the whole of his assets and debts, and the names
and addresses of the creditors to whom such debts respectively are due
Such resolution, together with the statement of the debtor as to his
assets and debts, shall be presented to the court; and the court shall,
upon notice to all the creditors of the debtor of not less than five days,
and upon hearing, inquire whether such resolution has been passed in
the manner directed by this section; and if satisfied that it has been so
passed, it shall, subject to the provisions hereinafter contained, and
upon being satisfied that the same is for the best interest of all con-
cerned, cause such resolution to be recorded and statement of assets and
debts to be filed; and untir such record and filing shall have taken
place, such resolution shall be of no validity. And any creditor of the
debtor may inspect such record and statement at all reasonable times.
The creditors may, by resolution passed in the manner and under the
circumstances aforesaid, add to, or vary the provisions of, any composi-
tion previously accepted by them, without prejudice to any persons
taking interests under such provisions who do not assent to such addi-
tion or variation. And any such additional resolution shall be pre-
sented to the court in the same manner and proceeded with in the same
way and with the same consequences as the resolution by which the
composition was accepted in the first instance. The provisions of a
composition accepted by such resolution in pursuance of this section
shall be binding on all the creditors whose names and addresses and
600 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS.
the amounts of the debts due to whom are shown in the statement of
the debtor produced at the meeting at which the resolution shall have
bcMi passed, but shall not affect or prejudice the rights of any other
creditors.
Where a debt arises on a bill of exchange or promissory note, if the
debtor shall be ignorant of the holder of any such bill of exchange or
promissory note, he shall be required to state the amount of such bill
or note, the date on which it falls due, the name of the acceptor and
of the person to whom it is payable, and any other particulars within
his knowledge respecting the same; and the insertion of such particulars
shall be deemed a su£&cient description by the debtor in respect to such
debt
Any mistake made inadvertently by a debtor in the statement of his
debts may be corrected upon reasonable notice, and with the consent of
a general meeting of his creditors.
Every such composition shall, subject to priorities declared in said act,
provide for a pro-rata payment or satisfaction, in money, to the creditors
of such debtor in proportion to the amount of their unsecured debts, or
their debts in respect to which any such security shall have been duly
surrendered and given up.
The provisions of any composition made in pursuance of this section
may be enforced by the court, on motion made in a summary manner by
any person interested, and on reasonable notice; and any disobedience
of the order of the court made on such motion shall be deemed to be
a contempt of court. Rules and regulations of court may be made in
relation to proceedings of composition herein provided for in the same
manner, and to the same extent as now provided by law in relation to
proceedings in bankruptcy.
If it shall at any time appear to the court, on notice, satisfactory
evidence, and hearing, that a composition under this section cannot, in
consequence of legal difficulties, or for any sufficient cause, proceed with-
out injustice or undue delay to the creditors or to the debtor, the court
may refuse to accept and confirm such composition, or may set the same
aside ; and, in either case, the debtor shall be proceeded with as a bankrupt
in conformity with the provisions of law, and proceedings may be had
accordingly; and the time during which such composition shall have been
in force shall not, in such case, be computed in calculating periods of
time prescribed by said act.
Sec. 18. That from and after the passage of this act the fees, com-
missions, charges, and allowances, excepting actual and necessary dis-
bursements, of, and to be made by the officers, agents, marshals, mes-
sengers, assignees, and registers in cases of bankruptcy, shall be reduced
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 501
to one-half of the fees, commissions, charges, and allowances heretofore
provided for or made in like cases: Provided, That the preceding pro-
vision shall be and remain in force until the justices of the Supreme
Court of the United States shall make and promulgate new rules and
regulations in respect to the matters aforesaid, under the powers con-
ferred upon them by sections ten and forty-seven of said act, and no
longer, which duties they shall perform as soon as may be. And said
justices shall have power under said sections, by general regulations, to
simplify, and, so far as in their judgment will conduce to the benefit
of creditors, to consolidate the duties of the register, assignee, marshal,
and clerk, and to reduce fees, costs, and charges, to the end that prolixity,
delay, and unnecessary expense may be avoided. And no register or clerk
of court, or any partner or clerk of such register or clerk of court, or any
person having any interest with either in any fees or emoluments in bank-
ruptcy or with whom such register or clerk of court shall have any in-
terest in respect to any matter in bankruptcy, shall be of counsel, solicitor,
or attorney, either in or out of court, in any suit or matter pending in
bankruptcy in either the circuit or district court of his district, or in an
appeal therefrom. Nor shall they, or either of them, be executor, admin-
istrator, guardian, commissioner, appraiser, divider, or assignee of or upon
any estate within the jurisdiction of either of said courts of bankruptcy;
nor be interested, directly or indirectly, in the fees or emoluments aris-
ing from either of said trusts. And the words "except such as are
established by this act or by law," in section ten of said act, are hereby
repealed.
Sec. 19. That it shall be the .duty of the marshal of each district, in
the month of July of each year, to report to the clerk of the district
court of such district, in a tabular form, to be prescribed by the justices
of the Supreme Court of the United States, as well as such other or
further information as may be required by said justices.
First, the number of cases in bankruptcy in which the warrant pre-
scribed in section eleven of said act has come to his hands during the
year ending June thirtieth, preceding;
Secondly, how many such warrants were returned, with the fees, costs,
expenses, and emoluments thereof, respectively and separately;
Thirdly, the total amount of all other fees, costs, expenses, and emolu-
ments, respectively and separately, earned or received by him during such
year from or in respect of any matter in bankruptcy;
Fourthly, a summarized statement of such fees, costs, and emoluments,
exclusive of actual disbursements in bankruptcy, received or earned for
such year;
Fifthly, a summarized statement of all actual disbursements in such
cases for such year.
502 FORMER BANKRUPTCP ACTS.
And in like manner, every register shall, in the same month and for
the same year, make a report to such clerk of,
First, the number of voluntary cases in bankruptcy coming before him
during said year;
Secondly, the amount of assets and liabilities, as nearly as may be, of
the bankrupts;
Thirdly, the amount and rate per centum of all dividends declared;
Fourthly, the disposition of all such cases;
Fifthly, the number of compulsory cases in bankruptcy coming before
him, in the same way;
Sixthly, the amount of assets and liabilities, as nearly as may be, of
such bankrupt;
Seventhly, the disposition of all such cases;
Eighthly, the amounts and rate per centum of all dividends declared
in such cases;
Ninthly, the total amount of fees, charges, costs, and emoluments of
every sort, received or earned by such register during said year in each
class of cases above stated.
And in like manner, every assignee shall, during said month, make
like return to such clerk of,
First, the number of voluntary and compulsory cases, respectively and
separately, in his charge during said year;
Secondly, the amount of assets and liabilities therein, respectively and
separately ;
Thirdly, the total receipts and disbursements therein, respectively and
separately ;
Fourthly, the amount of dividends paid or declared, and the rate per
centum thereof, in each class, respectively and separately;
Fifthly, the total amount of all his fees, charges, and emoluments, of
every kind therein, earned or received;
Sixthly, the total amount of expenses incurred by him for legal pro-
ceedings and counsel fees;
Seventhly, the disposition of the cases respectively;
Eighthly, a summarized statement of both classes as aforesaid.
And in like manner, the clerk of said court, in the month of August
in each year, shall make up a statement for such year, ending June
thirtieth, of,
First, all cases in bankruptcy pending at the beginning of the said
year;
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 503
Secondly, all of such cases disposed of;
Thirdly, all dividends declared therein;
Fourthly, the number of reports made from each assignee therein;
Fifthly, the disposition of all such cases;
Sixthly, the number of assignees' accounts filed and settled;
Seventhly, whether any marshal, register, or assignee has failed to
make and file with such clerk the reports by this act required, and,
if any have failed to make such reports, their respective names and
residences.
And such clerk shall report in respect of all cases begun during said
year.
And he shall make a classified statement, in tabular form, of all his
fees, charges, costs, and emoluments, respectively, earned or accrued dur-
ing said year, giving each head under which the same accrued, and also
the sum of all moneys paid into and disbursed out of court in bankruptcy,
and the balance in hand or on deposit.
And all the statements and reports herein required shall be under
oath, and signed by the persons respectively making the same.
And said clerk shall, in said month of August, transmit every such
statement and report so filed with him, together with his own statement
and report aforesaid, to the Attorney General of the United States.
Any person who shall violate the provisions of this section shall, on
motion made, under the direction of the Attorney General, be by the
district court dismissed from his office, and shall be deemed guilty of a
misdemeanor, and, on conviction thereof, be punished by a fine of not
more than five hundred dollars, or by imprisonment not exceeding one
year.
Sec. 20. That in addition to the officers now authorized to take proof
of debts against the estate of a bankrupt, notaries public are hereby
authorized to take such proof, in the manner and under the regulations
provided by law ; such proof to be certified by the notary and attested by
his signature and official seal.
Sec 21. That all acts and parts of acts inconsistent with the pro-
visions of this act be, and the same are hereby, repealed.
AMENDMENT OF APRIL 14tH, 1876.
An act concerning cases in bankruptcy commenced in the supreme
courts of the several Territories prior to the twenty-second day of June,
eighteen hundred and seventy-four, and now undetermined therein.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled, That in all cases in
504 FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS*
bankruptcy commenced in the supreme courts of any of the Territories
of the United States prior to the twenty-second day of June, Anno
Domini eighteen hundred and seventy-four, and now undetermined there-
in, the clerks of the said several courts shall immediately transmit to
the clerks of the district courts of the several districts of said Territories
all the papers in, and a certified transcript of, all the proceedings had in
each of said cases; and the said clerks of the district courts shall im-
mediately file the said papers and transcripts as papers and transcripts in
the said district courts.
Sec. 2. That the clerks of the said several supreme courts shall trans-
mit the papers and transcripts provided for in section one of this act,
in each case, to the clerk of the district court of the district wherein the
bankrupt or bankrupts, or some one of them, resided at the time of the
filing of the petition in bankruptcy in said case; and as soon as the said
papers and transcript in any case shall have been transmitted and filed,
as herein provided, the district court in which the same shall have been
so filed shall have jurisdiction of the said case, to hear and determine
all questions arising therein, and to finally adjudicate and determine the
same in all respects as contemplated in other bankruptcy cases by the act
entitled, "An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy throughout
the United States," and approved March second, eighteen hundred and
sixty-seven, and amendments thereto.
Approved, April 14, 1876.
Amendment of July 2Gth, 1878.
An act to amend the act entitled, "An act to amend and supplement
an act entitled, 'An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy
throughout the United States' approved March second, eighteen hundred
and sixty-seven, and for other purposes," approved June twenty-second,
eighteen hundred and seventy-four.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled, That section twelve of
said act be, and the same is hereby, amended as follows: After the
word "committed," in line forty-four, insert: "Provided also. That no
voluntary assignment by a debtor or debtors of all his or their property,
heretofore or hereafter made in good faith for the benefit of all his or
their creditors, ratably and without creating any preference, and valid
according to the law of the State where made, shall of itself, in the
event of his or their being subsequently adjudicated bankrupts in a pro-
ceeding of involuntary bankruptcy, be a bar to the discharge of such
debtor or debtors." That section fifty-one hundred and eight of the
Revised Statutes is hereby amended so as to read as follows: At any
time after the expiration of six months from the adjudication of bank-
FORMER BANKRUPTCY ACTS. 505
ruptcy, or if no debts have been proved against the bankrupt, or if no
assets have come to the hands of the assignee, at any time after the -
expiration of sixty days, and before the final disposition of the cause,
the bankrupt may apply to the court for a discharge from his debts.
This section shall apply in all cases heretofore or hereafter commenced.
Approved, July 26, 1876.
Repealing Act of June 7th, 1878.
An act to repeal the bankrupt law.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled, That the bankrupt law
approved March second, eighteen hundred and sixty-seven, title sixty-one.
Revised Statutes, and an act entitled, "An act to amend and supplement
an act entitled. An act to establish a uniform system of bankruptcy
throughout the United States, approved March second, eighteen hundred
and sixty-seven, and for other purposes, approved June twenty-second,
eighteen hundred and seventy-four," and all acts in amendment or supple-
mentary thereto or in explanation thereof, be, and the same are hereby,
repealed: Provided, however, That such repeal shall in no manner in-
validate or affect any case in bankruptcy instituted and pending in any
court prior to the day when this act shall take effect; but as to all such
pending cases and all future proceedings therein, and in respect of all
pains, penalties, and forfeitures which shall have been incurred under
any of said acts prior to the day when this act takes effect, or which
may be thereafter incurred, under any of those provisions of any of
said acts which, for the purposes named in this act, are kept in force, .
and all penal actions and criminal proceedings for a violation of any of
said acts, whether then pending or thereafter instituted, and in respect
of all rights of debtors and creditors (except the right of commencing
original proceedings in bankruptcy), and all rights of, and suits by, or
against assignees, under any, or all of said acts, in any matter or case
which shall have arisen prior to the day when this act takes effect
(which shall be on the first day of September, Anno Domini eighteen
hundred and seventy-eight), or in any matter or case which shall arise
after this act takes effect, in respect of any matter of bankruptcy author-
ized by this act to be proceeded with after said last-named day, the
acts hereby repealed shall continue in full force and effect until the same
shall be fully disposed of, in the same manner as if said acts had not
been repealed.
506 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
COURTS OF UNITED STATES WITH BANKRUPTCY
JURISDICTION.
United States Supreme Court.
Chief Justice.
Melville W. Fuller.
Associate Justices.
John M. Harlan. William R. Day.
Oliver W. Holmes. Edward D. White.
David J. Brewer. Rufus W. Peckham.
Henry B. Brown. Joseph McKenna
Clerk.
James H. McKenney, Washington, D. C.
Circuit Courts of Appeals of the United States.
The act of March 3, 1891, Sec. 1 Sup. Rev. St. U. S., 901, creates in
each of the nine judicial circuits, into which the United States is divided,
a Circuit Court of Appeals and determines the juridsiction. This act
has been amended July 16, 1892, 2 Sup. Rev. St. of U. S., 40, by abolish-
ing the office of marshal and providing that duties of marhsals be perf-
formed by United States marhsals. Act of Feb. 18th, 1895, 2 Sup. Rev.
Stat. U. S., 377, extending equity jurisdiction to appeals in injvmction
proceedings. Act of Jan. 20th, 1897, 2 Sup. Rev. Stat. U. S., 541, con-
ferring final jurisdiction on Circuit Courts of Appeals in all criminal
cases not capital. Act of June first, 1898, 2 Supp. Rev. St. U. S., 771,
conferring appellate jurisdiction in award in cases under arbitration act.
Act of June, 6th, 1900, 2 Sup. Rev. Stat, U. S., 1,445, conferring joris-
diction to entertain appeal on interlocutory order granting injunction.
First Circuit.
Circuit Justice. Oliver W. Holmes, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts
and Rhode Island.
Circuit Judges: Le Baron Colt, Bristol, R. I., William
L. Putnam, Portland, Me.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, John G. Stetson, Boston,
Mass.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 507
Annual term, first Tuesday in October; stated sessions, first Tues-
day in every month, sessions for hearing cases, first Tuesday in January,
April and October, at Boston, Mass.
Second Circuit.
Circuit Justice: Rufus W. Peckham, Washington,
D. C.
States in Circuit. — Vermont, Connecticut and New York.
Circuit Judges, William J. Wallace, Albany, New York,
Henry Lacombe, New York, N. Y., William K. Townsend,
New Haven, Conn.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, William Parkin, New York,
N. Y.
Annual term last Tuesday in October ,|at New York City.
Third Circuit.
Circuit Justice, Henry B. Brown, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. — New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware.
Circuit Judges, Marcus W. Acheson, Pittsburg, Pa., Geo.
M. Dallas, Philadelphia, Pa., George Gray, Wilmington,
Del.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, William H. Merrick,
Philadelphia, Pa.
Annual term, first Tuesday in March and third Tuesday in September,
at Philadelphia, Pa.
Fourth Circuit.
Circuit Justice, Melville W. Fuller, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. — North Carolina, South Carolina, Mary-
land, Virginia and West Virginia.
1 Circuit Judges, Nathan Goff, Clarksburg, W. Virginia,
Charles H. Simonton, Charleston, S. C.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, Henry T. Meloney, Rich-
mond, Virginia.
Annual term, first Tuesday in February, first Tuesday in May, and
first Tuesday in November, at Richmond, Va.
508 judges^ clerks and referees.
Fifth Circuit.
Circuit Justice, Edward D. White, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. — Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi,
Louisiana and Texas.
Circuit Judges, Don A. Pardee, New Orleans, La., A. P.
McCormick, Dallas, Texas, David D. Shelby, Huntsville,
Ala.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, Charles H. Lidnum, New
Orleans, La.
Annual term, first Monday in October at Atlanta, Ga. and third
Monday in November, at New Orleans, La.
Sixth Circuit.
Circuit Justice, John M. Harlan, Washington, D. C-
States in Circuit. — Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky and Ten-
nessee.
Circuit Judges, Henry F. Severens, Kalamazoo, Michigan,
Horace H. Liu-ton, Nashville, Tenn, William R. Day, Can-
ton. O.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, Frank 0. Loveland, Cin-
cinnati, Ohio.
Terms: First Tuesday in October and continues until the first Tues-
day in October in the ensuing year. Three sessions will be held in Chi-
cago, beginning on the first Tuesdays in October and January and the
second Tuesday in April.
Seventh Circuit.
Circuit Justice, William R. Day, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. — Indiana, Illinois, and Wisconsin.
Ciruit Judges, James G. Jenkins, Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
Peter S. Grosscup, Chicago, 111., Francis. E. Baker, In-
dianapolis, Indiana.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, Edward M. HoUoway,
Chicago, 111.
Terms: First Tuesday in October; term divided into three sessions,
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 509
beginning on first Tuesday in October, first Tuesday in January and first
Tuesday in May, at Chicago, 111.
Eighth Circuit.
Circuit Justice, D. J. Brewer, Washington, D. C.
States in Circiiit. — Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Arkansas,
Nebraska, Colorado, Kansas, Wyoming, North Dakota,
South Dakota, Utah, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Indian
Territory.
Circuit Judges, Henry C. Caldwell, Little Rock, Arkansas,
Walter H. Sanborn, St. Paul, Minn., Amos M. Thayer, St.
Louis, Mo.
Clerk Circuit Court of Appeals, John D. Jordan, St. Louis,
Mo.
Terms: First Monday in May, at St. Paul, Minn., first Monday in
September, at Denver, Colo., first Monday in December, at St. Loviis, Mo.
Ninth Circuit.
Circuit Justice, Joseph Mckenna, Washington, D. C.
States in Circuit. — California, Oregon, Nevada, Washing-
ton, Idaho, Montana, Alaska, Arizona and Hawaii.
Circuit Judges, William W. Morrow, San Francisco, Cal.,
William B. Gilbert, Portland, Ore., Erskine M. Ross, Los
Angeles Cal.
Clerk Circiiit Court of Appeals, Frank D. Monckton, San
Francisco.
Terms: Annual term first Monday in October, and adjourned sessions
on the first Monday of each month at San Francisco, Cal., Annual
term, second Monday in September, at Seattle, Washington. Annual
term, third Monday in September, at Portland, Oregon.
510 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
DISTRICT JUDGES. CLERKS AND REFEREES, AND THEIR JUR-
ISDICTIONS.
ALABAMA (5th Circuit.)
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Thos. Goode Jones, Montgomery, Ala.
Clerk District Court, Charles J. Allison, Birmingham, Ala.
Referees with jurisdiction. N. W. Trimble, Birmingham, Ala. Ref-
eree for Counties of Jefferson, St. Clair, Shelby, Bibb, Tuscaloosa, Pick-
ens, Greene, Stimter, Hale, Blovmt, Walker, Lamar and Fayette.
H. D. McCarty, Anniston, Ala. Referee for the Counties of Calhoun-
Clebiume, Cherokee, DeKalb, Etowah.
Jere Murphy, Jr., Himtsville, Ala. Referee for the Counties of Madi,
son, Jackson, Limestone, Lauderdale, Colbert, Franklin, Lawrence, Mar-
shall, Winston, Cvdlman, '^Morgan and Marion.
MIDDLE DISTRICT.
District Judge, Thos. Goode Jones, Montgomery, Ala.
Clerk, District Court, Joseph W. Dimmick, Montgomery, Ala.
Referees with jurisdiction. Walter R. Shafer, Selma, Ala., Referee
for the Covmties of Dallas and Perry.
Asa E. Stratton, Montgomery, Ala., Referee for the Coimties of An-
tauga, Barbour, Btillock, Butler, Chilton, Chambers, Clay, Coffee, Coosa,
Covington, Crenshaw, Dale, Elmore, Geneva, Henry, Lee, Lowndes,
Macon, Montgomery, Pike, Randolph, Russell, and Tallapoosa.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Harry T. Toulmin, Mobile, Ala.
Clerk, District Court, Richard Jones, Mobile, Ala.
Referees with jurisdiction. Robert T. Ervin, Mobile, Ala., Referee for
the Counties of Baldwin, Choctaw, Clarke, Conecuh, Excambia, Marengo,
Mobile, Monroe, Washington, Wilcox.
ALASKA (9th Circuit).
DIVISION NO. 1.
District Judge, Melville C. Brown, Juneau, Alaska.
Clerk, District Court, W. J. Hills, Juneau, Alaska.
DIVISION NO. 2.
Note.
This list of referees is as complete as could be made from corre-
spondence. In many counties no referees have been appointed, and
vacancies exist in others, especially in the rural districts.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES, 511
District Judge, Alfred S. Moore, Nome, Alaska.
Clerk District Court, Geo. V. Borchsenius, Nome, Alaska.
C. A. S. Frost, Referee, Nome Alaska.
DIVISION NO. 3.
District Judge, James Wickersham, Eagle, Alaska.
Clerk District Court, A. R. Herlig, Eagle City.
ARIZONA (9th Circuit).
First District.
Justice, George R. Davis, Tucson, Ari.
Clerk District Court, Clinton D. Hoover, Tucson, Ari.
Referees with jurisdiction. Thomas A. Barton, Tucson, Ari., Referee
for Counties of Cochise, Pima and Santa Cruz.
Second District.
Justice for District, Fletcher M. Doan, Florence, Ari.
Clerk District Court, Daniel C. Stevens, Florence, Ari.
Referees with jurisdiction. W. H. Benson, Florence, Ari., Referee for
Pinal County.
William H. Duryea, Globe, Ari., Referee for Gila County.
E. S. Mashbir, Solomanville, Ari., Referee for Graham County.
Third District.
Chief Justice, Edward Kent, Phoenix, Ari.
Clerk District Court, Elias F. Dunlevy, Phoenix, Ari.
Referees with jurisdiction. Alfred Franklin, Phoenix, Ari., Referee for
the Counties of Maricopa and Yimia.
Fourth District.
Justice, Richard E. Sloan, Prescott, Ari.
Clerk District Court, J. M. Watts, Prescott, Ari.
Referees with jurisdiction. Thos. C. Job, Prescott, Referee for Yavapai
and Mohave Counties.
Fred W. Nelson, Holbrook, Ari., Referee for Coconino, Novajo and
Apache Coxmties.
ARKANSAS (8th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Jacob Trieber, Little Rock, Ark.
Clerk District Court, Eastern Division, Emerson R. Crum, Helena.
512 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Referees with jurisdiction. M. L. Stephenson, Helena, Referee for
the Counties of Mississippi, Crittenden, Lee, Philips, Clay, Craighead-
Greene, Cross, St. Francis and Monroe.
Northern Division.
Clerk District Court, Joseph W. Parse, Batesville.
Referees with jurisdiction. Charles F. Cole, Referee for Counties of In-
dependence, Cleburne, Stone, Izard, Sharp, Fulton, Randolph, Lawrence
and Jackson.
Western Division.
Clerk District Court, Sid. B. Redding, Little Rock, Ark.
Referees with jurisdiction. P. C. Dooley, Little Rock, Referee for the
Counties of Arkansas, Ashley, Bradley, Chicot, Clark, Cleveland, Conway,
Dallas, Desha, Drew, Faulkner, Garland, Grant, Hot Springs, Jefferson,
Lincoln, Lonoke, Montgomery, Perry, Pope, Prairie, Pulaski, Saline, Van
Buren, White, Woodruff.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, John H. Rogers, Ft. Smith, Ark.
Texarkana Division.
District Clerk, John M. Somervell, Texarkana, Ark.
Counties in Division: Calhoun, Columbia, Hempstead, Howard,
Lafayette, Little River, Miller, Nevada, Ouachito, Pike, Sevier, Union.
Fort Smith Division.
Clerk Dist. Court, H. B. Armistead, Ft. Smith, Arkansas.
Counties in Division, Benton, Crawford, Franklin, Johnson, Logan,
Polk, Scott, Sebastian, Washington, Yell.
Harrison Division.
Clerk Dist. Court, W. F. Mitchell, Harrison, Ark.
Counties in Division, Baxter, Boone, Carroll, Madison, Marion, Newton,
Staicy.
CALIFORNIA (9th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, John J. DeHaven, San Francisco, Cal.
Clerk District Court, George E. Morse, San Francisco.
Referees with Jurisdiction: R. M. Swain, Santa Rosa, Sonoma Covmty;
A. P. Holland, Oakland, Alameda County; Milton J. Green, San Francisco,
San Francisco County; Richard Belcher, Marysville, Yuba, Colusa, Sut-
ter, Glenn, Butte, Sierra, Pltunas, Tehama, Shasta, Lassen, Trinity, Sis-
kiyou, and Modoc Cotmties; W. T. S. Hadley, Eureka, Hvunboldt and Del
Judges, clerks aNd referees. 513
Norte Counties; W. A. Coulter, San Jose, Santa Clare & San Mateo Coun-
ties; Chas. A. Bliss, Sacramento, Sacramento, Amadon, Yolo & El Dorado
Counties; Thomas L. Carothers, Ukiah, Mendocino & Lake Counties; Ira
H. Reed, San Andreas, Calaveras County; E. P. Foltz, Stockton, San
Joaquin & Stanislaus Coimties; Charles D. Harvey, Loomis, Placer Coun-
ty; Ed Martin, Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz County; Paul C. Harlan, Fairfield,
Solano Cotmty and Napa; A. A. Smith, Sonora, Tuolumne Cotmty.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Olin Wellborn, Los Angelos, Cal.
Clerk District Court, Edward H. Owen, Los Angelos.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Lyman Helm, Los Angelos, Referee for
Los Angelos Coimty; William G. Irving, Riverside, Referee for Riverside
County; J. C. C. Russell, Hanford, Referee for Kings County; Ray Billing,
sley, Santa Ana, Referee for Orange County; W. E. Shepherd, Venttira-
Referee for Ventura County (resigned) ; Henry P. Starbuck, Santa Bar-
bara, Referee for Santa Barbara County; J. Z. Tucker, San Diego, Referee
for San Diego Coimty; Wiley J. Tinnin, Fresno, Referee for Fresno Coun-
ty; Charles L. Allison, San Bernardino, Referee for San Bernardino Coun-
ty; Louis Lomy, San Louis Obispo, Referee for San Louis Obispo Coimty;
Arch McDonald, Madera, Referee for Madera County; E. L. Moore, Mer-
ced, Referee for Merced and Mariposa Cotmties.
COLORADO (8th Circuit.)
District Judge, Moses Hallettt.
Clerk District Court, Charles W. Bishop, Denver.
The State is divided into nine Bankruptcy Districts.
First District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. David V. Bums and William B. Harri-
son, Denver, Referees for the Counties of Arapahoe, Douglas, Elbert,
Lincoln, Cheyenne, Kit Carson, Yuma, Phillips, Sedgwick, Washington,
Logan, Morgan, Weld, Park, Jefferson, Clear Creek, Gilpin, Summit,
Grand, Boulder and Larimer.
Second District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. John B. Cochran, Colorado Springs, Ref-
eree for the County of El Paso
Third District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Samuel D. Trimble, Pueblo, Referee for
the Counties of Pueblo Fremont, Chaffee, Custer, Huerfano, Otero, Bent,
Prowers, Kiowa.
514 JUDGES^ CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Fourth District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Robert T. Yeaman, Trinidad, Referee for
the Counties of Las Animas and Baca.
Fifth District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Ezra T. Elliott, Del Norte, Referee for
the Counties of Rio Grande, Mineral, Sagauche, Costilla and Conejos.
Sixth District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Chancellor T. Morgan, Durango, Referee
for the Counties of La Plata, Archulita, Montezuma, San Juan, Dolores.
Seventh District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. George S. Stephan, Delta, Referee for the
Counties of San Miguel, Ouray, Hinsdale, Gunnison, Montrose, Delta
and Mesa.
Eighth District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Jacob B. Philippi, Glenwood Springs,
Referee for the Counties of Pitkin, Garfield, Rio Blanco, Routt.
Ninth District.
Referees with Jurisdiction. William R. Kennedy! Leadville, James M.
Binson, Cripple Creek, Referees for the Coxmties of Lake and Eagle.
CONNECTICUT (2nd Circuit).
District Judge, James P. Piatt, Hartford, Conn.
Clerk District Court, Edwin E. Marvin, Hartford.
Referees with Jurisdiction. George A. Kellogg, Hartford, Referee for
the Coiuitiesof Hartford and Tolland; Henry G. Newton, New Havn.e
Referee for New Haven County; John W. Banks, Bridgeport, Referee
for Fairfield Coxmty; Gustaf B. Carlson, Middletown, Referee for Middle-
sex County; Amos A. Browning, Norwich, Referee for New London Counk
ty; John F. Carpenter, Putnam, Referee for Windham County; Fran-
B. Munn, Winsted, Referee for Fairfield County.
DELAWARE (3rd Circuit).
District Judge, Edward G. Bradford, Wilmington.
Clerk District Court, S. Rodman Smith, Wilmington.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Arthur W. Spruance, Wilmington, referee
for Covmty of New Castle; George M. Jones, Dover, referee for Kent
County; Charles F. Richards, Georgetown, Referee for Sussex Coimty.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 515
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.
Clerk of Supreme Court, John R. Young, Washington.
Clerk of Court of Appeals, Robert Willett, Washington.
Referees for District, Edward S. McCalmont, 409 Coliimbian Building,'
and Charles H. Ames, 458 La Ave., N. W.
FLORIDA (5th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Charles Swayne, Pensacola.
Clerk, District Court, Frederick W. Marsh, Pensacola.
Referees with Jurisdiction. K. Nichols, Pensacola; E. R. Sprague,'
Funiak Springs; J. J. Hodges, Tallahassee. These Referees have con-
current jurisdiction for the Counties of Calhoun, Escambia, Franklin,
Gadsden, Holmes, Jackson, Jefferson, Lafayette, Leon, Levy, Liberty,
Santa Rosa, Taylor, Wakulla, Walton, Washington.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, James W. Locke, Jacksonville.
Clerk District Court, Eugene O. Locke, Jacksonville.
Referees with Jurisdiction. George M. Powell, Jacksonville, Referee
for Counties of Duval, Nassau, St. John, Volusia, Putnam, Clay; Frank
De Ferro, Lake City; Counties of Madison, Hamilton, Suwatinee and
Columbia; E. E. Voyle, Gainsville, Alackua, Bradford, Marion and Lake;
William Hunter, Tampa, Central Division Southern District, Counties ■
of Hillsboro, Citrus, Sumpter, Hernando, Pasco, Manatee, Polk, De Soto,
Sea, Osceola, Orange; W. R. Anno, Miami, Dade and Brevard; J. M.
Phipps, Key West, Referee for Cotmty of Monroe.
GEORGIA (5th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, W. T. Newman, Atlanta.
Clerk District Court, W. C. Carter, Atlanta.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Percy H. Adams, Atlanta, Referee for the
Coimties of Ftdton, De Kalb and Campbell; C. D. McCutcheon, Dalton,
Referee for the Counties of Whitfield, Murray, Catoosa, Dade, Bartow,
Gordon; George D. Anderson, Marietta, Referee for the Counties of Cobb,
Cherokee, Pickens, Gilmer, Fannin, Milton; Clifford M. Walker, Monroe,
Referee for the Counties of Walton, Morgan, Greene, Newton, Gwinnett,
White, Towns, Lvunkin, Hall, Forsyth, Rockdale; R. O. Jones, Newman,
Referee for the Coimties of Coweta, Heard, Meriweather, Troup; W. S,
Rowell, Rome, Referee for the Coimties of Floyd, Chattooga, Waiver,
Polk, Paulding; S. E. Grow, Carrollton, Referee for the Counties of CarroUt
516 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Douglas, Harralson; Frank U. Garsard, Columbus, Referee for the Counties
of Muscogee, Harris, Talbot, Taylor, Chattahoochee, Marion, Schley;
H. A.Wilkinson, Cuthbert, Referee for the Counties of Stewart, Webster,
Quitman, Randolph, Terrell, Clay, Early, Miller.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Emory Speer, Macon.
Eastern Division.
Clerk District Court, H. H. King, Savannah.
Referees with Jurisdiction, A. H. MacDonnell, Savanah, Referee for
the Coimties of Chatham, Bryan, Liberty, Tatnall, Montgomery, Eman-
uel, Bullock, Screven and Effingham; J. H. Merrill, Bainbridge, Referee
for the Counties of Decatur, Thomas, Brooks, Colquitt, Worth, Irwin,
Coffee, Berrien, Lowndes, Clinch and Echol; Alfred J. Crovatt, Bruns-
wich, Referee for the Counties of Mcintosh, Glynn, Camden, Charlton,
Pierce, Ware, Appling and Wayne.
North-Eastern Division.
Clerk District Court, George K. Calvin, Augusta.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Joseph Gunahl, Augusta, Referee for the
Counties of Burke, Columbia, Glasscock, Jefferson, Johnson, McDufiie,
Richmond, Washington, Warren, Lincoln, Tolieferre, Wilkes.
Western Division.
Deputy District Clerk, Lenoir M. Erwin, Macon.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Alexander Proudfit, Macon, Referee for
the Counties of Baker, Baldwin, Bibb, Butts, Calhoun, Crawford, Dodge,
Dooley, Dougherty, Hancock, Houston, Jaspar, Jones, Laurens, Lee, Ma-
con, Mitchell, Monroe, Pike, Pulaski, Putnam, Sumter, Telfair, Twiggs,
Upson, Webster, Wilcox and Wilkerson.
HAWAII.
District Judge, Morris M. Estee, Honolulu.
Clerk District Court, Walter B. Maling, Honolulu.
IDAHO (9th Circuit).
District Judge, James H. Beatty, Boise.
Clerk District Court, Alonzo L. Richardson, Boise.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Warren Tiiiitt, Moscow, Referee for Latah
Cotmty ; W. A. Brodhead, Harley, Referee for Blaine Covmty ; A. C. Keams
Wallace, Referee for Shoshone Cotmty (resigned); J. H. Padghaur,
Salmon City, Referee for Lemhi County (resigned) ; Niles W. Tate, Boise,
Referee for Ada County (resigned) ; Fred G. Caldwell, Pocatello, Referee
for Bannock Coimty; W. A. Hall, Grangeville, Referee for Idaho Coimty;
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 517
Jesse R. S. Budge, Montpelier, Referee for Bear Lake County; Douglas
M. Todd, St. Anthony, Referee for Fremont County; L. H. Johnston,
ChalHs, Referee for Custer County; Robert S. McCrea, Rademani, Referee
for Kootenai County; John C. Rice, Caldwell, Referee for Canyon County
(resigned) ; Van W. Hasbrouck, Lewiston, Referee for Nez Pierces Cotinty;
George F. Mahoney, Mountain Home, Referee for Elmore [County; S.
H. Travis, Weiser, Referee for Washington County.
ILLINOIS (7th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
Northern Division.
District Judge, C. C. Kohlsaat, Chicago.
District Clerk, T. C. MacMillen, Monadnock Block, Chicago.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Frank L. Wean, Sidney C. Eastman, Ref-
erees for the Counties of Cook, Lake and McHenry ; Morrill Sprague, Joliet,
Referee for the Cotinties of Will, Grvmdy and Kankakee ;lFred A. Dolph,
Aurora, Referee for the Counties of DuPage, Kane, Kendall and De
Kalb; H. G. Cook, Ottawa, Referee for the Cotmties of La Salle and
Bureau. Arthur E. Fisher, Rockford, Referee for the Counties of Boone,
Winnebago, Stephenson and Jo Daviess; Henry S. Dickson, Dixon, Ref-
eree for the Counties of Lee, Whiteside, Ogle and Carroll.
Southern Division.
Referees with Jurisdictions. David McCuUoch, Peoria, Referee for
the Counties of Peoria, Woodford, Stark, Tazewell, Marshall and Put-
nam; Claude E. Chiperfield, Canton, Referee for the Counties of Fulton
and McDonough; Adair Pleasants, Rock Island, Referee for the Cotmties
of Rock Island, Henry, Mercer; LeRoy Wharton, Galesbtirg, Referee
for the Covmties of Knox, Warren and Henderson. H. G. Greenebavim,
Pontiac, Referee for the Counties of Livingston and Iroquois.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, J. Otis Hvimphrey, Springfield.
Clerk District Court, Robert C. Brown, Springfield.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Edward S. Robinson, Springfield, Ref-
eree for the Cotmties of Adams, Alexander, Bond, Brown, Calhoun, Cass
Champaign, Christian, Clark, Clay, Clinton, Coles, Crawford, Cumber-
land, DeWitt, Douglas, Edgar, Edwards, Effingham, Fayette, Ford,
Franklin, Gallatin, Greene, Hamilton, Hancock, Hardin, Jackson, Jas-
per, Jefferson, Jersey, Johnston, Lawrence, Logan, Moultrie, Macon, Ma-
coupin, Madison, Marion, Mason, Massac, McLean, Menard, Monroe,
Montgomery, Morgan, Perry, Pratt, Pike, Pope, Pulaski ,']^ Ran dolph, Rich-
land, St. Clair, Saline, Sangamon, Schuyler, Scott, Shelby, Union, Ver-
milion, Wabash, Washington, Wayne, White and Williamson.
518 JUDGES^ CLERKS AND REFEREES.
INDIANA (7th Circuit).
District Judge, John H. Baker, Indianapolis.
Clerk District Court, Noble C. Butler, Indianapolis.
First District. Referees with Jurisdiction. Orville W. McGinnis,
Evansville, Referee for the Counties of Posey, Gibson, Pike, Dubois,
Spencer, Warrick and Vanderbtirg.
Second District. Lawrence B. Huckeby, New Albany, Referee for
the Counties of Perry, Crawford, Orange, Washington, Harrison, Floyd,
Clark and Scott.
Third District. Minor F. Pate, Bloomfield, Referee for the Counties
of Sullivan, Owen, Greene, Daviess, Martin, Lawrence and Monroe.
Fourth District. Thomas C. Batchelor, Vernon, Referee for the
Counties of Brown, Bartholomew, Jackson, Jennings, Decatur, Ripley,
Jefferson, Dearborn, Ohio and Switzerland.
Fifth District. Horace C. Pugh, Terre Haute, Referee for the
Counties of Vigo, Vermilion, Parke, Clay, Putnam, Hendricks and Mor-
gan.
Sixth District. Albert Rabb, Indianapolis, Referee for the Coun.
ties of Marion and Johnson.
Seventh District. Clay C. Hunt, New Castle, Referee for the Coun-
ties of Hancock, Shelby, Rush, Henry, Wayne, Fayette, Union and
Franklin.
Eighth District. Charles A. Burnett, Lafayette, Referee for the
Counties of Fovmtain, Warren, Benton, White, Tippecanoe and Mont-
gomery.
Ninth District. Harry C. Sheridan, Frankfort, Referee for the
Covmties of linton, Boone, Howard, Tipton and Hamilton.
Tenth District. John W. Ryan, Muncie, Referee for the Counties of
Madison, Delaware, Blackford, Wells, Adams, Jay and Randolph.
Eleventh District. Frank Swigart, Logansport, Referee for the
Counties of Carroll, Cass, Miami, Wabash, Huntington and Grant.
Twelfth District. John O. Bowers, Hammond, Referee for the
Counties of Newton, Lake, Porter, Jasper, Pvilaski and Starke.
Thirteenth District. Frank E. Lambert, South Bend, Referee for
the Counties of LaPorte, St. Joseph, Marshall, Fidton, Elkhart and Kos-
ciusko.
Fourteenth District. Augustin|A. Chapin, Ft. Wayne, Referee for
the Counties of La Grange, Noble, Whitley, Steuben, DeKalb and Allen.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 519
INDIAN TERRITORY (8th Circixit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
Judges, Joseph A. Gill, Vinita.
Clerk District Court, Charles A. Davidson, Vinita.
Deputy District Clerks, Robert C. Hunter, Claremore; Thos. C. John-
son, Herbert C. Smith, Tahlequah.
Dennis H. Wilson, Vinita, and James H. Huckleberry, Sallisand,
Referee for district.
CENTRAL DISTRICT.
Judge, Wm. H. H. Clayton, South McAlester.
Clerk District Court, E. J. Fannin, South McAlester.
Referees for the District which comprises the Choctow Nation, James
S. Amote, South McAlester; P. C. Bolger, Poteau; Eugene Easton, Ant-
'ers and C. H. Elting, Caddo.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
The District comprises the Creek and Seminole nations and portions
of the Cherokee and Choctow nations adjacent to the eastern and south-
em bovmdary of Creek nation.
District Judge, Charles W. Raymond, Muscogee.
Clerk District Court, Robert P. Harrison, Muscogee.
Thos. A. Sanson, Muskogee, Referee for District.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Hosea Townsend, Ardmore.
Clerk District Court, C. M. Campbell, Ardmore.
Ardmore Division.
Deputy Clerk District Court, N. H. McCoy, Ardmore.
John Hinkle, Ardmore, Referee, Pickens Co.
Pauls Valley Division.
Deputy District Clerk, J. T. Fleming, Pauls Valley.
T. N. Robnett, Referee, Pauls Valley.
Chicasha Division.
Deputy Clerk, J. W. Speake, Chicasha.
Z. E. Taylor, Referee for Indian Territory.
Ryan Division.
Deputy Clerk, S. H. Wootton, Ryan.
Eugene Hamilton, Chickasha, Referee for Chickasha and Ryan.
520 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
PuRCELL Division.
Deputy Clerk, T. G. Green, Purcell.
George M. Miller, Referee, Purcell.
IOWA (8th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, O. P. Shiras, Dubuque.
Clerk District Court, Alonzo J. Van Duzee, Dubuque.
Referees with Jurisdiction. C. S. Stillwell, Waukon, Alamakee County;
W. A. Leathers, Dubuque, Dubuque, Delaware and Clayton Counties;
F. W. Myatt, Maquoketa, Jackson County; M. W. Harmon, Independence,
Buchanan County; W. J. Rogers, West Union, Fayette; R. F. B. Portman,
Decorah, Winnesheik; M. M. Moon, Cresco, Howard; E. L. Smalley, Wa-
verly, Bremer; W. P. Hoxie, Waterloo, Blackhawk and Gnmdy; J. S.
Bradley, Charles City, Floyd; A. E. Roberts, Osage, Mitchell; J. S. Stacy,
Anamosa, Jones; J. S. Anderson, Cedar Rapids, Linn and Cedar Coun-
ties; J.G. Mamer, Iowa City, Johnson; Fred K. Feenan, Marengo, Iowa;
C. I. Vail, Blairstown, Benton County; C. J. Stevens, Montour, Tama
County; Charles O. Ryan, Eldora, Hardin Coimty; L. F. Sutton, Clin-
ton, Chnton County; C. C. Doolittle, Estherville, Emmet County; W. H.
MorUng, Emmetsbxu*g, Palo Alto Covmty; W. C. Ralston, Pocahontas,
Pocahontas County; J. C. Kerr, Calhoim, Rockwell City County; J. C.
Raymond, Algona, Kossuth County; G. S. Garfield, Hvunboldt, Hiim-
boldt County; Frank Farrell, Ft. Dodge, Webster County; Thomas A.
Kingland, Forest City, Winnebago County; Wesley Aldridge, Britt, Han-
cock County; Porter Donly, Eagle Grove, Wright Coimty; W. J. Covil,
Webster City, Hamilton Covmty; A. H. Cummings, Mason City, Worth
and Cerro Gordo Counties; Henry White, Hampton, Franklin and Butler
Counties; G. W. Patterson, Spencer, Dickinson and Clay Cotmties; Mark
M. Moulton, Storm Lake, Buena Vista Covmty; H. L. Loft, Cherokee,
Cherokee County; W. D. Brown, Onawa, Sac, Monona and Ida Counties;
J. L. E. Peck, Primghar, O'Brien County; J. W. Kachelhoffer, Rock Rap-
ids, Lyon; John E. Orr, Orange City, Siovix County; C. L. Joy, Sioux Cit,y
Plymouth and Woodbury Covmties.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Smith McPherson, Red Oak.
Clerk District Court, Wm. R. McArthur, Des Moines.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Hillbause Buell, Keokuk, Referee for the
Covmties of Lee and Van Bvu-en; La Monte Cowles, Burlington, Referee
for the Counties of Des Moines and Louisa; Joseph E. Ells, Muscatine,
Referee for the County of Muscatine; John M. Helmick, Davenport,
Referee for the County of Scott; Henry M. Eicher, Washington, Referee
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 521
for the Counties of Keoktik and Washington; Roger C. Galer, Mt. Pleasant,
Referee for the Counties of Henry and Jefferson; A. W. Enode, Ottawa,
Referee for the Counties of Davis and Wapello; Will C. Raybum, Grin-
nell, Referee for the County of Powershick; Graham W. Laurence, Mar-
shalltown, Referee for the Cotinty of Marshall; Ohver C. Meredith, New-
ton, Referee for the County of Jasper; Irving C. Johnson, Oskaloosa,
Referee for the Covmties of Mahaska and Marion; Clarence S. Wyckoflf,
Centerville, Referee for the Covmties of Appanoose and Mimroe; Warren
S. Dungan, Chanton, Referee for Lucas County; John W. Freeland,
Cory don. Referee for the Counties of Wayne, Decatur and Clarke; Stephen
S. Ethridge, Des Moines, Referee for the Counties of Polk, Warren and
Madison; Arthvu- T. Browne, Boone, Referee for the Counties of Boone,
Strong and Greene; Hugh M. Fry, Creston, Referee for the Counties of
Union, Taylor, Ringgold and Adair; M. J. Hallenan, Bayard, Referee
for the Counties of Guthrie and Dallas; William R. Lee, Carroll, Referee
for the Counties of Carroll and Crawford; Joseph B. Rockafellow, Atlantic
Referee for the Coimties of Cass, Audubon; H. C. French, Red Oak,
Referee for the Counties of Page, Montgomery, Fremont Adams and
Mills; Wingfield S. Mayne, Coimcil Bluffs, Referee for the Counties of Pot-
tawattamie, Mills, Harrison, Shelby.;
KANSAS (8th Circuit).
District Judge, William C. Hook, Leavenworth.
Clerk District Court, Frank L. Brown, Topeka.
Referees with Jurisdiction, J. G. Slonecker, Topeka, Referee for the
Counties of Washington , Riley, Jackson, Wabaunsee, Morris, Osage, Frank
lin, Marshall, Pottawatomie, Geary, Shawnee, Lyon and Douglas;
Thomas J. White, Kansas City, Referee for the Cotmties of Doniphan,
Leavenworth, Johnson, Jefferson, Memaha, Atchinson, Wyandotte and
Brown; Zarah C. Millikin, Salina, Referee for the Counties of Clay, Mc-
Pherson, Ottawa, Republic, Mitchell, Ellsworth, Osborne, Ellis, PhilUps,
Graham, Gore, Decatur, Thomas, Wallace, Cheyenne, Dickinson, Saline,
Cloud, Jewell, Lincoln, Russell, Smith, Rooks, Trego, Norton, Sheridan,
Logan, Rawlins and Sherman; Charles E. Cory, Ft. Scott, Referee for
the Coimties of Greenwood, Chautauqua, Woodson, Montgomery, Allen,
Labettee, Bourbon, Cherokee, Elk, Coffey, Wilson, Anderson, Neosho,
Linn, Crawford and Miami; Thomas B. Wall, Wichita, Referee for the
Coimties of Chase, Cowley, Harvey, Sumner, Kingman, Rice, Stafford,
Barber, Pawnee, Kiowa, Ness, Ford, Lane, Meade, Finney, Seward,
Kearney, Stevens, Hamilton, Morton, Butler, Marion, Sedgwick, Harper,
Reno, Barton, Pratt, Rush, Edwards, Comanche, Hodgeman, Clark,
Gray, Scott, Haskell, Wichita, Grant, Greeley and Stanton.
522 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
KENTUCKY (6th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Andrew N. J. Cochran, Maysville.
Clerh District Court, Joseph C. Finnell, Covington, and Walter G.
Chapman, Frankfort.
Referees with Jurisdiction, J. W. Tutle, Monticello, Referee for the
Counties of Wayne, Pulaski and Whitley; W. W. Tinsley, Barbourville,
Referee for the Counties of Knox, Clay, Bell, Harlan, Leslie, Licher,
Perry and Knott; J. M. Saunders, Stanford, Referee for the Counties of
Lincoln, Rockcastle, Jackson and Laurel; Thomas H. Hardin, Harrod-
burg. Referee for the Counties of Mercer, Boyle, Garrord and Anderson;
D. W. Lindsey, Frankfort, Referee for the Counties of Franklin, Owen,
Henry, Shelby, Woodford and Scott; Martin M. Durrett, Covington,
Referee for the Counties of Kenton, Campbell, Grant, Pendleton, Boone,
Gallatin, Carroll and Trimble; H. Clay Howard, Paris, Referee for the
Counties of Bourbon, Harrison and Nicholas; C. Suydam Scott, Lexing-
ton, Referee for the Counties of Fayette and Jessamine; R. W. Miller,
Richmond, Referee for the Counties of Madison, Clarke and Estill; Thomas
R. Phister, Maysville, Referee for the Counties of Mason, Bracken,
Robertson and Fleming; A. T. Wood, Mt. Sterling, Referee for the Coim-
ties of Montgomery, Bath, Rowan, Menifee, Elliott and Morgan; G. W.
Gourley, Beattyville, Referee for the Counties of Lee, Powell, Wolfe,
Owsley, Breathitt; P. K. Malin, Ashland, Referee for the Counties of
Boyd, Greenup, Lewis, Carter, Lawrence, Floyd, Magoffin, Johnson,
Pike and Martin.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Walter Evans, Louisville.
Clerk District Court, Thomas Speed, Louisville; Thos. Speed, Owens-
boro.
Referees with Jurisdiction, W. P. Lee, Mayfield, Referee for Covmties
of Carlisle, Fulton, Graves, Hickman; E. W. Bagby, Paducah, Referee
for Counties of Livingston, Ballard, Calloway, McCracken and Marshall
J. I. Landes, Hopkinsville, Referee for Cotmties of Caldwell, Crittenden,
Lyon, Trigg, Hopkins, Christian, Webster; John A. Dean, Owensboro,
Referee for Counties of Henderson, Union, McLean, Daviess, Ohio, Han-
cock, Breckenridge; J. Caldwell Browder, Russellville, Referee for the
County of Logan; C. W. Millikeri, Bowling Green, Referee for the Coun-
ties of Allen, Edmondson, Simpson, Warren; A. B. Montgomery, Eliza-
bethtown. Referee for the County of Hardin; H. C. Gorin, Glasgow,
Referee for the Counties of Clinton, Cumberland, Metcalfe, Barren,
Monroe, Russell; John B. Baskin, Louisville, Referee for the Coimties
of Oldham, Spencer, Nelson, Jefferson, Bullitt, Meade; W. J. Lisle, Le-
banon, Referee for County of Marion.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 523
LOUISIANA (5th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Charles Parlange, New Orleans.
Clerk District Court, Frank H. Mortimer, New Orleans.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Wm A. Bell, New Orleans, Refercf for
Parish of Orleans and adjoining parishes; J. H. Morrison, New Roads, La.,
Referee for Parishes of Pointe Coupee, East and West Feliciana,
East and West Baton Rouge, Iberville and Ascension; John
L. Peytavin, Union, Referee for the Parishes of St. John the Baptist,
St. Charles, Jefferson, Plaquemines and St. Bernard; Louis U. Folse,
Napoleon ville, Referee for Parishes of Iberia, Assumption, St. James,
St. Mary, Terribonne and Lafourche.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Aleck Boarman, Shreveport.
Clerk District Court, Walter Jackson, Shreveport.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Thomas T. Taylor, Lake Charles, Referee
for Parishes of Rapids, Grant, Catahoula, Winn, Natchitoches, Arcadia,
Calcasieu, Vermilion, St. Martin, Lafayette, St. Landy, Avoyelles and
Vermors; Percy Sandel, Monroe; A. D. Land, Jr., Shreveport.
District includes Counties of Avoyelles, Arcadia, Bienvillfe, Bossier,
Caddo, Calcasieu, Caldwell, Cameron, Catahoula, Clairbome, Concordia,
DeSota, East Carroll, Franklin, Grant, Jackson, Lafayette, Lincoln,
Madison, Morehouse, Natchitoches, Ouachita, Rapids, Red River, Rich-
land, Sabine, St. Landry, St. Martin, Tensas, Union, Vermilion, Vernon,
Webster, West Carroll and Winn.
MAINE (1st Circuit).
District Judge, Clarence Hale, Portland.
Clerk District Court, A. H. Davis, Portland.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Henry W. Oakes, Auburn, Referee for
Androscoggin County; Edwin L. Vail, Houlton, Referee for Aroostock
County; Lewis Pierce, Portland, Referee for Cumberland County; John
B. Redman, Ellsworth, Referee for Hancock County; Fremont J. C.
Little, Augusta, Referee for Kennebec County; Lewis F. Starrett, Rock-
land, Referee for Knox County; George A. Wilson, South Paris, Referee
for Oxford County; John R. Mason, Bangor, Referee for Penobscot Coun-
ty; John F. Sprague, Monson, Referee for Piscataquis County; William
T. Hall, Jr., Bath, Referee for Sagadahoc and Lincoln Counties; Daniel
Lewis, Showegan, Referee for Somerset County; William P. Thompson,
Belfast, Referee for Waldo County; Clement B. Donworth, Machias,
Referee for Washington Cotmty; John B, Donovan, Alfred, Referee for
York Cotmty.
524 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
MARYLAND (4thCircmt).
District Judge, Thomas J. Morris, Baltimore.
Clerk District Court, James W. Chew, Baltimore.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Thomas F. Hisky, 215 N. Charles St.,
Baltimore; Daniel L. Brinton, Low Building, Baltimore, Thomas Foley
Baltimore, Referees for Baltimore City; Walter J. Mitchell, La Plata,
Referee for Charles, St. Mary's and Calvert Cotinties; Edwin Y. Golds-
borough, Frederick, Referee for Frederick and Montgomery Counties;
Emanuel W. Herman, Towson, Referee for Cotmty of Baltimore; E.
Oliver Grimes, Jr., Westminster, Referee for Carroll Covmty; Clarence
W. Perkins, Chestertown, Referee for Kent, Queen Anne's, Talbot, Caro-
line and Dorchester Counties; Albert A. Daub, Cumberland, Referee for
Alleghany and Garrett Counties; William T. Warburton, Elkton, Referee
for Cecil County; Peter L. Hopper, Havre de Grace, Referee for Harford
County; John D. Parker, 220 St. Paul St., Baltimore, Referee for Coimties
of Anne, Anmdel, Howard and Prince George.
MASSACHUSETTS (1st Circuit).
District Judge, Francis C. Lowell, Boston.
Clerk District Court, Frank H. Mason, Boston.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Charles E. Burke, Pittsfield, Referee for
Berkshire County; Clifford P. Sherman, New Bedford, Referee for Coun-
ties Bristol, Nantucket and Dukes; Wm. Perry, Salem, Referee for Essex
Coimty; Archibald D. Flower, Greenfield, Referee for Franklin County,
Charles W. Bosworth, Springfield, Referee for Hampden Covmty; Edward
L. Shaw, Easthampton, Referee for the County of Hampshire; Henry E-
Warner, Lincoln, Referee for County of Middlesex; George W. Stetson,
Middleboro, Referee for the Coimties of Plymouth and Barnstable; James
M. Olmstead and Lewis G. Farmer, Boston, Referees for the Coimties of
Suffolk; Charles F. Aldrich, Worcester, Referee for the County of Wor-
cester.
MICHIGAN (6th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Henry M. Swan, Detroit.
Clerk District Court, D. J. Davison, Detroit.
Northern Division.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Chester L. Collins, Bay City, Referee for
Coimties of Alcona, Alpena, Arenac, Bay, Cheboygan, Clare, Crawford,
Genesee, Gladwin, Gratiot, Huron, Iosco, Isabella, Midland, Montmorency,
Ogemaw, Oscoda, Otsego, Presque Isle, Roscommon, Saginaw, Shiwassee
and Tuscola; Harlow P. Davock, Detroit, Referee for Counties of Branch,
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 525
Calhoun, Clinton, Hillsdale, Inhgam, Jackson, Lapeer, Lenowee, Living-
ston, Macomb, Monroe, Oakland, St. Clair, Sanilac, Washtenaw and
Wajme.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, George P. Wanty, Grand Rapids.
Clerh District Court, John McQuewan, Grand Rapids.
Northern Division.
Benj. O. Pearl, Marquette, Referee for Counties of Alger, Baraga,
Chippewa, Delta, Dickinson, Gogebic, Houghton, Iron, Keweenaw, Luce,
Mackinac, Marquette, Menominee, Ontonagon and Schoolcraft (entire
upper peninsula).
Southern Division.
Referees with Jurisdietion. Alfred H. Himt, Grand Rapids, Referee for
Counties of Kent, Ottawa, lona, Muskegon, Newaygo, Oceana, Mason,
Lake, Manistee, Benzie, Leelanaw, Grand Traverse, Antrim, Kalkaska,
Wexford, Osceola, Mecosta, Montcalm, Clinton, Missaukee ,|Charlevoix and
Emmet; H. C. Briggs, Kalamazoo, Referee for the Counties of Allegan,
Barry, Eaton, Kalamazoo, St. Joseph, Cass, Berrien and Van Btiren.
MINNESOTA (8th Circuit).
District Judge, William Lochren, Minneapolis.
Clerk District Court, Charles L. Spencer, St. Paul.
First Division. Referees with Jurisdiction, William Bums, Winona,
Referee for Cotmties of Winona, Wabasha, Olmstead, Dodge, Steele, Fill-
more, Houston and Mower.
Second Division. Jean A. FUttie, Mankato, Referee for the Coim-
ties of Freeborn, Faribault, Martin, Jackson, Nobles, Rock, Pipestone,
Murray, Cottonwood, Watonwan, Blue Earth, Waseca, Sucar, Nicol-
let, Brown, Redwood, Lyoi>; Lincoln, Yellow, Medicine, Sibley, Lac qui
Parle.
Third Division. Michael Dom, St. Paul, Referee for Cotmties of
Chicago, Washington Ramsey, Dakota," Goodhue and Scott; E. S. Bas-
sett, Faribault, Referee for Cotmty of Rice.
Fourth Division. O. C. Merriman, Minneapolis, Referee for Counties
of Hennepin, Wright, Renville, McLeod, Carver, Anoka, Sherbiime and
Isanti; E. W. Campbell, Litchfield, Referee, Meeker, Kandioyhi, Chip-
pewa, Swift.
Fifth Division. Crawford Sheldon, Little Falls, H. F. Greene, Du-
luth. Referees for Counties of Cook, Lake, St. Louis, Itasca, Cass, Crow
Wing, Aitkin, Carlton, Pine, Kanabec, Millelac, Morrison and Benton.
526 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Sixth Division. Ole J. VatUe, Crookston, Referee for Clay, Nor-
man, Polk, Marshall, Kittison, Red Lake, Rosecan, Beltram. Clear Water.
Columbia; William L. Parsons, Fergus Falls, Referee for the Counties
of Steams, Pope, Stevens, Big Stone, Traverse, Grant, Douglas, Todd,
Ottertail, Wilkins, and Southern part of Clay, Becker and Hubbard.
MISSISSIPPI (5th Circuit.)
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Henry C. Niles, Kosciusko.
Clerk District Court, J. S. Burton, Oxford.
Referees with Jurisdiction, John A. David, Kosciusko, Referee in
bankruptcy for the Covmties of Winston, Choctaw, Coahoma, Carroll,
Tunica, Attala, Desoto, Tate, Marshall, Panola, Tippah, Tisomingo, Al-
corn, Prentiss, Itawamba, Union, Lownds, Oktibbeha, Benton, Lee, Mont-
gomery, Grenada, Tallehatchee. La Fayette, Pontotoc, Monroe, Chickasaw,
Webster, Clay, Calhoun, Quitman, and Yalabushe; B. T. Markette, Clarks-
dale. Referee for the entire District, which includes the Counties of De Soto
Yalobusha, Coahoma, Lafayette, Marshall, Timica, Quitman, Talla-
hatchie, Grenada, Benton, Tate and Panola.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Henry C. Niles, Kosciusko.
Clerk District Court, L. B. Moseley, Jackson.
Referees with Jurisdiction, J. B. Sterling, Jackson, Referee for Counties
of Adams, Amite, Copiah, Covington, Franklin, Hinds, Holmes, Jeffer-
son, Lawrence, Lincoln, Leflore, Madison, Pike, Rankin, Simson, Smith,
Scott, Wilkinson Yazoo, Greene, Hancock, Harrison, Jackson, Marion,
Perry and Pearl River; W. T. Houston, Meridian, Referee for Coimties of
Clarke, Jones, Jasper, Kemper, Lauderdale, Leake, Neshoba, Newton,
Noxubee and Wayne; E. H. Moimger, Vicksburg, Referee for Coimties
of Bolivar, Clairbome, Issaquena, Sharkey, Sxmflower, Warren and
Washington.
MISSOURI (8th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Elmer B. Adams, St. Louis.
Eastern Division.
Clerk District Court, William Morgan, St. Louis
Referees with Jurisdiction, Walter D. Coles, St. Louis, Referee for
City of St. Louis; Alexander Ross, Cape Girardeau, Referee for Counties
of Cape Girardeau, Scott, Mississippi, Stoddard, Butler, New Madrid,
Dunklin and Pemiscot; G. P. Smith, Montgomery City, and Sherman T.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 527
Gresham, Farmington, Referees for the Cotinties of Anderson, Bollinger,
Carter, Crawford, Dent, Franklin, Gasconade, Iron, Jefferson, Lincoln,
Madison, Montgomery, Oregon, Perry, Reynolds, Ripley, St. Charles,
St. Francis, Ste. Genevieve, St. Louis, Shannon, Warren, Washington,
and Wayne.
Northern Division.
Clerk District Court, Geo. C. Moore, Hannibal.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Frederick W. Neeper,' Guaranty Building,
Hannibal, Referee for the Counties of Macon, Marion, Monroe, Ran-
dolph, Lewis, Adair, Scotland, Schuyler, Pike, Ralls, Knox, Clark and
Shelby.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
Judge District Court, John F. Philips, Kansas City.
Western Division.
Clerk District Court, John M. Nuckols, Kansas City.
Referee with Jurisdictions. Thomas T. Crittenden, Kansas City, Ref-
eree for the Coxmties of Barton, Bates, Caldwell, Carroll, Cass, Chariton,
Clay, Grtmdy, Henry, Jackson, Jasper, Johnson, Lafayette, Linn, Liv-
ingston, Mercer, Putnam, Ray, St. Clair, SaUne, Sullivan and Vernon.
Southern Division.
Clerk District Court, Geo. Pepperdine, Springfield.
Referee with Jurisdictions. George S. Rathbim, Springfield, Referee for
the Counties of Christian, Cedar, Dade, Dallas, Douglass, Greene, Howell,
Laclede, Ozark, Polk, Pulaski, Taney, Texas, Webster and Wright.
Central Division.
Clerk District Court, Henry C. Geisberg, Jefferson City.
Referees with Jurisdictions. John Montgomery, Jr., Sedalia, Referee
for the Counties of Benton, Boone, Callaway, Cooper, Camden, Cole,
Hickory, Howard, Maries, Miller, Moniteau, Morgan, Osage, Pettis and
Phelps.
St. Joseph Division.
Clerk District Court, Calvin C. Colt, St. Joseph.
Referee with Jurisdictions. Woodson, St. Joseph, Referee for
the Coimties of Andrew, Atchison, Buchanan, Clinton, Daviess, DeKalb,
Gentry, Holt, Harrison, Nodaway, Platte and Worth.
JOPLIN DIVISION.
Clerk District Court, — , Springfield, Mo.
528 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Referee with Jurisdictions. A. E. Spencer, Joplin, Mo., Referee for
Counties of Jasper, McDonald, Stone, Barry, Newton, Barton, Vernon.
MONTANA (9th Circuit).
District Judge, Hiram Knowles, Helena.
Clerk District Court, George W. Sproule, Helena.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Distrcit No. 1. Thompson Campbell,
Butte, Referee for Covmties of Beaverhead, Deer Lodge, Madison, Silver
Bow, Ravalli, Granite and Missoula; District No. 2. S. A. Balliet, Helena,
Referee for the Cotmties of Broadwater, Gallatin, Jefferson, Lewis and
Clark and Meagher; District No. 3. , Missoula, in-
cludes Covmties of Granite, Missoula and Ravalli; District No. 4.
, Great Falls, Referee for Counties of Choteau, Cascade,
Fergus, Flathead, Teton, and Valley; District No. 5. Henry A. Frith,
Billings, Referee for the Counties of Carbon, Custer, Dawson, Park, Sweet
Grass, Yellowstone and Roseland.
NEBRASKA (8th Circuit) .
District Judge, William H. Mtmger, Omaha.
Clerk District Court, R. C. Hoyt, Omaha.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Ernest C. Eames, and E. E. Spencer, Lin-
coln, Referees for the Coimties of Lancaster, Saline, Johnson and Seward;
Charles E. Clapp and W. H. Heedman, Omaha, Referees for the Counties
of Douglas, Sarpy, Washington, Bart and Cass. John A. Davies, Platts-
mouth. Referee for Cass County; E. S. Ricker, Chadron, Referee for the
Counties of Dawes, Sioux, Box, Butte and Sheridan; James W. Eaton,
Nebraska City, Referee for the Counties of Otoo, Nemaha and Richardson;
August Wagner, Columbus, Referee for the Counties of Platte, Merrick,
Nance, Boone, Colfax and Butler; F. W. Vaughn, Fremont, Referee for
the Counties of Dodge, Cuming and Saunders; E. P. Weatherly, Nor-
folk, Referee for Counties of Madison, Pierce, Stanton, Knox and Antelope;
W. L. Kirkpatrick, York, Referee for the Counties of York, Polk, Hamil-
ton and Filmore; A. C. Mayer, Grand Island, Referee for the Counties
of Hall, Buffalo, Howard, Sherman Valley, Greely, Wheeler and Gar-
field; Walter V. Hoagland, Kearney, Referee for the Covmties of Dam-
son, Lincoln, Logan, Keith, Deuel, Cheyenne, Kimball, Banner, Scotts
Bluffs; Fulton Jack, Beatrice, Referee for the Counties of Gage, Pawnee,
Jefferson and Thayer; James Britton, Wayne, Referee for the Counties
of Wayne, Cedar, Dixon, Dakota, Thurston; J. I. White, Curtis, Referee
for Counties of Perkins, Gasper, Frontier, Chase, Dundy, Hitchcock,
Furnas, Red Willow and Hayes; J. A. Gardiner, Hastings, Referee for
the Counties of Adams, Clay, Unokoll, Webster; G. Norberg, Holdrege,
Referee for the Covmties of Phelps, Kearney, Harlan and Franklin; J. H.
Shinn, Broken Bow, Referee for the Covmties of Custer, Loup, Blaine,
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. v 529
Thomas, Hooker and Grant; A. W. Scattergood, Ainsworth, Referee for
Keyapaka, Cherry, Holt, Boyd and Rock.
NEVADA (9th Circuit) .
District Judge, Thomas P. Hawley, Carson City.
Clerk District Court, T. J. Edwards, Carson City.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Samuel Piatt, Carson City, Referee for the
entire District.
NEW HAMPSHIRE (1st District).
District Judge, Edgar Aldi;ich, Littleton.
Clerk District Court, Bums P. Hodgman, Concord.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Fremont E. Shurtleflf, Concord, Referee for
the Counties of Rockingham, Hillsboro, Cheshire, Sullivan and Merri-
mack; Dwight Hall, Dover, Referee for the Counties of Strafford, Bel-
knap and Carroll; Benjamin H. Coming, Littleton, Referee for the Coim-
ties of Coos and Grafton.
NEW JERSEY (3rd Circuit).
District Judge, Andrew Kirkpatrick, Newark.
Clerk District Court, George T. Cranmer, Trenton.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Clarence L. Cole, Atlantic City, Referee for
Atlantic County; George J. Bergen, Camden, Referee for Camden Cotmty;
Lewis T. Stevens, Cape May City, Referee for Cape May County; Frede-
rick W. Leonard, Newark, Referee for Essex County; Edwin A. Lewis,
Hoboken, Referee for Hunson County; Samuel D. Oliphant, Jr., Trenton,
Referee for Mercer County; James Parker, Perth Amboy, Referee for
Middlesex County; Frederick Parker, Freehold, Referee for Monmouth
Cotmty; C. Franklin Wilson, Morristown, Referee for Morris County;
John W. Harding, Paterson, Referee for Passaic County; William V.
Steele, Somerville, Referee for Somerset and Himterdon Counties; At-
wood L. DeCoster, Summit, Referee for Union County; William H.
Morrow, Belvidere, Referee for Warren County.
NEW MEXICO (8th Circuit).
First District.
Associate Justice, John R. McFie.
Clerk District Court, Alfred M. Bergere, Santa Fe.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Benjamin M. Read, Sante Fe, Referee for
the Counties of Sante Fe, San Juan, Rio Arriba and Taos (resigned).
Second District.
Associate Justice, Beni. S. Baker, Albuquerque.
530 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Clerk District Court, William E. Dame, Albuquerque.
Referees with Jurissdictions. William D. Lee, Albuquerque, Referee
for Bernalillo and Valencia and McKinley Counties.
Third District.
Associate Judge, Frank W. Parker, Silver City.
Clerk District Court, James P. Mitchell, Las Cruces.
Referees with Jurisdictions. H. B. Holt, Las Cruces, Referee for the
Coimties of Grant, Donna, Ana, Sierra, Lima and Otero.
Fourth District.
Chief Justice, Wm. J. Mills, Las Vegas.
Clerk District Court, Secundino Romero, Las Vegas.
Referees with Jurisdictions. C. M. Bayne, Raton, Referee for the Coun-
ties of Union, Colfax; S. B. Davis, Jr., Las Vegas, Referee for Coimties
of San Miguel, Guadalope and Mora.
Fifth District.
Associate Justice, Daniel H. McMillan, Socorro.
Clerk District Court, John E. Griffith, Socorro.
Referee with Jurisdictions. W. E. Kelley, Socorro, Referee for the
Coimties of Socorro, Lincoln, Chavez and Edely.
NEW YORK (2nd Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Geo. W. Ray, Norwich.
Clerk District Court, W. C. Doolittle, Utica.
Referees with Jurisdiction, R. A. Gunnison, Binghamton, Referee for
the Counties of Boone, Chenango and Delaware; John M. Brainard, Au-
burn, Referee for Cayuga County; Henry T. Kellogg, Plattsburg, Referee
for the Counties of Clinton, Essex and Franklin; Charles L. Stone, Syra-
cuse, Referee for the Counties of Cortland and Madison; R. B. Fish, Ful-
tonville. Referee for thQ Counties of Fulton, Hamilton, Montgomery;
W. H. Comstock, Utica, Referee for the Counties of Oneida and Herkimer;
Joseph Atwell, Watertown, Referee for the Counties of Jefferson and
Lewis; Nathan B. Smith, Pulaski, Referee for Oswego County; B. W.
Hoye, Oneonta, Referee for Otsega County; Edwin A. King, Troy, Ref-
eree for the Counties of Rensselaer and Washington; John C. Tulloch,
Ogdensburg, Referee for St. Lawrence County; James Lee Scott, Sara-
toga Springs, Referee for the Counties of Saratoga, Schnectady and
Warren; WilUam Lansing, Albany, Referee for Albany, Schoharie County;
George S. Tarbell, Ithaca, Referee for the Counties of Tioga and Tomp-
kins.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 531
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Geo. B. Adams, New York.
Clerk District Court, Thomas Alexander, New York.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Charles M. H. Arnold, Poughkeepsie, Referee
for Duchess Cotmty; Walter C. Anthony, Newburgh, Referee for Orange
County; Theodore Cuf 149 Broadway, Nathaniel S. Smith 302 Broadway,
Stanley M. Dexter, 71 Broadway, Ernest Hall, 64 WilUam street, George
C. Holt, 34 Pine street, Macgrane Coxe, 63 Wall street. Seaman Miller,
346 Broadway, Peter B. Olney, 68 William street, Francis K. Pendle-
ton, 27 Williams street, N. A. Prentiss, 120 Broadway, John J. Town-
send, 45 Cedar street, Morris S. Wise, 40 Exchange place. Referees for
New York City; Sylvester H. Thayer, Yonkers, Referee for Westchester
Cotmty; Amon Van Etten, Rondout, Referee for Ulster County; Clayton
Ryder, Cannel, Referee for Putnam County; Ira D. De Lamater, Hudson,
Referee for Colimibia County; William T. B. Storms, Nyark, Referee for
Rockland County.
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Edward B. Thomas, Brooklyn.
Clerk District Court, Richard P. Morle, Brooklyn.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Robert F. Tilney, 26 Court street, Brook-
lyn; Frank Rejmolds, 16 Court street, Brooklyn, and Waldo E. BuUard,
26 Court street, Brooklyn, Referees for Kings County; for Queens and
Nassau Counties, Charles A. Tipling, 26 Jackson avenue. Long Island
City; for Suffolk Cotmy, William G. Nicoll, Babylon, Suffold County;
for Richmond Covmty, Charles L. Hubbell, West New Brighton, Staten
Island.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, John R. Hazel, Buffalo.
Clerk District Court, George P. Keating, Buffalo.
Referees with Jurisdiction, W. L. Ward, Wellsville, Referee for Alle-
gany County; V. E. Peckham, Jamestown, Referee for the Counties of
Cattaraugus and Chautauqua; W. H. Hotchkiss, Buffalo, Referee for
Erie Coimty; Roswell E. Moss, Elmira, Referee for Chemimg County;
Quincy Van Voorhis, Rochester, Referee for Monroe County; Delmar
M. Darrin, Bath, Referee for the Counties of Steuben and Livingston;
George D. Judson, Lockport, Referee for the Counties of Niagara and
Orleans; Asa B. Priest, Canandaigua, Referee for Ontario County; John
Knight, Arcade, Referee for the Counties of Genesee and Wyoming;
Charles M. Woodward, Watkins, Referee for Schuyler Coimty; Charles
A. Hawley, Seneca Falls, Referee for the Counties of Seneca, Yates and
Wayne.
532 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
NORTH CAROLINA (4th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Thomas R. Pumell, Raleigh.
Clerk District Court, H. L. Orant, Raleigh.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Charles Guirken, Elizabeth City, Referee
for the Counties of Currituck, Camden, Pasquotank, Perquimans, Chowan,
Gates, Dare, Hyde, Tyrrell and Washington; James R. Gaskill.Tarboro,
Referee for the Counties of Hertford, Bertie, Martin, Edgecombe, Hali-
fax, Northampton, Beaufort, Nash and Pitt; L. J. Moore, Newbum,
Referee for the Counties of Crain, Lenoir, Jones, Pamlico, Carteret,
Wayne and Onslow; S. H. Macrae, Fayette ville, and S. P. Collier, Wil-
mington, Referees for the Counties of New Hanover, Pender, Brunswick
Colximbus, Bladen, Robeson, Sampson, Duplin, Cumberland, Richmond,
Hartnett and Scotland; Victor C. Boyden, Raleigh, Referee for the Coun-
ties of Wake, Chetham, Johnston, Wilson, Dunham, Person, Granville,
Franklin, Vance, Warren and Moore.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, James E. Boyd, Greensboro.
Clerks District Court, Henry C. Cowles, Statesville; W. C. Hyams,
Asheville, and S. L. Trogdon, Greensboro.
Referees with Jurisdiction, H.S. Anderson, Henderson ville. Referee
for the Counties of Polk, Rutherford, Lincoln, Gaston, Cleveland, Union,
Anson, Buncombe, Henderson, Transylvania, Burke and Catawba; J. R.
McCrary, Lexington, Referee for the Counties of Davie, Davidson, Ala-
mance, Randolph, Montgomery, Guilford, Orange, Rockingham, Cas-
well, Rowan, Iredell, Stanley; Alfred A. Dula, Referee for the Counties
of Caldwell and Alexander; J. E. Alexander, Winston-Salem, Referee for
the Counties of Alleghany, Ashe, Watauga, Forsythe, Stokes, Yadkin,
Surry and Wilkes; J. J. Hooker, Webster, Referee for the Coimties of
Swan, Jackson, Graham, Clay and Cherokee
NORTH DAKOTA (8th Circuit) .
District Judge, Charles F. Amidon, Fargo.
Clerk District Court, J. A. Montgomery, Fargo.
Referees with Jurisdiction, L. H. Whithead, Grand Forks, Referee for
the Coimties of Grand Forks, Traill, Walsh, Pembina, Cavalier, Nelson,
Ramsey, Eddy, Benson, Towner, Rolette, Bottineau, Pierce, McHenry,
Ward and Williams; Guy L.Wallace, Fargo, Referee for the Counties of
Burleigh, Stustman, Logan, Mcintosh, Emmons, Kidder, Foster, Wells,
McLean, Stark, Morton, Oliver, Mercer, Billings, Cass, Richland, Barnes,
Dickey, Sargent, La Moure, Ransom, Griggs and Steele.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 633
OHIO.
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judges, Augustus J. Ricks and F. J. Wing, Cleveland.
Clerk District Court, H. P. Carleton, Cleveland.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Fordyce Belford, Toledo, Lucas, Fulton and
Williams Counties; Robert Carey, Upper Sandusky, Wyandotte and Marion
Counties; W. C. Carman, Yotmgstown, Mahoning Coimty; Chas. D.Dickin-
son, Leetonia, Columbiana Cotmty; Dayton A. Doyle, Akron, Summit
County; L. B. Faarver, Elyria, Lorain and Medina Counties ; Ed. M. Fries,
Bowling Green, Wood and Henry Counties; John W. Grimm, Findlay,
Hancock Cotmty; L. F. Himter, Warren, Trtmibull County; Chas. H.
Keating, Mansfield, Richland Coimty; W. F. Kean, Wooster, Wayne and
Holmes Counties; T. H. LoUer, Dennison, Tuscarawas County; A. M.
McCarty, Canton, Stark and Carroll Covmties; W. L. Monnett, Bucyrus,
Crawford County; J. H. McGiffert, Ashtabula, Ashtabula County; Harold
Remington, Cleveland, Cuyahoga County; H. G. Richie, Van Wert,
Van Wert County; Geo. B. Smith, Ashland, Ashland County; W. B,
Brattain, Paulding, Patdding and Defiance Counties; Frank E. Seager,
Fremont, Sandusky Coimty; Geo. E. Scroth, Tifiin, Seneca Coimty; E. S.
Stephens, Sandusky, Erie and Ottawa Covmties; S. S. Wheeler, Lima,
Allen, Auglaize and Putnam Coimties ; L. W. Wickham, Norwalk, Huron
County; Lewis J. Wood, Painesville, Lake, Geauga and Portage Coimties;
Chas. S. Yoimger, CeUna, Mercer Coimty; George E. Crane, Kenton,
Hardin County.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, A. C. Thompson, Cincinnati.
Clerk District Court, B. R. Cowen, Cincinnati.
Referees with Jurisdiction, J.O. McMannis, West Union, Adams County;
L. A. Koons, Athens, Athens and Hocking Counties; James M. Rees, St.
Clairsville, Belmont County ; Wm. D.Yoimg, Ripley, Brown County; H. H.
Haines, Hamilton, Butler County ; George W. Poland, Urbana, Champaign
County; Frank M. Knapp, Springfield, Clark Coimty; William C. Bishop,
Batavia, Clermont County; Frank B. Mills, Wilmington, Clinton Coimty;
Elijah Devor, Greenville, Darke County; Chas. M. McElroy, Delaware,
Delaware County; Chas. C. Carpenter, Lancaster, Fairfield County; Lee
Rankin, Washington, C. H., Fayette County; CM. Rogers, Columbus,
Franklin, Madison and Licking Counties; T. E. Bradbury, Gallipolis,
Gallia Coimty; G. D. Dugan, Cambridge, Guernsey Coimty; WilUam S.
Howard, Xenia, Greene County; R. H. Minteer, Cadiz, Harrison County;
Henry C. Dawson, Hillsboro, Highland County; Chas. T. Greve, Cincin-
nati, Hamilton County; Alfred Mack, Cincinnati, Hamilton County;
Morison R. Waite, Cincinnati, Hamilton County; Wm. H.Whittaker
534 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Cincinnati, Hamilton County; Evan E. Eubanks, Jackson, Jackson and
Vinton Cotinties; Justin E. Moore, Steubenville, Jefferson County; W.
L. Gary, Mt. Vernon, Knox C«imty; P. C. Booth, Ironton, Lawrence
County; Wm. H. West, Bellefontaine, Logan County; Albert D.
Russell, Pomeroy, Meigs County; George H. Black, McConnellsville,
Morgan County; Wm. P. Vaughan, Cardington, Morrow Coimty; Fred
S. Gates, Zanesville, Muskingum Cotmty; Walter S. Kessler, Troy,
Miami Cotmty; Walter D. Cline, Dayton, Montgomery Coimty; James
L. Sayler, Eaton, Preble, Coimty; John Ferguson, New Lexington, Perry
Cotmty; Harry B. Weaver, Circleville, Pickaway County; Elijah Cut-
right, ChilUcothe, Ross Cotmty; Cecil S. Miller, Portsmouth, Scioto
County; David Oldham, Sidney, Shelby Cotmty; Robt. McCreary,
Marysville, Union Coimty; John E. Smith, Lebanon Warren Cotmty;
Jewett Palmer, Marietta Washington County.
OKLAHOMA (8th Circuit).
First District.
Chief Justice, John H. Burford, Guthrie.
. Clerk District Court, F. A. Neal, Guthrie.
Referees with Jurisdictions. S. S. Lawrence, Guthrie, Referee for the
Counties of Logan, Lincoln and Payne; A. G. Ctmningham, Woodward,
Referee for Woodward Cotmty.
Second District.
Associate Justice, C. F. Irwin, El Reno.
Clerk District Court, E. M. Hegler, El Reno.
Referees with Jurisdictions. George T. Bowman, Kingfisher, Referee
for the Counties of Canadian, Blaine, "D," Day, Roger Mills, Custer and
Washington.
Third District.
Associate Justice, B. F. Burwell, Oklahoma City.
Clerk District Court, B. D. Shear, Olkahoma City.
Referees with Jurisdictions. E. E. Hennessey, Oklahoma City, Ref-
eree for the Counties of Oklahoma, Pottawatomie, Cleveland and Greer.
Fourth District.
Associate Justice, Bayard T. Hainer, Perry.
Clerk District Court, J. E. Pickard, Perry.
Referees with Jurisdictions. John L. Pancoast, Perry, Referee for
the Counties of Beaver, "P," Noble and Osage Nation.
Fifth District.
Associate Justice, John K. Beauchamp, Enid.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 535
Clerk District Court, C. F. McElish, Enid.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Charles H. Parker, Enid, Referee for the
Counties of Garfield, Grant, Blaine, Roger Mills; Robert A. Lyle, King-
fisher, Referee for Covinties of Kingfisher, Canadian, Cleveland, Curtis,
and Washita.
OREGON (9th Circuit).
District Judge, Charles B. Bellinger, Portland.
Clerk District Court, E. D. McKee, Portland; Jos. A. Sladen, Portland.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Alex Sweek, Portland, Multnomah County;
Charles H. Page, Astoria, Clatsop County; Albert Abraham, Roseburg,
Douglas Coxmty; H. T. Bagley, Hillsboro, Washington Coimty; C. C.
Bryant, Albany, Linn, Benton and Lincoln Counties; M. D. L. Rhodes,
McMinnviUe, Yamhill County; John Bayne, Salem, Marion Cotinty; E.
Holgate, Corvallis, Benton County; Thomas FitzGerald, Pendleton,
Umatilla County; Florence Olson, Milwaukee, Clackamas Cotmty; C. A.
Wintermeier, Eugene, Lane County; J. B. Messick, Baker City, Baker
Cotmty; R. E. WiUiams, Dallas, Polk County; G. S. Reavis, Enterprise,
Wallowa Covmty; J. W. Hopkins, Prineville, Crook Coimty; Edward
Dunn, Condon, Gilliam County; B. O. McCullough, Grants Pass, Josephine
County; Win. A. Gowan, Bums, Harney Cotmty.
PENNSYLVANIA (3rd Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, John B. McPherson, Philadelphia.
Clerk District Court, W. C. Craig, Philadelphia.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Joseph Mason, 1318 Stephen Girard Bldg.,
for Philadelphia County; Theodore M. Etting, 705 Land Title Bldg.,
Philadelphia Cotmty; Alfred Driver, 505 Chestnut street, Philadelphia
County; Byerly Hart, 228 South Third street, Philadelphia County;
Edward F. Hoffman, 560 Bullitt Bldg., Philadelphia County; Richard^S.
Hunter, 308 Walnut street, Philadelphia County; Christian H. Ruhl,
Reading, Berks County; William C. Ryan, Doylestown, Bucks Cotmty;
George M. Rupert, West Chester, Chester County; George E. Darlington,
Media, Delaware County; B. Frank Eshleman, Lancaster, Lancaster
County; John G. Diefenderfer, Allen town, Lehigh County; George F.
Coffin, Easton, Northampton Cotmty; C. Henry Stenson, Norristown,
Montgomery Cotmty; Wm. M. Fausset, Pottsville, Schuykill Cotmty.
MIDDLE DISTRICT.
District Judge, R. W. Archbald, Scranton.
Clerk District Court, E. R. W. Searle, Scranton; F. P. Snodgrass.'Har-
risburg; GeorgeC. Scheuer, Dep. Clerk Dist. Ct., Scranton; A. J. Colbum,
Scranton.
536 JUDGES^ CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Referees with Jurisdiction:
C. A. Van Wormer, Referee, Scranton, for the Counties of Lackawan-
na, Susquehanna, Wyoming and Maine.
Alonzo T. Searle, Referee, Honesdale, for the Counties of Wayne and
Pike.
Henry A. Fuller, Referee, Wilkesbarre, for the County of Luzerne.
Louis M. Hall, Referee, Towanda, for the County of Bradford.
H. A. M. KiUip, Referee, Bloomsburg, for the County of Columbia.
William G. Thomas, Referee, Mauch Chimk, for the County of Carbon.
M. H. Taggart, Referee, Stmbury, for the Counties of Northumber-
land, Montour, Snyder and Union.
Leon B. Ferry, Referee, Wellsboro, for the Coimty of Tioga.
John M. Wilson, Referee, Williamsport, for the Covmties of Lycoming
and SulUvan.
Alonzo R. Moore, Referee, Coudersport, for the Counties of Potter
and Cameron.
Henry C. Quingley, Referee, Bellefonte, for the Counties of Centre
and CUnton.
M. W. Jacobs, Referee, Harrisburg, for the Counties of Dauphin and
Perry.
Cyrus R. Lantz, Referee, Lebanon, for the Coimty of Lebanon.
W. Bronson Orr, Referee, Chambersburg, for the Counties of Franklin
and Fulton.
WilUam H. Trude, Referee, Htmtingdon, for the Counties of Htmting-
don, Mifflin and Juniata.
WilUam W. Fletcher, Referee, Carlisle, for the County of Cumberland.
John B. McPherson, Referee, Gettysburg, for the Counties of Adams
and York.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Joseph Buffington, Pittsburg.
Clerk District Court, Wm. T. Lindsay, Pittsburg; Frank W. Grank,
Erie. ,
Referees with Jurisdictions, William R. Blair, Pittsburgh, for Allegheny
County; Joseph M. Force, Erie, Erie County; William E. Ransom, Will-
iamsport, Lycoming County; Thomas C. Hare, Altoona, Blair County;
Henry Russell Myers, Washington, Washington County; John Q. Van
Swearingen, Uniontown, Fayette County; Fred L. Kahle, Franklin, Ve-
nango County; A. G. Richmond, Meadville, Crawford County; James
R. W. Baker, Mercer, Mercer County; Horace R. Rose, Johnstown,
JUDGES^ CLERKS AND REFEREES. 537
Cambria and Somerset Cotmties; Frank L. Harney, Foxburg, Clarion
Cotmty; Joseph M. McClure, Bradford, McKean Covmty; E. H. Beshlin,
Warren, Warren Coimty; J. W. Hutchinson, Butler, Butler Coimty;
James E. Keenan, Greensburgh, Westmoreland County; James Denny
Daugherty, Kittanning, Armstrong County; Edwin Mahlon Under
wood. New Castle, Lawrence Coimty; W. C. Pentz, Du Bois, Clear-
field County; S. J. Telford, Indiana, Indiana County; Samuel Russell
Longenecker, Bedford, Bedford Cotmty; Thomas Spencer Crago, Waynes-
burg, Greene County; William T. Darr, Brookville, JeflEerson County.
PORTO RICO.
District Judge, William H. Holt, San Juan.
Clerks District Court, Ricardo Nadal, San Juan; Frank Antonsanti
Mayaguez ; Antonio Aguayo.
RHODE ISLARD (1st Circuit).
District Judge, A. L. Brown, Providence.
Clerk District Court, W. P. Cross, Providence.
Referees for Entire District, Chester W. Barrows, N. W. Littlefield,
Providence.
SOUTH CAROLINA (4th Circuit).
District Judge, William H. Brawley, Charleston.
Clerk District Court, C. J. C. Hutson, Charleston.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Bnmson, Wm. A., Florence, Florence
Ck)xmty; Jvdius E. Boggs, Pickens, Pickens Coimty; John J. Carle, Col-
umbia, Richland County; *B. W. Ball, Laurens County; H. E. De Pass,
Spartenburg, Spartenburg County; S. Means, Beaty, Union, Union
Coimty; Chas. T. Connors, Lancaster, Lancaster County; Wm. W. Wan-
namaher, Orangeburg, Orangeburg Comity; R. A. Ellis, Barnwell,
Barnwell County; Sanders Glover, Yemassee, Beaufort County; J. N.
O. Gregory, Saluda C. H., Saluda County; Julius H. Heyward, Green-
ville, Greenville Coimty; Edward W. Hughes, Charleston, Charleston
County; L. C. Inglis, Bamberg, Bamberg County; Thos. J. ICirkland,
Camden, Kershaw County; J. Fraser Lyon, Abbeville, Abbeville County;
Henry A. Meetze, Lexington, Lexington County; J. E. McDonald,
Winnsboro, Winnsboro Cotmty; John J. McLures, Chester, Chester
County; D. T. McNeill, Conway, Horry County; J. M. Paget, Anderson,
Anderson County; A. M. Rankin, Darlington, Darlington and Ches-
terfield Counties; I. C. Strauss Sumter, Sumter County; C. W. F.
Spencer, Rock Hill, York Coimty; Robert A. Thompson, Walhalla,
Oconee County; Robert H. Welch, Newberry, Newberry County; T. W.
Johnson, Marion, Marion County.
♦Deceased; no successor.
538 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
SOUTH DAKOTA (8th Circuit).
District Judge, John E. Corland, Sioux Falls.
Clerk District Court, O. S. Pendar, Sioxix Falls.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Granville G. Bennett, Deadwood, Lawrence,
Pinnington, Custer, Fall River, Meade and Butte Counties; John F.
Hughes, Pierre, Hughes County; Charles N. Harris, Aberdeen, Brown
County; Samuel A. Ramsey, Woonsocket, Sanborn, all Counties S. of
Hand, Hyde, Kingsbury, Brookings, and E. of Mo. River, except Braelli
County; Ralph W. Parliman, Sioux Falls, Minnehaha Coxmty.
Henry A. Mueller, Sioux Falls, Referee for Counties of Clay, Union,
Yankton, Turner, Lincoln, Bon Homme, Clark's Mine, Douglas, Hutchin-
son, Brab, Aurora, Davison, Hanson, McCrook, Minnehaha, Moody,
Lake Miner, Sanborn, Beadle, Kingsbury, Lyman, Gregory, Todd, Crow
Creek, Lower Brtde and Yankton Indian Reservations.
The above counties are designated as "Districts of Referees in Bank-
ruptcy," and cases are referred pursuant to the following rule:
"In case any petition in bankruptcy is filed by or against any person
residing in a county not designated as a Referee District, the same shall
be referred to a Referee in the Referee District, in the same Division of
the District of South Dakota, nearest by the usually traveled route to
the residence of the person by or against whom such petition is filed;
but, if such case is one of volimtary bankruptcy, the petitioner may, in
writing, at the time of filing his petition, designate the Referee District
within the proper division, to which he prefers to have the matter re-
ferred, and the reference shall, tmless otherwise ordered, be made accord-
ingly."
TENNESSEE (6th Circuit) .
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Charles W. Clark, Chattanooga.
Clerk District Court, Henry O. Ewing, Chattanooga; James F. Carter,
Knoxville.
Referees with Jurisdictions. John Cox, Johnson City, Referee for the
Counties of Johnson, Carter, Unicoi, Sullivan, Washington, Greene, Haw-
kins, Hancock, Cocke, Hamblen; W. L. Grayson, Chattanooga, and J. W.
Caldwell, Knoxville, Referees for the Covmties of Anderson, Bradley,
Bledsoe, Blount, Campbell, Claiborne, Cumberland, Fentress, Grainger,
Hamilton, James, Jefferson, Knox, Loudon, Marion, McMinn, Meigs,
Monroe, Morgan, Polk, Rhea, Roane, Sevier, Scott, Sequatchie and
Union.
MIDDLE DISTRICT.
District Judge, Charles D. Clark, Nashville.
JUDGES^ CLERKS AND REFEREES. 539
Clerk District Court, Henry M. Doak, Nashville.
Referees with Jurisdiction, A. L. Childress, Nashville, Referee for the
entire district, comprising the Covinties of Bedford, Cannon, Cheatham,
Clay, Coffee, Davidson, Dekalb, Davison, Franklin, Giles, Gnindy,
Hickman, Hiomphreys, Houston, Jackson, Lawrence, Lewis, Lincoln,
Macon, Marshall, Matuy, Montgomery, Moore, Overton, Pickett, Putnam,
Robertson, Rutherford, Smith, Stewart, Sumner, Trotisdale, Van Buren,
Warren, Wayne, White, Willingson and Wilson.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Eli S. Hammond, Memphis.
Clerk District Court, John B. Clough, Memphis.
Eastern Division.
Referees with Jurisdiction, John R. Walker, Trenton, Referee for the
Counties of Benton, Carroll, Chester, Gibson, Henry, Hardman, Hardin,
Henderson, Decatur, Madison, McNairy, Obion, Perry Weakley, Lake
and Crockett.
Western division.
Richard D. Jordan, Memphis, Referee for the Counties of Dyer, Lauder-
dale, Tipton, Shelby, Fayette and Hajrn'ood.
TEXAS (5th Circuit).
NORTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Edward R. Meek, Ft. Worth.
Clerk District Court, J. H. Finks, Dallas.
Referees with Jurisdiction. Eugene Marshall, Dallas, Referee for the
Counties of Navarro, Johnson, Ellis, Kaufman, Dallas, Rockwell, Hunt;
G. P. Meade, Fort Worth, Referee for the Counties of Comanche, Hood,
Erath, Tarrant, Parker, Palo Pinto, Wise, Clay, Jack, Young, Archer,
Wichita, Wilbarger, Baylor, Bailey, Hardeman, Cottle, Motley, Briscoe,
Hall, Childress, Collingsworth, Donley, Armstrong, Randall, Deaf Smith,
Oldham, Potter, Carson, Gray, Wheeler, Hemphill, Lipscomb, Ochiltree,
Roberts, Hutchinson, Hansford, Sherman, Moore, Hartley, Dallam,
Foard, Parmer, Swisher, Castro, Lamb, Hale, Floyd, Cochran, Dawson
and Hockley.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
Waco Division.
Referees with Jurisdictions. M. C. H. Park, Waco, Referee for the
Counties of Milan, Robertson, Leon, Limestone, Freestone, McLennan,
Falls, Bell, Coryell, Hamilton, Bosque, Somerville and Hill; K. K. Leg-
gett, Abilene, Referee for the Covmties of Eastland, Stephens, Throck-
morton, Shackleford, Callahan, Taylor, Jones, Haskell, Knox, Noland,
540 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Fisher, Stonewall, Kent, Dickens, King, Crosby, Garza, Lubbock, Gaines,
Andrews, Mitchell, Scurry, Borden, Howard, Martin, Midland, Yoakum,
Terry, Lynn; A. W. Wilson, Brownwood, Referee for the Counties of
Glasscock, Sterling, Coke, Tom Green, Crockett, Schleicher, Sutton, Irion,
Mills, Runnels, Coleman, Brown, Menard and Concho.
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, David E. Bryant, Sherman.
Division Returnable to Jefferson.
Clerk District Court, W. E. Singleton, Jefferson.
Referees with Jurisdictions. J. A. Hurley, Sulphur Springs, Referee
for the Covmties of Bowie, Camp, Cass, Franklin, Harrison, Hopkins,
Marion, Morris, Titus and Upshur.
Division returnable to Tyler.
Clerk District Court, D. W. Parish, Tyler.
Referees with Jurisdiction. C. G. White, Referee for the Covmties of
Anderson, Angeline, Cherokee, Gregg, Henderson, Houston, Nacogdoches,
Panola, Raines, Rusk, Shelby, Smith, Trinity, Van Zandt and Wood.
Division Returnable to Galveston.
Clerk District Court, CD. Hart, Galveston.
Referees with Jurisdictions Referee for
the Covmties of Austin, Brazoria, Chambers, Colorado, Fort Bend, Gal-
veston, Grimes, Harris, Madison, Mortagorda, Montgomery, Walker, Wal-
ler, Wharton and Jackson.
Division Returnable to Paris.
Clerk District Court, John B. Dailey, Paris.
Referees with Jurisdictions. F. B. Dillard, Referee for the Cotmties of
Delte, Fannin, Grayson, Lamar and Red River.
Division Returnable to Beaumont.
Clerk District Court, C. Dart, Jr., Beaumont.
Referees with Jurisdictions. W. J. Crawford, Beaumont, Referee for
the Counties of Jasper, Jefferson, Liberty, Newton, Orange, Polk, Sabine,
San Augustine.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Walter T. Bums, Houston.
Clerk District Court, C. Dart, Galveston.
Counties Returnable to Galveston.
Austin, Brazoria, Chambers, Fort Bend, Galveston, Matagorda,
Wharton.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 541
Counties Returnabte to Houston.
Brazos, Calhoun, Colorado, Goliad, Grimes, Harris, Jackson, Lavaca,
Madison, Montgomery, Polk, San Jacinto, Trinity, Victoria, Walker,
Walter.
Counties Returnable to Laredo.
Referee with Jurisdictions. Referee A. Winslow, Laredo, Referee for
Aransas, Dimmit, Duval, Lasalle, McMuUen, Ninces, Refugio, San Pa-
tricio, Webb, Zabato.
Counties Returnable to Brownsville.
Cameron, Hidalgo, Stair.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Thomas S. Maxey, Austin.
Division Returnable to San Antonio.
Clerk District Court, A. Grosenbacher, San Antonio.
Referees with Jurisdictions. T. M. Watlington, San Antonio, Referee
for the Coimties of Atacosa, Bandera, Bexar, Bee, Comal, Calhoim, De-
witt, Edwards, Frio, Guadalupe, Gonzales, Goliad, Kerr, Kendall, ICin-
ney, Karnes, Lavaca, Live Oak, Medina, Maverick, Nueces, Uvalde, Val-
verde, Wilson and Zavalla.
Division Returnable to El Paso.
Clerk District Court, J. T. Hodgson, El Paso.
Referees with Jurisdictions. M.I. Killegon, • , Referee
for the Coimties of Brewster, Buchel, Bailey, Castro, Cochran, Crane,
Dawson, El Paso, Ector, Foley, Floyd, Hale, Hockley, Jeff Davis, Lamb,
Lynn, Loving, Presidio, Pecos, Parmer, Reeves, Swisher, Terry, Upton,
Winkler, Yoakum and Ward.
Division Returnable to Waco.
Clerk District Court, L. B. McCuUoch, Waco.
Division Returnable to Austin.
Clerk District Court, D. H. Hart, Austin.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Franz Fiset, Austin, Referee for the
Counties of Blanco, Bastrop, Burleson, Burnet, Caldwell, Fayette, Lilies-
pie, Hays, Kimble, Lee, Llano, Lampassas, Mason, McCuUough, Milan,
San Saba, Travis, Washington and Williamson; A. Winslow, Laredo,
Referee for the Counties of Duval, Lasalle, McMuUen, Webb, Zapata,
Nueces, San Patricio, Arancos, Refugio.
UTAH (8th Circuit).
District Judge, John A. Marshall, Salt Lake City.
542 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Clerk District Coitrt, J. R. Letcher, Salt Lake City.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Pearl E. Keeler, Logan City, Referee for
Cache County; Thomas Maloney, Ogden City, Referee for the Cotinties
of Weber and Box Elder and Davis; Charles Baldwin, Salt Lake City,
Referee for Salt Lake Cotinty and Tooele County; Elmer E. Corfman,
Provo City, Referee for the County of Utah; Frank H. Holzheimer,
Eureka, Referee for Juab Coimty; George Christensen, Mt. Pleasant,
Referee for San Peet Coimty; John Nowers, Beaver City, Referee for
Beaver County.
Business for the Coxmties of Kane, Sevier, Uinta, Summit and Davis,
on accotmt of inability to find persons to be Referees, has been referred
to other referees in other Counties.
VERMONT (2nd Circuit).
District Judge, H. H. Wheeler, Brattleboro.
Clerk District Court, George E. Johnson, Burlington.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Frank W. Tuttle, Vergennes, for Addison
County; George W. Deberville, Burlington, Chittenden County; Hiram
M. Mott, St. Albans, Frankhn County; Fred H. McFarland, Hyde Park,
Lamoille County; , Bradford, Orange
Coimty; John W. Redmond, Newport, Orleans Coimty; Joel C. Baker,
Rutland, Rutland County; Edward H. Deavitt, Montpelier, Washington
Coimty; Frank D. E. Stowe, Brattleboro, Windham County; Gilbert A.
Davis, Windsor, Windsor County; Marshall Montgomery, St. Johnsbury,
Caledonia and Essex Counties.
VIRGINIA (4th Circuit) .
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Edmund Waddill, Jr., Richmond.
Clerk District Court, George E. Bowden, Richmond, Va.
Deputy Clerk, Joseph P. Brady, Alexandria; Juno S. Fowler, Rich-
mond.
Referees with Jurisdiction.
District Number One.
Referee Walter U. Vamey of Alexandria, Virginia, comprising the
City of Alexandria, and the Counties of Alexandria, Fairfax, Loudon,
Prince William, Fauquier and Culpepper.
District Number Two.
Referee Charles P. Caldwell, of Richmond, Virginia, comprising the
City of Fredericksburg, and the Counties of Spottsylvania, Stafford,
King George, Westmoreland, Richmond, Northimiberland, Lancaster,
Essex, King and Queen, Middlesex, Gloucester, Orange, Louisa, Hanover,
Caroline, King WiUiam, New Kent and Charles City.
JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES. 543
District Number Three.
Referee Robert H. Talley, of Richmond, Virginia, comprising the
Cities of Richmond and Manchester, and the Counties of Henrico, Chester-
field, Powhatan and Goochland.
District Number Four.
Referee W. W. Forbes, of Farmville, Virginia, comprising the Coimties
of Prince Edward, Nottoway and Amelia.
District Number Five.
Referee George S. Bernard, of Petersburg, Virginia, comprising the
City of Petersburg, and the Coimties of Dinwiddie, Prince George, Surry,
Sussex, Greensville, Lunenburg, Mecklenburg and Brunswick.
District Number Six.
Referee John B. Locke, of Newport News, Virginia, comprising the
Cities of Newport News and Williamsburg, and the Counties of James
City, Warwick, York and Elizabeth City.
District Number Seven.
Referee Charles H. Causay, Jr., of Suffolk, Virginia, comprising the
Counties of Nansemond, Isle of Wight and Southampton.
District Number Eight.
Referee D. Lawrence Groner, of Norfolk, Virginia, comprising the
Cities of Norfolk and Portsmouth, and the Counties of Norfolk, Princess
Anne and Matthews.
District Number Nine.
Referee John Gofiigon, of Cape Charles City, Virginia, comprising
the Counties of Accomac and Northampton.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, H. Clay McDowell, Bigstone Gap.
Harrisburg Division.
Clerk District Court, A. K. Fletcher, Harrisonburg.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Walter H. Turner, Front Royal, Referee
for City of Winchester, Counties of Frederick, Clarke, Warren and Rap-
pahannock; Robert J. Walker, Mount Jackson, Referee for Counties of
Shenandoah and Page; Charles M. Keezel, Harrisonburg, Referee for the
Counties of Rockingham, Greene, Madison, Shenandoah and Page; J.
E . R. Nelson, Staunton, Referee for the City of Staunton and Buena
Vista, and Countie? of Augusta, Highland, Bath, Alleghany, Rockbridge,
Botewurt.
Lynchburg Division.
Clerk District Court, William McCauley, Lynchburg.
544 JUDGES, CLERKS AND REFEREES.
Referees with Jurisdiction, L. O. Hayden, Charlottsville, Referee for
the City of Charlottsv-ille, and the Cotmties of Albermarle and Fluvana;
W. C. Franklin, Pamlin, Referee for the Coiinties of Nelson, Amherst,
Appamattox, Buckingham and Cumberland; R. C. Blackford, Ljmchburg,
Referee for the City of Lynchburg, and the Covmties of Campbell and
Bradford; G. H. Penn, Roanoke, Referee for the City of Roanoke and
County of Craig.
Danville Division.
Clerk District Court, S. W. Martin, Danville.
Referees with Jurisdiction, L. S. Thomas, Danville, Referee for the
City of Danville, and the Covmties of Pittsylvania, Halifax and Charlotte;
Franklin, Henry and Patrick.
Abingdon Division.
Clerk District Court, Isaac C. Fowler, Abingdon.
Referees with Jurisdiction, O. T. Bailey, Abingdon, W. N. Ragland,
Radford, Referees for the City of Radford, and Cotmties of Montgomery,
Giles and Floyd; D. F. Bailey, Bristol, Washington W. Va., Referee for
Counties of Washington, Smyth, Grayson, Russell, Scott, Lee, Wise and
Dickinson; Thornton L. Massie, Pulaski, Referee for the Covmties of Pu-
laski, Carroll, Wythe, Scott; W. C. Pendleton, Tazewell, Referee for the
Counties of Bland, Tazewell and Buchanan.
WASHINGTON (9th Circuit).
District Judge, Cornelius H. Hanford, Seattle.
Clerk District Court, R. M. Hopkins, Seattle.
Referees with Jurisdiction, E. C. Ellis, Whatcom, and John P. Hoyt,
Seattle, Referees for the Counties of King, Kitsap, Snohomish, Skagit,
Whatcom, Island, Jefferson, Clallam and San Juan; Adolph Mvmter,
Spokane, and F. W. Dewart, Spokane, Referees for the Counties of Spo-
kane, Stevens, Adams, Lincoln, Douglas, Okanogan, Kittitas and Ferry;
H. W. Canfield, Colfax, R. D. McCuUy, Goldendale, Geo. T. Thompson,
Walla Walla, and J. A. Taggard, North Yakima, Referees for the Counties
of Walla Walla, Franklin, Columbia, Asotin, Garfield, Whitman, Yakima
and Klickitat.
WEST VIRGINIA (4th Circuit).
District Judge, John J. Jackson, Parkersburg.
Clerk District Cou^tj J. Y. Moore, Clarksburg.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Frank C. Cox, T\Tieeling, Referee for Ohio,
Wetzel, Tyler, Marion, Monongahela Covmties; B. L. Butcher, Fairmont,
Eugene Sommerville, Grafton, all Northern District; Geo. P. Shirley,
Parsons, Referee for Counties of Tucker, Randolph, Ban Buren; James
Judges, clerks and referees. 545
D. Butt, Martinsburg, Referee for Counties of Jefferson, Berkley, Morgan
and Mineral; W. Frank Stout, Clarksburg, Referee for County of Harrison;
George M. Johnson, Parkersburg, all Northern District.
WISCONSIN (7th Circuit).
EASTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, W. H. Seaman, Sheboygan.
Clerk District Court, Edward Kratz, Milwaukee.
Referees with Jurisdiction. D. Lloyd Jones, Milwaukee, Wis., Referee
for Counties of Milwaukee, Wavikesha, Ozankee, Washington, and Dodge;
Charles H. Forward, Oshkosh, Referee for Counties of Winnebago, Fond
du Lac, Green Lake, Marquette and Waushara; Paul V. Cary, Appleton,
Outagamie County, and any other Coimties in the Eastern District con-
venient for parties; Paul I. Krez, Sheboygan; Charles H. Lee, Racine,
Referee for Counties of Racine, Walworth and Kenosha; Daniel H. Sum-
ner, Waukesha, T. P. Silverwood, Green Bay, Referees for Brown Coun-
ty; Charles Churchill, Waupaca, Referee for Counties of Waupaca and
Wauskara.
Each Referee has jurisdiction of any case assigned from any part of
District.
WESTERN DISTRICT.
District Judge, Romanzo Bunn, Madison.
Clerk District Court, Franklin W. Oakley, Madison; Alfred Harrison,
La Crosse.
Referees with Jurisdiction, Henry M. Lewis, Madison, Theodore M.
Thorson, West Superior, Guy C. Prentiss, La Crosse, Referees for the
Coimties of Adams, Ashland, Barron, Bayfield, Buffalo, Burnett, Chippe-
wa, Clark, Colvmibia, Crawford, Dane, Douglas, Eau IClaire, Grant,
Green, Iowa, Iron, Jackson, Jefferson, Juneau, La Crosse, Lafayette,
Lincoln, Marathon, Monroe, Pepin, Pierce, Polk, Portage, Price, Rich-
land, Rock, St. Croix, Sank, Sawyer, Taylor, Trumpealeau, Vernon,
Vilas, Washburn, Wood.
WYOMING (8th Circuit).
District Judge, John A. Riner, Cheyenne.
Clerk District Court, Louis Kirk, Cheyenne.
Referees with Jurisdictions. Clyde M. Watts, Cheyenne, Referee for
the whole district, which comprises the entire state.
GENERAL INDEX.
A.
PAGE.
Abate — suits by or against trustee not to, by death or removal of —
Sec. 46 158
death or insanity of bankrupt not to. Sec. 8 15
Abbreviations — not to be used in petition or schedules. Gen.
Ord. V 260
Absence of bankrupt — duties and remedies of creditors. Gen.
Ord. IX 263
Judge, order of reference during. Form No. 15 316
referee to act, when. Sec. 38a (3) 148
clerk to refer cases when. Sec. 18f 118
Acceptance of appointment by trustee. Form No. 26 327
Accommodation paper, statement of, in voluntary cases. Form
• No. 1, Sch. A (5) 291
Account — deposition to prove debts in. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 272
what averment to contain. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 272
sales, required of trustees. Gen. Ord. XVIII (2) 268
Accounts— false. Sec. 29b (2) 140
inspection refused. Sec. 29c (3) 141
provable. Sec. 63a (4) 207
of marshall. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
trustee, final. Form 49, Sec. 47a (2) 270
oath to. Form No. 50 270
referee to audit. Gen. Ord. XVII. 348
Acknowledgment — of assignment of claim. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) . . 270
of letter of attorney. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
Act — bankruptcy to limit amoimt collectable. Sec. 65 (e) 219
Actions — rights of pass to trustee when. Sec. 70 (a) (6) 249
Acts of Bankruptcy. Sec. 3 31
denial of. Form No. 6 305
jury trial of. Sec. 19a '. 119
Additional Parties. Sec. 2 (6) 19
Addresses of Creditors — how ascertained and filed. Sec. 58a 185
creditors to file in involuntary cases. Gen. Ord. IX 265
voluntary bankrupt to file. Sec. 7 (8) 70
Adjudicate — courts of bankruptcy may. Sec. 2 (1) 13
or dismiss petitions, referee to. Sec. 38a (1) ' 147
547
548 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Adjudication — appeal from. Sec. 25a (1) 135
by referee. Sec. 38 (1) 147
contested, costs in. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 280
court first taking to retain jurisdiction. Gen. Ord. VI 261
date of fixes change of title. Sec. 70a 241
definition. Sec. 1 (2) 4
of bankruptcy. Form No. 11 .311
that debtor is not a bankrupt. Form No. 12 312
voluntary, when. Sec. 18g 119
when to dissolve levies, judgments and attachments. Sec
67 (f) 229
when to dissolve liens. Sec. 67 (c) 222
Adjudications. Sec. 18 113
Administering Estate — expense of. Sec. 62 (a) 204
of partnership property. Sec. 5h 57
only one trustee fee allowed. Sec. 48b. 164
trustees to furnish information of. Sec. 47a (5) 160
Admission — act of bankruptcy, when and how. Sec. 3a (5) 41
Adverse Claimants — suits against by trustee. Sec. 23 (b) 127
Affairs of Estate — right to inspection denied. Sec. 29c (3) 140
Arbitration — trustee may submit controversy to. Sec. 26 (a) 139
application for to state, what. Gen. Ord. XXXIII 280
arbitrators, three, how chosen. Sec. 26b 139
finding filed in court. Sec. 26 (c) 139
Arbitrators — how chosen. Sec. 26 (b) 139
Arrest of Bankrupt. Sec. 9 (a) (b) 76, 77
bankrupt, protected against. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Assets — of estate, property fraudulently conveyed, remains. Sec.
67 (e) 227
of estate, property seized when. Sec. 3 (e) T . . 46
none, return of. Form No. 48 346
of partners. Sec. 5 51
Assignable Property. Sec. 1 (23) 9
Assigned Claims — notice of assignment given to original claimant,
by whom. Gen. Ord. XXI (3) 271
proof of assignment to be filed. Gen. Ord. XXI (3) 271
when referee to make order subrogating assignee to claimants.
Gen. Ord. XXI (3) 271
Assignment — act of bankruptcy, when. Sec. 3 (a) (4) 7 40
of claim, acknowledged before. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
definition of. Sec. 1 (25) 10
for benefit of creditors. Sec. 3 (a) (4) 40
Assignments — by bankrupt, when void. Sec. 67 (f) 229
Attachment — ^petition creditor may obtain, when. Gen. Ord. IX. . 263
GENERAL INDEX. 549
Attachments — when void. Sec. 67 (f) 229
Attachments Against Debtors — when may issue. Gen. Ord. IX . . 263
Attempted Extortion — how punishable. Sec. 29b (5) 141
Attendance— of bankrupt. Sec. 7a (1) (9) :: 69-72
of witness. Sec. 21a, Sec. 41a (4) 154
Attorney — general letter of. Form No. 20 321
money paid to in contemplation of bankruptcy. Sec. 20 (d)
must be attorney for district or circuit court. Gen. Ord. IV 260
name and place of business of, to be entered on docket. Gen.
Ord. IV 260
papers filed by, to be endorsed. Gen. Ord. IV 260
proof of debt by. Form No. 35 334
referee may not be when. Sec. 39 (b) (2) 152
when notices to be served on. Gen. Ord. IV 260
Attorney General — duties. Sec. 53 169
Attorney in Fact— letter of. Form No. 21 322
Attorney's Fee — when prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (3) 211
when paid in contemplation of filing petition. Sec. 60 (d) . . 202
Auction — sales to be by trustee. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
Auditing — accounts of trustee. Gen. Ord.. XVII 268
Avoiding title, trustee can if creditor could. Sec. 70 (e) 250
Award of arbitrators. Sec. 26 (c) 139
Affidavit of Lost Bill or Note. Form No. 37 336
Affirm — who may. Sec. 20 (b) 121
Affirmation — definition. Sec. 1 (17) 8
false, pvmishment. Sec. 20 (b) 121
may be taken in lieu of oath. Sec. 20 (b) 121
oath to include. Sec. 1 (17) .' 8
Agent — creditors', used in act, includes. Sec. 1 (9) 5
"persons" used in act, includes. Sec. 1 (19) 9
proof of claim by. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
debt by. Form No. 35 334
offenses by or through. Sec. 29b (3) 7 141
secured debt by. Form No. 36 335
Agreement — as to value of securities. Sec. 57h 182
controversies may be settled by. Sec. 26a 139
Allowance of Appeals. Gen. Ord. XXXVI 281
of attorneys' fees. Sec. 64 b (3) 211
Allowance of Claims — appeal from. Sec. 25a (3) 15
jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (2) 135
not to affect prier declared dividends. Sec. 60 (c) 200
preferred claims. Sec. 57 (e) 177
Allowance of ©acemptions. Sec. 6 . . . .■ 58
55 O GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Allowed Claims — dividends declared on. Sec. 65 (b) 218
entitled to vote, when. Sec. 56 (a) 173
Amendment — form of; Gen. Ord. XI 264
must be ratified. Gen. Ord. XI 264
referee to cause. Sec. 39 (2) 149
setting up earlier acts of bankruptcy. Gen. Ord. VI 261
when allowed. Gen. Ord. XI 263
Amendment of Petition — when to assert act of bankruptcy. Gen.
Ord. VI 261
Amount and Number of creditors. Sec. 56 (a) 172
Amoimt of Bond — to be given by creditors in involuntary cases.
Sec. 3 (e) 46
of referee. Sec. 50 (a) 164
of trustee. Sec. 50 (b) 165
Amount of debts necessary for voluntary proceedings. Sec. 4 (b) . . 48
Answer to Petition — creditors may file. Sec. 59 (b) 191
must be accompanied by list of creditors, when. Sec. 59 (d) 191
when may be filed. Sec. 59 (b) (1) 191
Answer— in equity. U. S. Eq. R., 39, 40, 41
Appeals— Sec. 25a, Gen. Ord. XXXVI 135-281
from a judgment concerning a debt. Sec. 25 a (3) 135
governed by equity rules. Sec. 25 (a) 135
how regulated. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (1) 281
time limit for. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (2) 281
from a judgment concerning discharge. Sec. 25a (2) 135
from a judgment of adjudication. Sec. 25 (a) (1) 135
Appeal bond not required of trustees. Sec. 25 (c) 138
Appeals and Writs of Error. Sec. 25 135
Appearance — bankrupt or creditor may enter. Sec. 18 (b) 115
may be by attorney. Gen. Ord. IV 259
when that of trustee may be ordered. Sec. 11 (b) 84
Appellate Courts — definition. Sec. 1 (3) 7 4
jurisdiction. Sec. 24 132
of Circuit Court of Appeals. Sec. 24b 133
of Supreme Court. Sec. 24a 132
of Supreme Courts of the territories. Sec. 24a. . 132
Application for confirmation of composition. Form No. 61 358
Appointment — of appraisers. Form No. 13, Sec. 70 (b) 250
of receivers. Sec. 2 (3) 16
to seize and hold property. Sec. 3 (e) 46
of referees. Sec. 34 145
of trustees. Forms Nos. 23 and 27, Sec. 44 (a). Gen. Ord.
XIII 324, 328, 267, 156
of trustees' notice of. Form No. 24, Gen Ord. XVI 268
GENERAL INDEX. 551
PAGE.
Apportionment of Compensation Among — referees. Sec. 40 (c) . . 154
trustees. Sec. 48 (b) 164
Appraisement — all property to be appraised. Sec. 70 (b) 250
Appraisers — appointed by court. Sec. 70 (b) 250
appointment, oath, etc., of. Form No. 13 313
number of. Sec. 70 (b) 250
to report to the court. Sec. 70 (b) 250
B.
Bail — bankrupt may give to await examination. Sec. 9 (b) 77
Bankers — when may be adjudged bankrupts. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Banks — national, may not be bankrupts. Sec. 4 (b) 48
designated as depositories. Sec. 61 204
shall pay out money how. Gen. Ord. XXIX 277
Bankrupt — arrest of exemption from. Sec. 9a 76
Bankrupt — arrest of, exemption from. Sec. 9a 76
to prevent leaving district. Sec. 9b 77
release~from. Gen.; Ord. XXX 277
burden of proving solvency is on. Sec. 3 (c) 44
composition, when may be offered by. Sec. 12 (a) So
contempt of, for refusal to deliver assets. Sec. 41 154
death or insanity of, not to abate proceedings. Sec. 8 75
detention of. Sec. 9 76
discharge of, co-debtor not affected by. Sec. 16 104
from arrest. Sec. 9 76
debts. Sec. 2 (12), Sec 14, Sec. 17. .25, 89, 105
revocation of. Sec. 16 104
duties of. Sec. 7 69
estate of defined, what includes. Sec. 70 241
jurisdiction of court over. Sec. 2 (7) 19
examination of concerning his business. Sec. 8 (9)
arrest of for. Sec. 9 (b) 77
creditors to have notice of . Sec. 58a (1) . . 185
form for. Form No. 29 329
order for. Form No. 28 328
exemptions of, courts of bankruptcy, jtmsdiction of. Sec.
2 (11) 24
exemptions of, allowance of. Sec. 6 58
trustee to set aside. Sec. 47a (11) 161
extradition of, jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (14) 27
from one district to another. Sec. 10 78
is competent witness. Sec. 21 (a) 122
. may appear by attorney. Gen. Ord. IV 260
552 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Bankrupt — Continued.
may conduct proceedings in person. Gen. Ord. IV 260
offenses by. Sec. 29 (b) 140
property of concealing, punishment. Sec. 29 (a) 140
referee may order surrendered. Sec. 38a (3) . . 148
seizure of before adjudication. Sec. 3 b 42
suits by and against. Sec. 11 78
title to vests in trustee. Sec. 70 T 241
trustee may avoid transfer of when. Sec. 70 e 250
what reckoned in determining insolvency. Sec. 1 (15) ... . 7
who is. Sec. 1 (4) .^ 4
who may be adjudged. Sec. 2 (1), Sec. 4 13-47
Bankruptcy — acts of, what are. Sec. 3 32
adjudication of. 18 (d), Form No. 12 117-312
courts of, creation and jurisdiction. Sec. 2 12
jurisdiction of to punish violations of the act.
Sec. 2 12
power of not restricted by enumeration. Sec. 2. . 12
date or time of defined. Sec. 1 (10) 6
law of, congress may enact court. Sec. 8 1
statute, time when it takes effect 251
Bankrupt's petition for discharge. Form No. 57 354
Belief — reasonable cause for as affecting liens. Sec. 67c (2) 223
Bills or notes lost, statement of. Form No. 37 336
Blanks to be furnished referee, when. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
Bona fide holder — must hold for value prior to adjudication. Sec.
67 (e) 227
of property protected. Sec. 70 (e) 250
Bonds — joint and several when. Sec. 50 (j) 166
liability on. Sec. 50 (h) 166
limitation of suits on. Sec. 50 (m) 7 166
sued on, how. Sec. 50 (h) 166
sureties on number of. Sec. 50 (b) 165
where filed. Sec. 50 (h) 166
Bonds — applicant for receiver must give. Sec. 3 (e) 46
form of. Form No. 9 -. 308
seizure of property must give. Sec. 69 (a) . . 239
liability for unlawful seizure. See 69 339
for appearance. Sec. 9 (b)
depositories to give. Sec. 61 204
of marshal. Form No. 10 310
petitioners to give, form of. Form No. 9, Sec. 69 309, 239
GENERAL INDEX. 553
PAGE.
Bonds, 1?rustees' — ^no appeals allowed. Sec. 25 (c) 138
approved by referee. Sec. 50b, Form No. 25, 26 165, 326, 327
certified copy of order approving evidence of vesting title
in. Sec. 21 (e) 125
corporation may be surety on. Sec. 50 (g) 166
court fixes amount of when. Sec. 44a, 50 (c) 165
creditors fix amount of when. Sec. 50 (c) 165
failure to give vacates office. Sec. 50 (k) 166
filed in clerks' office. Sec. 50 (h) 166
form of trustee's bond. Form No. 25 326
sued on, how. Sec. 50h 166
sureties, number of. Sec. 50 (e) 165
referees. Sec. 50a 164
amount, how fixed. Sec. 50a .^ 164
corporations, sureties on. Sec. 50g 166
failure to give vacates office. Sec. 50k 166
filed where. Sec. 50h 166
limitation of suits on. Sec. 50 1 166
Bond — order approving trustee's. Form No. 26 327
when bankrupt may give. Sec. 69 (a) 239
when creditors to give. Sec. 69 (a) 239
possession is taken of bankrupt's property. Sec. 3 . . . . 32
Books of account — concealment or destruction of. Sec. 14 (b) (2) . . 100
duty of bankrupt to produce on examination. Sec. 3 (d) . . . . 45
failure to keep effect of on discharge. Sec. 14 (b) (2) 48
Belief — reasonable cause for as affecting liens. Sec. 67 (e) (2) . . . . 223
Bills or notes lost, statement of. Form No. 37 336
Burden of Proof — discharge creditors have who oppose. Sec. 15 ... . 103
solvency is on bankrupt when. Sec. 3 (c) , Sec. 3 (e) 44—46
Business of Bankrupt — continuation of authorized. Sec. 2 (5) ... . 18
place of may determine jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (1) 13
C.
Cases — appeals in what may be taken. Sec. 25 135
in which referees not to act. Sec. 40 (b) 153
index of to be kept by clerk. Sec. 71 255
jurisdiction to reinstate. Sec. 2 (12) 25
preceedings in partnership. Gen. Ord. VIII 263
referees fee in cases transferred. Sec. 40 (b) 153
reference of when judge absent. Sec. 18 (g) 119
after adjudication. Sec. 22 .' 125
order of. Form No. 14 314
record of how and by whom kept. Sec. 42 155
transfer of from one referee to another. Sec. 22 (b) 126
554 GENERAL INDEX.
PA6B.
Cases — Continued
jurisdiction to. Sec. 2 (19) o 30
when to another district. Gen. Ord. IV 260
when may be tried before a jury. Sec 19 119
Certificate — by referee to judge. Gen. Ord. XXIII .' 275
form of. Form No. 56 353
of controversies to the Supreme Court. Sec. 25 (d) 138
of justice of Supreme Court necessary to appeals in what
cases Sec. 25 (b) (2) 137
of discharge, form of. Form No. 59 356
when to issue. Sec. 14 89
of search clerks to issue. Sec. 71 255
Certified Copies of — proceedings in bankruptcy evidence. Sec. 21 (d) 124
order concerning composition or discharge. Sec. 21 (f) . . . . 125
order approving trustee's bond evidence of title. Sec. 21 (e) 125
order confirming composition evidence of investing title.
Sec. 21 (g) 125
Certiorari — when writs of may issue. Sec. 25 (d) 138
Checks — money to be paid out by only. Sec. 47 (a) (4), Gen. Ord.
XXIX 160, 277
to be coiintersigned by judge or referee. Gen. Ord. XXIX . . 277
Children's allowance not affected by death. Sec. 8 75
Choice of new trustee form of order for. Form No. 55 352
Choses in action statement of. Form No. 1, Sch. B (3) 298, 294
Circuit Court — (see covirts) cases may be certified to for trial by jury.
Sec. 19 (b) 120
concturent jurisdiction of offenses. Sec. 23 (c) 132
jurisdiction of in law and equity. Sec. 23 (a) 126
over suits by trustees when. Sec. 23 (a) 126
Circuit Court of Appeals — (see courts) (see appeals) appeals from
courts of bankruptcy to . Sec. 24 (f) 133
are Appellate Courts of bankruptcy. Sec. 1 (3) 4
jurisdiction of over bankruptcy. Sec. 24 (a) 132
practice governing appeal to. Gen. Ord. XXXIII 280
to Supreme Court from. Sec. 25 (b) '. 137
Claimant — cannot collect more than act authorizes. Sec. 65 (e) . . 219
when to be served with notice of depositions. Sec. 21 (c) . . 124
Claims — (see debt) (proof of claims) account open, how proved.
Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
adverse claims, bankruptcy court jurisdiction to determine.
Sec. 2 (7) 19
against other bankrupts may be proved by trustee. Sec. 57
(m) 184
allowed after dividends, how paid. Sec. 65 (c) 218
GENERAL INDEX. 555
PAGE.
Claims — Continued.
jurisdiction to allow. Sec. 2 (2) 15
unless opposed to be allowed. Sec. 57 (d) 177
reconsideration of allowance. Sec. 57k 184
amount of computation of. Sec. 59 (a) 187
appeal from allowance of. Sec. 25 a (3) 135
assignment of claims, how shown. Gen. Ord. XXI (3) . . . . 271
bankrupt to examine. Sec. 7 (3) 70
compounding claims. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 276
false, oath as to (see offenses). Sec. 29b (3) 141
false, bankrupt to inform trustee as to. Sec. 7 (7) 70
firm, proved against bankrupt member. Sec. 5 (a) 51
limitations of time to prove. Sec. 57n 7 184
liquidation of. Sec. 64b 211
list of recorded by referee. Form No. 40 338
partnership against individual estate. Sec. 5 (f) 57
penalties and forfeitures not allowed. Sec. 57 j 184
prior in paj'^ment. Sec. 64 610
proof of, (see proof of claims) . Sec. 57 173
bankrupt to examine correctness of. Sec. 7 (3) ... . 70
before whom oath may be taken. Sec. 20 121
corporations, how prove. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) . . . . 270
depositions to establish. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) . . . . 270
form of, by agent or attorney. Form No. 36 335
by corporation. Form No. 33 332
by partnership. Form No 34 333
secured debt by agent. Form No. 36. . . . 335
secured debt. Form No. 32 331
tmsecured debt. Form No. 31 329
may be expunged. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
surety for creditor may make. Sec. 57 (i) 183
within what time to be made. See. 57 (m) 184
provable, what are (see debts which may be proved) . Sec. 63 205
proved, after dividend declared. Sec. 65 c , 218
preferred must be surrendered. Sec. 57g, Sec 60 (a) (b)
178,192,197
proved, transmission of to clerk . Gen. Ord. XXIV 274
re-examination of. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
set-off, when allowed. Sec. 60 (c). Sec. 68 200-238
unrecorded when not liens. Sec. 67 a 220
when allowance of not to affect rights of creditors. Sec.
65 (c) 218
where to be filed. Sec. 57c 177
which have priority. Sec. 64 210
5 $6 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE
Claims — Continued.
objections to. Sec. 57 (f) 7 178
penalty and forfeiture. Sec. 57 (j) 7 183
preferences. Sec. 57 (g) 178
proved after dividends declared, dividends paid on. Sec.
65 (c) 218
which have priority, schedule a (1). Form No. 1 287
Clerk — wages of a prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (4.) 214
Clerks— includes what. Gen. Ord. XXXV (1) 275
duties. Sec. 51 167
account for fees. Sec. 51 (1) 167
collect fees. Sec. 51 (2) 167
deliver papers to referee. Sec. 51 (3) ^. ... 168
issue process summons, etc. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
pay fees to referee and Trustee. Gen. Ord. 51 (4) . . . . 168
reference by when made. Sec. 18f 118
referees records to be transmitted to. Sec. 39b (7) 151
(see duties of clerks) (officers) compensation of. Sec.
62 (a) 168
compensation of. Gen. Ord. XXXV (1) 281
definition. Sec. 1 (5) 5
may require indemnity for expense. Gen. Ord. X 264
filing papers by. Gen. Ord. II 259
to endorse time of filing and character on papers filed. Gen.
Ord. II 259
to enter cases in docket and number. Gen Ord. 1 259
to keep docket. Gen. Ord. 1 259
to sign checks for withdrawal of money deposited. Gen.
Ord. XXIX 277
to test process. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
Co-debtor of Bankrupt — liability not affected by discharge. Sec. 16 104
Commencement of Proceedings — definition. Sec. 1 (10) 6
Commissions — of referee. Sec. 40 (a) 15
of trustees. Sec. 48 (a) 162
Commissioner of Deeds — ^may be referee. Sec. 35 (a) (2) 146
Commissioner — U. S. acknowledgment before. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
Commitment — for contempt, practice. Sec. 41 (b) 155
referee, no power of. Sec. 38 (a) (2) 147
Compensation — of clerk. Sec. 52 (a) 168
of clerks, referees and trustees. Gen. Ord. XXXV 275
of marshal. Sec. 52 (b) 169
of referees. Sec. 40 (a) 152
of stenographers. Sec. 38 (5) 149
of trustee. Sec. 48a 162
GENERAL INDEX. 557
PAGE.
Compensation — Continued.
withheld from trustees, when. Sec. 48 (c) 164
Composition — Sec. 12, 13 85-89
Application for. Sec. 12 (b) 86
application for confirmation of. Form No. 61 358
order on. Form No. 62. . 359
approval of, judge to hear. Gen. Ord. XII 265
by whom approved. Gen. Ord. XII (3) 266
confirmation of, property to revest in bankrupt. Sec. 70 (f) 251
by judge when. Sec. 12d 87
confirmation or rejection and setting aside. Sec. 2 (9) 24
discharge on. Sec. 14 (c) 103
distribution to be as court directs. Sec. 12(b) 89
notice of. Sec. 58 (a) (2) 185
opposition to. Gen. Ord. XXXII 273
order confirming. Form No. 62 359
^ of distribution on. Form No. 63 360
petition for meeting to consider. Form No. 60 357
when set aside. Sec. 13 89
title to property to vest in trustee. Sec.
70 (d) 250
Compositions — when set aside what claims to be prior. Sec. 64 (c) 217
Compounding of Claims. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 276
Compromise — notice of. Sec. 58 (a) (7) 186
Compromises. Sec. 27 a 139
notice to creditors on. Sec. 58 (a) (7) 186
Computation of Time. Sec. 31 142
Computing Number of Creditors. Sec. 59 (ej 191
Conceal— definition. Sec. 1 (22) 9
Concealment — act of bankruptcy. Sec. 3 (a) (1) 32
from trustee by bankrupt. Sec. 29 (b) (1) 140
of book prevents discharge — . Sec. 14 (b) (s) 100
Concurrence of two out of three trustees necessary. Sec. 47 (b) . . 161
Concurrent Jurisdiction — of offenses in Circuit Courts. Sec. 23 (c) 132
Conditional Sale, see transfer. Sec. 1 (25) 10
Conduct of Business — courts of bankruptcy may supervise. Sec.
2 (5) 18
Conduct of Proceedings — in person or by attorney. Gen. Ord. IV 260
Conflicting Petitions — disposal of in different districts. Gen. Ord.
VI 261
disposal of in same districts. Gen. Ord. VII 261
Consanguinity — petitioning creditors not to be coimted for accoimt
of. Sec. 59 (e) 191
558 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Consent — creditors may meet by. Sec. 55 (b) 171
jurisdiction by. Sec. 23 (b) 127
Consent of parties — not to dismiss proceedings without notice to
creditors . Sec. 59 (g) ^ 192
Consular officers may administer oaths in foreign countries. Sec.
20 (3) 121
Contemplation of bankruptcy as affecting liens. Sec. 67 (c) (2) . . . . 223
Contempts before Referees . Sec. 2 (16) 29
Sec. 41 (a) 154
procedure. Sec. 41 (b) 154
Contested adjudications — costs in. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 274
Contested Matters — referee to make up records in. Sec. 39 a (5) ... . 150
Contingent Liability — proof and dividend. Gen. Ord. XXI (4) . . . . 272
Continuation of busmess. Sec. 2 (5) IS
Conveyance — when court may order. Sec. 67 (f) 229
Contract — debt founded on provable. Sec. 63 (a) (4) 207
Contracts — rights of action on, title to. Sec. 70 (a) (6) 249
Controversies — arbitration of. Gen. Ord. XXXIII 274
Convenience of — creditors consulted in first meetings. Sec. 55a. . . 170
parties grovmd for transfer of case. Sec. 32 a 143
trustee consulted in selecting depositories. Sec. 61 204
Conversion of securities to determine value. Sec. 57 (h) 182
Conveyances — to be made by trustee. Sec. 70 (c) 250
within four months void. Sec. 67 (e) 227
Copies — certified, when admissible. Sec. 21d 124
of written instruments, when filed. Sec. 57 (b) 177
Copjnights — title to passes to trustee. Sec. 70 (a) (2) 241
Correctness of Claims — duty of bankrupt to examine. Sec. 7 (a) (3) 70
Corporation — definition. Sec. 1 (6) 5
may be sixrety. Sec. 50 (g) 166
may be trustees. Sec. 45 (a) (2) 158
officer of to execute letter of attorney. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) . . 272
proof of claim to be by treasurer when. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 276
proof of debt due to. Form No. 33 332
what may be involuntary bankrupts. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Costs — expenses are part of. Gen. Ord. X 264
fees deposited when. Sec. 51 (a) (4) 168
Costs— taxing. Sec. 2 (18) . , 29
in contested adjudications. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 274
of administration prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (3) 211
of immaterial depositions. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
of preserving estate, prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (1 211
on seizure of property. Sec. 3 (e) 46
provable debts, when. Sec. 63 (a) (3) (4) 207
GENERAL INDEX. 559
PAGE.
Counsel fees — see seizure. Sec. 3 (e) 46
Counselors in bankruptcy — referees cannot be. Sec. 40 a (2) 152
Counterclaims and set off. Sec. 68 238
Counties — referees appointed in when needed. Sec. 34 (a) (2) . . . . 146
Court — appoints trustees when. Sec. 44 156
appraisers to report to. Sec. 70 (3) 250
Appellate, defined. Sec. 1 (3) 4
definition. Sec. 1 (7) 5
may allow amendments to petition and schedules. Gen.
Ord. XI 264
call special meeting of creditors. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
discharge imprisoned debtor. Gen. Ord. XXX 277
order appointment of trustee. Gen. Ord. XV 267
sale of perishable goods on petition when. Gen.
Ord. XVIII 269
that no meeting of creditors be held after &rst meet-
ing. Gen. Ord. XV 267
sales made subject to approval of. Sec. 70 (b) 250
to appoint appraisers. Sec. 70 (b) 250
Supreme, appeals to when taken. Sec. 25(b) 137
controversies may be certified to. Sec. 25 (d) . . . . 138
when may order conveyance. Sec. 67 (f) 229
United States and State jurisdiction of. Sec. 23 126
Courts of Bankruptcy — created and defined. Sec. 2 12
and their jurisdiction. Sec. 2 , 12
appeals from. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (1) 282
definition. Sec. 1 (8) . , 5
to designate depositories of money and fix bonds. Sec. 61 (a) 204
Courts and Procedure— Ch. IV, Sec. 18 to 32 114
Courts — Appellate. Sec. 24 132
in appeal case, to certify what. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (3) 282
jurisdiction. Sec. 23 126
Creation of Offices— Sec. 33 (a) 145
Credit — given by creditor after preference. Sec. 60 (c) 200
Creditor — (see creditors) definition. Sec. 1 (9) 5
entitled to balance only after set-offs allowed. Sec. 68. . . . 238
may appear by attorney. Gen. Ord. IV 260
may manage his own interest before the bankruptcy court.
Gen. Ord. IV 260
offense, punishment. Sec. 29 (b) (3) 141
recovery of dividend. Sec. 57 (1) 184
secured. Sec. 56 (b) 173
definition. Sec. 1 (23) 9
56o GENERAL INDEX.
PARE.
Creditor — Continuee.
to file schedule, when. Gen. Ord. IX 263
when allowed costs. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 280
Creditors— Ch. VI, Sec. 55 to 60 170
appoint trustee. Sec. 44 a 156
as voters. Sec. 56 172
bond of . Sec. 69 239
when required. Sec. 3 (e) 46
claims (see proof of claims) Sec. 57 a 173
proof of forms for. Forms No. 31, 37 330
damage bond. Form No. 9 309
entitled to information of estates from referees. Sec. 39
(a) (3) 150
entitled to notice of compromise. Sec. 58 (a) (7) 186
declaration of dividends. Sec. 58 (a) (5) 185
dismissal of petition. Sec. 59 (g) 192
dismissal of proceedings. Sec. 58 (a) (8) 186
examinations of bankrupts. Sec. 58
(a) (4) 185
filing of trustee's accounts. Sec. 58
(a) (6) 186
hearing on composition or discharge.
Sec. 58 (a) (2) 185
notice of meetings of creditors. Sec.
58 (a) (3) 185
payment of dividends. Sec. 58 (a) (5) 186
sales of property. Sec. 58 (a) (4) 185
failing to appoint trustees, court shall. Sec. 44 156
final meeting of. Sec. 55 (f) 172
issue as to number of, how formed. Sec. 59 d 191
letter to trustee. Form No. 41 339
list of debts proved at first meeting. Form No. 18 319
may enter appearance in opposition to discharge. Gen.
Ord. XXXII 280
may file involuntary petition when. Sec. 59 (b) 187
may request meeting. Sec. 55 (d) (e) 172
meetings of. Sec. 55 170
names and addresses of creditors to be transmitted to clerk.
Gen. Ord. XXIV 274
notice of first meeting, form of. Form No. 18 319
notices to. Sec. 58 185
by referee. Sec. 39 (a) (4) '160
offenses by. Sec. 29 (b) 140
petitioning, bond of. Form No. 9 309
GENERAL INDEX. 5^'
PAGE.
Creditors — Continued.
of partnership. Sec. 5 (6) 51
petition. Form No. 3 301
petitioning or opposing may conduct proceedings. Gen.
Ord. IV 260
preferences. Sec. 57 g 178
receiving dividends, rights of (see dividends). Sec. 65 c . . . 218
rights against bankrupt may be enforced by tnistee when.
Sec. 67 (b) 222
preference. Sec. 57 (g) 178
special meeting of . Gen. Ord. XXV 275
court may call. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
subsequent meetings of, after first meeting. Sec. 55 (d) (e) 172
surety. Sec. 57 (e) 177
those within the U. S. to be first paid, sum equal to etc.
Sec. 65 (d) 218
three may file involimtary petition. Sec. 59 (b) 187
voters at meetings. Sec. 56 172
when first meeting only may be held. Gen. Ord. XV 267
Creditors in Involuntary Petition — niunber, how computed. Sec.
59 (e) 191
joining in involuntary petitions, who not to be counted.
Sec. 59 (e) 191
letter to trustee. Form No. 41 339
petition, form of. Form No. 3 301
order to show cause on. Form No. 4 303
Criminal — jurisdiction (see concurrent jurisdiction). Sec. 23 (c) . . 132
proceedings, examination of bankrupt not evidence in. Sec.
7 (9) 72
Cross-examination of Witnesses. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Custody of Property — by marshal. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
D.
Damages — for seizing property. Sec. 3 (e) ... .7 32
right of action for title to. Sec. 70 (a) (6) 249
Date of bankruptcy — definition. Sec. 1 (10) 6
time of. See adjudication, Sec. 1 (2) 4
Days, how computed (see computation of time) 240
Date of investiture of title. Sec. 70a. Sec. 31 (a) 142
Death — of bankrupt. Sec. 8 75
of trustee. Sec. 46 (a) 158
Debt— definition. Sec. 1 (11) 6
Appeal from allowance or rejection of. Sec. 25 (a) (3) 135
proof of, by agent or attorney. Form No. 35 334
562 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Debt — Continued.
partnership. Form No. 34 333
secured. Form No. 32 331
unsecured. Form No. 31 330
unsecured, proof of by agent. Form No. 36 335
Debt due corporation — proof of. Form No. 33 332
Debtor — imprisoned, produced before referee. Gen. Ord. XXX 277
when to furnish schedule. Gen. Ord. IX 263
Debtors — adjudication that not bankrupt. Form No. 11 311
petition, form of. Form No. 1 285
recover costs, when Gen. Ord. XXXIV 280
Debts— what are a fixed liability (See debt) . Sec. 63 (a) (1) 205
costs of administration. Sec. 64 (b) (3) 211
preserving estate subsequent to filing petition. Sec.
64 (b) ( 1) 211
entitled to .priority imder state laws. Sec. 64 (b) (5) 216
having priority. Sec. 64 210
due as costs. Sec. 63 (a) (2) 206
due as costs. Sec. 63 (a) (3) 207
on debts reduced to judgment after filing of petition. Sec.
63 (a) (5) 209
Debts — due on open account. Sec. 63 (a) (4) 207
filing fees of creditors. Sec. 64 (b) (2) 211
not affected by discharge. Sec. 17 (a) 105
proved at first meeting list of. Form No. 19 320
wages earned in three months. Sec. 64 (b) (4) 214
which may be proved. Sec 63 (a) 205
Debts and assets — form for summary of. Form No. 1 298
Declaration of dividends. Sec. 65 (a) (b) 217-218
notice to creditors of . Sec. 58(a) (5) 185
Deed. See Document, Sec. 1 (13). Transfer, Sec. 1 (25) 10
from bankrupt to trustee, the equivalent of . Sec. 21 (e) 125
from trustee to bankrupt. Sec. 21 (g) 125
Deeds, books, papers and writings — list of. Form No. 1 298
Defalcation — not discharged from liability for. Sec. 17 (4) 110
Default — clerk may refer after. Sec. 18 (f) 118
When may be taken against bankrupt and creditors. Sec.
18 (e) 117
Defeat act — effort to. See offenses. Sec. 29 (f) (4) 141
Defense to proceeding in bankruptcy — solvency. Sec. 3 (c) 44
Definitions, Ch. 1, Sec. 1 (a) 3
Delivery and return of papers between clerks and referees. Sec. 51
(al (3) 167
Demand. See debt. Sec. 1 (11) 6
GENERAL INDEX. 503
PAGE.
Denial of bankruptcy. Form No. 6 305
Denying discharge, appeal from order. Sec. 25 (a) (2) 135
Deposit of moneys — See Duties of Trustees. Sec. 47 (a) (3) 159
Depositions. Sec. 21 (b) 124
before referee, how taken. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
notice of. Sec. 21 (c) 124
to prove accounts. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
to prove claims, how entitled. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
Depositories for money. Sec. 61 204
courts of bankruptcy to designate. Sec.
61 (a) : 204
courts of bankruptcy to fix bond of. Sec.
61 (a) 204
money must be deposited in. Sec. 47 (a) (3) 159
money may be increased. Sec. 61 (a) 204
Depository — how money withdrawn from. Gen. Ord. XXIX 277
to be furnished with copy of order for payment of money and
name of referee. Gen. Ord. XXIX 277
Designation — of depositories. Sec. 61 204
Designation — of newspapers. Sec. 28 T 139
of referee's districts. Sec. 34 (a) (2) 146
Destroyed Note or Instrument — how proven. Sec. 57 (b) 176
Destruction of books prevents discharge. Sec. 14 (b) (2) 100
Detention — of bankrupt. Sec. 9b 77
of property. See seizure. Sec. 3 (e) 46
right of action for passes to trustee. Sec. 70 (a)
(6) 249
Deterioration — ground for taking possession. Sec. 69 239
Determination of value of securities. Sec. 57h 182
Diminishing Claims — how and when. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
Diplomatic officers may administer oaths in foreign cotmtries. Sec.
20 (3) 121
Directors — see persons. Sec. 1 (19) 9
not released from liability. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Disbursements and receipts — trustee must account for. Sec. 47 (a)
(6) 160
how made by trustees. Sec. 47 (a) (6) 160
Disallowance of Claims — jtxrisdiction. Sec. 2 (2) 15
appeal from. Sec. 25 (a) (3) 135
Discharge — application for. Gen. Ord. XII 265
co-debtors not affected by. Sec. 16 104
by composition. Sec. 14c 103
by whom granted. Gen. Ord. XII (3) 266
564 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Discharge — Continued .
credit extended after (See Priority) . Sec. 64 (c) T 217
debts not affected by. Sec. 17 .' 105
definition. Sec. 1 (12) 6
evidence of. See Proof. Sec. 21 (f) 125
hearing for. Sec. 14 (b) 90
hearing on, notice to creditors. Sec. 58 (a) (2) 185
jurisdiction to grant. Sec. 2 (12) 25
may be referred to referee. Gen. Ord. XII 265
objection to. Sec. 14 (b) 90
of bankrupt form for. Form No. 59 187
opposition to. Gen. Ord. XXXII 278
petition for. Form No. 57 173
what to state. Gen. Ord. XXXII 278
referee's jimsdiction over. Sec. 38 (a) (4) 148
revoked, trustee appointed when. Sec. 44 156
setting aside jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (12) 25
specifications of objections. Form No. 57 187
on objection to. Gen. Ord. XXXII 278
when granted. Sec. 14 (a) 89
revoked. Sec. 15 (a) 103
title to bankrupt's property in Trustee Sec.
70 (d) 251
Discharging preferences — failure to, act of bankruptcy. Sec. 3 (a) (3) 36
trustee, order for after allowing account. Form No. 51 349
Discharge of Bankrupt — order for. Form No. 59 356
Discretion of court as to costs of objectionable matter.^ Gen. Ord.^
XXII 273
Disinterested — appraisers must be. Sec. 70 (b) 250
Dismiss petitions — referees may when. Sec. 38 (a) (1) 147
Dismissal of Proceedings — notice of. Sec. 58 (a) (8) 186
notice of. Sec. 59 (g) 192
lack of sufficient cause for. Sec. 59d 191
Disobedience before referee. (See contempts.) Sec. 41 (a) (1) . . . . . 154
District Court — when taay issue habeas corpus. Gen. Ord. XXX . .'. 277
a cotirt of bankruptcy. Sec. 2 12
Districts of referees. Sec. 34a (2) 146
District of Columbia, Supreme Court of — Appeals from. Gen. Ord.
XXXVI (2) 282
Jiuisdiction of. Sec 1 (8) 5
Dividend Notices — form of. Form No. 41 339
Dividend Sheet — referee to furnish to trustee. Sec. 39 (1) 149
Dividends — belonging to minors. Sec. 66 (b) 218
claims not to affect, when. Sec. 65 (c) 218
GENERAL INDEX. 565
PAGE.
Dividends — Continued .
declaration and payment of. Sec. 65 T 217
first dividend when declared. Sec. 65 (b) T 218
judge may order, when. Sec. 65 (b) 218
list of recorded by referee. Form No. 40 338
not to be paid unless. Gen. Ord. XXI (4) 272
notice of. Form No. 41 339
declaration, etc. Sec. 58 (a) (5) 185
recovered on claims reconsidered and rejected. Sec. 57(1). .. 184
referee to declare. Sec. 39 (1) 149
to be paid into court, when. Sec. 66 (a) 219
on allowed claims, when. Sec. 65 (a) 217
unclaimed. Sec. 66 219
when creditors within the United States to be first paid. Sec.
65 (d) 219
to be distributed. Sec. 66 (b) 219
paid on contingent claims. Gen. Ord. XXI (4) . . 272
paid the bankrupt. Sec. 66 (b) 219
Docket. Gen. Ord. I 259
clerk to keep. Gen. Ord. I 7 259
name of attorney to be entered on docket. Gen. Ord. I 259
open to public inspection. Gen. Ord. I 259
what to contain. Gen. Ord. I 7 259
Document — definitions. Sec. 1 (13) 6
Documents — neglect to produce contempt. Sec. 41a (3) . . . . T 154
title to. See Title. Sec. 70 (a) (1) 241
Domicile — jurisdiction. Sec. 2(1) 13
of debtor, controls first hearing when. Gen. Ord. VI 261
Drafts — disbursements to be by. Sec. 47(a) (4) 160
Duplicate — petition filed in. Sec. 59(c) 190
Duties of attorney General. Sec. 53a 169
Duties of Bankrupt. See Bankrupt. Sec. 7. . . 7 69
Duties of clerks. (See Clerks.) Sec. 51a 7 167
Duties of referees. (See Referees.) Sec. 39a, Gen. Ord. XII 149-265
Duties of trustees. (See Trustees.) Sec. 47a, Gen. Ord. XVII. 168-268
Earlier act of bankruptcy, when amendment setting up allowed. See
Petitions in different districts. Gen. Ord. VI 261
Effect, when Act goes into 241
Embezzlement by trustee. (See Offenses.) Sec. 29a. . 7 . . 7 140
not dischargable debt. Sec. 17(4) 7 110
Employes of bankrupt — not counted as creditors, when. Sec. 59 (e). 191
Enforced, what liens may be. See Liens, Sec. 67d. . . . 7 224
S66 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Enforcement of liens, trustees may effect for benefit of estate. Sec.
67(c) (3) 223
Entries on docket, what required. See Docket, Gen. Ord. 1 259
Entry of cases. See Docket, Gen. Ord. 1 259
of appearance, what must include. Gen. Ord. IV 260
Equalization of dividends. (See Dividends.) Sec. 55c 218
Equity jurisdiction. (See Circuit Courts.) Sec. 23a 126
Equity practice followed on appeals. Gen. Ord. XXXVI . . , 281
Eqmty rides govern in bankruptcy. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 282
Error. See Appeals. Sec. 25 135
Errors of referee, how corrected. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
Equity rules. See United States Equity Rules 363
Estates — closing and re-opening — power to. Sec. 2(8) 23
collection and distribution. Sec. 2(7) 19
how administered by three trustees. Sec 47b 161
how closed up. See Duties of Trustees. Sec. 47. 158
in bankruptcy, referee cannot ptu-chase. Sec. 39b (3) 7 . . 152
information to be furnished by referees. Sec. 39(a) (3) 150
inspection of affairs of refused. (See Offenses.) Sec. 29(c)
(3) 141
jiuisdiction of. Sec. 2 (7) 19
of individuals. Sec. 5(g) 57
of partners. Sec. 5 51
property fraudulently conveyed, assets of. (See liens.)
Sec. 67(e) 227
reports on condition of , made to courts, when. Sec. 47(a) (10). 160
trustees must collect and reduce to cash. Sec. 47(a) (2) 159
Evidence — examinations, when taken. See. 21 (a) 122
of revesting title. Sec. 21 (g) 125
of trustees' title. Sec. 21 (e) , 125
referee to preserve. Sec. 39(9) 151
taken in absence of stenographer. Sec. 39(a) (9) 151
Examination — bankrupt shall submit to. Sec. 7(9) 72
Examination of bankrupt. Form No. 29 328
as to solvency. Sec. 3 (d) 45
at first meeting. Sec. 55(b) 171
duty of bankrupt to submit to. Sec. 7(a) (9) 72
notice of to creditors. Sec. 58(a) (1) 185
refusal to submit to contempt. Sec. 41(a) (4) 154
stenographically reported, when. Sec. 38(a) (5) 149
Examination of witnesses. Sec. 38(a) (2) , Gen. Ord. XXII 147-273
Examinations — order for, of bankrupt. Form No. 28 328
Exceptions — to referee's findings. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
GENERAL INDEX. $67
PAGE.
Exceptions — Continued.
to trustee's report, argument on. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
Execution of assignment of claim. Gen. Ord. XII (5) 273
letter of attorney. Gen. Ord. XXII(5) 273
of papers. (See Duties of Bankrupts.) Sec. 7(4) 70
Exempt property — statement of claim to. Form No. 1., Sch. B(5) . .
298, 297
title to not in trustee. Sec. 70 (a) 241
Exemption of bankrupts — jiuisdiction to determine. Sec. 2(11) . . 24
not effected by bankruptcy. Sec. 6a 58
trustee to set apart. Sec. 47(a) (11) 161
when set oflf. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
Expenses — indemnity may be required for. Gen. Ord X 264
of publishing notices. Gen.. Ord XXXV (2) 281
to be allowed of estates. Sec. 62 (a) 204
examined by the court. Sec. 62 (a) 204
reported in detail under oath. Sec. 62 (a) 204
of administering estates Sec. 62 204
marshal, return of to be made under oath. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
referee, include what. Gen. Ord. XXVI 275
stenographer. Sec. 38 (a) (5) 149
when bankrupt entitled to. Sec. 7 69
Expimging claims. See Proof Debts. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
Expunging claims — order for. See Form No. 39 337
Extortions (see Offenses) . Sec. 29 (b) (5) 141
Extradition of bankrupts. Sec. 10 78
bankrupts' jurisdiction of. • Sec. 2 (14) 27
P.
Facts reported by referee, when. Gen. Ord. XII (3) 266
Failure to give bond creates vacancy. Sec. 50k 166
False affirmation — punishment, same as false oath. Sec. 20 (b) 121
claim — pimishment for filing. Sec. 29 (b) (3) 141
oath— pimishment for. Sec. 29 (b) (2) 141
Falsify— definition. Sec. 1 (22) 9
Farmers excepted from involuntary proceedings. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Fees— judge may order paid. Gen. Ord. XXXV (4) 281
witnesses prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (3) 211
Fees — and commissions of referees. Sec. 40 (a) 152
and commissions of trustees. Sec. 48 162
clerks must collect and account for. Sec. 51 (a) (4) 168
deposited by moving creditors have priority. Sec. 64b (2) . . . . 211
deposited when paid out. Sec. 51 (a) (4) 168
in volimtary cases, how collected. Gen. Ord. XXXV (4) 282
568 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Fees — Continued .
judge may order paid. Gen. Ord. XXXV (4) 282
of attorneys for bankrupt examined into. Sec. 60d. . .7 202
of clerks. Gen. Ord. XXXV (4) 282
of officers do not cover expenses. Gen. Ord. XXXV 281
of witness must be paid or tendered in advance when. Sec.
4 (a) (4) 154
priority of payment of (see Priority). Sec. 64 210
voluntary bankrupt not required to pay, when. Sec. 51 (a)
(2). . 167
witnesses' fee a prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (3) 211
Fiduciary debts not discharged. Sec. 17 (a) (4) 110
Filing of claims for allowance. Sec. 57 (c).. 177
Filing of papers. Gen. Ord. II 259
after reference — may be filed with the clerk or the
referee. Gen. Ord. XX 271
time of filing and character to be endorsed on.
Gen. Ord II 259
Final — account of trustee — notice of filing, etc. Sec. 58 (a) (6) 186
meeting of creditors, when. Sec. 55f 172
statement of trustees. Sec. 47 (a) (7) (8) 160
Findings of referee — confirming, modifying, overruling, returning
of Sec. 2 (10) 24
Findings of fact by court required on appeals. Gen. Ord. XXXVI
(3). . 282
First dividend — when declared. Sec. 65 (b). . 218
First meeting — bankrupt shall attend. Sec. 7 (1) 69
list of debts proved at. Form No. 19 320
notice of, how published. Sec. 7 (a) (1) 69
First meeting of creditors. Sec. 55 (a) (b). . . 7 170-171
notice of. Form No. 18 319
when no other meetings necessary. Gen.
Ord. XV 267
who presides at, of creditors. Sec. 55 (b) 171
Forma pauperis — petition in. Sec. 51 (2) 167
Former bankruptcy acts — Act of 1800 . . . , 423
Amendment Feb. 13, 1801. .77. . 443
Apr. 29, 1802 444
Dec. 19, 1803 444
Actof 1841. . . 7 445
amendment Mch. 3, 1843 455
Actof 1867. . . 7 456
GENERAL INDEX. 569
PAGE.
Former Bankruptcy Acts — Continued.
amendment July 27, 1868 488
June 30, 1870 T 489
July 14, 1870. . .7.. 490
June 8, 1872 490
Feb. 13, 1873. ..... 491
March 3, 1873 491
June 22, 1874 7 492
Apr. 14, 1876 503
July 26, 1876 604
June 7, 1878 505
Forms. Sec. 307 142
prescribed to be followed. Gen. Ord. XXXVIII. 7 283
Forms in Bankruptcy.
accovmt of trustee. Form No. 49 347
adjudication of bankruptcy . Form No. 12 7 312
that debtor not a bankrupt. FormNo. 11 . . . . 311
affidavit of lost bill or note. Form No. 37 336
application for confirmation of composition. Form No. 61 . . . 358
appointment, oath and report of appraisers. FormNo. 13... 313
of trustee by creditors. Form No. 22 323
by referee. Form 23 324
bankrupt's petition for discharge. Form No. 57 7 354
bond of petitioning creditors. Form No. 9 309
of referee. Form No. 17 318
of trustee. Form No, 25 7 326
to marshal 7 7
certificate by referee to judge. Form No. 56 7 353
denial of bankruptcy. Form No. 9 7 309
discharge of bankrupt. Form No. 59 356
examination of bankrupt or witness. Form No. 29 228
letter of attorney in fact, general. Form No. 20 321
special. Form No. 21 322
list of claims and dividends. Form No. 40 7 338
of debts proved at first meeting. Form No. 38 337
notice of dividend. Form No. 41 339
of first meeting of creditors. Form No. 18 310
of petition for removal of trustee. Form No. 53 7 350
to trustee of his appointment. Form No. 24 325
oath to final account. Foim No. 50 348
to Schedule A 7 291
to Schedule B 7 297
of bill in equity. Eq. Rule20 7 367
of last interrogatory in eqtiity cases. Eq. Rule 71 388
570 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Forms in Bankruptcy — Continued.
of order allowing account and discharging trustee. Form
No. 51 349
approving trustee's bond. Form No. 26 327
confirming composition. Form No. 62 359
expxmging claim. Form No. 39 337
for choice of new trustee. Form No. 55 354
examination of bankrupt. Form No. 28 328
jury trial. Form No. 7 306
removal of trustee. Form No. 54 353
of distribution on composition. Form No. 63 360
reference Form No. 12 315
in judge's absence. Form No. 15 316
reducing amount of claim. Form No.
38 337
that no trustee be appointed. Form
No. 27 327
petition, creditors. Form No. 3 301
order to show cause on. Foim No. 4 . . . 303
debtor's. Form No. 4 303
partnership . Form No. 2 299
and order for sale by auction. Form No.
42 340
of perishable property. Form No. 46 . 344
subject to liens. Form No. 44 342
private sale. Form No. 45 343
for meeting to consider composition.
Form No. 60 359
removal of trustee. Form No. 52 349
proof of debt by agent or attorney. Form No. 35 334
partnership. Form No. 34 333
due corporation. Form No. 33 332
secured. Form No. 32 331
by agent. Form No. 36 335
unsecured. Form No. 31 330
referee's oath of office. Form No. 18 317
Schedule A, debts of bankrupt 287
Schedule B, property of bankrupt 292
special warrant to marshal. Form No. 8 307
return thereon 307
specification opposing discharge. Form No. 58 356
subpoena to alleged bankrupt. Form No. 5 S04
summary of debts and assets. Form No. 1 . , 299
summons to witness. Form No. 30 329
GENERAL INDEX. 27I
PAGE.
Forms in Bankruptcy — Continued.
return thereon. Form No. 30 329
trustee's report of exempt property. Form No. 47 345
no assets. Form No. 48 346
Four months' limitation on Acts. Sec. 3b (1) 42
what liens void, when within. See Liens, Sec. 67 220
Frame of petition. Gen. Ord. V 260
Fraud — act of bankruptcy, when. Sec. 3(a) 32
composition may be set aside for. Sec. 13 89
discharge may be revoked for. Sec. 15(a) 103
on this Act, as affecting liens. Sec. 67(c) (3) 223
prevents discharge. Sec. 14(b) (2) 100
transfer void for. Sec. 67(e) 227
transfer void for. Sec. 67(c) (3) 223
when exempted from arrest for. Sec. 9(a) (2) 76
Fraudulent — conveyances. See Liens, Sec. 67(e) 227
title in trustee. Sec. 70(a) (4) 243
debts not discharged. Sec. 17(a) (4) 110
expenditure by trustee. Sec. 29a 140
Further credit — when set off. Sec. 60b 197
G.
General trustee — not to be appointed. Gen. Ord. XIV 267
Guarantor for Bankrupt. Sec. 16 104
Gender — masculine, includes what. Sec. 1 (28) " 11
General Assignment.
when an act of bankruptcy. Sec. 3(a) (4) 40
letter of attorney. Form No. 20 7 321
Orders— include forms. Gen. Ord. XXXVIII 284
General Orders.
accounts of marshals. Gen. Ord. XIX. . . . ." 270
accounts of referee. Gen. Ord. XXVI 275
amendments. Gen. Ord. XI 264
appeals. Gen. Ord. XXXVI 282
appointment and removal of trustee. Gen. Ord. XIII 267
arbitration. Gen. Ord. XXIII. . ..." 280
compensation of clerks, referees, and trustees. Gen. Ord.
XXXV 281
conduct of proceedings. Gen. Ord. IV 26
costs in contested proceedings. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 281
docket. Gen. Ord. 1 259
duties of referee. Gen. Ord. XII 265
duties of trustees. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
filing of papers. Gen. Ord. II 265
272 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
General Orders — Continued.
forms. Gen. Ord. XXXVIII. . ..T 283
frame of petitions. Gen. Ord. V. . . ? 260
general provisions. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 282
Indemnity for expenses. Gen. Ord. X 264
Imprisoned debtor. Gen. Ord. XXX 277
no official or general trustee. Gen. Ord. XIV 267
notice to trustee of his appointment. Gen. Ord. XVI 268
opposition to discharge or composition. Gen. Ord. XXXII . . 278
orders of referee. Gen. Ord. XXIII 278
papers filed after reference. Gen. Ord. XX 270
payment of moneys deposited. Gen. Ord. XXIX 277
petition for discharge. Gen. Ord. XXXI 278
I>etitions in different districts. Gen. Ord. VI 261
priority of petitions. Gen. Ord. VII 262
proceedings in partnership cases. Gen. Ord. VIII. . 263
process. 'Gen. Ord. Ill 259
proof of debts. Gen. Ord. XXI. 270
redemption of property and compoimding of claims. Gen.
Ord. XX 276
review by judge. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
sale of property. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
schedule in involvmtary bankruptcy. Gen. Ord. IX 263
special meeting of creditors. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
taking of testimony. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
transmission of proved claimant to clerk. Gen. Ord. XXIV. . 274
trustee not appointed in certain cases. Gen. Ord. XV 267
H.
Habeas corpus — to release debtor. Gen. Ord. XXX. .7 277
Hearing on involtmtary petition. Sec. 59(d) . . . . 7 191
as to sufficient nxunber of creditors. Sec. 59(d) ... .7 191
Hearings on applications for discharge, notice of, required.. Sec.
58(a) (2) 185
consolidated petitions. Gen. Ord. VII 262
confirmation of composition, notice of required. Sec. 58 (a)
(2) 185
contempts. Sec. 41 (b) 155
objections to claims. Sec. 57 (f) 178
when and where had. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Hire, see Wage-earner. Sec. 1 (27) 11
Holding property in advance of adjudication. Sec. 3(e) '. 40
HoUday — definition of. Sec. 1 (14) 7
excluded if last day. Sec. 31 (a) 7 142
GENERAL INDEX. 573
PAGE.
Homestead — see Exemptions. Sec. 6. ... 7 58
duty of trustee to set aside . Sec. 47a (11) 161
statement of claim to. See Form No. 1, Sch. B(5) 7 296
I.
Identity to be established, when. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
Implied contract — debt fotmded on, provable. Sec. 63 (a) (4) 207
Imprisonment, as pvmishment under act. Sec. 29 140
Imprisoned debtor. Gen. Ord. XXX. 277
Incumbrance of property by bankrupt — void when. Sec. 67 (e) 227
Indebtedness, amoimt necessary in involuntary proceedings. Sec.
4(b) 48
Indemnity for expenses, when may be required. Gen. Ord. X 264
Expenses, money paid for, shall be repaid out of estate
when. Gen. Ord. X 264
Indian Territory. See States. Sec. 1 (24) 10
Individual debts and assets. See Partners. Sec. 5 51
Indorser. See Secured Creditor. Sec. 1 (23) 9
Infants and insane persons allowed more time for proof of claim.
Sec. 57 (n) 184
have one year after majority to claim dividends. Sec. 66 (b) 219
Inferior courts of bankruptcy. See Appellate Courts. Sec. 24 (b) 133
Information as to bankruptcy. Sec. 53 169
as to estates. Sec. 39 (a) (3) 150
trustees to fixmish. Sec. 47 (a) (5) 160
Injunction — by whom granted. Gen. Ord. XXII (3) 273
suits restrained by, when. Sec. 11, a 78
Injuries — judgment for wilful and malicious — not discharged. Sec.
17 (2) 107
Injuries to property — right of action for. Sec. 70 (a) (6) 249
Insane persons allowed more time for proof of claims. Sec. 57 (n) . . . 184
Insanity of bankrupt. Sec. 8 (f) 75
Insolvency laws — when act not to affect , 250
Insolvency, jury trial of. Sec. 19 (a) 119
preference and effect on liens. Sec. 67 (c) (1) 223
when person is, definition. Sec. 1 (15) 7
Inspection — accounts to be open for. Sec. 49 (a). 164
of docket, right of. See docket. Gen. Ord. 1 259
of records, refusal to allow. Sec. 29 (c) (3) 142
Instrument — See Dociiment. Sec. 1 (13) 6
in writing, how proved and withdrawn. Sec. 57 (f) 176
Insiu-ance policies,on life, title to. Sec. 70 (a) (5) 248
schedule of. Form No. 1, Sch. B (3). 294
574 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Intention, affecting preference. Sec. 60 (b) 197
Intent to, defeat act. Sec. 29 (b) (4) 141
to give preference affecting payment. Sec. 60 (b) 197
when affect act of bankruptcy. Sec. 3 (a) 32
Interest — on accounts, proof of. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
provable as part of debt when. Sec. 63 (a) (1) 205
trustees must account for. Sec. 47 (a) (1) 150
Interlineation — not permitted in petitions. Gen. Ord. V 263
Interlocutory judgments. Sec. 24 (b) 131
Intervenors. Sec. 59 (f) 198
Inventory — trustee to prepare. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
Involvmtary bankrupt — subpoena to. Form No. 5 304
trial by jury. Sec. 19 (a) 119
who may become. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Involuntary bankruptcy — petitioning creditors to file schedule.
Gen. Ord. IX 263
Involuntary bankrupts. Sec. 4 (b) 48
cases bond to be given by creditors. Sec. 69 (a) 239
costsin. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 230
marshal may seize property, when. Sec. 69 (a) 239
Involuntary petition — answer to, must contain list of creditors, when.
Sec. 59(d) (e) 191
appearance of creditors in interest. Sec. 59(f) 191
certain creditors not to be counted. Sec. 59 (e) . 191
creditors who must join in. Sec. 59(b) 187
defense maybe made by partners. Gen. Ord.
VIII 263
not to-be dismissed without notice. Sec. 59 (g) . 192
petitions to be filed in duplicate. Sec. 59(c) . . 190
what first heard. Gen. Ord. VII 262
who may file. Sec. 59(b) 187
Involuntary petitions — creditor's filing fees, prior claims. Sec. 64 (b)
(2) 211
Issue as to number of creditors. Sec. 59d 191
Issues, how and when determined. Sec. 18(d) 117
joiner in bankruptcy. See Form No. 6 305
of fact referred to referee. Gen. Ord. XII (3) •. . . 266
J.
Joining petitions. Sec. 59f 191
. to prevent dismissal. Sec. 59d 191
Joint bond of trustees. Sec. 50h 166
Joint trustees. Sec. 47 (b) 168
GENERAL INDEX. 575
PAGE.
Judge — definition. Sec. 1 (16) 1
clerk may refer when absent. Sec. 18 (f) 118
can remove trustee. Gen. Ord. XIII 287
may issue warrant to seize and hold property of bankrupt,
when. Sec. 69 (a) 239
modify niles of practice. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 283
order declaration of dividends. Sec. 65 (b) 218
remove trustee. Gen. Ord. XIII 237
review referee's finding. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
powers of vested in referees. Sec. 38 (a) (3) 143
referee may act in absence of. Sec. 38 (3) 148
referee's certificate to. Form No. 56 353
shall approve, fix the amount of bond. Sec. 69 (a) 239
the sureties on bond. Sec. 69 (a) 239
State Court, witness may be ordered before Sec. 21 (a) 122
to hear application for discharge. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Judges— list of U. S. Districts 506
Judgment — when a preference. Sec. 60 (a) 192
Judgment Debt — provable claim. Sec. 63 (a) (1) 205
Judgments — after petition filed, provable when. Sec. 63 (a) (5) . . . . 239
against bankrupt's estate. Sec. 67 (b) 222
of referee's, review of. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
preferences when. Sec. 60 (a) 192
provable when. Sec. 63a (1) 205
void when. See liens. Sec. 67f 229
voidable by trustee when. Sec. 60b 197
when by judge. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Jurisdiction. Chapter II. Sec. 2-12 12
See adjudicate bankrupt power to. Sec. 2 (1) 13
appeals, power to entertain. Sec. 25 135
appointment of trustee. Sec. 44 156
Circuit Courts. Sec. 23a 126
Circuit Court of Appeals. Sec. 24 (b) 133
composition. Sec. 2 (9) 24
concurrent. Sec. 23 (c) 132
conduct of business. Sec. 2 (5) 18
contempts. Sec. 2 (16) ; Sec. 41, 29 154
costs. Sec. 2 (18) 29
court first acquiring to retain. Gen. Ord. VI 261
discharge. Sec. 2 (12) 25
estates. Sec. 2 (7) 19
exceptions. Sec. 2 (10) 24
exemptions. Sec. 2 (11) 25
576 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Jurisdiction — Continued.
extradition. Sec. 2 (14) 7 27
parties, to make. Sec. 2 (6) 7 19
possession. Sec. 69 239
powers not enumerated. Sec. 2 30
proof. Sec. 21 (f) 125
receivers. Sec. 2 (3) 16
referees. Sec. 34, 38 145
seizure. Sec. 3 (e) 7 46
State Courts. Sec. 23 (b) 127
transfer of cases. Sec. 2 (19) 30-143
trustee. Sec. 2 (17) 29
of referees. Sec. 38a 147
adjudicate or dismiss petitions. Sec. 38 a (1). 147
administer oaths. Sec. 38 (a) (2) 147
exercise powers of judge, when. Sec. 38 (a)
(3) 148
follow rules as to duties. Sec. 38 (a) (4) 148
Jiiry, specially summoned. Sec. 19 (b) 120
Jury Trial — order for. Form No. 7 306
right to. Sec. 19 (c) 121
Jury Trials. Sec. 19 (b) 120
Justice of the peace referee may be. Sec. 35 (a) (2) 146
K.
Knowledge of preference intended — when it will render the preference
voidable. Sec. 60 (b) 197
intended renders lien void. Sec. 67(f) ... . 229
I/.
Last day included, when. Sec. 31 (a) 142
Law and fact, conclusions and findings. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (3) .... . 282
Law, jurisdiction — proceedings in . .Gen. Ord. XXXVII 283
Leave to amend petitions and schedule. Gen. Ord. XI. ..." 264
Legal proceedings, liens obtained under void. Sec. 67(f) 229
Letter of attorney — acknowledged before. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
acknowledgment of. General Ord. XXI 272
on behalf of corporation. Gen. Ord. XXI 272
partnership. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
to be under oath. Gen. Ord. XXI(5) 272
Letter of attorney in fact — general. Form No. 20 321
special. From No. 21 322
to trustee by creditor directing payment of dividends. Form
No. 41 339
GENERAL INDEX. 577
PAGE.
Levies — ^when right under passes to trustee. Sec. 67(f) 229
preserved for estate. Sec. 67(f) 7 229
void under Act. Sec. 67(f) 7 229
Liability of trustees. See Duties of trustees. Sec. 47 158
Liens. Sec. 67 7 220
given after being adjudged bankrupt. Sec. 67(e). . , 227
petition and order of sale subject to Form No. 44 342
trustee subrogated to right to. Sec. 67(b) 222
unrecorded when not liens. Sec. 67(a) 220
what dissolved by adjudication. Sec. 67(c) ... 7 222
not affected by Act. Sec. 67(d) 7 224
when creditor has knowledge of insolvency. Sec. 67(c) (2) . . . . 223
obtained during insolvency . Sec. 67 (c) (1) 223
within four months. Sec. 67(f) 7 229
permitted in fraud of Act. Sec. 67(a) (3) 220-223
Limitation — bonds of referee. Sec. 50(1) 166
trustee. Sec. 50(m) 166
four months as to liens. Sec. 67 220
claims. Sec. 57 (n) 7 184
offenses. Sec. 29(d) 142
on appeals. Sec. 25(a) (3) 135
on claiming dividends. See unclaimed dividends, Sec. 66 ... . 219
suits by or against trustee. Sec. 1 1 (d) 85
Limited partnership — definition. Sec. 1 (6) 5
Liquidated demands. Sec. 63(b) 7 209
List of claims and dividends to be recorded by referee. Form No. 40. 338
List of creditors, when to be filed with answer in involuntary cases
Sec. 59 (d) 191
when to be filed by referee. Sec. 39a(6) 150
List of debts proved at first meeting of. Form No. 19 320
proved claims shall contain what. Gen. Ord. XXIV. ........ 274
Lost bill or note, afiidavit of. Form No. 37 336
Lost writing. Sec. 57(b) 176
M.
Mailing notices, expense of. Gen. Ord. XXXV (1) (2) 281
Majority in number and amount of creditors may designate place for
meeting. Sec. 55(e) 172
of three trustees must concur Sec. 47(b) 161
Malicious and wilful injuries — judgments for. Sec. 17(2) 107
Manufacturing corporations. Sec. 4(b) 48
Marshal— bond to. Form No. 10 7 310
compensation of. Sec. 52(b) .... 7 169
578 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Marshal — Continued.
jurisdiction over. Sec.2(3) 7 16
may require indemnity for expenses. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
to make retiim of expenses incurred tmder oath. Gen. Ord
XIX 270
to obtain vouchers, when. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
warrant to, special. Form No. 8 307
when ordered to seize property of involuntary bankrupt. Sec. ^
69(a) 239
Marshalling assets of partnership. Sec. 5 (f), (g) 55-57
Masculine gender — definition. Sec. 1 (28) 11
Master in chancery — referees may be. Sec. 35(a) (2) '. 146
Meeting of creditors — court may order that none be called after the
first. Gen. Ord. XV 267
final. Sec. 55(f) 172
first. Sec. 55(a), (b). .. .7 170-171
first notice of. Sec. 58(b) 186
list of debts proved at first. FormNo. 19 '320
notice of. Sec. 58(a) (3) 185
special. Gen. Ord. XXV. . .~ 275
subsequent. Sec. 55(a) (b) 170-171
to consider composition. Form No. 60 357
Meeting of creditors. Sec. 55 170
Mercantile corporations may be bankrupts. Sec. 4(f) 48
Mileage of witnesses has priority. Sec 64b (3) 211
paid or tendered in advance . Sec. 41 (a) (4). ... 7 154
Minors — dividend belonging to claimed after majority. Sec. 66(b).. 219
Misappropriation by trustee. Sec. 29(a) 140
not discharged from liability for. Sec. 17(4). .. T 110
Money — courts to designate depositories for. Sec. 61 (a) 204
depositories for. Sec. 61 204
to be withdrawn from depository by check. Gen. Ord. XXIX. 277
Mortgage. (See Transfer.) Sec. 1 (25) 10
when and how discharged. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 276
Mutilate— definition. Sec. 1 (22) 9
Mutual debts or credits set oflf. when. Sec. 68a. . . 7 238
N.
National Banks — seem to be contemplated as depositories. Form
No. 61 358
excepted from bankruptcy proceedings. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Necessary expenses allowed when. Sec. 62 7 204
expenses of court officers. Gen. Ord. XXXV 282
Neexeat. Sec. 9(b) 77
GENERAL INDEX. 579
PAGE.
New credit — when claim under may be set off. Sec. 60 (c) 200
New Parties. Sec. 2 (6) 19
Newspapers — designation of. Sec. 28a .....? 139
New trustee — order for choice of. Form No. 55 352
No trustee appointed, when. Gen. Ord. XV 267
order that none be. Form No. 27 327
Nonresidents — jurisdiction of. Sec. 2 (1) 3 13
Notary Public — referees may be. Sec. 35 (a) (2) 141
what may be acknowledged before. Gen. Ord. 5^X1 ? 271
Not bankrupt — adjudication. Form No. 11 316
Note— affidavit of lost. Form No. 37 336
how proved and withdrawn. Sec. 57 (b) 179
Notice — designation of newspaper. Sec. 28 * 139
of dividend. Form No. 41 339
first meeting of. Form No. 18 318
, order discharging bankrupt from custody. Gen. Ord. XXX 270
petition, order for. Form No. 57 354
for redemption. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 7 276
for removal of trustee. Form No. 53 350
record of revesting title. Sec. 21 (g) 125
of trustee's title. Sec. 21 (e) 125
special meeting of creditors. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
referee's order to show. Gen. Ord. XXII 7 273
to be given by referee. Sec. 58 (c) 186
to trustee of his appointment. Form No. 23 324
what to contain. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
Notice of Assignment of Claim — given to original 7;
claimant. Gen. Ord. XXI (3) 271
Notice of Involuntary Petition — to be given to contesting partner.
Gen. Ord. VIII 7 263
when to be given to creditors. Sec. 59 (d) 191
Notice to trustee of appointment. Form No. 24 325
to be made by referee. Gen. Ord.
• XVI 268
what to contain. Gen. Ord. XVI 7 268
Notices and Orders — when served on attorney. Gen. Ord. VI 261
Notices to Creditors. Sec. 58 7 185
how given. Sec. 58 (b) 7 186
may be waived in writing. Sec. 58 (a) 185
must be by mail. Sec. 58 (a) 7 185
of dismissal of petition. Sec. 59 (g) 7 192
referee to give. Sec. 39 (4) 7 150
sale to take place without, when. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
58o GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Notices to Creditors — Continued.
sent to any address on request. Gen. Ord. XXI (2) 7 371
to prosecuting creditor in habeas corpus. Gen. Ord. XXX . . . T 277
to whom addressed. Gen. Ord. XXI (2) 7 271
when required. Sec. 58^ (a) ? 185
Number of Creditors — how computed. Sec. 59 (e) 191
issue formed on. Sec. 59 (d) 191
referees. Sec. 37 (a) 7 147
trustees. Sec. 44 T 156
Numbering cases. Gen, Ord. I 259
O.
Oath — by whom administered. Sec. 20 (a) 121
definition. Sec. 1 (17) ? 8
expense accoimt to be reported tmder. Sec. 62 ? 204
false, punishment. Sec. 29 (b) (2) 140
form for to schedule (b) . Form No. 1 285
of appraisers, form of. Form No. 13 313
of office, referee's. Form No. 16 7 317
referee's return to be under. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
retiuTi of marshal's expenses to be made xmder. Gen. Ord.
XIX 270
to final accovmt of trustee. Form No. 50 7 348
Oaths, Affirmation, etc. Sec. 20 121
Obedience to orders — cotirt's power to enforce. Sec. 2 (13) 25
Objections to claims. Sec. 57f 7 178
to questions, how taken. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
to discharge. Gen. Ord. XXXII 278
specifications of grotmds of. Gen. Ord. XXXII 7 278
OflEenses — jurisdiction of cotirts. Sec. 23 (c) 132
limitations. Sec. 29 (d) : 142
ptmishment. Sec. 29 (a) 140
what are under act. Sec. 29 (a) 140
Officer— definition. Sec. 1 (18) 8
Officers — their duties and compensation, Ch. V. Sec. 33 to 54 145
to include "persons" in act. Sec. 1 (19) 7 9
to prepare statistics. Sec. 56 161
official bonds. Sec. 50 (a) 164
Official Forms (See Forms) 285
Official trustee, not to be appointed. Gen. Ord. XIX 270
One trustee or three. Sec. 44 ■ 1 56
Open account, provable. Sec. 63 (a) (4) 207
Operation of law, title changes by. Sec. 70 7 241
Opporttmity for inspection, reasonable, refused. Sec. 29 (c) (3) 141
GENERAL INDEX. 58I
PAGE.
Opposition to discharge or composition. Gen. Ord. XXXII T 278
Opposition to discharge — specifications of grounds. Form No. 58 . . 356
to petitions creditors may make. Sec. 59 (f) 191
Order — allowing account and discharging trustee. Form No. 51 .... 340
approving trustee's bond. Form No. 26 327
confirming composition. Form No. 62 T 359
discharging bankrupt. Form No. 59 1 357
evidence of. Sec. 21f 125
expunging claim. Form No. 39 7 337
for choice of new trustee. FormNo. 55 T 352
examination of bankrupt. Form No. 28 328
general jurisdiction to make. Sec. 2 (15) 27
jury trial. Form No. 7 '." 306
removal of trustee. Form No. 54 T 351
sale of real estate. Form No. 42 340
distribution on composition. Form No. 63 360
notice on petition for discharge. Form No. 57 7 356
payment of debts having priority. Sec. 64 210
of reference. Form No. 14 315
copy of order to be sent to referee. Gen. Ord.
XII .265
in judge's absence. Form No. 15 T 316
referee, review of. Gen. Ord. XXVII T 275
of reference, what to contain. Gen. Ord. XII .' 265
on motion, must contain name of moving attorney. Gen.
Ord. IV 260
petition for private sale. Form No. 45 7 343
sale by auction. Form No. 42 7 7 340
petition for sale subject to lien. Form No. 44 7 342
reducing claim. Form No. 38 7 337
that no trustee be appointed. Form No. 27 . ' 327
to show cause on creditor's petition. Form No. 4 303
Orders — general. Sec. 30. See General Orders 142
Orders — bankrupt shall comply with. Sec. 7 (2) 69
enforcing obedience to. Sec. 2 (13) 7 25
Orders of Referee — what to contain. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
Original claimant, notice to of proof of assigned claim. Gen. Ord.
XXI (3) 271
jurisdiction. See courts of bankruptcy. Sec. 2 12
vested in Circuit Cotirts of Appeals. Sec. 24 (b) 133
P.
Papers — bankrupt shall execute. Sec. 7 (4) 70
books, deeds and writing, Hst of. FormNo. 1. Sch. B 6. 298, 297
582 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Papers — Continued.
filed after reference. Gen. Ord. XX 270
clerks must deliver or mail to referees, when. Sec. 51 (a) (3) . . 168
etc. to be endorsed with name of attorney. Gen. Ord. IV . . . . 260
trustee's open to inspection. Sec. 49 164
of estates, inspection refused. Sec. 29 (c) (3) 141
to be called for by referees in person. Sec. 39 (a) (10) 151
Parties, additional, new and substitution. Sec. 2 (6) 19
in interest, right to inspect papers. Sec. 49 164
Partner — when to file schedule of debts. Gen. Ord. VIII 263
Partners — adjudged bankrupt when. Sec. 5 (a) 51
jurisdiction of one gives ofj estate. Sec. 5 (c) 54
refusing to join in petition. Gen. Ord. VIII 263
Partnership — claim by; deposition by partners. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) . 270
accounts of trustee. Sec. 5 (a) 55
adjudged bankrupt, when. Sec. 5 (a) 51
claims of against members. Sec. 5 (g) 7 57
creditors of. Sec. 5 (b) 54
distribution of assets. Sec. 5 (f) 55
expenses how paid. Sec. 5 (e) 65
jurisdiction of one partner enough. Sec. 5 (c) 54
petition against in different districts, when amended. Gen.
Ord. VI 261
petition of. Form No. 2 299
proof of debt by. Form No. 34 333
trustee, how chosen. Sec. 5 (b) 54
when adjudicated bankrupt. Sec. 5 (a) 7 51
where all partners not adjudicated. Sec. 5 (h) 57
Partnership Cases — expenses. Sec. 5 (e) 55
proceedings in. Gen. Ord. VIII 7 263
Partnership Petition — form for. Form No. 2 299
Patent rights to pass to trustee. Sec. 70 (a) (2) V 241
Patents — title to, to pass to trustee. Sec. 70 (a) (2) 241
Paupers' affidavit. Sec. 5(a) (2) 167
Payment. See Transfer. Sec. 1(25) 10
Payment of dividends — notice of declaration of and time of. Sec.
58(a) (5) 185
of. Sec. 65 217
of moneys deposited. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 277
Penalties and forfeitures, how far allowed. Sec. 57J. ... 7 183
Pending proceeding, not dismissed until creditors notified. Sec. 59d . 191
Perishable property — petition and order for sale. Form No. 26. . . 7 . . 327
Saleof. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
Perpetuating testimony. Gen. Ord. XXXV (2) 281
GENERAL INDEX. 5^3
PAGE.
Person against whom, etc., definition. Sec. 1 (1) T 4
Persons — definition. Sec. 1 (19) 9
Personal property — appraisal of. Sec. 70b 250
Petition — creditors, form of. Form No. 3 -, 301
definition. Sec. 1(20) 7 9
filedin duplicate. Sec. 59(c) 190
form of volimtary. Form No. 1 285
< for partnerships. Form No. 2 T 299
. how amended. Gen. Ord. XI 264
framed. Gen. Ord. V 260
in different districts. Gen. Ord. VI 261
involuntary, who may file. Gen. Ord. V, Sec. 59 (b) 187
order to show cause on — form of. Form No. 4 303
Petition and order for private sale. Form No. 45. . . 7 343
redemption of property from lien. Form No.
43 341
sale of perishable property . Form No. 46. . . .7 344
sale subject to lien. Form No. 44 7 342
Petition for discharge Gen. Ord. XXXI 278
Form No. 57 354
Petition for meeting to consider composition. Form No. 60 7 . . 357
Petitionforreview— filed with Judge. Gen. Ord. XXVII 7 275
finding of referee to be certified. Gen. Ord.
XXVII 276
Petition for redemption ef property. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 276
Petition for sale of real estate. Form No. 42. . . 7 340
Petitions — court may order to be consolidated. Gen. Ord. VII. . . 7 . . 262
debtor's domicile to control hearing on. Gen. Ord. V 260
frame of. Gen. Ord. V 260
in different districts. Gen. Ord. VT, . . 7 261
may be adjudicated or dismissed by referees when. Sec, 38
(a)<l) 147
must be filed in duplieate. Sec. 59(c) 7 190
not to be dismissed without notice. Sec. 59(g) T 192
not to be filed until 251
number of creditors necessary. Sec. 59(d). . . .'. 191
one alleging first Act of Bankruptcy to be first heard. Gen.
Ord. VII 262
priority of. Gen. Ord. VI 261
volimtary, who may file. Sec. 59(a) 7 187
who may file and dismiss involuntary. Sec. 59(b) 187
Petitions and schedules to be written or printed. Gen. Ord. V 260
584 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Petitioner's bond. See Possession. Sec. 69 239
when reqmred. Sec. 3(e) T 46
Petitioning creditor's bond. See Form No. 9 309
recover costs, when. Gen. Ord. XXXIV 281
Place where referees shall act. Gen. Ord. VII 265
Plead, who may. Sec. 18(f) 115
Pleadings. Sec. 18 114
to be verified. Sec. 18(c) 116
varying time for. Gen. Ord. XXXVII .. .: 283
Plural nimiber — definition. Sec. 1 (29) ...7 11
Policy of insurance — when to pass to trustee. Sec. 70(a) (5) 243
Poor person — when not to pay fees. Sec. 51 (2) 167
Possession of property — when judge may order taken. Sec. 69a . . ; . . 239
when may be seized. Sec. 3(e) . . . . 7 46
Powers not enumerated. Sec. 2 7 27-30
which bankrupt might exercise to pass to trustee. Sec. 70 (a)
(3) 242
Powers of attorney, how made and attested. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
attorney, forms for Forms 20-21 331-332
Practice — Appeals. Sec. 25 7 135
equity rules to govern, when. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 282
law rules to govern, when. (kn. Ord. XXXVII 282
referees not to in bankruptcy. Sec. 39(b) (2) 152
Preference — ^what is giving. Sec. 60(a) 192
credit after preference. Sec. 60(c) 200
test in dissolving liens. Sec. 67(c) (1) 223
when lien works. Sec. 67(c) (1) 7 223
when act of bankruptcy. Sec. 3 (a) (2) 33
when trustee may set aside. Sec. 60 (b) 1 192
when surrendered, claim allowed. Sec. 57 g 178
Preferred Creditors. Sec. 60 192
when may claim set-oflf. Sec. 60 (c) 7 200
Prescribed rules, forms and orders. Sec. 30 (a) 142
Preservation of estates. Sec. 2 (3) 16
Preserving estate, cost of has priority. Sec. 64 (b) (1) 211
Principal place of business. Sec. 2 (1) 13
Prior Claims — schedule, form of schedule (a) (1). Form No. (1) 287-295
Priority — claims having, how far allowed. Sec. 57 (e) 177
not entitled to vote. Sec. 56 (b) 172
debts having. Sec. 64 (a) 210
costs of administration. Sec. 64b (3) 211
costs of preserving estate. Sec. 64 (b) (1) . . 211
debts entitled to priority \mder state or
GENERAL INDEX. $8$
PAGE.
Priority — Continued.
federal laws. Sec. 64 (b) (5) 216
filing fees. Sec. 64 (a) 211
taxes due. Sec. 64 (a) 210
wages due working men and clerks. Sec.
64b (4) 214
of petitions. Gen. Ord. VII 262
statement of debts having. Form No. 1, Sch. A (1) 298, 287
given by state laws, preserved by bankrupt cotirt. Sec.
64 (b) (5) .■ 216
Private — bankers. Sec. 4 (b) 48
corporations. Sec. 1 (b) 5
sale petition and order for. Form No. 45 348
Procedtire — ^violation of act. Sec. 2 (4) 7 13
See Appellate Courts. Sec. 24 132
conduct of proceedings. Gen. Ord. IV 260
death of trustee. Sec. 46 T 158
debts provable. Sec. 63 T 205
dividends. Sec. 65 T 217
duties of referees. Sec. 38 T 147
Notices to creditors. Sec. 58 7 185
no trustee. Gen. Ord. XV ? 267
petitions. Sec 59 7 187
possession. Sec. 69 239
proof and allowance of claims. Sec 57 173
rules. Sec 30a 142
Supreme Court. Sec. 25 7 135
transfer of cases. Sec. 32 (a) 7 143
Proceeding — when bankruptcy is denied. Sec. 3 (d) 45
Proceedings — how conducted. Gen. Ord. IV 260
in partnership cases. Gen. Ord. VIII 7 263
under state insolvency laws not affected. Sec. 70b . . 261
Process. Sec. 18 7 114
Process. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
disobedience of contempt. Sec. 41 (a) (1) 154
judge may vary time allowed for retvun of. Gen. Ord.
XXXVIII 283
to be tested by clerk. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
to issue out of court under seal. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
Promissory note — how proven and withdrawn. Sec. 57 (b) 176
Proof burden of as to solvency. Sec 3 (c) 44
Proof and allowance of claims. Sec. 57a 173
duty of bankrupt as to. Sec. 7 (a) (3) 70
Proof of Claims — ^where filed after reference. Gen. Ord. XX 7 270
586 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Proof of Debt — by agent or attorney. Form No. 35 7 334
by partnership. Form No. 34 7 333
due corporation. Form No. 33 332
Proof of Debts— (See claims) , how made. Gen. Ord. XXI T 270
deposition must aver what. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
must show reason why when made by an agent.
Gen. Ord. XXI 270
Depositions to prove must be entitled in cause and court.
Gen. Ord. XXI 270
letterof attorney to represent in. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
notice to creditors where sent. Gen. Ord. XXI (2) 271
on open account to state date debt is due. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) . 271
proof of assigned claims. Gen. Ord. XXI (3) 271
debt due a partnership must show deponent
member. Gen. Ord. XXI 270
re-examinationof proof of claim. Gen, Ord. XXI (6) '. 272
Gen. Ord. XXI (2) T 271
trustee to deliver to referee. Gen. Ord. XXI (1) 270
when debt due corporation who to make deposition. Gen.
Ord. XXI (1) 270
Proof of Secured Debt. Form No. 32 T 331
by agent. Form No. 36 7 335
tmsecured debt. Form No. 31 330
Property — appraisement of. Sec. 70 bV 250
bankrupt shall convey what. Sec. 7 (5) 70
judge may issue warrant to seize. Sec. 69 (a) 7 239
partnership. Sec. 5 51
possession of. Sec. 69 239
recovery of by trustee. Sec. 70 (e) 250
recovery from bankrupt. Sec. 29b (4) V 141
referee caimot purchase when. Sec. 39 (b) (3) 152
statement of in volxmtary proceedings. Form No. 1, Sch. B
292
sales of, notice to creditors to be given. Sec. 58 (a) (4) . . . . 185
sales of. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
title to. Sec. 70 239
title to what in trustee. Sec. 70 (a) 241
to be released if bankrupt files bond. Sec. 69 (a) 239
when bankrupt about to neglect. Sec. 69 (a) 239
Property of Bankrupt — to be appraised. Sec. 70 (b) 250
to be sold subject to approval of court Sec. 70 (b) 260
trustee to convey title to . Sec. 70 (c) 250
Prosecutions — concurrent jurisdiction of. Sec. 23 (b) 127
GENERAL INDEX. 587
PAGE.
Protection of Bankrupts. Sec. 9 '. 76
Provable Claims — (see debts which may be proved. Sec. 64 210
Proved Claims — list, referee to transmit. Gen. Ord. XXIV 274
Publication of Notices of creditors' meetings. Sec. 58 (b) 186
service by. Sec. 18 (a) 114
Punishment — jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (4) 18
Purchase — by referee of property of bankrupt. Sec. 29 (c) (2) . . . . 141
by referee at sale. Sec. 39 (b) (3) 152
Purchaser — bona fide, when not affected by bankrupt act. Sec.
67 (f) 229
Purchased— claim not set oflF. Sec. 68 (b) (2) '. 238
Purchasers in good faith protected, when. Sec. 67 (e) 227
Qualifications of — referees. Sec. 35 (a) 146
trustees. Sec. 45 (a) 158
R.
Real Estate — petition and order for sale of. Form No. 42 340
schedule of. Form No. 1, Sch. B (1) 292
Receivers — jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (3) 16
when appointed. Sec. 3 (e) 46
Reconsideration of Claims — jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (2) 15
Recorded Lien — not affected by act. Sec. 67 (d) 224
Record — as affecting liens. Sec. 67 (a) 220
in case of appeals. Gen Ord. XXXVI (3) 283
notice of revesting title. Sec. 21g 125
trustee to, conveyances. Sec. 71 255
Records — referee to make. Sec. 39 (5) 150
Records of Referee — confirming, modifying, overruling or returning.
Sec. 2 (10) 24
Records of Referees. Sec. 42 154
Recovery of Property. Sec. 67 (e) 227
Redemption of Property. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 276
from lien, petition for. Form No. 43 341
Re-examination of Claims. Gen. Ord. XXI (6) 272
Referee — accovmt of expenses to be kept by. Gen. Ord. XXVIII 269
application for discharge may be referred to. Gen. Ord.
XII 265
appointment of trustee by. Form No. 23 324
approval of composition may be referred to. Gen. Ord.
XII 265
bond, limitation on. Sec. 50 (1) 166
bond of. Form No. 17 318
588 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGB
Referee — Continued.
certificate of to judge. Form No. 56 .' 353
clerk to pay fee to. Sec. 51 (4) 168
compensation of. Gen. Ord. XXXV (2) 282
contempts before. Sec. 41 154
call on clerk for papers. Sec. 39 (a) (10) 151
creation of ofi&ce. Sec. 33 145
declare dividends. Sec. 39 (a) (1) 149
definition of. Sec. 1 (21) 9
depositions before. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
dividend sheets. Sec. 39 (a) (1) 149
duties of. Sec. 39. 149
examine schedule. Sec. 39 (a) (2) 149
fiUTiish information, duty to. Sec. 39 (a) (3) . . . . 150
give notices to creditors, duty to. Sec. 39 (a) (4) . . 150
make records. Sec. 39 (a) (5) 150
prepare schedules. Sec. 39 (a) (6) 150
preserve evidence. Sec. 39 (a) (9) 151
records. Sec. 39 (a) (7) 151
transmit papers to clerk. Sec. 39 (a) (8) 151
duties of. Gen. Ord. XII 265
duties performed as to time and place. Gen. Ord. XII 265
examination of witnesses before. Gen. Ord. XX 270
exceptions to trustee's report argued before. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
expenses not to be included in fees. Gen. Ord. XXXV (2) . . 282
expenses to be returned under oath. Gen. Ord. XXVI .... 275
failure to give bond. Sec 50 (k) 166
indorse time of filing on papers. Gen. Ord. II 259
jurisdiction of. Sec. 38 147
may require indemnity for expense. Gen. Ord. X 264
may take acknowledgment of. Gen. Ord. XXI (5) 272
number of. Sec. 37 ." 147
oath of office. Sec. 36 147
oath of office. Form No. 16 317
offense by, punishment. Sec. 29 (c) (1) (2) (3) 140, 141
papers may be filed with after reference. Gen. Ord. XX . . 270
petition for review to be filed with. Gen. Ord. XXVII .... 275
qualification of. Sec. 35 146
removal and districts of. Sec. 34 145
time to act on cases fixed by judge. Gen. Ord. XII 265
to approve appointment of trustee. Gen. Ord. XIII 267
to be furnished blanks when. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
to give notices. Sec. 58 (c) 186
notify trustee of appointment. Gen. Ord. XVI 268
GENERAL INDEX. 589
PAGE.
Referee — Continued .
to protect bankrupt from arrest. Gen. Ord. XII 265
to transmit list of claims to clerk. Gen. Ord. XXIII 274
to whom case referred. Sec. 22 (a) 125
transfer of cases from one to another. Sec. 22 (b) 126
what may be referred to. Gen. Ord. XII 265
what orders must show. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
when proceedings had before. Gen. Ord. XII 265
to countersign checks. Gen. Ord. XXX 277
when to order assignee of claim subrogated to original claimant
Gen. Ord. XXI 271
when to order rule to show cause on trustee for failure to
file report. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
Referees — bonds of. Sec. 50 (a) 164
cases in which they may not act. Sec. 39 (b) (1) 151
compensation. Sec. 40 152
contempts before. Sec. 41 154
not to practice as attorney, when. Sec. 39 (b) (2) 152
not to purchase property in bankruptcy. Sec, 39 (b) (3) . . 152
records of. Sec. 42 155
Referee's Absence or Disability. Sec. 43 156
Reference. Sec. 18 (f) (g) 118, 119
order of. Form No. 14 315
in judges' absence. Form No. 15 7 316
to name date on which bankrupt shall attend
before referee. Gen. Ord. XII 265
Reference of Cases — after adjudication. Sec. 22 a 7 125
may be general or special. Sec. 22 a (1) 126
to whom made. Sec. 22 a (2) 126
Reinstating Cases — jiirisdiction in. Sec. 2 (12) 7 25
Removal of referees. Sec. 34 (a) (1) 145
Removal of Trustee — petition for. Form No, 62 349
notice of petition for. Form No. 53 350
order on petition for. Form No. 54 351
Report of Appraisers — form of. Form No. 13 313
of exemption property by trustee. Form No. 47 345
of exemptions by trustee, when made. Gen. Ord. XVII.. 268
of trustees, when to be made. Sec, 47 a (7) (8) (10) 160
Residence — of bankrupt, jurisdiction. Sec. 2 (1) 13
of trustees. Sec. 45 158
of witness not compelled to attend of state, of his. Sec.
41 a (4) per 154
590 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Return of — marshall on special warrant. Form No. 8 307
no assets by trustee. Form No. 48 346
process time allowed for. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 283
subpoena. Sec. 18 a T 114
summons to witness. Form No. 30 329
Reveslonary interests, statement of. Form No. 1, Sch. B (4) 298, 295
Revesting Title — evidence of. Sec. 21 (g) 125
Revestment of Title. Sec. 70 d 250
Review by Judge — how had of referee's findings. Gen. Ord. XXVII 275
records in to be made by referees. Sec. 39 (a) (5) 150
Revoking Discharge — evidence of. Sec. 21 (f) 125
Right of Action— title to. Sec. 70 (a) (6) 249
Right of Trial by jury. Sec. 19 119
Ride Nisi — against trustees for defaults. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
on creditors' petition. Form No. 4 303
Rules— may be modified by judge. Gea. Ord. XXXVII 283
8.
Sale — by auction, petition for. Form No. 42 340
of perishable property. Form No. 46 344
private, petition for. Form No. 45 343
subject to lien, petition for. Form No. 43 341
account of to be kept by trustee. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
court may authorize trustee to sell. Gen. Ord. XVIII ...... 269
may order, when. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
notice of. Sec. 58 (a) (4) 185
private sales when made. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
to be by public auction. Gen. Ord. XVIII 269
to be made subject to approval of court. Sec, 70 (b) 7 250
without approval of court, when. Sec. 70 (b) 250
Schedules — bankrupt shall prepare and file. Sec. 7 (8) 70
examined by referees. Sec. 39 (a) (9) , 151
form of, of accomodation paper. Form No. (1) , Sch. (a) (5)
298, 291
bills and notes. Form No. (1), Sch. (a) (4) . .298, 290
books, etc., relating to bankrupt's business.
Form No. (1), Sch. (b) (6) 298, 297
chcfees in action. Form No. (1), Sch. (b) (3) 298, 294
exempt property. Form No. (l),Sch. (b) (5) 298, 296
personal property. Form No. (1), Sch. (b) (2) 298, 293
prior claims. Form No. (1), Sch. (a) (1) 298, 287
real property. Form No. (1), Sch. (b) (1). .298, 292
reversions, remainders, etc. Form No. (1),
GENERAL INDEX. 591
PAGE.
Schedules — Continued.
Sch. (b) (4) 298, 295
secured creditors. Form No. (1), Sch. (a) (2) 298, 288
statement of all property of bankrupt. Form
No. (1), Sch. (b) .298, 292-297
unsecured creditors. Form No. (1), Sch. (a)
(3) 298, 289
how framed. Gen. Ord. V 260
in involuntary bankruptcy. Gen. Ord, IX 263
petitioning creditors shall file, when. Gen. Ord. IX 263
when, how and amend. Gen. Ord. XI . . , 264
Secrete — definition of. Sec. 1 (22) 9
Secured Claims — how far allowed. Sec. 57 (e) 177
not entitled to vote. Sec. 66 (b) 173
Secured Creditor. Sec. 56 (b) 173
Secured Creditor — definition. Sec. 1 (23) 9
Secured Debt — proof of. Form No. 32 331
Seciuities — determination of value. Sec. 57 (h) 192
Security — may prove debt of principal, when. Sec. 57 (1) 183
Seizure of Property. Sec. 3 (e) 46
Servants — wages of, prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (4) 214
Service of process. Sec. 18 a 114
expense of service. Gen. Ord. XIX 267
Set-offs — when not provable. Sec. 68 (b) (1) 238
when not to be allowed. Sec. 68 (b) 238
when obtained to gain a preference. Sec, 68 (a) (2) 238
preferred creditor may claim. Sec. 68 b (1) (2) 238
to be made. Sec. 68 (a) 238
Settlement of controversies, when and how had. Gen. Ord. XXXIII 280
estates, arbitration in. Sec. 26 139
Singular Number — definition. Sec. 1 (30) 11
Solvency — (see insolvency) . Sec. 1 (15) 7
burden of proof of. Sec. 3 (c) 44
Special— letter of attorney. Form No. 21 322
meeting of creditors. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
orders modifying practice. Gen. Ord. XXXVII 283
reference. Sec. 22 (a) (1) 126
how referee compensated. Sec. 40 c 154
warrant to marshal. Form No. 8 307
Specification of Opposition to Discharge. Form No. 58 356
State Courts— jurisdiction. Sec. 23 (b) 127
proceeding in, enjoined. Gen. Ord. XII (3) 266
witnesses may be stunmoned before judges in bankruptcy
proceedings. Sec. 21 (a) 123
592 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
State Insolvency Laws — proceedings begun tinder, not affected by-
act 251
State Laws — concerning exemptions followed. Sec. 67 (e) 227
Statement of Debts. Form No. 1, Sch. A 208, 287-291
trustee must make in detail. Sec. 47 (a) (7) 160
States— definition. Sec. 1 (24) 10
Statistics of Bankruptcy Proceedings. Sec. 54 a 169
Stay of Proceedings — when granted. Gen. Ord. VI 261
Stenographers — employment and compensation. Sec. 38 (5) 149
SubpcEna to alleged bankrupts. Form No. 5 304
to witness and return on. Form No. 30 . . 329
to issue out of court. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
Subrogation — of securities. Sec. 57 (i) 183
when trustee entitled to. Sec. 67 (b) 222
when trustee has right of to lien. Sec. 67 (c) (3) 223
Substitution of Parties, Sec. 2 (6) 19
Subsequent Dividends — (see dividends). Sec. 65 (b) 218
meetings of creditors. Sec. 55 (b) 172
Stiits by and against bankrupt. Sec. 11 78
Sunmiary — hearing on contempts. Sec. 41 (b) 155
of debts and assets. Form No. 1, Sch. A. B 298, 287-297
Summons to — issue out of court. Gen. Ord. Ill 259
witness. Form No. 30 • 329
Svmday, when excluded. Sec. 31 142
Supreme Court U. S.— appeal to. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (2) 282
appeals to. Sec. 25 (b) 137
Surety — ^may prove claim. Sec. 57 (i) 183
Sureties on Bond — by whom approved. Sec. 69 (a) 239
must show solvency. Sec. 50 (d) 165
two required. Sec. 50 (e) 165
Surrender of Preferences Required. Sec. 57 (g) 178
T.
Taxes must be paid. Sec. 64(b) . 211
not discharged. Sec. 17(a) (1) T 106
Term of office referees two years. Sec. 34(a) (1) 145
Territory — appeal to Supreme Court of. Gen. Ord. XXXVI (1) .... 282
Territories — what included in definition. Sec. 1 (24) 10
Testimony — expenses of. Gen. Ord. XXII 264
of bankrupt not to be used in criminal proceedings. Sec. 7(9) . 72
taking of. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
Time — computation of. Sec. 31 142
for appeals. Gen. Ord. XXXVI 281
of bankruptcy. See date of bankruptcy, Sec. 1 (10) ? . . . . S
GENERAL INDEX. 593
PAGE.
Time — Continued .
when act takes effect. Sec. 71 (a) 251
petition may be filed. Sec. 3(b) 7 42
Title to property. Sec. 70 T 241
bankrupt's property to vest in trustee. Sec. 70(a) 241
documents relating to bankrupt's property. Sec. 70(a) (1). . T 241
insurance policy with cash sturender value. Sec. 70a (5)
how proved , T 7 243
interest in patents, patent rights, etc. Sec. 70(2) ... 7 241
powers which bankrupt might exercise for his own benefit.
Sec. 70(a) (3) 242
property transferred in fraud by bankrupt. Sec. 70(a) (4) . . .7 24
property which might have been transferred and sold by bank-
rupt. Sec. 70(a) (5) 243
rights of action on contract. Sec. 70(a) (6) .... 7 249
when to revest in bankrupt. Sec, 70(f) . . . 7 251
Title to vest in trustee — as of what date. Sec. 70(d) .. 7 250
vests in trustee, as of date of adjudication. Sec. 70(a) 241
Trade-marks — title to passes to trustee. Sec. 70(a) (2) 241
Trading corporations. Sec. 4(b) 7 48
Transfer— definition. Sec. 1 (25) 10
when to be avoided by trustee. Sec. 70(f) 251
when a preference. Sec. 60(a) T 192
Transfer of cases — power of court. Sec. 2(19) T 30
where petitions in different districts. Sec. 32 . . 7 143
from one district to another. Gen. Ord. VI 7 261
from one referee to another. Sec. 22(b) ... 7 126
Transfers by bankrupt — when void. Sec. 67(e) 7 227
Transmission of proved claims to clerk. Gen. Ord. XXIV . . 7 274
Treasurer of corporation, to prove claim, when. Gen, Ord, XXI (1) . 270
Trial by jury — order for. Form No. 7 . . 7 306
Trustee's accotmts in partnership cases. Sec, 5(d) 55
accovmt. Form No. 49. ... 7 347
Trustee, accounts and papers of. Sec. 49 164
appointment of. Gen. Ord. XIII 267
by creditors. Form No. 22 323
power to make. Sec. 2 (17) 7 29
by referee. Form No, 23 324
by creditors. Sec. 44 7 156
bond of. Form No. 25 326
bond of, order — approving. Form. 26. , . . 7 327
certified copy of order approving bond. Sec. 21 (e) 125
clerk to pay fee to. Sec. 51(4>., , 168
594 GENERAL INDEX.
PAGE.
Trustee — Codtinued .
compensation of. Gen. Ord. XXXV ? 281
compensation of. Sec. 48 162
compromise by. Sec. 27 ? 139
court may order appointment of. Gen. Ord. XV 267
creation of, office. Sec. 33 " 145
definition. Sec. 1(26) 11
duties of. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
accovmt for interest. Sec. 42(2) ... '. 159
close up estate. Sec. 47(3) 159
deposit money in depository. Sec. 47(3) 159
disburse money by check or draft on depository.
47(4) 160
final report and account. Sec. 47(8) 7 160
furnish information. Sec. 47(5) 160
keep accounts. Sec. 47(6) 160
pay dividends. Sec. 47(9) 160
set apart exemptions. Sec. 47(11) 161
statement of Adm. Sec. 47(7) 160
when to report. Sec. 47(10) 160
final accovmt and discharge of. Sec. 2(8) 23
failure to give bond. Sec. 50 (k) 166
joint bonds. Sec. 50 (j) 166
may avoid transfers when. Sec. 70(e) 250
make application for leave to submit controversy to
arbitration. Gen. Ord. XXXIII 280
petition to redeem property. Gen, Ord. XXVIII. . . . 7 . . 276
recover money paid attorney by bankrupt, when. Sec.
60(d) 202
no general or official trustee to be appointed, (yen. Ord. XIV . 267
not appointed in certain cases. Gen. Ord. XV 267
not required to give bond on appeal. Sec. 25(c) .... 7 138
notice of appointment. Gen. Ord. XVI 268
notice of petition for removal. Form No. 53 350
Form. No. 24 325
oath to final account of. Form No. 50 348
order allowing account and discharge of . Form No. 61 349
order for choice of new. Form No. 54 351
order for choice of new. Form No. 55 352
offenses by, punishment. Sec. 29(a) 140
Sec. 29 (c) (3) 141
order that none be appointed. Form No. 27 327
petition for removal of. Form No. 52 349
preparation and fiUng of inventory by. Gen. Ord. XVII. ..... 268
GENERAL INDEX. 595
PAGE.
Trustee — Continued .
qualification of. Sec. 45 158
removal. Sec. 2 (17) 29
removal of. Gen. Ord. XIII 267
record kept of money paid out by. Gen. Ord. XXIX 277
recover bankrupt's property. Sec. 70(e) 250
report of exempt property. Form No. 47 345
report in compliance with. Sec. 47. Gen. Ord. XVII 268
takes title to property when composition set aside.lL Sec. 70(d) 250
takes title to property when discharge revoked. Sec. 70(d) . . . 250
to convey title to property to purchaser. Sec. 70(c) 250
to have title to certain property. Sec. 70 241
to pay unclaimed dividends into court. Sec. 66(a) 219
vacancy in office of. Gen. Ord. XXV '." 275
when conveyed property passes to. Sec. 67(e) 227
may preserve lien for estate. Sec. 67(f) . .. .'. 229
subrogated to rights of creditor. Sec. 67(b) 222
where may sue. Sec. 23(b) 127
who appoints in partnership cases. Sec. 5(b) 54
return of no assets. Form No. 48 346
bond limitation. Sec. 50(m) 166
bonds — who to fix amount. Sec. 50(c) 165
bonds of. Sec. 50(b) 165
death or removal of. Sec. 46 158
duties of. Sec. 47 158
Two years limitation of suits. Sec. 50 (1) (m) 166
U.
Unclaimed dividends — (see Dividends) . Sec. 66 219
Unliquidated claims — how liquidated. Sec. 63 (b) 209
United States Circuit Courts (see Circuit Courts.) Sec. 23 (a) 126
United States Courts — judges, clerks and referees 506
United States Equity Rules 381
Answers. 373-381
amendment of 381
exceptions to 381
Appearance 366
Bills, amendment of 370
cross 388
frame of 367
nominal parties to 377
parties to revivor and supplemental 380
stockholders of corporation 395
taken pro confesso 366
596 GENERAL INDEX,
PAGE.
United States Equity Rules — Continued.
cross-bills 388
Decrees 392
Demurrers and pleas 372
English chancery practice — to govern when 394
Exceptions to answers 381
to report of master. . . ;' 392
Form of the last interrogatory. 388
Frame of bills 367
Guardians and prochein ami 393
Injimctions 394
Issue 383
Masters 388
Nominal parties to bills 379
Parties to bills 377
Pleas. . ; 372
PreUminary regulations. 361
Proceedings before masters 388
Process 363
service of. . .7 365
Pro confesso bills taken 366
Reference to and proceedings before masters 388
RepUcation and issue 383
Report of master, exceptions to. . . .7 392
Revivor, bills of . 380
Service of process 365
Stockholders of corporation, bills by. . . .". 395
Testimony De Bene Esse 387
how taken 383
V.
Vacancy in office of referee — ^how filled. Sec. 43 (a) 156
Vacancy in office of trustee. Gen. Ord. XXV 275
Value of securities, how ascertained. Sec. 57h 182
Verification of pleadings. Sec. 18 (c) 116
Vesting of title in trustee. Sec. 70 (a) 241
Violation of act — jurisdiction to pvmish. Sec. 2 (4) . . .7 18
Voluntary bankrupt. Sec. 4 (a) 47
petitions, adjudication on. Sec. 18 (g) ... 7 119
Voluntary — who may file petition for. Sec. 59 (a) 187
Voters at creditors' meetings. Sec. 56a 171
creditors with security, not. Sec. 56 (b) 173
Vouchers — when referee to give. Gen. Ord. XXVI. . .7 276
GENERAL INDEX. 597
W.
PAGE.
Wage-earner — definition. Sec. 1 (27) 11
may not be made involtmtary bankrupt. Sec. 4 (b) 48
Wages — when prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (4) 214
Warrant to marshal — special. Form No. 8 307
to seize property of involuntary bankrupt when may issue.
Sec. 69 (a) 239
Who may become bankrupts. Sec. 4 47
Witness — examination of Form No. 29 328
fees and mileage. Sec. 41 (a) (4) 154
fees of, prior claim. Sec. 64 (b) (2) 211
summons to. Form No. 30 329
when not compelled to attend before referee. Sec. 41 (a) (4) 154
Witnesses — examination of. Gen. Ord. XXII 273
Women, see Gender. Sec. 1 (28) 11
Words— definition. Sec. 1 (28) (29) (30) - 11
Workmen — wages of, prior claim when. Sec. 64 (b) (4) 214
Writ of habeas corpus — when to issue. Gen. Ord. XXX. 277
Written instrument — debt founded upon, provable. Sec. 63 (a) (1) 205
%
u
University of California
SOUTHERN REGIONAL LIBRARY FACILITY
305 De Neve Drive - Parking Lot 17 • Box 951388
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90095-1388
Return this material to the library from which it was borrowed.
■jV
SCHOOL OF LAW LIBRAKf
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORJVIA
LOS ANGELES